Can anyone fill the Huawei void? | Inside Story
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2024
- It's seen as a major blow for Chinese technology and a win for U.S. President Donald Trump.
The UK says it's banning China's Huawei 5G from its networks.
The British government says the decision was not easy, but right for national security and the economy.
The move comes as the U.S. intensifies its campaign against the tech giant.
And it reverses the UK's attempt in January to allow restricted use of Huawei's equipment.
From the end of this year, UK operators will not be allowed to buy the firm's 5G kits.
Gear already in place will have to be removed by 2027.
The UK has reportedly asked Japan to help build its internet infrastructure instead.
What does it mean for the timeline of 5G services?
Presenter: Sami Zeidan
Guests
Simon Lacey, former Vice President of Global Government Affairs at Huawei Technologies in Shenzhen, China.
Robert Pritchard, cybersecurity consultant and former Deputy Head of Cyber Security Operations Centre in the British Government.
Marc Einstein, Chief Analyst for Digital Services at ITR Japan.
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
#AlJazeeraEnglish #Huawei #InsideStory
Huawei already has a working 5G system end to end! Sure you can go a different route by piecing components together from companies all over! But it will cost more... a lot more! And how well will these components work together?! And since Huawei has most of the patents, they get paid either way!
Huawei is on a temporary leave of absence in the west, remember that they have a captive audience of over 1.4 billion plus the other 2 billion in Asia and are the leading inovater in 5G and already working on 6G so as Arnold says " I will be back "
Wow! You are the minority in the West.
We were always behind countries like South Korea and Japan when it came to Internet speeds, now we will be behind most of the developing world when it comes to Mobile Internet speeds. Just brilliant.
Your life gonna get better with faster mobile???? Right!!!!
Vincent Conti 5G isn’t only about fast internet service on mobile there are many applications that benefit from 5G tech
@@vincentconti3633 Only a person with zero understanding of tech would make such a dumb comment. The internet is not used just for surfing websites companies can not function without it in todays world, and if they have slower speeds it means less productivity. I guess your one of those guys who just uses his mobile for telephone calls nothing else.
@@vincentconti3633 I don't think you understand how tech advancing is crucial in improving lives. Internet is not all about tiktok kid.
@Investigative Audit please research about rakuten 5g u will be amazed
" UK turn to Japan for 5G is liken to asking a blind fellow for direction " 🤭
Desperation and jealousy is what's driving the world.
Communists Spying on everything in every country by every possible way, they totally spying, controlling and threatening their own citizens living in foreign countries, they steal technology every single day, they don't respect to International IP laws at all, they launch cyber attacks on western countries every time, Private companies in their country has to 100% obey communists orders even to exist in the business, they don't respect to International law and order, they don't believe in democracy and freedom at all ! So anyone with a tiny brain should understand real threat coming from Huawei or any other company from these communists countries....
So PATHETIC! Backstabbing others just because you can't compete. Stoop so low to do such thing. Really SHAMEFUL
@@chaddissanayake9520 ask Edward Snowden. The whole world knows.
@@chaddissanayake9520 l
Would you go to a locksmith a well known burglar to cut your house keys? China is synonymous to a burglar
Imagine if a UK company owns the tech and US does this to them.
@Xye Leyx samsung is involved aswell
They would cry like a baby. Uk can't challenge USA. They do what USA dictates them to do. We all know this, don't we? 😊
@@galaxyguardian5883 most of the time, but not always. UK is a parliamentary system, meaning the government doesn't always get to do what it wants. Classic example is air strikes on Assad regime in Syria for using chemical weapons. UK government wanted to support the US & Obama, but parliament said no, parliament said strikes would not make things better for Syrians due to all the terrorists. It had the effect of blocking US strikes as Obama was unwilling to take unilateral military action.
Funny enough, the UK and EU have largely been against US's monopoly of the tech industry in the past specifically companies like Microsoft and Intel though there is little they can do about this because of the lack of any tech alternative in Europe and it was largely blindsided.
Communists Spying on everything in every country by every possible way, they totally spying, controlling and threatening their own citizens living in foreign countries, they steal technology every single day, they don't respect to International IP laws at all, they launch cyber attacks on western countries every time, Private companies in their country has to 100% obey communists orders even to exist in the business, they don't respect to International law and order, they don't believe in democracy and freedom at all ! So anyone with a tiny brain should understand real threat coming from Huawei or any other company from these communists countries....
Just the sheer number of graduates in China every year gives an indelible impression that even if the world combine its graduates against China will still thwart in comparison. Therefore, China will continue to dominate in technological innovations and reasonably priced goods that the world needs.
Agreed.
Well said, and by reasonably priced goods means bringing 21st century technology that used to be reserved to the rich in the West. Before the Chinese cyber and wireless revolution, I PHONE and Samsung smartphone were affordable only to high middle class, now anybody can own a high tech gadget
The graduates that had to go to the US to get their education, interesting how you leave this out.
And now the mainlanders come to Taiwan to learn, where they get more education technology than their own supposed glorious party gives them.
China schools were among the worst in the world before the mid 2000s, they won't tell you that.
@@lanchu5772 How come they're leading in wireless technology today? The US must have a two tons boulder attached to its academic ankle, and China can't hear the UNCLE yelling ... WAIIIIT CHINA! You're going to fast ... and China replies : Sorry Yank, I have two millions engineers to graduate and they must have a job ... see what I mean ...
It's not only ironic but pathetic the UK has to do its former colony's bidding.... Lol
It Karma. soon the rest world will do the same if the brits population keeps falling and the ethnics keep coming.
It's pathetic to think of the past to and think about the glory days
When U.S talking about national security, Edward snowden laughing*
And I'm also laughing after reading your comment🤣🤣🤣. Thanks man. You made my day.
So am I ...
Edward Snowden lives in Putin's Russia. So I don't know how much laughing he's doing.
Looking back at the steady fall of the once mighty Great Britain, one can understand her plight of this diminishing "empire" who still think that history could be leveraged to change its course. With technological changes being absorbed by the developing nations so quickly, the time lag is no longer applicable; in fact at the current rate of development in all sectors, the developing nations are steadily over taking the West in all aspects of comparable technologies. When the nation's GDP is slowly dropping in the international parade, you can't hope to influence the rest of the world just by propaganda!
To turn down Huawei & use Japan did not make any business sense🥺 So it must be political 😨
US warmonger pressure... forced Johnson to look like a weak leader..
Japanese companies are twenty times more advanced than chinese ones. They don't steal IP and don't make fake products.
@@kshitijshekhar1144😂😂😂
Long story short: too much BS in the British accent but admitting to being bullied by the U.S.
Aussie also trying to umm ummm ummm words to sound neutral but know they're screwed.
American in Japan excited to be on Al jazeera
as long as the ccp imposes an authoritarian regime on the chinese people it cannot be trusted
@@nowwhat7181
Are you aware that 93% of the Chinese citizens approved of their government's administration? Who are you? Just another lap dog of the US.
Al Jazeera is just another anti China news station. Also known as the lap dog of the United Satans of America.
@@nowwhat7181 ,if China is so bad, why then UK used huawei previously for 3G, 4G and only will remove these by 2027.?? Why not remove these now?
If China is bad and can't be trusted, why UK let China build nuclear power station in UK?
@@kennyng2289 containment of CCCP's China is long overdue
The point is "who will make the most affordable 5g" and "not who will make it"
The cost of HUAWEI is much lower than Japanese. And it is no value to spy normal person. Why I use iphone,I don't care American spy me. I just want the money is,safe. My information is useless for CIA.
@@luckyma590 it doesn't matter all the countries in the world are banning you companies, so enjoy their is no use of giving your recommendation
@Naught Guile I dont believe in white supremacy or black I believe credibility, I would like to have my trust on democratic nation rather than communist or dictatorship.
@@abhijeetshetty5950 lmao democratic nation or communist country who is more dangerous well ask the libyans and the iraqi how credible us actions have been towards them
When you wanna replace something you have to make sure you're replacing with something better than it is not much worse than it is.
Communists Spying on everything in every country by every possible way, they totally spying, controlling and threatening their own citizens living in foreign countries, they steal technology every single day, they don't respect to International IP laws at all, they launch cyber attacks on western countries every time, Private companies in their country has to 100% obey communists orders even to exist in the business, they don't respect to International law and order, they don't believe in democracy and freedom at all ! So anyone with a tiny brain should understand real threat coming from Huawei or any other company from these communists countries....
Chad Dissanayake May I,remind you that the US is the biggest data collector, do you think the US secret services don’t have access to it? Merkel, spying on friends is an absolutely no go. Educate yourself!
@@chaddissanayake9520 I'm sorry i have to object to that but you're actually accusing them of what we are doing. Reality is more important to me than interest.
@@chaddissanayake9520 don't believe politicians too much.. because 99% times they lie to their people..
I agree. Will remember this when I choose a new wife.
Huawei started in 2005 when they upgraded British Telecom network. So in 15 years its not a security threat and now it is? We have all the programs and tools that sniffs networks and know where packets are destined to be headed. I considered British Intelligence to be top notch but if for 15 years they didn't notice that threat then they should be ashamed of themselves it took them that long.
If UK ministers say 2-3 years, that would mean around 5. Nice, eh?
Probably UK can skip 5G to pursue 6G.
@@junyuchen9548 Something telepathic, perhaps.
US: Jump
UK: How High?
Australia: did you say bend over?
By 2027 6G will come?????
China got 6G in same place now. Pakistan will have 5g before the UK. and Thailand is have put now so work out
@Naught Guile yes in the UK the army are use huawel still it the public thay are stopping that funny l think
Japan may have been a tech powerhouse in the 70s but it's advances have remained stagnant for many years due to an ageing population and strict corporate culture.
japan is 5g right now.. but you had to paid extra 1000 yen to change from 4g to 5g.. while 5gb and phone and other fee... cost monthly at 9000yen already....
Japan could be even more advanced if it was not restricted and contained by the US. The US won't allow its allies to own a much more powerful super computer than what they have. The Japanese still resent the Yanks for that limitation. Well, when you lose a war, you lose ...
Sony is a good example of lack of innovation, look at their mobile phone.. so old school design..
Well US suppressed Japan technology advancement to be exact.
@@teogeorge3987 Yeah, Sony really fell behind all these other tech companies.
Pity Britain using 4g because of Trump. Britain will be less competitive
you know it 4g+ right.... it don't matter if we can not get to 5g since it so fast and used up battary and overprice internet.. most people won't using it...
Europeans discussing the fate of non-European countries. I'm sure they want the best for everyone. I can smell the love.
Invest now? isn't that like chasing a high speed rail with a bicycle? No matter who joins, Huawei is going to profit off various patents
WEST will probably not pay fees for those patents.
thata xx Exactly.I understand that Huawei hold most of the patents on 5g technology.
Is there an alternative to Huawei ? Ask by British Prime Minister Boris Johnson when he was interviewed by a BBC reporter.
Hwauei is now started to work on 6G 👌
no?
Japan doesn't have 5G lmao
they do... just slow 5g ...
@@campkira ok what's the use then lol
@@campkira , that slow 5g is called enhanced 4g.
not NEC again ... disaster when losing 3G to Ericsson, and I heard a lot of horror stories of how they treated staff
Japan doesnt have 5G. I worked in Tokyo in 2020 and 5G was nowhere availabe.
Surprised me that they don’t find Europe or US replacements but Japan?
some saying : More u press - ur letting them more stable and rise??????
It's a huge political win of us. Huawei's loss in UK's 5G market; UK's 5G rollout will be delayed by 2 to 3 years; UK mobile phone users will end up paying more, and not be able to use the most advanced 5G technology.
Yes it’s win win 😂🤣
that would be great... and people will preferred buying Samsung or iPhone
Everyone needs to know that China don't have any history in war with other countries, Japan does!! Think about it.. U might waken up a sleeping dragon.. Something to think about.
it will cost them 5x the money to do so!
raysschoko money doesn’t count for BJ and his cons, he is under enormous pressure from the US to get a trade deal!
France took the EXACT SAME position the UK just took and BEFORE the UK (6 to 7 years for Huawei presence in France to be phased out) but Al jezirah did not do a WHOLE show on that.
It is not always about cost or how expensive it is, but a proper balance of what you want, the cost and what you can compromise in between.
Huawei will Launch 6G before anyone else
@AadiYogi Let's wait & see
Uk is americas dog nice job you when from singing " rule britannia " to " O america" LMAO
I bought two Chinese LED bulbs at Rs.40 each seven years back,the same are still in perfect condition,whereas eight others Indian made bought for Rs 250 each got fused more than once.
Thank you,the export goods quality of China is good. I hope the quality of Chinese goods can be better in future.
No wonder, when the Indians say, China made items have less quality, but their import from China increases.
Now, we can see the biases contradictions!!!
Excellent questions by the host.
Would be cool if countries can invest in their own technology
There is no software that cannot be exploited. IT pro's all know that all software is based on earlier software, and the holes in that have never been fixed.
UK can pay money to Japan.
Why can’t the British build there own ?
😂🤣🤣😂🤣
What about Ericsson and Nokia ? almost neck to neck or in some aspect ahead of Huawei in 5G . also Ericsson is current number 2 in market share and was number 1 for decades. already Ericsson has bag full of global contracts.
The problem is the cost, not the technology
the cost means too much effort in technology.
@@HuaJarry I think only India could compete with such low cost
Thank you for doing the program, but please don’t interrupt Simon so often.
Cost of racism against Chinese. British colonial mentality ... Nokia, Ericsson also dealt with Iran, but only Huawei was attacked, because US was having trade war against China.
Now US Have 4.5G hahahaha saying they have 5G. Lol. They cannot gasp the 5G technology. Now they trying all unnecessary solution to get it,😂🤣😅
are East Asian leading in 5G tech compare to Europe or US???
Or is it bcz of the price??
Jio also launch 5G
India have no patent in 5G, this technology is not going to just pop out from nowhere
Every country can have their own 5G network if the state really wants it..
Jio
Would be really funny if Japan outsource the production of their 5G equipment to China.
How? The Japanese government just provided 2 billion dollars for leading Japanese companies to move the production out of China.
@@darwinism18 , those are small potatoes companies and not 5g manufacturers. Since Japan did not have 5g, it must contract with either Huawei, Erickson, or Nokia which the 5g equipments are produced in China.
The tech gurus are saying Huawei going full steam to develop 6G. Will 5G be superceded in popularity like facebook or Twitter to Tik Tok in the US.
US: Pull out of the 5G deal.
UK: Okay Boss.
Japan has no 5G only Huawei and Ericsson. It would take years to develop.
you ever heard of Sony Ericson.. SONY... and by the way.. the latest xperia series of sony has 5G
@@xamina12345You are dumb. It's not about smartphones, it's about 5G networks.
Communists Spying on everything in every country by every possible way, they totally spying, controlling and threatening their own citizens living in foreign countries, they steal technology every single day, they don't respect to International IP laws at all, they launch cyber attacks on western countries every time, Private companies in their country has to 100% obey communists orders even to exist in the business, they don't respect to International law and order, they don't believe in democracy and freedom at all ! So anyone with a tiny brain should understand real threat coming from Huawei or any other company from these communists countries....
from health concern to 5G, i guessing it's all geopolitic, right ?
waiting until february
USA became crazy in there security because of huawei presence.
Is there really any global free trade? What is the definition of free trade?
This was a complete waste of 24 minutes after the question was answered
This UK Digital Secretary is soooo intelligent! 😅
Geez. Japan doesn't even have a solution for its own 5gG.
If you want to pay more. You think Japan or Korea don’t have back doors just like everybody?
I was born in abject poverty - no water, no electricity, no roof, no money - but i learned in life early , never to cheat, lie or steal; it won't end up well.
Then, I learnt to do the right thing right in everything small and big. And today, I m convinced that it is most rewarding in the end however difficult the decision or task may be - both in terms of tangible and intangible values. Most importantly, I know that is the way man is meant to be & it will never change.
Looks like the British eye is smarter than the rest of the other eyes.
I wonder if anyone else would see an Asian adversity build up when there are Ericsson, Nokia, or even Siemens to fill that gap.
US needs to develop 7G to stay ahead
Good luck with that.... When it can't do even 5g
All BS it is. They want to buy 5G from Japan? then I think to buy 5G from my friend Eric, just because it adds more sense to all of it
Reliance Jio from India? They claim to have developed their own 5G network
😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂 Good one!!
An idiotic move. But when you know they have Bojo, you are not surprised.
The night of US military power means they do not need to be logical, reasonable or act with any sort of restraint. The world must learn this lesson.
I feel bad for the huawei.
Great panel, but poorly briefed journalist, who could have asked questions that were less reactionary and more incisive.
Maybe Japan can build the U.K. a Sega Genesis.
I thought it was interesting thar AT andT uses Hauwei in Mexico. No Problemo!
Nec has no 5G technology
Cannot compromise
The National security !!!!
Q: Can anyone fill the Huawei void?
A: It be a company none discussed here in the discussion, Jio from India with low cost solution with a complete end to end home grown solution from scratch. With all components self made.. They already got 400mil+ new 4g customers in last 4 years. Also happens to be the cheapest 4G in the world with a large margin.
In comparison to China, India is ahead by almost 30 years in terms of technology
So China can ban google but US can't ban Huawei?
So US is the same as China which is described as totalitarian or dictator by west?Where is the superiority now?US could ban Huawei ,but why they threat their allies to ban Huawei?Another fact is that US is moving to ban Tiktok! Google is banned because they don’t place server in China,What is the proof they have to Ban Huawei?It is nothing to do with Huawei and Google ,it is just competition and geopolitics.Democracy and free market is already a laughingstock now because it is a tool to contain and oppress other nations
When China is poor and backwards in the era of 3G or 4G, China adopted and received all those western equiopments and standards. Even now when Huawei's tech is the leading player in the world, Still China allow western companies to come in and play a role in its 5G infrasture building, what if China now did the same like the U.S, how would you guys feel about that? China don't have its national security cocerns as the U.S do ?
They already do that to all foreign companies
Hows that going for Facebook twitter, snapchat, whatsapp, instagram. all blocked in China. but only the 50 cent wumao army can use it!
BEING ONCE BITTEN TWICE SHY, JAPAN HAS SHY away from being innovative since the ACCORD in 1983.
The guy from Tokyo got well pay from the Japanese
Japan once held the title of super power in electronics in the 80s. Japan was so rich then. Everyone owned a Sony walkman, Sanyo, Toshiba... electrical appliances. Who killed Toshiba?? Maybe a documentary on what happened to Toshiba will be good. Japan is still a very cash based with an aging society and facing a low birth rate problem. Japan does not easily grant a Japanese citizenship to others to protect her own identity. It will be an uphill task to catch up in the near future. I am glad Japan is doing very well in preserving her culture despite Western influences. Other countries should learn from Japan on how to preserve own culture for future generations.
Why we should allow Chinese technology when they don’t allow other products? like google , TH-cam whatsapp etc
UK should consider buying 5G from Africa once Huawei has sold to one of the African continent, except UK can ask it to be re-labeled. That way, you do not seem to be buying from Huawei directly. What do you think ???
That may work in a roundabout way to appease the US for having lost the 5G war. LOL.
Can’t competition just band it’s. !!!!!
do japan even have 5g?
what an interesting program, the three interviews have basically the same opinion... this type of stale, infertile thinking is reaally productive...
According to news, Huawei is number one tech for 5G and none can replace it. Very well. Ttry if there is any other alternative. Even new alternattive choice is a bit less technique, new ideas may emerge out . Solving such problems with integrated approach by combining tech of different nations other than China, a superior and more versatile tech may emerge out. What is the hurry.
These guys has no ideas that mean not possible without china .
Did Huawei ever invent anything? No just repackaging, reassembly, copying of already existing technologies and designs using a much cheaper labor market manufactured in an area of the world that has no environmental laws.
We have to support Huawei
Ericsson know all about 5G network, no problems. They can fill the void ezy.
Huawei has the most 5G SEP patents, so even going to Japan UK cannot avoid Huawei technologies.
By getting rid of Huawei equipments in UK totally, it will take 7 years. So how soon can UK switch to another provider, and will the next provider be able to get rid of Huawei and China make components completely.😉
@Alvin Aroa SEP patents are property rights granted to the inventor. So the technology came from the inventor, not stolen.
US has no 5G technology of its own, neither has UK.
@Alvin Aroa China stole technology from others and is ahead of their competitors ?? You mean China's superior innovative technology by far supercedes all others ??? LOL.
@Alvin Aroa Wow, although I am in IT, but I cannot steal data from US. We are using US cyber security system. 😅
@Alvin Aroa Think its TH-cam problem, that your texts got deleted.
Happened to me as well.
YT clearly doesn't respect freedom of speech when they summarily demonetize responses to obnoxious comments.
The 5g world should be built on a market mechanism but the pandemic has sadly changed the rules
why does it always sound like the British & Americans is mispronouncing the name huawei... (to me its said as Hu_A_Wei but to the brits and Us hua_wei) or is it just me???
Great decision UK, well Japan can challenge any country in any technology.
DIRTY & EVIL political game by the US. SHAME on you playing Dirty just because you know you can't compete. Such actions should be condemned.
Japan doesn't have 5G tech, why go there for help? Korea has 5G, better than Japan i think, cause they also produce 5G phones
Chinese people can't seem differentiate between supporting the communist government of China and supporting the Chinese nation/people having a shared history and culture