For a long time, he never showed his face on his 3B1B channel, I thought he was not likely good-looking since he was so intelligent and articulate, turned out he is good-looking. Now I just discovered he is musically talented too. All good genes.
Lyrics: Ain't no twin prime solution It ain't known how they behave Do the twin primes go on and on? It's been open so damn long No-one knows quite what to say When are primes just two away? Well firstly are primes ever done? Euclid said there's just no way Multiply them and add one Every factor of that sum Is a prime not in the array So they never end, well, okay But when are primes just two away? Is there some algorithm? To sift the primes some simple way? I know the first one, that's the two To find the rest, here's what you do Reduce the naturals modulo two (Oh I get it! ...No, I, I, I don't get it, actually. Can you spell it out?) It goes one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh... (Tim! Tim!) (What?) (There IS more to the algorithm.) (Ah, that- that makes sense, actually. Um - please continue.) You knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod three, like One oh, two one, oh two, one oh, two one, oh two, one oh... (Oh, okay! I get it.) Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod five, like One oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four, one oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four... Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod seven, like Hey, that's a neat little thing you've shown But what of twin primes on and on? As the new primes do go on (That prime theorem) The gaps between them grow this way (Something about Riemann) For a big prime, call it p The gap that follows tends to be On the mean, the logarithm base e But will they stop coming just two away? No-one knows quite what to say (Well okay.) Yet I get crank proofs every day (Dear sir! I have proven the twin primes conjecture!) They always start the same damn way (I study an elegant proof of prime generation!) To count the twin primes all you do Is list the numbers all the way through Reducing all of them modulo two (It's so simple!) It goes one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh... (Huge red flag if you're starting this way!) Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod three, like One oh, two one, oh two, one oh, two one, oh two... (All you're doing is applying a sieve...) (Search term you're looking for is "parity problem".) Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod five, like- Hey, you want to leave that proof alone There ain't no chance that's how it's shown When you start so trivially (One oh, one oh, one oh...) Like with the sieve of Eratosthenes (One oh, two one, oh two...) Chances are high you went wrong (I am the greatest math wizard alive) It's been open so damn long (Now take out the zeros, reduce 'em mod five) Someone else would've found such a way (Now one oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four...) You want a proof twin primes go on You want to be the next Yitang Zhang Maybe read what researchers say When the primes are just two away When are primes just two away? When are primes just two away?
Notes: -Some of the later 'one oh, two one, ...' don't follow the proper pattern. I assume this was unintentional; the above transcription has (what I believe is) the actual pattern. -I can't figure out what Grant says at 3:35. -4:21 sounds a lot more like "You want a proof twin primes are one" to my ears, but I don't think that makes sense so I'll assume they sang 'go on'.
So glad to say I was there live, the crowd went wild with the “1 0 1 0 1 0….” Also I see the first attempt of this was not included here, which has some impressive Grant vocals😉
Im just seeing Mr. Sanderson's face here, which I do very rarely, and Im noticing that without this man even knowing I exist, he has instilled the love for mathematics into me and taught me so much that I wouldve never known before. Thank you so much for changing my life so wildly and bringing me to such great places. Keep doing what youre doing, Im excited to see what comes next.
I keep rewatching this! Their voices, beautiful separately and wonderful together. The banter, and Grant saying Damn. The playing, and the slides. The fun lyrics, and the parts where they diverge and come back together. It's all such a great combination!
Hi Grant! Thank you for putting our balloons up on stage. The one seen in the background of this video was supposed to be a brown cube. There were three other balloon shapes, all blue tetrahedrons. It was a blast sneaking the balloon pump into the venue and building these shapes before the show.
HOLY SHIT WHAT THE FRICK TWO OF MY FAVORITE TH-cam DUDES TOGETHER I LOVE YOU BOTH THANK YOU SO MUUUUUCH (I now officially understand k-pop fans when they shout all their lungs during the whole concert)
Sift the twos and sift the threes, In the Sieve of Eratostheses, Sift the fives and sift the sevens, Then go round and sift elevens, And as the multiples sublime, The numbers that remain are prime!
This is the greatest parody of a pop song that includes a full mathematical proof in its lyrics of all time. Seriously, so happy about this song, pure genius.
@@tylerduncan5908 Nah, TH-cam is full of them. This one is much better than most, though. Most of them are American college students studying Calculus 1 and getting really excited about integration by parts.
There’s no proof in their lyrics. Although this is an excellent practice of a researcher, I agree. I think theyre taking inspiration from a blues motive - it seems distinctly that its not a ‘pop’ thing. And in this case, it can’t be equated with actual blues music.
math, teaching, poetry, amazing speaking and singing voice, guitar, handsomeness ... is there anything Grant can't do (iirc he also helped compose a bit of the main channel's music)
Oh, too cool! I love blues, and I'm a bit of a maths nerd, so when YT offered this up for me to watch, I was intrigued. It did NOT disappoint! 😂 Love it, now I'm going to go look for more of the same!
Holy primes Grant, this made my day! Just when I thought I couldn’t fall any deeper in love with your content! 😃 I had no idea you that you play guitar, and also sing. I’m also a guitar player and a singer-songwriter, and a computer scientist who’s very passionate about mathematics. Incredible performance, and so creative! Bravo!! 👏
woah this is awesome. i didn't know about that sieve algorithm thing before and it's hilarious how there are apparently a lot of people thinking they have proved the twin prime conjecture starting from that algorithm even though they probably have not.
Hey Grant, parody idea for you: "Axiom of Choice", to the tune (or rhythm) of "Weapon of Choice". I've tried myself, but I don't know enough maths. Your maths song parodies are great and I think you could do the idea justice.
This is what I pay my internet bills for
Sometimes I forget the internet isn’t free
😂😂😂
grants singing voice is amazing
I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know
yeah, could be at 70 million subs with very little effort
Before I ever saw him, I imagined him to look kinda like Withers, so this makes so much sense :)
For a long time, he never showed his face on his 3B1B channel, I thought he was not likely good-looking since he was so intelligent and articulate, turned out he is good-looking. Now I just discovered he is musically talented too. All good genes.
He's been serenading us with his math voice for years, it's no great surprise when his singing voice is just as good 🙂↔️
I'll tell my kids these were Simon and Garfunkel
Lyrics:
Ain't no twin prime solution
It ain't known how they behave
Do the twin primes go on and on?
It's been open so damn long
No-one knows quite what to say
When are primes just two away?
Well firstly are primes ever done?
Euclid said there's just no way
Multiply them and add one
Every factor of that sum
Is a prime not in the array
So they never end, well, okay
But when are primes just two away?
Is there some algorithm?
To sift the primes some simple way?
I know the first one, that's the two
To find the rest, here's what you do
Reduce the naturals modulo two
(Oh I get it! ...No, I, I, I don't get it, actually. Can you spell it out?)
It goes one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh...
(Tim! Tim!)
(What?)
(There IS more to the algorithm.)
(Ah, that- that makes sense, actually. Um - please continue.)
You knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod three, like
One oh, two one, oh two, one oh, two one, oh two, one oh...
(Oh, okay! I get it.)
Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod five, like
One oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four, one oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four...
Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod seven, like
Hey, that's a neat little thing you've shown
But what of twin primes on and on?
As the new primes do go on (That prime theorem)
The gaps between them grow this way (Something about Riemann)
For a big prime, call it p
The gap that follows tends to be
On the mean, the logarithm base e
But will they stop coming just two away?
No-one knows quite what to say
(Well okay.)
Yet I get crank proofs every day
(Dear sir! I have proven the twin primes conjecture!)
They always start the same damn way
(I study an elegant proof of prime generation!)
To count the twin primes all you do
Is list the numbers all the way through
Reducing all of them modulo two
(It's so simple!)
It goes one oh, one oh, one oh, one oh...
(Huge red flag if you're starting this way!)
Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod three, like
One oh, two one, oh two, one oh, two one, oh two...
(All you're doing is applying a sieve...)
(Search term you're looking for is "parity problem".)
Knock off the zeros, reduce 'em mod five, like-
Hey, you want to leave that proof alone
There ain't no chance that's how it's shown
When you start so trivially (One oh, one oh, one oh...)
Like with the sieve of Eratosthenes (One oh, two one, oh two...)
Chances are high you went wrong (I am the greatest math wizard alive)
It's been open so damn long (Now take out the zeros, reduce 'em mod five)
Someone else would've found such a way (Now one oh, two one, three two, four three, oh four...)
You want a proof twin primes go on
You want to be the next Yitang Zhang
Maybe read what researchers say
When the primes are just two away
When are primes just two away?
When are primes just two away?
Notes:
-Some of the later 'one oh, two one, ...' don't follow the proper pattern. I assume this was unintentional; the above transcription has (what I believe is) the actual pattern.
-I can't figure out what Grant says at 3:35.
-4:21 sounds a lot more like "You want a proof twin primes are one" to my ears, but I don't think that makes sense so I'll assume they sang 'go on'.
This needs to be pinned!
@@rtg_onefourtwoeightfiveseven at 3:35 grant says "No, stop", (Also, it says this in the [man-made] subtitles as well)
@@ZephyrysBaum Thanks. (The subtitles weren't up at the time I made the original comment, just for the record.)
So glad to say I was there live, the crowd went wild with the “1 0 1 0 1 0….”
Also I see the first attempt of this was not included here, which has some impressive Grant vocals😉
I was kind of clenching at this part -- the mod 5 part seems really hard to sing without messing up!
For the people, who do not know the original Bill Withers song, which is being parodied here, it is called: "Ain't No Sunshine". :)
Do I have to watch Notting Hill again now?
The bassline is kinda like superstition?
Thank you
What the hell can’t grant do, these should be the role models people look upto. Loved this!
Love the polymeter at 2:18 ! Putting the "math" in "math rock"
If you thought 5/4 or 7/8 were difficult time signatures, let's talk about prime time....
I love how Matt is just sitting there looking at his laptop as if the greatest collab this world ever needed wasn’t happening right in front of him.
He was running the slides (per Grant at the end).
You guys just casually drastically raised the standard for videos to show in high school math classes
Im just seeing Mr. Sanderson's face here, which I do very rarely, and Im noticing that without this man even knowing I exist, he has instilled the love for mathematics into me and taught me so much that I wouldve never known before. Thank you so much for changing my life so wildly and bringing me to such great places. Keep doing what youre doing, Im excited to see what comes next.
2:39 tim's singing here is killer and i refuse to let it go under yall's radars
I keep rewatching this! Their voices, beautiful separately and wonderful together. The banter, and Grant saying Damn. The playing, and the slides. The fun lyrics, and the parts where they diverge and come back together. It's all such a great combination!
10 10 10 10 10 10....
Just can't get it out of my head!!
Hi Grant! Thank you for putting our balloons up on stage. The one seen in the background of this video was supposed to be a brown cube. There were three other balloon shapes, all blue tetrahedrons.
It was a blast sneaking the balloon pump into the venue and building these shapes before the show.
I saw it and knew it was a cube! I assumed it was from a previous act.
HOLY SHIT WHAT THE FRICK TWO OF MY FAVORITE TH-cam DUDES TOGETHER I LOVE YOU BOTH THANK YOU SO MUUUUUCH (I now officially understand k-pop fans when they shout all their lungs during the whole concert)
PREACH!
Two??? The third one is sitting right there!
As a kpop enjoyer I can tell you I almost lost my voice watching this lol.
I love this comment so much like REAL
@@JanStrojil He's the Parker favorite!
Sift the twos and sift the threes,
In the Sieve of Eratostheses,
Sift the fives and sift the sevens,
Then go round and sift elevens,
And as the multiples sublime,
The numbers that remain are prime!
Tim's voice is unreal. That falsetto at the end. Omg.
Standupmaths, 3blue1brown, acapellascience in one video? Music and math? This is my favourite video in TH-cam 😭
Damn this guy knows coding, math, teaching and singing. What am I doing in my life
Anyone else here who has this song stuck in your head?
Wherever I go now, I always hear "one oh, one oh, one oh"....
Another unexpected surprising side of the great Grant Sanderson.
One oh one oh one one oh...hey-ya gonna leave that PROOF alone, ain't no way that it's shone...
This slaps so hard.
I swear ive watched this video waaay too many times… and i will continue to do so!
“one oh- two one, oh- two one, oh- two one, oh- two” so inspirational 🥹
It’s so good to hear our fave singing scientist!!!!
This video deserves the largest known prime number of likes!
Or at least the logarithm of the next natural number base 2.
@@allozovsky That looks a bit more feasible...
This is the greatest parody of a pop song that includes a full mathematical proof in its lyrics of all time.
Seriously, so happy about this song, pure genius.
It might be the only one, so you're not wrong
@@tylerduncan5908 Nah, TH-cam is full of them. This one is much better than most, though. Most of them are American college students studying Calculus 1 and getting really excited about integration by parts.
There’s no proof in their lyrics.
Although this is an excellent practice of a researcher, I agree.
I think theyre taking inspiration from a blues motive - it seems distinctly that its not a ‘pop’ thing.
And in this case, it can’t be equated with actual blues music.
How come that isn't a category at the Grammys?
@@scottychen2397They prove the infinitude of primes toward the start.
Everytime I come back to this video I catch myself trying to like it again lol 😆
math, teaching, poetry, amazing speaking and singing voice, guitar, handsomeness ... is there anything Grant can't do
(iirc he also helped compose a bit of the main channel's music)
oneOoneOoneO hahahhaha what a bless is to have Grant in this universe
Didnt know my mans could sing so well ❤
I love the intersection of math and music on TH-cam
why am I addicted to this song 😭
The little harmonies at 4:34 are so juicy!
3:22
I think Bill's opinion might be that you NAILED the repetitive parts!! Excellent!!
SUPER nice to see Tim Blais joining in! What a match :D
GRANTS LIVE VOCALS FOR DAYSSSS❤️🔥❤️🔥 I was screaming my head off the whole time. Pls release more music!!
I like the music! I like the voices. I like maths too.. but this one's over my head
Another banger
You just let me discover AcapellaScience. Holy Moly you are both so talented in your YT channels!
Such a fun channel! I think my favorite is Entropic Time, followed by the one about planets with the Disney songs.
This is just amazing. No end to Grant's talents
is this math rock?
Legitimately incredible.
Oh, too cool! I love blues, and I'm a bit of a maths nerd, so when YT offered this up for me to watch, I was intrigued. It did NOT disappoint! 😂 Love it, now I'm going to go look for more of the same!
Woke up to this. Made my day
You’re amazing and this show was so good. Thanks for coming to one of my favorite venues! ❤
this is my new favorite video of all time holy moly
Absolutely fantastic in a fun and creative way.
Great material. Congratulations it exceeded my expectations and spent a good moment listebing !
Holy primes Grant, this made my day! Just when I thought I couldn’t fall any deeper in love with your content! 😃 I had no idea you that you play guitar, and also sing. I’m also a guitar player and a singer-songwriter, and a computer scientist who’s very passionate about mathematics. Incredible performance, and so creative! Bravo!! 👏
This is so funny that I go in the bus and start laughing alone
PLEASE release this on spotify
They are at their prime! ❤👏
I started watching and laughed my butt off within 5 seconds once I saw who was sitting at that computer
Absolutely amazing
Excellent work, Grant! This song is amazing. This is going to become a classic in math classes.
Damn, the lyrics is pure joy! This was just awesome🔥
The way they incorporated one-o in the song ❤
the banger was "one oh one oh" that was supposed to be "I know I know" LOL
This was both super cool and hilarious. lmao
I'm so glad we get to hear more math songs from Grant!
I need a studio version of this!
A duet with Vi Hart would simply be too much power to be contained within the known universe
woah this is awesome. i didn't know about that sieve algorithm thing before and it's hilarious how there are apparently a lot of people thinking they have proved the twin prime conjecture starting from that algorithm even though they probably have not.
Love you guys, I really do
Lawyers + Historians = our own only hope
This is really good music
Omg this is the maths youtuber crossover I didn't know I needed
omg giants of math and science communication!
Best prime numbers songs.
Awesome 💯
Brilliant!
I must say, good job with the camera work!
I had my doubts but boy did this deliver! Great stuff! 😂
splendid! thank you very much! very funny and interesting
AHAHAHAHAHA 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 THAT COOL GUYS!!!, "LEAVE THAT PROOF ALONE!!"
This may be my favorite genre of parody
This is amazing. My jaw is on the floor. 🤯
this is amazing
This is the best thing I've ever seen
Simply wow
Never thought I’d hear 3blue1brown’s singing voice
Genuine full voiced cackle from me at 1:42 😂😂😂
That bass line tho!
Well, this was fun.
❤❤ absolutely love this you are so talented grant
Love that there was something to (slant) rhyme with Eratosthenes!
Didn't know this dude could sing.
I'm pleasantly surprised
that's awesome! does anyone still remember The Klein Four Group? They had a song called "Finite Simple Group (of Order Two)".
Soo good!
I need more math parody songs in my life
What can't this guy do?
love how the emcee is vibing along 🔥
(3:47) so, is this a parity parody?
Beautiful
Hey Grant, parody idea for you: "Axiom of Choice", to the tune (or rhythm) of "Weapon of Choice". I've tried myself, but I don't know enough maths. Your maths song parodies are great and I think you could do the idea justice.
I would love a Spotify playlist with all the lyrics teaching me something.
How do you make a duck funky? Put it in the oven 'til it's bill withers 🦆 🔥
I had to laugh, but it's a little disturbing.
Yo this fire