While the concept of a game being redeemable is almost always true, it is pretty anti consumer to release a game like this. it seems that they just weren't able to solidify an idea and decided that the sunk cost means they should just throw it to the consumers and recoup what they can by keeping it embargoed up to release date. I dunno I'm just tired of extremely large companies having zero accountability. Also i feel bad for the devs putting in the hard hours to create something that consumed years of their lives and it ends up as another live service with a 6 month life line before the plug is pulled.
Anti consumer... give me a break man. Make an informed decision before you buy a game. If you still go forward with it then don't complain about the consequences of your own actions.
@@hanumanbearpig Whether or not someone buys the game and regrets it is irrelevant to the point - it's still an anti-consumer practice to create and release a game that you feel is so unimpressive that you embargo the reviews until AFTER the release so that the inevitable poor reviews don't affect the initial sales as much.
@@rnickerson43 While i understand that some people dislike the game for such reasons, It is purely opinionated. I for one am having so much fun with this game. If before the game came out you felt as if it would flop in your opinion, then why preorder it. If the game flopped and you refunded it why are you still going around complaining about how you dislike the game.
As a DEV I don't like dissing on other games that could have a lot of potential because this game does. I think its best if we believe in the company that things will change. Just give them time. No one wants their game they works so hard for to be utter trash from the community. Whether people will give it another chance is one thing.
Finally. I appreciate at least one review that is not just a big rant about how broken the game is. I love that you objectively break down what is good, bad, or mediocre about this game. Keep up the good work.
Brilliant video. Congrats. I love the channel, the idea of it, the care you put into your reviews and how you never put yourself above the games you play. You are precise, honest, but also really respectful of both the devs and their craft. Mortismal is one of my favorite gaming channels and now, with this review of Redfall and your statement on failure, you have my utmost admiration. Really, really impressed. Thank you for your work.
It’s because many people who haven’t developed the skills to properly articulate elements that work or don’t, just bandwagon on the outrage of the day…same with “culture war” YTers. I really appreciate Mortym’s approach! It’s always a treat to see these.
But should you? Should a game with so many chances and failed examples before it be allowed the same leniency as it's predecessors? Why should this game be except from the basic principle of learning from mistakes? Why should we stay level headed when the developers are clearly fine with shipping us a broken product? Why should I respect this product enough to give it a fair chance when it's creators have no respect for me?
@@joelshajan8706 By all merits, everyone has the right to be bashing this game. Triple A price tag and it’s broken launch at launch, static cutscenes, cut costs etc etc. But still props to Mortim for being fair in this review.
Level headed? He is shilling cuz if he didn't he would get destroyed. Look at resident evil 4 remake. If you say anything Bad about it you get cancelled. So of course people will shill. Look at exclusive ace and jack frags!
@@joelshajan8706 this is Arkane’s Fallout 76, and the best games they have made (Dishonored and Prey) are miles above anything Bethesda have developed. The backlash from this pos will be far reaching and not forgotten anytime soon. I just hope they can recover as a studio, because they’ve made some of my favorite games I’ve ever played.
I have more of an issue around pre-ordering. I believe if we as consumers stop pre ordering titles then developers will ensure their products are upto scratch before they leave the studio. Developers have got lazy on-top publishers put pressure on them to release the game whether it is ready or not.
The best part is that he 100 percents all the games he reviews. I've seen loads of reviews where they openly admit to only playing a couple hours out of a 60 hour game and then basing the entire review around that.
I think part of the backlash against this game comes from the fact that people are getting tired of basic mechanics and other things that should be finished BEFORE release are pushed out the door half baked. But they will slap that 70$ price on it and hope you dont notice all the wrong in it. I think the word your looking for with the combat is inconsistent.
Its unbelievable to me that you have people defending this game. When are people going to learn? How many times are we going to go through this release now, patch later process? The consumers are not beta testers, AAA games should be released when they are finished. Not released half finished and then slowly patched over time. We are paying $70 for games, and even more in other countries. We should have higher standards than that.
I think the major reason why people are criticizing this game heavily is because it’s $70 in the US. Games need to deserve that price while this game feels like Borderlands 1 with some slight window dressing.
Exactly, they can’t just charge 70 bucks for these games but still continue to give us broken, unfinished garbage time and time again, knowing full well how bad a state the game is in, yet releasing it anyways while charging 70 bucks for it, it’s a joke that isn’t funny anymore, it’s insulting to say the least.
Not necessarily gamers but “normie” gamers. Normie gamers will blind buy the newest game without any second thought (why FIFA and Madden games still sell while they stepped up in micro transactions to worst than a Japanese mobile game.) Gamers are mostly cautious about what they are buying now.
Thanks for the awesome video! In this era that asks us to love or hate something instantly constructive criticism like yours seems like a rare species. One the most of important things that you mention is that the core gameplay doesn't seem broken so it's not impossible to get a less frustrating game over time.
I think you are being very generous with your criticism of this game, considering the price tag, all the issues it has and the resources available to the studio (Microsoft money).
This is a rather positive review, although I think the term "constructive" is better. However, it's still very generous since you are saying the game will be good once they fix the graphical glitches, combat balance, AI, itemization, cutscenes, vampire nests, enemy varieties, number of side quests, character uniqueness and pathfinding. That's a tall order, and realistically they are unlikely to fix most of those. Your final recommendation makes sense though, which is wait for Arkane to fix the game and for a good sale. I think being constructive helps offsets all the "OMG It's Awful" reviews (which I notice only started once the early reviews pointed out problems, i.e. the negativity is a pile-on/bandwagon effect once reviewers knew they were not being an outlier) and the shill reviews (of which there were a few early reviews). Being consistent and not swayed by what the audience "mood" is makes for a more trustworthy reviewer, and if it helps get review copies earlier then that helps us, the audience looking for a non-hysterical review.
This was actually super useful for me, good job! I have been interested in this game for months, mainly because of the setting tbh - love the New England in the fall style of it. But then all the reviews came in and I was totally put off. But... I have Game Pass, and Game Pass for PC (very high end PC) so will now be checking it out, if only for the atmosphere / vibes. If I don't like it after a few hours I can always get on with my life! Again, good job on the review!
It's amazing that you decided to complete the game, based on what I've seen. The vast majority of articles and reviews have given this game poor ratings for many reasons. As a subscriber I appreciate your commitment to what you do. I don't even have thr option to play this game and once upon a time that was upsetting.
It's not a bad game at all the gameplay is really good for the type of game it is people just accept every game to be GTA or Cod and that not realistic had a great time so far over ten hours play time and I've been gaming longer then most of u have be alive
I have to say, this review is a testament to your work ethics, it really felt like a review analyzis as to what is good and bad about the game, if its salvageable, and taking the perspective of the devs and consumer alike without the vitriol that the internet is famous for, its good to know that there is an opinion that i can trust regardless if its my cup of tea or not, keep up the amazing work, these efforts arent going unnoticed
New to this channel and already loving the balanced 100% evaluation style instead of the usual impulsive hate-dumping you find on so many other ones. Agreed on your take here too, you can definitely see there's a good looking and fun game to be had here beneath the imperfections, all of which are, as you correctly stated, salvageable. Please accept my subscription by way of thanks.
I really do appreciate a reviewer who has actually played the full game, most of these other reviews they are like lvl 5 where the enemies are still dumb founded you're in their game. But as you said that very much changes later on, great job!
They are still dumb in the ending too ai dorsnt change and as another 100 percenter...im glad i got this for free..cause it is still not worth 50 bucks
Sure but thats not a reasonable defense for AI being shit, its not like they miss their shots more often, they are literally hardstuck by chairs and objects
Great review I really appreciate all the work you put into them! I do appreciate you addressing the issues the game has and stating that it is not all bad. I'm sure it is important that the people who actually put the work in these games have an opportunity to see that work noticed. I think the problem a lot of people have is that you didn't say a single thing the studio wasn't already aware of. The difference between a failed video you put out and a game like this is that you have full control over what you do with it in the aftermath. The people who made this (very passionate people, I've no doubt) are most likely not the people who can decide it's fate. It was sold unfinished, they knew this. The more mild the feedback the less incentive they have to care about it and maybe fix things. If they even care about feedback, the game selling well = good enough I guess.
Just subscribed. In all the videos I watched where everyone was completely bashing the game, the gameplay looked decent to me so I went ahead and tried it out. Played well on my PC (3060TI) and I’m actually enjoying it. I agree with a lot of what you’re saying. Glad to see all reviewers aren’t sycophants. I look forward to your other videos!
I’ve put about 6 hours in the game so far and this review is the first to align so well with my own views on the game. I’m definitely going to check out your reviews for games I haven’t played in the future.
Its amazing that they not only ignored the same issues that were in their last game, but seemingly just made a Co-op Looter Shooter without even utilizing general quality of life things even their contemporaries like Dead Island 2 do such as offer an option to increase the level of any weapon with enough in game currency. Hopefully Arkane was more hampered by Executive demands or hardware limitations then incompetence, as Redfall's lows really do make Borderlands look like a masterpiece at times.
It's such a refreshing take from all the "this game is rotted to the core" another plus to your 100% reviews and a testament to your integrity. This is why you are my reviewer #1!
Ive been jamming on this in my free time since release and i agree with much of what youve presented. My only critique of the review was your comment of playing fps on controller not being your forte. Lol. Teasing aside, thank you for the time and thorough combing youve done, and i will dig in to your back catalogue and await future reviews!
I am inclined to believe the opinion of someone who has spent countless hours playing a game to perfect it as opposed to other reviewers who only play it on passing. Your reviews offer invaluable insights into a game's gameplay loop that may not become apparent without spenting a lot of time with the game. Highly appreciated!
Tbf, reviewers who only play it casually are more likely to have the experience that casual gamers have with it as opposed to completionists. So in a sense they're more relevant to most people than this reviewer is. Albeit not as accurate.
Glad to finnaly see someone making a real review & not just rushing a review after 3hours "it's bawd & that's all". Always a joy looking your reviews ^^
Really well constructed and thorough review. I played about 7 hours and I have to admit that I really don’t see this game being improved noticeably post launch: highly doubt theyre going to add animated cutscenes, better bosses and more rewarding skills. I think this is one is dead in the water (or the coffin?) and I am fully expecting a “we are moving on from Redfall and focusing on our next title” announcement early next year.
Amazing job as always Mortismal! If feedback could be provided to your incredible reviews, if any, I would say that the transitions between the sections of your analysis could be smoother, because sometimes they feel a little forced. What other reviewers do, and I'm not suggesting you do that, is that between sections they show some gameplay to reflect what was just said (without the reviewer speaking, I mean!). Anyway, hope this makes sense, great as always!
Thanks for pointing out the reason why the vampires can go outside when there's light in this game. Almost all the other reviewers were pointing out like if was a huge oversight
That's because they didn't pay attention to the first 5 minutes. They just wanted to hop on the bandwagon hate train and never actually gave the game a chance
Excellent review! I feel exactly the same about this game. As I leveled up I noticed that the world felt a little less empty and the mobs were a little faster and a little more dangerous until I actually got owned by a minor pack of vampires for the first time. I did not play death loop so I was unprepared and thought I was imagining it becoming harder because I wanted to like the game. The other thing I wanted to expand on is your affection for the art style. Not only is it good in my opinion, it is entirely sculpted. So, when you were showing footage of you fighting up the switchback later in the video, I knew EXACTLY where you were because there is so much distinctive about each location in the game.
I liked your words at the end and your positive attitude. I have zero knowledge about game developing, but I wonder if all this work that is needed to improve the game is viable (read: profitable); sometimes when we ask for things in games I feel like we're demanding a ton of work hours or something that is technically really complicated. I'll also join the other comments and say that I have some doubts about the developer fixing the issues. Oh well, other games managed to do it, so why can't this one accomplish it as well. PS: the kitchen sink: a vampire's most feared enemy. That was hilarious.
With all the over the top negative reviews of this game playing it up for clicks, I found myself thinking “I can’t trust any of this until I see what Mortym says.” Thanks for being a level headed and reliable reviewer.
This reminds me of the Marx quote "History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce." Arkane has some good games under their belt... it's unfortunate that they have had two unsuccessful sequential game launches that suffer from similar issues. I really do hope that they take stock of what went wrong and how they can fix it moving forward. Games have gotten so expensive, it's frustrating to see so many come out poorly. Thank you for your well thought out reviews, I like knowing that you have done everything in the game, so you can give a full review. Your reviews are very nuanced, which I appreciate. Although... I don't know how you run through games so quickly, it's impressive! I am so slow. I appreciate thorough reviews, they save me money and time!
As an aside, I do love reading comments on Reddit constantly asking about your process, despite you explaining it in nearly every video. Appreciate the work as always Mortym!
I see you have a ton of subscribers and will probably not see this. But I have to say, this is probably the best review I’ve watched in along time. Im new to your channel this is my first video. I love how you keep a level head and tell it how it is not act like a child. This game to me is alot of fun. To me enemy pathing is the biggest issue. If you can just stand on a car and kill 7 enemies that’s just plain broken. Then fix the other stuff.
Your reviews are consistently better than everyone and getting better every time I watch. I love that you include a short steam deck section in your vids and you always try to see the good in everything. I appreciate you.
I appreciate your mature, logical review. Instead of saying it's garbage, all of the developers of this game should be fired etc, you say it is a good game underneath the bugs and glitches. Outstanding job. New subscriber after watching this.
You're the most honest critic I've ever found on youtube and probably in all media. Most of the critics just slams this game to the ground. A triple A title such as this should at least put more on the table. I wouldn't mind they doing 1st person cutscene or making a Dead Island style cutscene where all the characters shown up to progress the story...but I doubt they would rework the cutscene or change how the story would be told. also at this point, I'm not sure if they would release the promised content for bite back edition. shame, I do like the game story and the concept.
What a concept to 100% a game before reviewing - no joke, I have never come across anything like this. Liked and Subscribed!! Also, I am thoroughly enjoying Redfall despite its flaws. The atmosphere and the Arkane signature is still there and feels great - awesome job with this objective review and noting artistic preferences!
I've seen so many reviews of this game where the reviewer played 5 or 6 hours and then said (justifiably) "It's absolute trash, do not buy, do not buy!" - and I think you bring a lot of perspective to the table with your review style. While the game really is in a terrible state on launch, you forced yourself to play it long enough for the good elements to have a chance to come to the surface. And that enables you to give an informed and balanced conclusion. Subscribed.
My friend, you singlehandedly are worth more to gaming journalism than all the big media combined. Every single video that you make seems objective, in depth and well put together. The 100% you do for games should be a must for every professional reviewer, let alone huge companies that have a ton of manpower and can pool information. Please continue doing what you're doing and improving; because you're a gem that's just waiting to be found and appreciated.
This is the most fair review of the game I’ve seen so far. It has its issues for sure, but everyone I’ve seen saying it’s unplayable are grossly exaggerating. It should absolutely not been released yet, but the bones for a good game are there for the devs to build on, IMO.
Love this review! This game really needed your style of review because I feel like most others are getting turned off in the beginning of the game and not touching the end game. This game gives me similar vibes to Sons of the Forest. A great game that still needs it's systems to be fleshed out. The big difference there is that Sons of the Forest is labeled as early access and only cost $30. Whereas Redfall is labeled as feature complete and cost $70.
It costs WAYYYY more, considering the DLCs with additional characters. You will need spend over $100 for all the content. Game is a broken mess and not up to AAA standard. Honestly, Arkane should take the L on this one and just move on to making Dishonor 3 or a new IP. I'd rather them doing that than spending the next 2 years fixing a game that was DoA.
Underrated content by far! Seen a review, and they stated they only played the game for an hour. I have no idea how you can get the full scope of a game in that amount of time. Great work as always!
Exactly! This is not one of those rush through games. I am still playing it and I am enjoying it. The different types of vampires and how they sometimes caught me slipping is very good indeed. ✌️
Never really fully appreciated the 100% thing until today. You deserve a metal mate
What kind of metal? Steel?
Bronze, Silver or Gold ?
potassium? bananas?
Tungsten Arm O'Mortym
chrome? titanium? tin?
While the concept of a game being redeemable is almost always true, it is pretty anti consumer to release a game like this. it seems that they just weren't able to solidify an idea and decided that the sunk cost means they should just throw it to the consumers and recoup what they can by keeping it embargoed up to release date. I dunno I'm just tired of extremely large companies having zero accountability. Also i feel bad for the devs putting in the hard hours to create something that consumed years of their lives and it ends up as another live service with a 6 month life line before the plug is pulled.
Anti consumer... give me a break man. Make an informed decision before you buy a game. If you still go forward with it then don't complain about the consequences of your own actions.
@@hanumanbearpig Whether or not someone buys the game and regrets it is irrelevant to the point - it's still an anti-consumer practice to create and release a game that you feel is so unimpressive that you embargo the reviews until AFTER the release so that the inevitable poor reviews don't affect the initial sales as much.
@@rnickerson43 While i understand that some people dislike the game for such reasons, It is purely opinionated. I for one am having so much fun with this game. If before the game came out you felt as if it would flop in your opinion, then why preorder it. If the game flopped and you refunded it why are you still going around complaining about how you dislike the game.
As a DEV I don't like dissing on other games that could have a lot of potential because this game does. I think its best if we believe in the company that things will change. Just give them time. No one wants their game they works so hard for to be utter trash from the community. Whether people will give it another chance is one thing.
The first time you have a
This whole channel should be considered the standard on how reviews should be done ! Great video, as always, man, keep the great work !
Yes indeed ! Mort reviews are 11/10 , the worth a buy guy is also very good and ruthless 😂, although very grumpy man .
@@FennelRPG to be honest people are different, some are articulated, other are subtle, I like to see the opinion reviewer that have core basics.
Finally. I appreciate at least one review that is not just a big rant about how broken the game is. I love that you objectively break down what is good, bad, or mediocre about this game. Keep up the good work.
Brilliant video. Congrats. I love the channel, the idea of it, the care you put into your reviews and how you never put yourself above the games you play. You are precise, honest, but also really respectful of both the devs and their craft. Mortismal is one of my favorite gaming channels and now, with this review of Redfall and your statement on failure, you have my utmost admiration. Really, really impressed. Thank you for your work.
Best review by far I have seen, I really liked how you show examples of different things as you went through the review such as combat
I love your reviews. Very detailed and constructive instead of hyperbolic and click baity. Please keep it up!
Once again, Mortim is a real class act when reviewing a poorly received game. Thank you for your level-headed input!
It’s because many people who haven’t developed the skills to properly articulate elements that work or don’t, just bandwagon on the outrage of the day…same with “culture war” YTers.
I really appreciate Mortym’s approach! It’s always a treat to see these.
But should you? Should a game with so many chances and failed examples before it be allowed the same leniency as it's predecessors? Why should this game be except from the basic principle of learning from mistakes? Why should we stay level headed when the developers are clearly fine with shipping us a broken product? Why should I respect this product enough to give it a fair chance when it's creators have no respect for me?
@@joelshajan8706
By all merits, everyone has the right to be bashing this game. Triple A price tag and it’s broken launch at launch, static cutscenes, cut costs etc etc.
But still props to Mortim for being fair in this review.
Level headed? He is shilling cuz if he didn't he would get destroyed. Look at resident evil 4 remake. If you say anything Bad about it you get cancelled. So of course people will shill. Look at exclusive ace and jack frags!
@@joelshajan8706 this is Arkane’s Fallout 76, and the best games they have made (Dishonored and Prey) are miles above anything Bethesda have developed. The backlash from this pos will be far reaching and not forgotten anytime soon. I just hope they can recover as a studio, because they’ve made some of my favorite games I’ve ever played.
As usual very tactful and respectable review. Very well delivered.
@@johnwrath3612 I appreciate your opinion, but disagree.
I have more of an issue around pre-ordering. I believe if we as consumers stop pre ordering titles then developers will ensure their products are upto scratch before they leave the studio. Developers have got lazy on-top publishers put pressure on them to release the game whether it is ready or not.
I definitly wait for these reviews. You certainly know how to pick apart a game!
Man you're being really nice for recommending getting it on sale.
Thanks again for another awesome review.
probably the best reviewer out there. you actually play the game, with an open mind, and don't just jump on the band wagon. keep it up!
The best part is that he 100 percents all the games he reviews. I've seen loads of reviews where they openly admit to only playing a couple hours out of a 60 hour game and then basing the entire review around that.
I think part of the backlash against this game comes from the fact that people are getting tired of basic mechanics and other things that should be finished BEFORE release are pushed out the door half baked. But they will slap that 70$ price on it and hope you dont notice all the wrong in it. I think the word your looking for with the combat is inconsistent.
And you still have people defending this game lol
Its unbelievable to me that you have people defending this game. When are people going to learn? How many times are we going to go through this release now, patch later process?
The consumers are not beta testers, AAA games should be released when they are finished. Not released half finished and then slowly patched over time.
We are paying $70 for games, and even more in other countries. We should have higher standards than that.
Especially because Arkane has shown that they can do much, much better.
i think red fall took a hit for the team, because of star feild , ultimately a good thing if true!
@@Ilearnedtodayy What do you mean be that? Arkane does not assist BGS with their game projects with the only exception being Fallout 76.
Another great review, the effort doesn't go unnoticed
I think the major reason why people are criticizing this game heavily is because it’s $70 in the US. Games need to deserve that price while this game feels like Borderlands 1 with some slight window dressing.
Exactly, they can’t just charge 70 bucks for these games but still continue to give us broken, unfinished garbage time and time again, knowing full well how bad a state the game is in, yet releasing it anyways while charging 70 bucks for it, it’s a joke that isn’t funny anymore, it’s insulting to say the least.
Not necessarily gamers but “normie” gamers. Normie gamers will blind buy the newest game without any second thought (why FIFA and Madden games still sell while they stepped up in micro transactions to worst than a Japanese mobile game.) Gamers are mostly cautious about what they are buying now.
Echoing a lot of others, thank you for the nuanced opinions! I really appreciate hearing the breakdown of what went right and what went wrong
A fair review - I always enjoy your commentary.
This is the best review of this game on the internet. Thanks for giving the full view, good or bad, on this game without bias.
Thanks for the awesome video! In this era that asks us to love or hate something instantly constructive criticism like yours seems like a rare species. One the most of important things that you mention is that the core gameplay doesn't seem broken so it's not impossible to get a less frustrating game over time.
best reviewer ive seen. Cant believe this is the first time ive seen one of your videos, def subbed
I think you are being very generous with your criticism of this game, considering the price tag, all the issues it has and the resources available to the studio (Microsoft money).
first video of yours I’ve seen, came up as recommended. very good, been looking for more channels to binge old content of so this is perfect
This is a rather positive review, although I think the term "constructive" is better. However, it's still very generous since you are saying the game will be good once they fix the graphical glitches, combat balance, AI, itemization, cutscenes, vampire nests, enemy varieties, number of side quests, character uniqueness and pathfinding. That's a tall order, and realistically they are unlikely to fix most of those. Your final recommendation makes sense though, which is wait for Arkane to fix the game and for a good sale. I think being constructive helps offsets all the "OMG It's Awful" reviews (which I notice only started once the early reviews pointed out problems, i.e. the negativity is a pile-on/bandwagon effect once reviewers knew they were not being an outlier) and the shill reviews (of which there were a few early reviews). Being consistent and not swayed by what the audience "mood" is makes for a more trustworthy reviewer, and if it helps get review copies earlier then that helps us, the audience looking for a non-hysterical review.
Yea, Arkane doesn't usually do much in the way of patches beyond basic bug fixes. Which is too bad.
This was actually super useful for me, good job! I have been interested in this game for months, mainly because of the setting tbh - love the New England in the fall style of it. But then all the reviews came in and I was totally put off. But... I have Game Pass, and Game Pass for PC (very high end PC) so will now be checking it out, if only for the atmosphere / vibes. If I don't like it after a few hours I can always get on with my life! Again, good job on the review!
It's amazing that you decided to complete the game, based on what I've seen. The vast majority of articles and reviews have given this game poor ratings for many reasons.
As a subscriber I appreciate your commitment to what you do. I don't even have thr option to play this game and once upon a time that was upsetting.
Hell just looking at gameplay you can tell the game is soulless.
It's not a bad game at all the gameplay is really good for the type of game it is people just accept every game to be GTA or Cod and that not realistic had a great time so far over ten hours play time and I've been gaming longer then most of u have be alive
The game isn't as bad as the internet pile-on makes you think if you haven't tried it.
The frame rate alone makes this seem painful
@@YouJGSousa you do realize all games where 30 fps before a few years ago right
I have to say, this review is a testament to your work ethics, it really felt like a review analyzis as to what is good and bad about the game, if its salvageable, and taking the perspective of the devs and consumer alike without the vitriol that the internet is famous for, its good to know that there is an opinion that i can trust regardless if its my cup of tea or not, keep up the amazing work, these efforts arent going unnoticed
You are a true g for this completion..way to take one for the team
Anakin: "I 100% every game I review."
Padme: "Sure but not Redfall, right?"
Anakin: "......."
Padme: ".... But not Redfall right ...?"
New to this channel and already loving the balanced 100% evaluation style instead of the usual impulsive hate-dumping you find on so many other ones. Agreed on your take here too, you can definitely see there's a good looking and fun game to be had here beneath the imperfections, all of which are, as you correctly stated, salvageable.
Please accept my subscription by way of thanks.
I really do appreciate a reviewer who has actually played the full game, most of these other reviews they are like lvl 5 where the enemies are still dumb founded you're in their game. But as you said that very much changes later on, great job!
They are still dumb in the ending too ai dorsnt change and as another 100 percenter...im glad i got this for free..cause it is still not worth 50 bucks
Sure but thats not a reasonable defense for AI being shit, its not like they miss their shots more often, they are literally hardstuck by chairs and objects
You don't know anything about artificial intelligence, obviously.
Well it’s hard to fully play a game to don’t enjoy and aren’t having fun with
I really appreciate the clarity of your review and your detication to 100% it. Subscribed.
Question is , if devs could fail and learn without charging us AAA or even AA price for their learning process ?
@GameFrame dev* it's the devs fault that the game is this bad
I have watched at least a dozen reviews and this is the only channel I subscribed to. Impressive review
Great review I really appreciate all the work you put into them! I do appreciate you addressing the issues the game has and stating that it is not all bad. I'm sure it is important that the people who actually put the work in these games have an opportunity to see that work noticed. I think the problem a lot of people have is that you didn't say a single thing the studio wasn't already aware of. The difference between a failed video you put out and a game like this is that you have full control over what you do with it in the aftermath. The people who made this (very passionate people, I've no doubt) are most likely not the people who can decide it's fate. It was sold unfinished, they knew this. The more mild the feedback the less incentive they have to care about it and maybe fix things. If they even care about feedback, the game selling well = good enough I guess.
Asmongold shouted you out today as being one of the best Reviewers on TH-cam! Keep doing great.
He did? Where can I see this
He looks like a creature from wrong turn. Asmon what A WEIRD LOOKIN MAN
Just subscribed. In all the videos I watched where everyone was completely bashing the game, the gameplay looked decent to me so I went ahead and tried it out. Played well on my PC (3060TI) and I’m actually enjoying it. I agree with a lot of what you’re saying. Glad to see all reviewers aren’t sycophants. I look forward to your other videos!
You review after 100% and even test steam deck performance. Great job.
I’ve put about 6 hours in the game so far and this review is the first to align so well with my own views on the game. I’m definitely going to check out your reviews for games I haven’t played in the future.
Its amazing that they not only ignored the same issues that were in their last game, but seemingly just made a Co-op Looter Shooter without even utilizing general quality of life things even their contemporaries like Dead Island 2 do such as offer an option to increase the level of any weapon with enough in game currency. Hopefully Arkane was more hampered by Executive demands or hardware limitations then incompetence, as Redfall's lows really do make Borderlands look like a masterpiece at times.
It's such a refreshing take from all the "this game is rotted to the core" another plus to your 100% reviews and a testament to your integrity. This is why you are my reviewer #1!
Ive been jamming on this in my free time since release and i agree with much of what youve presented. My only critique of the review was your comment of playing fps on controller not being your forte. Lol. Teasing aside, thank you for the time and thorough combing youve done, and i will dig in to your back catalogue and await future reviews!
I am inclined to believe the opinion of someone who has spent countless hours playing a game to perfect it as opposed to other reviewers who only play it on passing. Your reviews offer invaluable insights into a game's gameplay loop that may not become apparent without spenting a lot of time with the game. Highly appreciated!
Tbf, reviewers who only play it casually are more likely to have the experience that casual gamers have with it as opposed to completionists. So in a sense they're more relevant to most people than this reviewer is. Albeit not as accurate.
THE SOUND DESIGN IS SOOOO GOOD!!!
Thank you so much for an actual reasonable review of Redfall.
Kudos to you for putting yourself through that. Earned a sub.
Glad to finnaly see someone making a real review & not just rushing a review after 3hours "it's bawd & that's all". Always a joy looking your reviews ^^
Really well constructed and thorough review. I played about 7 hours and I have to admit that I really don’t see this game being improved noticeably post launch: highly doubt theyre going to add animated cutscenes, better bosses and more rewarding skills. I think this is one is dead in the water (or the coffin?) and I am fully expecting a “we are moving on from Redfall and focusing on our next title” announcement early next year.
A genuinely helpful perspective. Thanks!
Amazing job as always Mortismal! If feedback could be provided to your incredible reviews, if any, I would say that the transitions between the sections of your analysis could be smoother, because sometimes they feel a little forced. What other reviewers do, and I'm not suggesting you do that, is that between sections they show some gameplay to reflect what was just said (without the reviewer speaking, I mean!). Anyway, hope this makes sense, great as always!
Do you mind providing an example I'm actually not sure what you mean? (youtube will filter a link, but I'll see it eventually)
Thanks for pointing out the reason why the vampires can go outside when there's light in this game. Almost all the other reviewers were pointing out like if was a huge oversight
That's because they didn't pay attention to the first 5 minutes. They just wanted to hop on the bandwagon hate train and never actually gave the game a chance
Excellent review! I feel exactly the same about this game. As I leveled up I noticed that the world felt a little less empty and the mobs were a little faster and a little more dangerous until I actually got owned by a minor pack of vampires for the first time. I did not play death loop so I was unprepared and thought I was imagining it becoming harder because I wanted to like the game. The other thing I wanted to expand on is your affection for the art style. Not only is it good in my opinion, it is entirely sculpted. So, when you were showing footage of you fighting up the switchback later in the video, I knew EXACTLY where you were because there is so much distinctive about each location in the game.
I liked your words at the end and your positive attitude. I have zero knowledge about game developing, but I wonder if all this work that is needed to improve the game is viable (read: profitable); sometimes when we ask for things in games I feel like we're demanding a ton of work hours or something that is technically really complicated. I'll also join the other comments and say that I have some doubts about the developer fixing the issues. Oh well, other games managed to do it, so why can't this one accomplish it as well.
PS: the kitchen sink: a vampire's most feared enemy. That was hilarious.
Really good review! Keep up the great work :)
This is the best review of Redfall. Thank you!
I subscribed, simply because of the amount of work you put it and how you broke it all down. Great job.
I salute your sacrifice
Hey dude, this might be the best review I've ever listened to on this platform. Kudos and massive props to you for the constructive feedback.
With all the over the top negative reviews of this game playing it up for clicks, I found myself thinking “I can’t trust any of this until I see what Mortym says.”
Thanks for being a level headed and reliable reviewer.
you cant debate the fact that this game costing more than 30$ outside of gamepass is actual robbery
@@danutghidia5820 I agree. A 70 dollars game should be an amazing game. This is far from it.
U went thru this torture for 174k subs??? Damn you deserve more! And you already got a new sub today(me)
Strong last words about growth. Totally agree.
This reminds me of the Marx quote "History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce." Arkane has some good games under their belt... it's unfortunate that they have had two unsuccessful sequential game launches that suffer from similar issues. I really do hope that they take stock of what went wrong and how they can fix it moving forward. Games have gotten so expensive, it's frustrating to see so many come out poorly. Thank you for your well thought out reviews, I like knowing that you have done everything in the game, so you can give a full review. Your reviews are very nuanced, which I appreciate. Although... I don't know how you run through games so quickly, it's impressive! I am so slow. I appreciate thorough reviews, they save me money and time!
Wow i didn't expect your 100 percent of this game ao fast. Good job man
Gratifying to see your channel grow, you put in the work.
The Review I was looking for. Thank you.
As an aside, I do love reading comments on Reddit constantly asking about your process, despite you explaining it in nearly every video. Appreciate the work as always Mortym!
I see you have a ton of subscribers and will probably not see this. But I have to say, this is probably the best review I’ve watched in along time. Im new to your channel this is my first video.
I love how you keep a level head and tell it how it is not act like a child. This game to me is alot of fun. To me enemy pathing is the biggest issue. If you can just stand on a car and kill 7 enemies that’s just plain broken. Then fix the other stuff.
Fantastic review.
Your reviews are consistently better than everyone and getting better every time I watch. I love that you include a short steam deck section in your vids and you always try to see the good in everything. I appreciate you.
I appreciate your mature, logical review. Instead of saying it's garbage, all of the developers of this game should be fired etc, you say it is a good game underneath the bugs and glitches. Outstanding job. New subscriber after watching this.
Thanks for including the Steam Deck section in your reviews.
thanks for your review, got some questions and you answered them all ...
very nice and wise words at the conclusion about mistakes and improvement 👍
You're the most honest critic I've ever found on youtube and probably in all media. Most of the critics just slams this game to the ground.
A triple A title such as this should at least put more on the table. I wouldn't mind they doing 1st person cutscene or making a Dead Island style cutscene where all the characters shown up to progress the story...but I doubt they would rework the cutscene or change how the story would be told. also at this point, I'm not sure if they would release the promised content for bite back edition. shame, I do like the game story and the concept.
What a concept to 100% a game before reviewing - no joke, I have never come across anything like this. Liked and Subscribed!!
Also, I am thoroughly enjoying Redfall despite its flaws. The atmosphere and the Arkane signature is still there and feels great - awesome job with this objective review and noting artistic preferences!
I've seen so many reviews of this game where the reviewer played 5 or 6 hours and then said (justifiably) "It's absolute trash, do not buy, do not buy!" - and I think you bring a lot of perspective to the table with your review style. While the game really is in a terrible state on launch, you forced yourself to play it long enough for the good elements to have a chance to come to the surface. And that enables you to give an informed and balanced conclusion. Subscribed.
I started watching this channel cause I got really into DoS2 awhile back but stayed for the reviews them being the only reviews I watch
Cheers man, Bless your heart, great job
Only sane review I've seen of the game.... great work.
a real review instead of someone just shitting one it, well done man
Comment for algorithm. Plus, great review! Love your channel good work
Heard enough about red fall, not interested in hearing more - but commenting and liking because kudos for 100%in…
My friend, you singlehandedly are worth more to gaming journalism than all the big media combined.
Every single video that you make seems objective, in depth and well put together. The 100% you do for games should be a must for every professional reviewer, let alone huge companies that have a ton of manpower and can pool information.
Please continue doing what you're doing and improving; because you're a gem that's just waiting to be found and appreciated.
Compared to other reviewers he sounds like a company shill....shrug.
@@acomaslip5212 hope you kept the receipt on that busted-ass keyboard.
I’ve been binge watching Redfall reviews and yours has been the best by far. Super detailed and comprehensive, and not just “lol bad game.”
Custom Steamdeck setting? That's impressive. I hope it's a sign of things to come. Onward to 200k. All glory to the algorithm.
This is the most fair review of the game I’ve seen so far. It has its issues for sure, but everyone I’ve seen saying it’s unplayable are grossly exaggerating. It should absolutely not been released yet, but the bones for a good game are there for the devs to build on, IMO.
Wow this one must have been a though one to do ! Ure a hero !
I think that your videos are criminally underrated. Sub to this guy
The 100% thing... wow. And to think, this is just one of many supreme vids. What a wonder.
Thanks for your thoughtful, honest review.
Our hero, against all odds finished the game and reports to us so we do not have to play it our self. Thank you.
Wow that was a great review.
Never seen someone 100% a game just to review holy shit. You earned a sub man!
Nice job on this review. Very insightful.
Finally a review worth listening to.
man, you got some grit getting through this for 100%! :)
Love this review! This game really needed your style of review because I feel like most others are getting turned off in the beginning of the game and not touching the end game.
This game gives me similar vibes to Sons of the Forest. A great game that still needs it's systems to be fleshed out. The big difference there is that Sons of the Forest is labeled as early access and only cost $30. Whereas Redfall is labeled as feature complete and cost $70.
It costs WAYYYY more, considering the DLCs with additional characters. You will need spend over $100 for all the content. Game is a broken mess and not up to AAA standard. Honestly, Arkane should take the L on this one and just move on to making Dishonor 3 or a new IP. I'd rather them doing that than spending the next 2 years fixing a game that was DoA.
I love your energy man
Underrated content by far! Seen a review, and they stated they only played the game for an hour. I have no idea how you can get the full scope of a game in that amount of time. Great work as always!
Exactly! This is not one of those rush through games. I am still playing it and I am enjoying it. The different types of vampires and how they sometimes caught me slipping is very good indeed. ✌️
Finally a real review of this game.
It sounds like they have the Destiny 1 problem of "yes, we have a good story behind all this. No, we won't tell you what it is."
Nice video, good deal doing 100%. You may not be first but at least I know your review will be well informed.