Parts of the second movement are reminiscent of Bartok's 3rd etude. Overall a superb piece that maintains interest for both the listener and the performer. Based.
Liu really gets this music ! Did CarlVine live in North Africa for a while?I know he is Australian but the music has the heat of North Africaand the rhythms of authentic Africa subSaharan climes in it . So much of his music feelsand transports that clime and feel ! Very different in ways textures similar with and from the 1st Sonata which so many pianists have learned and taken on theroad . This generation's 1990-2010 Barber Ginastera and Prok 6,7,8 recital faves -as are the abundance of tertiary harmony but much different lyrical force less obvious jazzy still very modal . I learned some nes things looking at the score .Thanks for doing the work to make it so easily acessible ! The 7th minute speaks !
![Carl Vine - Piano Sonata No. 3 [with score]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kkHggVsMfXw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Carl Vine - Piano Sonata No. 3 [with score]](/img/tr.png)
![Carl Vine - Piano Concerto No. 1 [with full score]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PcGBPjaeInI/mqdefault.jpg)
Parts of the second movement are reminiscent of Bartok's 3rd etude. Overall a superb piece that maintains interest for both the listener and the performer. Based.
Very true…I wish that Etude was a part of a larger work tbh its so cool
Yes! Glad i'm not the only one who hears some similarity in those running passages
3:45 11:11 18:30 epic gamer moments
A great Sonata. Superb Performance. Brava.
11:16 - This left hand figure is such an earworm.
Don't worry, everything is just Vine
Liu really gets this music ! Did CarlVine live in North Africa for a while?I know he is Australian but the music has the heat of North Africaand the rhythms of authentic Africa subSaharan climes in it . So much of his music feelsand transports that clime and feel ! Very different in ways textures similar with and from the 1st Sonata which so many pianists have learned and taken on theroad . This generation's 1990-2010 Barber Ginastera and Prok 6,7,8 recital faves -as are the abundance of tertiary harmony but much different lyrical force less obvious jazzy still very modal . I learned some nes things looking at the score .Thanks for doing the work to make it so easily acessible ! The 7th minute speaks !
The arpeggios are so _cleeean_
Parts of this are heavily indebted to Tippett's 2nd Piano Sonata, no question.
Bravo - well done !
VERY BASED
Your Kapustin uploads are probably just as based.
12:52
@@Whatismusic123 🤡
@@Whatismusic123 Coherent noise
@@Whatismusic123 All music is, by definition, noise.
when Harvey's interpretation 🥺
I like this recording more lol
@@musicboiscores a ok cool
i made a video with it, it got blocked bcs of copyright
Epic
Почему никто не пишет о том, что работа недооценена?
BASED
boi
よくコンビニのコピー機なんかで商品番号入力して購入できる楽譜あるじゃないですか。
あれも本当に当たり外れが激しいというか、曲そのものは知ってる楽曲の楽譜でも全然原曲とかけ離れていたり、どうやって弾くのかイメージすらできないものもけっこうあるんですよね。
しかも鍵盤は88あるのに、どの高さで弾いたらいいのかがわかりにくいんですわ。
あと左手と右手で何オクターブ間隔を開けないといけないのか、疑問は尽きないものです。
よく「中央のド」と書かれているのを見掛けますが、C3のことなのかC4のことなのか、そのあたりも曖昧ですからね。
有料で購入している楽譜にしては疑問が残りますね。