What an absolutely wonderful lecture! I hope we can have more Ri talks with Ed Yong; he speaks really well, explains things very clearly and has such a fascination for the subject that he brings his audience to experience this same excitement and wonder towards the world.
mesmerizing talk - man we truly are the most gifted generation to be able to listen to such high quality information for zero $s. Thanks Ed for the talk. Love it.
As a physicist/mathematician I have a practice I call "bio-imagination", which I use along with science data/facts to attempt to subjectively feel/sense what its like to be in the body of, insects, mammals, reptiles, fish, spiders, birds, jelly fish, etc., etc,. I have been doing this daily for quite some time and the practice has greatly expanded my connection with all life forms and nature. I am currently reading and enjoying "An Immense World".
For the life of me I cannot understand why so many people in this comment thread care so much that this gentleman is wearing a mask. All I heard two years ago was "my face, my choice". Now it seems that what many people really want to do is to control what others do, as usual.
A bluejay was demonstrating a variety of song bird imitations to a friend. It would alternate between an imitation, and the stereotypical bluejay squawks. The other bluejay responded to each squawk with a squawk of their own. All of the squawks sounded identical to me, but they obviously carried information between the jays. I want to know what they were saying. I heard that bluejay practicing its impersonations the day before, but there wasn't another one providing feedback. It was out of sight in a tree so at the time I didn't know what animal was making the weird bird noises. A pair of red tailed hawks live nearby. Bluejays routinely imitate the hawk call to scare other birds away from food that they want to steal. The bluejays swoop out of their hiding place when the other birds fly away in panic. I can't imagine how the jay is planning to use its new sound effects.
Crows, jays, ravens, magpies are all excellent mimics! My ornithology professor had a magpie that learned words very fast. He could fly free outside during the day. One week I was taking care of him and the other pets. The first thing the magpie did was grab the house keys off the table and fly out into the trees with them. At least they weren't my car keys! 😂
Humans also have vast differences in the meaning they see in the world. What things are and the relationships between them. It’s different levels of seeing things like other, self, and world. It’s important because It is the reason for all wars and atrocities. But it’s also why we can build huge civilizations. The highest level is the unity of all things, and brings peace. It’s worth understanding that. This talk helps immensely by analogy ❤️🔥🙏🏻 Also, I love jumping spiders. They are cute as anything 😊 Also the tree-hoppers who thump on things to communicate 🥰
As a physicist/mathematician I have a practice I call "bio-imagination", which I use along with science data/facts to attempt to subjectively feel/sense what its like to be in the body of, insects, mammals, reptiles, fish, spiders, birds, jelly fish, etc., etc,. I have been doing this daily for quite some time and the practice has greatly expanded my connection with all life forms and nature. I am currently reading and enjoying "An Immense World". I thoroughly enjoy my bio-imagination practice when I jump into a jumping spider body and attempt to be it.
I’ve noticed when I walk my dog that he will anchor himself at certain spots to sniff around for a minute. He is only 20 pounds but if I’m not paying attention it jerks my arm back. I let him smell around because clearly that are a is important to him lol.
Just read the book. It's really wonderful. Thanks to it, I love animals more, and even the rat I hate the most doesn't look that ugly and gross for me.
Ed Yong is the next Sir David Attenborough. He should join Professor Jim Al Khalili and do a talk on Quantum Biology which explains these animal senses.
Professor JohnJoe McFadden cowrote "Life on the Edge," the quantum biology book, cowriten by Jim Al Khalili. McFadden has youtube talks also. Actually McFadden had an earlier quantum biology book also.
Regarding the bugs tasting food with their feet, what differentiates a taste receptor from a smell receptor in this context? They're both chemoreceptors
I wonder if that spider with the specialized eyes experiences the inputs from both sets of eyes as a single sense, or if it's like how we experience taste and smell as different senses even though they're both chemoreception
Human "Brain" is a sense in itself as it is only a consulting thing on the brainstem (Stammhirn) like any other sense. The dimension and disciplins it consults in, are manigfold. It could be memory - as somenone laid it down in another comment- could be understanding long sentences, as I laid down in my comment to this memory- comment or it could be "deep thought" and consultation. Could as well be association as I do in writing this here. It is a swiss-pocket-knife tool-sense a little like eyes or like Math is such a tool in science. Many people doing AI and reducing it to ML have not understood this concept.
I think this is interesting, because throughout the talk I was thinking we have an idea of the behavior of other people. We cannot read their minds but interpret the state of their minds from their behavior. This is the whole "theory of mind" thing in autism research. This is a sense because it adds meaning to the behavior.
I gave it some thought awhile ago. The brain of a dog probably has as much processing power as that of a human,. The part of our brain devoted to color has shifted in a dog to smells. I conjure up the picture in my mind of a dog sniffing and seeing the clouds of aromas that are all around us that humans cannot sense in any way.
Well if you think about it if animals had super senses it would be extremely overstimulating… I think about Superman’s super hearing… he can hear everything that is happening hundreds if not thousands of miles away… no wonder he likes to sleep in space… think about the nightmare of trying to sleep in the city with super hearing… every car, every train, every plane, and so on…
Seriously? And you’re here in the lecture hall of the royal institute? It’s a sign of his responsible concern for the health of his audience, pure and simple.
@@Ethan7s only if you like to look for ulterior motives in everything you see other people do. Pandemics respond to masking. Which is done by the intelligent, who often are more virtuous as well. Maybe that’s what confuses some people.
I always wear a mask. I even sleep with a mask on. I'm quite sad that the daddy government didn't tell me to wear one before 2020. How could they keep the secret away from us? The mask it's the reason why we're all alive today!
@@jimsullivanyoutube I use Sci-hub to read science for free - that is otherwise behind paywall. The lady who created the Sci-Hub website has to be in hiding so you are free to be willfully ignorant.
I can not find his book, did he put all these original ideas/imaginations in writings? Also wondering if he is a writer or a zoologist or just a masked/anonymous talker?
Great fun and info. The mask, come on. Enough at this point. I wore one, got shots but the real risk, now. Getting bitten by the dog and dying from rabies higher likelihood.
You've been a good boy. Your daddy government is proud. Keep believing what the government tells you and keep obeying. It's a bit too late to disobey now.
I'm so glad Ed here is wearing a mask to protect not only the audience members sitting 30 ft away, but also us watching at home on TH-cam. You're really making a difference, Ed. May we never see a human face again.
What an absolutely wonderful lecture! I hope we can have more Ri talks with Ed Yong; he speaks really well, explains things very clearly and has such a fascination for the subject that he brings his audience to experience this same excitement and wonder towards the world.
mesmerizing talk - man we truly are the most gifted generation to be able to listen to such high quality information for zero $s. Thanks Ed for the talk. Love it.
I read this book a month ago and since then I've been waiting for this lecture and finally it's here.
As a physicist/mathematician I have a practice I call "bio-imagination", which I use along with science data/facts to attempt to subjectively feel/sense what its like to be in the body of, insects, mammals, reptiles, fish, spiders, birds, jelly fish, etc., etc,. I have been doing this daily for quite some time and the practice has greatly expanded my connection with all life forms and nature. I am currently reading and enjoying "An Immense World".
Thank you Ed, that was wonderful! Always enjoyed reading your articles about animals on The Atlantic.
Nothing short of brilliance. Enlightening.
I heard Ed gives this exact same speech last night in Sarasota, Florida. If anything, he's improved it since then. Fascinating speaker and writer.
My greyhound sniffs Everything on her walks. This is called a ‘Sniffari walk’.
I call them Smell-a-thons. 😂
Reading the newspaper.
A.K.A. Smellivision
Amazing. Thank you. Anthropocentrism stops us from really trying to understand and empathize with the creatures around us.
For the life of me I cannot understand why so many people in this comment thread care so much that this gentleman is wearing a mask. All I heard two years ago was "my face, my choice". Now it seems that what many people really want to do is to control what others do, as usual.
Thank you for your Hypocricy ❤️
@@lorezampadeferro8641 , I'll thank you if next time you can spell "hypocrisy" correctly.
@@erichodge567 thanks a lot ❤️
A bluejay was demonstrating a variety of song bird imitations to a friend. It would alternate between an imitation, and the stereotypical bluejay squawks. The other bluejay responded to each squawk with a squawk of their own.
All of the squawks sounded identical to me, but they obviously carried information between the jays. I want to know what they were saying.
I heard that bluejay practicing its impersonations the day before, but there wasn't another one providing feedback. It was out of sight in a tree so at the time I didn't know what animal was making the weird bird noises.
A pair of red tailed hawks live nearby. Bluejays routinely imitate the hawk call to scare other birds away from food that they want to steal. The bluejays swoop out of their hiding place when the other birds fly away in panic. I can't imagine how the jay is planning to use its new sound effects.
Crows, jays, ravens, magpies are all excellent mimics! My ornithology professor had a magpie that learned words very fast. He could fly free outside during the day. One week I was taking care of him and the other pets. The first thing the magpie did was grab the house keys off the table and fly out into the trees with them. At least they weren't my car keys! 😂
Fascinating !Thankyou this was brilliant to watch
Such and interesting Lecture...and the final reflection is 👌🏼
Really enjoyable talk, thank you
Humans also have vast differences in the meaning they see in the world. What things are and the relationships between them. It’s different levels of seeing things like other, self, and world. It’s important because It is the reason for all wars and atrocities. But it’s also why we can build huge civilizations. The highest level is the unity of all things, and brings peace. It’s worth understanding that. This talk helps immensely by analogy ❤️🔥🙏🏻
Also, I love jumping spiders. They are cute as anything 😊 Also the tree-hoppers who thump on things to communicate 🥰
As a physicist/mathematician I have a practice I call "bio-imagination", which I use along with science data/facts to attempt to subjectively feel/sense what its like to be in the body of, insects, mammals, reptiles, fish, spiders, birds, jelly fish, etc., etc,. I have been doing this daily for quite some time and the practice has greatly expanded my connection with all life forms and nature. I am currently reading and enjoying "An Immense World". I thoroughly enjoy my bio-imagination practice when I jump into a jumping spider body and attempt to be it.
This was beautiful :)
I’ve noticed when I walk my dog that he will anchor himself at certain spots to sniff around for a minute. He is only 20 pounds but if I’m not paying attention it jerks my arm back. I let him smell around because clearly that are a is important to him lol.
Thanks Ed - really enjoyed your presentation!
Fantastic!
Thankyou. Great talk. 😃
Thanks for the great lecture.
Thank you. Very interesting!!👍🏻
Fascinating lecture.🙏🏽👏🏽👌🏽
Just read the book. It's really wonderful. Thanks to it, I love animals more, and even the rat I hate the most doesn't look that ugly and gross for me.
Fascinating! Thank You.
I learn alot, really good .🙂
Most animal senses are amazing we can use them as iot sensors they are just beautiful
Fascinating!
Ed Yong is the next Sir David Attenborough. He should join Professor Jim Al Khalili and do a talk on Quantum Biology which explains these animal senses.
Professor JohnJoe McFadden cowrote "Life on the Edge," the quantum biology book, cowriten by Jim Al Khalili. McFadden has youtube talks also. Actually McFadden had an earlier quantum biology book also.
Regarding the bugs tasting food with their feet, what differentiates a taste receptor from a smell receptor in this context? They're both chemoreceptors
Absolutely fascinating. I have a new appreciation for species differences in the experience of the world we share.
snakes sense the heat in a left right center fashion
a little bit of up and down...
they mostly just try centering in on higher heat concentration
I wonder if that spider with the specialized eyes experiences the inputs from both sets of eyes as a single sense, or if it's like how we experience taste and smell as different senses even though they're both chemoreception
Human "Brain" is a sense in itself as it is only a consulting thing on the brainstem (Stammhirn) like any other sense. The dimension and disciplins it consults in, are manigfold. It could be memory - as somenone laid it down in another comment- could be understanding long sentences, as I laid down in my comment to this memory- comment or it could be "deep thought" and consultation. Could as well be association as I do in writing this here. It is a swiss-pocket-knife tool-sense a little like eyes or like Math is such a tool in science.
Many people doing AI and reducing it to ML have not understood this concept.
I think this is interesting, because throughout the talk I was thinking we have an idea of the behavior of other people. We cannot read their minds but interpret the state of their minds from their behavior. This is the whole "theory of mind" thing in autism research. This is a sense because it adds meaning to the behavior.
sitting next to a tree hopper without knowing it? I caught them by hand since they were eating my newly planted chestnut trees.
Germany here. Better translation of this Umwelt thing is maybe "ambient".
this is such a brilliant talk! got to learn and be aware about a lot of thing!
RI, bees did not come before flowers. 37:45. A simple internet search would show that.
Its called co-evolution. E.g. apple trees with bigger appels evolved from bears who were eating bigger apples for ages:-)
I gave it some thought awhile ago. The brain of a dog probably has as much processing power as that of a human,. The part of our brain devoted to color has shifted in a dog to smells. I conjure up the picture in my mind of a dog sniffing and seeing the clouds of aromas that are all around us that humans cannot sense in any way.
Typo is smelling how critics marked the stack of books?
it was probably staged with a hidden Typo Treat.
Well if you think about it if animals had super senses it would be extremely overstimulating… I think about Superman’s super hearing… he can hear everything that is happening hundreds if not thousands of miles away… no wonder he likes to sleep in space… think about the nightmare of trying to sleep in the city with super hearing… every car, every train, every plane, and so on…
why the guy is wearing a mask if he is isolated on stage?
He did a lot of science reporting on the pandemic so he knows the science better than most.
He's not isolated, there was an audience.
@@bryan__m they can't respond - I saw the person listed on the "SorryAntiVaxxer" site.
🛰e2v chip=fish retina
*sniff sniff*
Doggy is cute. No eat ;)
Speaking of senses, what's up with the mask?
Well the mask can have many usefull functions. Like prevent the spread of airborne viruses and bacteria.
Seriously? And you’re here in the lecture hall of the royal institute? It’s a sign of his responsible concern for the health of his audience, pure and simple.
It’s for another unique human perception, virtue signaling.
@@Ethan7s only if you like to look for ulterior motives in everything you see other people do. Pandemics respond to masking. Which is done by the intelligent, who often are more virtuous as well. Maybe that’s what confuses some people.
@@pmboston So you disagree with Joe Biden, when he said the pandemic is over several weeks ago?
Your comment is actually distracting
The mask is distracting.
Lmao, how have you survived this long?
@@merrickhurst4150 probably by being in the healthiest 99.998% of the population.
@@Ethan7s sounds like they would have accidentally walked into traffic by now. Still time i suppose
@@merrickhurst4150 Wishing strangers would get hit by oncoming traffic, definitely the compassionate and inclusive type.
Really? The mask is distracting in a science lecture? Are you okay?
Hate French 9
Late 2022 and wearing a mask 😷?
I always wear a mask. I even sleep with a mask on. I'm quite sad that the daddy government didn't tell me to wear one before 2020. How could they keep the secret away from us? The mask it's the reason why we're all alive today!
@@drumetul_dacic I even shower with it.
Thanks for your virtue signalling mask ❤️
He's a well-known journalist on the pandemic. So he knows the science too well.
Why are you wearing a mask? Are you going to operate on something? Do you like re- breathing your own exhaust?
He's a well-known science journalist on the pandemic so he must know the science better than you.
@@voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 or he's bought and paid for. 🤔 💰
@@jimsullivanyoutube I use Sci-hub to read science for free - that is otherwise behind paywall. The lady who created the Sci-Hub website has to be in hiding so you are free to be willfully ignorant.
👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
I can not find his book, did he put all these original ideas/imaginations in writings? Also wondering if he is a writer or a zoologist or just a masked/anonymous talker?
Great fun and info.
The mask, come on. Enough at this point. I wore one, got shots but the real risk, now. Getting bitten by the dog and dying from rabies higher likelihood.
You've been a good boy. Your daddy government is proud. Keep believing what the government tells you and keep obeying. It's a bit too late to disobey now.
I'm so glad Ed here is wearing a mask to protect not only the audience members sitting 30 ft away, but also us watching at home on TH-cam. You're really making a difference, Ed. May we never see a human face again.
Bull. Enough. He’s young and is at NO risk. Compared to driving a car.
If there are folks in audience that are at risk, wear mask or stay home. Driving way more dangerous.
Pushing the per.papa.Gundi of those who pay his paycheck.
What a nonsense, ignorant comment!
@@dukeallen432 erm so if wearing a mask is a perfectly acceptable option to you for the audience, then what's wrong with him wearing one?
Hate dogs..