Lab Test Comparisons of Tractor Hydraulic Fluid (Round 2)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ค. 2024
- UPDATE FEB 2024: This is Lab Testing Part 2 covering John Deere Hy-Gard, Rural King (Providence), Amsoil, Lucas Oil, and Walmart Super Tech. It also includes data from the Part 1 Video for Kubota Super UDT2, AGCO Permatran 821XL, Traveller from Tractor Supply, and Mobile Delvac
Index:
00:00 Intro
01:02 Test Methodology
03:29 Could Pour Test
03:58 Shopping for Tractor Hydraulic Fluid
05:39 Hydraulic Fluid ASTM and ISO Tests
06:35 Specs, Side by Side
07:49 Blackstone Lab Results, Side by Side
12:35 Outro
13:54 Individual Blackstone Report Pages
www.blackstone-labs.com/produ...
Note, that TAN (Total Acid Number) is not like the pH scale. A Low TAN = Low acidity.
This video is also mentioned in this BITOG thread: bobistheoilguy.com/forums/thr...
Wonderful! thank you!
I was thinking of using the supertech in my New Holland. For the price i think it would be a good choice. Thanks for the info.
Great video and test comparison. I know this is off topic, but what wood stove insert do you have?
I'm shocked how similar they all are. UDT2's add pack being a little lower is almost the only thing that stands out to me
BITOG sent me here
Thread: VOA on several UTF's
Can you post the title of the BITOG thread or link to it? I'm not seeing it when I search BITOG.
@@Redneck_Ed I've tried posting the link a couple times but the post disappears.
@@marstedt No problem. I found it by title and posted a link to the BITOG thread in the description of this video. Thank you for letting me know!!
Its a lot of info, thanks for your time. Based on everything youve seen ciuld/would you rate them from 1 to 5? Im new to tractors and whts the best. Thanks
I'd say that for a new tractor owner, what is best is what the manufacturer recommends unless it's a huge problem for you to obtain that fluid due to distance from the dealer or finances. I think Mobile Delvac is the best overall value with the highest degree of confidence that it's a quality product for that price. If I had a Kubota, I'd be questioning multiple dealers tying to find out why their fluid is so thin and lacking in additives. Maybe there is a reason like their base oils possibly are far superior, but it would take a lot of convincing for me to believe that. Even so, I'd stick with UDT2. The reason I say this is because the tractor manufacturers and dealers have the most stake in the game. Like it or not, their fluids absolutely must work well for the masses or they would go broke fixing warranty claims.
I have a Massey GC1723e and will stick with Permatran as they recommend. Good info though.
Me too. The testing shows that Permatran is a good product.
Would you use the supertech over the agco 821xl for your massey? The supertech has all kinds of different applications on the back of their bottle which includes the 821xl
I will not, but if I had an issue with the price or if Permatran was not easily accessible to me, the SuperTech was pretty good. Only thing is that I would definitely take more time and care in cold weather to make sure the hydraulic fluid is warm before using the transmission or hydraulic functions. Maybe just let it warm up for an extra 5 or 10 minutes and then start out slow using the loader with an empty bucket (i.e. no load). Just some ups and downs to get it flowing. I know that even with the Permatran, you can see the fluid looks a little cloudy inside the sight glass when it's cold, so that's another indication of whether the fluid is warmed enough.
Have you tested Triax oils or fluids yet? I just decided to switch over to them
No, I have only tested these 9 fluids which has cost more than my channel makes in ad revenue. This brand is on my list though for possible future testing.
I have some new Shell Rotella HD I'd like to test before my 50hr change, I'm at 26hrs now. What is the correct test called? I could provide you with the results once I get back.
It is the Blackstone standard transmission oil analysis which is $35 plus the TAN add-on test for another $10. Here is a link to that test package: www.blackstone-labs.com/product/oil-tan/
@@Redneck_Ed Thanks!
@@Redneck_Ed I received 2 containers. Do I fill both up with new Rotella HD or can I fill one with my existing utf and one with new Rotella HD?
Just wondering why you didn't test Schaeffers hydraulic fluid?
@@markhammersmith8361 I don't make a whole lot of youtube revenue to pay for this testing, and Schaeffers is not readily available here locally. I had to draw a line. Maybe I'll test it in the future.
@@Redneck_Ed
Got it. Agreed, makes sense
That UDT2 must SUCK at operating temps.
It definitely is the thinnest fluid of all that I had tested, but at 51.6, it's high temp viscosity was still within the typical range of 50-59 for tractor hydraulic fluid.
@Redneck_Ed was that near the high end of the temperature spectrum or just temperatures you may see? My concern would be how it does at the very end where you would decide to dial back the machine to prevent it from overheating. That is the point where damage happens fast. My second concern is when the temp of the fluid is as an "average". Then say the machine is working hard and climbing temps, which means somewhere in the system. Their is a really hot spot that is well over operating temperatures. Typically around a valves or pumps which happens to be lots of seals. That spot, which is creating a tremendous amount of heat, is my largest concern. That oil, against that seal or area of heavy friction will be much hotter than the average temperature and thus my concern is how it performs rght outside of the operating temperatures.
@@nicholasmendoza6159 The SUS and cST viscosity tests are performed around the same temp as the ASTM D445 standard (temp shown in the results chart). All of the fluids were within range for typical THFs. Also don't forget that Kubota UDT2 had the highest viscosity index spec at 199 which is a measure of viscosity stability over a large temp range. If temp extremes are your concern. then VI is the more important number.