ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 เม.ย. 2022
- “The Unlawful Activities Prevention Act has been misused and today, we have a fear that this Bill itself may be misused,” says TMC MP from West Bengal, Mahua Moitra.
Referring to the Criminal Identification Bill, she says, “This law is being proposed in the absence of any overreaching Data Protection law, which India so desperately needs today.”
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors, and reporters, and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
As Singapore Prime Minister warned, " more than half of India's law makers in the Parliament are criminals", will the Government put them in prisons first, before finding fault with others?
India me deshvirodi zyada ha
from all the parties then im ok with it
Singapore is ruled by only 1 party, you can see how they have removed opposition. Also his data is wrong if u see cause they are accused of it not sure whether its true or not. It may hold true. But laws arent made my parliamentarians, its made by bureaucracy, then somewhat amended by parliamentarians and then presented without others knowledge. So she read everything about the bill and its flaws and the whole central govt mps looking at her without understanding anything
Ha bhai.....2014 se yeh sub hua na usase pehle to ram rajya hua karata tha.....🤣🤣🤣🤣par dukh iss baat ka hai ki kisi ko yeh pata nahi tha......😂😂😂😂
Arrey Bhai yeh law criminals par lagoo hoti hai jo rapist hai cause riots steal money commit murder... Mujhe samajh nai aata moitra aur tum log kyun pareshan ho??🤔🤔🤔
How many non criminals are there in the honourable parliyament?
They'll of course be exempted from the law while implementing it.
Do you mind.... join BJP. 🤗
@@SS33333 more criminals in aap party then BJP what you think Go and search first then replay andbhakt
BJP tops list,,, ADR report Google kar lo. I'm not dumb like you buddy. 😊
@@SS33333 number bhi dheklo
Ration nikalo fir bolna
Remember a movie called Minority Report where they build a system in which all criminals are caught before they do any crime. Then the hero finds out that the system itself has faults in it.
Haha...she is our desi Tom Cruise 😄😄😄
The speech is winsome.
Her statement and rebuttal are pointing to ponder and I appreciate her unparalleled and perpetual commitment on the gravity of the current bill.
The reflections on the contextualized bill and her discerning on evidence on criminology are worthy of admiration. Hail India.
Yes more power to police means more hogism by police
@@meshra26 take this as an opportunity to pick new words and improve upon your english...would help in other aspects of your life
@@syedrais7626 wow bro what a flamboyant way to address this issue however I was wondering if these laws are for criminals who are rapist, murderers, rioters, burgler s why are you scared?🤔🤔🤔
Law if for criminals.....why are people opposing it......
@@venkateshnarayana9099 not sure why but whenever I read or hear the word "flamboyant", a photo of 'he who must not be named' wearing sunglasses, watch and designer "Chinese" suit worth lakhs of INR flashes before my eyes...
Coming back to original topic, just like UAPA and NSA is been misused to quell critics and watch dog agencies are used to silent opposition...these laws will be misused if no proper guidelines are laid down from the start. No sane Indian would oppose a law which has the potential of lowering crimes rates but this law in its current form is just another arrow in government's quiver to target critics and opposition. Jai Hind🤘
Kudos to MP Mahua Moitra for well informed discussion and critical analysis on the Bill which is very likely to restrict the freedom of speech of a citizen, critical of the works and policies of the Government of the day.
At 12.13 Amit Shah is sleeping [ what a Joke from Union Home Minister ]
Freedom of speech itself have restrictions in constitution of India
It is big joke. In WB non TMC people do not have safety to live. Your comment is suitable to your state only madam
😂 ab isme kaha se freedom of speech aa gya bhai
Moitara se kaho Jo 10logon ko jalaya diya inko insaaf dilaye phir tum human rights anarchy aur facism ka lecture Dena..
Mooh mein dahi jama kar bhaithi hai jab baat apne par aati hai.. hai isme dum ?? Unko nyaay dilane ki
The Speaker is so touchy. Won't let an MP from opposition speak against the facts. Speakers must realise they are not from one party but Speaker for the House.
Absolutely Correct, Speaker must understand that he is the speaker of the House.
Inki bhavana aahat ho jaati hai,,, samajhta nahi hai yaar.
Whole system is now rigid...from top echelon of judiciary and executive to level of peons and clerks...
Criminals in the parliament are passing the criminal identification bill..joke of the year😂country is run by 2 most wanted criminals hailed as protectors of hindu religion 😂😂
You are a bangladeshi migrant. So support anti Indians. West bengal has become the safe heaven of Bangladeshi criminals due to the blind support of mamta and Co. India may be divided by this anti nationals and one day Hindus will be driven out of West bengal like kashmir pandits.
And tmc party which killed and injured many people after winning election are opposing the bill
They are not protecting Hindu or hindutwa..infact they are bringing bad name to a holy religion by misusing the dharmas puranas and vedas by condemning the other communities.. which is very sad on the part of a true Hindu.
@@jafferhussain5532 We understand who said "Muslims have first right to resources."
Yes , she is absolutely right !!
Fantastic argument against mindless proposal.....India has come a long way where notorious convicted criminals are trying to define criminal laws...hope public respond in big numbers in defence of freedom and dignity for all citizens of our country.....Jai Bharat...!!!
Typical nonsensical argument from a useless leftist! These are the same people who were against Aadhar as well. They want India to be a backward country where the state has no power whatsoever even to go after criminals. Countries like the US are so good at catching criminals MAINLY because they have excellent electronic records on various attributes (fingerprints to DNA) of all criminals. Heck, in the US they take such records even if a person is getting arrested/remanded (before conviction), just to see if they can match up any unresolved crimes!
No home work, rather She gives home work to home department
You need to get into more intricacies mate. You clearly have a biased opinion and a bad judgement of personalities.
Iron lady of India... No one stop u for speak for peoples.
My support with u..
🙏🙏🙏
But her mouth is sealed for the people who were burnt alive ...arrey they were her own party workers
What to speak of other 🤔🤔🤔
She is a shameless lady under an facist ruler disi
She has done a lot of data and record collection Excellent presentation. We need such people in parliament.
Every single parliamentary intervention by this MP has been an eye opener , the role model for how an elected must stand up to the purpose of representations of people's rights ..such passionate , well prepared , purposeful presentation illumines the nations collective conscience..law makers have the solemn sworn duty to protect the rights of the people irrespective of one being in the treasury benches or opposition ..
You mean criminal’s right to protect their identifiers
But sanghi maniacs neither have a mind nor conscience except whims and ego of inferiority complex...they are determined to experiment Hitlerism here till meet the fate of the fascist as well....
When will we see such clean and clear intellect and intention lead India again.
Mahua Moitra is simply excellent.
Only sound no content.
Salute to the one who wrote her speech. Content is extremely rich. Very intelligent and intellectual.
Rice bag spotted
Goosebumps from George Orwell's 1984...
I love her detailing in every opposition stand she takes. Good job! Lot of info to process
She is opposing criminal identification bill...... that's the dumbest thing you can do...... even united states has this bill called patriotic act
@@tarapappa1594 but the thing is even suspects will have to give away their private information to the police and it is a violation of our right to privacy. Some sort of modifications are required. Also, yes, the police will get an upper hand. That's gonna be dangerous in a country like India where policegiri is at its peak
They never let her speak. And this is such a critical issue. Democracy in our country has gone down the drain.
If that's the case than why after 2014 government has decided to publish parliament debate on national broadcast........such idiots...... don't fall into narratives created by both right wing and left wing......have your independent thought process.....rather than taking opinion of others
I see her speaking entire video, what are you talking?
This bill is only for using security agencies as sophisticated weapons for ruling govt,
Aa if they were not used by congress before.....remember emergency......🤣🤣🤣🤣every Bollywood movie has a terrist name hamid Gul......the question is who is hamid gul😂😂😂😂and what relation it has with butto(pakistani president) that ignited insurgency in kashmir......
Exactly. You've nailed it.
It's actually a no brainer but too many idiots in the nation.
Let her speak...why this commotion ?
Well explained। She,s excellent speaker ।
Verbal diarrhea.
Great speech… valid points …
At 12.13 Amit Shah is sleeping [ what a Joke from Union Home Minister ]
The honorable speaker can talk for himself. He is the chairperson. Why these two parliamentarians want to be his protector or spokesperson?
Love you Mohua Di ❤️
Really, Leaders must be like her. She is well informed and brought out short comings of the proposed bill. I personnally feel, why BJP do not take consents of its own leaders who are well versed with law. BJP seems to be in hurry. That may affect adversely if power goes out of hand.
Any law passed in bjp period is not in favour of people and the nation, every law is unlawful, great government, for whom they pass the law god only knows
First ask to take care of her mess state WestBengal
Absolutely spot on observation 👌 education is the power...this lady has proved time and again. Most unfortunately what she is telling is just word of commoners
Even united states has this bill called patriot act
@@tarapappa1594 provisions are not as stringent as this one... 1st amendment empowers the common citizens there beyond everything such as right to remain silent, right for advocate and no 3rd degree torture... Andhbhakti like urs hv screwed the country whtevr it was built in past 70yrs. Shit.
@@tarapappa1594 US used them wisely but here they used everything for the benifits of their political career. Eg. they used religious issues , they used farmers bills/law , privatization on govt. Companies , price hike on any goods and any products . Now this law will be for the benifits of their political carrier. How funny is it.
So state shouldn’t collect biological identifiers of convicted criminals as per TMC
@@lolxd926 while i agree to your point, i dont see any problem even if an innocents biomarkers are recorded? It is simply for identification of individual in the case of investigating a crime.
When bills are framed by criminals, you will have such idiotic bills with criminal intent. This govt do not respect for individuals or empathy.
Yupp.....only indira gandhi had empathy towards people.....she had highest level of empathy during emergency......
@@tarapappa1594 live in the moment dear...what happened decades ago is nothing more then history lesson to learn from and avoid it's reoccurrence
AGREED.
@@syedrais7626 yupp.... that's what we are doing......this bill will clamp down on criminals......if you are not criminal that you don't have anything to worry about
@@tarapappa1594 riddle me this...which asian countries have better police then us? Shouldn't the focus be on fixing an existing problem or creating environment for problem to crop up?
Wah U nailed it again,
Proud of you!
Mahua moitraji GOD bless you. You’re doing great job.
Ye lo... Class 10 fail ministers are the law makers in India 😆😆🤣🤣 Its joke right ... And they want tto make new criminal procedure 🥴🤣😆..Lawyers and Judges are quitely laughing in the corner
Very well said Madam. If this bill would have brought by UPA then BJP would have made human cry.
Thank you Mahua for keeping an eye on the thugs trying to disenfranchise more and more Indians.
i did search her speech on UAPA and he did say that. I dont why they went such ruckus mode ?
th-cam.com/video/Gnes2t-CzVM/w-d-xo.html
just for reference..👍
At 12.13 Amit Shah is sleeping [ what a Joke from Union Home Minister ]
She has analysed well the content of the bill . Such literate and best mps are needed most for us.
Uapa and other laws are made only for deshdrohi jehadi.who are doing gaddari with country to separate kashmir.😂😂
At least she's speaking, otherwise opposition from Congress fully dumb and stupid, and all are seniors who has no spine to speak up. What's going on. And they are running our country
I thought bjp was .
What's worse is her silence towards Mamta Banarjee. WB is 10th in the abuse of UAPA (4th adjusted to population). Our leaders insult the values they espouse.
Amit Shah, with a notorious criminal history and his Home Ministry are designing such laws and expecting the country to trust them!!! what an irony!!!
Notorious criminal history? What are you even talking about? He’s free from all charges that were falsely planted on him.
@@rohsindia Reminds a Hindi movie featuring Ajay Devgan and what's his name. Two special officers sent to Rajasthan ...whee the judges are corrupt and cab be bought .
@@techknowsimply you are forgetting it was during congress rule that he got a clean chit
@@techknowsimply that was the moment Amit Shah decided to destroy Congress and he very successfully did.
Rice bag fart spotted
Thank you, Bengal & Mamta for giving such a person to parliament.
First take care of criminals of West Bengal fully supported by the state. The peaceful
Logical, factual analysis done Excellently.
Well explained ! This is proposed short sightedly for a perticular short sightedly aimed for.
First, y not check all criminals in parliament n show them the jail as they r definately not fit to b on that seat. The reason y evm r roaming around during election to b in power so all this is put in place n have control on everyone.
we r the first line criminals dropping on ballats for them in form of votes , without checking their backgrounds and their ethical sense .
What honourable m.p.says is required more attention by the entire makers
Great speech by one of the finest MP.
Smt Mahua is doing wonderful work as a MP.
Highly appreciated Mam !! This is the role of an opposition parties... not siting with a blank faces
Moitra ji,
Most of the bjp mpies in sabha didn't understand what all you explained. Probably, they would sit with a translator and watch your lecture
@Braju B you have understood that good on their behalf. Appreciated
With all due respect to everyone in the gathering, not many sitting there GOT the whole point of the argument made by Mahua. Lost in translation, maybe.
Her party will all go straight to database for criminal charges without delay lol 😂
Well done ma'am. Thank you for being our voice. You are very brave 🙏🏻🙏🏻
She is voice of all Indians. Only thing many are unaware of the danger of human dignity of the citizens. I admire the wisdom you have madam. You are legendary member of Indian parliament.
Law is for terrorists, criminals
Speaker is also the heckler wah wah BJP Desh dekh raha hain...it's on record what Ms Mitra said that .......Mr Joshi father of 3 girl child, Mr Megwal and Mr Dubey trying to heckle .....just want to say we are seeing 4 liars on record.... Jai Hind 🇮🇳
She's a gem in poltics .
She’s a disgrace coming from a disgraceful party
Sare Criminal to parliament mein betha hey, sare riots karke yahan pe aake beth gaya hey
These rapists and terrorists committed genocide and are elected by corrupt and criminals people
Indian: Very rightly pointed out brother....
She's on the dot...
Is he a hm or a goonda king 🙄 comes here only to forcefully introduce ruthless bills
Excellent. Instead of boycotts and Gherao, Parliament is meant for such useful debates. hats off to Mahua Moitra for putting the concern in right perspective.
Mahua Moitra, more power to you.
Taaki woh uska achar Dale.. pehle kuch apne state ke logon ko to nyaay dilwa de ...10 logon ko zinda jala dete hai godhra style mein aur yeh lady mooh mein dahi jama ke bhaith gayee..kyon? Marne wala iska saga nahi tha..
Arrey mujhe to lagta hai agar saga bhi hota to bhi dahi mooh jama kar bhaithi hoti..baat karti hai
This is too much for tiny Brian's of illetrate minister's
Lol ministers are illiterates? But you Madarsa grads are highly brainy 😂
This bill should be opposed by all the members of the oppositions.
All the points are valid.
All points 👉 that the law is valid to stop the talebani, tabliqi
Very promptly and wisely putting across her point. Salute.
0:27 Shah be like ae mere ko baad mei smja dena kya boli....
Jaise Tera baap bola tere Maa ko jab tu paida huwa
At 12.13 Amit Shah is sleeping [ what a Joke from Union Home Minister ]
India needs such educated politicians
Nothing will work until the entire opposition demands counting and matching of vvpat slips.
Until there is counting of vvpat the election is a farce. Why is opposition not demanding it. The vote is not sacred till the vot is verifiable
Shah seems what she is speaking. He came with beautiful attire yellow jacket and a ribbon. Didn't even understood any thing and he is home minister. What a shame.unEducated are in power
Her tension can be undrestandable
I don't even support TMC but i absolutely agree with this representative. She is extremely persuasive and passionate.
But she did err in confronting the speaker without proper sources (even if it was in records she should have had a copy with her) now media is publicising that portion and not what she said with regard to the bill
Dear karthik can she do the same for her own fellow statemen who were burnt alive a few days ago..
A person who keeps mum on the deaths of own people and just stands as an onlooker for 1000 of people who left their homes in fear of their lives..
What solidarity and compassion can you expect from her... 🤔🤔🤔
@@venkateshnarayana9099 apologies in advance but if you are a Modi bhakt then the above statement is nothing more then hypocrisy consider his views on Gujarat roits and ongoing economy of hatred and blatantly open anti-muslim ranting
@@venkateshnarayana9099 Yes she can. The CM has already done it.
@@harryboxer1835 Apologies in advance, but when 1000 of people left their homes in fear of their lives, BJP was ruling. It has been in power for 15 years total since then and has done nothing for the displaced apart from promoting a movie. Also, if you want justify the genocide in Gujarat, then I'm sure you will also justify the exodus of the kashmiris, "given the political and social situations at that time".... No genocide is good, and people justifying it are just as bad as the perpetrators.
@@harryboxer1835 Thank you for the clarification, but don't let that distract you from the fact that the ruling party was complicit in both. That was the important point I was trying to make. I won't justify either of those killings, and if you don't believe that the government was involved, you cannot deny the fact that they failed to stop it which shows their incompetency.
This is a way every mp should speak in parliament instead of ho halla
mohua jaisa intelligent agar sab hota to kuch aur hota. great mohua
This Law Is Very Dangerous & Can Be Misused Against Common Man.... 😣
When will my country get 100% member of parliament like this informative firebrand member 👍👍👍❤🙏
Itna achcha bola ki Amit Shah ka kapda gira diya
Now I am worried about the types of laws passed in parliament.. lets say the "preventive detention" term she used becomes law.. so police can detain anyone.. and now their samples are taken and entered into database.. this guy cannot join any govt job or anything and his life is done.. so indirectly if you speak against govt.. your life will be destroyed.
Mahua Moithra 🔥🔥👌👌
She is a gem of TMC.
Agree with her. She was speaking harsh truth, so the speaker from BJP and the ruling party MP's started heckling her.
After she wrongly alleged them.
@@alen6937 No. Incorrect. Om Birla did say about the UAPA in 2019 that it would only affect terrorist not her. She was quoting him.
th-cam.com/video/4yujmP-enSo/w-d-xo.html
Thank you madam for your valuable speech God bless you all the time.
ईमानदारी से सभी विधयकों सांसदों के क्रिमिनल रिकॉर्ड के आधार पर इडेन्टिफिकेशन एक्ट लागू करे और निष्कलंक राजनीतिक इच्छा शक्ति का परिचय देवे। इससे राजनीति भी स्वच्छ ह्योगी।
महुआ मोइत्रा ने सही कहा था? आसंदी ने व्यंग्य कर कहा था इसका प्रभाव आप पर नही पढ़ेगा ? क्या माफी मांगेंगे?
These measures will inconvenience the uneducated and poor a lot
Do these law apply to Mps and Miss?
The middle class and the rich will be more impacted .
This bill directly privileges the rich and powerful and solidifies caste divides in society. That is what the RSS wants, they want to impose the caste system through law
The speaker should be from the second largest opposition party because if he is from ruling party he will be partial towards others...this is exactly what this speaker is doing.....
How would that make speaker impartial?
Actually, these Sanghis have ruined all the protocols, decorums, uprightness, neutrality, checks & balances provided by the Constitution of India by way of catapulting weak, spineless, manipulative & unscrupulous individuals into all such & other Constitutional offices of high repute & importance. This is Modi/Bjp way of ruling, rather this is their way of establishing misrule.
@@sanjaypal9202 so well said infact the words you used to describe Modi Shah's BJP are amazing
@Braju B since when Public Protest have become a crime in our Democracy & Democratic setup ⁉️⁉️⁉️
Which law bars distribution of Biryani to the People/Citizens of India ⁉️⁉️⁉️
Hawa mein gole chorna ka shauk mat palo. Aur itna hi shauk hain, toh apne ghar ke andar🚀🚀🚀gole choro. Not in public domain.
@Braju B bhai, comedian toh tera Sanghi lordship hain, who goes on and on fooling himself and his chela-chapatas. You are free to fool yourself or permit your lordship to fool you, but you have no legal, constitutional or moral rights to fool all others.
What is terrorism or who are terrorists ??? One who TERRORISE others, whether be it in a gang or in individual capacity and the actions as is defined u/s 15 of the UAP Act, 1967 amended in 2019. Well, whether you like it or not, you understand it or not, hardly matters, but you need to understand, other then this said definition none else could be called Terrorist. You are LEGALLY WRONG in calling any one or group terrorist.
On the contrary, given the UNLAWFUL acts/actions of the chela-chapatas & goons of Sanghis/BJP Jamat, all those unlawful actions of this Sanghi/BJP Jamat can well be termed as an act of Terrorism under section 15 of the UAP Act. And once your incompetent, useless and worthless Sanghi lordship is ousted from the PMO, all these Sanghis/Bjpwalas involving in UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES will be CHARGED under UAP Act, 1967 then see how they all sit on the roads with their Rudaalies to save their skins.
And look, if you don't understand anything, then better stay away and stay quiet, but don't preach wrongs.
Thus, Feeding Biryani to any other human being is NOT wrong. Infact, you all chela-chapata at the command of your Sanghi masters/Lordships make things look wrong.
STOP ALL YOUR UNLAWFUL ACTIVITIES.
Even person for preventive detention …. Gross misuse of power
She is absolutely right. There is a base in what she is trying to explain.
Its all about all the common Indian Citizens as a whole.
First take care of west bengal laandyas
wow!!!
we really need a person like her at present time..
Rice bag
Superb speech
Always faltu speech.....
Mrs Mitra"s argument is praise worthy.Thanks tmc.
BJP doesn't have anyone to match her oratory with facts
India needs strict laws like this to avoid anarchy.
Thousand culprits can escape but,one innocent can not be punished,,,,as said by a great man ,,,,,,,result is the todays society,,,lot of criminals.
Criminals are Maha Raj in most state and they need to be contained, for the safety of those who seek peace and harmony.
It is mostly needed in West Bengal
Well done mam Well explain
she is so good! love her!
I don't know any other M.P who is prepared to that extent of debate.
Salute to Mahua Moitra.
Very scary scenario indeed
Full of wisdom... Salute to you ma'am
Ms. Mahua is political educatator of high order! We must congratulate her!
Since Bhagwat mann gone ‘ it’s alone Mahua Moitra who is fighting.
The interruptions and objections again Ms. Moitra's speech by the BJP MPs was not out of concern for the Speaker's reputation. The folks objecting couldn't understand a single sentence of what Ms. Moitra was saying, but knew for sure that she was poking at their reputation very severely.
If she was within their ranks, they would happily thump their desks, even if they didn't understand a single sentence... just like they supported this Bill, without knowing a little, what they were supporting !!! The expression on the HM's face says it all!!
Criminals are presenting criminal bills ..... incredible India
The Bill passed today. Carefull with your comments now
Right Sir No questions.🙏🇮🇳
My love for Mohua Moitra G will never stop. I love you ❤.
Jihadi show ur papers
It is very important to elect MPs,MLAs like educated understanding representative to the parliament so that they can raises the questions to the govt in connection about the Bill and to ensure that bills can be passed in point of the benefits of country.We think more than 50% MPs do not understand what she is pointing out the disadvantage about the bills which is going to be excellent speech.
We need more & more M.P'S Like HER...The Fighter.... Educated... Well speaker... BJP's are illiterate, Barking
Are you sure..... about her.....some of the literate in TMC said that Indian soil cannot have bullet train.......it is not possible...... honestly do you believe this kind of nonsense 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mahuya Maitra ji ne Jo kaha ... Wo too Amit Shah ki Saar ki Upar se ja raha hain! Usse koye samjhao woha beyatne ke liye Education ki jarurat hota hain !
Speaker OM Birla daughter became an IAS through Lateral entry ... Use of power
Bhai thoda padh le, there was no lateral entry.
Splendid oratory😇