Modi govt responds after Mahua Moitra asks 'who is the Pappu' in Parliament | Watch
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- Fiery exchange between TMC Mahua Moitra and Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman. This after Mahua Moitra took a 'Pappu' jibe at the ruling BJP led by PM Narendra Modi in Lok Sabha. Finance minister reacted sharply, saying the 'Pappu' is in Bengal, the home state of Mahua Moitra.
#mahuamoitra #tmc #nirmalasitharaman #pappu #economy #india #parliament #westbengal #modigovernment #rahulgandhi #narendramodi #loksabha
Hindustan Times Videos bring you news, views and explainers about current issues in India and across the globe. We’re always excited to report the news as quickly as possible, use new technological tools to reach you better and tell stories with a 360 degree view to give you a better understanding of the world around you.
Reminds me of a line, Those who live in glass houses should not throw stones at others
In india all these politicians live in glass castles and throw stones at each other
Exactly. That's what I expressed already.
just like rupee didnt get weak but dollar got stronger?
@@bago-r1z 0 knowledge on geopolitics makes you a TMC supporter.
@@bago-r1z - Do you even know the main reason of dollar getting strong ? Not only Rupee, but euro, pound every currency is weakened in comparison to dollar . Now if you don’t know basic reason then better to get or learn some knowledge about it. Blaming Rupee weakening is just foul crying . Also read what is India is already doing in world to get away from dependency of dollar . People have zero knowledge about currencies bluntly just comment
Electronics Production at Rs 6.4 lakh Crore, Export at Rs 1.09 lakh Crore in FY2022 🔥🔥🔥
GST on panner zero this year 5% 🤣🤣
@@sarvottamsingh93 paneer me hi atka rahio
@@sarvottamsingh93 free rebriya Delhi mai milta hai udher ja. Bhikhari
@@sarvottamsingh93 5% means 2 rs bade h teri aukat 2 rs ki hi h
@@sarvottamsingh93 pappu ka paneer khana muskil ho rha h lgta h
Good criticism is always welcome no matter from where it comes..
But...
Before criticising anyone DIDI's MP should be prepared to accept the same on their face also. Actual scenario is West Bengal is at it's worst currently...
Is the discussion about WB?
@@moirangthemlakshman8715 The discussion may not be on west bengal , but if you conduct yourself more poorly than the one your are criticising , then it's better not to go on such a rant !
@@moirangthemlakshman8715 not at all i believe
Exactly.
U cannot worship in temples freely in West Bengal. I was stopped from visiting the temple as it was some other religion prayer time.
Imagine someone who genuinely has "Pappu" as a name 💀😂
Rajesh Ranjan urf pappu yadav
Imagine Modi name is Feku
my father 😅
Rahul Gandhi called pappu.
Feel bad for this guy😢😂😂
As a Bengali we are ashamed of our state government..we are already sold by rs 500(lakkhir vandar), a bogus scheme with which developement has been totally stalled and compromised..road conditions in WB is at its worst level..we are not in good hands.
Still political illiterates Hindus still voted her. Fools.
Yes I also agree with you ....
Unfortunately it's true... Mamata begum is ruining our state
totaly agree dada ...amader bongaon toh tmc key kichu bola mane nijer bari k agun eyi fele dawa
Bt there is no good Bjp leadership in Bengal. Subhendu Adhikary, Mukul r all corrupt ex-TMC members. Bjp should remove these people nd promote new generation leaders.
I wonder why nobody talks about what happened in Bengal post elections! This silence is the reason why such politicians could stand firmly and blame others being shameless on what happened in their own state.
2 wrongs don't make it right.
Bengals post elections violence should be investigated and the culprits should be punished as well but at the same time we should not ignore the things that are happening currently.
I hate TMC as well for ruining WB but here the discussion is about something else.
Mahua in this speech raised some valid questions with actual facts which needs to be answered instead of diverting to the WB elections.
If you are so concerned with post poll violence in Bengal...... What you did for that. Why waiting for other's. If you really feel what happen is bad then come forward with proper proof.
@@surajthakuri4422 What can I do when people on positions responsible for law and order situation didn't do anything and mostly denied when several video evidences were there in the media? What can I do when people of bengal are fine with electing such and being led by such? Everyone has a role in society and state mine is not to investigate it. By this logic I shouldn't be concerned about any rape victim because I didn't do any investigation nor came forward with proofs? I mean please if you're from bengal atleast behave like one being from a state of renowned spiritual and intellectual people.
@@arohisrivastava8621 I don't know why you are bringing all these irrelevant topics?
What has these things got to do with the criticisms from Mahua?
Tell me what is wrong in her speech here?
And I have not formed my opinion from these few minutes but I myself keep a track on the country's records as well.
We didn't vote the government to see the same things that other party's do. We voted for a better and transparent governance.
@@surajthakuri4422 and FYI those are not others, they are the leaders and people withholding posts which are meant to do this work
I'm just impressed at their ability to keep a straight face while saying "who's pappu,where is pappu" etc😂
Let's give name to Modi also ....
@@nsamy7628 Modi name is Feku Feku is in Srilanka
After pappu there should be a debate on "Jumlebaj"also.
Nirmala is pappu
"FEKU" or "JUMLEBAZ"? Which is the correct one?
What a topic to me discussed in Parliament. Just Wow !!
"she will find papu in west bengal"😂😂😂😂
She found the pappu of westbengal...that is the leader of Bengal Bjp.
@@dipusk6234 i think you meant TMC. Anyways i corrected it for you.
@@dipusk6234 kid u can't become chad by commenting this stop it get some help!!🐖🐖😂😂🚩🚩
Our Pappu Abhishek Banerjee..
@@dipusk6234 its mr. Abhishek the najayaz son if momo begum
I think TMC members should be the last ones to criticize anyone on economic conditions 😆. Bengal's growth rate has been consistently below national average in last 10 years.
But people, especially, Hindus voting her!?
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 bro bengal is 30% muslim. Not even 0.01% of them vote for anyone other than TMC. Then comes the bhikhari class of bengalis i.e. the rural bengalis. Here in bengal people fight over ₹1. How can you expect them to vote against TMC? Gov give them a lot of freebies. Mamta is basically baap of AAP and these freebies are mainly targeted towards poor rural communities and farmers. Mamta won because of this rural population.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 , only for rs 500/1000
@@RomitDholakia5 , Rural people can't voted against any ruling party , except they all are decided to switch over . Migrated Bengali who leaves in city , they can vote individually but they only think about own belly and under the belly ....
@@RomitDholakia5 Even after partition, bengal is 30% mu-slim? How?
Even though Nirmala Sitharaman's Hindi is not that Good but the way she used a negative word like Match Stick in a Positive way was fabulous
It's quite a mixed emotion when Mai-san is giving opinions on Indian politics
Commenting on the FM’s Hindi, how is your Telugu and Tamil?
Mai saannnnn ❤️❤️
Mai san, lets go on a big adventure with me !! Join my crew!!!
@@mugiwara9978 Yeah sure
Great Mahua .... keep going.
Cash for queries, Nashedi Ganjedi Aunty 😂😂
I m from bengal n we know the reality we can't we dare to speak what we want to say or else our houses will be on fire, there is definitely no democracy in bengal , we are in to much scared at present government in bengal
@World of Farm & pets you need to LIVE here to assess the situation.
@World of Farm & pets Maybe because you aren't a WB voter, or maybe you are just lucky. UP in general has a legacy of bad law and order, but I bet WB is catching up fast, if it hasn't already.
Don't worry speak out loud I gurantee you nothing will happen, this is Mamta Raj where everyone can speak not like Central Government where you will harrassed by ED or any other
@@surajthakuri4422 you know nothing.
@@surajthakuri4422 u get a notice from ED if u have looted the country. So please dont defend thieves and looters.
Had she questioned the same to her party head that too with the same energy, the situation/scenario of w.b would’ve been completely different. Kudos to the speech but her debate just reminds me of a student who just memorises their speech and simply rants it out. Ah! Only the residents of Bengal know the real scenario. 💀
Vomits rather.
She doesn't have the guts to ask the same questions to her party head .
She always screaming
whats up with bengal? doesnt make the news but all the bengalis are commenting that.
She is still in school debate...for and against ..
West Bengal is devastated thanks to MOMOtha bein
Not bein its begum .
Gobar bhakts like you got devastated again...56 inch anpadh gavaar can never roar in lioness's territory.
So instead of answering fiscal deficit, demand for grants questions to choose ask qstn for qstn!!!
Great
West Bengal is a gone case. As a bengali I can say with certainty. I just wonder from where ministers of this state party get so much confidence to raise questions in the parliament.
kerala also in the same league.
500 rs gas cylinder is 1200rs now....
Bengal will soon become east Bangladesh
@@shankar5497 stop reading BJP it CELL NEWS 😁😁
@@jaypanda9959 Yeah read bamata begum's news
As bengali I fully support nirmala ji's cmnt . She (mahua moitra) including her party don't have any knowledge how to run a country or state ,
But yet they get re-elected to power. How strange....
Hmm era bangali meyeder nam kharap korche
@@saraswathisunku3401 know about politics u wouldn't comment like that anymore.. Delhi is the capital of India, why kejruddin running it, instead of BJP?
@@saraswathisunku3401 you already saw what happened to the people who opposed Tmc in post poll violence,
People in here voted not by motivation but by fear so that their home will safe. Or anything can happen.
@@saraswathisunku3401 election fraud rohingya population
It's really sad that in politics we always have to choose the lesser of two evils.
This is absolutely true be it in regional (in general) and in centre particularly.
Yes because it is kalyug and no sant mahatma is born to take a heavy task of leading this country selflessly.. everybody wants laxmi in their pocket and thats how evil starts...
That's y voting is waste of time
Third options are AAP in Gujarat, etc..
Naam Tamilar Katchi in Tamil Nadu.
Similarly many parties we should encourage
@@balun872 but evanum TN la poda mattan except below 30 to 35yr
You are the puppies mam excellent speech by our LIONESS sister MP of Bengal.
Raga is like: you guys fighting over my name.
I'm not even in the Parliament.
He will be like waah maza aa gaya 😂😂😂
Cut to today he has been removed LoL
I did not know that pappu means incompetent.
Thanks Mahua.
😃😃😃
Mahua seems like a college student who is excited to find a platform to speak ….
She thinks blubbering in English made her great. That bubble burst. Next it's Tharoor's turn.
@@subbaraotanguturu9271 don't cry bcz U don't know what they have spoken.
Like you shouting here.....
She was a student and worked in MNC, what about you, did you pass 10 th?
she has studied from such a college where ignorant people like you wont even get the job of a sweeper
Rude, Savage, Aggressive Words are reflection of inside instinct...
where is Mohua Moitra's louis vuitton 2.5 Lakh bag ?
You didn't answer her questions like FM 🤣🤣
It's a her earned money not like modi 15 lakhs suit
She is rich so she can buy. Also she worked as an investment banker for JP Morgan Chase in New York City and London before coming to politics. What's the big deal with the bag ?
@@firststike katwae suvar gaddar
@@Napolean-mt3ms katwae harami gaddar mullae
Mahua moitra reminds me of the old saying " empty vessels makes more noise".
HOW TRUE IT IS!!!
Hobena hobena! Cholbena cholbena! Korbena korbena!
lol, that's the entire BJP
@@Bargains20xx So?
Vedanta inks MOU with 30 Japanese firms for Making Semiconductor 🔥🔥🔥
Both of them have got the strong points against each other. The only decision is whom we think can lead the future of India.😐
Gadkari
Oh my God
Never seen this side of Finance minister ma'am. Aag laga dia, what a revert 😀
First time felt happy to see Moitra roasted 😂🤣
Because you are a fool 💩💩💩
Surely not everyone in India would like to emulate West Bengal Govt policies.
No wonder their great leader is not able to find takers outside her state.
Well said Finance Minister 👏 👍 👌 🙂
Being a Bengali..I feel ashmed of current Bengal government.
We all do
Most bengali hindus are oversmart enough to keep voting TMC
+1
Seriously bro 😞
If you think that India is growing then you are the real PAPPU and you should be really ashamed of your ignorance.
Hope you do some research and find out whether this govt has any data to plan for future. It does not. This govt has done everything to keep people uneducated and hungry. These are the 2 things needed to enslaved people. These were the 2 tools used by British, Then Pakistani army used it in Pakistan and now used by Modi govt. I won't say BJP because there is no dearth of great leaders in BJP.
How beautifully FM answered answered this questions without talking about the the factual questions and stressed on just "machis kisne diya" comment😂
Have u heard the whole answer - it's more than a hour long
Stand for right party
Whole video is the 'manipulation' of Hindustan Times, reality is something different. If you have patience and interest go thru full reply of Finance Minister.
@@sivanathkhandavalli what's the full reply?
Great speech , good fact check, gear up your team and make people aware of real issues and financial and economic growth of real India .
What a speech madam🙏👌🙏🙏🙏🙏 nirmala ji🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
NS literally tore apart Mahua and TMC.
Agreed and did not answer the real question of budget deficit
Ns a pagal lady don't have any sense
Mahua looks so nervous, shivering deep inside 😱😱😱
I think she loves Pappu
🤣🤣
Have you forgotten the Lonon affair a couple of months back? All came back except RaGa and "M".
He is a Bachelor, Life settle ho gaya na .. She could be next Sonia 🤣🤣
😂😂😂
She has had a foreign husband before. So i guess this isn't shocking
Finally Nirmala didn't answer the questions Moitra raised..
She did. Go watch the whole video.
Ye hui na pappu supporter wali baat
Mohua Moitra ? Look at the confidence 😄 Oh my god, how did she managed to get into Lok Sabha ? I have never seen such a selective selection of data so blatantly 😄
In the same way how BJP got elected in Gujarat in the recent assembly election. There's no difference between the voters in both the states., and their elected representatives.
@@augustinealbertsouza9434 please educate urself about how elections were conducted in WB and in Gujarat. Ur hatred for BJP has blocked ur ability to think clearly. Grow up. India should come first.. not a bunch of goons who u think should be allowed to rape and plunder .. time for u to read up on current affairs.
@@augustinealbertsouza9434 lol what a joke
@@augustinealbertsouza9434 Tushar is not questioning Mahua's getting elected to Parliament; he is questioning SELECTIVE INTERPRETATION or conveniently twisted reading of statistical data. Souza bhai, please read comments properly before sending a reply pot-shot.
@@satheeshprabhu2577 Leftists have a problem with comprehension. This is to be expected.
South Korea's Youngone Corporation to invest Rs 3,000 Crore in India 🔥🔥🔥
What a befitting response by our Minister Nirmala Ji.... Jai Ho....
@Mohd G i can understand it's religion speaking here.
Hi dera baba disciple how are you
She always finds strong support among the *peaceful*.
@Mohd G send madrasachap to Israel,iron done😆
@@mohdg send Ayesha to huzoor
Well done, good Speach and good Clarification
Not congress.JaiBJP
Mohua Moitra got trolled very badly.
She deserves even worst. Crying in English is all about knowledge, debate. She became so arrogant only due to her ego. She was misled to believe that she is greatest speaker in the parliament. Anti Modi and Hindu brigades made her to believe so. See the wire, the print and Mojo of Burqua Dutt postcasts.
expected , nothing new ?
i initially thought why pappu is dragged here but later understood its actually general pappu lol
We need to understand one thing out here is the whole concept of the ruling party being a ruling party is their inevitable ability to evade from the matter at hand and shift the focus of masses to insignificant concerns 😅
Exactly! She didn't answer any of the questions related to economic state of the country that were raised by her but rather she just shifted the focus on something else. This is how people are reacting in this video because they don't know what tactics these politicians use to shift the focus and fall prey to petty politics.
As a Bengali, I'm delighted to see Mahua Moitra roasted like this. Bravo Nirmala ji!
😂😂
was roasted you mean or Mahua roasted!?
👌
Nirmala ji roasted well after that. See the full video
Uncle Subbarao manam ki evearu roast chesaro ella telustadi, kullam modda chekutu batakadam thappa
I AM A BENGALI AND I KNOW WHAT OUR finance minister SAID IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT, SITUATION HERE IS PATHETIC.
Lol 🤣🤣
Do you think she is having brain to act like as finance minister?
She is saying rs not getting weaker but dollar getting stronger.
She is saying we don't use onion and garlic what does she means, she is saying don't use sugar to avoid diabetes what the fu*k she is talking about. While visit to telengana she was angry that why there is no photos of modi on free rashan lol 😂🤣
Ap bjp k bakht lgte ho🤣😂
Try having Beef in UP vs Beef in Bengal. Same country, but one choice will get you killed by a mob.
Bengal is far better in tolerance. Paid troll. 😂
Dil ko behllane k liye khayal acha hai
@@zahidkhadim8952 chupkatuae
_Amul the taste of India_
_Rahul( Pappu) the waste of India_
🤣🤣🤣👌👌
are bhai 😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂
😂😂😂
Pappu is the apt word for rahul
Loved the way Nirmala Sitharaman countered her
That is called speaking. Mahua just shouts like a dog
😂😂😂😂😂 counteeerreddd?
Meanwhile PAPPU after listening this while he is busy with Bharat Jodo Jatra - " Gazab beijjati hey yaar " 😝
😂
Pappu Make Narendra Modi 10 Yrs PM ...
The question in toughest exams could be asked is " who is pappu ?"
Godi is pappu
Rahul
1-1
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Feku
Savage reply 😊
❤️‼️MRS. MAHUA MOITRA'S‼️
MP (LOK SABHA)‼️☑️🙋♂️
‼️ THIS LADY IS DYNAMIC HIGHLY EDUCATED AND VERY INTELLIGENT MP (LOK SABHA) SHE WAS BANKERS IN THE FOREIGN INTERNATIONAL BANK IN UNITED STATES, BEFORE POLITIC, WE NEED SUCH TYPE OF HONEST AND BRAVE LEADER TODAY'S TIME, THANKS 🙏🙋♂️🙋♀️✌️👍🏼👋
😂
I totally agree with u love and regards
Wholesale Price Inflation Declines to 21-Month Low of 5.85% in November 2022 🔥🔥🔥
Even B grade film story writers have to be responded with such patience. Finance minister is very patient and gave very simple reply. MM is synonym of waste of breath.
Ofcourse! its simple because there are no factual arguments. Aise to pados ki aunty bhi simple reply kar leti hai
Factual arguments 🙃 . . Possibly she was arguing with herself. Facts are facts and may have its root in many policies from past, atleast this government is protecting borders and making sarakari babus work, has an international presence with independent educated discretion. Its working at all levels. Facts in WB are also facts, not worth arguing. Looks like somebody observes auntys and watches too many SaaS bahu serials. Very few finance ministers of developed nations have steered nations with this skill in Covid and war-time. Only thankless and citizens without integrity can ignore this fact. Finance minister is a citizen of developing nation.
@@vm3889 and ... where did you get your information from? oh! I know where.
Btw i am not sure what to thank this government or the previous government for, paid 7 lakhs in advance tax yesterday. And what do i get in return? Nothing .. waterlogged roads, potholes, no medical insurance, housing prices and inflation that has been soaring... If that is of concern to me, I am sure it concerns a lot of people who have families and a much lesser income than me. Go on, keep beating the drums... it will come for you as well
@@Bargains20xx i agree. Even I am not getting all the immediate service levels you are seeking. vote out this one, but surely find a better one first. Let me know. Who set the corruption culture in Indian DNA. BTW, do you segregate your waste before it gets collected? . . Do you collect the wrappers of food you have when outside home? . . . Are you paying 400 rs for 500gms of simple vegetables? . . Then account what you get first and at what cost. What do you pay your househelp? Do you avoid employing school going kids for house help? . . You should actually go out of India to enjoy the services which your tax can buy and live like a second citizen or just choose to change your nation by giving feedback, filing complaints where it matters, not on TH-cam comments.
@@vm3889 Cmon man! I am not making a BJP vs Congress argument. Also I do collect my garbage man! I have lived abroad. Also I never had to pay 400 for 500gms of vegetable even in one of the most advanced economies in the world. Where do you come up with these kinds of arguments. Also the quality of food used to be much better. Lol! and what is it about employing children for househelp! I have never done that. As far as going out is concerned, the reason i mentioned taxes is because I am indeed moving out. Atleast I get free health insurance and don't have to pay for my children's fees in the future. What is it about these complaints that the government or the general public is not aware of that you are asking me to file it somewhere else ? Also I wasn't complaining.
now she is my inspiration . She really gives solid reply. proud to have such ladies in our country
LOL! Just because her reply was in eloquent english, it does not make it "solid". There was no substance in her argument.
We do not need dialogues by Smriti n nirmala tai.what work they r doing matters.
Just come in Bengal and compare it with any other state.
@@vegetal8460 sanatani baad mein. Abhi bharatiya banne ka time aa gaya hai. Deemak agar sanatani hai, tab bhi deemak ,deemak hi hota hai. Desh hi nahi rahega toh , sanatan ka kya karoge?
it was solid. her substance was that she exposed TMC's hypocrisy@@anujchaturvedi6296
Tai nailed it
well said 🔥
Pappi herself asking who is Pappu & blaming the government.
When you argue with your headmaster this happens
Kitna dukh chupa hey Moitra ji Kay maan may..😮😮 and she bows that all that she said is wrong to a certain extent that is why she is emphasising so much on delivering a show for the audience…😊✌🏼
Super presence of mind by Nirmala ji. All these urban Naxals are a threat to the progress of India.
Silly question but robust and real answer, thanks madam FM 🎉🙏🙏yes everyone of us know WB doesn’t have Rule of the State but run by Rule of the Party.Shame for Bengal people.
Hats off Madam Moitra 🙏🙏
Like always Mahua Moitra is hysterical
She is a Bengaali trying to prove that she's intellectual.
@@Yours608 Don't know about that , but she proves herself to be a depressed & hysterical woman. That's for sure.
Not only hystrical .. seems she is having convulsions when she belabours inanities / defeacates through her mouth !!
@@Yours608 Now that's a classic strawmans argument. Don't paint an entire community with it's poorest representatives. Lemme tell you who were Bengalis. Swamiji was a Bengali. Netaji was a Bengali. Tagore was a Bengali. People like Mahua, they are Bengali only by birth, not by their deeds, as is so evident even in this speech of her.
@@ahamasmiarinm Oh leave the past glory. Was this was that,,shut up and stop coming to South India if you can't listen truth. Bengaali always create havoc and 99% are depressed leftist.
Isn't this the same lady who spoke abt inflation while having a Louis Vuitton bag in parliament? I'm sure it's her remember cleverly she tried putting the bag down to hide it. Can someone clarify if this is her?
First answer her questions IT CELL DALAL of BJP
If we ask questions we are dalal of bjp, then who are these the chamchas and by the Madam sitharaman answered her questions very correctly but chamchas won't understand
The DY of IMF has even said India is a bright spot in the global economy. She is an alumnus of Princeton and teaches at Harvard so I'm inclined to believe her assessment abt India. But Mahua chooses to select a particular industrial contraction and ignore the remaining parameters, why doesn't Mahua speak on the growth of the agricultural sector? Because it is inconvenient for her. Then she tries targeting govt on the issue of demonetization, I mean demonetization helped India become the global leader in real-time payments but she claims falsehoods were being spread. I mean demonetization helped India usher into the digital Era which has won praise from multiple countries but Mahua doesn't wanna talk abt this cause it's inconvenient. Mahua is one tone-deaf MP she has no clue what she is talking abt and when someone responds she can't comprehend.
Seriously the guy above said is true when ppl respond to ur questions you call them BJP IT Cell and whole other nonsense. The fact is liberals can't handle the truth so it's become a defense mechanism of sort where you accuse ppl of BJP IT Cell and whole other nonsense to deflect. But let me remind you it makes you ppl look pathetic when you do that.
Moral: Question for a question leaves no answer.
When answers are already out but you can't understand so keep roaming here and there
She spoke an hour and half go watch
She replied bro!!!!
@@praneshhodlur9168 Sorry I can't see Bengal riots as an answer to question on economic slowdown and brain drain. Help me understand...
@@ashutosh_aman Dear, i meant, watch the full video,it's just the closing dialogues mentioned here.
Instead of debating/fighting on these issues--which no one really cares about--please get together with a plan and follow it by action. The Indian people need effective action and soon!
I don't care where or what mohua has studied....the fact that she can't speak decently without getting restless speaks volumes about her aptitude and character
Experience, will come slowly and steadily in future. Even If u are in ruling party, then also it happens.
💯👍
Even my blood boils because we are not a progressing country and you should be ashamed as well. Im not sure how much tax you pay to the government??
@@soundararajanvenkataraman1445 I am confident that Mohua Moítra would be able to speak more vocal
Ohooo...what a response by Nirmala ji. Being a Bengali I m very proud of this Central govt and equally ashamed of this state govt.
Khela Hobay Jindabaad ⚽⚔️⚽⚔️⚽ Madame Momota Bannerjee Jindabaad 💪⚔️💪⚔️💪
BEING A BENGALI I AM VERY PROUD OF MY STATE GOVERNMENT AND ASHAMED OF THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT. THAT'S IT.
@@anuragganguly5024 no one cares
@@Sudeep.Manerkar NO ONW CARES ABOUT WHOM?? YOU??😂
@@anuragganguly5024 nope u
Mahua can very well ask the Indian public on which they are unanimous.
Contraction in manufacturing for a particular month does not neccesarily translate into job loss.
There were no jobs before either.
@@archiem654 Yeah, as if the entire country is out on the streets begging. I mean, seriously? There's stats and numbers and there's the reality, and any interpretation of the stats and numbers should conform with the reality. If it doesn't conform, it's your analysis and interpretation that needs to change, but you are looking to change the reality to conform with your analyses and interpretations. How foolish.
@@archiem654 Yeah, as if the entire country is out on the streets begging. I mean, seriously? There's stats and numbers and there's the reality, and any interpretation of the stats and numbers should conform with the reality. If it doesn't conform, it's your analysis and interpretation that needs to change, but you are looking to change the reality to conform with your analyses and interpretations. How foolish.
@@ahamasmiarinm the reality is there are no jobs. and people are not begging. They are protesting. Sometimes agneeveer, sometimes against late results, sometimes against no new vacancies. There are no jobs in private sector. And they are eliminating govt jobs as well. Take a look at the situations of all competitive exams. All are either late, postponed or result is late.
@@archiem654 Ok, agreed, but tell me something new. Dude, when I graduated, and I was an honours graduate in a stream of applied science, my departmental job exams haven't had happened for 10 years, and there was no indication when it would happen next. All my batchmates went abroad and those who wanted to remain in IND chose a different career. I too opted for the latter.
This was in the early 2000s. Hence I ask, tell us something new, and the purpose of referring to the past was not to portray any indifference to the problem by highlighting that it always existed but to show that this is a really age old problem, a kind of problem which would need decades before it can be resolved.
However, I can say one thing. If policies like 100% MSP or Old Pension Schemes are brought into practice, it would only add to our problems, and not only the problem of unemployment but of health, education and all infrastructure issues.
Instead answering topic changed to match box😂😂😂
Defence Purchases via GEM Portal from MSMEs near Rs 42,000 Crore 🔥🔥🔥
Nirmala mam speaking in modi style... Mja aaya...😂
NO one respect. After she become finiane minter, India money value is sinking. No one respect in TN as well. Stupid women
Bro pls we are stupids who listening bjp speeches..
These frauds are trained in same way😂
@@പിപ്പിടികുട്ടൻ cause they don't wanna be like pappu 💀
Pappu national award has been won by Rahul Gandhi no debates
And lot of people in Congress are really competitive and envious for it
Like a Jackal that died in between waring Rams Rahul Pappu become victim.
And jhasaram award in the world is only made for our feku ji. Let's clap your hands on the belly of tadipad.
@@mr.ganguly2624 okay pappubhakt
@@mr.ganguly2624 pappubhakt 🤣
Jai mahuwa madam
Superb speach madam
Anybody who still have any doubt in Nirmala ji, just look at Indian stock market and inflation rate and compared it to developed countries. And let's thank RBI also 🇮🇳🙏❤️🇮🇳
In 2008 all the developed countries except china faced massive inflation and downfall in development due to huge recession but India is the topper in growth rate and best in the world regarding inflation control during that phase.... and now due to covid effect and russia-ukrain war effect developed countries suffering as they made some restriction against russia and those restrictions hitting them back... but there is not much effect of Rus-Ukrain war on India as India didn't agreed for any restrictions so India must perform very well but with these leaders like Nirmala ji our economy collapsing equally with other countries.... since 2019 in India growth is collapsing continually, so covid is not a big factor in our economy downfall as our priya modi ji ka sarkaar successfully collapsing our economy since before covid existence...... Nirmala ji is worst FM India ever had..... she didn't answered even a single question that raised by Mrs.moitra with official data but still you are praising her....Andhbhakt Jahapana aap ko koti koti naman.....
A corrupt and incompetent government will fall down automatically when people suffer from a government party that has poor governance and corruptive practices. Congress lost and win many elections in the past due to poor governance and high corruption. Need to wait and see what the people of this nation are going to decide in next general elections. Are they having a very tough period now or still life is fairly going thru well in spite of the turmoil the world is going through now (people of India have to compare and see what happened to the tiny neighbouring countries). The people should weigh down in their minds and see whether BJP government is worst or at least good in governance.
What about increasing anti social elements in Bengal....
I like when mahua is trolled in public 😅
This is true . WB's post voting situation was worst as per my view after living longer time of period there
What a superb reply our FM , Well done Mam 🙏🙏
What happened?? who is pappu?? what is the meaning of the pappu??
Great answer Madam Finance Minister. Salute you for your spirited and factual reply.
The capability is seen in the demeanour and body language. While the former is dancing in and around with anger and fear and what not, the latter is visibly calm and maintains her composure!
Jab clear majority ho to demeanor composed hi rehta hai.
@@S_Mukherjee. us Decomposed lady ki baat mat kar. India ko sadaa ke barvad kar di. Finance Minister bani aur India ka foundation thod dali, ab log bharat chod ke jane lage. Bharat chodo# Leave India
Oh my I've seen the latter turn into Atila the hun with her nostrils flared especially when RAGA asks pertinent questions. Netizens have called her nostrilammi. Pickle Ammi has still not got her act together and has no idea on macro economics. And the Janta who gave the matches are high on gau mutra. Gujarat is their bastion so nothing great. No takers in the literate south for gobar
Isn't Nirmala tai the one who said that piyaj khana chhod dene se uska daam Kam ho jayega
BJP members need to have IQ like Modi I wonder
@@kanadmitra2267 she said mai pyaz nhi khati 😅
TNX GOOD brother and sister TNX GOOD Family First good Indian First good business ok thanks good
Hats off to our FM . What are response . Loved it !!!! Jai hind
Well said Nirmalaji. Mahua & Team are best at only showing their middle finger in News Channel. 1 of the worst parties in Bengal (even worse than CPM) is Mamta's goonda party
The thing which was astounding is that finance minister didn't even gave the answer of one single question asked to her, and just pointed the gun on another
Because she asked questions without her so called facts
Thats why nirmala is a pappu
She already stated, she answered her rant in various forms.
Listen to the entire session.
The entirety of her speech is not covered in this buddy. In question hour all the questions asked by mahua need to be answered number wise. This is not a debate between friends. Parliamentary debates are moderated.
@@arnavsadhu she would never answer them and she can never answer them...had she answered the stooge HT would have shown it....since she had given this pathetic response, they are showing it as a heroic response and closed the topic....hopeless BJP government as usual.....
Madam I appreciate your COURAGE in asking the Finace minister, who is pappu, When YOU asked the question you know very well who is pappu. Madam YO
Mohua tried to be more smart, but FM tought her a lifetime lesson🤣🤣🤣
y she has not able to reply main points these are rethoric. main useing cbi hands of govt but no result in accusation y didnt she spk
@@mgopalnaidu7709 Tmc all leaders are corrupt including mamata...
I am from Bengal , nirmala ji great reply to mohua Moitra , she said abolutely right to use of 'machis'
Kyu bhai agaya swaad?..... moment
She does not represent herself like a respectable political personality. The way she delivers her points are acceptable upto the level of college debate and so is with Smt. Nirmala Madam. They both should act like a matured Parliamentarian.
Asking the questions is far more important than if it's asked in a appropriate way or not. Hope you get the point Grandpa
Nirmala maa'm replying to the point and shown molina Mitra that u are still in school level debate and I am the principal..
Mahua moitra is a comode me chipki hui tatti 😂😂😂
this is our Parliament. Instead of rejecting such questions that denigrate the parliament she chose to answer it. I think madhua mitra should watch the video where the actual "papp" accepted in front of the whole assembly that he is a pappu.
Mohua ji asked questions on the facts and data but nirmala as an finance minister expected to give answer on facts and data but nirmala replying only on who is pappu and this is how bjp ministers blame and reply to opposition because bjp and there ministers don't have any answer and that's why Shame on bjp and there ministers
response was very good ...😁
Mohua Mitra should lecture this to her queen and tell her to introspect of the situation of wb.
Mahua Moitra
You are doing really good. Keep it up. Do not fear. India needs more people like you. And people watching you are becoming braver. Don't back down. You are doing great
She is good can talk without loud speaker. Maybe being a singer a better choice.
Well ! I have heard the parliamentary. Debate But the debate in the chat section of this video is amazing. kudos to all responsible citizen of India who are really concern about Indian politics.
4-5 lines Mahua barking Moitra inserted only for bravado - "I am this ... I am that ... Dont talk to me ... I am blah blah " 🤣
This is what is passed off as "fiery speech" and "reigns fire".
What a reply by nirmala ji 👏
Mind-blowing ...
She is from JNU she can take all these stuff
ok. but her reply was beyond the original questions. Mahuya raised questions about the economy in the past months. But Nirmala ji totaly out of mark. actually she have no answer about that. she pointed out only political comments
Ja ja andbhakt.... Tuje kay pata ki politics kay cheez hai🥸
@@animeshdebnath9991
That's where Sashi Tharoor is ahead of her (Mahua) and rest.