I was emotional throughout watching this video. I pray that Rana sahib and many others like him are given visas to visit their friends and I see their deeply rooted background. I am ashamed of all my friends from India who have commented here with so much hatred. I can only pray that God enlightens you ✝️🌹🙏
Why hatred ? So many uncountable terrorists attack, broke our country in name of religion by stupid theory they do bigotry at every point and now then this small neutral minority people of their community didn't spoke about their majority and became silent watchers .
I doubt your identity..A Hindu/ sikh punjabi cannot forget the trauma inflicted on his ancestors by these people... These sufferings are of their own making..
Surely this man who still carrys the love for his native place deserves to be able to visit. Rana Sahab should've been granted long ago but it's better not to talk about the hatred that was seeded by who we know, if there's any angst on this it's bit normal, specially for the people who were displaced, and this feeling cannot be felt by those whose ancestors didn't go through this pain.
Arvind, plz do a similar program on Kashmiri Hindus who lost their moorings, their homeland in 1990. And, ask Ishtiaq Ahmed to comment on it because he avoids commenting on Kashmiri Hindus. Two generations of Kashmiri Pandits have died in the last 35 yrs.
Nostalgia is very painful, gentleman anguish is piercing my heart. Partition was biggest blunder, only person responsible was Jinnah, in his pigheaded approach to win the case on million of dead bodies. Still, he got nothing, achievement a big zero. @Arvind bhai, your programs are always very difficult to watch except with tears.
@medusaachla Our Gandhi- Nehru duo was equally responsible. Had their approach been logical, they would have encouraged all Muslims living in India to migrate to Papistan. Complete transfer of population - then Hindus would not have faced persecution in Bangladesh, Papistan n Afghanistan.
Hinduo ka iska koi drd nahi hai muslo ki gulami krta hai humai bhai chara nahi chia ab inki asliyat pata chl chuki hai humai Pakistan se koi relation nahi chia 🚩🚩
यह एक दिल को छूने वाला अफसाना है। हम भी कश्मीर की यादों से छुटकारा नहीं पाते हैं। घर जहां जन्म लिया वह जनत से भी प्यारा होता हैं। राणा साहब ने मर्जी से घर को खैराबाद किया।हमे घर छोड़ने के लिए मजबूर किया गया। रहम!
When Ishtiaq was in Delhi- Gurgaon, I offered to set up a meeting with displaced Kashmiri Pandits at Delhi/ Gurgaon as per his convenience. He never responded.
We didn't ask i mean our ancestors we are also from same haryana. Muslim league explaoited indian Muslims please stop this now we are paying price already here
कहाँ है आतंकवाद? यूनाइटेड नेशन का फ़िलहाल आतंकवाद की परिभाषा यूनाइटेड नेशन और ईसाई मुसलमानों का दोहन कर रहे हैं। जब तक मुसलमान गैर मुसलमान को लूटता है, या कत्ल करता या उनकी नारियों का बलात्कार करता है, वह कार्य जिहाद होता है। जब तक मुसलमान काश्मीर या इजराइल मांगता है। वह जिहाद होता है। जब तक मुसलमान भारतीय सैनिकों पर हमला करता है, वह जिहाद होता है लेकिन ज्यों ही ईसाई मारा जाता है, पेंटागन व लंदन की रेल व बसौ पर हमला होता है और मुसलमान अमेरिका व इंग्लैंड मांगता है, वही कार्य आतंकवाद हो जाता है। काश्मीर व गाजा पट्टी पर समझौता कराने के लिए ईसाई सदैव तत्पर रहते हैं। अल्लाह ने मुसलमानों को विश्व की सारी धरती सौंप रखी है, फिर वे अमेरिका व ब्रिटेन मुसलमानों को क्यों नहीं सौंप देते?
मनुष्य इतने घृणित हैं कि इच्छा नहीं होती है इनसे सहानुभूति रखने की। पाकिस्तान के कारण पिछले पचहत्तर वर्ष से हमलोगों ने इतना झेला है कि अब दर्द नहीं होता।
Pakistanis are the most tolerant people in the world. Usually I hear Hindu baniya, Hindu Kaffir, Ghazwa-e-hind, lal qile par jhanda phrases on Pakistani discussions. These are all phrases of love and tolerance. Also see how Pakistanis have treated Hindus, bengalis, Shias, Balochs, Pashtuns, Sikhs, Parsis, Jews, Christians, Ahmadis, and now Afghans. No one will call Pakistanis intolerant. Everyone in the world should appreciate this.
Manoj ji, your opinion is justified for the mullas and paki military backed so called TV anchors. We cannot declare 250 million Pakistanis anti India 🇮🇳. Like we have anti muslim extremists in India 🇮🇳 ,Pakistan has anti Hindu groups too. More broadly speaking it’s not India 🇮🇳 or Pakistan, extremism and racists exist all over the world in all countries.
Extremists and hate mongers not only exist in India 🇮🇳 or Pakistan but all over the world in different countries. Humans at large believe in coexistence, it’s law of nature.
अरविंद जी ऐसा ही इंटरव्यू भारत में बसे निर्वासित पाकिस्तान से और काश्मीर से आये लोगो का भी लिजीऐ ताकी पाकिस्तान और काश्मीर के जेहादी ओ के झुठी , गलतफहमी ओ की जानकारी मीले,,
O Kaka, Hume kya lena dena, kisi bi Pakistani bujurg se. Wo kya kahta hai. Hum logo ko maf karo bhai..Agar koi dislike ka button hota to main use click ker deta.
Emotional blackmailing 77 saal se chalte arah hai Arvind ji. now we are more aware of this & tired of it. No more same nara "we are same people of this land" & " Hindi chini bhai bhai"😂.
This is Mr. Arvind Saharan’s way of emotional blackmail. Much as I empathise with Rana sahib but issues are caused by the Pakistani establishment. The appeal should be made to the Pakistani government and establishment to mend their ways.
Five six more years ..this emotional touch will end permanently .. Than pakistan and India will have no relation at all . Both will happily ever after ..
अरविंद जी कभी हिंदुस्तानियों का इस तरह का इंटरव्यू नहीं करेंगे क्योंकि आपको देख मुस्लिम में और ज्यादा से ज्यादा मुसलमानों का यह सपोर्ट करते हैं आपके मन में कितना भाईचारा है यह इन चीजों से पता पड़ता है आप जो छुपा हुआ है झंडा चला रहे हो अच्छा नहीं
Muslims live in peace when they are ruled by foreigners or other religionists. Heard Hindu Muslims Sikhs used to live in peace during Maharaja Ranjitsingh rule!
Namashkar, really it had been very emotions loaded episode. Made us to think "what a blunder we committed. We had sympathy with Rana sahib to get visa n re-live his younger days here in Hariana, Punjab
Arvind Paaji 🙏, Mai Hoshiarpur se too nhi par hamare enn Buzurg Taya ji ke liye Hariana ja sakta hu aur VC pe inko Inka school aur kasba dikha sakta hu agar aap co-ordinate krre 🙏
@@ArvindSaharan Why do you feel sorry? They wanted Pakistan, so now they got it. What is the problem, jinnah and his muslims killed loads of non muslims in the partition. Why do you feel sorry for these ppl. You want this to happen to the next generation, too,wake up ppl, how many ppl did this guys family kill?and rape? That's a question
It is irreversible. Nothing can be done.Boodiest partition in history of mankind which killed millioins of innocent people. People who instigated this tragedy are still in India and are after another partition When this rock n roll stop?
My father used to live with his maternal grandparents in village Nangal Issar, about two or three miles from Hariana.He did his matriculation from a school in Hariana in 1930. Our own village is about 5 miles from Hariyana,near Bhunga. I have great memories of spending summer holidays in our village. There were thousands of desi mango and Jamun trees in that area.Most of these have now been cut down unfortunately, and replaced with Poplar and Eucalyptus trees.
What is the point of all this, Arvind? One cannot go back to the past. Pakistan has turned out to be an evil state as far as Indians are concerned. Pakistani army just cannot accept a peaceful co-existence with India because they have to then dismantle all their enterprises/establishments/postures/edifices. That will never ever happen. So all this talk is a waste of time other than triggering some emotions. Please be realistic.
Empathize with him and his emotions. Wish him best of health and hope he has good time with the help of his good memories. Impractical wishes will only hurt him. The two nations have moved apart and the generations have changed, many cannot relate to such emotions. Given the mistrust between the two nations, scope for good relations is nowhere in sight.
अरविंद जी, आज जो इंटरव्यू राणा मोहम्मद अजहर जी का आपके चैनल पर देखने का मौका मिला असल में यह अजहर जी ही क्यों आज जो पाकिस्तान में हिन्दुस्तान में करोड़ों लोग हैं इसी हिंदुस्तान के हैं। हिंदुस्तान में रहने वाले भी सभी उनके जैसे हैं। आज की स्थिति क्यों हुई, यह तो जो उस समय लोग थे उन्हें विचार करने की जरूरत है। आज भी कुछ भी संभव है अगर दोनों और के लोग चाहे तो.... ओरिजनली तो सब एक थे एक हैं यह एक मजहब हमारे बीच ऐसा आया जिसने हमें बांट दिया हमें ही नहीं, हमारी धरती को भी बांट दिया, अपनों को भी बांट दिया, और जहां हम दुनिया में आज हो सकते हैं, हम जो ओरिजनली थे वह अगर हम हो जाय तो इस दुनिया में हमारे सामने किसी की भी खड़े होने की हिम्मत नहीं हो सकती। हम अपनी सारी ताकत आपस में ही लड़कर बर्बाद कर रहे हैं, क्यों लड़ रहे हैं यह तो हमें ही सोचना पड़ेगा कोई दूसरा हमारे बारे में सोचने वाला नहीं आएगा।
I have just seen the early 15 minutes of the episode and already emotional! I am myself from Haryana and my family moved from Lahore to Uccha Pind in Punjab and then finally to Haryana. Very few 90+ souls left now who have living memories before partition left and can make such passionate pitch on their living & Religion bias free life.
Indian Punjabi logon ka Pakistani Nostalgia ka dush parinaam Bharat ko itne saal bhugatna pada. Ab Pakistani Senior Citizen ko kyun footage dilate ho ?
पाकिस्तानी बुजुर्ग की अपील बड़ी हृदय छूने वाली है। इसे स्वीकार किया जाए क्योंकि मैं भी अपने जन्म स्थान तौंसा शरीफ को नहीं भूल सका। वाकई हम बचपन भूल भी नहीं सकते।
Similar old persons created Pakistan, when younger.!!check present youth ideology in Pakistan..!! Remember Tariq fateh.. Hanskar lia Pakistan, larrkar lenge Hindustan... These peoples responsibility can't be ignored for creating present pakistani ideology.
This episode truly moved me to tears. I believe that 45 minutes was far too brief for such meaningful conversations. Rana Saheb deserved more time to share his insights without frequent interruptions. It’s inspiring to witness a 90-year-old in such remarkable health, with a clear voice and sharp memory. I urge you to consider another episode with him, and please inquire about his secrets to maintaining such excellent health, voice, and memory. Additionally, having Prof. Istiaq Ahmed in this episode added a fascinating dimension to the discussion.
पर आप लोगो को तो इस्लाम का नशा चढा था ना कि इस्लामी देश चाहिये. आप कि सोच भी वही थी इसलिये तो वहा चले गये. नही तो यहा रहते जैसे और मुस्लिम रहे यहा. आपने पाकिस्तान मुस्लिम देश बनाया इसलिये वहा के हिंदू लोगो को मजबुरी मे वहा से हिंदुस्थान आना पडा. आपको तो ऐसा कुछ नही था. अब रोके क्या फायदा.
आम पाकिस्तानी लोगों ने अलग देश नहीं मांगा था,अधिकतर मुस्लिम जमीदारों,नेताओं ने मिलकर पाकिस्तान माँगा था,मोहम्मद अली जिनांह ने प्रधानमंत्री भारत के पहले प्रधानमंत्री बनना चाहते थे,लेकिन जनसंख्या के कारण वे हार गये ।तब उन्हें पाकिस्तान की माँग की।95 प्रतिशत मुस्लिम आबादी तो धर्म परिवर्तन के कारण ही हिंदू से मुस्लिम बनी थी,उसके भी कई कारण थे,उन कारणों को हिंदू और मुसलमान दोनों ही जानते थे,इसीलिये दोनों के बीच उस समय इतना प्रेम और भाईचारा था ।
I have heard like all this from my father who was a renowned teacher in East Pakistan before partition ie in the period of 1935 - 1960. As a Indian I humbly request our govt ro do sympathy to Rana Sahab who is 90 years old man .
Any particular reason why people in POJK dont speak and write Kashmiri, dogri or any local language? What happened to the Buddhists, Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis in Pakistan and Bangladesh? What happened to the Temples, Sharda scriptures, Valmiki community?The people who are cut off from their roots are now crying because of economic and governance failure. Time to reflect on your own Ideology and failures. So please leave India alone.
It is only Pakistan and jineh who is responsible for all genocide of both hindus and muslims in 47 i am a kashmiri hindu we have also left our birth place in 90. We feel pain like you. What to do now. It all happened due to the bad policy of Pakistan since the period of general ziaulhaq.
Babaji kahate the sab ikathha rahate the, sahi hai . Magar Hindu, Sikhkh, Jain, Bauddh, Musalman sabhi ek hi culture ke follwer the . Tab tak thik tha. Baad me musslmanone hindusthani culture se hatkar Arab aur Turqi ka culture apanana shuru kiya. Mere village me maine musalnan mardrfonko dhoti aur turban aur women saree pahane huye families kafi dekhi hai lekin unki hi aaj ki generation arabi pahanawa me rahati hai. Dadiyo ke purane modern kapadome photoes hai ,lekin unhiki potiya burqe me rahati hai.
On humanitarian basis such cases on merit, should be permitted to vìsit Indian villages/towns etc. He should apply immediately, people lile me are there to help. Col Malik🇮🇳 Jai Hind.
Arvindbhai please find someone who migrate from Pakistan to India during partition and not happy with their decision. They all are happy. If they had not left Pakistan then by now they would have been forcibly converted or killed. I have a friend and his family is one of them. His grandparents said this was their one of the best decision they had made to move out from Pakistan.
Mere pita ji ne batayea ke punjab me sabh hindu muslim khushi se rehte the par kush gadaro ne mathre watan ke sath gaddari kar ke pakistan ki muhim chalai
I have really gone sentimental on seeing Rana Muhammad Sahib and listening his appeal..I wish he should apply for visa and Indian Govt will certainly grant him visa.I pray almighty for his long life.
please make a program on millions of hindus and Sikhs who left behind everything, including properties and land, who also been deprived of their belongings. most of old film actors, directors, all left behind everything. how they must have felt?
babaji aaj sab badal suka he na wo galiya rahi hogi na wo khet rahe hoge meri age 50 sal ki he me 28 sal pahle mere pas truck the me hi chalata tha or bharat ke bahot rajyo me jata tha lekin ab kuch sal pahle ghumne nikla to me na 1 bhi rasta pahchan paya na saher sab badal suka he jaha kache road hote the waha aaj 4 line ban suke he jaha kache makan maholle the waha bade bade apartment ban suke he ab to koi bujrur log sirf itna bata sakte he ke pahle kinsa mahola kaha tha aaj to apne hi saher me bhule pad jate he sab badal suka he
Jab itna pyar muhabbat tha, fir maarkaat kisne shuru ki, aaram se batwara kyo nahi huaa ? Kamini, kutti, jalim sarkare thi jinhone batwara to kara diya, likin loago ko hifazat se nahi bheja, ITNI MAARKAAT KYO HUI ???
In his younger days what he did and thought about India and Hindus? Does he denounce Ghazwa e Hind? Otherwise all of this expression has no meaning...there are millions of people who had to take refuge in India? Can they repeat this for Hindus?
Dr.Ishtaq sahib, I am senior citizen Kashmiri Pandit , living since 35 yrs. in Delhi, bcaz of exodus due to Terrorism. I can go to Kashmir as a Tourist BUT can't live AS I USED TO. Now, so many lollipops in the form of some examples & stories can definitely be given but TRUTH is what I have told to u. Now my observation is that as long as Muslims of Kashmir were confined to Nimaz & other rituals, Peace to greater extent was there. Ever since Muslim preachers from other part of the country visited them & extensively discussed kafir & in & around teachings, situation changed to the extent that even being FOUR % had to run away. Now my question to u is, can u openly discuss those verses of ur Book which often are held responsible for these sort of developments ? After all, reading from Relegious scriptures shouldn't be a problem.
Arvind sir i am a regular watcher of your videos but this video has shattered me because mere ghar main mujhe sikhaya gaya hai ki bacche aur bujurg inke mann main kabhi chhal kapat nahi hota toh main bhi govt of India se gujarish karungi ki inhe jarur visa de ki ye kisi guilt main na rahe but being a youth i am so confused about some nation ki ye apni foreign policy girgit se bhi tej badalte there were three tries from indian government according to my knowledge (atal,modi,most favourite nation)zero response from their side fir 4 wars terrorism toh hai hi,fir china ditched in 1962,then Maldives aur ab Bangladesh ye chaar aise nations hai jinka koi imaan dharam nahi hai apni hi kahi hui baat se aise palatte hai jaise kabhi kaha hi na ho fir woh islam toh beech main aata hi hai toh aap hi socho trust issues ke saath relationship nahi chalte toh desh ki foreign policy kaise chalegi woh ek aise neighbour ke saath jiska past dhoka dene se bhara hua hai chahe india ho America ho Afghanistan ho ya fir Palestine ho so thankyou bas itna hi poochhna tha.
We belong to village Jalalabad near river beas around 35 km from Amritsar and lost our close ones. We could not find the bodies, if anyone has any clue, will appreciate
हां बचपन की यादों को नहीं भूल सकते हैं वह बात अलग है कि आदमी अपना करियर बनाने में और काम काजो मैं व्यस्त होने के कारण चाहकर भी अपने गांव नहीं जा पता है जनसंख्या बढ़ने के कारण अब इंसानों में इतना प्रेम नहीं रहा पुरानी बातें सपनों जैसे लगती है जय हिंद जय भारत वंदे मातरम 🙏🙏
In sab k liye jinnah jimmedar h agr hm saath rhte to ye sb kyu hi dekhna pdta but unko to chull padi thi alg desh banane ki aur wo bhi sirf apni politics k liye congress last tak oppose krti rhi partition ko but last me usko bhi partition mananaa hi padaa
So sad and moving. Arvind bhaee this is the harsh reality. Like Rana Mohammed ji (GOD bless him), there are many others like him who had lost everything at the time of ‘dreaded’ partition, were left heartbroken and forced to leave their homes and become refugees on both sides. My great grandfather a world war -1 veteran, along with my grandfather and my father were natives of chak no 200 GB, in dist Lyallpur(now Faisalabad) where they lived peacefully until the tragic events of partition forced them to migrate . My father (92 years)who passed away couple of years back, would often narrate us incidents of his childhood memories and we grew up listening to their heartfelt stories, often becoming emotional and mourning the loss of their cherished homeland. Sad that my father couldn’t visit his native village and his wish remained unfulfilled
I was emotional throughout watching this video. I pray that Rana sahib and many others like him are given visas to visit their friends and I see their deeply rooted background. I am ashamed of all my friends from India who have commented here with so much hatred. I can only pray that God enlightens you ✝️🌹🙏
Why hatred ? So many uncountable terrorists attack, broke our country in name of religion by stupid theory they do bigotry at every point and now then this small neutral minority people of their community didn't spoke about their majority and became silent watchers .
I doubt your identity..A Hindu/ sikh punjabi cannot forget the trauma inflicted on his ancestors by these people... These sufferings are of their own making..
All nabi badmash got killed why? Don't follow them.😂
Surely this man who still carrys the love for his native place deserves to be able to visit. Rana Sahab should've been granted long ago but it's better not to talk about the hatred that was seeded by who we know, if there's any angst on this it's bit normal, specially for the people who were displaced, and this feeling cannot be felt by those whose ancestors didn't go through this pain.
To kill us ? We are kafir for them.... watch exmuslims sahil zafar heretic sameer Sachwala
Arvind, plz do a similar program on Kashmiri Hindus who lost their moorings, their homeland in 1990. And, ask Ishtiaq Ahmed to comment on it because he avoids commenting on Kashmiri Hindus. Two generations of Kashmiri Pandits have died in the last 35 yrs.
सही कहा
कुछ यूट्यूबर रहमदिल हिंन्दुओं की भावना से खेलने का मंच बनाकर बैठे हैं
Arre, usme views Kahan milega? Arvind himself seems to have an identity crisis. I think he secretly wants to be a Pakistani punjabi
Nostalgia is very painful, gentleman anguish is piercing my heart. Partition was biggest blunder, only person responsible was Jinnah, in his pigheaded approach to win the case on million of dead bodies. Still, he got nothing, achievement a big zero. @Arvind bhai, your programs are always very difficult to watch except with tears.
@medusaachla Our Gandhi- Nehru duo was equally responsible. Had their approach been logical, they would have encouraged all Muslims living in India to migrate to Papistan. Complete transfer of population - then Hindus would not have faced persecution in Bangladesh, Papistan n Afghanistan.
Hinduo ka iska koi drd nahi hai muslo ki gulami krta hai humai bhai chara nahi chia ab inki asliyat pata chl chuki hai humai Pakistan se koi relation nahi chia 🚩🚩
अरविंद बेटा इनको जन्नत में जाने का शौक है
आपको जन्नत के मार्ग में रोड़ा नहीं बनना चाहिए
Ha😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😮😮😅😮😮😮😮🎉😮🎉😮🎉😅🎉
यह एक दिल को छूने वाला अफसाना है। हम भी कश्मीर की यादों से छुटकारा नहीं पाते हैं। घर जहां जन्म लिया वह जनत से भी प्यारा होता हैं। राणा साहब ने मर्जी से घर को खैराबाद किया।हमे घर छोड़ने के लिए मजबूर किया गया। रहम!
When Ishtiaq was in Delhi- Gurgaon, I offered to set up a meeting with displaced Kashmiri Pandits at Delhi/ Gurgaon as per his convenience. He never responded.
Hypocrisy,they are alike unlike hin dus,
Accha
This is the reality.
This partition was not asked by Hindus. it was asked by Muslims, so they have to pay the price for the nation they created for themselves.
Wrong, partition was asked by Muslim League…. Not by all the muslims……. The common man was deceived by false narrative….
So very right you are. Don't ever give them visas ever.
We didn't ask i mean our ancestors we are also from same haryana.
Muslim league explaoited indian Muslims please stop this now we are paying price already here
कहाँ है आतंकवाद? यूनाइटेड नेशन का फ़िलहाल आतंकवाद की परिभाषा
यूनाइटेड नेशन और ईसाई मुसलमानों का दोहन कर रहे हैं। जब तक मुसलमान गैर मुसलमान को लूटता है, या कत्ल करता या उनकी नारियों का बलात्कार करता है, वह कार्य जिहाद होता है। जब तक मुसलमान काश्मीर या इजराइल मांगता है। वह जिहाद होता है। जब तक मुसलमान भारतीय सैनिकों पर हमला करता है, वह जिहाद होता है लेकिन ज्यों ही ईसाई मारा जाता है, पेंटागन व लंदन की रेल व बसौ पर हमला होता है और मुसलमान अमेरिका व इंग्लैंड मांगता है, वही कार्य आतंकवाद हो जाता है। काश्मीर व गाजा पट्टी पर समझौता कराने के लिए ईसाई सदैव तत्पर रहते हैं। अल्लाह ने मुसलमानों को विश्व की सारी धरती सौंप रखी है, फिर वे अमेरिका व ब्रिटेन मुसलमानों को क्यों नहीं सौंप देते?
100 million percent true
मनुष्य इतने घृणित हैं कि इच्छा नहीं होती है इनसे सहानुभूति रखने की। पाकिस्तान के कारण पिछले पचहत्तर वर्ष से हमलोगों ने इतना झेला है कि अब दर्द नहीं होता।
Pakistanis are the most tolerant people in the world.
Usually I hear Hindu baniya, Hindu Kaffir, Ghazwa-e-hind, lal qile par jhanda phrases on Pakistani discussions. These are all phrases of love and tolerance.
Also see how Pakistanis have treated Hindus, bengalis, Shias, Balochs, Pashtuns, Sikhs, Parsis, Jews, Christians, Ahmadis, and now Afghans. No one will call Pakistanis intolerant.
Everyone in the world should appreciate this.
Manoj ji, your opinion is justified for the mullas and paki military backed so called TV anchors. We cannot declare 250 million Pakistanis anti India 🇮🇳.
Like we have anti muslim extremists in India 🇮🇳 ,Pakistan has anti Hindu groups too. More broadly speaking it’s not India 🇮🇳 or Pakistan, extremism and racists exist all over the world in all countries.
Extremists and hate mongers not only exist in India 🇮🇳 or Pakistan but all over the world in different countries. Humans at large believe in coexistence, it’s law of nature.
Not only that. See how their love pours out for India. Woh to India tha jo chhal se unko Pakistan bana ke dhakel diya
Delusion haa no cure same as pigeon closes eyes to evade coming danger.😅
HAHA R U COMEDY ME HAHAHA THEN WHO WAS ATTACK IN MUMBAI TAJ HOTLE INDIAN PARLIAMENT GUJRAT TEMPLE BOMB BLAST
Pakistan se itna pyar hai to Newzealand main kya kar rahe ho jao na pakistan
bilkul sahi
@@Karangaming-ty He is earning youtube income by views
Tmhri nafrat ni khtm ho gi 😢 grow up
Bhai newzealand me jihad jo karna hai ..
Monkey business pays money and liberal tag both.
Now Hindus haters are trying to blackmail Indian govt emotionally.
These people are nauntankibaaj, not trustable.
अरविंद जी ऐसा ही इंटरव्यू भारत में बसे निर्वासित पाकिस्तान से और काश्मीर से आये लोगो का भी लिजीऐ ताकी पाकिस्तान और काश्मीर के जेहादी ओ के झुठी , गलतफहमी ओ की जानकारी मीले,,
Sorry ji unka Pakistani Lahori aur Muslim hona Lazmi hai.
Lahori Churan waha ka sabse behtar hai.
O Kaka, Hume kya lena dena, kisi bi Pakistani bujurg se. Wo kya kahta hai. Hum logo ko maf karo bhai..Agar koi dislike ka button hota to main use click ker deta.
He still remember his child hood days. Do you know why??? Because he never had simillar happiness in his life again. This is called karam bhoog.
Emotional blackmailing 77 saal se chalte arah hai Arvind ji. now we are more aware of this & tired of it. No more same nara "we are same people of this land" & " Hindi chini bhai bhai"😂.
Bakaiti hain aur kuch nahin
I have seen the same pain' in the eyes of my parents and grandparents who came from Jhang to Delhi.
This is Mr. Arvind Saharan’s way of emotional blackmail. Much as I empathise with Rana sahib but issues are caused by the Pakistani establishment. The appeal should be made to the Pakistani government and establishment to mend their ways.
Five six more years ..this emotional touch will end permanently ..
Than pakistan and India will have no relation at all .
Both will happily ever after ..
अरविंद जी कभी हिंदुस्तानियों का इस तरह का इंटरव्यू नहीं करेंगे क्योंकि आपको देख मुस्लिम में और ज्यादा से ज्यादा मुसलमानों का यह सपोर्ट करते हैं आपके मन में कितना भाईचारा है यह इन चीजों से पता पड़ता है आप जो छुपा हुआ है झंडा चला रहे हो अच्छा नहीं
Arvind is peace loving human-being ❤
Muslims live in peace when they are ruled by foreigners or other religionists. Heard Hindu Muslims Sikhs used to live in peace during Maharaja Ranjitsingh rule!
Namashkar, really it had been very emotions loaded episode. Made us to think "what a blunder we committed. We had sympathy with Rana sahib to get visa n re-live his younger days here in Hariana, Punjab
Friends we would really appreciate if you could please like, comment and share this program.🙏🙏
Good morning Arvind ji 🙏
Jub Hindu Muslim main itna pyar tha phir Bharat mata ka Partisonkyo hua
Arvind Paaji 🙏, Mai Hoshiarpur se too nhi par hamare enn Buzurg Taya ji ke liye Hariana ja sakta hu aur VC pe inko Inka school aur kasba dikha sakta hu agar aap co-ordinate krre 🙏
@@ArvindSaharan Why do you feel sorry? They wanted Pakistan, so now they got it.
What is the problem, jinnah and his muslims killed loads of non muslims in the partition. Why do you feel sorry for these ppl.
You want this to happen to the next generation, too,wake up ppl, how many ppl did this guys family kill?and rape? That's a question
@@sukhjindersingh4446brother please email me - arvind.saharan084@gmail.com
sTOP TOXIC MADRASA EDUCATION FOR PEACE AND HARMONAY
टू नेशन थेरी वालो ने जघन्य पाप किया
इनकी बद दुआ लग रही है उनको
It is irreversible. Nothing can be done.Boodiest partition in history of mankind which killed millioins of innocent people. People who instigated this tragedy are still in India and are after another partition When this rock n roll stop?
We are afflicted with a terrible cancer which is threatening to swallow the whole subcontinent. May God help all of us.
My father used to live with his maternal grandparents in village Nangal Issar, about two or three miles from Hariana.He did his matriculation from a school in Hariana in 1930.
Our own village is about 5 miles from Hariyana,near Bhunga.
I have great memories of spending summer holidays in our village.
There were thousands of desi mango and Jamun trees in that area.Most of these have now been cut down unfortunately, and replaced with Poplar and Eucalyptus trees.
What is the point of all this, Arvind? One cannot go back to the past. Pakistan has turned out to be an evil state as far as Indians are concerned. Pakistani army just cannot accept a peaceful co-existence with India because they have to then dismantle all their enterprises/establishments/postures/edifices. That will never ever happen. So all this talk is a waste of time other than triggering some emotions. Please be realistic.
Is this an old video🤔
बहुत अच्छा लगा कि ऐसा भी एक स्कूल था जहां पर पढ़ाया जाता
सरबत दा भला
ईश्वर एक है
परंतु अल्लाह के सिवा कोई और पूजने लायक नहीं है
अब तुम्हें नहीं तुम्हारी पीढियां को भी रोना पड़ेगा तुम लोग तो हमारी नफरत के भी लायक नहीं हो
😂😂😂😂😂
Indian govt should give Visa, No matter what situation between two countries, such humanitarian request must be addressed
Excellent memory , perhaps last chance for people like us to hear survivors of 1947.
Thank you
There is a need for Reforms in different religions especially Islam.
That's simply not possible. Reforms in all other religionss are possible but not in this religion
Empathize with him and his emotions. Wish him best of health and hope he has good time with the help of his good memories. Impractical wishes will only hurt him. The two nations have moved apart and the generations have changed, many cannot relate to such emotions. Given the mistrust between the two nations, scope for good relations is nowhere in sight.
अरविंद जी,
आज जो इंटरव्यू राणा मोहम्मद अजहर जी का आपके चैनल पर देखने का मौका मिला असल में यह अजहर जी ही क्यों आज जो पाकिस्तान में हिन्दुस्तान में करोड़ों लोग हैं इसी हिंदुस्तान के हैं। हिंदुस्तान में रहने वाले भी सभी उनके जैसे हैं। आज की स्थिति क्यों हुई, यह तो जो उस समय लोग थे उन्हें विचार करने की जरूरत है।
आज भी कुछ भी संभव है अगर दोनों और के लोग चाहे तो.... ओरिजनली तो सब एक थे एक हैं यह एक मजहब हमारे बीच ऐसा आया जिसने हमें बांट दिया हमें ही नहीं, हमारी धरती को भी बांट दिया, अपनों को भी बांट दिया, और जहां हम दुनिया में आज हो सकते हैं, हम जो ओरिजनली थे वह अगर हम हो जाय तो इस दुनिया में हमारे सामने किसी की भी खड़े होने की हिम्मत नहीं हो सकती। हम अपनी सारी ताकत आपस में ही लड़कर बर्बाद कर रहे हैं, क्यों लड़ रहे हैं यह तो हमें ही सोचना पड़ेगा कोई दूसरा हमारे बारे में सोचने वाला नहीं आएगा।
Love you, agree with you, lot of respect for you
सहारन साहब, राणा साहब तो अपने 'खेत' देखना चाहते हैं लेकिन ये पाकिस्तान में रह गये 'हिन्दुओं' को दिखा सकते हैं हम हिन्दुओं को!!?? सहारन साहब जी
करम का लेख मिटे न रे भाई
Pakistan ka Matlab kya LA ilah il Allah, Hindustan ka Matlab kya jai shri Ram
I have just seen the early 15 minutes of the episode and already emotional! I am myself from Haryana and my family moved from Lahore to Uccha Pind in Punjab and then finally to Haryana. Very few 90+ souls left now who have living memories before partition left and can make such passionate pitch on their living & Religion bias free life.
I love ❤️ my mother land India
बहुत सुंदर वीडियो, राणा जी को कम से कम एक बार मौका मिलना चाहिए।
True
Last desire of this senior citizen should be filled without any further delay. Dr.Satpal Singh, Rohtak Haryana
Aaj yaad aya 😂😂😂
Indian Punjabi logon ka Pakistani Nostalgia ka dush parinaam Bharat ko itne saal bhugatna pada.
Ab Pakistani Senior Citizen ko kyun footage dilate ho ?
पाकिस्तानी बुजुर्ग की अपील बड़ी हृदय छूने वाली है। इसे स्वीकार किया जाए क्योंकि मैं भी अपने जन्म स्थान तौंसा शरीफ को नहीं भूल सका। वाकई हम बचपन भूल भी नहीं सकते।
Similar old persons created Pakistan, when younger.!!check present youth ideology in Pakistan..!! Remember Tariq fateh.. Hanskar lia Pakistan, larrkar lenge Hindustan... These peoples responsibility can't be ignored for creating present pakistani ideology.
This episode truly moved me to tears.
I believe that 45 minutes was far too brief for such meaningful conversations. Rana Saheb deserved more time to share his insights without frequent interruptions.
It’s inspiring to witness a 90-year-old in such remarkable health, with a clear voice and sharp memory.
I urge you to consider another episode with him, and please inquire about his secrets to maintaining such excellent health, voice, and memory.
Additionally, having Prof. Istiaq Ahmed in this episode added a fascinating dimension to the discussion.
और और-और और भारतीय हिन्दुओ ने पार्टीशन मे दस लाख लोगे की कुर्बानी के बाद भी यहाँ रह गए लोगो को अपनाकर आज भुगत रहे हैं
बचपन कभी भुला नहीं जाता
पर आप लोगो को तो इस्लाम का नशा चढा था ना कि इस्लामी देश चाहिये. आप कि सोच भी वही थी इसलिये तो वहा चले गये. नही तो यहा रहते जैसे और मुस्लिम रहे यहा. आपने पाकिस्तान मुस्लिम देश बनाया इसलिये वहा के हिंदू लोगो को मजबुरी मे वहा से हिंदुस्थान आना पडा. आपको तो ऐसा कुछ नही था. अब रोके क्या फायदा.
आम पाकिस्तानी लोगों ने अलग देश नहीं मांगा था,अधिकतर मुस्लिम जमीदारों,नेताओं ने मिलकर पाकिस्तान माँगा था,मोहम्मद अली जिनांह ने प्रधानमंत्री भारत के पहले प्रधानमंत्री बनना चाहते थे,लेकिन जनसंख्या के कारण वे हार गये ।तब उन्हें पाकिस्तान की माँग की।95 प्रतिशत मुस्लिम आबादी तो धर्म परिवर्तन के कारण ही हिंदू से मुस्लिम बनी थी,उसके भी कई कारण थे,उन कारणों को हिंदू और मुसलमान दोनों ही जानते थे,इसीलिये दोनों के बीच उस समय इतना प्रेम और भाईचारा था ।
I have heard like all this from my father who was a renowned teacher in East Pakistan before partition ie in the period of 1935 - 1960.
As a Indian I humbly request our govt ro do sympathy to Rana Sahab who is 90 years old man .
kindly Indian government issue viza for this older man as human level thanks 🙏
Big garet bharat 🇮🇳🕉️🚩🐅💪🙏😅
I also request indian government to help Rana Sahib
Modi had done for friend ship with Pakistan.but pakistan army had destroyed modi effort by attacking on.pathan kot.
Jinnah ko vote bhi muslmaano ne diye Direct actionm day bhi kiya Hindu to Kashmir me bhi nahi ja pata bas paise lautaane jata hai
ये अरविन्द कितना भारत हितेषी है ये नहीं कहा जा सकता। पैसा कमाने के लिए ये दिखावा भी अच्छा कर लेता है
Any particular reason why people in POJK dont speak and write Kashmiri, dogri or any local language? What happened to the Buddhists, Hindus, Sikhs, Parsis in Pakistan and Bangladesh? What happened to the Temples, Sharda scriptures, Valmiki community?The people who are cut off from their roots are now crying because of economic and governance failure. Time to reflect on your own Ideology and failures. So please leave India alone.
Arvind saharan you must live in Pakistan congratulations
It is only Pakistan and jineh who is responsible for all genocide of both hindus and muslims in 47 i am a kashmiri hindu we have also left our birth place in 90. We feel pain like you. What to do now. It all happened due to the bad policy of Pakistan since the period of general ziaulhaq.
Babaji kahate the sab ikathha rahate the, sahi hai . Magar Hindu, Sikhkh, Jain, Bauddh, Musalman sabhi ek hi culture ke follwer the . Tab tak thik tha. Baad me musslmanone hindusthani culture se hatkar Arab aur Turqi ka culture apanana shuru kiya. Mere village me maine musalnan mardrfonko dhoti aur turban aur women saree pahane huye families kafi dekhi hai lekin unki hi aaj ki generation arabi pahanawa me rahati hai. Dadiyo ke purane modern kapadome photoes hai ,lekin unhiki potiya burqe me rahati hai.
Muslman desh bhegt hoty to aaj pak bengla desh nhe hoty
ਇਹ ਦਰਦ ਦੇਖ ਬਜ਼ੁਰਗਾਂ ਦਾ ਮਨ ਬਹੁਤ ਦੁਖੀ ਹੋ ਗਿਆ। ਮੈਂ ਦੁਨੀਆਂ ਦੇ ਲੋਕਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਬੇਨਤੀ ਕਰਦਾ ਹਾਂ ਕਿ ਨਫ਼ਰਤਾਂ ਛੱਡ ਕੇ ਇਕ ਦੂਜੇ ਨੂੰ ਪਿਆਰ ਦੀਆਂ ਜੱਫੀਆਂ ਪਾਈਏ।🙏❤️🌷
*थोड़ा और रुक जाओ। भारत भी पाकिस्तान होगा। कोंग्रेस को वोट दे।*
On humanitarian basis such cases on merit, should be permitted to vìsit Indian villages/towns etc. He should apply immediately, people lile me are there to help. Col Malik🇮🇳 Jai Hind.
Arvindbhai please find someone who migrate from Pakistan to India during partition and not happy with their decision. They all are happy. If they had not left Pakistan then by now they would have been forcibly converted or killed. I have a friend and his family is one of them. His grandparents said this was their one of the best decision they had made to move out from Pakistan.
Very Nice veer je khus raho Whaguru je alha tala thodi tamana pori kare
Arvind, why don't you make a video on Kashmiri Pandits? Invite Dr. Ajay Chungru and do a show with Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed.
Aman ki Asha 2.0 in action.
Mere pita ji ne batayea ke punjab me sabh hindu muslim khushi se rehte the par kush gadaro ne mathre watan ke sath gaddari kar ke pakistan ki muhim chalai
I have really gone sentimental on seeing Rana Muhammad Sahib and listening his appeal..I wish he should apply for visa and Indian Govt will certainly grant him visa.I pray almighty for his long life.
Rana ji aap ke jajwat ki kader karta hun .kash aap jaisi souch har muslim ki hoti .
Best inspirational debate.
Mr. Arvind is a big fan of Pakistani people.
Very touching. Well done Arvind. Keep up the good work. Let us make this our mission to get visa for Rana Saha .
Victim card start kar diye.
Kitne hindu ko maar diye Pakistan ne.
Unka dukh batao
please make a program on millions of hindus and Sikhs who left behind everything, including properties and land, who also been deprived of their belongings. most of old film actors, directors, all left behind everything. how they must have felt?
If this person so emotional, in this day and age he can instead view it virtually, mainly due to his age.
Really heart touching appeal by born & brought up person who migrated to Pakistan . Wish his efforts are realised in his life.
प्लीज़ इनको हिन्दुस्तान के वीसा दे दो इनकी आत्मा हिन्दुस्तान में रह गई प्लीज़ इनको मोत हिन्दुस्तान आनी चाहिये
Arvin Beta ji thanks for repeating this video this video touched my heart remembering how that happened in my childhood I was 12 years old that time
babaji aaj sab badal suka he na wo galiya rahi hogi na wo khet rahe hoge meri age 50 sal ki he me 28 sal pahle mere pas truck the me hi chalata tha or bharat ke bahot rajyo me jata tha lekin ab kuch sal pahle ghumne nikla to me na 1 bhi rasta pahchan paya na saher sab badal suka he jaha kache road hote the waha aaj 4 line ban suke he jaha kache makan maholle the waha bade bade apartment ban suke he ab to koi bujrur log sirf itna bata sakte he ke pahle kinsa mahola kaha tha aaj to apne hi saher me bhule pad jate he sab badal suka he
Right
Jab itna pyar muhabbat tha, fir maarkaat kisne shuru ki, aaram se batwara kyo nahi huaa ? Kamini, kutti, jalim sarkare thi jinhone batwara to kara diya, likin loago ko hifazat se nahi bheja,
ITNI MAARKAAT KYO HUI ???
In his younger days what he did and thought about India and Hindus? Does he denounce Ghazwa e Hind? Otherwise all of this expression has no meaning...there are millions of people who had to take refuge in India? Can they repeat this for Hindus?
Arvind ji yah video dekhkar aankhon mein aansu a gai
Maybe he has been used by ISI to breach …..
Most dreaded enemy of Insaniyat is Jinnah.
Dr.Ishtaq sahib, I am senior citizen Kashmiri Pandit , living since 35 yrs. in Delhi, bcaz of exodus due to Terrorism. I can go to Kashmir as a Tourist BUT can't live AS I USED TO. Now, so many lollipops in the form of some examples & stories can definitely be given but TRUTH is what I have told to u. Now my observation is that as long as Muslims of Kashmir were confined to Nimaz & other rituals, Peace to greater extent was there. Ever since Muslim preachers from other part of the country visited them & extensively discussed kafir & in & around teachings, situation changed to the extent that even being FOUR % had to run away. Now my question to u is, can u openly discuss those verses of ur Book which often are held responsible for these sort of developments ? After all, reading from Relegious scriptures shouldn't be a problem.
shame ishtiak u will remian pakistani than human
Arvind sir i am a regular watcher of your videos but this video has shattered me because mere ghar main mujhe sikhaya gaya hai ki bacche aur bujurg inke mann main kabhi chhal kapat nahi hota toh main bhi govt of India se gujarish karungi ki inhe jarur visa de ki ye kisi guilt main na rahe but being a youth i am so confused about some nation ki ye apni foreign policy girgit se bhi tej badalte there were three tries from indian government according to my knowledge (atal,modi,most favourite nation)zero response from their side fir 4 wars terrorism toh hai hi,fir china ditched in 1962,then Maldives aur ab Bangladesh ye chaar aise nations hai jinka koi imaan dharam nahi hai apni hi kahi hui baat se aise palatte hai jaise kabhi kaha hi na ho fir woh islam toh beech main aata hi hai toh aap hi socho trust issues ke saath relationship nahi chalte toh desh ki foreign policy kaise chalegi woh ek aise neighbour ke saath jiska past dhoka dene se bhara hua hai chahe india ho America ho Afghanistan ho ya fir Palestine ho so thankyou bas itna hi poochhna tha.
बेहतरीन
Salute 🙏
Jinnah was the REAL culprit.
We belong to village Jalalabad near river beas around 35 km from Amritsar and lost our close ones. We could not find the bodies, if anyone has any clue, will appreciate
Very emotional moments
Doctor sahib, you should request Indian authorities for his visa
हां बचपन की यादों को नहीं भूल सकते हैं
वह बात अलग है कि आदमी अपना करियर बनाने में और काम काजो मैं व्यस्त होने के कारण चाहकर भी अपने गांव नहीं जा पता है
जनसंख्या बढ़ने के कारण अब इंसानों में इतना प्रेम नहीं रहा
पुरानी बातें सपनों जैसे लगती है
जय हिंद
जय भारत
वंदे मातरम
🙏🙏
Main Hindustan Se Hun Or Jo Bhi Hamarey Bhai Chacha Jo Bhi Pakistan Gaye Hain Ham Un Sabhi Ka Swagat Karna Chhahengey 😂😂😂😂
In sab k liye jinnah jimmedar h agr hm saath rhte to ye sb kyu hi dekhna pdta but unko to chull padi thi alg desh banane ki aur wo bhi sirf apni politics k liye congress last tak oppose krti rhi partition ko but last me usko bhi partition mananaa hi padaa
So sad and moving. Arvind bhaee this is the harsh reality. Like Rana Mohammed ji (GOD bless him), there are many others like him who had lost everything at the time of ‘dreaded’ partition, were left heartbroken and forced to leave their homes and become refugees on both sides. My great grandfather a world war -1 veteran, along with my grandfather and my father were natives of chak no 200 GB, in dist Lyallpur(now Faisalabad) where they lived peacefully until the tragic events of partition forced them to migrate . My father (92 years)who passed away couple of years back, would often narrate us incidents of his childhood memories and we grew up listening to their heartfelt stories, often becoming emotional and mourning the loss of their cherished homeland. Sad that my father couldn’t visit his native village and his wish remained unfulfilled
ये जज्बा जवानी में कहा जाता है
Love to this old man, one should learn from him the value of mother land God bless him.
A stream which moved me very much.Great.
Very immotion video. Love from Bharat.....
What you said is absolutely correct, but Four days ago, Masood Azhar also gave an immotional speech for Gazva .e ..**nd
Ek bhi comment kisi muslim ka nahi h. Sara pragrame kewal hindu hi dekhta h. Or comment krta h
जिन्ना से बोल