I don't know why many people said this is a bad debut song. Yes, the concept from Black Tinkerbell maybe different, but this is a good and catchy song. While this maybe is not the kind of masterpiece song, but the tune is the kind that stick into your head, and that's what a debut song is all about. Bottomline, this is a good song and also not a bad group
johnny santiago Yeah, I know. I also like this, but so many comments from K-netizen said that this song is not good, like it's so generic, standard, etc. because they compared this to their other single "Black Tinkerbell"
I remember back when these girls debuted there were so many bitter and racist kpop fans hating on them just because they were mixed. It's a shame they disbanded because literally everyone on this group was so talented and they had such great potential. I think they just debuted at the wrong time. I feel like if they had debuted now there would have been more of a chance of making it,
agree! this song is quiet addictive and even, i dont understand what this song about but it got feels. I just found out this group from disbanded group video.
TT ... at least, we know now we are in better times :,( ... Whyyy, SOMEBODY KNOWS WERE ARE THEM???? i hope they feel they were honestly amazing and don´t feel bad for this
This is one of those music videos where it's like screaming THIS PERSON IS OUR VISUAL. PAY ATTENTION TO HER. Like seriously they cut to Tia like 823945732895 times.
why are you complaining about tia showing too much jeeeez in every single group there is a member who stand out the most in miss A for example it`s all about suzy why no one is complaining and this song is good
sarra benyossef @Form of Therapy has a point though 😅 i think that for miss a's case, they dont have suzy get all the one-shots (sorry i dont know what its really called, but its the part where only 1 person is shown at face-level) in here, tia gets most of the one-shots, to the point that even if its not her part, she's the one shown (such as in 1:42, when it was julianne who was singing). if u watch the vid again, tia has a bunch of one-shots, followed by melanie, then none for the others 😫
@@melissacharbonneau1860 Im pretty sure tia was the only one who went solo Melanie is actually already married with a child but im not sure what the other 3 are doing but i know there active on Insta
1:262:14 Jaeyoon (Long Yellow Hair) 0:23 Minsoa (Long Red Hair) 0:121:211:353:27 Tia (Long Dark Brown Hair) 0:311:37 Melanie (Short Dark Brown Hair) 0:25 Julianne (Long Brown Hair)
They debut in 2011, and to be honest when i heard this song i just cant stop listening to it over and over again! But too bad they received so much racism hate due to their mix heritage... 😢 If only they debut today where kpop has been accepted worldwide, surely they will all succeed way more than anyone can imagined ❤️❤️❤️
It wasn’t even so much the fact that they were mixed. Moreso the fact that the company marketed the crap out of their “biracialness” and seemed to focus on that more than anything else, including music and talent. (They were very talented, but the company didn’t care to keep honing their talent as they grew up) but I agree, I bet if this was a recent debut they would’ve had much more success
Fuuuuck... they debuted at the wrong time. This kind of music/instrumental is now in style 😭 even that kinda sassy sing-chant thing in the chorus is trendy now UGHHH I'm so mad Chocolat should've been huge 😭
yeah, and sadly 2011 is practically the time when the big 3 became superior, we got, shinee and snsd AND FX from sm, wonder girls and miss A from jyp, 2ne1 ad big bang from yg, ChoColat didnt even get a chance to breath
Tia has the ideal Korean Beauty Standards. Shes really tall, slim, pale, big eyes, tall but small nose, small mouth, v shape jaw. Until today i wonder why she is not popular like YoonA, Hyun-A, Seolhyun, and Suzy.
I think, the company actually tried to hold Tia when the group disbanded. Btw, her Instagram and Twitter are the onliest still active ones from the whole group :P
Chocolat were one of my first K-pop groups back in 2011! Syndrome was ADDICTION! I really loved that song! Sadly, I haven't kept in touch with them as much later on but sometime around last year I started to re-discover them. And, I realized I have missed a rich ocean of talent! First, I started to check their non-title songs, their 1st Mini Album is A.R.T! EACH SONG OF THAT ALBUM IS AMAZING HOW COME IT DIDN'T GET ANY AWARDS OR RECOGNITION!???????? I seriously lost respect to the K-pop fandom cause everyone slept on that masterpiece. :/ Black Tinkerbell is another masterpiece. This song is so catchy and it has a deep message in it. The B-Side track ' All Night ' is a fun and catchy song as well. All what everyone could do is to make this release fail so hard to the point where they disband???? I can't anymore. I've read Melanie's story, I could see her being frustrated by the company's treatment & the group's failure, but what I want to say is that Chocolat was really and will always be one of a kind. Their music were quality and they deserved way more recognition. They only stayed from 2011-2013 but they released great music to dance crazily to or to cry to. There'll never be a bi-racial girl group who makes catchy music ever again. Especially not one who gotten close to our hearts like Chocolat.♡ Chocolat's disbandment will always be a tragedy in the history of K-pop lol.
So I just did a count. TOTAL NUMBER OF SOLO SHOTS FOR EACH MEMBER. Tia: 24 Short Brown hair: 11 Blonde: 4 Red hair: 1 Frizzy hair: 1 I like pretty much never got a good look at the frizzy and red hair girl.
After 9 years... I'm back. I was so crazy about this group when the first debuted. Couldn't wait for every new song and had their songs in my mp3 player lol
0:22 - Min Soa. She's the leader. She was just a vocalist, but now she's the lead vocalist. 0:33 - Melanie, Here she was the lead vocalist but Jaeyoon left the group, and now she's the main vocalist. Also she's the lead rapper and the lead dancer 1:39 - Juliane. She is just the vocalist. 2:22 - Jaeyoon. She was the main vocalist, but she left the group. 2:04 - And as you know, she's Tia. She's the Main Dancer, Vocalist and Main Rapper.
This came out around the time I got into kpop and I remember they used to constantly play it on Arirang TV. It was a bop when I was listening to it as a 14 yr old and it's still bumps 9 years later. For some reason girl groups from that Era made some timeless songs that aged like fine wine but were paid dust. I wish they debuted now it's unfair :(
it's super annoying that they show tia "singing" parts that aren't even hers. that's why they got so much hate back in the day, I'm not sure if they really disbanded but I really hope they comeback with a visual similar to black tinkerbell
+Barbara Ferreira the reason why they were hated so much "back in the day" was that, first, korean people reject mixed blood girls, and second, all mixed blood girls around the globe were jealous of them that they might become kpop stars.
+KpopNiDontStop they are not disbanded yet. its funny how people like you assume that. tia announced via sns that the girl lori or lora idr her name, but she was in black tinker bell mv, would be joining chocolat. so. just wait, before starting rumors. -_-
TheEvaristoCaitlin well that new member Lori already left the company along time ago... idk if u saw that... maybe you're right they arn't done but a lot of members are not not gonna be the same.
The blonde is Jaeyoon, who is currently on hiatus from the group due to medical issues. 0:19 (with red hair) is Soa, who's the leader 0:34 is Melanie 1:34 is Tia, the face of the group (if you can't tell by her obscene amount of close-ups in this video...) 1:39 is Julianne
This is so good !!! Their visuals, their vocals, the CHOREOGRAPHY, the song, the quality of the video and the filming ! Everything is so good. So how did I never know about this before ?? I am almost constantly searching for old kpop songs, why is it so hard to find them all at once...
they are the first group that open knetz eyes to not be racist, they path the way so anyone can become a kpop star.. too sad for them because at that time they got allot of hate bcs of racism..
I still love this song and this group... wish they had debuted from a big company. Whoever was in charge of their production really sucked cuz they lacked a specific concept and you can obviously see that all the spotlight went to Tia in all the close-up shots. The company could have done better.
In this music video they fuck up, but in music they were so great. For me all of their singles are gold (the songs of the albums are just fine) but they deserve more, the company having a lot of free publicity (INTERNET IN GENERAL!) they just promote them in their Korean fancafe... If they make a comeback in 2017 they would be really popular, Chocolat has something really different to show in comparation to other girls groups
Javi er I know :'( I also find it strange that they managed to get great songs but they failed to make it big time. Wish they had done more marketing on social media. And in terms of having all the spotlight on Tia, I said that because the company only had Tia modeling for cosmetics and had reporters write articles only on her as well. I just wish other members got more attention as well. Generally, I feel bad for the girls because I saw potential in them.
All of the girls has a different potential to be sucessfull in the korean industry. Juliane has the BODY; she do a lot of sport and you can check it on Dream Team (she win to all the girls and for seconds she almost win to the boys!) (+also can speak in English!). Soa has a good acting and has a beatiful korean face to be in TV (and also I imagine her singing OST's). Melanie has te best voice of ChoColat, it's the maknae and could be doing MC on tv programs or to be in shows (she knows english, so it is a big plus and has a sparkly? personality). And Tia, I think she has all and more; she is more than a pretty face she is a beautiful person and can be adaptable in everything (for me, she is the new HyunAh haha for that I hope she still could be in the industry, I see a lot of potential on her). (sorry for my english again, I hope you can understand
why are you complaining about tia showing too much jeeeez in every single group there is a member who stand out the most in miss A for example it`s all about suzy why no one is complaining and this song is good
Kommt richtig gut! 😃👍 Und meine absolute Favoritin hier ist Tia!! Man ist die hübsch! 😙💕 Deshalb finde ich es auch sehr gut, daß sie eindeutig im Mittelpunkt steht...! 😁
I can tell they really like Tina (or Tia, I forget how it’s spelled) because half of this video is her face. I get visuals, but I’m pretty sure the girl with red hair never got a close up. How rude.
Sad that Chocolat has disbanded, but all members are happy living lives. Tia has talked about her own debut, in February on her IG she made public that her contract ended and she did not plan to resign.
Well Melanie just had a baby girl with her husband so I don't think she'll be rushing back to music. Tia still makes music with Amber from F(x) on her YT channel
I am so confused, like, these girls would have killed it now and all but--even then this was SUCH a good song. I randomly had the hook stuck in my head 2 years ago and couldn't remember the name of the song or the group name and I've been searching for it until randomly I found them!!! I am literally so stoked but also I am a little sad because they're all so talented and its such a shame. Does anyone know if any of the members are still pursuing their dreams in the entertainment industry?
I used to hate this song when it first came out, but now coming back many, many years later I feel like I can appreciate what it is and the missed opportunities this group had.
Tia debuted at the wrong time... because Koreans had a negative look towards the biracials. Height 1.71, perfect voice, visual killer, meets all Korean standards... This girl was going to be more famous than Somi. .. if Somi and Tia were in the same group, everything would collapse...
They made me to be kpoper I never forget this group. Everyone after disbanding having a sweat live. Tia:Soloist Min soa:Have a cloth shop and model of own business Melanie:she got married and now have a baby Other member I Don't know working at a coffee restaurant as a waiter
I remember I fell in love with this group since their first time perform, very support them that time but unfortunately there's no news about them again so sad ㅠㅠ
![[MV] TINY-G(타이니지) _ Miss you(보고파)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9lhqOptKT0E/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm still here, 9 years later..
Melanie just welcomed a baby girl with her husband! Time flies
Was literally watching your videos just now 😂 yep, I too always come back here 😭
me too😻😻😻😻😻
Same ^^
@@versacegang42 melaniemarielee on ig i think
This debut was pretty iconic, even after 11 years, I come back and feel sad they disbanded so early.
@@stvrryun unfortunate
Agreed. Might’ve been a totally different outcome if they debuted in recent years
I don't know why many people said this is a bad debut song. Yes, the concept from Black Tinkerbell maybe different, but this is a good and catchy song. While this maybe is not the kind of masterpiece song, but the tune is the kind that stick into your head, and that's what a debut song is all about.
Bottomline, this is a good song and also not a bad group
Bad debut? For me it's one of the best kpop song ever xD
fiiliip18 Exactly!
+fiiliip18 exactly
This was my first kpop song that i heard and i love it since then
Bad debut? This is the best
johnny santiago Yeah, I know. I also like this, but so many comments from K-netizen said that this song is not good, like it's so generic, standard, etc. because they compared this to their other single "Black Tinkerbell"
이 노래 알면 kpop씹고인물임....
심지어 좋아했다면요???
@@peanutbutter9859 그럼 케이팝 고인돌
@@쮕쮕 😊😊😊
Agreeee
Si soy uwu desde los 11 años uwu
I remember back when these girls debuted there were so many bitter and racist kpop fans hating on them just because they were mixed. It's a shame they disbanded because literally everyone on this group was so talented and they had such great potential. I think they just debuted at the wrong time. I feel like if they had debuted now there would have been more of a chance of making it,
zynbw They actually give me hope. Three of the members are from german ancestry, like i'm.
fighting^^
zynbw น
that's what I thought :(
but do u know how they debuted? their parents are rich and friends to each other that's how they got to know each other and formed Chocolat...
im obsessed with this song but i never realised how young they were debuting at 14 only to basically disband 2 years later is crazy to me
Sad thing is that I feel they debuted at the wrong time. People would have loved them more if they debuted around this period. Oh well... 😢
agree! this song is quiet addictive and even, i dont understand what this song about but it got feels. I just found out this group from disbanded group video.
TT ... at least, we know now we are in better times :,( ... Whyyy, SOMEBODY KNOWS WERE ARE THEM???? i hope they feel they were honestly amazing and don´t feel bad for this
This is one of those music videos where it's like screaming THIS PERSON IS OUR VISUAL. PAY ATTENTION TO HER. Like seriously they cut to Tia like 823945732895 times.
Form of Therapy Well she was the visual and center so that makes sense..lol
lol Ikr
Ikr. That really annoyed me since I wanted to take a good look on other members but they kept cutting to her =_=
why are you complaining about tia showing too much jeeeez in every single group there is a member who stand out the most in miss A for example it`s all about suzy why no one is complaining and this song is good
sarra benyossef @Form of Therapy has a point though 😅 i think that for miss a's case, they dont have suzy get all the one-shots (sorry i dont know what its really called, but its the part where only 1 person is shown at face-level)
in here, tia gets most of the one-shots, to the point that even if its not her part, she's the one shown (such as in 1:42, when it was julianne who was singing). if u watch the vid again, tia has a bunch of one-shots, followed by melanie, then none for the others 😫
they didn't have ONE bad song. all of them were what you call a BOP - at least for me. seriously it's really unfortunate they disbanded :(
They disbanded? 😰😱😱
Justinne Acuña yes ;_;
do u know if they make solo or go to another group ?
melissa charbonneau no idea..
@@melissacharbonneau1860 Im pretty sure tia was the only one who went solo Melanie is actually already married with a child but im not sure what the other 3 are doing but i know there active on Insta
Chocolat had everything, they just debuted at the wrong time.
You’re right! They’re a great K-pop group!
1:26 2:14 Jaeyoon (Long Yellow Hair)
0:23 Minsoa (Long Red Hair)
0:12 1:21 1:35 3:27 Tia (Long Dark Brown Hair)
0:31 1:37 Melanie (Short Dark Brown Hair)
0:25 Julianne (Long Brown Hair)
Thank you. And lori?
Who’s the FOTG in ChoColat?
J + J =
They debut in 2011, and to be honest when i heard this song i just cant stop listening to it over and over again! But too bad they received so much racism hate due to their mix heritage... 😢 If only they debut today where kpop has been accepted worldwide, surely they will all succeed way more than anyone can imagined ❤️❤️❤️
It wasn’t even so much the fact that they were mixed. Moreso the fact that the company marketed the crap out of their “biracialness” and seemed to focus on that more than anything else, including music and talent. (They were very talented, but the company didn’t care to keep honing their talent as they grew up) but I agree, I bet if this was a recent debut they would’ve had much more success
But at that time. Not only knets who don't like them. International fans at that time also don't like them because a lot of them are mixed.
Still here in 2024
Fuuuuck... they debuted at the wrong time. This kind of music/instrumental is now in style 😭 even that kinda sassy sing-chant thing in the chorus is trendy now UGHHH I'm so mad Chocolat should've been huge 😭
They actually did it, just because of the wrong time. I hate it, i like them so much. Where r they right now? :(
Same
Yup. agreed. if they debut now. must have big fanbase already.
A lot of people like them back then too but they also got a lot of hate because of some members being half korean. (Idk why it was an issue back then)
yeah, and sadly 2011 is practically the time when the big 3 became superior, we got, shinee and snsd AND FX from sm, wonder girls and miss A from jyp, 2ne1 ad big bang from yg, ChoColat didnt even get a chance to breath
어렸을 때 이 뮤비 보면서 엄청 따라불렀던게 생각나요
이 걸그룹이 인간극장 에서도 출연하셨는데 우연히 아침에 보고난뒤 완전 팬이됬어요 ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ
정말 좋아하던 걸그룹이였는데 ㅠㅠ
2020.. still listening to their songs.. who else? Press like♥️
Edit :: & still, in 2021🌸🌸
& 2022♥️
& 2023🌸
& 2024♥️
me :(
Me girrrl
Me :(
meeeeeeee
Meeee
Tia has the ideal Korean Beauty Standards. Shes really tall, slim, pale, big eyes, tall but small nose, small mouth, v shape jaw. Until today i wonder why she is not popular like YoonA, Hyun-A, Seolhyun, and Suzy.
it's because she's not full Korean. Koreans love Koreans and Koreans are pretty racist so...
Candy Too Oh i see.
I think, the company actually tried to hold Tia when the group disbanded. Btw, her Instagram and Twitter are the onliest still active ones from the whole group :P
cika Tia_0315 is her Instagram :)
+Nini Blaxx ah i see! thank youuu ^-^ ♡
난 여전히 듣는다.. 2021년에 듣는 분들 계신가요..쇼콜라 못잊어..
Its 12 years ago and I remember this bop
Chocolat were one of my first K-pop groups back in 2011! Syndrome was ADDICTION! I really loved that song! Sadly, I haven't kept in touch with them as much later on but sometime around last year I started to re-discover them. And, I realized I have missed a rich ocean of talent! First, I started to check their non-title songs, their 1st Mini Album is A.R.T! EACH SONG OF THAT ALBUM IS AMAZING HOW COME IT DIDN'T GET ANY AWARDS OR RECOGNITION!???????? I seriously lost respect to the K-pop fandom cause everyone slept on that masterpiece. :/
Black Tinkerbell is another masterpiece. This song is so catchy and it has a deep message in it. The B-Side track ' All Night ' is a fun and catchy song as well. All what everyone could do is to make this release fail so hard to the point where they disband???? I can't anymore.
I've read Melanie's story, I could see her being frustrated by the company's treatment & the group's failure, but what I want to say is that Chocolat was really and will always be one of a kind. Their music were quality and they deserved way more recognition.
They only stayed from 2011-2013 but they released great music to dance crazily to or to cry to.
There'll never be a bi-racial girl group who makes catchy music ever again. Especially not one who gotten close to our hearts like Chocolat.♡
Chocolat's disbandment will always be a tragedy in the history of K-pop lol.
So I just did a count. TOTAL NUMBER OF SOLO SHOTS FOR EACH MEMBER.
Tia: 24
Short Brown hair: 11
Blonde: 4
Red hair: 1
Frizzy hair: 1
I like pretty much never got a good look at the frizzy and red hair girl.
ENOUGH
Don’t do queen tia like that
If you are here in 2024 , you are a legend
I can't believe they disbanded I actually really liked this group I think they had some good potently
+Movy1011 Where did you read that they disband?
+RagdollAlice23 onehallyu.com/topic/65969-a-concise-history-of-chocolat-kpops-first-and-only-multi-racial-girl-group/
and on Wiki it says 2011-2015
+Movy1011 Now CLC has 3 nations involved!
André Domingues Korean Thai and Chinese right?
+Movy1011 yup
this is so iconic
지금 들어도 숨은 명곡
Wah this dance is boppin
man they're SUCH detailed dancers, with challenging choreo too
이 노래 진짜 오랜만이네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
After 9 years... I'm back. I was so crazy about this group when the first debuted. Couldn't wait for every new song and had their songs in my mp3 player lol
I remember some of the fans were unhappy that Tia was getting too much screentime lol
same!!! take me back
Hereeee in 2022
2022 here!! I remember that time... I was also crazy about this group
this deserves billions of views, come on people, share it
Aren’t ChoColat at that time was Nugu?
0:22 - Min Soa. She's the leader. She was just a vocalist, but now she's the lead vocalist.
0:33 - Melanie, Here she was the lead vocalist but Jaeyoon left the group, and now she's the main vocalist. Also she's the lead rapper and the lead dancer
1:39 - Juliane. She is just the vocalist.
2:22 - Jaeyoon. She was the main vocalist, but she left the group.
2:04 - And as you know, she's Tia. She's the Main Dancer, Vocalist and Main Rapper.
2018?
OMG blacky is called my cat
Blacky
there is something very funny about this :v I do not know English and everything you read I do it by google translator :v
YEAAH
Me, after i saw a video of half-raced kpop stars
Yeah I'm still listen it
Maan this Kpop era TRULY WAS THE BEST! You can’t change my mind lol. I wanna rewind time 😩
this song is still living rent-free in my head. timeless jam that reminds me of my teen years /sadge
Hi this is me from 2022, i'm back here to rewatch a legendary MV of "Tia and friends - Syndrome" again
i’m crying hahahah
Lmao the editor was ridiculous for putting so much focus on Tia in this 💀
she would be it girl
June, 2023 🥰 still listen to ChoColat’ songs and really love them 🥰🥰🥰
지금 활동했으면 반응 왔을 그룹일지도 시대를 잘못 타고 났어
This came out around the time I got into kpop and I remember they used to constantly play it on Arirang TV. It was a bop when I was listening to it as a 14 yr old and it's still bumps 9 years later. For some reason girl groups from that Era made some timeless songs that aged like fine wine but were paid dust. I wish they debuted now it's unfair :(
it's super annoying that they show tia "singing" parts that aren't even hers. that's why they got so much hate back in the day, I'm not sure if they really disbanded but I really hope they comeback with a visual similar to black tinkerbell
+Barbara Ferreira the reason why they were hated so much "back in the day" was that, first, korean people reject mixed blood girls, and second, all mixed blood girls around the globe were jealous of them that they might become kpop stars.
馬君 racism all the way😔😔😔
this is how cruel the world we're living in.
When they debuted I remember they got hate for being mixed.
I really enjoyed this song when it came out, I used to watch that English teaching show the main singer was on.
I forgot how much I actually liked this song.. I also forgot how much this group should have been named Tia and the Girls lol.
Who is watching this video in 2017?
Rookie here
🤧✋🏻
me
I see this in 2018
Happy New Year :)
Tia ft. Melanie and the Chocolats
I totally agree. Tia is taking most of the attention of the audience. :( they should at least have the other members have more parts.
middle girl face
hahaha 😂
CHOCOLATS LMFAO
So many people discovering this group after they disbanded over a year ago...
+KpopNiDontStop they are not disbanded yet. its funny how people like you assume that.
tia announced via sns that the girl lori or lora idr her name, but she was in black tinker bell mv, would be joining chocolat. so. just wait, before starting rumors. -_-
TheEvaristoCaitlin well that new member Lori already left the company along time ago... idk if u saw that... maybe you're right they arn't done but a lot of members are not not gonna be the same.
I'm still listening to this song until now...you deserve to be more famous your song is amazing TT
The blonde is Jaeyoon, who is currently on hiatus from the group due to medical issues.
0:19 (with red hair) is Soa, who's the leader
0:34 is Melanie
1:34 is Tia, the face of the group (if you can't tell by her obscene amount of close-ups in this video...)
1:39 is Julianne
This song is great, they should be distributed on Apple Music and Spotify
ChoColat had spotify account
This is so good !!! Their visuals, their vocals, the CHOREOGRAPHY, the song, the quality of the video and the filming ! Everything is so good. So how did I never know about this before ?? I am almost constantly searching for old kpop songs, why is it so hard to find them all at once...
i remember learning this dance to perform at my middle school talent show LMFAOOOO I STILL KNOW IT... they were iconic
This group is full of vocals, dance and visuals
요즘으로 치면 대형 엔터에서 모을 수 있는 멤버들인데 소속사의 경영 능력이 부족했음
이중국적에 똑똑하고 이때 나이가 10대 중반..잠재력과 기량이 너무 아까운 그룹
another super talented and underrated kpop group, this is just perfection!
CHOCOLAT was too much ahead of their time. If they debuted today they would also be famous.
Of course, one more day must be a hit
somehow this has been stuck in my head for 9 years.
they are the first group that open knetz eyes to not be racist, they path the way so anyone can become a kpop star.. too sad for them because at that time they got allot of hate bcs of racism..
Who’s the black?
@WomensIconn there's 2 of wearing black dress. which one?
I still love this song and this group... wish they had debuted from a big company. Whoever was in charge of their production really sucked cuz they lacked a specific concept and you can obviously see that all the spotlight went to Tia in all the close-up shots. The company could have done better.
In this music video they fuck up, but in music they were so great. For me all of their singles are gold (the songs of the albums are just fine) but they deserve more, the company having a lot of free publicity (INTERNET IN GENERAL!) they just promote them in their Korean fancafe... If they make a comeback in 2017 they would be really popular, Chocolat has something really different to show in comparation to other girls groups
Javi er I know :'( I also find it strange that they managed to get great songs but they failed to make it big time. Wish they had done more marketing on social media. And in terms of having all the spotlight on Tia, I said that because the company only had Tia modeling for cosmetics and had reporters write articles only on her as well. I just wish other members got more attention as well. Generally, I feel bad for the girls because I saw potential in them.
All of the girls has a different potential to be sucessfull in the korean industry. Juliane has the BODY; she do a lot of sport and you can check it on Dream Team (she win to all the girls and for seconds she almost win to the boys!) (+also can speak in English!). Soa has a good acting and has a beatiful korean face to be in TV (and also I imagine her singing OST's). Melanie has te best voice of ChoColat, it's the maknae and could be doing MC on tv programs or to be in shows (she knows english, so it is a big plus and has a sparkly? personality). And Tia, I think she has all and more; she is more than a pretty face she is a beautiful person and can be adaptable in everything (for me, she is the new HyunAh haha for that I hope she still could be in the industry, I see a lot of potential on her). (sorry for my english again, I hope you can understand
This group was cool and the members were very interactive with fanw through social media.
I REALLY MISS THEM
same 😔
They shot Tia too much here, luckily they didnt do it again after this one
why are you complaining about tia showing too much jeeeez in every single group there is a member who stand out the most in miss A for example it`s all about suzy why no one is complaining and this song is good
Bitch Tia is everything the fuck
sarra benyossef but the others still get a fair amount of screen time, unlike in here
Maybe they like other members and want to see them too. After a while I wanted tia outta here
agree with you. the editor was not fair
THIS WAS MY JAM BACK THEN
Kommt richtig gut! 😃👍 Und meine absolute Favoritin hier ist Tia!! Man ist die hübsch! 😙💕
Deshalb finde ich es auch sehr gut, daß sie eindeutig im Mittelpunkt steht...! 😁
완전 띵곡이였는데..
I don't understand why there's so much hate? Am I the only one that's obsessed with this song?
Girls love to hate on girl groups, especially if theyre rookies, even more if they are a hot topic (biracial girls).
i can reply to people again.... HOLY FUCKING SHIT THE CURSE IS GONE FUCK YESSSSSSSSSSSS NOW I CAN TELL PEOPLE HOW FUCKING RETARDED THEY ARE
MonkeyAndGiraffe
o.O
***** I think they're really good.
***** Well, I am obsessed. :D
To copyright holder (ie. Paramount Music), please add this song to Spotify. Love this song and wish to share it to other listeners!
They were too ahead of their time..
2023 September
I accidentally found this made me back to that time! I love how this song sounds sooo Kpop❥
I can tell they really like Tina (or Tia, I forget how it’s spelled) because half of this video is her face. I get visuals, but I’m pretty sure the girl with red hair never got a close up. How rude.
The red haired girl is Min Soa ❤
Sad that Chocolat has disbanded, but all members are happy living lives. Tia has talked about her own debut, in February on her IG she made public that her contract ended and she did not plan to resign.
bop. I miss old kpop sometimes
I was so hapoy when i found out that 4/5 members were mixed(im half Korean) then they disbanded and my heart dropped.
3/5*
Prob got confused, when they were 6 ;)
+Linkatchu ?? there was never 6 lol
+diacy What the heck, I remoed that comment. But yes, they were 6, they had a former member Jaeyoon
+Linkatchu all together yeah (lori wasn't really a member) but line ups were only 4 or 5 members
Get this on spotify now!!
ChoColat already on spotify lmfao
Came back here after finding about KAACHI-
This makes me miss my girls. ❤
What happened to Kachi??
They had so much potential😢 i wish they at the big 3 company and they might end up different now..
i still stan these queens! I hope you guys come back 🥺💕
Now, can we replace KAACHI and bring CHOCOLAT back to the stage.
yes please
Yessss
Well Melanie just had a baby girl with her husband so I don't think she'll be rushing back to music. Tia still makes music with Amber from F(x) on her YT channel
Yass
LMFAO RIGHT
they were so ahead of their time 🥺❤️
I'm on the early 2010s horrible but catchy/guilty pleasure MVs binge-watching.
Haters gotta hate but I really love their group and this song! So to all haters, get lost and just shut up!
I am so confused, like, these girls would have killed it now and all but--even then this was SUCH a good song. I randomly had the hook stuck in my head 2 years ago and couldn't remember the name of the song or the group name and I've been searching for it until randomly I found them!!! I am literally so stoked but also I am a little sad because they're all so talented and its such a shame. Does anyone know if any of the members are still pursuing their dreams in the entertainment industry?
This song gives me such nostalgia. I remember my childhood listening to this beat and these voices.
The dancing in this video is pretty EPIC! Especially from ladies so young. Such clean, sharp movements and EXCELLENT hand work. Bravo!
This was the real kpop
Tia is such a wasted talent. The girl slayed
It’s 2021 and I’m still feelin’ this. I remember people would comment the most harshest and rudest things… such haters.
Tia is the prettiest Kpop idol in 2010s
Tia had alot of screen time in this video but i am still fighting for ChoColat even tho there are only 3 left :/
i think they should just change company, probably they already did tbh. I want them to comeback as a whole TT
Yes i agree :(
Which ones are left??
Min Soa, Juliane, Tia
How do you know ?
쇼콜라 진짜 괜찮았는데 별 이상한 토종아이돌 타령하는 늙은이 보수아재들 때문에 안 그래도 못 뜨던 게 완전히 가라앉아버렸지.., 노래도 괜찮고 실력도 나쁘지 않았는데. 지금까지도 활동했으면 어땠을까
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
지금 들어도 띵곡임 나왔을때 좋아서 엠피에 넣었는데 ㅋㅋ
저도 데뷔하고 멤버 하나하나 맥력있어서 너무 좋아했는데 그때 한참 혼혈 그룹으로 내세웠는데 엄청 욕먹있던게 기억나요ㅠㅠ 그때 애들 다 어렸는데..참..
ㄹㅇ 데뷔곡만 이상했지 그 이후 노래들 다 하나같이 너무 좋았음
하루만 더, I like it, 블랙팅커벨 모두 좆소노래치고 완성도 개 미쳤음
블랙팅커벨이 원조 다크몽환이다 이거시야,,
This song should be more recognized
I used to hate this song when it first came out, but now coming back many, many years later I feel like I can appreciate what it is and the missed opportunities this group had.
I love this song, it's so catchy and fun, also the choreo is really original with the arm moves
The short hair girl remind me of nanno the expression is so cool
Its melanie hahaha
I really like this group and this song and there other 3 songs. I could care less if other people dislike them or not.
Tia and melanie ran so somi. Nancy, lily, and bahiyyih could crawl
Tia debuted at the wrong time...
because Koreans had a negative look towards the biracials.
Height 1.71, perfect voice, visual killer, meets all Korean standards... This girl was going to be more famous than Somi.
..
if Somi and Tia were in the same group, everything would collapse...
Praise
You're right. Do you know Tia's Insta or Twitter?
@@ShrimplyReading thank you so much (:
race mixing wrong
@@fightfannerd2078 no one asked
They made me to be kpoper
I never forget this group.
Everyone after disbanding having a sweat live.
Tia:Soloist
Min soa:Have a cloth shop and model of own business
Melanie:she got married and now have a baby
Other member I Don't know working at a coffee restaurant as a waiter
jaeyoon is a theater singer and juliane is unknown what happened to her
Why hasn't anyone uploaded it to Spotify or Apple Music? 😢
They had Spotify lmao
LA CANCION NO ESTA EN SPOTIFY 😭
This song already in spotify
I remember I fell in love with this group since their first time perform, very support them that time but unfortunately there's no news about them again so sad ㅠㅠ
K-Pop's rhythm is so addictive, and I love that so much to the point I listen to one same song 1000 times a week.
this song & mv will always make me feel like I’m in a strange alternate world.