It always breaks my heart when a parent/loved one says their sorry for starting to cry. There is no need to say sorry when your loss affects you so deeply. Makes me want to just give them a hug and hold them tight.
Totally agree. Mr. And Mrs. Cardy, especially, are so stoic and strong. Mr. Cardy broke my heart when he said he got excited to go to identify his daughter's body, as he was going to _see_ his daughter again. Just heartbreaking.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Hmm, I like to think the guards would ‘accidentally’ leave a door open for other prisoners to get at people like Black. That paedophile can experience what it’s like to be tortured, brutalised and raped to a bloody pulp
I disagree on the death penalty for these evil pediphiles, i think they should be given life sentences and placed in general population in prisons with a special type of vindication installed by the inmates , then the pediphile can endure, and reflect on the exact suffering they inflicted on the victims, its eye for an eye.
There was an embargo on the crowns evidence being taken to the press. Then there was a press injunction on evidence of what he actually did being printed. Some of the things he did could only be read out to a judge. It was just beyond depravity.
@@leighirvine almost have to say is this reality and make you think that evil is running rampant in the last decade and feel that its at times a spiritual war. The only thing we can do is be responsible for our own actions and treat others with respect but when you hear stuff like this is mind boggling.
I have a hard time believing that monsters like this wait years in between murdering. I think we just don't know about the ones who were never found...
@@_slashes when or who decides is too soon? Out of sight, out of mind. One must remember that just because something isn't being reported on and/or shown to the public doesn't mean it's not being investigated.
When he was caught and that little girl was saved, she probably thought her daddy was the greatest police officer in the world. Thank God he was there.
This is so horrific. Jennifer’s mom just breaks my heart. Not only did she have to deal with her unfathomable pain. She talks about Jennifer’s brothers not understanding. It was an innocent time then. People didn’t know the evil out there. So so so sad
It was NOT an innocent time. Did you watch the video ? Robert Black was routinely sexualy abused by a member of staff when he was in Musselburgh. I wonder how many criminally run correctional homes like this one existed in Great Britain in those days.
I lost my son 6yr ago, and my heart has been broken in half since then. Knowing how painful this is, I just can't even begin to imagine the devastation these parents go through when their babies are taken in such a horrific manner. I wonder if my son was scared, or in pain but to know they were petrified and hurt so badly, I just can't comprehend. I'm pretty sure I would be in an institution
My Dad was 1 of the searchers for Jennifer Cardy. It was one of my earliest memories. We lived less than 5mins from her family home. I remember my Dad leaving to go on a search one evening & my wee toddler self, determined to go with her Dad to search too, was running along him! But obviously I couldn't go, nor could i keep up with him! My older sister came running behind me & took me back home. .
It's so, so sad, not only what happened to these children, and their families, but how children these days can't do things like I did as a child, like running around in the forest all the day, with no mobile phone, fishing in the rivers, making rafts, making tree-huts etc. Simply being free. I remember my mother called me "The child of the wild", when I came home for dinner in the afternoons, with red cheeks, after all I done in the forests with my friends. And nowadays when I see kids, they are all sitting with head bowed, staring down into phones, isolated at home in some artificial world... 😞
Jennifer's parents so sweet, smart, gentle, loving. After her, the demon took off the shoes of his prey. Mom said, "Jennifer had fire and strength in those wee legs." Little girl kicked the shit out of him! Good for her! Little spitfire Poor little girls, so heart breaking.😭
It is crazy how someone who grew up in a hard environment wouldn't take their adulthood to help others. Plenty of people I know who grew up with hard lives are the kindest, happiest people I know. This is just heartbreaking 😔
I have no kids, but every good person will feel for these parents and murdered children. One doesn’t have to be a parent to empathize with these parents.
I just lost my daughter to breast cancer she was 33yrs old with young girl's and I am broken inside my heart physically hurts and that is why I can't watch this one because they lost their daughter 💔 😔 🙏🙏🙏 I know that every person who has lost a child are not the same as they were before you lose a child is one of the hardest thing's I have ever done I will pray for your family and friends God Bless you 🙏❤
@@sanaibn8409 I am trying to but her husband is a selfish person who took all the money from the card's and went to California with a girl and the one thing my daughter wanted to do is go to Lake Tahoe and he took his girlfriend 2 week's after my daughter passed away I just want my grandchildren from PA to Florida and he couldn't even wait for 3 wks and left us with her funeral cost and it's so expensive and we are trying to pay it off yet he has no idea What he is doing to his girl's I want them here because he leaves them alone at night and the oldest one is only 13yrs old and 10yrs old I just want my daughter back. My oldest one told her dad that it should've been him not her mom and he just looked at her and now she's self harming herself and I don't know what to do anymore
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
The Pat Cardy's comment - smart and such a perfect way of putting it; “The crimes he committed, he committed against all of us, he murdered us”. I agree because he is added to the many reasons we need to worry and be on full alert in our homes and on the streets. No excuse for his crimes to be honest, we may not have been through his hell but we have our own stresses of life and not all of use went along destroying the world. He was already ill and it would have likely happened anyway, bad life or not. Some of us have been through worse and no one needed to die for it so Robert Black was too ill.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Thank goodness that man reported what he saw. He could have just told himself that he imagined it or that it was someone the girl knew or whatever. So many people just ignore instead of help or nowadays they film!
Agreed, but, in defence of filming, you can get a LOT of information that you would miss/forget/think unimportant or even unintentionally embellish. A dozen people can see the same thing, and tell totally different accounts.
There's actually a psychological term for this I learnt it when I studied criminal psychology! It's called the "bystander effect" im sure, it's horrific but there was a woman murdered and I think a total of 24 people saw this but didn't intervene or do anything coz they all thought someone else must have called the police 😬 the murderer actually left and came bloody back and finished her off, people vould have saved her but no one would! Its terrifying to know that! Her name was kitty genovese I'm sure so sad! I feel people are more aware now, esp with children, but we still just watch alot, id hope more people would intervene nowadays, but we are very selfish if we think we might be at risk. I still couldnt just watch that shit, id have to go help or at least call the police, very bizarre case-some humans are weird!
The amount of restraint that father had to not put hands on that monster when he found his daughter in that van… you’re right. It’s beyond me too. The rage I would have felt upon discovering that would have been unrestrained.
Hearing the ages of these young girls really makes me sick especially after hearing what happened to 8 year old Cherish Perrywinkle. Then when I listened to the medical examiner explain in graphic testimony what happened to her from the sexual assault really broke 💔 my heart. Hearing these ages just brought back what that medical examiner said and it's saddens me.
May I just say that Jennifer's parents are about the loveliest people I've ever seen. Such a tragedy for anyone, but especially for this beautiful couple. I feel calm just listening to them.
Jennifer’s mom explaining how she walked out the door just broke my heart 💔 These poor babies I don’t understand why evil like this is allowed to live in our world to harm our babies. How is it fair for a child to die or live forever with trauma and the person goes on with life
Have you not figured out yet that life isn't fair? Evil isn't *allowed* to exist, it just is. Laws and rules exist, but obviously there is no omnipotent being who insures things like this never happen. Reason I'm an atheist.
@@ashleysowers9904, I've actually had a pretty good life. I just understand that it's not fair. This man had awful things happen to him and it warped his persona. No one was able to stop it and his life went accordingly. No one was able to stop what he did until the man gardening paid attention and called it in. None of that was fair, but thank goodness the gardener was watching. That is all not fair, but it is how life works. Bless those poor little girls and curse this evil man but it's not as though anyone just *allowed* this to happen.
i don't understand these stories. i was a young child in the 80s. my mom, me and my sisters were very aware of stranger danger. we called them weird men. vans and strangers were scary to us. we could only walk to the store in groups. i couldn't imagine letting my sun go off by himself. rest in heaven babies☝🏾🙏🏾
We were the same. My oldest sister got taken by an old Jewish man, my Dad found them and kicked the shit out of him (they tell me, before I was born) and he got NO jail time but he was made miserable every time my father saw him.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
My aunt married a man like this. He abused all of her children. They divorced. And then she got back with him. Disgusting. After he died, they found videos and momentos that he stole from the kids after death. He lived in multiple states where kids went missing. He died in Florida and his name was Danny Gray. It was never publicly announced. families of those children may never know.
I still believe that this beast killed Genette Tate in 1978 in Devon. The way her bike was found and how very suddenly she disappeared fitted his MO exactly. The monster! May all his little victims have eternal peace. 🌹
It creates a really uneasy feeling seeing the smiling photos of the victims. It's disgusting trying to fathom how these children must have suffered. At his last would-be victim was rescued alive.
Jennifer’s parents are just he most amazing people, to be able to take anything positive away from such a horrific time in their lives is truly incredible ❤️ They’re so strong. I’m glad they finally got the closure they deserved ❤️🏴
Bless her, she was saved! That's millions to one chance. Thank God for the gardener and his quick actions. The mother and father here are so articulate, she explains their feelings so we'll, I can almost imagine how they felt. Has someone put this out before?
All of these horrific true crime cases have made me a bit paranoid about the world and remind me to NEVER trust anyone. These criminals look completely ordinary and commit the most disgusting and depraved crimes. I now carefully and attentively observe my surroundings and the people coming and going around me because you never know who might be out to hurt you or someone around you.
This is the most disturbing but maddening story. I could not have sat in front of this monster that did this to my child. I would have gladly spent life In prison for killing him.
I dont like violence am dead set against but God if I had gotten my hands on him Some pple would say its wrong but upsets me so much But also makes me just has angry How the police officer didn't beat him to death Maybe he's a better man than me
I am a surviving victim of Child abuse... I watch these series about serial killers and killers/ offenders of children to cope with the trauma... I pray for every victim and their families... I get help atm from a psychiatrist, but the trauma and PTSD will never end
I'll tell you how: SOCIETY ALLOWS IT. In a court of law, you're supposedly innocent until proven guilty. In sexual assault cases it always seems that the victim is guilty until proven innocent, and the proving can be next to impossible. Until the punishment fits the crime every single time, we stop letting these people out once caught, and we start paying closer attention to and believing victims by default (at least initially), this will continue as it always has. Not all, but certainly many of these monsters will think twice before destroying someone else's life if they KNOW they'll pay with their own.
My deepest condolences to the surviving family members for your losses. Anyone who commits violence against kids, especially sexual violence,should never see the light of day again. These criminals will never be rehabilitated and don't deserve an opportunity to leave prison early for "good behavior";their very crimes against children deems them a clear,present,and ongoing danger to society's most vulnerable population. To those who argue that pedos should be given parole opportunities,then open YOUR homes to these criminals and let them live with you and your kids... somehow I don't think many folks would actually endanger their own kids by housing a pedo. I truly hope the surviving families continue receiving mental health support services as they live with the devastation wrought by that vile sack of hot excrement.
Well said! Totally agree. My idea: Administrators that are making these decisions should be told that, if they free him, a home will be rented, FOR HIM, right next door to where THEY live. I think their decision would be hell no to freeing him!
They should bring back sessions like on “A Clockwork Orange” everyday for these monsters…then put em to death..bout the most humane way I can think of…
The worst part is these scum don't get put in main street prison they are kept in separate areas to protect them that's so bad no one protects the poor children these scum bags attract so stick them in with the main block lads save the tax payer a fortune.
I have such a hard time listening to these videos about children. I wish we would just put these beyond evil perverts to death right away. They will never get better.
@@littlewolf9049 why don't you find some. We're talking about rape and torture of little girls..the fact your morals are telling you to belittle someone over the keyboard especially when dealing with this topic.
I try not to watch programs like this and most the time I don’t because it weighs heavy on my heart and I don’t like to feel that way because it’s not good to the body and mind. I don’t like to hear detail Of how they were tortured because I start thinking of the pain they went through and how frightened they were and knowing they were crying out for their mother and dad. That’s horrible
@@SubliminalSociety so true. Ppl can say what they want about individuals behind bars, but I personally have always appreciated the way it’s just an unspoken agreement amongst those in prison, a rule of thumb per say, that inmates DO NOT tolerate ppl who hurt precious children. It’s the only thing I respect about criminals.
This is so heartbreaking to watch! I can't even imagine losing your young child in such a horrific way! I teared up when Susan's mom was describing how Susan was closing the door and her hair got in her face and she said "by now", I can just imagine in her cute Scottish accent which i find adorable even when adults speak. Also the part when she was being proud as Susan had fought that evil monster! I hope all the parents feel less pain in their heart! RIP little 😇 Jennifer, Susan, Caroline and Sarah!🙏
You don’t wanna watch programs that messes with your mood like tearing up because you caused negative chemical reaction in the brain and you will age faster and a negative way that’s why when they did a study on people that drink socially those individuals live longer because of the positive hormones that are released in the body. People that drink socially laugh a lot
@@samdoors5132 spare your psycho babble. It's healthy to experience all emotions, including sadness and anger. Avoiding them is cowardly and makes people unable to handle them when they arise unavoidably.
I was actually kind of confused. The Scottish mother is talking about Jennifer, and her hair, at least according to the visual narrative is being shown as very, very dark brown, not blonde, so something isn't matching up. Very sad, and disturbing, story though to be sure 🥺
This poor family. Oh my goodness it's heartbreaking when her Daddy said the officer had to hold him up when he saw her body...How on earth can anyone be so damn Evil ☠️ I just hate the thought of these people hurting children. 😢
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
I've never heard such an honest account as Andrew Cardy's....."...there was a certain amount of excitement about that, I was going to see my daughter again." Gosh, that's so heartbreakingly honest. My heart goes out to these families ❤️
That really caught my attention as well, it's hard to imagine what he was going through at that moment in time, it sounded strange to me at first but it makes sense when I try to imagine. A heart-breaking story.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
My dad was from Portobelllo and used to take me and my brother to the promenade, so i remember when Caroline Hogg went missing and my parents discussing with us what happened and why her picture was in shop fronts...etc. I must have been about 5yrs old myself. Her picture was etched in my brain and i remember seeing her face on the tv screen years later and upon listening to the news report it was discussing Black finally being charged with her murder. When i was about 8 or 9 a car stopped beside my friend and i and asked us if we knew the directions to a local country house. The country house was just a few streets away with easy directions. Yet, the man asked if we would mind jumping in the back of the car and showing him. My friend opened the door and was getting in when i told him to stop and that we won't be going with the man. The country house was an old derelict building with boarded over windows, hidden by trees, uncut grass and fields off the back. A place where all us kids would go play but no good reason for an adult to visit. I sometimes wonder what would have happened had we got in the car and if knowing about Caroline was part of the reason why i didn't trust the man.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
I can't believe that forensic psychologist would claim that the majority of pedophiles are immature & unable to have adults relationships. Like any crime the loners, or socially inept stick out & are more likely to get noticed & caught. The worst offenders are the ones who can blend in & be seen as good people, only to be monsters behind closed doors. The majority of survivors I've talked to had a married man molest them, or a family member/friend in a relationship with the abuser, mother's boyfriend, aunts husband, grandma's boyfriend etc, mother's best friend's partner etc. I find the claim that it's adults who aren't in relationships who are pedophiles to be inacurate & dangerous. Please don't let your guard down just because somone is in a romantic relationship, or is married.
I agree ……..the psychologist on this dock is not obviously up to snuff re pedophiles…….Pedos are smart enough to know how to groom, so I disagree with him.
In criminology, they will sometimes differentiate between child molesters (attracted to adults and children) and pedophiles (only attracted to children). I assume that is the distinction being made.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
@@Bootmahoy88 do you know, I actually agree with you. Sexual abuse as a child, kills many futures. And that's just for surviving. It is by far, the worst crime one can commit.
I'm 55 and I remember running wild and free when I was a kid not thinking that anybody would ever get a hold of us and now today I wouldn't consider my granddaughter's out of my site for not even 2 minutes
What an absolutely heart breaking situation to be in for the parents and these young children. Those poor children must’ve gone through hell. RIP beautiful angels x
Nobody can say "I understand" unless they have suffered that. My heart goes out to them. But, make no mistake they are no longer victims but incredibly brave survivors.
42.30 Amazing words. And there's truth in them. These people who hurt children should face a harsher fate than just prison. Harsh enough to act as a deterrent.
If they all ended up like Richard Huckle, it might! But then they should be kept in prison upon first offence for life instead of being paroled time after time. It's a sad statement when cops collect all of the evidence and deal with the bodies and some stupid judge and lawyer lets these creeps off with a slap on the wrist! It's a joke to think these monsters are ever "rehabilitated"!
“Do you want to see a box of kittens?” Evil...the person that said something similar to me used a guinea pig to get me to come in the house...they know it’s wrong and they still do it...I hope their families find peace 💜
This is maddening, tragic, and disgusting, all at the same time. And the poor parents and siblings of this monster's victims--how awful to live with the fact that your child or sister suffered so horrendously. I will never understand these sorts of people. As a young child, I suffered what I call "the abuse trifecta"--physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, both in foster homes and from my adoptive father. But it has never occurred to me to want to sexually abuse, let alone murder, children.
There’s always a danger when you let your under age kid go by themselves alone. Im thankful for shows like this learning that don’t leave your kids unattended in any situation. Sad for her family
It was different then. Kids could roam around free und unmolested in the countryside. I spent my whole childhood in the woods, never had a weird encounter with anyone. Prdophiles were unheard of.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Things like this haunt me on my best days! This is so heartbreaking and terrifying that little innocent babies and their families suffer like this. Anyone this evil needs tortured and castrated over and over again. I was so hesitant about even watching this because I knew it would be something of such sickening evil & I could never forget. R.I.H. 👼
A couple who lived next door to my grandparents (in fact, they were friends) had a damaged son who tried to kill his mother with a pair of scissors when he was 17. He was institutionalized at some point in the 50s. Eventually, he was released and he went to work as a gardener at a hotel. When a young girl was reported to be missing, he led the group that searched the hotel grounds. He became a suspect when he seemed to lead his search party directly to the girl's body. I have no idea what happened to him after this. I heard the story from my Dad. My curiosity is piqued, but....since my father has passed on, I cannot ask for details. He lived on Alexandra Parade in Glasgow. I believe his parents' names were Maisie and Jim. At first, I actually wondered if this was HIS story.
@@joli395 What is wrong you people?! What does animals have to do with this video of 4 innocent young girls being rapped and killed?! Are you OK!? So annoying, first post I read was about corrupted government with comments about stupid crypto and now you! Have some respect for lost life's and their family's! And btw I am an animal lover myslef but really?!
@@magdalenamezydlo6150 Stop being a bully agressively attacking my opinion. Animals are just like children innocenet nd dependent on us. If you can't see that you have aproblem! Calm down and learn to respect other points of view.
@@joli395 btw I have 3 babies name Rocky, Jax and Booger aka my dogs that I love lime my babies, besides my daughter! But how do you think the family would feel if they read 21 comments out 24 being about crypto and you comparing their children to animals. Trust me I get your point bcuz I love my 3 there are truly like my babies but not every one feels like that. And I just thing it's inappropriate to write comments on something that has noting to do with the video. But I do apologize if I come off aggressive! I guess the whole crypto conversation got me really upset and I also been abused as a child so it's a very sensitive subject to me when children get rapped and killed. I trie not to even watch this kind of videos much bcuz it take me to a dark place! Again, I'm sorry for the way I had reacted! Have a great day!
I couldn't imagine the pain of losing a child. I always say my son is the great love of my life. I say this because I obviously love my husband (his dad) but the second I held him and looked at him I felt a love I had never felt before, an unconditional, I would give my life for yours kind of love. When he was born I changed my life, I actually started to think about my decisions and stopped being impulsive because I didn't want anything to jeopardize me raising him. My husband was the same. We went from two idiots that partied all the time, got in trouble, no focus, no purpose, no strength, associated with shitty people ect. To when finding out I was pregnant, taking parenting classes, getting therapy, cutting bad influences, staying sober...to now over a decade later we both work solid jobs and provide our son with the love and stability we never got. I just couldn't imagine losing him.
Followed by the judges that hand out pathetic sentences , then the morons who successfully, or otherwise, campaign to have the perpetrators released early, only to commit the same crime that saw them jailed in the first place
The common denominator in cases like this is the person was never corrected from the get-go an investigation if the person themselves were molested and mistreated…. And the first time they are caught about a child is the last time they should be able to walk.. They should never be able to hurt another child never free to hurt another child
Why stop there? ALL “religious” CULTS. They’re all f’n twisted. Show me ANY religion and I’ll cite so many cases it’ll make your head spin. ALL OF THEM.
Sick story. This is made even more sick by the fact that the people of the UK lost their moral way and eliminated the death penalty. The only just penalty for murdering a child is death. The only just penalty for murdering multiple children is severe pain and suffering before death.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
This is for Mr Andy Clardy: I grieve for your loss by the cruel inhumane murder of your precious Jennifer. I just read an article about your regret at having bought your child a bicycle which in your opinion gave the beast Robert Black access to your daughter. Please sir do not see your glorious act of kindness and generosity to your beloved daughter in that light. You gave your daughter joy and pride that you trusted her to act responsibly with her new found freedom. That beast should not be allowed to rob that from you. When my parents finally scrapped enough together to buy all four of their daughters matching metallic turquoise and silver bicycles each of us were overjoyed. I remember riding my bike from our country farm home we rented to the nearby subdivision to find a friend to play with. I also remember riding to a grocery store about 5 miles away to buy pickling spices my mother needed for her many pickles and jams she canned each year. It was a joy I still remember. I’m sure when you see Jennifer again, she will tell you the joy you gave her sir. Hang on to this. God Bless
I suppose it means the child is dressed in a way the perpetrator finds attractive. Not that the child herself is dressed attractively. For example, if the perp has a thing for girls in hoodies, he would think that girls in hoodies are dressed attractively.
I watch true crime all the time and my mind just can not fathom the thought process of an adult wanting to do this or being attracted to babies. It’s sickening.
Those of us who are able must hunt these monsters and remove them from this world. Quietly and discreetly not with malice but with determination and purpose to save as many children as possible. There is only one way to obtain justice and that is it which I have described.
What does "attractively dressed" mean when talking about a 5 year old? I think that phrase is a bit twisted, there is no circumstance where you can use the word "attractive" when talking about an innocent young child.
A dog just for bit a person is immediately put to sleep, and these monsters never get the death penalty and they live happy in a prison eating well and doing nothing.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
God bless the precious joy being taken from these families by these terrible monsters that have been made through I don’t know what. I was terribly abused as a child myself, however I would never dream of harming another child, person or animal. I am a protector of those who don’t have a voice because I understand how it feels.
Any person doing these things to children or taking the life of anyone should receive the death penalty immediately and it should be in the same way they killed their victims
When my son got married he moved to Chisholm Place in Grangemouth Scotland and was actually living in the house Robert Black was brought up in. Now that was creepy 🏴
When Caroline Hogg went missing from Portobello, the police appealed to anyone who had been there that day (the beach & fairground) to hand in photos they'd taken so they could look for Caroline in the background. They didn't see the wee girl in any pics but there was a very high amount of known peadophiles there that day. That's only known peadophiles, there would have been many more not known by the police. That fact terrified me & has never left me all these years
Ok I feel genuinely sad for the hell he suffered as a child. My younger brother & oldest sister suffered unimaginable abuse. My younger bother was miraculously healed by Jesus Christ when he was a teenager so he grew up to be a wonderful father of 1 girl and 3 boys. Unfortunately my sister was damaged from the severe abuse & never got healed. But NOBODY SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO HARM CHILDREN FOR ANY REASON!!! NOBODY IS EXCUSED!!!! He should NEVER see the light of day EVER AGAIN!!!!
It's true that Jesus Christ is a wonderful healer, He (overnight) delivered me from suicidal thoughts, depression and demonic oppression and nightmares and has also miraculously healed me from illness! (As well as giving me salvation and eternal life!) I do wish that more people would turn to Him for help, it' s free, after all (though not free for Him as it cost Him His life).
I'm sorry but no one is truly healed from abuse. They may look like they have it together but they are probably crying by their self or after having a drink. It's all you think about. It consumes you.
These poor innocent children I can’t comprehend in my mind how anyone could commit these evil crimes on children these beautiful children had lives and a right to grow and become adults in safety their poor families it breaks my heart, rest in peace little ones my thoughts are with the families x
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
I grew up on a council estate in Keighley West Yorkshire we used to go shopping in Leeds, so it was familiar. I was 11 in 1986 everyone I went to school with lived in the same area. I remember us all being able to roam around our area & stay out before it got dark. We had tea at six o'clock every day so Look North/Calender was on TV. The Story about Sarah Harper was shown, she went to the corner shop to get a loaf of bread & disappeared. That's what we all did, you could buy cigarettes and alcohol for your parents back then but usually it was to buy gravy, milk or bread.. It was a safe thing to do & only 5 minutes walk but after the story aired everything changed . We couldn't go anywhere on our own so I had to walk to school with my sister & brother. When Sarah's body was found, that was it no more roaming around at all hours. We had curfews that were strictly enforced. If my curfew was 8pm and by 8.05pm if I hadn't come home, my dad came out looking for me he didn't have to go far because I was two minutes away from home trying hard to hide the fact that I smoked. That is also the first time we all found that not only did monsters who prayed on kids exist but they didn't look like monsters they looked like everybody else. It was also the first time we'd heard the word paedophile & what the word meant. It could have been anyone of us but it wasn't. Sarah Harper didn't die in vain, her murder made all of us aware that for the first time that evil walks amongst us hunting for their prey.. I have a photograph imprinted in my memory forever, it shows Sarah Harper sitting on the wall outside the corner shop. How does a parent or loved one get over the fact their child has been horrifically murdered by a monster no one knew existed. I can usually empathise & put myself in their shoes to know how they're feeling but unless you go through it yourself you'll never know know how they feel. Tbh I don't want to because no one should have to go through that. My heart goes out to all those parents & loved ones who've lost children in similar circumstances. We don't forget about them ever.
My mum has told me so many times about walking along the road on a main Dumfries road when she was 6 and seeing a white van driving up and down the road watching her in 1977, she’s always been convinced it was him and remembers his face but sadly unlike these girls there was always someone nearby to look out for her as she lived on a caravan park.
my mum was walking along and a white van stopped and got out and my mum started to run and the man took off and she is convinced it was him and i showed her a photo and she said it was him.
It grieves me to know that this Parasite was fed, housed and clothed daily, living out his life to the very end in prison, while these beautiful innocent angels never got a chance at life! 😡😿 I STILL feel that instead of giving these Parasites all of the above luxuries, subject them to the horrors with which they delt out to these innocent lives in every graphic detail. Then, justice is served. 😿
I’m sorry I’ve a 22yr old daughter and a 6 yr old son I would never allow them to walk alone in east end of Glasgow it stresses me out my daughter walks home from late night working without transportation it needs to be looked at
This is truly terrible 😢 We need to put them in prison and tell the inmates that their child rapists and murders and let them take care of the rest...my deepest apologies and love for all their families...
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
May God bless with strength and courage all the parents of the victims...This is so heartbreaking...💔 I don't think I would stay sane if I was in their shoes...
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Uhhhhhhhh he molested someone and his first punishement was ONLY 1 year.. What in the actual ****%€%&#* ive seen people get 20 plus years or even life in jail for way less. Ffs
I'm so sorry for the families who lost loved ones. But how was he able to take a 6 year old girl!!??? What were 6 year olds doing out walking alone? Where were the parents?? Who the hell let's a 6 year old out alone like that???!
@@oriana7026 I have a 8 year old I don't let him go out by himself I would be panicked and worried the whole time. We know sick evil people are out there so why the hell risk letting your young child out alone. Everyone thinks it won't happen to them but of course it does.
@@oriana7026 thank you I thought it might be me thinking wrong but I absolutely do not think a child of that age should be out unacompanied they should have an adult with them. Obviously I'm not saying I place blame on the parents I know this is horrific for them but this could have been prevented happening to their child if they didn't let he/she out alone at the age of 5/6
It always breaks my heart when a parent/loved one says their sorry for starting to cry. There is no need to say sorry when your loss affects you so deeply. Makes me want to just give them a hug and hold them tight.
So heart wrenching 💔💔💔they are so strong, God bless them all 💕💕💕🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Totally agree. Mr. And Mrs. Cardy, especially, are so stoic and strong. Mr. Cardy broke my heart when he said he got excited to go to identify his daughter's body, as he was going to _see_ his daughter again. Just heartbreaking.
This got to me too
Whenever someone cries and says sorry when I’m interviewing them, I always tell them not to be sorry and “take your time.” I can wait.
@@worldismyashtray what kind of people do you interview?
Appreciation to the man who called the police. He saved not 1 life but would be more other lives
Pat and Andy telling their story had me in tears. Rest in power to these angels.
I teared right up when Pat recounted that loving, exact memory of Jennifer's hair flipping as she slipped out the door.
Same. 💔😭
Nothing can change my mind on the stance that child rapists deserve the death penalty.
👍👍
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
💯👌👍🙌
Hmm, I like to think the guards would ‘accidentally’ leave a door open for other prisoners to get at people like Black. That paedophile can experience what it’s like to be tortured, brutalised and raped to a bloody pulp
I disagree on the death penalty for these evil pediphiles, i think they should be given life sentences and placed in general population in prisons with a special type of vindication installed by the inmates , then the pediphile can endure, and reflect on the exact suffering they inflicted on the victims, its eye for an eye.
How amazing are Jennifer’s parents? God bless them. Hearing them talk about their daughter and what happened absolutely broke my heart.
jennifers mothers appreciation for the local community helping in the search is so heartwarming
Sometimes it feels unreal that this type of evil can be done by a person. Just pure evil
Lenin?
Stalin?
Hitler?
Mao?
Pol Pot?
etc....
There was an embargo on the crowns evidence being taken to the press. Then there was a press injunction on evidence of what he actually did being printed. Some of the things he did could only be read out to a judge. It was just beyond depravity.
Evil is very real!!
Absolutely!! It’s hard to get your head around isn’t it!?
@@leighirvine almost have to say is this reality and make you think that evil is running rampant in the last decade and feel that its at times a spiritual war. The only thing we can do is be responsible for our own actions and treat others with respect but when you hear stuff like this is mind boggling.
I have a hard time believing that monsters like this wait years in between murdering. I think we just don't know about the ones who were never found...
if they kill too soon to another murder it highers the chance of getting caught, but good point
@@_slashes Huh?
@@_slashes when or who decides is too soon? Out of sight, out of mind. One must remember that just because something isn't being reported on and/or shown to the public doesn't mean it's not being investigated.
I agree and yeah they might but I think some do wait for fear they might get caught since getting caught will prevent them from doing it again.
Yeah but it doesn’t matter what you believe, where is your evidence?
As a father, this is one of the most heartbreaking docs I have ever seen...
When he was caught and that little girl was saved, she probably thought her daddy was the greatest police officer in the world. Thank God he was there.
She didn't think he was, she KNEW he was!
I'm sure it took a lot, for her dad, to restrain himself, that day.
Black should count himself lucky he wasn't killed right there on the spot by her father.
Even though she was sexually assaulted I’m so glad her father could be the one to save her. That somehow makes me feel like that helped her heal.
Yes and I dont know how he restraint himself from killing him
It's a cruel world so upsetting
This is so horrific. Jennifer’s mom just breaks my heart. Not only did she have to deal with her unfathomable pain. She talks about Jennifer’s brothers not understanding. It was an innocent time then. People didn’t know the evil out there. So so so sad
So sad in places where the crimes are not "common" to see in these innocent people.
It was NOT an innocent time. Did you watch the video ?
Robert Black was routinely sexualy abused by a member of staff when he was in Musselburgh.
I wonder how many criminally run correctional homes like this one existed in Great Britain in those days.
@@rontauranac I didn’t word it well. Yes there was horrible evil back then. The innocence I’m talking about is peoples awareness of it.
@@laurarominger2073 I agree with you.
👀what innocent time!!!OK I’LL WAIT
I lost my son 6yr ago, and my heart has been broken in half since then. Knowing how painful this is, I just can't even begin to imagine the devastation these parents go through when their babies are taken in such a horrific manner. I wonder if my son was scared, or in pain but to know they were petrified and hurt so badly, I just can't comprehend. I'm pretty sure I would be in an institution
Sorry for your loss, i cant even imagine what you go through.
Sending love your way.
why do you even watch this stuff then?
@@ColtTheWolf well said and so true
@@chrishandsome4267 Sometimes just to reassure ourselves that we can still feel anything at all!
@@willworkforyarn4893 I feel ya. I’m ready to just check out tbh
My Dad was 1 of the searchers for Jennifer Cardy. It was one of my earliest memories. We lived less than 5mins from her family home.
I remember my Dad leaving to go on a search one evening & my wee toddler self, determined to go with her Dad to search too, was running along him! But obviously I couldn't go, nor could i keep up with him! My older sister came running behind me & took me back home. .
Impressed the cops got to the vehicle in time in response to a phone call- first time I ever know of such a fast successful action- brilliant work!
It was more by luck, if Black hadn't driven back down the road, they would probably not got to the girl in time
It's so, so sad, not only what happened to these children, and their families, but how children these days can't do things like I did as a child, like running around in the forest all the day, with no mobile phone, fishing in the rivers, making rafts, making tree-huts etc. Simply being free. I remember my mother called me "The child of the wild", when I came home for dinner in the afternoons, with red cheeks, after all I done in the forests with my friends. And nowadays when I see kids, they are all sitting with head bowed, staring down into phones, isolated at home in some artificial world... 😞
This legit was the 80s
They still can live like that. We can't live in fear screw that
They can still do that stuff. Why live in fear? That's not living
Jennifer's parents so sweet, smart, gentle, loving. After her, the demon took off the shoes of his prey. Mom said, "Jennifer had fire and strength in those wee legs." Little girl kicked the shit out of him! Good for her! Little spitfire
Poor little girls, so heart breaking.😭
It is crazy how someone who grew up in a hard environment wouldn't take their adulthood to help others. Plenty of people I know who grew up with hard lives are the kindest, happiest people I know. This is just heartbreaking 😔
It's not usually how it works. Feels good, but not true. Abused tend to abuse. Sad all around
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles.
As a DV/SA survivor, I prefer to help others vs harm them. ❤️🌹🙏🌹❤️
@@Scorpio_Rose1980exactly. How adults don't comprehend to end the cycle is beyond me. But the US just reelected a pedo & felon. 😮😢
I'm not a family person and I don't have children, but the pain of this family is so tangable I feel for them.
I have no kids, but every good person will feel for these parents and murdered children. One doesn’t have to be a parent to empathize with these parents.
I just lost my daughter to breast cancer she was 33yrs old with young girl's and I am broken inside my heart physically hurts and that is why I can't watch this one because they lost their daughter 💔 😔 🙏🙏🙏 I know that every person who has lost a child are not the same as they were before you lose a child is one of the hardest thing's I have ever done I will pray for your family and friends God Bless you 🙏❤
I'm so sorry for your loss.. 🙏🕊🌹
Sorry about your daughter. Keep her memory alive with her kids.
Thoughts with you so very sad 💔😢
@@sanaibn8409 I am trying to but her husband is a selfish person who took all the money from the card's and went to California with a girl and the one thing my daughter wanted to do is go to Lake Tahoe and he took his girlfriend 2 week's after my daughter passed away I just want my grandchildren from PA to Florida and he couldn't even wait for 3 wks and left us with her funeral cost and it's so expensive and we are trying to pay it off yet he has no idea What he is doing to his girl's I want them here because he leaves them alone at night and the oldest one is only 13yrs old and 10yrs old I just want my daughter back. My oldest one told her dad that it should've been him not her mom and he just looked at her and now she's self harming herself and I don't know what to do anymore
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
most astonishing rescue+apprehension I've ever heard tell of. Very, VERY well done!!!
The Pat Cardy's comment - smart and such a perfect way of putting it; “The crimes he committed, he committed against all of us, he murdered us”. I agree because he is added to the many reasons we need to worry and be on full alert in our homes and on the streets.
No excuse for his crimes to be honest, we may not have been through his hell but we have our own stresses of life and not all of use went along destroying the world. He was already ill and it would have likely happened anyway, bad life or not. Some of us have been through worse and no one needed to die for it so Robert Black was too ill.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Thank goodness that man reported what he saw. He could have just told himself that he imagined it or that it was someone the girl knew or whatever. So many people just ignore instead of help or nowadays they film!
Ppl are more aware now and vigilant.
If anything looks weird, it's better to be safe than sorry. Saving a life vs making a mistake is far more important
Agreed, but, in defence of filming, you can get a LOT of information that you would miss/forget/think unimportant or even unintentionally embellish. A dozen people can see the same thing, and tell totally different accounts.
@@Nephilimfields True, fair comment
There's actually a psychological term for this I learnt it when I studied criminal psychology! It's called the "bystander effect" im sure, it's horrific but there was a woman murdered and I think a total of 24 people saw this but didn't intervene or do anything coz they all thought someone else must have called the police 😬 the murderer actually left and came bloody back and finished her off, people vould have saved her but no one would! Its terrifying to know that! Her name was kitty genovese I'm sure so sad! I feel people are more aware now, esp with children, but we still just watch alot, id hope more people would intervene nowadays, but we are very selfish if we think we might be at risk. I still couldnt just watch that shit, id have to go help or at least call the police, very bizarre case-some humans are weird!
How the father of baby sitting victim or the cop that found his daughter in the van didn't end that POS is beyond me
The amount of restraint that father had to not put hands on that monster when he found his daughter in that van… you’re right. It’s beyond me too. The rage I would have felt upon discovering that would have been unrestrained.
yea maybe they thought they can help more kids .
Hearing the ages of these young girls really makes me sick especially after hearing what happened to 8 year old Cherish Perrywinkle. Then when I listened to the medical examiner explain in graphic testimony what happened to her from the sexual assault really broke 💔 my heart. Hearing these ages just brought back what that medical examiner said and it's saddens me.
May I just say that Jennifer's parents are about the loveliest people I've ever seen. Such a tragedy for anyone, but especially for this beautiful couple. I feel calm just listening to them.
Jennifer’s mom explaining how she walked out the door just broke my heart 💔 These poor babies I don’t understand why evil like this is allowed to live in our world to harm our babies. How is it fair for a child to die or live forever with trauma and the person goes on with life
Have you not figured out yet that life isn't fair? Evil isn't *allowed* to exist, it just is. Laws and rules exist, but obviously there is no omnipotent being who insures things like this never happen. Reason I'm an atheist.
@@bcaye I’m sorry for whatever happened to you in life. Truly.
@@ashleysowers9904, I've actually had a pretty good life. I just understand that it's not fair. This man had awful things happen to him and it warped his persona. No one was able to stop it and his life went accordingly. No one was able to stop what he did until the man gardening paid attention and called it in. None of that was fair, but thank goodness the gardener was watching. That is all not fair, but it is how life works.
Bless those poor little girls and curse this evil man but it's not as though anyone just *allowed* this to happen.
Most adult people don’t understand it either… 😢
God fixes everything
i don't understand these stories. i was a young child in the 80s. my mom, me and my sisters were very aware of stranger danger. we called them weird men. vans and strangers were scary to us. we could only walk to the store in groups. i couldn't imagine letting my sun go off by himself. rest in heaven babies☝🏾🙏🏾
We were the same. My oldest sister got taken by an old Jewish man, my Dad found them and kicked the shit out of him (they tell me, before I was born) and he got NO jail time but he was made miserable every time my father saw him.
@@jenniferdnoseworthy2348 you made that up. Shame trying to get attention off these kids tragedy. Disgusting.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
My aunt married a man like this. He abused all of her children. They divorced. And then she got back with him. Disgusting.
After he died, they found videos and momentos that he stole from the kids after death. He lived in multiple states where kids went missing.
He died in Florida and his name was Danny Gray. It was never publicly announced. families of those children may never know.
OMG. Your aunt is not well in her head 😨
some women are very sick... wt a story
One of the hardest ones to watch. Thank God that dude was watching and took action.
I still believe that this beast killed Genette Tate in 1978 in Devon. The way her bike was found and how very suddenly she disappeared fitted his MO exactly. The monster!
May all his little victims have eternal peace. 🌹
It creates a really uneasy feeling seeing the smiling photos of the victims. It's disgusting trying to fathom how these children must have suffered. At his last would-be victim was rescued alive.
She was still raped, though
Jennifer’s parents are just he most amazing people, to be able to take anything positive away from such a horrific time in their lives is truly incredible ❤️ They’re so strong. I’m glad they finally got the closure they deserved ❤️🏴
Bless her, she was saved! That's millions to one chance. Thank God for the gardener and his quick actions. The mother and father here are so articulate, she explains their feelings so we'll, I can almost imagine how they felt. Has someone put this out before?
All of these horrific true crime cases have made me a bit paranoid about the world and remind me to NEVER trust anyone. These criminals look completely ordinary and commit the most disgusting and depraved crimes. I now carefully and attentively observe my surroundings and the people coming and going around me because you never know who might be out to hurt you or someone around you.
Same.
90% of this shit happens by people in your own circle so see things from that perspective and strangers aren't too bad.
This is the most disturbing but maddening story. I could not have sat in front of this monster that did this to my child. I would have gladly spent life In prison for killing him.
Prisons is to good for this demon.
Me too it's so hard to hear that children been abducted and die.
Wouldn't even have to be my kid. Deleting people like him is a net gain for humanity.
I dont like violence am dead set against but God if I had gotten my hands on him
Some pple would say its wrong but upsets me so much
But also makes me just has angry
How the police officer didn't beat him to death
Maybe he's a better man than me
We can go to war kill decent pple for protecting lands but we arnt aload kill these monsters protecting our children
Doesn't add up to me
I am a surviving victim of Child abuse... I watch these series about serial killers and killers/ offenders of children to cope with the trauma... I pray for every victim and their families...
I get help atm from a psychiatrist, but the trauma and PTSD will never end
I will never understand how someone can rape a baby hell rape anyone 😞
I'll tell you how: SOCIETY ALLOWS IT. In a court of law, you're supposedly innocent until proven guilty. In sexual assault cases it always seems that the victim is guilty until proven innocent, and the proving can be next to impossible. Until the punishment fits the crime every single time, we stop letting these people out once caught, and we start paying closer attention to and believing victims by default (at least initially), this will continue as it always has. Not all, but certainly many of these monsters will think twice before destroying someone else's life if they KNOW they'll pay with their own.
Some people are just birthed this way. Some are mad through abuse. But most of them are just birthed that way
The only true way to treat these excuses for humans is exacusion there is no excuses for such scum sorry.
Some people are sick in the head and can't get off without causing someone pain and terror
These are very, very sick people.
My deepest condolences to the surviving family members for your losses. Anyone who commits violence against kids,
especially sexual violence,should never see the light of day again. These criminals will never be rehabilitated and don't deserve an opportunity to leave prison early for "good behavior";their very crimes against children deems them a clear,present,and ongoing danger to society's most vulnerable population. To those who argue that pedos should be given parole opportunities,then open YOUR homes to these criminals and let them live with you and your kids...
somehow I don't think many folks would actually endanger their own kids by housing a pedo. I truly hope the surviving families continue receiving mental health support services as they live with the devastation wrought by that vile sack of hot excrement.
Well said! Totally agree. My idea: Administrators that are making these decisions should be told that, if they free him, a home will be rented, FOR HIM, right next door to where THEY live. I think their decision would be hell no to freeing him!
No, these monsters need to be immediately executed!
They should bring back sessions like on “A Clockwork Orange” everyday for these monsters…then put em to death..bout the most humane way I can think of…
I agree that they cannot be rehabilitated! They need to be taken out of society forever!
The worst part is these scum don't get put in main street prison they are kept in separate areas to protect them that's so bad no one protects the poor children these scum bags attract so stick them in with the main block lads save the tax payer a fortune.
Jennifer's parents come across as very merciful and dignified. After such a terrible event that is a testament to their characters.
I hesitated watching this. I know what it is about, and it is heartbreaking. Such unfathomable evil.
I have such a hard time listening to these videos about children. I wish we would just put these beyond evil perverts to death right away. They will never get better.
I also have been hesitant
But, did anyways. Can't be too put off by it. Get off your moral high horse.
@@littlewolf9049 why don't you find some. We're talking about rape and torture of little girls..the fact your morals are telling you to belittle someone over the keyboard especially when dealing with this topic.
I try not to watch programs like this and most the time I don’t because it weighs heavy on my heart and I don’t like to feel that way because it’s not good to the body and mind. I don’t like to hear detail Of how they were tortured because I start thinking of the pain they went through and how frightened they were and knowing they were crying out for their mother and dad. That’s horrible
This dude is somebody a prison gang should make an example out of.
Trust me, they will. Or at least here in the USA they would
@@SubliminalSociety so true. Ppl can say what they want about individuals behind bars, but I personally have always appreciated the way it’s just an unspoken agreement amongst those in prison, a rule of thumb per say, that inmates DO NOT tolerate ppl who hurt precious children. It’s the only thing I respect about criminals.
All, every one of that type person should be taken care of by the ones already in prison.......would save taxpayers a lot of money.
Well he died in 2016 so a little late for that
@@jameswessling6982 at least he’s dead
This is so heartbreaking to watch! I can't even imagine losing your young child in such a horrific way! I teared up when Susan's mom was describing how Susan was closing the door and her hair got in her face and she said "by now", I can just imagine in her cute Scottish accent which i find adorable even when adults speak. Also the part when she was being proud as Susan had fought that evil monster! I hope all the parents feel less pain in their heart! RIP little 😇 Jennifer, Susan, Caroline and Sarah!🙏
You don’t wanna watch programs that messes with your mood like tearing up because you caused negative chemical reaction in the brain and you will age faster and a negative way that’s why when they did a study on people that drink socially those individuals live longer because of the positive hormones that are released in the body. People that drink socially laugh a lot
@@samdoors5132 spare your psycho babble. It's healthy to experience all emotions, including sadness and anger. Avoiding them is cowardly and makes people unable to handle them when they arise unavoidably.
🙏 is a high five emoji, not prayer.
@@HVS-gk7oo No it isn’t. The high five emoji looks like 🙌 Are you new to the internet? 😂
I was actually kind of confused. The Scottish mother is talking about Jennifer, and her hair, at least according to the visual narrative is being shown as very, very dark brown, not blonde, so something isn't matching up. Very sad, and disturbing, story though to be sure 🥺
This poor family. Oh my goodness it's heartbreaking when her Daddy said the officer had to hold him up when he saw her body...How on earth can anyone be so damn Evil ☠️ I just hate the thought of these people hurting children. 😢
Thank goodness the gardening man saw the young girl disappear & called police! Thank you, mister💖✌🏽.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
I've never heard such an honest account as Andrew Cardy's....."...there was a certain amount of excitement about that, I was going to see my daughter again." Gosh, that's so heartbreakingly honest. My heart goes out to these families ❤️
That really caught my attention as well, it's hard to imagine what he was going through at that moment in time, it sounded strange to me at first but it makes sense when I try to imagine. A heart-breaking story.
How sad.💔
As a parent I 100% understand what he said....may God bless all the parents
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
My dad was from Portobelllo and used to take me and my brother to the promenade, so i remember when Caroline Hogg went missing and my parents discussing with us what happened and why her picture was in shop fronts...etc. I must have been about 5yrs old myself. Her picture was etched in my brain and i remember seeing her face on the tv screen years later and upon listening to the news report it was discussing Black finally being charged with her murder.
When i was about 8 or 9 a car stopped beside my friend and i and asked us if we knew the directions to a local country house. The country house was just a few streets away with easy directions. Yet, the man asked if we would mind jumping in the back of the car and showing him. My friend opened the door and was getting in when i told him to stop and that we won't be going with the man. The country house was an old derelict building with boarded over windows, hidden by trees, uncut grass and fields off the back. A place where all us kids would go play but no good reason for an adult to visit. I sometimes wonder what would have happened had we got in the car and if knowing about Caroline was part of the reason why i didn't trust the man.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
It was so heartbreaking to listen to that mother describe the day her little girl got murdered which is on my 13yr old sons birthday. 💔
I can't believe that forensic psychologist would claim that the majority of pedophiles are immature & unable to have adults relationships.
Like any crime the loners, or socially inept stick out & are more likely to get noticed & caught. The worst offenders are the ones who can blend in & be seen as good people, only to be monsters behind closed doors.
The majority of survivors I've talked to had a married man molest them, or a family member/friend in a relationship with the abuser, mother's boyfriend, aunts husband, grandma's boyfriend etc, mother's best friend's partner etc.
I find the claim that it's adults who aren't in relationships who are pedophiles to be inacurate & dangerous. Please don't let your guard down just because somone is in a romantic relationship, or is married.
I agree. It could be anyone. Hell..it could be your mother or father.
I agree ……..the psychologist on this dock is not obviously up to snuff re pedophiles…….Pedos are smart enough to know how to groom, so I disagree with him.
Yea wtf it’s like he was defending them he might be one
In criminology, they will sometimes differentiate between child molesters (attracted to adults and children) and pedophiles (only attracted to children). I assume that is the distinction being made.
Geeze..how do you get over something like this? Just tragic for those left behind 💔
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
@@Bootmahoy88 do you know, I actually agree with you. Sexual abuse as a child, kills many futures. And that's just for surviving. It is by far, the worst crime one can commit.
You don’t get over it…
I'm 55 and I remember running wild and free when I was a kid not thinking that anybody would ever get a hold of us and now today I wouldn't consider my granddaughter's out of my site for not even 2 minutes
What an absolutely heart breaking situation to be in for the parents and these young children. Those poor children must’ve gone through hell. RIP beautiful angels x
30 years before Jennifer got her justice??
Her poor parents.
It's truly heartbreaking! :(
Nobody can say "I understand" unless they have suffered that. My heart goes out to them. But, make no mistake they are no longer victims but incredibly brave survivors.
42.30 Amazing words. And there's truth in them.
These people who hurt children should face a harsher fate than just prison.
Harsh enough to act as a deterrent.
Yes many pa pas are being tempted
If they all ended up like Richard Huckle, it might! But then they should be kept in prison upon first offence for life instead of being paroled time after time. It's a sad statement when cops collect all of the evidence and deal with the bodies and some stupid judge and lawyer lets these creeps off with a slap on the wrist! It's a joke to think these monsters are ever "rehabilitated"!
Nothing deterres them. Even death penalty doesn't because they don't believe they will get caught 😐
They need putting out of their misery. They are good for nothing trash.
ges for all those criminals out there. punishment should be way harsher than what it is on all crimes.
“Do you want to see a box of kittens?” Evil...the person that said something similar to me used a guinea pig to get me to come in the house...they know it’s wrong and they still do it...I hope their families find peace 💜
This is maddening, tragic, and disgusting, all at the same time. And the poor parents and siblings of this monster's victims--how awful to live with the fact that your child or sister suffered so horrendously.
I will never understand these sorts of people. As a young child, I suffered what I call "the abuse trifecta"--physical, emotional, and sexual abuse, both in foster homes and from my adoptive father. But it has never occurred to me to want to sexually abuse, let alone murder, children.
There’s always a danger when you let your under age kid go by themselves alone. Im thankful for shows like this learning that don’t leave your kids unattended in any situation. Sad for her family
Absolutely!
It was different then. Kids could roam around free und unmolested in the countryside. I spent my whole childhood in the woods, never had a weird encounter with anyone.
Prdophiles were unheard of.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
What Black went through as child is no excused for what he did to those poor little girls.
Things like this haunt me on my best days! This is so heartbreaking and terrifying that little innocent babies and their families suffer like this. Anyone this evil needs tortured and castrated over and over again. I was so hesitant about even watching this because I knew it would be something of such sickening evil & I could never forget. R.I.H. 👼
Ive been watching these real crime episodes lately. This episode is just chilling. Brings me to tears.
How can someone harm kids ? It’s beyond any human imagination
A couple who lived next door to my grandparents (in fact, they were friends) had a damaged son who tried to kill his mother with a pair of scissors when he was 17. He was institutionalized at some point in the 50s. Eventually, he was released and he went to work as a gardener at a hotel. When a young girl was reported to be missing, he led the group that searched the hotel grounds. He became a suspect when he seemed to lead his search party directly to the girl's body. I have no idea what happened to him after this. I heard the story from my Dad. My curiosity is piqued, but....since my father has passed on, I cannot ask for details.
He lived on Alexandra Parade in Glasgow. I believe his parents' names were Maisie and Jim.
At first, I actually wondered if this was HIS story.
Depressing yet interesting Protect the children -- For They Are Our Future --
Protect animals as well as they have no voice and rely on us!
@@joli395 What is wrong you people?! What does animals have to do with this video of 4 innocent young girls being rapped and killed?! Are you OK!? So annoying, first post I read was about corrupted government with comments about stupid crypto and now you! Have some respect for lost life's and their family's! And btw I am an animal lover myslef but really?!
Well said Kim!
@@magdalenamezydlo6150 Stop being a bully agressively attacking my opinion. Animals are just like children innocenet nd dependent on us. If you can't see that you have aproblem! Calm down and learn to respect other points of view.
@@joli395 btw I have 3 babies name Rocky, Jax and Booger aka my dogs that I love lime my babies, besides my daughter! But how do you think the family would feel if they read 21 comments out 24 being about crypto and you comparing their children to animals. Trust me I get your point bcuz I love my 3 there are truly like my babies but not every one feels like that. And I just thing it's inappropriate to write comments on something that has noting to do with the video. But I do apologize if I come off aggressive! I guess the whole crypto conversation got me really upset and I also been abused as a child so it's a very sensitive subject to me when children get rapped and killed. I trie not to even watch this kind of videos much bcuz it take me to a dark place! Again, I'm sorry for the way I had reacted! Have a great day!
I couldn't imagine the pain of losing a child. I always say my son is the great love of my life. I say this because I obviously love my husband (his dad) but the second I held him and looked at him I felt a love I had never felt before, an unconditional, I would give my life for yours kind of love. When he was born I changed my life, I actually started to think about my decisions and stopped being impulsive because I didn't want anything to jeopardize me raising him. My husband was the same. We went from two idiots that partied all the time, got in trouble, no focus, no purpose, no strength, associated with shitty people ect. To when finding out I was pregnant, taking parenting classes, getting therapy, cutting bad influences, staying sober...to now over a decade later we both work solid jobs and provide our son with the love and stability we never got. I just couldn't imagine losing him.
Castration is not harsh enough. Turn the perp over to the families. Let the families determine their fate.
Agree friend
Better yet, make him suffer the exact same way his victims did.
Followed by the judges that hand out pathetic sentences , then the morons who successfully, or otherwise, campaign to have the perpetrators released early, only to commit the same crime that saw them jailed in the first place
The common denominator in cases like this is the person was never corrected from the get-go an investigation if the person themselves were molested and mistreated…. And the first time they are caught about a child is the last time they should be able to walk.. They should never be able to hurt another child never free to hurt another child
Suggestion for the next video:
"Catholic Church: Preying On Innocent Young Boys."
There are videos about that.
Why stop there? ALL “religious” CULTS. They’re all f’n twisted. Show me ANY religion and I’ll cite so many cases it’ll make your head spin. ALL OF THEM.
+Kocicka Kitty That would probably have to be a series spread out over years. 😞
@@MyTube4Utoo decades friend
The purest of evil is hurting Children! 😭
I was a teenager at the time and it stayed with me until this day 😭💔🏴
Sick story. This is made even more sick by the fact that the people of the UK lost their moral way and eliminated the death penalty. The only just penalty for murdering a child is death. The only just penalty for murdering multiple children is severe pain and suffering before death.
My heart breaks for Jennifer’s family. Such a sad story
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
😪😡🤬
This is for Mr Andy Clardy: I grieve for your loss by the cruel inhumane murder of your precious Jennifer. I just read an article about your regret at having bought your child a bicycle which in your opinion gave the beast Robert Black access to your daughter. Please sir do not see your glorious act of kindness and generosity to your beloved daughter in that light. You gave your daughter joy and pride that you trusted her to act responsibly with her new found freedom. That beast should not be allowed to rob that from you. When my parents finally scrapped enough together to buy all four of their daughters matching metallic turquoise and silver bicycles each of us were overjoyed. I remember riding my bike from our country farm home we rented to the nearby subdivision to find a friend to play with. I also remember riding to a grocery store about 5 miles away to buy pickling spices my mother needed for her many pickles and jams she canned each year. It was a joy I still remember.
I’m sure when you see Jennifer again, she will tell you the joy you gave her sir. Hang on to this. God Bless
I will never understand why people see crimes like this or are told and say nothing. It would save so many lives.
Plz tell me how a child can dress attractively??? That one investigator that said it just irked the hell out of me.
This confused me. Wtf does that mean??
I suppose it means the child is dressed in a way the perpetrator finds attractive. Not that the child herself is dressed attractively. For example, if the perp has a thing for girls in hoodies, he would think that girls in hoodies are dressed attractively.
It means the child is well-dressed.
Hearing Geoffrey Wansell speak reminds me of reading a book by a fire under a warm blanket. So soothing.
The content however is not soothing whatsowever!
The narrator??
I watch true crime all the time and my mind just can not fathom the thought process of an adult wanting to do this or being attracted to babies. It’s sickening.
Those of us who are able must hunt these monsters and remove them from this world. Quietly and discreetly not with malice but with determination and purpose to save as many children as possible. There is only one way to obtain justice and that is it which I have described.
It is not a sin to kill these type of men in the eyes of God. It is Righteous.
What does "attractively dressed" mean when talking about a 5 year old? I think that phrase is a bit twisted, there is no circumstance where you can use the word "attractive" when talking about an innocent young child.
right 🙄
It just means “well-dressed,” as opposed to sloppily dressed. Don’t read anything else into it.
A dog just for bit a person is immediately put to sleep, and these monsters never get the death penalty and they live happy in a prison eating well and doing nothing.
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
God bless the precious joy being taken from these families by these terrible monsters that have been made through I don’t know what. I was terribly abused as a child myself, however I would never dream of harming another child, person or animal. I am a protector of those who don’t have a voice because I understand how it feels.
The mother and father of the first victim are absolutely incredible people. I would love to meet them if possible.
Any person doing these things to children or taking the life of anyone should receive the death penalty immediately and it should be in the same way they killed their victims
Eye for an eye
@@DewberryJackson And the whole world goes blind, as they say.
If it was my daughter that I found in the back of the van, this monster would have never made it back to the police station…
When my son got married he moved to Chisholm Place in Grangemouth Scotland and was actually living in the house Robert Black was brought up in. Now that was creepy 🏴
England's judicial system is too lenient. The sentences they impose on criminals is too low. They need to make changes.
We all know that thanks.
When Caroline Hogg went missing from Portobello, the police appealed to anyone who had been there that day (the beach & fairground) to hand in photos they'd taken so they could look for Caroline in the background. They didn't see the wee girl in any pics but there was a very high amount of known peadophiles there that day. That's only known peadophiles, there would have been many more not known by the police. That fact terrified me & has never left me all these years
It is spelt paedophile actually.
@@fionagregory9147 I think it may actually be spelt fuckoffyousadlittlewoman.....actually.
Ok I feel genuinely sad for the hell he suffered as a child. My younger brother & oldest sister suffered unimaginable abuse. My younger bother was miraculously healed by Jesus Christ when he was a teenager so he grew up to be a wonderful father of 1 girl and 3 boys. Unfortunately my sister was damaged from the severe abuse & never got healed. But NOBODY SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO HARM CHILDREN FOR ANY REASON!!! NOBODY IS EXCUSED!!!!
He should NEVER see the light of day EVER AGAIN!!!!
It's true that Jesus Christ is a wonderful healer, He (overnight) delivered me from suicidal thoughts, depression and demonic oppression and nightmares and has also miraculously healed me from illness! (As well as giving me salvation and eternal life!) I do wish that more people would turn to Him for help, it' s free, after all (though not free for Him as it cost Him His life).
I'm sorry but no one is truly healed from abuse. They may look like they have it together but they are probably crying by their self or after having a drink. It's all you think about. It consumes you.
These poor innocent children I can’t comprehend in my mind how anyone could commit these evil crimes on children these beautiful children had lives and a right to grow and become adults in safety their poor families it breaks my heart, rest in peace little ones my thoughts are with the families x
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
I grew up on a council estate in Keighley West Yorkshire we used to go shopping in Leeds, so it was familiar. I was 11 in 1986 everyone I went to school with lived in the same area. I remember us all being able to roam around our area & stay out before it got dark. We had tea at six o'clock every day so Look North/Calender was on TV. The Story about Sarah Harper was shown, she went to the corner shop to get a loaf of bread & disappeared. That's what we all did, you could buy cigarettes and alcohol for your parents back then but usually it was to buy gravy, milk or bread.. It was a safe thing to do & only 5 minutes walk but after the story aired everything changed . We couldn't go anywhere on our own so I had to walk to school with my sister & brother. When Sarah's body was found, that was it no more roaming around at all hours. We had curfews that were strictly enforced. If my curfew was 8pm and by 8.05pm if I hadn't come home, my dad came out looking for me he didn't have to go far because I was two minutes away from home trying hard to hide the fact that I smoked. That is also the first time we all found that not only did monsters who prayed on kids exist but they didn't look like monsters they looked like everybody else. It was also the first time we'd heard the word paedophile & what the word meant.
It could have been anyone of us but it wasn't. Sarah Harper didn't die in vain, her murder made all of us aware that for the first time that evil walks amongst us hunting for their prey..
I have a photograph imprinted in my memory forever, it shows Sarah Harper sitting on the wall outside the corner shop. How does a parent or loved one get over the fact their child has been horrifically murdered by a monster no one knew existed. I can usually empathise & put myself in their shoes to know how they're feeling but unless you go through it yourself you'll never know know how they feel. Tbh I don't want to because no one should have to go through that.
My heart goes out to all those parents & loved ones who've lost children in similar circumstances. We don't forget about them ever.
I cried so much when Jennifer's mom talked about her I balled like a little girl. 😭 I hug my daughter harder. This is just heart breaking
My mum has told me so many times about walking along the road on a main Dumfries road when she was 6 and seeing a white van driving up and down the road watching her in 1977, she’s always been convinced it was him and remembers his face but sadly unlike these girls there was always someone nearby to look out for her as she lived on a caravan park.
my mum was walking along and a white van stopped and got out and my mum started to run and the man took off and she is convinced it was him and i showed her a photo and she said it was him.
What I find odd is that even all those years ago, and in another country, pervs drove white vans. I thought that was only a American weirdo thing.
It grieves me to know that this Parasite was fed, housed and clothed daily, living out his life to the very end in prison, while these beautiful innocent angels never got a chance at life! 😡😿
I STILL feel that instead of giving these Parasites all of the above luxuries, subject them to the horrors with which they delt out to these innocent lives in every graphic detail.
Then, justice is served. 😿
I agree, but the problem is that he WAS subject to these horrors. depraved people create depraved people. it's really sad
@@itdk107 You're right. Not to mention, he could never escape his demons. Very sad indeed.
I’m sorry I’ve a 22yr old daughter and a 6 yr old son I would never allow them to walk alone in east end of Glasgow it stresses me out my daughter walks home from late night working without transportation it needs to be looked at
Same in many parts of the country unfortunately.
Pay for a taxi. Save yourself the worry as its not that expensive.
This is truly terrible 😢 We need to put them in prison and tell the inmates that their child rapists and murders and let them take care of the rest...my deepest apologies and love for all their families...
I can not believe,how many times this monster,was given the chance to hurt children.!
I always thought, the access to a child was the cause. This Demon proves, it can just happen to any child, anywhere, anytime...That's scary!
The zozo demon
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
May God bless with strength and courage all the parents of the victims...This is so heartbreaking...💔
I don't think I would stay sane if I was in their shoes...
I applaud the formation of any serious vigilante collective to target pedophiles. The Sex Offender Registry makes it easy to find them. Like shooting ducks in a barrel.
Uhhhhhhhh he molested someone and his first punishement was ONLY 1 year.. What in the actual ****%€%&#* ive seen people get 20 plus years or even life in jail for way less. Ffs
Great coverage
I'm so sorry for the families who lost loved ones. But how was he able to take a 6 year old girl!!??? What were 6 year olds doing out walking alone? Where were the parents?? Who the hell let's a 6 year old out alone like that???!
Absolutely. One girl was only 5. Unbelievable.
@@oriana7026 I have a 8 year old I don't let him go out by himself I would be panicked and worried the whole time. We know sick evil people are out there so why the hell risk letting your young child out alone. Everyone thinks it won't happen to them but of course it does.
@@oriana7026 thank you I thought it might be me thinking wrong but I absolutely do not think a child of that age should be out unacompanied they should have an adult with them. Obviously I'm not saying I place blame on the parents I know this is horrific for them but this could have been prevented happening to their child if they didn't let he/she out alone at the age of 5/6
Rest in peace to all of the innocent children taken by this horrible man