ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 เม.ย. 2017
- The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that Russia failed to protect the hostages of the Beslan school siege in which about 330 people died in 2004. In the siege, Chechen rebels took more than 1,000 hostages, mostly children. The operation by Russian forces to end it used disproportionate force, the court added.
It also said that officials knew an attack was imminent but did not act. Russia said the ruling was "utterly unacceptable" and that it would appeal. No Russian official has been held responsible for the high number of deaths, which included 186 children.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
World In Pictures • WORLD IN PICTURES
Big Hitters • MUST SEE VIDEOS
Just Good News • Just good news
One Russian soldier jumped on suicide bomber to save children
Yea, my friend it was the great disaster for our little Ossetia... There were a lot of the same cases ((
@Proloop Under bro, u catch the right way of thinking.. It was only its guilt, only the authority.. They shut up the simple population, they shut up us(((. .. But no matter now.. A lot of Innocent souls lost... Because of the wish of deviding the religions and forced the nations to each other (((
thank you PuTINBOT#4100
@@stalkerino9532 thank you NATOBOT #1048
Actually? Or are you just making Russian jokes?
rebels dont kill children/ only terrorists can do that
Like what's happening in Ukraine?
@@davidmoore2445yes
Glad to see comments calling out BBC's love for jihadists.
The BBC is a disgusting cabal. Another example of that love. For decades their reporters didn't investigate the huge organised rape-gangs which existed in Britain mainly in the North. They are scared of the Religion of Peace and are utterly beholden to the custodians of the holy sites in the Middle East.
As V. Putin said, "a country which doesn't look after its children, has no future"
@Stephen Jenkins Doesn't America and EU also have oligrachs??? You know Bill Gate, Jeff Bezo, Morgan, and Mark Zuckerberg???
@Stephen Jenkins they don't they Lobby, is almost as running the country but with puppets. Last time I've check Bezo make million dollar per second but hey look at some Russian millionaire on a boat. You know how stupid you make when you ignore the wealth inequality in the West.
Can someone please fill me on what really happened I don’t know anything about this
@Sayfullah borz they did best they could to end a hostage situation. Yea it went tits up but soldiers were under tonnes of pressure and it would've been worse if noone intervened. Likely none of the kids would have survived.
One of the most disgusting titles I have ever seen about a situation like this. I think BBC is not much of journalism anymore.. sadly.
it is hijacked by Arabs and Islamists, BBC today airs the same Propaganda as Al Jazeera.
That’s what the quotation marks are there, Jesus
@@melodicnostalgic3823 yo wtf
@@zeekaa12 If you watch the video actually, you will see that the point is that in fact Russia failed, the quotations marks are there just because saying failed without the marks would be too direct.
Russia killed their own children
Rebels, huh? London Bridge, Westminster Bridge, Manchester Arena... then acts of rebelling I guess.
@08x840234 Can you source this?
@@tasinal-hassan8268 everything
@@Kriegter Yes,source it.
@Ch2149 Yes.
@Ch2149 You mean Iran?
I feel so bad for those children, Rest in Peace.
The fact they had to send tanks over is ridiculous….
Honestly hearing how spetsnaz threw themselves infront of children and suicide bombers just makes me tear up. They must be some brave men
They are children! Soldiers first priority is to protect innocent, children are the most innocent and they are our future, if we can’t protect them, what are we good for at all?
Citation?
lmao they were apparently the cause for most of those deaths
So brave they shot at the walls of the school without targets and then shot missiles at the school killing more people then the actual terrorist
Except if u read the reports most of the children probably were killed by Russian fire
Imagine dying protecting these children just to have journalists imply you ‘failed’ from the comfort of their laptop
BBC for ya
Compare this one to Uvalde Texas
@@lupohutchington269 well, difference is that those people were cowards in Texas
Here, they were just incompetent.
Well yeah, they failed, at least 80% of the hostages were killed by indiscriminate Russian fire during the raid.
Russophobia
Blaming a country for suffering a terrorist attack is beyond wrong. The soldiers clearly did their best, suffered casualties, and prevented a lot more deaths in an unimaginably tense situation. If the same thing happened in the USA or UK, this type of language would never be used to cast aspersions on their response.
Thank you🙏
Shameless BBC 🤨😒😐
Disrespectfull title...
This was not an act of rebels...these were pure simple coward terrorits with some shitty reasons to kill women and children.
Russian soldiers were true hereos that day....
#Respect for Beslan Hereos from Brazil.
I am British and I agree. Wghat the Chechen did at Beslan was pure evil.
The Russians fired 30mm and 125 mm shells into the school not to mention they called in a mi 24 read the debrief
And now the Russian soldiers in their "Special Operation" are the terrorists.
Rebels?! Are u siriously?!
The very same rebels as IS. They call the IS so anyway on BBC
They were coward murderous terrorists
Right, shit sounds like they're explaining a kid taking someone's lunch money
Technically, they aren’t wrong. Chechens WERE fighting for freedom from Russia...
western media are refrain from calling them terrorist. to attack innocent in eastern nation.
Being a British Royal Navy sailor and a patriot, I find the title of this video an utter disgrace, rest in peace to all those children and adults who died at the hands of Chechen jihadsts
Ask the parents of the killed. Relatives of the victims managed to sue Russia for their inadequate special operation attack violating hostages' human rights. Who uses RPG's, Tanks and flamethrowers in a hostage situation with kids? It is reported that as many as 80% of the victims were killed by the special forces. Considering that 2 years earlier the FSB again decided it's ok to kill hostages during attack in a similar situation (Moscow theater), it shouldn't surprise anyone.
"Being British Royal Navy sailor"
=====> Those words uttered in pride disgust me!!! You people fight wars against innocents wherever on this planet! Fuck UK!
@@napsterbg another virtue signaling who thinks he knows best what to do.
What would you have done in the Moscow theater without carfentanil to immobilize the insurgents?
Armchair strategist are always quick to judge or probably anger by recent events in order to smear on everything related to Russia without thinking intelligently
@@xayvath5221 You are the one who brings up recent events without them having any reference to the above mentioned. You are the one who talks of intelligent thinking, yet add no arguments to the topic.
I am no specialist, I could be wrong or right, facts are the FSB/government are killing way more civilians/hostages than the threads do themselves in major crisis's. They are the last guys you would want if you find yourself in a hostage situation. I find it hard to believe how anyone could defend their actions in both cases.
You can look up major Russian investigations regarding those events (add the apartment bombings as well) - how the FSB helped the terrorists, how the FSB abused their power, made human rights violations, killed more civilians than the terrorists in order for the crisis to stop and get political PR. Politicians and journalists who made those claims are killed or had an attempt on their lives. New censorship laws were passed days after those events in order to stop any political opposition, any critical thinking in the media.
But hey, because I couldn't do better than the FSB, I guess I can't criticize them for their obvious crimes.
@@napsterbg where's your recommendations armchair general to solve the hostage situation effectively?
Typical arguments: fsb are bad guys doing everything for political PR stunts. Heard a lot about that from a specific regional part of the world and their powerful msm.
I'd like to hear about how the fbi was unable to prevent 9/11 with their high qualify specialists or the cowardice super police during Uvalde school shooting. One policeman was too "busy" and found time to clean his hand with a sanitizer😉😂
Criticize others but we never make mistakes innit???
according to bbc russia is responsible for everything past present and future get it
It might not be apparent from the report, but Russian authorities used grenade launchers, flamethrowers and a tank cannon when storming the school (a bit of overkill, especially in a school full of children). The operation was uncoordinated, lacking formal leadership resulting in serious flaws in decision making and coordination between the agencies involved. Furthermore, they had intel enabling them to prevent the whole situation altogether. Russia then failed to properly investigate the incident at the national level. That's what the decision of the ECHR is about.
Yep.
What about western security services failing by allowing known jihadis prepare and carry out terrorist attacks in western cities???
and destroying the nazis
How was it not a failure then? They even failed to set up a perimeter....
This tragedy has happened on September 1, 2004, I remember that my family didn't depart 3 days from the TV. All very much worried. Still to this school people come and have made a memory memorial of it.
I reported this video for terrorism propaganda
👌❤️
Russian amid all odds standing firm against terrorism. That should be the title. What bbc did was disrespectful. Respect to the Russian people from the Philippines.
Thank you. A comment with sense
thank you for this words.
Uh, did you not hear, it's the family of the victims who blame authority and the actions of those who stormed the buildings as the reason why so many people died. They,the Russians, handled this poorly. They need a better defense force. And you're typing in English so lack of common sense isnt an excuse.
@@v.9964 shut up
@@Ollopicko Oh, that's it?! That was your viable adult conversation?! I was really impressed,you didn't produce any deviating thoughts or facts based in this video, but I was still mighty impressed by your vigorous use of non viable rhetoric and lack of social construct skills. It was pretty interesting to see your individual take on it, 2/10 for your lack of basic debate skills. Congratulations!!! And have a great day!
Noticed how they said “rebels” instead of u know what..
The situation was too tough, even Delta or SAS also might be failed in such conditions. Altough the consequence was disasterous, the one thing certain is that the russian soldiers did their best. They even became human-shield to protect hostages. Besides every political matters between western and eastern, the soldiers were still hero.
NO its called negotiation ....you wouldn't know.
@@XLENDIBAY1 negotiate with Islamic extremists? good luck. also they tried to negotiate for almost 2 days
@@therealchen 175 children, and no Americans or Brits would have fucked up equally as bad, you can't rescue over 700 hostages from 20+ armed gunman who have bombs rigged everywhere in a packed Gymnasium without at least 100+ dead civilians.
even...it means sas would fail for sure! Thats the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! no one could do it better! In situation with 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with hundreds of child hostages sitting around the bombs and parents with guns rushing the school that is success they saved so many people, 800 saved to be exact! 13 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body!
Imagining copy and past
I wonder how my UK Government would have dealt with a situation like this?
I remember watching this as it happened and I knew before the troops stormed in it was going to only end one way. BBC bias as usual.
More than likely: the SAS losing it's reputation, there was no other option, and considering Spetsnaz had already dealt with some chechens before at least they knew to not take prisoners, just imagine: holed up in one room, filled with bombs and grenades and with jihadists ready to die for a dumb cause with impossible to meet demands, the only thing that would change would be the BBC headline and the uniform.
UK doesn't give a shit about civilians. Remember how they murdered civilians wholesale in Fallujah.
Here are some edits:
00:12 but rebels stormed the school and forced more than 1,100
--> but 32 terrorists arrived at the school, killed 2 parents, and forced 1,128...
01:15 hundreds of Russian security forces surrounded the school
--> hundreds of armed locals and Russian security forces surrounded the school
01:20 (the security forces) stormed the building: explosions and gunfire rang out
--> there were 2 explosions inside the school, security forces and armed locals stormed the building
01:24 there was no sign of medical teams or ambulances
[Delete. No need to say this.Parking ambulances in front of the school would have signaled the
authorities planned to attack the school]
01:26 the attackers shot some of the children in the back as them ran for freedom
[This doesn't make sense, were they running back into the school for freedom?
Expand, clarify and cite a source]
01:38 some relative fought to get through the security cordon to find out what was happening to their loved ones
--> armed locals joined with regular forces pouring fire into the school, and advanced with them
01:56 but many families and victims blame (Russian) authorities
--> the whole world condemn the Chechen terrorists for attacking a school, but their victims can not, as they are no longer here
02:00 its come out that security forces fired tanks and flames throwers at the school
--> after 12 hours of fighting, to minimise losses, authorities finished off resistance with a shell from a tank.
Sugarcoating a tragedy to suit their bias and protect Islamists. Fuck BBC
the building is filled with explosives. what other situation was possible? the terrorists learned from the act of terror in the theater and laid the bombs under the children. there was no other way out here. there could have been significantly more casualties. The guys did what they could to save lives. here as medics who are not omnipotent and do not always succeed in rescuing a person from the grip of death.
0:11 Why not refer to them as what they are, Terrorists? They committed an act of terror after all - this is not like star wars where the Rebels are the good guys...
And to say the Russian's failed here...well the odds were stacked against them from the start. Even if we ignored the factors of the 1990s and early 2000s (economic crash, lack of reform and modernization, Yeltsin's "Dyermo-kratiya") which were being addressed but it took a lot from a low base, it was very unlikely they could have done anything else. I doubt any Special Forces group would have succeeded in Beslan, as described at 0:37, the terrorists had days to prepare and an arsenal of explosives and boobytraps, and considering everything we know about the Chechens, what would negotiations have achieved? They wanted to kill russians and were willing to die doing that (they were islamist after all), knowing their demands were unacceptable to the Russian Govt. Basically (like most terrorists) they made it as hard as possible for the Russians.
And flamethrowers!? Really?! I doubt that highly. If you are referring to the RPO, it is more of a Bazooka type weapon than that of a generic flamethrower, but I can believe the use of a RPO or similar weapon, not a 'classic' flamthrower like a LPO-50
Yes the Russians didn't do this perfectly, lessons were yet to be learned at that point as this was 'new' to them. Thankfully it appears the lessons of Chechnya were well learned. I do not see why the ECHR took this case; this was 13yrs ago, bit late, and the ruling shall forever be tainted by the anti-russia hysteria we are experiencing again, so even IF this ruling is objective and just (which I doubt) its reception shall be met with skepticism and its coverage skewed.
boff Russian refused to negotiate ... which would have solved the problem......and then came in with flame throwers and blew a hole in the wall where they knew the kids were . Actually the terrorists themselves were trying to protect the kids and parents . What you did was evil and insane ,,,, followed by an exact similar disaster at the Theatre ...YOU LEARNED NOTHING .
@@XLENDIBAY1
damn, how your mouth opened to say that! Nor flamethrowers could be used, they dont even have them! rpgs were shot by terrorists, not russians! That was the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with 1200 of child hostages sitting around the bombs and parents with guns rushing the school that is success they saved so many people, 900 saved to be exact! 15 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body to save children!
@@Orlington17 Yea lmao, who tf would use a flamethrower in 20th century, also, their army doesnt have them, true, rpgs maybe where used, but its all hostages words, what the fuck they know, im pretty sure every one was shitting themselver
@@Orlington17 They could be the bombs tho, not sure about the rpg shots or the tank ones
@@XLENDIBAY1 negotiate what?
just wondering who failed on
Westminster Bridge? just few weeks ago!
Marco Polo
Lol, you are a real piece of shit aren't you?
Marco Polo Russia again
Dardania Lion Marco Polo doesn't look like troll. Westminster Bridge: Difference was number & horror inflicted by those who *"submit to"* Islamic terror ideology
Русское море
As opposed to you, who just began as a piece of shit.
yes agree so are the police the government to blame for terror attack in london
As a Mexican American my condolences go out to Russia. We despise terrorists here in the U.S as well.
yep, fighting for your countries freedom is one thing, but killing innocents is unforgivable and dastardly
If you despise terrorist stop training and arming terrorist in Syria and don’t start wars in Iraq. Then I think we’d have less terrorist in the world
@@ssglbc1875 Silence Chmonya
@@joshuajuarez9930this video is from 2004
@@joshuajuarez9930He's right, we all know how the Taliban's seized power. Blame your government
My heart goes out to all the parents and families that lost children and loved ones. 🥀🌹🥀🌹🥀🌹🥀🌹🥀🌹🥀
Yeah they're called terrorists not "rebels"
They were rebels indeed
I remember watching a documentary a very long time ago about the experience of these children, and I thought I dreamed it up the whole experience. It wasn’t a couple years ago, where I found it again, and the real event it was based on. There are some things you wish to stay in nightmare, so many young people lost.
I know which documentary you are talking about
@@Zoey-jc1qdit’s called children of beslan
They wouldn't call the 7/7 attacks 'failures' would they, BBC.
They are definitely terrorists not rebels. Besieging a school with full of little angels, is the least on rebels's mind
Calling a band of terrorists as 'rebels' and calling the heroic deeds of soldiers who tried to save innocent civilians as a failure is an utter disrespect to all the people who died there. BBC isn't even qualified to be called a media outlet but a wahabi-loving propaganda outlet.
As a person who's lived in the midst of a terrorist war for 19 years, my condolences goes to the civilians and the soldiers who died at Beslan. Love and respect from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰💚🇷🇺
Yes, but Putin caused all of this with his attacks.
God bless you brother ☦️🇷🇺☦️ Z
All these media are Muslim propagandist
@@Toofast6849 shut up. That z symbol is the Russian swastika.
Thank you so much my brother..i studied at the school..that day i lost my friend forever..thank you ❤
🇷🇺❤🇱🇰
My heart goes out to the families ❤️ I’m so sorry about this but wtf has to be wrong with you to use that title for a video like this
"rebels"....
Yes they are rebels
@@senseinaruto8857 no
@@zer5372 yes
@@leggo9830 more like terrorists
Rebel !? Huh !? They killing their own people, rebel huh
Huh ? I am Turkish I dont Understand Turc?
So sad !We love you Russia , from France.
thanks!
@Sayfullah borz please. stfu.
@Sayfullah borz what are you talking about? This was terrorist's from Afghanistan.
@Sayfullah borz Please stop trying to be a mere cog in the propaganda machine by making everything into a political dilemma. This was a serious attack on innocent lives and those lives being russian does not change anything about that, make it less tragic or less of an atrocity. If this would have happened in the US or in the UK, I am sure that journalists would have dealt with it a different way.
Those were people getting killed who had absolutely nothing to do with the Chechnya wars and by no means is the original comment ''supporting dictatorships'' by supporting Russia, as in the nation itself. Not a single word being said about the government or the political system there.
If you think all there is about Russia are either the Soviets or Putin, you are severely misled.
@Sayfullah borz Untrue, russian soldiers sacrifice their lives just to get insulted by western media.
God bless the Russian Spetsnaz, Respect from India 🇮🇳🙌
And from the United States.
Спасибо вы пострадали от Британской тирании как никто и знаете какими Морскими и подлыми могут быть британцы 🇬🇧
Thanks bro
No matter the conflict, no matter the nation. There are heros and those who stand by, and yet all it takes is the words of slimey people to nullify the tragedy of such an event.
Rebels?
Yes Rebels
@@senseinaruto8857
no, it's inhuman, soulless terrorists
Over 20 terrorists with explosive vests lots of ammunition and properly trained with military background 😐 ...I don't know a single country that could handle that response fast with hostages in the mix
That was the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with 1200 of child hostages sitting around the bombs ! fsb group found the same school and were preparing all the variants of assaults, another fsb group conducted on-site reconnaissance through ventilation and other available options while police was negotiating with terrorists! But at one moment people heard explosion in school and armed parents just rushed there, so thats how they had to start! that is success they saved so many people, 900 saved to be exact! 15 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body to save children! rpgs were shot by terrorist! No flamethrowers were used! 1 tank shell was shot when hostages were saved and some terrorist barricaded in class!
The European Court did not bother checking the facts and simply took everything the plaintiffs said as God's honest truth, including blatant lies. The flamethrowers and tanks were used after the hostages were evacuated and/or in spots where there were no hostages e.g. the attic space from a sniper was firing at the rescuers). There is undeniable photo, video and physical evidence, which is ignored by these so-called "journalists". Doctors, medical brigades, ambulances, field hospital, full-size hospital and even a medical airplane were present and ready to care for the wounded, but the chaos couldn't be avoided given the scale of the attack. Over 200 hostages were killed during the explosions of the terrorists bombs on September 3rd, 21 adult men were shot on day 1, several - throughout the ordeal, 29 women and kids were shot by the terrorists as they were trying to escape right after the first explosions, others died in other parts of the building as they were dragged out by the "rebels" and used as human shieds or later succumbed to their wounds in hospitals. Russian Special forces did the impossible saving hundreds. 10 elite soldiers sacrificed themselves guarding people from fire (two jumped on grenades to cover hostages from the explosions) and 55 were wounded, not counting the dozens of the wounded military and civilian rescuers. The bbcs, cnns and such will always portray it as failure of the Special Forces, the government, Putin and will show a frantic group of poor women, who were brainwashed to think that the Spetsnaz killed their kids, as if they speak on behalf of the whole town. But almost all Beslan residents and, particularly, hostages know full well who was there to save them from the "rebels" and cherish their sacrifices dearly. The bbcs and cnns won't show that though. It doesn't fit the picture.
Sometimes i think that if this were to be on the hands of any other country or special forces.(SAS, Seals, swat, you get the point) it would've ended....way...waaaaay worse.
Over 400 were killed no other special forces would’ve successfully done this operation the terrorist had the upper hand
Trust the BBC to put a clown spin on it. Britain's cnn.
RIP poor children
Peaceful community spreading peace.
BBC, i wish you and your families will never experience this tragedy. And i just phrase the God not to make you pay an equal price for materials as this one. Do you know that there was an unexpected explosion inside the building ? Do you know that once that happened kids start running outside and terrorists opened fire after that and not after " Russians stormed the building"? Russian forces had no choice but react. They used so called "tanks" for cover mostly. Do you know BBC, that that day Russia had lost 10 special force soldiers from ALPHA and VIMPEL , our elites? Do you know that they gave their lives protecting kids? That one of those soldiers covered the grenade with his body and saved kids that were running out with him? That another Hero stood up like a wall in between the kids trying to pass the hallway and terrorists machine gun point? BBC you have know idea what happened there, and what kind of pain this people and all out nation went through and you have no right to show this tragedy without mentioning Heroes , without exposing details that matters the most.
I've heard that gunfire was not begun by explosions within the school building but by two shots fired from OUTSIDE the school.
Excellent response 👌
I'd really like to learn more on this, I had no idea that special forces did that.
Please tell me more 🤔
@@amandamiller6275
That was the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with 1200 of child hostages sitting around the bombs ! fsb group found the same school and were preparing all the variants of assaults, another fsb group conducted on-site reconnaissance through ventilation and other available options while police was negotiating with terrorists! But at one moment people heard explosion in school and armed parents just rushed there, so thats how they had to start! that is success they saved so many people, 900 saved to be exact! 15 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body to save children! rpgs were shot by terrorist! No flamethrowers were used! 1 tank shell was shot when hostages were saved and some terrorist barricaded in class!
Same as saying america failed on 9.11
it did though?
The most successful anti-terrorist operations are the ones you will never hear about. My respect to FSB.
like ukraine LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOO LOLOLOLLL FAILED...
Sadly u will not reply cuz my lil kili blyat is dead in ukraine
Usa: “Stop resisting”
Russia: “stop existing”
Somewhat true😂
This joke made my day.
Operation might have been a clusterfuck on behalf of the Russian Government but real heroes were the FSB and Spetsnaz forces who gave their lives in the siege. Peace to the fallen 🇷🇺
I Can remeber watching this on this news, it struck deep as it was my nephews first day of nursery, the thought of these poor children and the adults too being so scared not knowing what was going on. To then after all that time being held to still be killed,the news feeds were beyond heartbreaking.
Beslan is so very far away from my small welsh coal mining village but those children are forever etched on my heart and the sorrow of the families left behind.
What about the carpet bombing and virtual flattening of Grozy that happened a full 10 years before? Or did that not make it to world headlines?
Yeah sounded horrible. They were all hungry and so terribly thirsty. 3 long days in a sweltering hot gymnasium no food or water.
I absolutely agree - this is a tragedy I find particularly hard to emotionally process.
Is this the school where the child fell out of a window and then climbed back in? I have NEVER been able to get that image out of my head.
Welldone ro russian soldiers you shown true courage and bravery
@SPECIAL RECONNAISSANCE REGIMENT No they didn't why would you think that happend. You are just saying bullshit man. Many russian soldiers sacrificed their lives for the children yet you disrespect them.
If further research were to be done, people would find how there was literally little to do in order to combat this situation. The terrorists had no remorse for killing the hostages and took no negotiations at all. Maybe something could've been done but in reality it probably would've went down this same path.
how the fuck can you side with someone who takes a hospital hostage??? jesus christ!!!.
Well done the BBC. This is the worst comment section I have ever read on TH-cam. That is some achievement.
Don't pay your license fee fellow Brits🇬🇧🏴
is this not the worst thing that has happened in modern history?
many aren't even aware that this happened, but of course the narrative provided by the bbc is that it was 'the russians'
RIP to all that lost their lives, this is truly horrifying to me
The holocaust
I remember hearing about this when I was little. It was so sad.
1:24 no sign of medical teams or ambulances. 1:33 Ambulance vehicle
well spotted!!!!
southsidesancho its police. in russian "milicija"
southsidesancho , its not ambulance, its police ( i am from Russia)
Itis written MILITZIJA. That is not an ambulance. Anyway. Perhaps they shoould have sent the MEDICS to kill the terrorists..
@@user-up1vn9ls4f Why did this happen?
I'm asking you as your Russian.
I have knowledge on Dunblane school shooting in Scotland, where I'm from.
🤬 ME!
How am I just now learning of this?!
God Bless all the victims and heroes.
Whats the purpose of posting it? It happened a decade ago. What are you trying to justify to your subscriber? Hey stop posting negativity about russia
yes technically law enforcement didn't do as well as they should/could have, but I'm reasonably certain a country who protests knives isn't really one to be the one to point that kind of a finger.
dont listen to bbc sh1t! That was the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with 1200 of child hostages sitting around the bombs ! fsb group found the same school and were preparing all the variants of assaults, another fsb group conducted on-site reconnaissance through ventilation and other available options while police was negotiating with terrorists! But at one moment people heard explosion in school and armed parents just rushed there, so thats how they had to start! that is success they saved so many people, 900 saved to be exact! 15 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body to save children! rpgs were shot by terrorist! No flamethrowers were used! 1 tank shell was shot when hostages were saved and some terrorist barricaded in class!
Long live Russia. Once again you'll see glorious days. Your Indian friend.
@@therealchen What even is your stand on the situation. I feel like u have something against russia
@@alexwatson4263 he does, he's been posting this type of stuff in a lot of comments defending russia. just another neckbeard Texan that watched too much fox news, don't mind him
@@therealchen Indians comment this type of shit 🤣
BCC is awful. You guys call this journalism? I'm unsubscribing.
WOW! You really put a dent in the BBC, keyboard warrior!
Honestly, in this case it is so incredibly difficult to storm something like this and come up with very few civilian casualties. Just like the Dubrovka theatre disaster, the hostages were right next the heavily armed terrorists with explosives right next to them. Unlike the situation where GIGN stormed a plane, taking 0 non-terrorist casualties. They were able to do that because the hostages were seperated from the terrorists. This is completely different. they had no choice
They did had a choice, the chechens offered the release of hostages if Russians withdrew from chechnya, three calls were made, and in the last one, Russian command said we won't attack, and minutes later spetsnaz attacked.
Seems like the Russians don't care about their own civilians.
I'm crying this is so sad
They don't use the word "terrorists", just rebels...
They fired shells tank rounds flamethrowers as there were still hostages.
May their souls find peace and rest..🙏..
For America: Children dead
For Russia: Russian police failed to do their job.
Wouldn’t say “failed”, how else are you supposed to solve the situation when negotiations are impossible and the problem at hand is 1100 hostages over a large school. It would be more accurate to say the Russian government failed
good that they are not killing the living attacker. he gets to suffer just as the people they took hostage did.
334 not 330 and 783 injured
Ббс про провалы лучше молчать, или лучше напомнить за башни близнецы?
FAILED !! wtf
those soliders fought more bavery than our americans did in afghanistan
Only a life sentence for attacking the school ? Death penalty torture Let parents interrogate the son of b** so he can the same story over & over
This is the deadliest school shooting in history
Shame on you BBC for your biased reporting . Even shame will die of shame.
Russians killed majority of the dead hostages. You are biased for supporting a regime which fired rockets and tank rounds at a school full of children.
@@visluxman2012
dont listen to bbc sh1t! That was the unique hostage situations nobody seen before! 32 terrorist, barricaded and fully mined school with 1200 of child hostages sitting around the bombs ! fsb group found the same school and were preparing all the variants of assaults, another fsb group conducted on-site reconnaissance through ventilation and other available options while police was negotiating with terrorists! But at one moment people heard explosion in school and armed parents just rushed there, so thats how they had to start! that is success they saved so many people, 900 saved to be exact! 15 soldiers died and two of them gave they life covering grenades with their body to save children! rpgs were shot by terrorist! No flamethrowers were used! 1 tank shell was shot when hostages were saved and some terrorist barricaded in class!
Rebels???
A glimpse into a real incidents as opposed to the Las Vegas thing
Britain failed at not becoming a Pakistani Bangladeshi colony. Most common British name - Mohhamed
BBC has no shame.
Failed my god bbc disgusting
what game is this
I don’t blame the faith for the bad things that people do. I just blame the people.
let's see the West try and solve a similar situation.
iran embassy siege
@@lil_693 that one was more tame.
@@lil_693we’re talking about 1100 hostages in a large school
Loughgall Ambush was a massacre and failure.
Operation Barras was a failure.
kettle pot springs to mind
21 times confirmation why?
In Russia if someone runs into ur school with LMG It must be joke
I also like it how she claims, "there is no ambulance or medical team waiting to help" then the next few scenes you see an ambulance waiting. I remember this event live and saw plenty of medical support waiting. Was there enough? No, I don't think that place could predict such a big event happening and realistically afford such a huge medical crew on immediate stand by for a huge crisis. They had to respond to what they had.
it wasn't an ambulance car, but "milicija".
they also forgot to mention that civilians were using their cars as ambulances, and if nothing was available, people held their family as they ran to the hospital
One of the worst channels
In Pakistan also some terrorist attacked school in 2014 16 dec many childern died thats so sad to hear it happened in russia also 😭😭
Didn't they hang out the Gun Buster sign??
What could you of done hundred of hostage u can’t just shoot the building
and they didnt! thats bbc bs!
ok big brother corp. If you say so.
This is a very sensitive topic. If i was in any parent's place in that situation and i lost my child i'd probably find the government guilty too. But there is the other side of the coin. If politicians agreed to the terms it'll be like offering the country on a silver plating to anyone who wants something. Basically Russia would've become US with lots and lots and lots of random gunfights and mass shootings.
What the truth is inappropriate and offensive? I wish that everyone would agree taking guns into schools is inappropriate and offensive, telling the truth no matter how hard is not offensive or inappropriate, ever.
point of the story don't ever trust islam
Point of the story - don't trust Russia with hostage negotiations and response
... and BBC fails almost every day :-)
Why isn't this crisis talked about as much as it should?
Probably cause it’s not in the USA
They used thermobaric weapons.... THEY USED THERMOBARIC WEAPONS IN A HOSTAGE SITUATION.
I remember In the end,100 of armed civilians rush into the school to save their children ,that’s totally Russian style...
Yea lmao XD, the parents rushed the school
that'd happen in every country
And history repeats itself in Texas
Two extremely different cases
At least those pesky Russians tried. Can’t say the same for Uvalde PD
The world needs a peaceful restart and a future based on international law and revision over the last fifty years. The people's suspicion in international courts, law and their intentions has been established.
I'm crying inside