Tamal and team, thank you for your impartial and objective reporting. It's a refreshing change from the sensationalist news channels that prioritize TRP. While we have reliable national channels for unbiased news, you're the first in Bengal to offer such quality reporting. I hope to see more unbiased journalists emerge from Bengal in the future. Before discovering your channel during the Jadavpur case, I relied solely on print media for Bengal-related news. Now, I trust your channel as a valuable source of information. Best wishes for your future endeavors, onward and upward.
There are videos where the parents were crying as the body was taken away with their knowledge. The local netas took the body to the crematorium and themselves signed the papers. The parents we later brought and last rites were made to carry out
Group rape or single man rape, when there are no evidences I think from the wounds and torture the judges sometimes need to use their damn commonsense to look at cases logically! One person can't make a girl suffer till like dis.
I just love this channel. I am from South Africa and have been ffg Tamal and subscribed this channel immediately when I saw him reporting on the ground from inception, when this ghastly deed was done. I remember watching a video where it was in the wee hours of the morning, in the rain, without food. He covered this story very very well , he did a brilliant job in this video also. I echo his sentiments also in this video. Keep shining Mr Tamal. Your English is superb. Blessings from South Africa
Why destruction of vital evidence??? Why were goons sent on 14th August to the hospital?? Why was the body cremated in a hurry??? You need to find answers these questions. CBI has to look at all angle and possibilities now.
It's common sense to know that the principal has a hand in covering up . Pls don't try to excuse culprits with ur indian Oxford law English. Simplicity opens eyes
Well stringent punishment to the accused will lead to chain of cases like this to be checked and the culprit be punished since in most cases the politicians are also involved too and did we hear any politician got hanged. ITS TIME FOR US TO THINK rather believing blindly a political party because none is CLEAN in the political mess in this country.
There shld be higher punishment for destroying evidence How can such brutal murder happen and no one has a clue till morning this seems such nonsense happening
CBI have provided its report to Supreme court, and they seem to satisfied with that. The court seem to suggest, that some facts need to kept away from public domain in the interest of the case.
Rape yes to camouflage. I think motive must be different. Why rape and murder even after visiting red light area. Not satisfactory with investigation. Is there something behind.
I don't think OC Tala had any ulterior motive. What was the permanent police picket at RG Kar doing?. The picket duty personnel should have cordoned the crime scene. How can the OC do so who is located at the PS. CBI is simply beating around the bush. Abhijit Mondal is being made the scapegoat. The success rate of CBI is very very low.
Nobody can find out the truth if all evidences destroyed. Body cremated, building demolished, autopsy doubtful. State government committed all the crimes. Totally erased all the evidences. And gleefully handed over this case to. CBI & watch. Nobody even Scotland yard not find anything.
Tamal , I am called in neighbourhood on occasions to confirm if patient is dead. I examine : Pupillary reaction to light Then pulse at various points Then I hear heart & breath sounds Even if I make out that death has taken place, I ask for ecg in a near by hospital. Only then can death be declared. The exact time of death can be found at autopsy only, unless patient dies in hospital.
The renovation of the buildings is the main reason to wash away all the prints that has been taken out otherwise they are captured in the location so remember these are the evidence to proof the real siiuation that had happened to the lady doctor .
Why did police put pressure on parents to cremate the body so fast? Why didn't they allow parents to do that when it was suitable for them to do so? Bloody rascals.
Hi, Well think about it...top guys were involved with this rape and death...maybe he was part of that group the prev night , Could the commisioner be part of that night??? Something maybe they should look into his whereabouts that night
CJI said to Advocate Edulji that the CBI status report is worse than what he thinks about tampering, the CBI findings are very very disturbing. Tamal Saha is focussing on whether it was rape or gangrape. The number of views says everything. He is a covert "Chatichata" , now a very popular Bengali acronym which means sycophant or stooge of ruling party.
Irrespective of what the status report to SC contained and what the Hon'ble SC commented thereon ,what investigation did the CBI do during this 40 odd days except harping that the evidence was tampered ? 39:29 It took more than 20 days to decide to send samples to Delhi for second opinion. and more than 30 days to obtain dental impressions of the main accused. It is still working on the call records of the suspects It has not yet reached any conclusion about the number of active criminals :one or many . It did not even occur to them that how can one criminal of the lean physique of Sanjoy Ro could single-handedly subdue and inflict that much bodily harm on the victim without giving her an opportunity to escape or raise an alarm It spent a whole 15 days interrogating Sanjoy Ghosh giving priority to corruption charges instead of criminal charges It did not even question the Kol PC , the main target of the junior doctors. It did not even summon thr CM to ask why she appointed Sanjoy Ghosh as the principal of NMCH within 3 hours of his resignation from RG Kar All this delay when a full team including two joint directors has been fully assigned exclusively for this case only Even the agitating junior doctors have chosen to ignore this strange inaction of CBI .And the mainstream tv channels are engaged 24×7 in running meaningless debates and discussions and making easy money
@@Nonamettt7 Evidence is the result of proper investigation. And culprit can be nabbed when evidence is gathered. The pace at which the CBI is proceeding , it will take a long, long time to unravel the mystery The grounds on which the Tala thana OC was arrested were there from the very first day But it took more than 30.days for the CBI to arrest him.But strangely nobody not even the doctors or the courts are asking them in this regard
The Judge in power of authority for Laws and order, so what evidence is required for a case of the crime commit to deliver in a court of law for Public justices by Attorneys of Laws but because they victims are locally people and the perpetrators are authority control goons and hooligan to be protected from being exposed to the families and friends of demise of the Doctor claims suicide when it was a case of rape and murder. The administration for the People Democrats rights now revealing that the crime commit and enquiries about who are involved, where, when, why, and how must be clandestinely.
Everything said by KP is true according to you😂and blaming the victim's family who lost their only daughter for ' different narratives' is the lowest your 'journalism' can stoop to
Victim's family is not an expert. It was clear with the DNA report that there was only one rapist i.e. Sanjoy Roy. But due to fake propaganda and misinformation spread by political vultures regarding the incident some where convinced the family to believe that it's a gang-rape and Kolkata police is trying to hide something.
I am afraid either you do not understand English or making comments on pre-conceived notions .The journalist was just explaining the facts. based on documents submitted by the CBI to the Sealdah Court.And he was questioning the delay on the part of the CBI in arresting the Tala thana OC. In the 49 min long video at what point did he blame the victim ' s family ? Please specify the video time
He is just defending the ruling party and police from day one. In one of the initial videos he tried to prove that the Kolkata police had no fault, and now we all know the real fact. Even the Supreme Court reprimanded.
Bro, I really appreciate you for your❤ excellent brief and clean clear explanation on remand note.... We all hope for the Justice.
It's true we all want justice God is there
CBI needs to also check the car of the victim that was destroyed. Hopefully they may get some leads.
Tamal and team, thank you for your impartial and objective reporting. It's a refreshing change from the sensationalist news channels that prioritize TRP. While we have reliable national channels for unbiased news, you're the first in Bengal to offer such quality reporting. I hope to see more unbiased journalists emerge from Bengal in the future.
Before discovering your channel during the Jadavpur case, I relied solely on print media for Bengal-related news. Now, I trust your channel as a valuable source of information. Best wishes for your future endeavors, onward and upward.
Yes, this channel gives impartial, quality information, and refreshing because of no loud and strident sensationalisation.
There are videos where the parents were crying as the body was taken away with their knowledge. The local netas took the body to the crematorium and themselves signed the papers. The parents we later brought and last rites were made to carry out
Excellent presentationn..
Group rape or single man rape, when there are no evidences I think from the wounds and torture the judges sometimes need to use their damn commonsense to look at cases logically! One person can't make a girl suffer till like dis.
Vary well explained. We just pray that the truth triumphs
I just love this channel. I am from South Africa and have been ffg Tamal and subscribed this channel immediately when I saw him reporting on the ground from inception, when this ghastly deed was done. I remember watching a video where it was in the wee hours of the morning, in the rain, without food. He covered this story very very well , he did a brilliant job in this video also. I echo his sentiments also in this video. Keep shining Mr Tamal. Your English is superb. Blessings from South Africa
❤
Why destruction of vital evidence???
Why were goons sent on 14th August to the hospital??
Why was the body cremated in a hurry???
You need to find answers these questions.
CBI has to look at all angle and possibilities now.
Sanjib Ghosh is the main culprit ,what do you think when he tried to cover up everything.
I agree with you
Find the evidence that local nata signed the death certificate. Not the parents.
It's common sense to know that the principal has a hand in covering up . Pls don't try to excuse culprits with ur indian Oxford law English. Simplicity opens eyes
I agree with you
Gosh probably told him to cover-up and he will give him some money.
Very good reporting Tamal! With God on our side, the truth will prevail.
How can police be sure the victim was unconscious and not napping?
What about other 5 culprit Doctors they are free a what???
Boss FIR should launch before postmortem
Well stringent punishment to the accused will lead to chain of cases like this to be checked and the culprit be punished since in most cases the politicians are also involved too and did we hear any politician got hanged.
ITS TIME FOR US TO THINK
rather believing blindly a political party because none is CLEAN in the political mess in this country.
There shld be higher punishment for destroying evidence
How can such brutal murder happen and no one has a clue till morning this seems such nonsense happening
Absolute clear analysis
CBI have provided its report to Supreme court, and they seem to satisfied with that. The court seem to suggest, that some facts need to kept away from public domain in the interest of the case.
Crime is not committed by Sanjay Roy. Everyone can clearly see d whole picture yet experts like CBI taking so long to come to conclusions. Sad
the poligraph should be test to the confidence hospital
where are the bollywood actor who fight for the murder of sushant right
Sir, weather it's raped or gangrape, it's raped, so we need only justice.. Thats all
Rape yes to camouflage. I think motive must be different. Why rape and murder even after visiting red light area. Not satisfactory with investigation. Is there something behind.
Judge is bought over! Shame
I don't think OC Tala had any ulterior motive. What was the permanent police picket at RG Kar doing?. The picket duty personnel should have cordoned the crime scene. How can the OC do so who is located at the PS. CBI is simply beating around the bush. Abhijit Mondal is being made the scapegoat. The success rate of CBI is very very low.
Nobody can find out the truth if all evidences destroyed. Body cremated, building demolished, autopsy doubtful. State government committed all the crimes. Totally erased all the evidences. And gleefully handed over this case to. CBI & watch. Nobody even Scotland yard not find anything.
Nicely questioned
Fairly informed without making it sensational.
We want justice
Tamal , I am called in neighbourhood on occasions to confirm if patient is dead. I examine :
Pupillary reaction to light
Then pulse at various points
Then I hear heart & breath sounds
Even if I make out that death has taken place, I ask for ecg in a near by hospital. Only then can death be declared.
The exact time of death can be found at autopsy only, unless patient dies in hospital.
414141 DAYS. HOW MANY TIMES
What more evidence more you needed when the young doctor was indeed rape and murdered.
The renovation of the buildings is the main reason to wash away all the prints that has been taken out otherwise they are captured in the location so remember these are the evidence to proof the real siiuation that had happened to the lady doctor .
Free the symtem of mafias
You can keep both of them in your house
Unsubscribed sir thank you for such great reporting.
Why did police put pressure on parents to cremate the body so fast? Why didn't they allow parents to do that when it was suitable for them to do so? Bloody rascals.
To destroy the evidence
But the body was death at around ,5. a.m . Who the hell said the wrong information !?
So what OC should have to Cordon off the area immediately after his first visit at crime area
How can Sandip Ghosh be the Head Principal. Are there many Principals which he heads. Laugh
able.
WHEN SHE DIED , THE IST ? CAN ANYBODY ANSWER ? INVESTIGATION IS NOT DONE SINCERELY.
Only the truth can set u free to Sandip Sanjay mandil u can't hide the truth it shall find u out
Will justice be given soon?
HOW MANY TIMES WILL YOU REPEAT THE TITLE?!!
This was excruciating to listen to. Please, you don’t have to repeat every single line twice and then paraphrase it a third and a fourth time
You were an reporter some time ago do not get smart in this case remember murder can be conived by these people
No protocolin this hospiltal
That should read our instead of are
Hi, Well think about it...top guys were involved with this rape and death...maybe he was part of that group the prev night , Could the commisioner be part of that night??? Something maybe they should look into his whereabouts that night
You havent answered the caption of your video
You should be the spokesperson of TMC
CJI said to Advocate Edulji that the CBI status report is worse than what he thinks about tampering, the CBI findings are very very disturbing. Tamal Saha is focussing on whether it was rape or gangrape. The number of views says everything. He is a covert "Chatichata" , now a very popular Bengali acronym which means sycophant or stooge of ruling party.
Irrespective of what the status report to SC contained and what the Hon'ble SC commented thereon ,what investigation did the CBI do during this 40 odd days except harping that the evidence was tampered ? 39:29 It took more than 20 days to decide to send samples to Delhi for second opinion. and more than 30 days to obtain dental impressions of the main accused. It is still working on the call records of the suspects It has not yet reached any conclusion about the number of active criminals :one or many . It did not even occur to them that how can one criminal of the lean physique of Sanjoy Ro could single-handedly subdue and inflict that much bodily harm on the victim without giving her an opportunity to escape or raise an alarm It spent a whole 15 days interrogating Sanjoy Ghosh giving priority to corruption charges instead of criminal charges It did not even question the Kol PC , the main target of the junior doctors. It did not even summon thr CM to ask why she appointed Sanjoy Ghosh as the principal of NMCH within 3 hours of his resignation from RG Kar All this delay when a full team including two joint directors has been fully assigned exclusively for this case only Even the agitating junior doctors have chosen to ignore this strange inaction of CBI .And the mainstream tv channels are engaged 24×7 in running meaningless debates and discussions and making easy money
You will
L be the next CP guaranteed
If you are saying that probe is not going in a proper way...then who according to you as per the evidences , so called evidences left is the culprit?
@@Nonamettt7 Evidence is the result of proper investigation. And culprit can be nabbed when evidence is gathered. The pace at which the CBI is proceeding , it will take a long, long time to unravel the mystery The grounds on which the Tala thana OC was arrested were there from the very first day But it took more than 30.days for the CBI to arrest him.But strangely nobody not even the doctors or the courts are asking them in this regard
The Judge in power of authority for Laws and order, so what evidence is required for a case of the crime commit to deliver in a court of law for Public justices by Attorneys of Laws but because they victims are locally people and the perpetrators are authority control goons and hooligan to be protected from being exposed to the families and friends of demise of the Doctor claims suicide when it was a case of rape and murder. The administration for the People Democrats rights now revealing that the crime commit and enquiries about who are involved, where, when, why, and how must be clandestinely.
Chor ka bara sor
Everything said by KP is true according to you😂and blaming the victim's family who lost their only daughter for ' different narratives' is the lowest your 'journalism' can stoop to
Victim's family is not an expert. It was clear with the DNA report that there was only one rapist i.e. Sanjoy Roy. But due to fake propaganda and misinformation spread by political vultures regarding the incident some where convinced the family to believe that it's a gang-rape and Kolkata police is trying to hide something.
I am afraid either you do not understand English or making comments on pre-conceived notions .The journalist was just explaining the facts. based on documents submitted by the CBI to the Sealdah Court.And he was questioning the delay on the part of the CBI in arresting the Tala thana OC. In the 49 min long video at what point did he blame the victim ' s family ? Please specify the video time
Pls watch the news again. Some people don't understand facts and want to listen to what they believe. He is just explaining what the CBI said to SC.
He is just defending the ruling party and police from day one. In one of the initial videos he tried to prove that the Kolkata police had no fault, and now we all know the real fact. Even the Supreme Court reprimanded.
Great better then CBI,all we want a Justice to Moumita
Plz don't use victim's real name. Even the Supreme court has passed and order on this.