Highly recommend to add features such as limit order/stop loss/take profit. Or else it is very unintuitive to use as an simulation trading experience because practical trading would require things like that.
This is a decent start. However, as others have said, you REALLY need: - automatic stop loss / take profit - buy/sell multiple units Otherwise, the usefulness of this feature is minimal.
This is awesome! A much-awaited feature. It would be great if it had a limit price feature for buy and sell. Now the position can only close after the candle is closed. If it is a big candle, it can take away all the profit. Hopefully, this option will be added soon. Thank you.
We'll share this with the team. We also have some updates coming in 2023. Stay tuned! Lastly, we'll create another video that goes deeper into our planned updates. Please keep sharing feedback here.
Can we trade 1 minute and 5 minutes of historic data ? earlier it was only available till last 45 days on bar reply.. Thats the reason i did unsubscribe from the annually subscription.
Great .. Are you gonna develope it more in the future ?? such as the Buy & Sell orders , they can be taken with more that one share like the normal market order ... also , repalying more than one timeframe in the same time ( simultaneously ) such as ( 1 Min , 5 Min & 15 Min )
So cool you implemented this feature (but yeah don't forget people with your brokers you must take account spreads too when will really trading, so choose much lower spreads broker), thank you will test it today!
@@TradingView - excellent! (since it's kinda useless without it because it doesn't reflect real-world triggers). Also, instead of hitting Buy/Sell 10 times for 10 contracts (Ex. Futures), maybe the normal text box where I can add how many contracts/shares I'd like to jump in with when I press the button. Pretty cool otherwise!
Great feature, but as others have said, it should really be integrated with proper SL/TP features. Also, I suggest adding a feature to right-click any bar and select "reply from here" to start replay.
I am in doubt if the mid bar updates in the replay are realistic. As the new bar is drawn I see that it draws the high and low of the bar in terms of wicks. I tried finding a bar that realistically closed beyond the initially drawn high and low and I couldn't. I really would like to be mistaken on this but it seems like you can cheat it because you can guess whether the price will move towards the ends of the wick. -I am using 15 min - 1hour chart replays -I tried other timeframes 4h, 1D, only in 1 week chart the mid bar updates look realistic. I tried more and on the lower time frames once you see a big doji bar with long wicks/tails for example if the price if the price is close to the bottom you can cheat by betting on that the price will close higher near the wick high. Vice versa if the doji has a big wick at the bottom you can bet the price is going down because the high/low of the bar is shown to you before hand. In programming terms this could have been done a lot better.
Before finishing the video and reading any comments I was thinking where are the Buy/Sell position sizing % risk control and other important order types for actual trading? Still using MT4 but checking out TV for simulated trading, needs more sauce imho.
Amazing feature and tutorial. Is there a way to show charts hourly by perfect hour increment such as 10:00 am, 11:00 am, 12:00 pm, 1:00pm and so forth. Currently shows mid-hours 9:30, 10:30, 11:30 and so forth 🙏🏼
You can use compare option. The bar replay is available on compare symbol(New pane option). But the problem is that you cannot have indicators on the second symbol.
How to change the label of a position from the center of the screen? Why open position label is in the center of the screen? How to move it to the left or to the right? I have searched everywhere in the sitings and I didn't find it even with AI. HELP!!!!
@3:59 what if I want to sell at the highest point? You are only able to close the trade when the candle is closed. Seem like this example is good but then technically this feature is not that good.
Amazing feature! Any chance of y’all adding the ability to buy/sell multiple units? I’d like to simulate buying multiple contracts with different take profit levels). Right now you can achieve it by hitting the buy/sell button multiple times, but each trade shows up separately on the chart instead of as one order and that gets messy. Stoked about this regardless 🎉🎉
Yes we have several updates planned! Stay tuned. In addition, we have some new videos being recorded to help show new features and tools similar to this.
Please add a feature where the replay happens on multiple time frame charts at the same time.... i would like to see the 5min and 30min chart at the same time during replay.
how can i stop the candle jumping ahead in high timeframe when switched from lower timeframe for example 5mins to higher timeframe like 1hr. it always makes me cheat.
You should add settings for the buy/sell font size and arrows. They are too big when using it on 1 min. chart making very difficult to see details and read the chart.
wish there was an auto enter sl and tp for set it and forget it type of trades with no emotion eg enter 20k account risk 1% (200) sl 1% then when it wins it then ajust the % based on new account size so next trade will be a potenial 220 win or 220 loss
Hello friends, I have a question and it is that I have a premium account, but I also want to have a second premium with another email of mine using the same credit card? Is that possible without breaking any tradingview rules?
How can I publish chart video in tradingview mobile. Like the desktop version the publish button won't show recording video on mobile, even after using the desktop site on many browsers. I don't have a PC, I want it on an Android phone.
Seemingly no way to connect alerts to the buy and sell buttons. Which would not be so annoying if you could rewind to place the order where the alert would have happened (without erasing P/L)
Hi, thanks for the new nice feature releasing, it is helpful in most of the time. However, the "request security" malfunctions in the bar replaying mode for some symbol. 1. In normal mode, if we request a value from a realtime bar of a larger timeframe, we get the latest update value in that realtime bar. 2. In bar replaying mode, if we request a value from a "simulated realtime bar" , we will get latest update value in the "realistic realtime bar". For example: I am in a replaying mode, the timeframe is 30m. The reality time is 2023/3/31 and I have traveled backward to 2023/1/1 10:30 am (the simulated realtime bar). My indicator is requesting a "close" from the M(month) timeframe. Guess what? I get the latest close value of 2023/3/31(the realistic realtime bar of M-timeframe), instead of 2023/1/31. Such arrangement make my indicator have the ability to "foresee" the future in that bar replaying mode (I saw the value of 3/31 when it was 1/1). I was very excited for the performance until I find a different story in the strategy test result.🤣😅
Hey great feature is there a way or a button not to show the chart before you start. I would like to blindly back test but I don’t want to see the chart before I start. If I pick February 3, 1993 i don’t want to see anything after that date. The problem I have with back testing is seeing the whole chart. It ruins the experience. Please let me know when this is available and I’m all in. Thanks so much. I’m pretty sure it’s an easy fix to have a “Ghost mode chart” name it after me. Dunlap’s Ghost Mode chart. 😊 Or make a indicator that can do this. Thanks in advance
Go to chart settings, uncheck the 3 boxes for the candles, now you see nothing, then pick your date you want to start from, hit the replay button and go to where you want to start, not settings and check all the candle boxes. Unless you are far to the right of the chart where you want to start you will still see a few candles.
When this stop loss/take profit functionality is coming? That has been already more than 6 months since your last status update in the comment-section!!
This is a great help for backtesting! But when I am in a Currency Chart, it always sets the Profit/Loss to the Quote Currency of the Chart I am in. How can I set it permanently to USD?
@mmx8988 I use dedicated softwares these days for backtesting. With that said, last time I checked, you can only add TP and SL after you entered the trade. Not great, but better than what I thought the case was.
This feature is here! We'll make sure to rearrange our newest videos so that you can see it. We've uploaded many new videos since this one and shows you all the tools you have.
your Bar replay it is useles because you cant change from lower temporality to higher temporality without seeing the future , IE i am in 15 M timeframe and I want to see 4H but as soon as I change I see the full 4H candle showing me the result of the future result of the last 8 15M canldles,, other problem is I change temporality M1 and it just send you to present time .... useless software that cant properly let you bactesting , i dont know why I even paid a whole year for it
I think its cool initially but lot of work to be done....u can check soft4fx which provide many features and give real time condition to bactest your strategy in forex
Highly recommend to add features such as limit order/stop loss/take profit. Or else it is very unintuitive to use as an simulation trading experience because practical trading would require things like that.
Yes these are crucial to testing
I would add also the ability for stops with reversal
Yes we need limit buy order
yes without its very stupid
if they added all of them, then fxreplay will bankrupt ahahhaha
This is a decent start. However, as others have said, you REALLY need:
- automatic stop loss / take profit
- buy/sell multiple units
Otherwise, the usefulness of this feature is minimal.
Using Bar Replay in conjunction with the Long Position/Short Position tools is pretty helpful as well. Cheers 🍻
Thanks for sharing!
This is awesome! A much-awaited feature. It would be great if it had a limit price feature for buy and sell. Now the position can only close after the candle is closed. If it is a big candle, it can take away all the profit. Hopefully, this option will be added soon. Thank you.
We'll share this with the team. We also have some updates coming in 2023. Stay tuned! Lastly, we'll create another video that goes deeper into our planned updates. Please keep sharing feedback here.
@@TradingView When will be the video released?
@@TradingView CAN WE MAKE MONEY FROM REPLAY METHOD PLEASE TELL
@@DanishRaza-vv7sw 😅you can't, it's for practicing
Can we trade 1 minute and 5 minutes of historic data ? earlier it was only available till last 45 days on bar reply..
Thats the reason i did unsubscribe from the annually subscription.
Tradingview, you guys are the best!!!!!
We'll plan more videos like this! Glad it helped.
Great .. Are you gonna develope it more in the future ?? such as the Buy & Sell orders , they can be taken with more that one share like the normal market order ... also , repalying more than one timeframe in the same time ( simultaneously ) such as ( 1 Min , 5 Min & 15 Min )
So cool you implemented this feature (but yeah don't forget people with your brokers you must take account spreads too when will really trading, so choose much lower spreads broker), thank you will test it today!
Best explanation ever THANKS!!!
Really difficult switching between time frames
Highly recommend to add features such as limit order/stop loss/take profit.
Our team is working on some new features for this tool! Stay tuned
@@TradingView - excellent! (since it's kinda useless without it because it doesn't reflect real-world triggers). Also, instead of hitting Buy/Sell 10 times for 10 contracts (Ex. Futures), maybe the normal text box where I can add how many contracts/shares I'd like to jump in with when I press the button.
Pretty cool otherwise!
Great feature, but as others have said, it should really be integrated with proper SL/TP features.
Also, I suggest adding a feature to right-click any bar and select "reply from here" to start replay.
Outstanding! Thank you!
❤❤❤
I am in doubt if the mid bar updates in the replay are realistic. As the new bar is drawn I see that it draws the high and low of the bar in terms of wicks. I tried finding a bar that realistically closed beyond the initially drawn high and low and I couldn't. I really would like to be mistaken on this but it seems like you can cheat it because you can guess whether the price will move towards the ends of the wick.
-I am using 15 min - 1hour chart replays
-I tried other timeframes 4h, 1D, only in 1 week chart the mid bar updates look realistic. I tried more and on the lower time frames once you see a big doji bar with long wicks/tails for example if the price if the price is close to the bottom you can cheat by betting on that the price will close higher near the wick high. Vice versa if the doji has a big wick at the bottom you can bet the price is going down because the high/low of the bar is shown to you before hand.
In programming terms this could have been done a lot better.
Before finishing the video and reading any comments I was thinking where are the Buy/Sell position sizing % risk control and other important order types for actual trading?
Still using MT4 but checking out TV for simulated trading, needs more sauce imho.
Great Feature. Thank you
And more updates coming to it soon! Stay tuned.
@@TradingView when is it coming?
Absolutely great feature. It would be even better if I could set OCO/bracket orders. I like to trade an entire week. Also add leverage for futures.
How can we remove buy/sell labels from bar replay mode/? It’s really irritating and blocks candles…
Please answer to this
Please answer to this
This is a great feature
🎉🎉🎉
I’m trying to use the bar replay but I can’t see the scissors icon when trying to cut back the graf
How can I put the execution tab in the long & short projection tool?
Is this amazing feature available on the mobile application basic plan? Thank you.
Amazing feature and tutorial. Is there a way to show charts hourly by perfect hour increment such as 10:00 am, 11:00 am, 12:00 pm, 1:00pm and so forth. Currently shows mid-hours 9:30, 10:30, 11:30 and so forth 🙏🏼
Hello, I hope all is well. Can ya'll please make bar replay available for non traditional chart types (Heiken Ashi, Renko, Kagi, line break, etc.)?
very good thank you so much
Please, we really need the feature to be to backtesting with limit orders.
Great video.
I think tradingview should work towards more automation on paper trading just like FX replay has.
It'll be a greata addition i believe
Thanks for sharing
@@TradingView CAN WE MAKE MONEY FROM REPLAY METHOD PLEASE TELL
@@DanishRaza-vv7sw yes you can go back to 2011 then invest all your money in bitcoin and boom free millions
@@DanishRaza-vv7sw no bruh
Excellent!
Glad you liked it!
Great tutorial👍💯
are limit orders possible here
is the feature available in 5min chart?
If i have split chart, can i bar replay for those charts simultaneously? This is to understand the co relation. Kindly answer or add this feature.
that would be good actually
You can use compare option. The bar replay is available on compare symbol(New pane option). But the problem is that you cannot have indicators on the second symbol.
@@RahulANair thats a good thought, appreciate it.
What is the leverage used in bar replay?
Really useful tool! Thanks!
Glad it was helpful!
how can we buy/sell a specific dollar amount instead of 1 share?
Is there a way to replay at the actual speed? So I could actually “re-experience “ and not re-check.
How to change the label of a position from the center of the screen? Why open position label is in the center of the screen? How to move it to the left or to the right? I have searched everywhere in the sitings and I didn't find it even with AI. HELP!!!!
@3:59 what if I want to sell at the highest point? You are only able to close the trade when the candle is closed. Seem like this example is good but then technically this feature is not that good.
the paper trading account can still be connected to the bar replay
Well done..Ty
Hi , is there a functionality where we input our stop loss and profit targets that get executed? Thanks
Amazing feature! Any chance of y’all adding the ability to buy/sell multiple units? I’d like to simulate buying multiple contracts with different take profit levels). Right now you can achieve it by hitting the buy/sell button multiple times, but each trade shows up separately on the chart instead of as one order and that gets messy. Stoked about this regardless 🎉🎉
Yes we have several updates planned! Stay tuned. In addition, we have some new videos being recorded to help show new features and tools similar to this.
@@TradingView CAN WE MAKE MONEY FROM REPLAY METHOD PLEASE TELL
If i have split window on both NQ and ES, can I have both chart replay at the same time?
This reply mode should be free for new traders as they are getting scammed by repaint indicator’s 😢
no why to put a limit order in replay mode?
I liked that this instruction video did not make look like trading is easy 👍
Glad you liked it! But remember - trading is not easy! Look first.
Please add a feature where the replay happens on multiple time frame charts at the same time.... i would like to see the 5min and 30min chart at the same time during replay.
Our Bar Replay team has some great features coming. Stay tuned and subscribed here to see them
CAN YOU CHANGE THE QUANTITY ON THE PAPER TRADE WHILE USING BAR REPLAY
how can i stop the candle jumping ahead in high timeframe when switched from lower timeframe for example 5mins to higher timeframe like 1hr. it always makes me cheat.
You should add settings for the buy/sell font size and arrows. They are too big when using it on 1 min. chart making very difficult to see details and read the chart.
You can simply remove them
Please watch our newest video about this here: th-cam.com/video/_Lgh-5kD7tw/w-d-xo.html
Thank you
How do you change lot size? im trading forex and it only buys 1 lot
How can we acces the list of trades?
💥 Renko doesn't allow Bar Replay... why is that? Possibly because its not time based???
wish there was an auto enter sl and tp for set it and forget it type of trades with no emotion
eg enter 20k account
risk 1% (200)
sl 1%
then when it wins it then ajust the % based on new account size so next trade will be a potenial 220 win or 220 loss
Please watch our newest video about this here: th-cam.com/video/_Lgh-5kD7tw/w-d-xo.html
Hello friends, I have a question and it is that I have a premium account, but I also want to have a second premium with another email of mine using the same credit card?
Is that possible without breaking any tradingview rules?
How can I publish chart video in tradingview mobile. Like the desktop version the publish button won't show recording video on mobile, even after using the desktop site on many browsers. I don't have a PC, I want it on an Android phone.
Seemingly no way to connect alerts to the buy and sell buttons. Which would not be so annoying if you could rewind to place the order where the alert would have happened (without erasing P/L)
Please watch our newest video about this here: th-cam.com/video/_Lgh-5kD7tw/w-d-xo.html
Hi, thanks for the new nice feature releasing, it is helpful in most of the time. However, the "request security" malfunctions in the bar replaying mode for some symbol.
1. In normal mode, if we request a value from a realtime bar of a larger timeframe, we get the latest update value in that realtime bar.
2. In bar replaying mode, if we request a value from a "simulated realtime bar" , we will get latest update value in the "realistic realtime bar".
For example: I am in a replaying mode, the timeframe is 30m. The reality time is 2023/3/31 and I have traveled backward to 2023/1/1 10:30 am (the simulated realtime bar). My indicator is requesting a "close" from the M(month) timeframe. Guess what? I get the latest close value of 2023/3/31(the realistic realtime bar of M-timeframe), instead of 2023/1/31.
Such arrangement make my indicator have the ability to "foresee" the future in that bar replaying mode (I saw the value of 3/31 when it was 1/1). I was very excited for the performance until I find a different story in the strategy test result.🤣😅
Thank you for this feedback! We will share it with the team
Hey great feature is there a way or a button not to show the chart before you start. I would like to blindly back test but I don’t want to see the chart before I start. If I pick February 3, 1993 i don’t want to see anything after that date. The problem I have with back testing is seeing the whole chart. It ruins the experience. Please let me know when this is available and I’m all in. Thanks so much. I’m pretty sure it’s an easy fix to have a “Ghost mode chart” name it after me. Dunlap’s Ghost Mode chart. 😊 Or
make a indicator that can do this. Thanks in advance
Go to chart settings, uncheck the 3 boxes for the candles, now you see nothing, then pick your date you want to start from, hit the replay button and go to where you want to start, not settings and check all the candle boxes. Unless you are far to the right of the chart where you want to start you will still see a few candles.
Do I have to pay to get this feature?
Is this on free version
If i buy the essential plan
How far can i go back in time
With the inter
Intraday bars
Please add limit orders! Youll make a lot of money
King
When this stop loss/take profit functionality is coming? That has been already more than 6 months since your last status update in the comment-section!!
This is a great help for backtesting! But when I am in a Currency Chart, it always sets the Profit/Loss to the Quote Currency of the Chart I am in. How can I set it permanently to USD?
What is going on with the bar population? It does not reflect how the bar actually forms. Can anyone explain how they populate the bar during replay?
Cant do 1m chart though ☹️
some diamond hand member held CVNA til now
lol
Hey that's mine
I can don’t set a order ?
Please watch our newest video about this here: th-cam.com/video/_Lgh-5kD7tw/w-d-xo.html
I think you guys would have more subscribers if it had TP or SL.
It does
@mmx8988 I use dedicated softwares these days for backtesting. With that said, last time I checked, you can only add TP and SL after you entered the trade. Not great, but better than what I thought the case was.
This feature is here! We'll make sure to rearrange our newest videos so that you can see it. We've uploaded many new videos since this one and shows you all the tools you have.
I don't get your software at all. Its confusing
Can i make demo account in this website
Yes! We have Paper Trading accounts that can be opened to test strategies and trading styles.
0.1 is too fast to use on 1 min chart. Need slower speeds
❤️O 😘m 🙏 g 💯
Candle repainting needs to be better
I know I designed that
your Bar replay it is useles because you cant change from lower temporality to higher temporality without seeing the future , IE i am in 15 M timeframe and I want to see 4H but as soon as I change I see the full 4H candle showing me the result of the future result of the last 8 15M canldles,, other problem is I change temporality M1 and it just send you to present time .... useless software that cant properly let you bactesting , i dont know why I even paid a whole year for it
Spanish pleace
They want money for it lol
Make it free
I dine did this yall must be watching me on delta abs alpha hmmm well thars what you traders do.lil
I think its cool initially but lot of work to be done....u can check soft4fx which provide many features and give real time condition to bactest your strategy in forex