Bar Replay needs synchronization amongst time frames so that multiple time frames will play market action back simultaneously. This is such an essential feature to strategy development.
Either allow for limit / stop entry orders or allow us to edit the entry line to be more specific since the bar doesn't paint like in the live markets and only skips to the OHLC.
I love the tradingview app, but the mutli timeframe issue in the bar replay mode is really ruining my entire backtest. I really hate this situation. Please fix this.
@@TradingViewwhat other detail do you need. When you want to go back in time you can only do it on one chart and not the other while you have multiple charts on. We want multiple charts in sync so we can analyse between 2 or more charts at a certain date to practice and back test
We love hearing this feedback! It's why we put special emphasis into our TH-cam channel, creating educational content for all. Please make sure you're subscribed to get updates here on other features.
Would like if you could add such a feauture in replay where if we look at higher timeframes we can decided by how much should bars be updated. Meaning If i cut back to 31st Jan 9:00 clock and want to look at weekly timeframe, the chart should be what weekly chart was showing at 31st Jan 9:00 and not at the end of week. Like we should be able to choose by how much will price update. Helps for traders who use various timeframe for backtesting.
At what speed should i replay if i want to simulate the exact market timing of intraday charts? Like, if the market remains open for 5 hours in a day then the bar replay from first open candle till last close candle should also take 5 hours. I feel the need for this because replaying at higher speeds distorts our perception of time required for staying in the trade and this ruins our patience for playing in live market. Ideally there should be one option in the speed selection dropdown that says something like 'market time' which will replay bars accordingly e.g. 5 min bar will take 5 min to form, 15min bar will take 15min to form and so on. In a way replaying the recording of the entire market hours duration.
I was disappointed also that they didn't have the tick-by-tick replay. One important thing I need to practice is patience by observing the momentum (how fast, how slow) a candle is formed and this feature could help me a lot.
CanTradingView add a feature that randomizes a time a day to replay? If I see some of the prices and price action when I am moving the Select Bar, then I have a mental bias and idea of what the trade will do. As a user, I want replay to randomize a stock, date, time, and price. Thanks!
How do you get the replay bar to show the results on the screen as it did at minute 3:41. I've been clicking on everything and can't get that graphic to show up on my screen
I figured it out. If you let the replay finish, you'll get that splash screen. I don't think you can display it at will. I got a $19.75 profit with a 100% win rate. Woo Hoo! Great learning tool. Now I need to spend lots of time in this simulator so I don't crash the plane. TV is incredible software. My broker is currently Schwab, but after the hiccups they've had, I think I need to move on and perhaps get a broker that integrates with TV.
Please be sure to turn up your volume on your computer and using the youtube volume slider. We will also make adjustments on future videos. We may have to remake this one for that reason - stay subscribed to see our new videos!
Bar Replay needs synchronization amongst time frames so that multiple time frames will play market action back simultaneously. This is such an essential feature to strategy development.
Yes
absolutely agree
We are working on it and have many new releases in 2024! Please stay subscribed and we'll share a video of this tool as we improve it.
@@TradingViewwhen do you see these features being released?
@@TradingView was this a lie? 5 months In 2024…
Either allow for limit / stop entry orders or allow us to edit the entry line to be more specific since the bar doesn't paint like in the live markets and only skips to the OHLC.
Yes need limit order😢
Add
adding adjustable entry’s are crucial. How can sl and tp be adjustable but not entry? Makes no sense. Should be an easy fix
Please can you entry in bar replay limit buy order?
+
+
Bracket orders! We'll make a new video to really show everyone this.
@@TradingView LIMIT Order, The ability to set an entry price and let price action trade to a level and then trigger said trade.
Can you place entry limit / stop orders?
Yes need limit order
네 맞아요
+
exactly 👍
Love this tool for back testing
Glad you like it! More features coming in 2024. Stay subscribed
I love the tradingview app, but the mutli timeframe issue in the bar replay mode is really ruining my entire backtest. I really hate this situation. Please fix this.
Exactly same 💯💯💯💯
You would like to use bar replay on the multi-chart layout? Could you share a few more details so we can get this to the team?
@@TradingViewwhat other detail do you need. When you want to go back in time you can only do it on one chart and not the other while you have multiple charts on. We want multiple charts in sync so we can analyse between 2 or more charts at a certain date to practice and back test
Amazing thank you so much! wish I had realised you could do so much with the replay months ago.
We love hearing this feedback! It's why we put special emphasis into our TH-cam channel, creating educational content for all. Please make sure you're subscribed to get updates here on other features.
it would be great if one could save trades in paper trading and then export them and make statistical surveys of one's strategies
Would like if you could add such a feauture in replay where if we look at higher timeframes we can decided by how much should bars be updated. Meaning If i cut back to 31st Jan 9:00 clock and want to look at weekly timeframe, the chart should be what weekly chart was showing at 31st Jan 9:00 and not at the end of week. Like we should be able to choose by how much will price update. Helps for traders who use various timeframe for backtesting.
We will share this with the team!
Hi, Thanks for the video, great information, but the buy and sell does not work for me in bar replay mode. Please suggest a fix.
Thanks a lot for this information, I don’t know I could backtest like this with placing a buy or sell
Please add limit order in bar replay
Yes need add
At what speed should i replay if i want to simulate the exact market timing of intraday charts?
Like, if the market remains open for 5 hours in a day then the bar replay from first open candle till last close candle should also take 5 hours. I feel the need for this because replaying at higher speeds distorts our perception of time required for staying in the trade and this ruins our patience for playing in live market.
Ideally there should be one option in the speed selection dropdown that says something like 'market time' which will replay bars accordingly e.g. 5 min bar will take 5 min to form, 15min bar will take 15min to form and so on. In a way replaying the recording of the entire market hours duration.
I was disappointed also that they didn't have the tick-by-tick replay. One important thing I need to practice is patience by observing the momentum (how fast, how slow) a candle is formed and this feature could help me a lot.
@@nikosp3156 same here
CanTradingView add a feature that randomizes a time a day to replay? If I see some of the prices and price action when I am moving the Select Bar, then I have a mental bias and idea of what the trade will do. As a user, I want replay to randomize a stock, date, time, and price. Thanks!
Can move the sell and buy bottom on the right bottom corner while trade live trade???? And how????
How do you move or place the buy and sale buttons on right bottom corner???????
Is it possible to remove those indications or buy/sell? They disturbing me the chart gets too busy when they are there.
How to move open position label from the center of the screen? Why its in the center? i don't see chart. How to move it to the right or left???
Thanks a lot for the information 😊👍
Thank you! We hope you enjoy all the features that come with this.
How do you get the replay bar to show the results on the screen as it did at minute 3:41. I've been clicking on everything and can't get that graphic to show up on my screen
X2
I figured it out. If you let the replay finish, you'll get that splash screen. I don't think you can display it at will. I got a $19.75 profit with a 100% win rate. Woo Hoo! Great learning tool. Now I need to spend lots of time in this simulator so I don't crash the plane. TV is incredible software. My broker is currently Schwab, but after the hiccups they've had, I think I need to move on and perhaps get a broker that integrates with TV.
Will tradingview have tick replay coming soon?
We've got some updates planned and please do check out our latest Bar Replay videos for additional updates and walkthroughs.
Bro how do you record screen of the trading view
How can I get bar reply exactly like live market trading?
can't we toggle between $ P&L and % P&L for example? why always $ P&L? thanks
What timeframes are available? I use 15, 5, and 3 minutes real time.
Hi. How can i go back a month or more to back test on a 5 second time. I can only retest the present day only on a 5 second time.
the paper trading account can still be connected to the bar replay
Does it let you replay INTRADAY BARS?
Why i cant see Buy and Sell while replaying?
Informative 👍
Thanks 🙂
More updates coming this year.
Stay subscribed to follow all the releases!
is bar replay works on 4 timeframes once 4 different layouts ?
Coming soon
Good informative video, but is difficult to hear as the volume is too low.
Please turn up the slider on the TH-cam video and also your computer. We'll also make a new video with better volume.
How do I turn off the buy sell text and just have arrows ? It’s highly annoying when reading candles.
The chart settings menu has all the features you need to hide/show your specific tools. We have a video about this as well.
Not available on 4H & 1H Time Frame
What is the leverage used in bar replay?
Currently there is no leverage, but we are working on some updates that will include new features. We'll share a video here when it's ready.
@@TradingView Thank you. Does this mean it's x1 currently?
how do you take all the text of the buys and sells off the chart ? its so messy ?
This can all be edited in our Chart Settings menu
we need detailed statistics
would be Excellent if jumping time frames while in replay mode doesn't reveal future price action when you switch back to a lower time frame
Thanks for the feedback! Let's see what we can do
really sucks you guys still haven't fixed the synchronization issue... 2024 is almost over and here we still stand.
Please, fix the audio from the video. There's good info but impossible to follow with the audio so low. Thanks.
Please be sure to turn up your volume on your computer and using the youtube volume slider. We will also make adjustments on future videos. We may have to remake this one for that reason - stay subscribed to see our new videos!
Start nerd
the paper trading account can still be connected to the bar replay