How Rap Works in Hamilton Part 2: Metaphor
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- HOW RAP WORKS IN HAMILTON PART 3: • Vernacular: How Rap Wo...
WHY 10 DUEL COMMANDMENTS IS AMAZING: • 10 Reasons 10 Duel Com...
HOW HAMILTON MAKES YOU CRY: • How Hamilton Makes You...
Sign up for SOUNDFLY and get 15% OFF with code "HHMusic15"
Head to Soundfly to sign up here: bit.ly/2AleTt3
This is Part 2 of a series about How Rap Works in Hamilton. What is a musical metaphor? And how is it used to create the music of Hamilton? Welcome back to this series How Rap Works in Hamilton! We're gonna explore and answer these questions and more!
Common - I Used to Love H.E.R.
• Common - I Used to Lov...
THNKR - Les Mis Inspires Creator of In the Heights
• Les Mis Inspires Creat...
Genius - Lin-Manuel Miranda on Hamilton's Rap Battles
• Video
Kevin Nealon - Lin-Manuel Miranda Accidentally Gained Weight
• Lin-Manuel Miranda acc...
60 Minutes
www.cbsnews.co...
MTV News - All Eyes on Jay-Z and Nas
• All Eyes On Jay Z & Na...
BBC - Hamilton Creator: It's the Story of America Then Told by America Now
www.bbc.com/ne...
Playing Shakespeare - Using the Verse
• RSC Playing Shakespe...
Hamilton, Great Performances documentary
www.pbs.org/wne...
In the Heights, Great Performances documentary
www.pbs.org/wne...
Forthright: Stronger Than a Weapon
atlasofthefutu...
Music Map
www.musicmap.i...
Nas - Ether
• Ether
Music by
Verified Picasso "Thing Are Going Southampton"
Latasha "Castille Soap"
Shows/Movies discussed include:
Shrek
1776
West Side Story
In the Heights
Into the Woods
Hamilton (obviously)
Fiddler on the Roof
Beautiful
Jesus Christ Superstar
Spring Awakening
Images by Pixabay
If you like these videos and want to support them more directly, please join me on Patreon for some extra goodies!
BECOME MY PATRON: / howardho
This video is a labor of love, so I'd love to hear from you. Please like, follow, and comment at me!
WEB: howardhomusic.com/
TWITTER: / ho_howard
SOUNDCLOUD: / howardwho-1
INSTAGRAM: / howardwho
For the official sheet music for Hamilton, please go to your nearest bookseller or online retailer. Here's the link to Amazon: goo.gl/rElUqr
#HowHamiltonWorks #HowRapWorksInHamilton #HowardHo
![[DRIP] ‘Love, Maybe’ PREVIEW](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/U7hwHp95m1k/mqdefault.jpg)
A simile is a type of metaphor, according to the Oxford Companion to the English Language. The confusion is that there are actually two definitions of metaphor, one that includes simile as a subspecies and one that does not. So if you learned that metaphor and simile are different, you're not wrong either! But for the purposes of this video, I'm using the definition that does include similes. Here's an article that helps to explain this more: www.litcharts.com/literary-devices-and-terms/metaphor
If you don't mind me asking, what ever happened to your next video in this series?
I was always tought that a metaphor is basically a similie but without like or as
Actually, I am sorry to say, but it is neither metaphor nor simile. Here Shrek is using the onion in a more scientific than a poetic mode; he is explaining a complex idea about ogres using the onion as a model. This renders his explanation an analogy, which is not a metaphor and not even figurative. :-)
@@adamusement Similes and analogies are the same thing. Your separation of "poetic" and "scientific" mode is completely artificial, and the words "simile" and "metaphor" (and "analogy" for that matter; "model" I'll agree is a more specific scientific usage) are used to describe the relevant entities in a variety of contexts, and notably in the context of discussing language itself (which is the context we're in here).
Another thing you didn’t mention is how Lin also uses the absence of rap as a metaphor. Notice how in the entire musical one of the only main characters that doesn’t rap is Eliza. The original actress for Eliza has even mentioned it, everyone else tries to get as many words in as possible but Eliza takes her time. She has these ballads and she draws out the words to symbolize the fact that everyone else doesn’t have enough time, but Eliza? She has time. She’s like the counter to Alex’s non-stop behavior and I️ think it’s beautiful how they show that
Ohhhh...very nice. Thanks for sharing.
She does beatbox though.
Tim Thomason well the beatboxing is the support/background for Phillips rap. Shes not the main one rapping, shes the support, the motherly figure.
That was deep bro
Also the King and the Farmer because they don't want things to change, while the revolutionaries all rap as a metaphor for war because they want change
Everyone: Hamilton was great but it lived its moment in the spotlight and it's kinda dead-
Howard Ho: *I'm gonna have to stop you right there*
It'll never die
I'll stay alive for ever. And ever. And ever and ever and ever.
Not everyone:Þ
whoever said it died???
Yup.
A couple things to add:
1. Rap is also used as a metaphor of sharing similar mindset. Hamilton tells Angelica “You’re like me” so they’re similar and they both rap skillfully. However, Eliza never raps bc although she loves Hamilton, she is not like him.
2. Period literalism is also (kind of) used when Jefferson first comes on scene and he sings a Rag Time song which, compared to rap, is out of date. He’s been in France so he’s out of date and out of touch with everyone in America
I cover your second point in the next video: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
I keep forgetting that Hamilton doesn't actually look like Lin Manuel Miranda
💯😂
What are you talking about? They are the same person
Bro same
I see Arron burr and get confused because in my head he’s black because of Leslie Odom jr
Yeah, I always forget that the founding fathers were some of the whitest people alive.
Everyone: Hamilton is done. It’s lived it’s life and now we need to mov-
Hamilfans: *allow us to introduce ourselves*
I can’t move on. Ever
One more day!
Disney-it’s back bitch
@@julielove370 no, that's les mis ;)
Hamilfilm: You sure about that?
Me: I have reached peak amazement at Lin's brilliant magnum opus.
Each new Howard Ho video: Yes, but have you considered this?
burke615 check out the motifs in Hamilton video by make stuff. So. Good.
I honestly didn't hear about the "sound of Hamilton" that guy on drums is amazing!!
Honestly it makes me feel more impressed but also makes me feel less overwhelmed by how amazing he is. I get to see his process even more.
@@kilroymoa The sound of Hamilton.... Did you mean this th-cam.com/video/L5JqO1S8DEI/w-d-xo.html ?
This series is such a hidden gem of TH-cam
Spread the word! And thanks!
i dont know if youve mentioned it before, but i think another couple cool metaphors in hamilton's style of music lie in king george singing very poppy love ballads (being sort of out of touch with the cool "hip-hop" thd youngsters are using these days) and thomas jefferson's opening song being a jazz tune (since he "basic'lly missed the late eighties")
Yes he mentioned it in other videos
Yes he did but still thank you for the comment. Only by stressing it in that context you opend my eyes to yet another hidden layer of meaning: namely I now see the link that the "late 80s" not only refer to the 1780s but additionally to the 1980s where hip-hop had its breakthrough - omg I wonder how many layers there still are to be discovered :D
5:00
"Rap is something you do; Hip Hop is something you live." --KRS-One
That's perfect. Yeah, KRS One is the best.
I read this right when I saw it
Did anyone realize he said “Lez go” ? :)))
Let it go. Let it go. Can't hold it back anymore
Mr.E more like “ let’s go... alexander .. i have to leave, alexander! “
@@MrE_ Let it go, stay alive for me
"treasury"
"lEzS gOw"
@@charmieleza08 "Look around, look around. Look how lucky we are to be alive right now."
"Helpless!"
Oh glorious duck I didn't realize you'd made so many. Preparing to binge Hamilton video essays...
Oh yes, I went all in on Hamilton. Enjoy!
brill series please never stop i know hamilton has enough in it for you to talk forever and these videos are so so well made!
Me as someone who only recently discovered hamilton, is really happy with this series of videos being created by you now
“To use another metaphor, fits like a glove” love this video series but made me laugh
"Witch is what I'll be talking about in the next video" - nice
LOL
Your video essays are so well-researched and well-presented! It is simply a joy to watch and learn more about Hamilton and Hip Hop.
coleyblossoms Yes! So interesting and well done...and I am 71 years old and have yet to see Hamilton!
Last time I was this early, Alex's cousin was still alive
Wut
Edit:oh i get it now. Oof
@Jon Swecker a voice saying "alex you gotta fend for yourself", he started rertreatin and readin every treatise on the shelf!
@Jon Swecker started working, clerkin? For his late mothers landlord traded sugar cane and rum and other things he cant afford
@Jon Swecker in New York you can be a new man (just you wait)
in New York you can be a new man (just you wait)
in New York you can be a new man (just you wait)
in new york New York (just you wait)
@Jon Swecker The ship is in the harbor now See if you can spot him Another immigrant comin' up from the bottom His enemies destroyed his rep America forgot him We fought with him
A great video to come home to after a long, annoying day at school
I’m so hooked on this series!
Hurrah a part second to the what makes hammy wammy function
I’m trying to find the full interview of Lin and Nas from 5:58, does anyone have a link?
also once again a wonderful video ☺️ always get excited when I see a new video of yours pop up
Hannah I was searching for the same interview, finally found it: th-cam.com/video/ub82Xb1C8os/w-d-xo.html
every video you come out with i watch instantly and am so disappointed when it ends and you are like "im gonna talk about this really cool thing in the NEXT video", i gotta wait??? rude but videos are good so see you next video
I have completely fallen in love with your videos. I knew that there was a lot of depth and complexity to the musical choices made in Hamilton, but I don't know enough about rap/hip-hop or musical theory to even begin thinking about it. Thank you so much for these!
At the end you say that there's going to be a Part 3 focusing on Vernacular. Is that still going to happen? I am greatly enjoying all of your Hamilton video essays, but this series is particularly interesting to me.
Here's Part 3: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Hamilton is so good. In my country no one really knows Hamilton,it's not famous here(maybe it's because we don't speak english and we are not really into musicals),so i found out about it like...2 months ago.And oh my god,your videos just made me love this show and Lin-Manuel even more.I heard that in America you are really divided about it?Like,some people love it and some hate it?I get that people don't like rap and history,and Lin put these things together,yeah,but i just wonder if these people really listened to the songs,like,REALLY listened to them. To me it just works and your videos told me why.
Throwing shade on Short Circuit 2 at 7:42?
BAD HUMAN!
I love that movie, but yeah...Los Locos...sigh.
I wish I could of got here in time but it premiered at 12 am where I live soooo yeah I actually am planing to write multiple essays on Hamilton’s writing considering all it’s foreshadowing, character dynamics and character personality it shows with its lyrics I don’t know anything about music stuff so I actually use this for reference. Thanks you since you always Blow us all away
Good luck on your essays!
Howard Ho oh THANKS!!! Good luck on the rest of your video series
I just watched Hamilton live before watching this video. It was awesome! Amazing analysis!
One of the best parts of this video is the distinction made between rap and hip-hop. It's a point that gets overlooked so often, but it's an important distinction to make. Not the only great part of this analysis, but I'm glad it got pointed out.
Nice work!
Just got home from into the woods rehearsal and I’m playing jack. Very strange hearing the name pop up
For a few seconds, I was confused at how a cow could cause war, kill and fight to the end.
Binge watching these videos to prepare for Hamilton on Disney
Please please please finish this series on Rap in Hamilton! Its so fascinating and I learn loads from your videos!
Here's part 3: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Keep the Hamilton content coming!
My man, this is probably my fave/your best. Fantastic work
Thank you for explaining that there is a difference between Rap and Hip Hop. Not alot of people get that.
yes yes yes yes yes tysm for making these videos
Damn, Lin Manuel Miranda is such a music nerd! (In the best way possible!!)
Bumping because this series is incredible! Thank you!
Haha...thanks for the bump!
Dude I would love to talk to you about Hamilton, I feel like I could have the conversation I've wanted to have since I first started listening to it
The drums in Schuyler sisters are so good
Another example of musical literalism in Hamilton is the use of 17th century basso continuo with a harpsichord in Seaburry's and King George's parts. It's actually supposed to be anachronistic even for the 18th century and symbolizes the conflict between 17th century baroque monarchism and 18th century enlightment.
Ah yes, basso continuo. I forgot everything I learned about figured bass. LOL
thank you for the note at 11:35. I did a double take and nearly paused the video to google. :)
also, brilliant essay.
I never realized that about Jack!
i don’t want to wait for another video 😔
How did you get the footage where you can see the drummer playing during Hamilton's show? That can actually be useful educationally.
Amazing as always!!!!
Awesome vid but where’s part 3
It's on the way, I promise!
I just discovered this but where's part 3?? I wanna know about the vernacular!
Here it is: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Finally! I hope to see the next part soon
Enjoyed watching every second of this video! lookin forward to the next on:)
Thank you Howard. As always 🔥🔥🔥.
looking forward to that next part!
th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Narrator: "Emimem has the biggest vocabulary in rap" Fans of Aesop Rock: "?"
I thought the same until I read ''biggest vocabulary in rap of top selling musicians''
This is so good!
不
不ba
im looking foward to the third
When I saw the genres and I saw 'Jamaican/Reggae music' I kinda went 'huh?' but then I saw it break down into the other Jamaican genres like Ska, Rocksteady and Dub and I thought 'niiiice'
AAAAA I LOVE LIN SO FUCKING MUCH
I didn't know that the music was being played live, wow
2:07 References musicmap.info I'm like Whaaaat this guy knows it toooo
Where’s part 3, Howard?
.... *Where’s part 3, Howard?*
Just you wait.
@@HowardHoMusic Boo. Hahaha but boo.
11:35 revealing to me that Shakespeare if alive would also applaud Lin-Manuel and Hamilton; wow, 😂👏
Also, are you putting out part 3?
It came out finally: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
@@HowardHoMusic 👏👏👏 checked it out.
Amazing 👌
i am learning more things of some thing that i love learning and seeing than i learn of something i might not even need in life like animal cells
Where you got the Hamilton musical videos? (Like the video in 3:33)
High DATALORE th-cam.com/video/ub82Xb1C8os/w-d-xo.html
@@Arbeeeet i hate you😂😂😂
"OgReS aRe LiKe OnIoNs" that is a simale
Similes are a type of metaphor. If you go back to that part of the video, you can see that I wrote that underneath "Ogres are like onions."
Your language arts teacher would be proud of you
Searching for Part 3 on Vernacular but can’t find it. Is YT punking me or is it not out yet?
Here it is: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
So pretty much what you’re saying is, all the other musicals may have had the lyrics but they didn’t have the SAUCE💋👌🏽
"Ogre's are like onions" is actually a simile because it uses the word "like"
11:40 also Magneto
Oh yes!
July 4th!
I'm not finding a part 3. Did you do one?
I did: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Part 3?
Coming soon....very, very soon....
Every time he mentions the musical 1776, I go: New York City. Pardon me, are you Aaron Burr, sir?
Finger to the throat means death!
Oops! Wrong movie!
Vernacular!
Here ya go: th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Pls keep going
th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
also is dancehall, reggae and merengue Latin American genres? bc I thought they were Jamaican/Caribbean genres.
Latin America usually includes the Caribbean.
My man's gonna talk about vocabulary in hip hop and not mention Aesop Rock??? More words than Shakespeare? C'mon man, dropped the ball.
Yup, Aesop Rock is the vocabulary king. But that list I mentioned was only of "top selling musicians."
@@HowardHoMusic Ohhh you right! Sorry Ho, great video!
And you even include a clip from parasite lol
OMG
Where is Part 3?
th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Yup.
That's Gandalf.
Gods i wish i knew how to rap
wham bam kablam shablam
Where is part 3?
th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
0:35 eeerm actually this is a simile because Shrek uses "Like" 🤓☝️
*uses a simile at the beginning of the video*
Yup, and a simile is a type of metaphor. See my note above.
So uhhhhhh where's part 3??
It's coming....just you wait.
Shame on youtube / google for allowing lengthy ads to dominate viewer ability to see Hamilton post. Pulled earplugs. Wtf? How to get rid of really long ads? Just pull your plugs?
Where is the third part?
Just posted. Enjoy! th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
One of the first 1000 Yea!!
"fits like a glove" is a simile not a metaphor lol
A simile is actually a type of metaphor. I made a note about it in the pinned comment.
Next part when?
Just posted! th-cam.com/video/84NcQT4Ekgw/w-d-xo.html
Ogers are like onions is a simile
So is like a glove.
They're not metaphors
"Metaphor" is not just a sentence that uses "is" instead of "like." I know we were taught that in school, but that's only the tip of the iceberg. For example, when music represents an emotion, there is no sentence saying "music is love"...it just happens, and we understand that's the comparison. That's because metaphor can also refer to any type of poetic comparison, which also includes similes.
No fair
Of course Eminem has the highest vocabulary by double of the seconds and third place
Next time tell everyone that a simile is a type of metaphor. That's all the comment section is talking about.🤣
❣️
Criolo porra vai Brasil !!!!
Was I the only one who paused the video multiple times to jump around in excitement and scream some of the lyrics?
잘한다 :)