The problem with this test is that as long as ice remains in the mug, the water temp will remain at 32. So all the tumblers will be equal as long as there is any amount of ice. Try a test where you take chilled water from the fridge, NO ICE, and check every hour to see the temp difference. That would give you a better idea of which tumbler is better.
I’ve had an Ozark for years and never disappointed. I do have popular brands as well but use my Ozark the most. I just today got a Brumate so I’ll see how that works.
Great video! I have ALMOST pulled the trigger on purchasing a Yeti multiple times this year, but something has held me back...the price tag LOL... thanks for sharing this video.
I've had my Yeti sitting in my car in Arizona in open parking lots on 110+ degree days during shopping trips. Still cold at the end of the day. Maybe the others are just as good, but having cold water after six hours in a hot car IS real world.
In real world experience, I've had my yeti tumblers keep hot for a few hours, and keep ice all day. Most people are going to drink whatever is in their cup before the ice melts or coffee gets cold, anyway. The bottles keep ice way longer. I've had ice keep in one of my bottles for a couple of days.
I only have the Ozark trail but I love it. I don't imagine the others could make me happier at 5x the price. I wish I got the 40 oz Ozark but I've never seen them at my store or on line.
@@CruelSun69 compared to Stanley. I have a bunch of the 32 oz Ozark trail tumblers I caught on sale for $5 - $7. Since I posted that I bought a 40 oz Ozark trail for $19.95. that's not nearly the price difference but still good enough
YETI, because of the options, handle, straw lid, replacements.., and the lid is less likely to break on the YETI than all those others, and easier to remove and clean without breaking, also that YETI is better than the new handle ones because it doesn't drink in one direction like the new screw on ones with handles that will wear out the seal in that one spot over time.
2 years later Stanley hiked up to 40.00 😭 I used to buy Stanley tumbler for teacher gifts cause they were cheap and now I can’t do it anymore. 😢 Great review as I was looking for new cups to be gifted this year.
the Stanley he reviewed was 30 oz so the price only raised $2. 40$ for a 40oz is definitely overpriced tho! So expensive cause its a big trend on Tik Tok... lol XD
I've been rocking the Ozark tumbler for a few years now and I couldn't be happier, if I remember correctly I payed around $8 at Walmart when I bought it.... I can't imagine paying what those other cups cost today when the Ozark will do just as good if not better than the others; I'll keep my money in my pocket!!!
Great video, I only have the ozark trail one. Always wanted a Yeti but could not see a reason to spend that much money on it, just for the name brand. Thanks again!
I know my comments late but I have a BUILT brand tumbler.had it for 2 years now.i love it just as much as my Ozark Trail mini tumbler.bc of these cups I drink more water now than tea or soda.i loved watching this video.great job ❤
The first practical test. Agreed not using my tumbler to store ice but also while on the road, opening up another can of soda, nice to still have some ice. So boils down to the two and maybe quality of build. I have had my Stanley thermos for years, fallen off my truck several times and still works fine. Maybe some brand loyalty, but for the price, I can afford to buy a replacement. ,
Im planning to get a tumbler one day but not sure which one yet lol. With Stanley im seeing the bennefit of being suitable fir hot and cold drinks. The lid allows that easily. However it has the isssue of leaking and the lead controversy. The hydro Flask and Yeti ones seem more secure but with hydroflask you need a whole different mug for hot drinks on the go while with the yeti spend just another 10 for a lid for hot drinks.
I've already got an Ozark Trail. I figured out several years ago that they work just as well, and cost way less. Since all of them are made in China now, I can't even justify buying a more expensive one to support an American manufacturer.
I have three YETI cups there are great cups. Would like to see you do another video using a Contigo cup with the push button to drink and seal. I promise you it will beat every cup you tested.
Awesome video. Thanks! 1 more thing which I was expecting from this video was what happens when it’s hot? Does the lid come off when it’s hot? Does it spill?
I need to compare the Kodi, RTIC, Yeti and Ozark can koozies and probably get the same results. FYI the Ozark can koozies have a cap lifter on the bottom that sells for $8.94, the Kodi sells for $13.95.
In my experience they all keep Ice about the same but I work in a office environment and prefer bigger cups so that I don't have to get up and refill constantly and man do some of the cheap and mid teir cups make your water taste like garbage after a number of hours.
The straw alone on that Stanley is a game changer 😂 only have Yeti mug and a small 12 oz rambler so need a bigger reliable rambler for when I’m roofing and need coffee at 6am thank you for the video 🙏🏽
Good review. Most videos i have seen comparing ozark-RTIC-YETI shows that yeti products usually get out performed with RTIC and ozark trail flip flopping depending on the product and conditions. Great review
Buy the Ozark. I've had one almost 4 years. You can put hot coffee in it in the Am and it will still be warm by the afternoon. At indoor temps ice will last all day in it. You can leave it in a parking lot on 100degree days while shopping and still have ice. I once filled it with crushed ice & pina colada and had it sit in the sun a few hours by the pool. There was a big ice ball in the bottom when I was finished.
You don't need a thermometer if there is still ice in the cup. If the temps were above 32F, the ice would have already melted. An easier way to do this is to simply see which loses the ice first. There is really no need for a thermometer for cold testing until after all the ice is gone.
4 hrs is not enough time. As long as there is ice in the cups the water will stay at 32 degrees. But maybe one of them had less or more ice than the others which would indicate if it's better or worse quality. In Texas 4 hours matters a lot lol it's brutal here. I would test them for an entire day only because I use the half gallon jugs and I use them for work. The Ozark trail has not disappointed but I do wonder if the yeti is worth the price. I wouldn't mind paying the price if it performed significantly better
Great review! I use my Tumblers everyday for work and I have noticed no real difference between my old black Ozark cup and my different Yeti's besides the price. Luckily, I don't pay retail for the Yeti's but its still higher than an Ozark Trail.
@@skylolo7359 with my experience the tinted lids get warm faster when in direct sunlight. It would be nice to know what ones block UV. It seems to me in sunlight the tinted one attracts more heat
Excellent test I watch a lot of people with those digital laser thermometers and they're coming up with ice water colder than 32ﾟ The only thing that may be is they got the laser on an ice cube ice water's 32ﾟ that's how we calibrate The monitors ice water is 32ﾟIt doesn't matter if it's in a hot car hot addictOr at the North Pole if it's ice water It's 32ﾟ thanks for the video Great job🙂
It appeared to me you put the thermometer from one to the others too fast to see they all were at 32°..wouldn't it be a better test to put 4 of the same brand & type thermometers in the 4 different cups..maybe they would register different temperatures ...
As long as there was more ice than water it was going to be 32°. Besides those thermometers cost money. I had already bought all tje cups and I dont have sponsors. Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment.
Hi from Oamaru Sth island New Zealand. I have a yeti 30 oz travel mug which I put in 2 minute noodles but I just realized I can't remove the screw on lid when it's hot. Do you have any ideas how to remove cap?.. cheers Carl
Great test and you made it with the actual intended use, no one will leave a cup full of ice for a few days in real life and expect go back to it expecting to drink from it, well done. My research and personal experience has shown that the Yeti has copper inside the walls of which takes the metallic taste that some other metal containers have. For example, I had a Hydro Flask brand that tasted like I had a mouthful of coins, Yeti did NOT have that issue and I have never used anything other than that after. To me it's worth the extra money but I have not tried the others in this video. ;)
@@EverydayMan I agree! I have a Rtic tumbler going on to about 5 years now and still kicking and no metallic taste whatsoever. I use it here in South Texas when temperatures reach 117 degrees outside! I love my cup 😊especially since it is customized with Punisher designs.
The problem with this test is that as long as ice remains in the mug, the water temp will remain at 32. So all the tumblers will be equal as long as there is any amount of ice. Try a test where you take chilled water from the fridge, NO ICE, and check every hour to see the temp difference. That would give you a better idea of which tumbler is better.
I think you make a great point.
@gr-os4gd Exactly . . . which holds ice the longest.
Went to my Wal-Mart the other day (March 2023) and the Ozark Trail tumblers now come with a copy of the mag slider lid. Still $9.
I’ve had an Ozark for years and never disappointed. I do have popular brands as well but use my Ozark the most. I just today got a Brumate so I’ll see how that works.
I never really notice the difference between the yeti and the Ozark, thanks for covering this!
Thanks for watching!
@C if your wallet notices $20 youve got bigger problems.
@C if you cant find the Yeti for $38 like i did 4 hours ago... in the middle of nowhere Montana.... youve got bigger problems than basic math bud.
@@OvertonWindexThank you for making sure this thread isn't douche-free.
If you want to spend 28$ more for a couple different letters on a cup… “I want the one that says yeti” they are the same thing….
That’s insane.
I've had a few Ozark Trail items in various sizes and they've never let me down
Great video! I have ALMOST pulled the trigger on purchasing a Yeti multiple times this year, but something has held me back...the price tag LOL... thanks for sharing this video.
Thank you
I've had my Yeti sitting in my car in Arizona in open parking lots on 110+ degree days during shopping trips. Still cold at the end of the day. Maybe the others are just as good, but having cold water after six hours in a hot car IS real world.
In real world experience, I've had my yeti tumblers keep hot for a few hours, and keep ice all day. Most people are going to drink whatever is in their cup before the ice melts or coffee gets cold, anyway.
The bottles keep ice way longer. I've had ice keep in one of my bottles for a couple of days.
I have an Ozark, but I bought a yeti lid for it because I like the magnetic design lol
I only have the Ozark trail but I love it. I don't imagine the others could make me happier at 5x the price. I wish I got the 40 oz Ozark but I've never seen them at my store or on line.
5x?
@@CruelSun69 compared to Stanley. I have a bunch of the 32 oz Ozark trail tumblers I caught on sale for $5 - $7. Since I posted that I bought a 40 oz Ozark trail for $19.95. that's not nearly the price difference but still good enough
🤣 when you said it's 107° In the car i was like DAMN, youre not gonna sip on any of that ice cold water?!?
Lol
YETI, because of the options, handle, straw lid, replacements.., and the lid is less likely to break on the YETI than all those others, and easier to remove and clean without breaking, also that YETI is better than the new handle ones because it doesn't drink in one direction like the new screw on ones with handles that will wear out the seal in that one spot over time.
Thanks for the review that was real-world testing right there. I love my Ozark Trail Tumbler
They work as good as the rest!
2 years later Stanley hiked up to 40.00 😭
I used to buy Stanley tumbler for teacher gifts cause they were cheap and now I can’t do it anymore. 😢
Great review as I was looking for new cups to be gifted this year.
the Stanley he reviewed was 30 oz so the price only raised $2. 40$ for a 40oz is definitely overpriced tho! So expensive cause its a big trend on Tik Tok... lol XD
It’s even worse now 😂
Great video and very helpful. I was thinking Yeti but now, I've got to go with Ozark.
I've been rocking the Ozark tumbler for a few years now and I couldn't be happier, if I remember correctly I payed around $8 at Walmart when I bought it.... I can't imagine paying what those other cups cost today when the Ozark will do just as good if not better than the others; I'll keep my money in my pocket!!!
Appreciate your video. I’ve been wanting to purchase a tumbler but wasn’t sure which one. This helped BIG time!
Thanks for watching!
Wow! Thanks for this! I am going to save some money now that I've watched your video. I appreciate the great information!
Great video, I only have the ozark trail one. Always wanted a Yeti but could not see a reason to spend that much money on it, just for the name brand. Thanks again!
Thanks!
I know my comments late but I have a BUILT brand tumbler.had it for 2 years now.i love it just as much as my Ozark Trail mini tumbler.bc of these cups I drink more water now than tea or soda.i loved watching this video.great job ❤
The first practical test. Agreed not using my tumbler to store ice but also while on the road, opening up another can of soda, nice to still have some ice. So boils down to the two and maybe quality of build. I have had my Stanley thermos for years, fallen off my truck several times and still works fine. Maybe some brand loyalty, but for the price, I can afford to buy a replacement. ,
That RTIC looks prettyyyyyy. Thanks for reviewing them.
I like that one and the green yeti!
Project Farm does an extensive test on various insulated bottles.
Love it. I have a bunch of Yeti’s and love them but may have to try a few other now
Give them a chance
You saved me $20, was ready to order the Yeti. Thanks!
Glad I could help. My personal favorite is the RTIC.
Im planning to get a tumbler one day but not sure which one yet lol.
With Stanley im seeing the bennefit of being suitable fir hot and cold drinks. The lid allows that easily.
However it has the isssue of leaking and the lead controversy.
The hydro Flask and Yeti ones seem more secure but with hydroflask you need a whole different mug for hot drinks on the go while with the yeti spend just another 10 for a lid for hot drinks.
I love that neon yellow on the YETI, wish they still offered that color
If I would have known it was rare at tje time, I would have bought more. I love that color.
Great practical test! Thanks so much for all your real life testing!
Outside the box thinking, no one I have seen has put cups in a hot vehicle for any amount of time and checked temps, nice one. A fun little review.
Thanks!
At what point of this test did you realize you were wasting your time lol
Great Video! It's exactly what I was looking for!
My father and grandfather it seems were right about Stanley. I'd blow the extra money on the Stanley. They just need brighter cup colors like Yeti.
I agree.
Great video ...helped me decide ...thanks
I have an ozark somewhere around here but I just ordered my 4th cup from rtic
Very realistic test, good video man. It just goes to show bling isn't everything. 👍
Thanks, hope you enjoyed!
Buying the Ozark trial and if it magically disappears or grows feet and walks away at work, yeah I’d be upset, but easily replace it for
I've already got an Ozark Trail. I figured out several years ago that they work just as well, and cost way less. Since all of them are made in China now, I can't even justify buying a more expensive one to support an American manufacturer.
I'm probably going with RTIC TUMBLER it seems like the cheapest one and does just as good a job
I have three YETI cups there are great cups. Would like to see you do another video using a Contigo cup with the push button to drink and seal. I promise you it will beat every cup you tested.
Thank you for doing the test
Enjoyed your presentation. Would love to have one of the mugs.
Thanks
CPK
Awesome video. Thanks! 1 more thing which I was expecting from this video was what happens when it’s hot? Does the lid come off when it’s hot? Does it spill?
I dont know. May have to do another test.
I need to compare the Kodi, RTIC, Yeti and Ozark can koozies and probably get the same results. FYI the Ozark can koozies have a cap lifter on the bottom that sells for $8.94, the Kodi sells for $13.95.
I actually did that one too. Lol
th-cam.com/video/P1dLVFRe6jQ/w-d-xo.html
In my experience they all keep Ice about the same but I work in a office environment and prefer bigger cups so that I don't have to get up and refill constantly and man do some of the cheap and mid teir cups make your water taste like garbage after a number of hours.
Can u share which specific brands?
The straw alone on that Stanley is a game changer 😂 only have Yeti mug and a small 12 oz rambler so need a bigger reliable rambler for when I’m roofing and need coffee at 6am thank you for the video 🙏🏽
Thanks for watching!
Good review. Most videos i have seen comparing ozark-RTIC-YETI shows that yeti products usually get out performed with RTIC and ozark trail flip flopping depending on the product and conditions. Great review
Thanks!
Interesting test everyone swears t but yeti and I still don’t know why if it’s more price but under performing the cheaper brands 🤔
The way you added the cars was fucking hilarious 😂 spot on too
Good demo, I enjoyed it, thanks.
Thanks
I am A Yeti Guy With A Ozark Trail Bank Account….. Good Work
Thanks
Best test I've seen so far, realistic.
You can even put yeti lid into ozark one. Yeti lid is 10 so about 19 or 20 dollars you get a hybrid.
And the yeti lid is nice!
awesome test! Love your personality brother!
Thanks!
I’m a Stanley guy I like their products a lot
Me too
the stanley is the only one that could hold up to carbonated beverages. the carbonation pushes the top off the other 3 found out the hard way
Haha, I use all of them for my beer. But I do crack them open.
Man prices havr really gone up
They sure have.
Thanks this helped me a lot!
My man! Every guy loves a good coffee tumbler!
FYI. You can buy a sliding lid for the RTIC.
Thanks
Thank you for sharing the info. Greatly appreciate that.
Thanks for watching
I have that same color ozark and in my big rig cup holder that gets hot or the pick up while out running around. It’s really the best. $8
Hard to beat for sure.
Thank you 😊for your review ❤
Awesome showdown I just got a ozark trail tumbler and water bottle I'm so loving them they both are great
They sure are.
Thanks for review helped alot.
Glad it was helpful!
Now I will buy the Ozark!! Thank you
Great review! Thank you
All of the ice in each of them will melt before their temp starts rising. But, he did good by checking the temp, and measuring how much ice melted.
Buy the Ozark. I've had one almost 4 years. You can put hot coffee in it in the Am and it will still be warm by the afternoon. At indoor temps ice will last all day in it. You can leave it in a parking lot on 100degree days while shopping and still have ice. I once filled it with crushed ice & pina colada and had it sit in the sun a few hours by the pool. There was a big ice ball in the bottom when I was finished.
The Ozark definitely outperforms its price for sure! Thanks for watching!!
Good video. Put me in for one of the cups! Hhaha
Excellent test
Try the Magellan , I love it
Used my Ozark daily for a year and enjoyed it until the snap cover hinge broke
You don't need a thermometer if there is still ice in the cup. If the temps were above 32F, the ice would have already melted. An easier way to do this is to simply see which loses the ice first. There is really no need for a thermometer for cold testing until after all the ice is gone.
Thanks for watching
Lol, I was saying same thing! Lmao !
Dude keep probing the cubes in each cup lmao 🤣
I use Stanley and Artic. And have had usable ice still left in my tumbler after sitting in my truck over 9hrs. I live in south Texas
Me too!
4 hrs is not enough time.
As long as there is ice in the cups the water will stay at 32 degrees. But maybe one of them had less or more ice than the others which would indicate if it's better or worse quality. In Texas 4 hours matters a lot lol it's brutal here. I would test them for an entire day only because I use the half gallon jugs and I use them for work. The Ozark trail has not disappointed but I do wonder if the yeti is worth the price. I wouldn't mind paying the price if it performed significantly better
Great review! I use my Tumblers everyday for work and I have noticed no real difference between my old black Ozark cup and my different Yeti's besides the price. Luckily, I don't pay retail for the Yeti's but its still higher than an Ozark Trail.
They are all close for sure.
I went with Yeti over Ozark Trail because the Yeti is dishwasher safe.
The yeti and Stanley were on the side of the truck with the sun on it. This could possibly effect those two and make them last less.
I saw another test by someone and the Ozark did just a lil better he also noticed the lid on Ozark is tinted where yeti is clear
@@skylolo7359 with my experience the tinted lids get warm faster when in direct sunlight. It would be nice to know what ones block UV. It seems to me in sunlight the tinted one attracts more heat
Thank you for the video super helpful.
Thanks for watching!
need to do a 24/hr test
Great video...now i know which cup i want. ;)
Why did you want to see which one would have the least water in the glass at the end? Wouldn't more water be better?
The less water you have means the ice melted less.
@@EverydayMan ah. That makes perfect sense. I was thinking in terms of evaporation so thats why I was confused. Thank you for the explanation
Have you done a hot test on these?
I sure havent.
Excellent test I watch a lot of people with those digital laser thermometers and they're coming up with ice water colder than 32ﾟ The only thing that may be is they got the laser on an ice cube ice water's 32ﾟ that's how we calibrate The monitors ice water is 32ﾟIt doesn't matter if it's in a hot car hot addictOr at the North Pole if it's ice water It's 32ﾟ thanks for the video Great job🙂
Thanks!
Do i still have a chance to win a cup? I want the rtic one please 😁
I bet a hot test might yield different results? curious if it's different
Maybe so.
Good test for what these things are really used for. Good job.
Thanks
Try the same test with only the same amount of ice!
Great advice for all univercity professors to pay attention to so that the stu dents will
understand.
It appeared to me you put the thermometer from one to the others too fast to see they all were at 32°..wouldn't it be a better test to put 4 of the same brand & type thermometers in the 4 different cups..maybe they would register different temperatures ...
As long as there was more ice than water it was going to be 32°. Besides those thermometers cost money. I had already bought all tje cups and I dont have sponsors. Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment.
Hi from Oamaru Sth island New Zealand. I have a yeti 30 oz travel mug which I put in 2 minute noodles but I just realized I can't remove the screw on lid when it's hot.
Do you have any ideas how to remove cap?.. cheers Carl
No I sure don't. Sorry.
Good review
Whichever one is American made... if any
None of them unfortunately
11:33 love the random jpeg
Awesome test brother. I’m subscribing to your channel.
Thanks, glad u liked it!
C'mon dude! You gave the Rtic the mustang?! Lol I still live my Rtic.
Great video though!
Haha
Thanks!
Nice Vid Bro...I have an Ozark Trail and it works well...thanks for confirming it is good
Thanks for watching!
I found a 30oz Yeti left in a college classroom!
Great review! 12:08
Belly laughs. Keep this stuff coming
Great test and you made it with the actual intended use, no one will leave a cup full of ice for a few days in real life and expect go back to it expecting to drink from it, well done.
My research and personal experience has shown that the Yeti has copper inside the walls of which takes the metallic taste that some other metal containers have. For example, I had a Hydro Flask brand that tasted like I had a mouthful of coins, Yeti did NOT have that issue and I have never used anything other than that after. To me it's worth the extra money but I have not tried the others in this video. ;)
I haven't noticed any metallic taste in any of them. Thanks for watching.
@@EverydayMan I agree! I have a Rtic tumbler going on to about 5 years now and still kicking and no metallic taste whatsoever. I use it here in South Texas when temperatures reach 117 degrees outside! I love my cup 😊especially since it is customized with Punisher designs.