BEST 18 Gauge Cordless Brad Nailer - Head-To-Head
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ส.ค. 2019
- Link to Article: www.toolboxbuzz.com/cordless-...
Milwaukee Purchase Link:
shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=937848...
Makita Purchase Link:
shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=937848...
Several test simulations were used which are considered typical of tasks where a carpenter might use a brad nailer on. The simulations included:
Soft Wood Trim Installation- Brad nailers were used to install Pine trim onto framing lumber, to evaluate hole quality.
Hard Wood Trim Installation- Brad nailers were used to install Oak, Mahogany, IPE and Maple trim over plywood. This test allowed us to evaluate power, penetration of fasteners, depth of drive adjustments and nail hole quality.
Toe-Nail Application- We installed ½” Poplar bead-board was inatalled onto framing lumber by toe-nailing the tongue of the trim. This test evaluated penetration of fasteners, line of sight, and depth of drive adjustments.
Line of Sight and Accuracy Testing - Fasteners were installed onto cross-hair marks, and straight lines, to determine how well users could hit the marks and determine line of sight and accuracy of the contact tips.
18 Gauge Cordless Brad Nailer - Factors Considered
In addition to the simulations each of the crew members spent time shooting fasteners into varying materials, to evaluate each brad nailer independently. The simulations and individual evaluations were used to determine the Best 18 Gauge Cordless Brad Nailer, in several categories including:
Size and Weight
Ergonomics
Features -Performance
Power
Price
Best in Class - derived from the above categories
Size and Weight - WINNERS - Dewalt and Milwaukee
Cordless brad nailers certainly benefit from the lack of an air hose, but have to comprimise due to added weight of batteries.
The length, width, and height of the nailers were used to determine their cubic volume, and a rank was assigned based on volume and tool weight. In the accompanying graph, the upper band is the weight of the nailer while the lower band is the size ranking of the nailers.
The lightest brad nailer was DEWALT , at 5.2lbs. followed very closely by the Milwaukee at 5.7lbs. Makita and Metabo HPT were the heaviest brad nailers, approximately 1lb. heavier than DEWALT and Milwaukee.
Best Cordless Brad Nailer - Ergonomics - WINNER - Milwaukee
Ergonomics play a major role in all of our evaluations and testing. Not only does a tool need to perform well, but it’s very important that tools are comfortable, which ultimately leads to more productivity and reduced risk of injury.
Milwaukee finished first for the ergonomics category, coming in 11 points better than the second place DEWALT and 21 points better than the third place Metabo HPT. The team felt that the changes made to the NEW Milwaukee Gen 2 nailer were noticeable and impressive.
Balance
The team felt that Milwaukee was the best balanced nailer, with an even weight distribution
The DEWALT is more top heavy [with 2.0 Ah battery] but that can be drastically improved, by installing a heavier 5.0 ah battery. In that configuration, the DEWALT is as evenly balanced as the Milwaukee, but, slightly heavier.
Milwaukee Tool - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
![BOWKYLION - เจ้านายคะ (work-life imbalance) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6bFj8G2pOi4/mqdefault.jpg)
One of the best tool reviews I have seen. Clearly a lot of thought , preparation and time put into this and it is extremely impressive. I've just subscribed.
Wow I'm really impressed with your operation. Not only to afford all these tools with cross-duplication... but also the time to conduct these tests and produce these well organized vids. Thanks for all you're doing!
Thanks for the testing of the brad nailer- my daughter wants one-perfect timing to find your show
We use Dewalts 18g and 16g cordless nailers constantly. We love them
Hey guys just wanted to give a thanks for the reviews y’all do I bought this Milwaukee brad nailer after watching this and couldn’t be happier with it I also bought the metabo table saw and love that as well it’s funny cuz y’all say the nailer stops after 4 nails are remaining I noticed mine does it after 6 probably the only complaint but I still love it keep up the great work!
I scored the ryobi airstrike brad nailer on black friday sale for $79. It actually works super well, they did a good job with their nailer! I consistently drive 2" brads. Super easy to load and a lever to clear jams up top. I know people hate in Ryobi but I feel like it would be competitive with their brad nailer to these other companies.
A few people I know have this same nailer.And they really did a good job and consider gets a rio be tool
I used to spend hours on my phone trying to decide which tool to buy. Thank you for saving me all that time. Love the videos. Sharing this information for free ... you guys are doing a huge service to the professionals that demand the best tools for their jobs.
Nice review, I’m a finish carpenter and I run the Milwaukee gen 2 18 gauge run as my trim gun and absolutely love it, I work in a crew of 4 and all other 3 carpenters are attached to a hose still, but with the Milwaukee gun I’ve made them believers
Really informative review, So few tool reviews offer a quantified cross comparison of a tools virtues across brands. Thanks for setting the bar!
Very thorough! You guys helped me decide on a nailer. Awesome job!
I agree with the many others. You’re reviews kick ass. Very thorough, very clear, and it feels genuine and not a “paid to give a good review” because you list out your stats, testing, results, and scoring. 👏
Seriously these reviews are incredible
It is very thorough except it didn't include the Senco Fusion.
You said it all.
I enjoyed the professional analysis on all these tools bra . Thank you for your video
Certainly sponsored
@@ThekiBoran is hhdoing hhhiI hhihhiihihii
Always a pleasure listening to your reviews. Some of the most objective and complete reviews on TH-cam. I like that you add that the rankings can be adjusted based on what's important to oneself by adjusting the matrix you provide. As you state, not everyone has the same criteria for what is important. Nice that you acknowledge that.
This is the greatest, most comprehensive, straightforward, data driven, nothing hidden, down to earth, review I've ever seen. Absolutely amazing. You really won points with this engineer when you busted out the microscope to inspect the holes :)
so which one did u got
@@drive-2786 it's been a long time and I think I was going to get the milwaukee... but then got sticker shock on all of these and couldn't justify it for my frequency of use.
@@johnhendy1281 ,im getting the dewalt .,because i have other tools that use the same batteries .
After having a Ryobi cordless 18 gauge for a couple years, I got tired of the constant need to clean and oil the firing pin or the darn thing wouldn't complete the cycle and fire without actually driving the nail in. Sold it on craigslist and bought the Milwaukee since I have a couple of their other tools so have bats and a charger. Everything you say about it in this video is spot on. Fast, reliable, and easy to handle. So nice to have a tool that works perfectly every time.
The work you guys put into these reviews is staggering. Thank you
Robert!!! As usual, you nailed it. I own the Dewalt one. Anyway, love your reviews and agree 99% of the time. You do a thorough job as always. Thanks again, and keep those vids coming.
I bought the dewalt based on your review. I'm keeping the porter cable, hoses and compressor at home. I chose the dewalt over the Milwaukee based on price. Thank you.
By far the best and most thorough review on nailers I've viewed thus far. I've never owned a nailer and am seeking a good first time purchase as a DIYer for trimming, framing, birdhouse builds, home projects, etc. Thanks
Love the review went out and bought my Milwaukee nailer today I love your guys's honest opinions on things I love how you're not biased towards any brands you judge them based on how they work in real world applications great as always God bless and stay safe
shakee shakee how do you like it so far? Does it drive thru hard material wood?
This was REALLY helpful!
Great content, well thought out testing as always. Your videos and reviews always seem to be fair, insightful and educational. Keep the reviews coming, please !!
thx
Best tool review I've seen in my life. When you went in with a microscope to check nail holes, I was laughing out loud. It just amused me how far you took it. And I mean that in a positive way. 👍
Always great videos from this channel. I really like that you get to the point and get it done.
14:00 Holy crap, I never thought someone else was in the room when you were recording these. Mind blown. Hats off to Mr. Dead-silent Guy.
That was Stan - he was working on another test - yes quietly
I'm heartened to know that Milwaukee has greatly improved the gen 2 over the gen 1. I bought the gen 1 and even sent it to Milwaukee for repair when it would not consistently sink the brads. It came back with zero improvement in performance. I shelved it and bought the Hitachi to replace it. I have no complaints about that gun. It performs flawlessly everytime. I just sold the Milwaukee to a greenhorn because an imperfect nail gun beats non at all. I was forthright with him about the tool but he still saw the wisdom have buying it.
I'd love to get the new Milwaukee guns as they look to be terrific. But I can't justify it as of yet.
Jeff Powell You could’ve traded it in to Milwaukee for the latest one if you got it recently!
@@deluxepressure no I got it right after it came out. I sold it to a rookie that had no nail gun at all. It's certainly better than nothing.
How about - just because. Thats a good excuse
The same thing with this gen 2 is gonna happen I know a guy who has the gen 2 he loved in the beginning then it started not sinking them all the way, thats tge problem with nitrogen filled air container eventually the air escapes, the Dewalt uses a flywheel system and actually gets better as it gets older, it might be more noisey and very slight delay but it is by far the most reliable of the nail gun systems
I bought the Milwaukee gen1 and its a great looking piece of trash that I think they had a nerve for letting it out of the factory and on to the market in the first place.
Really great review. Love the detail and lengths you went to show each nailer.
Thanks for the video of head to head comparison test. I use a Senco 18 gauge brad nailer that has a slight edge of using 2 1/8” long brads. I use it for trim punch small jobs. I also have and use Senco 15 DA and the 16 gauge nailers. But my most used for cabinetry molding installation is the Makita 12v pin nailer. I kinda wish the Senco would have been in the test run off. Again thanks.
Excellent test! I really appreciate how the channel is professional, and has quality tool testings. Some other channels on YT has really poor content, with a load of click-baits. The editing is also good!
The editing is basic but Ill take the compliment - thanks
I second this. Great reviews on this channel.
Solid breakdown, I’m now content with my decision on going with the gen2 Milwaukee Brad nailer
My gen 1 only lasted a year and wasn’t covered by warranty fs
I've had a gen 1 for about 4 years now, dont use it every day but it's going well
And THAT is how you do a tool test video. Excellent video. Thank you.
Thanks for your time and effort in helping us choose .
Gr8 job Rob. Definitely, purchasing a Milwaukee. :))
Rob, No need to hide the Boston accent! New England is famous for its carpenters. MakitER it is! Massive thanks for your work here, as always. Great work!!!
I try!
He makes up for extra "r"s by leaving them off other words. "The Makiter is heaviah" It all balances.
@@garyK.45ACP You guys have been watching too much of This Old House lol
Great comprehensive reviews as usual. Thank you ☺
very helpful thank you, gonna enjoy my cool milwaukee now!
I love them all , where were they 15 years ago.
You guys really set the gold standard for tool comparison tests , also i never feel like you favor or are biased to any tool Brand/Company. Great work and thanks .
cmal90 thx
@@ConcordCarpenter
Conspicuously absent is the Senco cordless 18g nailer. I'm a Makita guy but when it came time to go cordless Makita 2 years ago had bad reviews. A coworker suggested Senco. It's never jammed or failed to properly drive a nail. I would say the line of sight isn't the greatest but I got used to it. It's super lightweight too. Oh yeah, the hook is highly adjustable.
@@ConcordCarpenter hey buddy can you do another with a ryobi thanks
Outstanding scope and depth of testing in this tool review! As a consumer, I feel confident and empowered by the detailed information I learned from your review. Thank you!
~Christy~
Awesome reviews guys! I’m sold on the Milwaukee Gen2. Thanks!
I have 3 the Milwaukee, DeWalt, and Ryobi I use the Ryobi the most. It's light and quick to use. Plus smaller
Ryobi are great ... massively underrated by past reputation and price snobbery!
I’m happy with my Mikita, especially as it came out good on power and performance, I started with Mikita and now I’m sort of brand loyal
I'm aiming on getting makita all the way
I am not swapping my makita lol
I’m a big time Makita guy but this one is not good ,
I mean, for the price of batteries it’s hard NOT to be brand loyal. I prefer red. I do prefer Makita for corded tools though.
Please don’t buy the dbn600, it’s garbage👎🏽
I just got the Milwaukee gen 2 for Father's Day- excellent addition to my Milwaukee collection!
Excellent review Rob. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you for the awesome review once again I can't wait to see your review Milwaukee framing nailer
incredible review as always guys.. Im team red for most tools but would have loved to see Ryobi in here for the budget option.
Best analysis of top nail guns I’ve seen. Very helpful.
One of the best tool reviews I've seen. Great job.
I'm glad I found this video, I about wasted money on the makita nailer. Milwaukee for the win!
I just want to thank you Rob and the rest of the TOOL BOX BUZZ crew for all that you do. I am a young contractor who is just getting started out on my own, and videos like these are EXTREMELY valuable to me. I am able to get a clear concise idea of these tools before I make a purchase, and these tools arent cheap. So again I just wanted to thank you guys and say please keep up the great work!
Glad to have you onboard!
@@ConcordCarpenter We got a new Dewalt Brad Nailer Battery powered and every time it gets to the last ~8 nails they won't come out even though the battery is good.
@@joew.1274 Dry fire lockout
@@thepewplace1370 Do you know if all brad nailers have it?
@@joew.1274 I'm not confident in saying all of them, but it's been a standard feature for cordless nailers for a while, from brads up to framing nailers.
That was awesome guys!
I’m still loving dewalt
I look forward to all your other videos that you have done in the past and are very consistent Way to go guys!
I hold you guys up in the top tier of product/tool reviews. I would have loved to see the paslode in this as I'm thinking of making the switch from paslode to dewalt 18g nailers. I love my paslode but when it's not working as it should it nearly turns into a cannon ball!
I believe anyone of the top three you can’t go wrong. Since I’m already on the Makita platform of cordless tools and have had no complaints, I’ll go that route. I’m currently upgrading my 1948 home and believe the Makita will do a great job on tongue and groove ceiling installation!
Hi, how is that Makita nailer doing for you.??
I’m curious also, there’s a lot of bad reviews
Hands down, the best tool reviews. I love how you always address ergonomics. Comfort and ease of use are critical
Man thanks for your time for sharing that information that was pretty incredible to see and to make a decision on what nailer to purchase great job to you and your crew.
You do the best tool reviews.....anywhere I've found. I actually spend my money based upon these reviews. Thank you
Wow, thanks!
great video I'm going with Milwaukee all my tools are Milwaukee from my screw guns to my lights to my vacuum stores everything now it will include nail guns because I had Porter Cable whit the pancake compressor with the 3 guns and I will be selling that to purchase the Milwaukee nail guns
Well done! Very professional delivery with insightful info. Many thanks😊
Love the hard work and effort put in to these reviews. Thank you and keep up the good work!
I am a Woman! I wanted to buy a finishing nailer. I didn't have a clue. I wanted to put up some trimming on a wall for design. This review is amazing! You do not know how much you have helped! 👏🏾💪🏾
Modern day Tim the tool man Taylor great vid love the content 🤙🏽
The entire point of the Tim Taylor character was that he was an incompetent jackass...
So that is actually an insult.
All my tools are Makita but I went for the HiKoki brad nailer (Metabo HPT) because I seen other videos on it saying it wasn't that great and lacking in power , interesting you had a different view ,great in depth review again lads 👏🏼
Another STELLAR review! Fantastic. Thank you, Rob!
Do you have a review of "platforms"? I need a number of cordless brushless tools-- drill, driver, circular saw, grinder, nailers. Best in class using the same battery platform? DeWalt, Makita, Bosch, Milwaukee?
Great job on the video. Very clear and easy to understand. You really helped me make a decision on what to buy!! Thankyou
The Metabo HPT (Hitachi) nailers are just proven and way to reliable for me to even consider anything else. I can deal with the weight for something that always works flawlessly 🤟🏼
Hitachi air guns were good their cordless line is very cheesy in my opinion.
Shoot about 20k nails through it and then come back. Mine is currently in the shop because of low pressure. It was around the 20k nail mark where it stopped sinking nails at all. I'm sure once it's fixed it'l be great, but.. it's been in the shop for coming up 2 months now. (issues getting parts I believe) But it is all under warranty so there's at least that.
@@KahluaBomb Were you keeping it oiled?
My HPT 18 gauge cordless is an alright tool. It wont sink long brads in hard wood anymore and a piece of plactic broke so I have to tape the magazine shut. Probably go Milwaukee next time if Makita doesnt release a new one.
Proven JUNK!!!
Based on this review I would say the Makita is the best as it outperforms others by far where it matters.
Nope...it sucks
Thank you so much for your excellent and thorough review of these products
!
Thanks for watching!
Your graphes made my little scientist heart happy :)
Where's the Ryobi Airstrike?...
I love this channel and damn near every video you guys put up BUT I’m disappointed the Ryobi AirStrike wasn’t included. In another video it bested the Milwaukee and should have been in this video by you guys. Your videos are the standard I use for my purchases
That's the video with the Gen1 Milwaukee, right?
Olav Nikolai Skuterud
th-cam.com/video/5Aqq_PhZX0M/w-d-xo.html
Isaac Ocasio thats 1st gen. The 1st gen Milwaukee was pretty bad. 2nd gen is soooo much better
@@ViaEffects ryobi beats all others for the price tho. Its on par if not better than other and its only 99
Yup I'd buy the Ryobi Airstrike products over these based off of function & value.
Nice review u definitely help me on my decision. I’ve been doing trim work with my uncle for some time now using his tool. I’m looking to purchase my own, but thinking of going everything cordless Dewalt.
so I had actually ordered a Hikoki/Hitachi/whatever else they're called but due to a stuff up with the vendor ended up getting the Milwaukee and boy does it live up to the reviews you guys have here even 2 years down the track. very happy with it and you guys did a fantastic review of these tools!
If you use it a lot, you should find somewhere to recharge the nitrogen after a year, because they definitely wear out. Milwaukee will charge a few hundred to refurbish their nailers once they lose their oomph.
The Hikoki is on their 2nd gen now, lighter than the M18. I've never used it, though.
Great review and testing. I wish you would’ve added to the testing was how long does each tool last till battery change out from a fully charged battery? I’m pretty sure it will be Milwaukee but I’m interested to really know.
9:09, mostly even but DeWalt is pretty low
Great review by way been waiting on this one. Hopefully we will be seeing a review on Milwaukee’s 18 V framing nailer and their new 12 inch compound miter saw sometime in the near future keep up the good work really respect the testing and reviews and the time and detail you put into them!
Just got a hell of a deal on the Milwaukee 2746. 👍 Very happy with this purchase.
I'm a female just getting into wood projects - this video was SO helpful - thank you!!!
You are so welcome!
Fair enough-perhaps a bit pro Mill,but heh I'm a dewalt nut. Thank you - well done
I thought it was actually pro dew.
Would like to see if Bosch release a new 18v nailer.
They had one but stopped making it. I'm curious if they'll bring it back or make a new one, too
I just picked up the Gen 2 Milwaukee brad nailer. Your review was the deciding factor in going with the Milwaukee over the dewalt as I’m on both platforms with certain tools. Thx again appreciate your thorough reviews! Jd
4 mins into my first video on your channel and I subbed. Love the criteria, detail and depth and content in general. Great review!
Milwaukee seems to get so much right among so many of their tools. I wonder how they are so good at designing tools.
It's owned by China
R&D it is called. They are top tier in that game .I wished they payed as much attention in the quality control of their 18V line as well...
@@inactiveusertypeofaccount181, no Biden is owned by China, that’s why his name is China Joe. Milwaukee is owned by...TTI, however Milwaukee is a standalone company with it’s own P&L, headquartered in the US. They actually manufacture tools all around the world in Milwaukee owned factories. You can’t get quality control like they have if it’s OEM’d.
I wish that all of their manufacturing was in the US, but unfortunately it’s not. Maybe if Trump hadn’t had the election stolen from him and us by the do nothing Dems, MSM and Big Tech, we would’ve seen more manufacturing coming back to the US.
@@martylucas8557 HAHAHA. China Joe? Election stolen from trump? You already proved how much your honesty and opinion is worth.
@@immathug Is worth a lot...
Good review! I'm a little surprised no Ryobi 18Ga nailer though. (I have a soft spot for the underdog, lol)
He tested 4 nailers made by different companies.
Ryobi is made by the same company as Milwaukee.
Thank you. I will now be purchasing the Milwaukee tomorrow
I love your alls reviews thanks a million
The MAKITERRRrrr..... lmao had me laughing so hard I had to watch it several times
Erik Flores come to Boston
I love your vids man I can listen to you talk all day long man.
@@Erikfl348 thx
Just bought the Milwaukee gen 2 and I agree, it is better.
Yup boy
you are very professional sir great watching every time
Best unbiased reviews every time. Thanks
I have the Ryobi airstrike 18g and 16g and I love them
The worst thing about the Ryobi is that it needs to be coddled a good bit. Otherwise, it's a good nailer.
n4thb4dc0 We looked at top 4 Pro grade nailers and chose not to include the Ryobi / Ridgid / PorterCable / Senior . Maybe in hindsight we should have, oh well too late
A Concord Carpenter / ToolBoxBuzz maybe in the future there could be a “ 8 gun shoot out test “ 👍🏼
timothy weigall maybe - were working on a bigger sampling of pneumatic framers now
A Concord Carpenter / ToolBoxBuzz you guys are so Ryobi racist. I know their not as good but it’s nice to see where it comes. Love your videos though
Happy Milwaukee improved their brad nailer. I can't see myself buying it unless the price comes down though.
Likely to. With the supply that Milwaukee makes, sometimes stuff starts going for ridiculously cheap. The 12v FUEL drill was going for 45 dollars a little while ago because of some combo kit deal.
No kidding. You can buy a good compressor and gun for half the price. Granted you do have to drag around the hose and it is much louder. But you can also use the compress for a lot more stuff. But if the price were to come down to around 250 it would be a game changer.
The first gen one sucked. But yes, it's too expensive.
@@cuchanu Definitely worth the price though. Used both the Dewalt and Milwaukee, Milwaukee is a much better nailer in my opinion. No flywheel noise, no problem with tip marks on pine trim unlike the Dewalt, feels well balanced.....
Fantastic review! You guys were very complete.
Rob, once again awesome tool review! I personally want to Thank you and your team for taking the time to study, use, dissect and compile these stats and sharing this info with the rest of us. I’m happy to say that RED has not let me down again and I will soon be purchasing this new Brad nailer and they’re new frame nailer to add to my ever growing M18 platform!! Thanks again and keep up the good work! 👍
Shane Huff thx
Thank you for this, as I already have DeWALT cordless tools I’m going to go the DeWALT
Frank O'Keeffe you won't be disappointed
I wish you had included the Porter Cable PCC790LA these are serious contenders based upon balance and power.
Agreed I own it and for the price better than all 4
@@loucifer323 Good sir. I have 2 friends who have these and swear by them. They have let me use them and they are outstanding. Along with the 16 gauge recommended.
Always the best reviews on the tools you wanna buy...thanks
Thanks for the review. Very helpful.
Only just discovered this channel but I think it’s great. Your a great tool review channel. Keep up the great work 👍🏻
thanks
Very helpful video and confirmed what I thought before watching. Just from comparing the Dewalt, Milwaukee and Makita in the store, I can tell the Milwaukee felt the best in hand and stood out over the rest. Unfortunately, I had to go with the Mikata because that's the system of tools and batteries I have. If I ever have to do it all over again, Milwaukee is my pick. With that said, Makita products have always served me well and I have no issue with them but I feel like Milwaukee is just making better products these days.
You could have just got a battery converter adapter for Milwaukee to makita and use makita batteries with Milwaukee tools 🤣
Thanks for your time & effort, greatly appreciated! I noticed during testing the M18 High Output 3.0 (newer battery cells 21700) was being used rather than the kit battery(2.0 18650 older cells) if that might be a bump in the overall score in terms of power and depth of drive and etc. Let me know your thoughts on why the discrepancy, I personally notice a difference with the newer cell batteries on the M18 tools.
I have this Nail gun and the 15 and
16(GEN I),gauge and 23 gauge pin gun I guess my point is I’m pretty familiar with these guns and that is a good point but in the case of the nail gun it’s not added power it’s added runtime. The newer fuel tools are designed to take advantage of the architecture of the 21700 cell battery but that is depending on the tool and how it can best use that extra power that the newer high output batteries offer and with the nail gun it’s added runtime. I’m not saying there’s not a slight bump in power but if so it’s not noticeable But the extended run time is.
Very helpful! I just got into carpentry, and wanted to research which would be the most efficient. Carrying and laying out chords and hoses around is a lot of time taken out of the job at hand, and chordless is faster. Charging batteries can be done in downtime while you’re doing something else instead of waiting. Thanks you!