@@myriadofcolours9861 Also the fact he doesn't have much of a "Grand" story and was used to set up WHAT the Hargengers are while acting more like a Fatui grunt gave me the feeling he was going to be used as a thorough plot device. His Master's name was the ONLY teaser to what his future holds if fascinating. It's cool we might have a source to what the Hex and Hound was based on now because I didn't have a frame of reference for it before.
I've always suspected Childe's family of having Mondstadt roots like Rosalyne. His name Ajax doesn't sound like Snezhnayan like that of Andrei, Vlad, Nadia, or Etkarina. Even his brother Teucer doesn't have a Snezhnayan-sounding name. It wouldn't be a surprise to me if Genshin revealed him in the future to be an immigrant from Mondstadt.
Realistically speaking, there's no way the card looks like Childe for no reason. That'd be like giving two characters the same name without it being plot relevant. Also it's mentioned in the game that Ajax' father named him that to honor an ancient hero. He also only uses a bow in game because it's the only weapon he hasn't mastered yet.
It'd make sense, Eula also has strong claims to a family that ruled by nobility of deed, and strong sea related themes. lady of seafoam, her grandfather gifting her a bone whistle to emulate the sound of waves. Seas and Sea journeys (like Thoma BG) seems to be a strong part of Monstadt lore.
I wonder if we'd see Childe again whenever we get Dorman Port since it's the only location of the region connected to sea and that's how they trade with other nations
Wasn't the bone whistle a gift from Amber's Grandfather? He gave it to Eula as a gift from his travels to Liyue, and we learn that the bone whistle has origins from Liyue.
considering how mondstadt is surrounded by the open sea and its people make a big deal out of their ports, it's no surprise if sea and seafaring is a big part of their lore/history/culture
This doesn’t really make sense... they are not that identical, but Russians and Germans are similiar anyway. I'd say you are able to recognize Russians and Germans, but only if you are used to both. Mondstadter and Shneznayans looking similiar is expected
@@Moonlight_Shad0w Nicholas II, his wife and Georges V were all grandchildren of Queen Victoria and all of them had German origins. So a uncle, a brother, a grandfather or whatever of the family of Thomas could have settle to Sneznhaya and established a new bloodline there. It's just a funny idea. ^^
Except if by that theory, that'll mean Thoma's true root was somehow in Inazuma, but migrated to Mondstadt then back to Inazuma again, bcs he uses Inazuma talent materials, not Mondstadt...
So does that mean that Paimon and the traveler when trying to hide Childe's identity accidentally revealed his origins Instead? Completely by accident that is Paimon's imagination To those who are confused after reading this😅😅 I'm referring to the Shiki taishou event in 2.2. In the story of the event when Xinyan questions the traveler about how they know Childe, Paimon and Traveler make up a story of Childe being a "Mondstadt adventurer who is prone to danger" @Ashikai loved the video 👍👍 Would love to see more of such character analysis and inspiration analysis every once in a while if not regularly
That was pretty funny ngl, i liked that event. Meeting the dude in Liyue, hails from Snezh, prances around in countries, and now if he was Mondstadt born? Truly Mr. Worldwide.
Yknow, one of the most strange things I've always thought about Childe's story is how he just happened to fall into a hole after being lost in a snowstorm. Like this could have happened to anyone else, why Childe? I later looked up that he was chased by bears and wolf packs, basically into the hole, and now I'm, wondering... Maybe Skirk Called him down there? Like out in the snow, you have this kid get chased by wild animals down into the abyss so his ancestors can teach him the way of combat? I think this analysis provides us with a lot more information to base our theories off of. (Skirk borrowing her ol' pal R's wolf creations to chase a child into the abyss, anyone?)
After learning scaramouche's full story I always wondered if some of the fatuui members were made and not recruited. So my theory was he was pushed but now it does seem like he was lured there. I wonder how long we'll need to wait to get more of his story 😭
I used to not like Childe much, but my appreciation of his character and potential allusions and inspirations have grown tenfold now! Thank you, as usual, for the delicious food of thought.
I used to think that he uses Mondstadt books and Liyue starconches because when he came out, Mond and Liyue were the only two nations released so what else were they going to do? This theory is much more fun, though! Headcanon accepted! 😊
Childe having inspirations from Cú Chulainn and Scathach, two iconic Fate Lancers, gave me so much joy as a lot of the playerbase has been saying that Childe is a Fate Archer bec of his kit 🤣 But back to Childe's connection to Parsifal, maybe bec it's common knowledge, but it wasn't mentioned in the vid that Osial, who Childe summoned in the Archon quest, is a sea monster with tentacles, so more kraken reference?
I saw lore about my favourite character and I had to click on it. AND OMG! I'm so happy finally the connections between Childe and Mondstadt is being explored. Thank you so much Ashikai! Edit: 11:07 When Enka first dropped I could not stop thinking about how eerily similar the broken stone spears looked to Childe's hydro spear. I ruled it out as something maybe related to what Skirk taught him, but finally after nearly a year, my question has been answered. I feel satiated.
Never thought I'd see the day that Cu Chulainn would be mentioned in a Genshin theory... he really is similar to Childe, since he abandoned his old name (Setanta) after killing a beast (it was a dog, but still). Also, as far as I remember, he used a hurley to kill the dog, maybe Ajax used something similar to kill an abyss monster?
I have never heard Scathach pronounced like that, it's normally Sca-hawk because Gaelic doesn't care how something is written, it will be spoken however it wants
Yeah the pronunciation was a bit weird, though about how Gaelic words are pronounced, if you know a bit of Irish or other Gaelic languages the rules of pronouncing things aren't too difficult just different from English
I’m not gonna lie the pronunciation in the video killed me. I do quite like the idea that childe is descended from Parcifal though. Makes sense given the artwork. It is still very strange to equate the descendant of arthurian Percival with ulster cycle Cu Chulainn though. I don’t think the analogy fits very well. Cu and Childe don’t really fit together that well. There were a bunch of heroes with transformative berserk modes. Also foul transformation and Cu’s warp spasms don’t fit together that well. Also Gae Bulg was a barbed spear, not a hooked spear. It was also launched by the foot and not the hand. Childe uses it in his hand and specifically with his delusion and not his vision. So I don’t think Cu was the prime inspiration for Childe. Though his teacher being inspired by scathach isn’t that surprising, as she’s one of the coolest warrior women in all of mythology.
It's not so strange as you think. In reality Arthurian legends and Germanic and Celtic mythologies have many similarities/common themes. Just look at Morgan le Fay and Morrigan, Arthur and Siegfried for exemple.
Finally a sane and reasonable comment on this video. I just scrolled down to see if anyone actually realized how off all her assertions were. She is gonna combine all of south east asian and south asian mythology into one giant coagulation with the way she equates one myth to another.
@@mizuhashitsunokaI mean Hoyoverse used that exact approach for the entirety of Sumeru's lore, like really mixing Buddhist, Iranian, and Egyptian legends that have little to do with each other. And everyone agrees Mondstadt is like based on German and Old Norse legends but Venti himself is based on the Greco-Roman wind gods. Pretty much all of Teyvat is a mishmash of different mythologies. Compared to all that, connecting Childe with Cu Chulainn isn't so far off. And if I'm remembering correctly, wasn't Cu Chulainn's spear made from sea monster bone? There's another Childe parallel for ya.
At this point, associating a character only by their hairstyle is not a stretch. The developers are amazingly good with details. They know what they're doing. It's not a coincidence.
Childe is a walking Fate reference. He's an archer that doesn't use his bow most of the time. He's a reference to Cu Chulainn as well. That red hair? Doesn't that remind you of Shirou? Case closed.
I always assumed Childe took Freedom books as of the six ideals that existed at the time of his release, that one fit his personality the best. This version is much better. You've convinced me :). I wonder if Circe's story and the story of the Blue-Eyes-Spear-Witch parallel each other any....
Yk the funny thing was when I first started playing Genshin, I literally knew nothing about the game. So the first time I heard of Childe was by that one Fatui Dude in Mondstadt. Because of the name 'Childe', which means Young Master, and because I didn't know that the fatui were some other organization from Snezhnaya, I thought Childe was an important and greatly revered young master from Mondstadt nobility and that he was one of the knights (the best one too 💀😅)
3:27, 4:11, 12:12 "Cray-ken" 8:54 "Poi-seidon" Dunno why but these pronunciations stood out to me a ton and I found it quite amusing XD Is this like a very specific regional accent thing?
Usually i’d have to do my own research into an abundance of Wikipedia pages when watching Ashikai’s videos But this theory was really easy from beginning to end since i’m a fate fan😅
Parsifal could also be Cu Chulainn. In the legends, he makes a deal with Scathach twin sister Aife to spare her life in exchange for her leaving Scathach alone and bearing him a child. That could explain how Childe is both related to the Blue Eyed Witch and Parsifal, and there being no record of Blue Eyed Witch meeting Parsifal after the second time.
Counter theory as to why Childe uses Mondstat talent books: Coz Mihoyo made the worst talent domain and wanted to punish players who wished for Childe 😅
It'd be interesting if this theory turns out to be true! I hope they give us more Childe content soon. Also, you mentioned Cu Chulainn and Scathach and all the Fate fans came out of their caves to comment lol (I'm also a Fate fan).
Okay, I need to scream. You cannot start a video about Childe saying he has never been to Mondstadt. Dragonspine is a part of Mondstadt and we know he goes there to remind himself of Snezhnaya because of climate. His artifact set is also located there.
I am always amazed about all the things that Ashikai manages to pull out of and put into Genshin's lore. There is so much depth, so many references and quite a few things will probably turn out right... I love it.
I would say it’s bc his books r freedom. Childe is well known to be free to do whatever and go wherever he pleases. He’s a free spirit, but he’s also sworn his life to serving another, so he’ll never really be free
Yeah no, this "Childe is from Mondstadt" is even bigger crack than the "Childe is from Enkanomiya" theory. 1. According to this logic, Wanderer's talent books should be from Inazuma, Thoma's from Mond and Amber's from Liyue. But that's not the case, now is it? 2. "Childe's specialty dish looks like cranken that killed Parsifal"... or you know, Osial, the big tentacle monster Childe summoned Edit: 3. The connections between Skirk and blue-eyed witch are stronger, but I don't see how she can't just be his teacher without being related. I also don't see why a noble from hex & hound can't be unrelated to Parsifal (Skirk is also described as a swordswoman, not a spear...woman, but I guess she can be both) 4. The descriptions of artifacts and weapons are usually factual, I think? That would mean that Parsifal DID die in the battle with the sea monster and didn't reunite with his lover. Unless they had a child(e) before he left Mond of course, but I don't think it was mentioned anywhere 5. The whole thing happened like a 1000 years ago. I doubt that the genes for orange hair and blue eyes would carry through generations for so long. Eula for example doesn't look like her ancestors from 1000 years ago
I have a fun bit to add to the theory that makes it even funnier to me. The place were Scathach taught these Irish heroes is Dun Scaith, which (according to Wikipedia anyway) is also known as the Fortress of Shadows. And where to Skirk teach young Ajax? In the Abyss, a place associated with Darkness. Oh and one more fun connection. The Gae Bolg/Bulg is said to be made of bone from a sea monster. which further relates to the Mondstadt Parsifal. Not only that, but being of bone and a sea monster also makes me think of Child's constellation. Monoceros Caeli, a narwhal. In other words a "sea monster" known for its "bone-like" horn (Incorrectly so, since it's actually a tooth.) Very loose connections, but very fun coincidences to throw into this soup of a Childe theory!
Or, or Childe was one of the first characters released in the time we only had Mondstald and Lyue released, and Sneznaya is gonna be out more at the end of the game, so they had to give him some talent books. Still, great video
I mean, this is what I always thought, but they could've given him Liyue talent books, like they do with other characters released in regions different than their own (see Kazuha or Scara). He was not once in Mondstadt (despite his first rerun making us believe he was going to be there lol). It could also be that they were experimenting since he was a really early 5-star, but it's definitely a curious choice they made.
And also does anybody know how he got his vision? if you check in his character story it doesn't show how he got his vision but instead shows delusion I would love to what theory you will make about this ashikai love ur theories!!! ❤❤
I've know of the Ajax and Cersei (after Hexenzirkel video) connection, I'm also quite fond of Childe's character - such a nice shade of gray. I did not know of Chulainn. That's quite interesting, I have to go read more of it. Yes. I love the character inspiration series (start?). So much potential.
I always assumed he used Mondstadt books because he's not from Mondstadt, he's not from Liyue, and we probably wouldn't get Snezhnaya for like five years at the time of his release, so they just said fuck it and gave him whatever. 😂 Also, aren't the books assigned by region and by a character's ideals/circumstances, so maybe the thought the freedom books suited him better than any of the Liyue ones?
Pronunciations aside, this is the first time I've ever heard of the Gae Bolg referred to as a harpoon. In the myth it was 'barbed' instead of 'hooked' to cause an enormous amount of pain and not be easily removed from the wound. I'm not saying that calling it a harpoon is wrong in any way but I've never really thought of it as one. It does make some sense.
Hi Ash - this isn't a request for a video so much as me being curious. Have you tried doing this style of analysis for anyone in Sumeru yet? I've attempted it a little myself, but I find a lot of the potential cultural meta surrounding their outfits are really...muddled. Just wondering if you've had the same experience.
Childe: Greek name along with greek named brother, fell in the abyss, met Skirk, Enkanomiya being based of off greek, has a weapon that looks similar to those in Enkanomiya, polar star weapon, fatui harbinger Her: Mondstadt!
I was missing childe content earlier and then Ashikai of all people bless us w a banger childe theory thank you childe stans have been w/o content for so long. I love this theory so much
Y'know, this shines a whole different light on that Labyrinth Warriors event scene where Paimon lied to Xinyan by claiming that Childe is an adventurer *_from Mondstadt._* I caught that the "adventurer" part references how he wanted to be an adventurer as a kid, but I wondered why Paimon chose Mondstadt, of all places, to claim that he's from.
about that part, I always thought that because there are only 3 nations we know at that time, and Monstadt is nearer Snezhnaya more than Liyue, so in term of appearance Monstadt and Snezhnaya people should be more similar than Liyue and Snezhnaya
@@MyTAnh-xu6og I suppose, but she really could have just said he was an adventurer who traveled all the way from Snezhnaya. I just think it would be interesting if this theory is true and Paimon saying he's from Mondstadt was a fun little foreshadowing.
Kazuha uses Liyue talent books even though clearly and canonically he is from Inazuma. Isn't it simply that at the time of their release their nation isn't out yet? Thoma being the exception as even his vision is that of Inazuma.
But why not Liyue? Surely that would make sense since there is where he currently resides. Kazuha does so too, and he did get the Liyue talent books. Whatever happened to Childe.
As soon as I first heard about Skirk back in 1.1 I immediately imagined her as Scathach from FGO and I'm so glad that I've (probably) been imagining her about right.
It's a cool format! I got gut punched because Cu is my favorite fate/ characters and Childe is a character I really like in Genshin. ...I would say these aren't likely to be related but Fate/Grand Order is the father of modern gacha games and it wouldn't be too farfetched to say they started there (or the original Fate/ Stay Night for that matter), then went back to the source materials for Cu Chulainn. This was an amazing analysis. Dear god.
Correction: Childe had been to Mondstadt before. He was in Dragonspine in one of the EP videos. But great video, holy crap! I've been talking with my friend about how the Heart of Depth artifact is connected to Childe and how the Hex & Hound book is connected to it, too. When I discovered this video, it made me and my friend feel heard! You explained the connections a lot better than we did, and now it's all making a lot more sense to me! I can now refer to this video when I talk about it, thank you so much! 🙏
Oh this was great... yeah he's a son-of-a-witch. Very witty, Ashikai. Enjoyed the new format. Looking forward to new 3.6 Sumeru zone lore!!! I figure another week or so!
Please please please make more of these!!! I am especially interested in Yoimiya, cause honestly I don’t really think that she is that simple of a character
childe has such weird lore like i read a tweet threat where they pointed out that he also has so many and also very strong ties to enkanomiya as in not only having been there but also his family actually being from enka and im just like...he really is Mr. Worldwide
Childe was released in 1.1 or 2 so he really was given Mondstadt talent books just to balance the cast. Also, Thoma uses Inazuma books, and Wanderer who still has Inazuman roots, uses Sumerians.
Okay hear me out, that could also VERY well be why Childe in fact has a blonde strand of hair. Another thing to note is that his foul legacy form looks like a seelie so I'm really wondering how that can be connected - but that's just a food for thought lol Childe is pretty interesting lore wise and once we get there - if they ever bother to explain - it's gonna slap harder than his riptide👀
i was wonderign has anyone made any connections to skirk and the oceanids and the water animals it produces? especially with the Circe reference it is interesting to think about
Wait so Skirk might have taken Childe under her wing because she either realised he was (her and?) Parcival's descendant or otherwise thought he looked like her old lover?? God that's such an intruiging possibility
I always thought that he had his talents in monstadt bc snezhaya isn’t out yet and monstadt is close to snezhaya and that the books he needs are called freedom. He looks pretty free to me
Wait a second... Ashikai also has red fluffy hair and blue eyes, does that mean... ASHKAI IS ALSO A DESCENDAND OF THE BLUE EYED WITCH???!!?!!?!11 😱😱😱😱😱😱
Abyss herald and lectors are from the Abyss and predate khaenriha. They are not human but like skirk they are from the Abyss. That is why child's foul legacy looks like a herald and not a lector who wield a catalyst weapon as suppose to herald who wield a melee weapon. I think the herald and lector are from a race in Abyss that are like the dragon race who lived a light realm and I think before sun and moon those two realms coexistence was a battle over power and balance like jing and jang. Then came the decend3r or second who came or primordial one and forced the human realm in between them. Something like that.
What you probably missed: 1) It's Nottfriega who turned the nobleman (Dietrich) into a dog. The implication of Dietrich missing ultimately caused the Lawrence to fall. 2) Nottfriega (and Magdalene)'s mother was the one said to be a witch. Nottfriega knew dark magic (from her mother) as Magdalene knew light. Apparently they shared body for a bit. 3) Mondstadt's yellow blonde hair and blue eyes is always implication to be correlated with the Gunnhildr. Like Jean gets her hair color from her mom (which doesn't appear in Barbara because her hair resembles more of her dad. Barbara is more like this light ash - light blonde, but Barbara still counts as a blonde because they want to note her as Jean's little sister, regardless.) In the end Mondstadt still abides the circle rule, and since Parsifal was a nobility, her lover the Blue-Eyed Spear Witch was probably also of nobility. Maybe one of the branches of the Gunnhildr or even the Gunnhildr themselves. Reminder: the only source of info for the Gunnhildr's "motive of participation" during the rebellion era was that of the Biography of the Gunnhildr, written... ofc by a Gunnhildr. Even if Jean talks about this biography a lot, she prob knew this was just propaganda by her ancestor to legitimize the Gunnhildr's "rule" over Mondstadt. Since any history can or has been tampered either 500 years ago or long ago, but any allegory tends to miss being tampered as they were already fictionalized in the first place, this is what created inconsistency regarding the whole rebellion saga. All we know is that in the end, Venti "used" Venessa and her quest to turn the wheel around.
My guess? I've been guessing Childe's connection to Mondstadt since day 1. Just like how they include Mona as Mondstadt cast despite being fully Fontaine. My guess atm (after reading around and watching your video and reading again) is like: 1) Dietrich in the Hex & Hound is obvious allegory to Eberhart, who went missing in the Dragonspine expedition after he basically tried to kill most of the aristocracy member. They never found out his real fate (he was grievously wounded and was last told to be travelling via the river to Cider lake from Dragonspine). The allegory explicitly changed the weapon from spear to sword, as sword was a sign of nobility in Mondstadt + hey it's an allegory. They wanted to avoid getting tampered by fate. Eberhart's real fate that is unknown now was probably the part that got tampered in Irminsul/the record in general/both. As even if Eberhart was a despicable person, he was the true conspirator of the rebellion against the aristocracy. (this implies he's involved with the forbidden knowledge or some kind later down the line, but that's unimportant in this context). 2) Eberhart never killed the blue-eyed spear witch. That part was tampered either by someone via Irminsul, or by the records, or by the witch herself, or by Eberhart himself which Venti acquiesced. The witch fled to Snezhnaya, where her fate is unknown (either she is Skirk, or Childe's mother/ancestor, or both, we don't know). Reminder that Venti and the Tsaritsa used to be good friends, before they fell out of favor. Back then they were still friends. So it made sense for Venti to ask for her favor. a) another possible twist was that he did kill her, but it was known and let to be by the blue-witch, or it was consensual between them. 3) However this had turned out, this was the main motive the Gunnhildr taking the side of the rebel, after the "failure" of Eberhart and his lover Priscilla. The Gunnhildr was always closer to the military side of Mondstadt (the side that Venti lied to) + there was really no reason to keep up with the aristocracy, now that the aristocracy was totally paralyzed due to losing Parsifal, and then Ingbert and Eberhart. The relationship between the Gunnhildr and Eberhart's faction never got ruined, since they knew of the truth. 4) and all in all, Venti prob knew and chose to neglect this condition, deciding to let Eberhart self-destruct the aristocracy from within, before then he chose his "prophetess", his champion to swoop in.
btw, hounds and wolves are always a thematic close to Mondstadt due to their mixed heritage with Andrius. One such instance was that of Rostam (Rosalyne "La Signora"'s lover, who died in the cataclysm 500 years ago) was known as the "wolf's pup". another one, ofc, is Razor, who is just Jungle Book. so having Eberhart getting allegory as a "hound" via Dietrich either tells the truth of his fate after the tragedy in Dragonspine, or his origin, instead ("illegitimiate child", reminder).
@Ashikai is there a reason you say it kray-kin and not crack-in similar to your pronoun citation of tighnari and Nahida? Also is tartalia a different character than childe? His in universe name is tar-ta-galia. Commonly mispronounced as tartalia and tartaglia, took me a while to realize the actual pronunciation as well.
little late to the game, but has anyone pointed out that the blue-eyed witch is probably ivanova of the hexenzirkel? you know, the only witch we know of that seems to have some ties to schnezniya, the russian-based region? and that further inspection shows that her and parcival's doomed love story mirrors that of jason of the argonaughts and princess medea, high priestess of hecete (aka the goddess of witchcraft, and therefore a very powerful witch herself), of greek mythology? i bring this up only cause i literally watched this vid back-to-back of your hexenzirkel rundown, and kinda connected the dots from the small lore-tidbits we have of both parcival and ivanova, and (given your theory craft for nicole) further wondered what that potential mythological connection could tell us about ivanova's possible role both within the zirkel, and within the larger metanarritive for genshin. personally, i think she's playing distraction for the zirkel, since medea was often depicted as dangerously clever, and prone to using deception and distraction to fell her enemies. maybe she's using both herself and possible childe/maybe the fatui as a whole to distract celestia while her sisters work in the shadows she's casting? thoughts?
This theory is rather stupid. In that case, why does Scaramouche use Sumaru talent books and those stupid shrooms that Collei uses(although I think he should have used the Maguu Kenki drops would have made more sense cuz I believe Maguu Kenki was built using the similar Khaenri'ahn technology but the drake still fits), or why does Kazuha use talent books from Liyue. I mean are fucks sack Childe's regional ascension material is from Liyue, The Starconches, just like Yalan. The real reason that there were barely any Snezhayan materials in the game in the 1.0 patches, literally the only ones were the Fatui enemy drops
I'm just started watching this video don't hate me for saying this I'm just saying this for fun I think childe is one of the earliest 5 star character and we need his meterial to upgrade hie tallent level so the might be chosen a random domain i guess And now im gonna watch the video
Skirk can also be inspired by the Norse Goddess Skadi because Scáthach and the goddess are thought of to have the same origin of inspiration. This would mean that Skirk would not only be an expert in combat and weaponry but might also be able to use runes that are second only from the runes used by Odin.
В который раз автор натянул сову на глобус. Откуда взяться книгам из Снежной в начале игры? Чайльд появился, когда были открыты только два региона. Простая игровая условность, которая никак не связана с лором.
A thing I found funny is that the first thing Paimon calls him to hide his identity is "he's from Mondstadt". Not only Thoma was supposed to be a different side of the same coin with Tartaglia. Also he didn't appear in the Mondstadt archon quest and I'm kinda disappointed.
I had a theory that Childe was originally from Mondstadt because of the talent books, but my theory was far more simplistic. It seems the fatui are filling their ranks with orphan children. Specifically orphan children from other nations. It was even hinted at that the fatui might be the ones that made them orphans in the first place. We hear about this recruiting of foreign children first in the Inazuma quest chain about Gendou Ringo's strange fortune slips, and it was mentioned also in the quest chain with a group of fatui during the second appearance of the golden apple archipelago. During this (sadly event locked) quest we found out, that these orphaned children refer to each other as their siblings, which would explain why Tartaglia has "siblings". So I theorized that Childe might very well be one of these orphaned children that were taken in to be made into fatui.
When I heard about Skirk my first thought was Scáthach (thanks Fate/GO) and I'm really glad that I'm not the only one, who thinks there may be a connection.
Talking about "Hound", so this is probably useless information, but since you once talked about Mona and her ability to see the fate from ones constallation. I have a official Mona-Stand from mihoyoverse as a little merchandise. It's a two part stand and it has a ring around Mona in the background that shows...animals, but they remind me of constallations, since there is a lion (Jean's constallation) and a falcon (Diluc's constallation) and a dragon (???) and, well, the a wolf (it looks like one). It's probably just random icons but when you said "hound" and Mondstadt, I noticed my Mona on my desk. 😅 Again, I think it's useless information bc merch probably isn't as deep and they just throw something on it. But the comment at least boosts the algorhythm. 🥰
So basically, Childe is a ginger who wields both a bow and two short swords, whose real name is Ajax, may or may not have a connection to Cu Chulainn and Percival, and is voiced by Ryohei Kimira in Japanese. What is this, a Fate fan's wet dream?
![[3.4] Are we missing a harbinger? - A Genshin Impact Theory](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yTARw6XjaiE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[3.4] Are we missing a harbinger? - A Genshin Impact Theory](/img/tr.png)
![[3.5] A First Look at the Hexenzirkel - Genshin Impact Lore & Theory](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/J4DMk5M3MP8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2.4] Enkanomiya Recap & Analysis - Genshin Impact](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pirZjZrXiSk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[3.3] The Complete Scaramouche Design Analysis](/img/n.gif)
Childe’s just the character that keeps on giving lmao. Introduced in Liuye and will be relevant all the way till Snezhnaya
Mr. Worldwide always comes back
truly
@@Anticaat HE DOES FR
@@yang2chan lol the stream was 3 days ago and u watch this childe lore video
@@reinhardvanastrea7793 u watched it too lol
I have a gut feeling that Childe's lore will be wild
Me too
I read somewhere that Hoyo said Childe is essentially a walking spoiler
And that a lot of his lore and story had to be purposefully left out
@Myriad Of Colours Where'd you hear that?? Because if its true goddamn I'm hyped for the future story
@@myriadofcolours9861 Also the fact he doesn't have much of a "Grand" story and was used to set up WHAT the Hargengers are while acting more like a Fatui grunt gave me the feeling he was going to be used as a thorough plot device. His Master's name was the ONLY teaser to what his future holds if fascinating.
It's cool we might have a source to what the Hex and Hound was based on now because I didn't have a frame of reference for it before.
Unless he fcking dies, that is.
Thank you for feeding us Childe fans with such good food
Fr, we've been starving for months at this point
Yes, he's my favorite character and I will eat any content about him up
Yeah childe is so interesting but since he is from shneznaya we can’t find more about him now
I’m still not over the betrayal of his event with Yoimiya being cut down to three time-sensitive, unvoiced NPC dialogues.
@@lancerguy3667 pretty sure they were only two dialogues! They were voiced though
I've always suspected Childe's family of having Mondstadt roots like Rosalyne. His name Ajax doesn't sound like Snezhnayan like that of Andrei, Vlad, Nadia, or Etkarina. Even his brother Teucer doesn't have a Snezhnayan-sounding name. It wouldn't be a surprise to me if Genshin revealed him in the future to be an immigrant from Mondstadt.
Ajax and Teucer and names from Greek mythology.
He's a snezhnayan 🙏
Ekaterina* tho?
@@childe07200 nah, evidence points out that he is Serbian
and also his sister tonia and younger brother Anthon
Realistically speaking, there's no way the card looks like Childe for no reason. That'd be like giving two characters the same name without it being plot relevant.
Also it's mentioned in the game that Ajax' father named him that to honor an ancient hero. He also only uses a bow in game because it's the only weapon he hasn't mastered yet.
it totally makes sense now why Childe's basic attack animations include him throwing an arrow with a hand and hitting opponent with the bow lol
if this is true i would love see childe interactions with skirk , but also if he really is based on Cu Chulainn it means his death flags just double
the man has too many death flags already. another one is just a drip of water now
I will cry if he dead
@@hymm0 me too , he is my favorite character by far in genshin
Just his name being Ajax is 10x red flags
@@softjytsu his name being Ajax and having a brother named Teucer is 10x red flag
It'd make sense, Eula also has strong claims to a family that ruled by nobility of deed, and strong sea related themes. lady of seafoam, her grandfather gifting her a bone whistle to emulate the sound of waves. Seas and Sea journeys (like Thoma BG) seems to be a strong part of Monstadt lore.
I wonder if we'd see Childe again whenever we get Dorman Port since it's the only location of the region connected to sea and that's how they trade with other nations
Wasn't the bone whistle a gift from Amber's Grandfather?
He gave it to Eula as a gift from his travels to Liyue, and we learn that the bone whistle has origins from Liyue.
considering how mondstadt is surrounded by the open sea and its people make a big deal out of their ports, it's no surprise if sea and seafaring is a big part of their lore/history/culture
That explains why Thoma and Tartaglia are so identical at first glance. They both from Mondstadt but ended up in another region.
Hmm sounds like they are regional twins
It would be funny if they're could be distants cousins. xD
This doesn’t really make sense... they are not that identical, but Russians and Germans are similiar anyway. I'd say you are able to recognize Russians and Germans, but only if you are used to both. Mondstadter and Shneznayans looking similiar is expected
@@Moonlight_Shad0w Nicholas II, his wife and Georges V were all grandchildren of Queen Victoria and all of them had German origins. So a uncle, a brother, a grandfather or whatever of the family of Thomas could have settle to Sneznhaya and established a new bloodline there.
It's just a funny idea. ^^
Except if by that theory, that'll mean Thoma's true root was somehow in Inazuma, but migrated to Mondstadt then back to Inazuma again, bcs he uses Inazuma talent materials, not Mondstadt...
Childe getting lots of love today with new set and new theory
Please his new set is also giving me the trauma I had when I farmed for the HoD set 😭
So does that mean that Paimon and the traveler when trying to hide Childe's identity accidentally revealed his origins Instead? Completely by accident that is Paimon's imagination
To those who are confused after reading this😅😅
I'm referring to the Shiki taishou event in 2.2.
In the story of the event when Xinyan questions the traveler about how they know Childe, Paimon and Traveler make up a story of Childe being a "Mondstadt adventurer who is prone to danger"
@Ashikai loved the video 👍👍
Would love to see more of such character analysis and inspiration analysis every once in a while if not regularly
Childe isn’t from Mondstadt
@@jakthesac5175 i never said he was.
That was pretty funny ngl, i liked that event.
Meeting the dude in Liyue, hails from Snezh, prances around in countries, and now if he was Mondstadt born?
Truly Mr. Worldwide.
Hol up. Hol up. What if it was paimon's planning all along?
@@anirbanghosh752paimon the mastermind
Yknow, one of the most strange things I've always thought about Childe's story is how he just happened to fall into a hole after being lost in a snowstorm. Like this could have happened to anyone else, why Childe? I later looked up that he was chased by bears and wolf packs, basically into the hole, and now I'm, wondering... Maybe Skirk Called him down there? Like out in the snow, you have this kid get chased by wild animals down into the abyss so his ancestors can teach him the way of combat? I think this analysis provides us with a lot more information to base our theories off of. (Skirk borrowing her ol' pal R's wolf creations to chase a child into the abyss, anyone?)
After learning scaramouche's full story I always wondered if some of the fatuui members were made and not recruited. So my theory was he was pushed but now it does seem like he was lured there. I wonder how long we'll need to wait to get more of his story 😭
BerylMorgan you were kinda right. Skirk taught Childe because he had awakened IT
I am shocked that you didn’t mention that Cu Chulainn is sometimes referred to as the “Child of Light”
I used to not like Childe much, but my appreciation of his character and potential allusions and inspirations have grown tenfold now! Thank you, as usual, for the delicious food of thought.
I used to think that he uses Mondstadt books and Liyue starconches because when he came out, Mond and Liyue were the only two nations released so what else were they going to do?
This theory is much more fun, though! Headcanon accepted! 😊
Could be Teachings/Guide/Philosophies of Gold especially considering how Zhongli used him as a walking wallet 💀💀💀
@@seonsunnysunshinethat payment under zhongli name are indeed golden teaching.
Finally, someone noticed the Scathach-Skirk connection! Been playing FGO for a while and my mental image of Skirk is someone like Shishou.
Childe having inspirations from Cú Chulainn and Scathach, two iconic Fate Lancers, gave me so much joy as a lot of the playerbase has been saying that Childe is a Fate Archer bec of his kit 🤣
But back to Childe's connection to Parsifal, maybe bec it's common knowledge, but it wasn't mentioned in the vid that Osial, who Childe summoned in the Archon quest, is a sea monster with tentacles, so more kraken reference?
I saw lore about my favourite character and I had to click on it. AND OMG! I'm so happy finally the connections between Childe and Mondstadt is being explored. Thank you so much Ashikai!
Edit: 11:07 When Enka first dropped I could not stop thinking about how eerily similar the broken stone spears looked to Childe's hydro spear. I ruled it out as something maybe related to what Skirk taught him, but finally after nearly a year, my question has been answered. I feel satiated.
Never thought I'd see the day that Cu Chulainn would be mentioned in a Genshin theory... he really is similar to Childe, since he abandoned his old name (Setanta) after killing a beast (it was a dog, but still). Also, as far as I remember, he used a hurley to kill the dog, maybe Ajax used something similar to kill an abyss monster?
I have never heard Scathach pronounced like that, it's normally Sca-hawk because Gaelic doesn't care how something is written, it will be spoken however it wants
Same, it was kinda weird to hear.
Yeah the pronunciation was a bit weird, though about how Gaelic words are pronounced, if you know a bit of Irish or other Gaelic languages the rules of pronouncing things aren't too difficult just different from English
Thank you for giving us some Tartaglia content. Sometimes I feel like hoyo forgot about my boy. 😞 I need more Childe lore
Tartagalia*
@@jonaskennedy ?
@@jonaskennedy No, its obviously Tagliatelle 😒
@@xkaraaa you left out the a that goes after g. It’s tar-tag-alia
@@jonaskennedy His in game name is Tartaglia tho?
i LOVE how you manage to even discover all of this just because childe uses mondstat book!!! i'm full from all the childe crumbs today🤤
I’m not gonna lie the pronunciation in the video killed me. I do quite like the idea that childe is descended from Parcifal though. Makes sense given the artwork.
It is still very strange to equate the descendant of arthurian Percival with ulster cycle Cu Chulainn though. I don’t think the analogy fits very well. Cu and Childe don’t really fit together that well. There were a bunch of heroes with transformative berserk modes. Also foul transformation and Cu’s warp spasms don’t fit together that well. Also Gae Bulg was a barbed spear, not a hooked spear. It was also launched by the foot and not the hand. Childe uses it in his hand and specifically with his delusion and not his vision. So I don’t think Cu was the prime inspiration for Childe. Though his teacher being inspired by scathach isn’t that surprising, as she’s one of the coolest warrior women in all of mythology.
It's not so strange as you think. In reality Arthurian legends and Germanic and Celtic mythologies have many similarities/common themes. Just look at Morgan le Fay and Morrigan, Arthur and Siegfried for exemple.
Finally a sane and reasonable comment on this video. I just scrolled down to see if anyone actually realized how off all her assertions were. She is gonna combine all of south east asian and south asian mythology into one giant coagulation with the way she equates one myth to another.
@@mizuhashitsunokaI mean Hoyoverse used that exact approach for the entirety of Sumeru's lore, like really mixing Buddhist, Iranian, and Egyptian legends that have little to do with each other. And everyone agrees Mondstadt is like based on German and Old Norse legends but Venti himself is based on the Greco-Roman wind gods. Pretty much all of Teyvat is a mishmash of different mythologies. Compared to all that, connecting Childe with Cu Chulainn isn't so far off. And if I'm remembering correctly, wasn't Cu Chulainn's spear made from sea monster bone? There's another Childe parallel for ya.
After Fontaine's archon quest wraps up, I'd LOVE a follow-up to this video.
At this point, associating a character only by their hairstyle is not a stretch. The developers are amazingly good with details. They know what they're doing. It's not a coincidence.
Childe is a walking Fate reference.
He's an archer that doesn't use his bow most of the time.
He's a reference to Cu Chulainn as well.
That red hair? Doesn't that remind you of Shirou?
Case closed.
I always assumed Childe took Freedom books as of the six ideals that existed at the time of his release, that one fit his personality the best. This version is much better. You've convinced me :). I wonder if Circe's story and the story of the Blue-Eyes-Spear-Witch parallel each other any....
never even thought that could be a possibility, but can't wait to hear your thoughts
Childe lore speculation was the last thing I was expecting today, but man am I incredibly happy to see it.
very late to this but love your pfp :D did you draw it?
@@shenheqqqs Thanks, indeed I did! c:
Yk the funny thing was when I first started playing Genshin, I literally knew nothing about the game. So the first time I heard of Childe was by that one Fatui Dude in Mondstadt. Because of the name 'Childe', which means Young Master, and because I didn't know that the fatui were some other organization from Snezhnaya, I thought Childe was an important and greatly revered young master from Mondstadt nobility and that he was one of the knights (the best one too 💀😅)
As a Childe enthusiast, this was the best thing ever. Thank you!
Please do more vids like this for other characters!
3:27, 4:11, 12:12 "Cray-ken"
8:54 "Poi-seidon"
Dunno why but these pronunciations stood out to me a ton and I found it quite amusing XD
Is this like a very specific regional accent thing?
Usually i’d have to do my own research into an abundance of Wikipedia pages when watching Ashikai’s videos
But this theory was really easy from beginning to end since i’m a fate fan😅
Parsifal could also be Cu Chulainn. In the legends, he makes a deal with Scathach twin sister Aife to spare her life in exchange for her leaving Scathach alone and bearing him a child. That could explain how Childe is both related to the Blue Eyed Witch and Parsifal, and there being no record of Blue Eyed Witch meeting Parsifal after the second time.
wow ashikai childe video? XD who would have thought
Counter theory as to why Childe uses Mondstat talent books: Coz Mihoyo made the worst talent domain and wanted to punish players who wished for Childe 😅
It'd be interesting if this theory turns out to be true! I hope they give us more Childe content soon.
Also, you mentioned Cu Chulainn and Scathach and all the Fate fans came out of their caves to comment lol (I'm also a Fate fan).
Okay, I need to scream. You cannot start a video about Childe saying he has never been to Mondstadt. Dragonspine is a part of Mondstadt and we know he goes there to remind himself of Snezhnaya because of climate. His artifact set is also located there.
I am always amazed about all the things that Ashikai manages to pull out of and put into Genshin's lore. There is so much depth, so many references and quite a few things will probably turn out right... I love it.
I always wondered why Childe used books from Mondstat. Thanks for going into the deep dive!
I would say it’s bc his books r freedom. Childe is well known to be free to do whatever and go wherever he pleases. He’s a free spirit, but he’s also sworn his life to serving another, so he’ll never really be free
Childe and Xianling: getting to choose from multiple sets and weapons
Yeah no, this "Childe is from Mondstadt" is even bigger crack than the "Childe is from Enkanomiya" theory.
1. According to this logic, Wanderer's talent books should be from Inazuma, Thoma's from Mond and Amber's from Liyue. But that's not the case, now is it?
2. "Childe's specialty dish looks like cranken that killed Parsifal"... or you know, Osial, the big tentacle monster Childe summoned
Edit:
3. The connections between Skirk and blue-eyed witch are stronger, but I don't see how she can't just be his teacher without being related. I also don't see why a noble from hex & hound can't be unrelated to Parsifal (Skirk is also described as a swordswoman, not a spear...woman, but I guess she can be both)
4. The descriptions of artifacts and weapons are usually factual, I think? That would mean that Parsifal DID die in the battle with the sea monster and didn't reunite with his lover. Unless they had a child(e) before he left Mond of course, but I don't think it was mentioned anywhere
5. The whole thing happened like a 1000 years ago. I doubt that the genes for orange hair and blue eyes would carry through generations for so long. Eula for example doesn't look like her ancestors from 1000 years ago
omg wait is the yanfei background the new library setup from the stream? I couldn’t see tge latter half of the stream so I’m not sure 😅
This is a lot of things but the most important thing is that Genshin took inspiration from EVERYWHERE 😭😭😭😭
this is the first time i've ever seen someone pronounce kraken as kaiken and not kracken
I have a fun bit to add to the theory that makes it even funnier to me. The place were Scathach taught these Irish heroes is Dun Scaith, which (according to Wikipedia anyway) is also known as the Fortress of Shadows. And where to Skirk teach young Ajax? In the Abyss, a place associated with Darkness.
Oh and one more fun connection. The Gae Bolg/Bulg is said to be made of bone from a sea monster. which further relates to the Mondstadt Parsifal. Not only that, but being of bone and a sea monster also makes me think of Child's constellation. Monoceros Caeli, a narwhal. In other words a "sea monster" known for its "bone-like" horn (Incorrectly so, since it's actually a tooth.)
Very loose connections, but very fun coincidences to throw into this soup of a Childe theory!
What if skirk saved him cuz he looked or is related to parceval
If I remember correctly, Childe used to have an eyepatch on his beta portrait/icon!
Or, or Childe was one of the first characters released in the time we only had Mondstald and Lyue released, and Sneznaya is gonna be out more at the end of the game, so they had to give him some talent books. Still, great video
I mean, this is what I always thought, but they could've given him Liyue talent books, like they do with other characters released in regions different than their own (see Kazuha or Scara). He was not once in Mondstadt (despite his first rerun making us believe he was going to be there lol).
It could also be that they were experimenting since he was a really early 5-star, but it's definitely a curious choice they made.
Yeah this is a reach...
Ashikai do you think you will write a story someday?
And also does anybody know how he got his vision? if you check in his character story it doesn't show how he got his vision but instead shows delusion I would love to what theory you will make about this ashikai love ur theories!!! ❤❤
God, I really wish we could get his Vision story at some point, like I NEED TO KNOW IT HOW AND WHEN HE GOT IT FFS
@@Natsu yeah I hope we get limited event or probably if we get to snezhnaya we will get to know more how he got his vision
Man...i just love Childe Ajax Tartaglia 😮💨
Thank you for such a fun content in this draught age of the 11th Harbinger ❤️
I've know of the Ajax and Cersei (after Hexenzirkel video) connection, I'm also quite fond of Childe's character - such a nice shade of gray. I did not know of Chulainn. That's quite interesting, I have to go read more of it.
Yes. I love the character inspiration series (start?). So much potential.
I always assumed he used Mondstadt books because he's not from Mondstadt, he's not from Liyue, and we probably wouldn't get Snezhnaya for like five years at the time of his release, so they just said fuck it and gave him whatever. 😂 Also, aren't the books assigned by region and by a character's ideals/circumstances, so maybe the thought the freedom books suited him better than any of the Liyue ones?
Pronunciations aside, this is the first time I've ever heard of the Gae Bolg referred to as a harpoon. In the myth it was 'barbed' instead of 'hooked' to cause an enormous amount of pain and not be easily removed from the wound. I'm not saying that calling it a harpoon is wrong in any way but I've never really thought of it as one. It does make some sense.
Childe's name in the Spanish version of the game is replaced by 'Nobile' instead of 'Childe', wich really sounds like nobility
Hi Ash - this isn't a request for a video so much as me being curious. Have you tried doing this style of analysis for anyone in Sumeru yet? I've attempted it a little myself, but I find a lot of the potential cultural meta surrounding their outfits are really...muddled. Just wondering if you've had the same experience.
Damn I was hoping it’d be about his connections to the abyss or Skirk being a sinner
Childe: Greek name along with greek named brother, fell in the abyss, met Skirk, Enkanomiya being based of off greek, has a weapon that looks similar to those in Enkanomiya, polar star weapon, fatui harbinger
Her: Mondstadt!
@@Azaleaaah fr!
I was missing childe content earlier and then Ashikai of all people bless us w a banger childe theory thank you childe stans have been w/o content for so long. I love this theory so much
Y'know, this shines a whole different light on that Labyrinth Warriors event scene where Paimon lied to Xinyan by claiming that Childe is an adventurer *_from Mondstadt._*
I caught that the "adventurer" part references how he wanted to be an adventurer as a kid, but I wondered why Paimon chose Mondstadt, of all places, to claim that he's from.
about that part, I always thought that because there are only 3 nations we know at that time, and Monstadt is nearer Snezhnaya more than Liyue, so in term of appearance Monstadt and Snezhnaya people should be more similar than Liyue and Snezhnaya
@@MyTAnh-xu6og I suppose, but she really could have just said he was an adventurer who traveled all the way from Snezhnaya. I just think it would be interesting if this theory is true and Paimon saying he's from Mondstadt was a fun little foreshadowing.
Kazuha uses Liyue talent books even though clearly and canonically he is from Inazuma. Isn't it simply that at the time of their release their nation isn't out yet? Thoma being the exception as even his vision is that of Inazuma.
But why not Liyue? Surely that would make sense since there is where he currently resides. Kazuha does so too, and he did get the Liyue talent books. Whatever happened to Childe.
The problem with Childe isn’t that he doesn’t use Snezhnayan talent books. It’s that he doesn’t use talent books from Liyue.
that's the unfun answer lmao
@@Chopsparillo because snezhnaya isn't out yet + hes not from liyue and hes released early
@@mysh24 he doesnt reside there, he travels according to tsaritsa's orders. i mean he recently was in inazuma, come on...
As soon as I first heard about Skirk back in 1.1 I immediately imagined her as Scathach from FGO and I'm so glad that I've (probably) been imagining her about right.
It's a cool format!
I got gut punched because Cu is my favorite fate/ characters and Childe is a character I really like in Genshin.
...I would say these aren't likely to be related but Fate/Grand Order is the father of modern gacha games and it wouldn't be too farfetched to say they started there (or the original Fate/ Stay Night for that matter), then went back to the source materials for Cu Chulainn.
This was an amazing analysis. Dear god.
Correction: Childe had been to Mondstadt before. He was in Dragonspine in one of the EP videos.
But great video, holy crap! I've been talking with my friend about how the Heart of Depth artifact is connected to Childe and how the Hex & Hound book is connected to it, too. When I discovered this video, it made me and my friend feel heard! You explained the connections a lot better than we did, and now it's all making a lot more sense to me! I can now refer to this video when I talk about it, thank you so much! 🙏
Oh this was great... yeah he's a son-of-a-witch. Very witty, Ashikai.
Enjoyed the new format.
Looking forward to new 3.6 Sumeru zone lore!!! I figure another week or so!
Please please please make more of these!!! I am especially interested in Yoimiya, cause honestly I don’t really think that she is that simple of a character
childe has such weird lore like i read a tweet threat where they pointed out that he also has so many and also very strong ties to enkanomiya as in not only having been there but also his family actually being from enka and im just like...he really is Mr. Worldwide
Childe was released in 1.1 or 2 so he really was given Mondstadt talent books just to balance the cast. Also, Thoma uses Inazuma books, and Wanderer who still has Inazuman roots, uses Sumerians.
Okay hear me out, that could also VERY well be why Childe in fact has a blonde strand of hair.
Another thing to note is that his foul legacy form looks like a seelie so I'm really wondering how that can be connected - but that's just a food for thought lol
Childe is pretty interesting lore wise and once we get there - if they ever bother to explain - it's gonna slap harder than his riptide👀
OH MY GOSH I LOVE THIS Ashikai just woke up and was like "time to feed all the childe fans". And it all actually makes sense!!!
Childe .... A real "sonofawitch"
i was wonderign has anyone made any connections to skirk and the oceanids and the water animals it produces? especially with the Circe reference it is interesting to think about
Im ready for my dose of COPIUM
Wait so Skirk might have taken Childe under her wing because she either realised he was (her and?) Parcival's descendant or otherwise thought he looked like her old lover?? God that's such an intruiging possibility
As a major Childe fan, I was fed well today
quake-en?
or
crack-en?
kraken
I always thought that he had his talents in monstadt bc snezhaya isn’t out yet and monstadt is close to snezhaya and that the books he needs are called freedom. He looks pretty free to me
Uhm how about Kazuha? Uses liyue books and azhdaha ascension mats
Wait a second... Ashikai also has red fluffy hair and blue eyes, does that mean... ASHKAI IS ALSO A DESCENDAND OF THE BLUE EYED WITCH???!!?!!?!11 😱😱😱😱😱😱
Abyss herald and lectors are from the Abyss and predate khaenriha. They are not human but like skirk they are from the Abyss. That is why child's foul legacy looks like a herald and not a lector who wield a catalyst weapon as suppose to herald who wield a melee weapon. I think the herald and lector are from a race in Abyss that are like the dragon race who lived a light realm and I think before sun and moon those two realms coexistence was a battle over power and balance like jing and jang. Then came the decend3r or second who came or primordial one and forced the human realm in between them. Something like that.
This channel is a gem, it’s clear that every video has much thought and effort put into them
Give👏Childe👏his👏own👏interlude👏quest 👏(plz)👏👏👏
Too many run-on sentences. But fun links and ideas
What you probably missed:
1) It's Nottfriega who turned the nobleman (Dietrich) into a dog. The implication of Dietrich missing ultimately caused the Lawrence to fall.
2) Nottfriega (and Magdalene)'s mother was the one said to be a witch. Nottfriega knew dark magic (from her mother) as Magdalene knew light. Apparently they shared body for a bit.
3) Mondstadt's yellow blonde hair and blue eyes is always implication to be correlated with the Gunnhildr. Like Jean gets her hair color from her mom (which doesn't appear in Barbara because her hair resembles more of her dad. Barbara is more like this light ash - light blonde, but Barbara still counts as a blonde because they want to note her as Jean's little sister, regardless.)
In the end Mondstadt still abides the circle rule, and since Parsifal was a nobility, her lover the Blue-Eyed Spear Witch was probably also of nobility. Maybe one of the branches of the Gunnhildr or even the Gunnhildr themselves.
Reminder: the only source of info for the Gunnhildr's "motive of participation" during the rebellion era was that of the Biography of the Gunnhildr, written... ofc by a Gunnhildr. Even if Jean talks about this biography a lot, she prob knew this was just propaganda by her ancestor to legitimize the Gunnhildr's "rule" over Mondstadt.
Since any history can or has been tampered either 500 years ago or long ago, but any allegory tends to miss being tampered as they were already fictionalized in the first place, this is what created inconsistency regarding the whole rebellion saga.
All we know is that in the end, Venti "used" Venessa and her quest to turn the wheel around.
My guess? I've been guessing Childe's connection to Mondstadt since day 1. Just like how they include Mona as Mondstadt cast despite being fully Fontaine.
My guess atm (after reading around and watching your video and reading again) is like:
1) Dietrich in the Hex & Hound is obvious allegory to Eberhart, who went missing in the Dragonspine expedition after he basically tried to kill most of the aristocracy member. They never found out his real fate (he was grievously wounded and was last told to be travelling via the river to Cider lake from Dragonspine). The allegory explicitly changed the weapon from spear to sword, as sword was a sign of nobility in Mondstadt + hey it's an allegory. They wanted to avoid getting tampered by fate.
Eberhart's real fate that is unknown now was probably the part that got tampered in Irminsul/the record in general/both. As even if Eberhart was a despicable person, he was the true conspirator of the rebellion against the aristocracy. (this implies he's involved with the forbidden knowledge or some kind later down the line, but that's unimportant in this context).
2) Eberhart never killed the blue-eyed spear witch. That part was tampered either by someone via Irminsul, or by the records, or by the witch herself, or by Eberhart himself which Venti acquiesced. The witch fled to Snezhnaya, where her fate is unknown (either she is Skirk, or Childe's mother/ancestor, or both, we don't know).
Reminder that Venti and the Tsaritsa used to be good friends, before they fell out of favor. Back then they were still friends. So it made sense for Venti to ask for her favor.
a) another possible twist was that he did kill her, but it was known and let to be by the blue-witch, or it was consensual between them.
3) However this had turned out, this was the main motive the Gunnhildr taking the side of the rebel, after the "failure" of Eberhart and his lover Priscilla. The Gunnhildr was always closer to the military side of Mondstadt (the side that Venti lied to) + there was really no reason to keep up with the aristocracy, now that the aristocracy was totally paralyzed due to losing Parsifal, and then Ingbert and Eberhart. The relationship between the Gunnhildr and Eberhart's faction never got ruined, since they knew of the truth.
4) and all in all, Venti prob knew and chose to neglect this condition, deciding to let Eberhart self-destruct the aristocracy from within, before then he chose his "prophetess", his champion to swoop in.
btw, hounds and wolves are always a thematic close to Mondstadt due to their mixed heritage with Andrius. One such instance was that of Rostam (Rosalyne "La Signora"'s lover, who died in the cataclysm 500 years ago) was known as the "wolf's pup".
another one, ofc, is Razor, who is just Jungle Book.
so having Eberhart getting allegory as a "hound" via Dietrich either tells the truth of his fate after the tragedy in Dragonspine, or his origin, instead ("illegitimiate child", reminder).
ohhhhh
@Ashikai is there a reason you say it kray-kin and not crack-in similar to your pronoun citation of tighnari and Nahida? Also is tartalia a different character than childe? His in universe name is tar-ta-galia. Commonly mispronounced as tartalia and tartaglia, took me a while to realize the actual pronunciation as well.
Next video: How Kaedehara clan was originally from Liyue bcs Kazuha also uses Liyue talent books, not Inazuma? 🤔
I mean...Kazuha uses Liyue books (which I understand is probably due to, you know, Inazuma not being released yet).
little late to the game, but has anyone pointed out that the blue-eyed witch is probably ivanova of the hexenzirkel? you know, the only witch we know of that seems to have some ties to schnezniya, the russian-based region? and that further inspection shows that her and parcival's doomed love story mirrors that of jason of the argonaughts and princess medea, high priestess of hecete (aka the goddess of witchcraft, and therefore a very powerful witch herself), of greek mythology? i bring this up only cause i literally watched this vid back-to-back of your hexenzirkel rundown, and kinda connected the dots from the small lore-tidbits we have of both parcival and ivanova, and (given your theory craft for nicole) further wondered what that potential mythological connection could tell us about ivanova's possible role both within the zirkel, and within the larger metanarritive for genshin. personally, i think she's playing distraction for the zirkel, since medea was often depicted as dangerously clever, and prone to using deception and distraction to fell her enemies. maybe she's using both herself and possible childe/maybe the fatui as a whole to distract celestia while her sisters work in the shadows she's casting? thoughts?
The pronunciations were throwing me off. Why were you pronouncing “Poseidon” as “Poiseidon”, and “Gae Bolg” as “Gay Bolg”, and “Kraken” as “Krayken”?
This theory is rather stupid. In that case, why does Scaramouche use Sumaru talent books and those stupid shrooms that Collei uses(although I think he should have used the Maguu Kenki drops would have made more sense cuz I believe Maguu Kenki was built using the similar Khaenri'ahn technology but the drake still fits), or why does Kazuha use talent books from Liyue. I mean are fucks sack Childe's regional ascension material is from Liyue, The Starconches, just like Yalan. The real reason that there were barely any Snezhayan materials in the game in the 1.0 patches, literally the only ones were the Fatui enemy drops
Woohoo
Interesting
I'm just started watching this video don't hate me for saying this I'm just saying this for fun
I think childe is one of the earliest 5 star character and we need his meterial to upgrade hie tallent level so the might be chosen a random domain i guess
And now im gonna watch the video
Skirk can also be inspired by the Norse Goddess Skadi because Scáthach and the goddess are thought of to have the same origin of inspiration. This would mean that Skirk would not only be an expert in combat and weaponry but might also be able to use runes that are second only from the runes used by Odin.
В который раз автор натянул сову на глобус. Откуда взяться книгам из Снежной в начале игры? Чайльд появился, когда были открыты только два региона. Простая игровая условность, которая никак не связана с лором.
A thing I found funny is that the first thing Paimon calls him to hide his identity is "he's from Mondstadt". Not only Thoma was supposed to be a different side of the same coin with Tartaglia.
Also he didn't appear in the Mondstadt archon quest and I'm kinda disappointed.
I had a theory that Childe was originally from Mondstadt because of the talent books, but my theory was far more simplistic.
It seems the fatui are filling their ranks with orphan children. Specifically orphan children from other nations. It was even hinted at that the fatui might be the ones that made them orphans in the first place.
We hear about this recruiting of foreign children first in the Inazuma quest chain about Gendou Ringo's strange fortune slips, and it was mentioned also in the quest chain with a group of fatui during the second appearance of the golden apple archipelago. During this (sadly event locked) quest we found out, that these orphaned children refer to each other as their siblings, which would explain why Tartaglia has "siblings".
So I theorized that Childe might very well be one of these orphaned children that were taken in to be made into fatui.
When I heard about Skirk my first thought was Scáthach (thanks Fate/GO) and I'm really glad that I'm not the only one, who thinks there may be a connection.
Talking about "Hound", so this is probably useless information, but since you once talked about Mona and her ability to see the fate from ones constallation. I have a official Mona-Stand from mihoyoverse as a little merchandise. It's a two part stand and it has a ring around Mona in the background that shows...animals, but they remind me of constallations, since there is a lion (Jean's constallation) and a falcon (Diluc's constallation) and a dragon (???) and, well, the a wolf (it looks like one). It's probably just random icons but when you said "hound" and Mondstadt, I noticed my Mona on my desk. 😅
Again, I think it's useless information bc merch probably isn't as deep and they just throw something on it. But the comment at least boosts the algorhythm. 🥰
The Childe lover in me is freaking out!
So basically, Childe is a ginger who wields both a bow and two short swords, whose real name is Ajax, may or may not have a connection to Cu Chulainn and Percival, and is voiced by Ryohei Kimira in Japanese. What is this, a Fate fan's wet dream?