Crimewatch 2010 EP4 | Dead man tells no tales?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- Watch how a deceased's tissue became an important piece of evidence for Police to unravel the mystery surrounding her death.
#Crimewatch2010
-----
Watch more on www.mewatch.sg/
Like us on Facebook: / mewatch.mediacorp
Follow us on Instagram: @mewatch.mediacorp
The IO who handle this case was aware of his lack of expertise on this case and seek assistance from various professionals and manage to resolve the case. Kudos to him
Considering he didn't even had the five years service medal to wear during the inquiry means he was still pretty new to the job at that point.
Cool profile dude
Despite not being very action-packed, I still rather enjoyed this episode. Its not every day where you see a Crimewatch episode like this.
true.
I believe that Crimewatch in the old days were 30 min Documentaries of Crime in Singapore with a mix of Drama and action.
@@brendan1470
Interesting. The re-enactment portion of the oldest CW episode I could find (th-cam.com/video/lXNuCnJ5Ieg/w-d-xo.html) does seem to give off alot of old Chinese drama vibes. But they've also begun incorporating some reporting elements too.
Agree. Todays Crimewatch is CCTV this CCTV that. Yes we know Big brother is watching but man i do miss CW being more of a serious crime documentary based on painstaking investigation minus all that superfluous drama
I am so sorry for the mother. It is very sad and heartbreaking to see this. Even though it was like 35 years ago, I still wish the girl to rest in peace.
Yes
I feel the same 😔
She did sue the doctor, Dr Lim. I studied this case for my tort during my 1st year in Temasek Polytechnic.
@@user-is6cy8ug8dsamee
Poor girl. The IO did a fantastic job.
You are right!
This has to be one of the best crime watch by far. It's not action packed but gets me on the edge of my seat. I am truly heart broken for the victim, she had to suffer so much and all due to negligence. May she rest in peace
Compared to modern day crime watch,the acting is 1000% better
So sorry to see this. The young lady suffered and died over nothing. Before deciding on any surgery, always seek 2nd and if possible, 3rd opinion. But in that era, most people wouldn't have thought of that. It's very sad.
No I just find tht there are missing pieces to the story... how do u know the tumor is cancerous without pathology report. To diagnose cancer you must first remove the tumor, send into pathology..
MRI alone dont diagnose. I done an open brain surgery I know the procedures.. Some thing abt this story is off... some pieces are missing during the diagnosis
And not all tumors are cancerous.
I feel sorry for the mom but also there is pieces hanging here and there
@@jasminetay9820 you think non medical professionals will know these? Let alone old aunties
@@phoonjzc dont need to be medical professionals.. My grandma who never went to school also feels sus when the doctor suddenly can just say the lump on her chest is cancer.
So she asked my uncle to change hospital and it was just a cyst 😌
And please lah dont stereotype aunties. Even young ppl like us can get ourselves into such simillar situation. Like a too good to be true paying job when you are desperate for money.. just one of many examples
A squawk from a sparrow does not mean a phoenix.
The doctor probably jumped to conclusions too fast in the first place.
But it was 1980s, so directives and thoughts might be different as compared to now.
@@reubenquek9456 In that case why didnt he admit that he was wrong? Why he block the police from accessing records?
It is good that justice is finally seen at the end, the girl can rest in peace now. Respects to aunty and uncle for losing a loved one.
Fantastic IO Avadiar. Well done. Professor Chao was a gem too.. But vast majority of IOs are far from competent though, from personal experience. Some likely just SIT on the case for months waiting for the next IO to take over. They don't see cases as their personal responsibilities.
Respect & Salute to IO Avadiar for his great investigation work to solving this Medical Negligent case! Scary that , such heartless person was in the operating room & being so uncaring to his dying patient! Uncaring doctors or nurses are Red Flags! Send dying patient to another Hospital immediately! Deepest condolences to the Family & Friends ... May the Deceased be Blessed to a Better World & Realm ...
Last time no google also
Oh.. I have checked that the medical council only suspended him for a year. They did not struck off his name from the register that would barred him from practice medicine in Singapore.. Anyways, his work pass was cancelled and he went back to Johor to work for his friend.
Johor?which place
@@xChaserofLightx yes..i just google and read it.
He should have been banned from practicing and given jail time too
This is the reason why I don't want to be doctor. Such mistakes can fuck up your mind.
How about become fake doctor? 😅
thats why Doctor was paid a lot of money, bcos they can’t make any mistake
Depending on the mistake you won’t get any punishment if it’s mistakes that are EASILY solvable then you should get punished if it’s not then no punishment
@@magicalseal8710 he said such mistake that will Kill someone
Thats why doctors and trained for years and years
No jail term? Strange. You mean a doctor can kill anyone and be blamed as negligence?
Yea it’s weird why he not sent to jail even though he was accused of suicidal verdict and misadventure verdict.
I hope her daughter can rest in peace 🕊
The doctor should be sent to prison. 🤦🏽♂️
right, should have been life imprisonment.
agreed even if that dr lim won the case im sure the parents told their friends family colleagues even the girls friends former teachers maybe bosses would have heard and found out and told everyone they know of not to go to dr lim
Wow. Really good episode. Watching from 2021. I didn’t know there was such thing as a State Coroner.
When the expert doesn't know what is it they will become expert in bullshitting
yes usually the family is too distraught to request an investigation upon the death of their loved one. I truly admire the IO for taking on the investigation even though it happened years ago!
It was so heartbreaking to see the mother cry
Singapore police: "I will investigate fully and bring justice"
Indonesian police; "bring me evidence and ehem.. 🤞💵.."
And they still betray U n help the richer side.
and so as Malaysia
@@DennisLiewDennis , India , …..,,,,, so on
Singapore police is so professional, I envy Singaporean because they have a very professional police.
Wish her rest in peace. Wish the parents had gotten over the tough time. Felt heartbroken for the loss due to the doctor's misconduct.
Thats why second opinion really plays vital role...so sorry to watch this unfortunate events
What do you mean by second opinion?
@@k-sooyaalove206 Pretty sure they mean taking the reports/findings to consult with multiple doctors and hospitals, and not relying on a single doctor (who can be incapable or malicious as in this case).
Did the "doctor" ever spent anytime in jail?
Bravo to the brave, diligent, never give up characteristic of AI Avadia.Justice was done with flying stars
Bruh bloody common sense to never discharge a patient until they fully recover
Yes, common sense, but discharging a patient usually isn't based on how much they have recovered, it's more of "how much medical attention do they still need"
There are some cases where it doesn't matter if they are in the hospital or not, eg: recovering from a broken body part, having a deeply cut wound heel, surgery done and now just waiting for the wound to heal
If we were to discharge patients only when they fully recover, cancer patients would be staying in hospital for months
But of course, you don't need more than 2 braincells to know NOT to discharge a patient in that situation, she's in pain, moving around so much
what a sad case. poor girl!
edit: props to the IO for his tremendous effort!
Trivia: Dr Tambyah mentioned in this episode was in fact the late Dr John Tambyah, Dr Paul Tambyah’s father
Had a nose cancer surgery 2 months ago, brain fluid leaked a little but my surgeon did a good job and fixed it. Can't imagine what would have happened if it kept leaking like in this case.
The acting is so on point wow actually made me sad
Why would you have not got a second opinion? I don't blame the parents or anything, I guess they just trusted him but I got a head injury when I was a toddler and doctors told my mum some bullshit about how I was perfectly fine, she got a second opinion, they said the same. She took me to a Doctors and two hospitals before they gave me an X-ray, I had skull damage. Not that serious but it's still something you should KNOW if you have. You should still ALWAYS listen to your gut and get multiple opinions until someone takes you seriously.
that is so true
Thanks to IO Avadiar and most respected Prof Chao who once again closed one big case. No crimewatch cases I've watched thus far had me gritted my teeth any harder than this goddamned neurosurgeon's deeds. But then again everything's soothed when ASP Jessica Ang walked into the scene. Is she still with SPF? 😘
What the fuck, the doctor needs to be jailed and punished.
The mom is such a great actress.
Ikr
She is not so active now, but she is really good as a supporting actress.
@@woiace Just realised that she played the mother of Leonard Goh in Channel 5 series Reunion!
She's a supporting artiste from Mediacorp Ch. 8. Has been acting in tv dramas.
She is the most senior among the extra company I used to work with. Often getting the more meatier roles :)
How can you discharge a patient while she steel needed IV and brain fluid coming out?
That Doctor was careless in his calculations and examinations on the patient
@@brendan1470 yes this is why i wouldn't want to be a doctor
@@kha_lis5319 I feel you, but it makes me wonder why most parents want their kids to study hard to become doctors without knowing the bad outcomes
@@brendan1470 cause maybe doctors earn a lot
@@brendan1470 the parents want their child to become a good doctor that care about people's health, not a greedy and arrogant doctor like Lim.
Arrogance doctor paid a heavy price for malpractices, lesson learn to others surgeons. Congrats to IO Avadiar.
That doctor only get suspended??? No send to jail?
Dr Chiang and Prof Chao are the mvp of the council
The counsel is absolutely right in saying that no doctor in Singapore will discharge a patient if the patient has to still undergo checkups while in hospital. No patient is to be discharged if further tests or observations show that the patient is still in a serious condition that renders him/her unfit for discharge from hospitalisation. In Singapore, strict laws and regulations have been in place. Any misdiagnosis in health or medical condition will be strictly investigated and if a medical practitioner is found to be negilent in his/her diagnosis of medical conditions, he/she will be put into investigation by the Medical Council of Singapore. If found guilty, his/her licence will be suspended. If the patient has died due to the wrong diagnosis of the medical condition he/she is in, the medical practitioner will have his/her licence revoked.
huh ?? why didnt sue the quack doctor ???? no jail ??? no rotan ??? should sue the doctor for $ 28 million for criminally causing an innocent girls death
19:44
Robber : gimme $200 !
Cab driver : i have $201.50 so....
Robber : Gimme! I will change you $1.50 !
Best episode ever
Ridiculous! Absolutely ridiculous! Dr. Lim Djoe Phing shouldn’t be merely suspended, he should’ve been charged and found guilty of causing death by negligent act! Not just suspended, his license to practice medicine should’ve been revoked permanently in its entirety!
Doctor Firth is an expert from UK
Me: After watching this video I finally knew that Expert Firth is a expert in telling lies
Expert in protecting the rich.
@@pamelanessa lol true
Gabe Newell from wish
"I'm HIV Positive!!!" That's one way to put it
Most evil and disgusting advice from a doctor is: 5:12
The acting from the mother is really good
I feel sorry for the mom of the victim I salute SINGAPORe police force and medical team for solving this case.
me after a motor cycle accident in emergency when the doctor told me " I got some bad news, your foot is broken, we need to perform immediate surgery to realign your bones in your toes".
Me " HAHHAHAHAHHHAHHAHHA. well lets get to it then"
Doc " why are you so happy?"
Me " it's a story to tell my grandkids "
during surgery " doc can i buy that anesthetics? "
then i knocked out. i never got my anesthetics
So sad story 😭
Rest in peace
I don't even know how to pronounce most of the medical jargon. Kudos to the dedication to solve this case.
some people really cannot be doctor so con
Moral of the story: Don’t hesitate to get a second opinion/multiple opinions from another medical provider. Poor girl. Rest in peace, Yunjing…
Why no sentence for Dr Lim?
Madam Pang acted as the taxi driver's wife in 2012 Ep7
did the mother of the deaths girl sue doctor lim for million of dollars?
Crime watch is
The singapore police so cool
And nice one
anyone noticed the skull in the doctors glasses reflection?
Why the doctor was not jailed??
Because he got suspended from Singapore medical council
11:55 My Father's Debut as the State Coroner in the Court
The actor or the actual court hearing?
@@ouya_expert He's an Actor
It’s the same guy from the 2013 pathologist?
@@FiveForLife-nk2ds Yes that my dad's acting in Episode 1 of 2013, he also acted as a different pathologist in Episode 7 of 2012 investigating an abandon cab stained with blood
@@brendan1470 oh that's the 2009 Taxi Murder by a dude from China that shocked Singapore then, isn't it?
What? No jail term???
No.
No evidence it is manslaughter or murder. Just a medical neligence.
And also protected by the agreement signed before operation that complications from surgery is not the responsibility of the doctor.
It is just overconfidence. The radiology result wasn't accurate and the radiologist had provide his initial opinion that also verified the flawed doctor's diagnosis.
Further statements from the British Expert Consultant Neurosurgeon also supported the flawed doctor's decisions.
Probably the actor for the doctor acted as villian very well or have that face that people don't like and wish to imprison him. Lol
Anyway, after this verdict.. Highly possible for the hospital to compensate the victim's parents.
Kind of reminded me of the security guard that operated on the woman and she died. Wtf
what
God Blessed I.O Avadiar & SPF 👌🏼😊
Dr Tambyah 43 - 1944
Dr Low Chen Hong 33 - 1954
Chao Tzee Cheng 1934 - 53
British Doctor 45 - 1942
Defence Lawyer 34 - 1953
Ur very smart to be able to show all ages n date of birth of every one
Dr Tambyah was such a nice soft spoken doctor. I enjoyed the ward rounds with him.
Which one or reenactment or Ori..Dr tambyah born 65
When the officer at the start described the woman as a young girl, i thought the victim was going to be primary school age or something
12:15 Wait, why is there Windows Media Player in 1989...
It's a re enactment
might as well get an OHP if they wanna commit, but again...
She should have checked to 2 or 3 other doctor just to make sure the disease. So sorru for the lost.😢
yes doctor James Khoo was an expert in Nero a famous neurologist
basket doctor,all he cares is money i already knewn
9:06 Dr John tambyah , have a son who also a Doctor and a chairman of SDP
This sucks, I felt she died again when verdict was announced.
So yun jing case because careless and lies to family patient
1:26 23 Years
2:09 24 Years
wah this IO solid
22:29 Don't move
Are Dr Lim is work private clinic or hospital?
Winnie Spencer 10 - 1940
Joseph Michael Nonis 23 - 1927
16:03 What does this mean? Is he sentenced to death by penalty?😦
Lose his medical license to practice in Singapore
IO Avadiar, My Grandfather
He alive or
So if its not the pituitary tumor whats causing her seizures? Also taxi uncle escape open door never see incoming cars lmao
Indonesian DOCTOR!
WTF!
Is this some kinda bias
Edit: Sg high rise of racism so I being careful
wu siao booo..........no cancer..........then doctor say u got cancer......which hosipital or clinic ?
So was it on the newspaper
the driver should said i only have 10 cents.
so sad
you can’t lie if that io is your grandfather
But why did the girl die?
70
@16:04, tsk, tsk, tsk….the Foreign Talent has taken another Singaporean’s life who’s population is already dwindling….tsk, tsk, tsk🤦♀️
As an Indonesian, I'm really sorry for his evil action🙁
What in the Pirate of Caribbean is the title?
'im HIV positive" urm chile anyways
HAHA. i had to resist from laughing out loud in the MRT.
Wdym by hiv positive
the doctor shouldn't have done this
dr Lim tjoe Ping already was not a good doctor during the 1990s.
1990s? His work permit wasn't renewed since 1987 so how could he still practicing medicine then?
This Dr Lim Djoe Phing is too much, he never check and anyhow say. This is not a brain cancer, she was diagnose a meningitis and pituitary tumour. How dare this doctor Lim anyhow say and try to be funny huh. The KK hospital ICU doctor scold the patients to wait for awhile and said no, how dare this ICU doctor say later and never say later.
Crimewatch 2010
🌹
Why did he want to rush the operation?
Faster do, faster earn $.
@@phoonjzc you mean they earn extra money for operating on patients?
@@pamelanessa it is a private hospital. The more you see the more you earn. Get it?
@@phoonjzc that's so wrong. Doctors are supposed to save lives, not put lives at risk for money.
@@pamelanessa hi pamela, nice to meet you. :) Did your parents teach you that highly educated people are trustworthy? Good night
asp jessica ang is hot !!!!!!!
Another story is the man rob the taxi driver at geylang a few hours later he was caught by the police after the taxi driver make a police report
Then there was the infamous case of the China man killing a taxi driver that same year
@@godsbelovedchild1810 there was a crimewatch episode on that too. If im not wrong, he killed the taxi driver. He then lied to the deceased family that he kidnapped him and ask for ransom but got caught in the end.
I know the story is at crime watch 2012 ep 7