ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ค. 2024
- CBS Reports presents a documentary special about the cottage industry that's built up across Central America to get migrants to the U.S. border.
Subscribe to the CBS News Channel HERE: / cbsnews
Watch CBS News live HERE: cbsn.ws/1PlLpZ7
Follow CBS News on Instagram HERE: / cbsnews
Like CBS News on Facebook HERE: / cbsnews
Follow CBS News on Twitter HERE: / cbsnews
Get the latest news and best in original reporting from CBS News delivered to your inbox. Subscribe to newsletters HERE: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
Get your news on the go! Download CBS News mobile apps HERE: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
Get new episodes of shows you love across devices the next day, stream CBS News and local news live, and watch full seasons of CBS fan favorites like Star Trek Discovery anytime, anywhere with CBS All Access. Try it free! bit.ly/1OQA29B
---
CBS News is the first digital streaming news network that will allow Internet-connected consumers to watch live, anchored news coverage on their connected TV and other devices. At launch, the network is available 24/7 and makes all of the resources of CBS News available directly on digital platforms with live, anchored coverage 15 hours each weekday. CBS News. Always On.
How many is enough? How many is too many? We can't take everybody. No country can.
Slowest that our business has been, very little money now , no one is migrating. #CARTELESUNIDOS
Ike the ranter don't let them in to begin with.
A border wall is in my opinion not a good strategy for immigration control but we need a new one first should be punishing so called sanctuary city's who deliberately are harboring illegals because shocker for you the second you enter America illegally you are breaking the law its in the term illegally entering the country
American invaded and fuked over those countries. American corporations took there resources
Ike the ranter the real issue is that trump and the gop swamp have made the problem worse. Hes a total failure as president
76,000 in February 100,000 in march .. I'm sorry folks but we're not responsible for the world's poor . we have our own problems
hans mueller sorry about your bad luck but you can't come over here.
Yes we are we invaded and fuked over south American countries. And also we have corporate welfare
And the US has caused problems from all over the world . 🤔
I agree totally and I do not apologize . Support yourselves and families.
Not to sympathetic and ethnic lawmakers of USA.
Stay home, be strong and brave, make YOUR own country great again
I think for alot of people its easy to have that mindset. That why cant they make their country great again. But what people often forget is that its a privilege to live in a country thats not run by cartels, its a privilege to live in a america. If they could they would, but they can't. Because the moment they step out of line, the moment they do something that will anger someone in a higher position of power, they'll be killed. And thats the truth for a lot of people living in countries such as these. They don't seek to commit crimes. What they seek is the opportunity. The opportunity to live better lifes, the opportunity to work, and the opportunity to perhaps one day be in a place that will allow them the ability to make there country a great nation.
Remember your forefathers didn't stay in Europe to make it great...
In other words let's get back to turning a blind eye on things so we can be comfortable. Right? Not our problem but we played a part in a lot of countries. Mind you this is a country built on immigrants escaping troubles.
That's what the Indians said when you landed there. Yet you killed, raped and looted them. Countries are concepts.
The mama Africa woman is an Angel.
Yes
She is
If you let them in your jobs will be taken
Medical care is going to get more expensive
We will have to pay for there well being
Its a burden
Then why did you interfere with their internal affairs? What you need to do is throw away or burn the "Monroe Doctrine" POS paper...
Stop spouting propaganda. Try empathy, try reading nevermind you are just another sheeple proud to be spouting catch phrases and scared of brown people who don't want your damn job, house or your precious white women. Maybe look at your own party and wonder wtf they want to cancel your healthcare. (Thats the reason you dont have the house anymore).
The rise in medical costs isn't 100% attributable to immigration. In fact, it is hardly ever mentioned because there are other factors that outsize that impact by an order of magnitude. One of the biggest reasons lies within cost-sharing.
Secondly, jobs can't be "taken" away. That's not how the labor market works. There's never a set amount of jobs. Additionally, labor studies show that the individuals impacted the most by the influx of immigrants are other immigrants who arrived earlier. That's who they're really competing against.
Lastly, illegal immigrants often don't get government assistance because of their lack of legal documentation. You just can't. What? Do you think state offices simply give out food assistance to everyone without looking at taxes, legal status, etc?
You know what's a burden? Idiots who can't educate themselves and continue to spew misinformation on the internet.
@Dread Master Varun yup and that's about end
There is a lot of jobs they can't take. Unless all of you who see this are maids, fast food or something that doesn't require more than an ITN. I watched a lot of immigrants get laid off and i had a very difficult time saying "oh try applying at x y z" because everywhere i thought up required more paperwork
Finish the report by showing how they get jobs and who is hiring them. The Rest of the Story....
Well they get hired by minimum wage jobs lol that’s the literal story and Americans are complaining
@@arieljoseph9362
AMERICANS or u.s. citizens ?.
YES
THEY ARE ON ASSISTANCE FROM GOVERNMENT...CRACKDOWN HARD! TOO LATE FOR MY STATE CALIFMEXICO. 80% MEXICAN
@@donnagrantham6771
Mexicans belong here!😀
I'm originally from Argentina but reside in the US illegally. After 35 years I have started my immigration process...
Going through my journey
Out of curiosity, how do you go about legalising your status after living in the U.S illegally?
@@mingailekieraite2168 I started the I130 petition
All the best to you!
The guy from pueblos sin Fronteras should be put in jail. Aiding and abetting and breaking federal law.
Shut down your borders dammit.Don't make the same mistake as we did in Europe.
How the heck you gonna stop people from leaving their countries and going elsewhere? You gotta fix those countries so that the people want to stay.
LiS Wright It’s not America’s job to fix other countries. These illegals take the easy way out to come to the US for a free ride when they should be fighting to improve their own country. The US needs to close the border and stop all the freebies and sanctuary. Then they will only have one choice.
@@Chicago48 We have to close the border, change asylum laws. ICE is suppose to be rounding up illegals and deporting them back to Mexico.
Kristina Caruso that’s what I was saying
Kristina Caruso what they expect they whole country to move into America
Very sad 😓 and that one baby saying can I please have the toy 😓 . I wish all of them great luck and prayers 🙏❣️ for that better life every human needs.
Acoge en tu casa a unos cuantos,es una buena idea no crees?
I feel sympathetic for those who try to cross the border to the US in seek for a better life but a country needs a border and legal immigration system, without those there’s no country
Borders and the concept of countries are man made anyways. Who cares? Just let people come in your country
THE US TAXPAYERS ARE NOT THE WORLD'S BABBY DADDY.
Nice documentary ...really amazingly explained . great work ...
Don't let them in to begin with.
Like you have a choice, idiot
This was actually good quality, largely unbiased journalism. Thank you!
i live in europe germany and i dont trust media years now.do you know a usa broadcast channel news that is more conservative ?
@@SM-ih6dt NTD News, Fox News, Newsmax. Hoover Institution
NOT ONE CAN STAY !
LIKE LOCUST THEY WILL SPREAD AND DESTROY. THEY KNOW CRIME, THEY COME FROM IT AS PART OF THEIR CULTURES!
THERE IS NEVER A REASON OR SITUATION WHY ANYBODY SHOULD EVER BE IN AMERICA ILLEGALLY
America or the u.s.?
@@jg0037 Well done!
The caravan organizer at 19;28 needs to have his US citizenship revoked for TREASON!!!
They all should, including the scumbag lawyers who serve them
Wow that's a great documentary...
6k-9k USD common i would rather go face the consulate for B2 visa or some other category
It's a freaking business in Mexico. Outrageous
Mexican do not want them, this film ultimately bias. You should see the violent protest and assaults Mexican natives are doing on them.
its a dog eat dog relationship.
I'm Mexican we don't want them here.
and by the way not all Mexicans want to go to US.
According to cbp it is about
140. Nacionalities. Is a lots of people from the caribe
Central abd south america and from oversea.
Mexico cant shelter and provide.
Mexican goverment cant stop those caravans
Biden administration handiling real wrong..
People like money here in Mexico. I know, I live here.
Luckily my current town is not like that, but in Chelem, Yucatan, etc. you get the vibe that it's all about money often!
That’s so beautiful
***** *20201228 ***** *Grand Total 450+ miles ***** (CBP: 446 miles as of 20201228 ; Private: 4 miles). Promises kept!
Dual citizenship? Dual loyalties? Something to consider when nation building.
Imagine this life.
Send them home
Najila nah but no more can’t come
Try that 😂😂😂😂
Crazy...
God bless America. Amen
When I saw the pot and when she mention fricase de cerdo. I want to it eat it I’m from Bolivia and that dish is very popular
These people don't look like they are starving or in distress we can't take care of these people something has got to be done soon. We are done as a nation they are not going anywhere thank the Democrats.
if these people are so brave and strong to make this journey, why don't they make their own country better? Makes no sense to me.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change_in_Latin_America
of course. you have no idea of what it means to HAVE to escape. Your level of privilege is overwhelming
are you dense ?
I hope that who ever made to the US try’s to help her out too like she helped them out. Either sending money or something
She's precious, right?! Love her attitude and work ethic!
So many countries are failing due to corruption , just be blessed you're born in the right one , I am . we can't fix the world. Greetings from Mexico.
We can try just because your load about not helping other doesn't mean it the end
@@recordstore2265 my family is from P oland
@@esqsusan what up, have a good day
Why people make children even when they can't afford to support them. some people really are their own nightmare and a real suffering for their own children simply because of their own choice.
Folks we have to stop this deadly crisis . They are coming !
"America has always been the greatest country in the world."
No, it hasn't and isn't.
yes. we are brainwashed to think this.
The u.s.!
America is the name of a continent, not a country!.
@@jg0037...you absolutely correct but tell me why if I mention to anybody around the world the word America they immediately associated with USA? I tell you why, when the rest of the Continent doesn't matter...
Just look at millions and millions...of people who want to reach USA that if you looking for an answer which is the best country in the world...
It's pretty good tho, can't lie about that . It could be better but what can't?
Put Gators and paranha in the Rio Grande they'll stop coming then
you need a wall on the Mexico, Guatemala border.
Those gators will be made into wallets, boots, jackets, belts, ect....
@Ashley Mitchell too big. Most illegals are coming from Central America. I want Mexico to build a border in its southern border between Mexico and Guatemala.
@Ashley Mitchell yea I hear they're piling up at the border now waiting on old joe blow to take office so they can come on in for the freebies thought we had eliminated that problem
SO TRUE...I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE ON THE LFFT ARE REALLY STARTING TO FINALLY WAKE UP AND GETTING IT NOW...DO YOU WANT THESE PEOPLE TO LIVE NEXT DOOR TO YOU? THINK ABOUT THAT
What up Trish Hello why not?
YEAH, I AM THINKING ABOUT IT, ACTUALLY, IT HAPPENED LIKE THESE HUNDREDS OF YEARS OR A THOUSAND YEARS AGO... WHEN WESTERN COUNTRIES, USA, EUROPEANS INCLUDED INVADED AND INFLUENCED SOUTH AMERICA TO MINED THEIR RESOURCES, SUCH AS GOLD, SILVER AND OTHER MINERALS, THEIR FARMLAND WAS EXPLOITED FOR AGRICULTURAL USAGE WITHOUT SHARING THE PROFIT WITH THE INDIGENOUS PEO[PLE. PEOPLE HAS TO AWAKEN TO REALIZE THAT THEY WERE TAKEN ADVANTAGED OF.
@@Nina-ur3ld If Russia was next to the US, you would be okay if they just walk over the border?
@@gailwaters814 Russia isn't next to the US. Why would you even make such a comparison? Mexico is not endangering our lives constantly... Besides, did you know that Russia is only 2.4 miles away from us, far up north in the Pacific Ocean near Alaska? I don't see you asking for constant military presence at the Diomede Islands.
@@lucaworkman4823 No country in the world allows illegal immigrants to walk over their borders and stay in their countries. NOT ONE.
This is a very good depiction of what's happening at the border. This is a worldwide problem; where is the UN and the UN peacekeepers? Maybe just maybe the US should charge $30,000 per migrant to come into the country on a Temporary visa?
Not a bad idea. 👍
Even you can’t pay that let alone an immigrant you just have a problem seeing any other race but your own in the country
The UN does NOT want to work with Trump
I agree. But this report also shows other countries coming through so they should also be charged.
@@arieljoseph9362 the difference is that the nationals belong. foreigners don't. if you think people are so bad, why do you want to come to the us.
I feel bad for them but we have a hard time finding jobs being from here how can we get them jobs when some Americans can't I know they take jobs nobody wants but to what extent is enough
Plus they be having 4-6 kids so it’s really kinda unfair tbh
are you still having a hard time finding a job now? There are hundreds of jobs available and Americans still don’t want to work because getting unemployment seems easier. You said it yourself immigrants work the jobs nobody wants to work, because they don’t come to take advantage or others but to work hard to provide for their families abroad. They didn’t just abandon their country, their loved ones, and everything they knew because they just wanted to do so but because they had no other choice.
There's an excess amount of jobs on all levels of paygrades. How many tech jobs and medical jobs open up and need to be filled every year? Too many. As someone in California who's grown up here, these immigrants support and are the backbone of our economy. Most of my friends who came from south of the border have parents who worked hard in minimum wage laborious jobs allowing for their children to go get higher educations and graduate into careers that pay 6 figures. I hate that arguement "they're stealing our jobs" ... well maybe your not doing your job well enough. Maybe you as someone who's been here for generations needs to stop relying on minimum wage jobs.
@@nicolerivera2322 my friend I know my family but honor is honor no choice come on I used to live in the Rio grande Valley Pharr TX im a diesiel mechanic and when a Latino which also can do what we do takes less then I can I had to leave north now I don't know but I served my country my mother and grandmother are from Mexico bit they paid a lawyer a lot of money and waited I Mexico to come across u get my drift no disrespect I love my culture but it's not like the honorable generation most come and mess up que no
I promise you that the jobs immigrants are taking are not jobs that American citizens want. Stop with this dumb argument.
Wow is a terrible situation but not all they deserve to stay on this country!!!!!!!!
Dominic Reynolds none of them sorry about the bad luck
@@jessicahamilton5383 pfff yeah ma'am yeah!!!!!!!
Does this kinda remind anyone of the "Underground Railroad"? Man, history might not repeat itself but, it sure does rhyme.
***** *20210104 ***** *Grand Total 457+ miles ***** (CBPe: 453 miles as of 20210104 ; Private: 4 miles). Promise kept!
This is ≥ 101% of 450 mile goal, ≥ 89% of 509 mile goal, ≥ 69% of previous 654 mile preexisting, ≥ 45% of 1,000 miles, & ≥ 23% of entire southern border. _*Extrapolated @ 1 mile per day using recent rate._
Why do they look so well nourished and clean if its that harsh. Every one is shaved, looks healthy, clothes look clean.
Because they work their arses off for a buck a day or whatever, and food is cheap there, so they are relatively well fed. Also, I assume some do go hungry a lot, but they haven't reached starvation levels yet. You're seeing the healthy ones on this video. Probably thousands have died on their way, or don't have the energy to even start the journey. As for clean clothes, they might wash them in the river, beat them on a rock, etc..
Looks are deceiving...
What kind of silly question is this? Dignity is important, even to the poor/desperate!
Please respect the United States. Please comply with US laws. You are welcome to come to the United States, but a visa is required. Just like I went to your house, you first agreed to my entry. I have never tried to climb over the fence into your home without your consent,
If USA star using the armed forces the problem will disappear, just like China or Korea to mention some
Did they give the Native Americans that courtesy??
@@haddingtoniangcp2464 I entered your house without your permission. When you find me, I will be very polite to you.
@@alfredohinojosi1898 If someone in your house forcibly enters, can't you use your weapon?
@@junchen2298 Well it earns you a ride to the morgue in my case. My house small and I'll find you quick. Self defence!
I like the 'attitude', but it's probably against the law(in the U.S.).
No kidding. No illegals should be allowed in our country. Americans are not allowed in other countries.
10 star punishment; learn how to be self-sufficient, BYE!.
We have to build the wall... We cannot help the entire world. There are lots of middle class families in America that need help as well. We do not have unlimited money.
what about the private sector that incarcerated and what about that bass as you can talk about that
Thank you mama Africa
I'm sorry but these people don't think about the burden they bring to these countries they only think of how they will have good life and live in these countries...sorry but their countries and leaders should help their people to the fullest..very sorry hope all goes well.
So why did the white people come to America, why don't you go back to Europe?
Build the WALL....!!
Pay for the wall
On the mexican/ Guatemalan border!, that's where the real problems are coming from!
Its all about the money. U got the right amount. They will get you through, under or over the wall. Great doc!
Kindly help me to migrate to USA please.
You're right. If you have money you can pay to legally be in America. I know people who paid about $300,000 USD or so for residency. You invest in a business or something.
Big big knowledge
What are you doing in your own country to change your situation you want to come to the US why don't you change things in your country wtf
You’re just hurt! It’s everyone dream to come to the USA where I’m from, it’s high time you acknowledge the privilege of being an American or watch others do it for you 💀
Thumbs up for the makers of this documentary
We pay tax for this people leave here in USA 🇺🇸 for free! Free school 🏫 free hospital 🏥 free free free everything!
#Stop #Illegal #Migration !
I don’t believe this powerful country cannot stop this people! Shame 🤬🤬🤬🤬
Yeah you right Harold.
My name is Nancy.. my pleasure to meet you
They need to fight for thier Country then looking for a hand out..
Join together, take it back
End the war on drugs!!!
What's a SW Asian with a Mexican/US citizenship organizing human caravans to the States for? What's the real purpose of Villages Without Borders? This project wasn't planned thoroughly. "it got out of hand"
Go CBS, actually reporting REAL NEWS!...kinda
Bryochemical Intuition right
Kinda
Cut the tap don. We've seen ENOUGH
CLOSE THE DAMN BORDER!!!! HOW DO WE PAY TO PROVIDE FOR THEM? IT ISN'T RIGHT TO THEM OR US. FJB
WOW
America is not the world’s shelter
GO HOME!
They do not have homes. I see this. But I agree the U.S. can't take them all in. We are short on water and housing right now.
Maybe they shouldn't act like Immigration is owed to them. Have attitudes in America. Speak a foreign language in the work place that not everyone knows, when they could speak English. And not boost their home countries flag in America.
In the u.s. ?
These people are being paid to come here.
Wanda Armes Yeah, supported by the Democrats!
THERE GOES MY JOB
The whole neighborhood.
I live in nampa idaho my granddaughter rides schoolbus, when she gets on bus there are 3 white kids 12 mexican kids, whole city is like this, enough is enough
As long USA let them work and going to school they will keep coming...who is guilty of this?
Breed more kids, then. Problem solved
What's wrong in having Mexican children in the US?
YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF YOUR WORDS.
how long they take time...i dont believe this b4..after watching..i cant imagine how they from bangldesh reach Tjuana..
This is disgusting & should be a crime not glorified!
I need the address of this shelter
F off
Lol..Jonathan you’re very funny? Anyway my name is Nancy.. my pleasure to meet you here
@@nancyjuliet3449 Hello Nancy. Nice meeting you
What has me thinking is 17:36 - 17:59. The subtitles don't match what she said. Whose paying and for what political reasons?
Buck stops with each countries status quo ♥️
Ain't it's pretty crazy how we can travel to their country with no problem but they come here it's a problem! As an American I'm ashame of this system! We are neighbors an should help each other out
Bc they over stayed their travel and education visas you bo' zo. All they had to do was not be sneaky!
its because americans go there to visit for a week or two. Not to move their whole livelihood and families into the country.
Such is life for rich nations. Down here in brazil alot of ppl coming under the table via north side. a nation real broken no job also. Nightmare for sure. Trump rules is working out
Wow wow good brother and sister TNX GOOD Family First good USA god TNX
Either the real people they need to be going after the coyotes they're the ones I should be going after first to stop it
the USA secretary of defences watching the last part 😳😳
Should of built that wall 😢
Many wants to escape poverty so they took their chances,illegally. But many don't know the constraints and limitations after that.Prioritise those seeking asylum are genuine cases or America will have to deal with a lot after that.
Does Something Happens to him because He brings the people to US and shows His face in the Internet?🙈
8:41 that's amharic 😔
REMEMBER THE ALAMO!
All people want to do is to live. To work and to have a roof over there heads. Something we American take for granted. God be with these family that try to find some happiness in this world we live in.
Si que traten de ser felices en este mundo,pero que no nos invadan.Ya te fijaste cuantos entran cada día y cuanto nos van a subir de impuestos.
In some cases there justification for immigration, but should have an application process.
Also business hiring illegals should be fined per person found start at $1.000.00 per head
Ha! That's already on the books, for even more than that, I believe; hasn't helped as much as it should. Cooperating businesses use E-Verify, like the large manufacturing companies in my city.
Yep these people will work for PEANUTS making it bad for American workers to be unable to negotiate a decent wage and because of that they will have all the jobs..the only way they'll go home is if business's won't hire them..it should be against the law to hire them & steep fines should be brought against those who do..
She is a golden ❤️ 😍. Good bless her.
The man likes his rice of course LoL 😂 LoL
I view them as human beings as well but we cant take all of central americas poor all of these people are coming for free govt handouts
not all
Reporten con la policia para que los garren no se queden callados porfavor
These poor people pay good money to get here illegally why not pay for legal entry
I think there comes a point where its not so much about money. I feel like for a lot of people crossing the border illegally its about time. They live in nations where the majority is living in poverty. And when there's poverty there's crime. For them its not a matter of money, its a matter if their child will be the next one dead. If there child will turn to crime. If there child saw something they shouldn't have. And yes they would like to enter legally but there's only so much time before something happens to there family.So they choose the seemingly faster way. You can't blame someone for wanting to get away from that environment and situation.
Amazing content!!
I can't believe the tone on these messages. Did we just watch the same documentary?
We live in a globalized world not just at a convenience to USA global business but also limiting resources and climate change which create political and economic instability globally. It's a global problem that needs global solutions. The berlin Wall was.justified back in the day. We must be braver and more creative in how we manage the situation
I don't condone this video, I do not condone any illegal activity
Lemme guess, the forefathers came off the Mayflower with visas, right??
Where are the babies!???????
If CBS thinks it’s garnering sympathy. They are wrong!!! Thanks CBS.
I agree people have had it with this bullcrud. They say people do it for the money and government does it.
If these migrants are able to get $700 why cant they stay in their own country? It's very hard to make $700 in the US
To be Asylums seeker is the worst thing will happen to a man life most especially when ur Asylums get rejected I'm Asylums seeker in Europe
I'm sorry...that's got to be an awful feeling, having your case rejected, trying to figure out what you can do, where you can go- especially when you just can't return to your country. Have you found a "home" yet? Praying that God keeps you in His care.
Mama Africa ❤️
I'm #Somali and I Drem To go in USA aftet D.Trump Full in presadent of 4 years
Insha allah
Allah ha iifududeeyo 🤲🤲🤲🤲
Matagtay