@@sunshine_hope1579 he must be devastated and probably wants to be at Moonbin's wake... svt also pushed back the release of their mini album after the funeral too.
Sinb literally grew up with them atleast hybe respected seungkwan s friendship allowing him to mourn and then there is sinb s agency she couldn't even attend her best friends funeral my heart hurts for her
When i heard about moonbin sudden death, the first thing came on my mind is SUENGKWAN and the rest of 98liners😢🥺 as a carat who support their friendships it broke me into pieces 😭. PLEASE STAY STRONG MY BOO🥺
Well basically everyone from 1998 line to 1st to 2nd Kpop Gen had been in contact with him since he had this life since he was a Child. But obviously it should make sense in our heart and mind if we worry most about anyone in the 1998 line +/- a few birth years.
Y peor Sinb Porqué no la dejaron Ir al funeral a despedirse de su amigo Moonbin Ahhhh Amado Artista Moonbin Todos estamos igual tristes Qué ser tan especial eras Dejaste tanto amor En todos los qué te conocieron Moonbin 🙏 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
When I first heard the news, i couldn't believe it. I was in denial and like most Carats, the first person that came into my mind was Seungkwan because they were such besties, followed by Moonbin's sister, Sua. I don't know much about Moonbin but I know that he was one of the happy pills in the Kpop industry. I've been listening to Circles (by SVT) ever since I came to accept the fact that another talented artist has left us and became a star. It still hurts ngl, but I hope Carats and Arohas and other fandoms will do what we can do now, to comfort and support our idols emotionally right now as they are resting ❤❤❤ I'm so relieved that many artists, including SVT, has postponed their schedules to grief for Moonbin, they definitely need this period to cope with the sudden news. I hope the artists, especially Moonbin's family, relatives, and close friends, will take as long as they need to rest, grief, and cope with this heartbreaking news 🙏 🙏 🙏 And for Seungkwan, I hope both his families will be there to comfort him because he needs them and their emotional support the most right now 🙏🙏🙏
Meanwhile others had /wanted to MC and had literal performance on stage and many had to go there ways in black attire. I just hope we as Fans can go back to simply say THANK YOU for all what they do for me and you through their melodies, shennanigans while we're breathing the same air as them (again).
no cause it shatters my heart that instead of saying sanha, the astro members, or just leaving out the name, he flat out said seungkwan💔 their friendship is so precious and i hope one day in their next lives they can meet again
seungkwan had been feeling low lately, even members had noticed and poke about it on 'in the soop2', if he cried so much when he just had a bad dream about wonu dying I can't imagine the state he must be in right now. I feel so sorry for him to have lost one of his best friends, I loved their friendship so much, im tearing up while writing this, I just want to send a warm hug to him right now, and tell him that everything will be okay even I can't even imagine the pain he must be going through. Uri Boo please stay strong, carats love you much, to moon bin who has become a star, rest well, we will always love and remember you in our hearts, you smile so contagious will always be remembered as well, stay healthy now where you are, we will look after seungkwan well and protect him the way you would've, so dont worry and rest in peace.
He probably looking for you too now Moonbin 😢 Ur okay now right Moonbinnaa ... From now on we never gonna see ur new comeback and there is no more Moonbin anymore to think about that makes me hurt inside .... Moonbinaa rest well now my baby ur doing your best we gonna see you in afterlife... RIP Moonbin 🌹🌹🌹❤
I pray that Seungkwan and Sinb are doing well... Moonbin-ah, I hope you are happy wherever you are..... You will always be remembered and loved May you rest in peace binne 💙 Its really true that the moon went to shine with the stars... Love you 🖤
I read it somewhere but the author said this, “The biggest smiles hide the deepest secrets and the people with the prettiest eyes hide the most tears and the people with the kindest heart hides the most pain.”
I am literally shock with the sudden news of moonbin death . I am not a big fan of Astro but I really used to respect them. I hope each and every idol gets to live freely and both mentally and physically healthy. They are the one who cured us from depression but because of such intense pressure they are falling into depression 💜💜
The first person came to my mind was sanha...😢i don't know how he is doing...he lost his most lovely brother....i don't know how he will react when he will be on stage without his binnie hyung 😭😭sanha be strong boy your binnie hyung is always with you 😢
Seungkwan is not participating in the pre-recording of "Mnet Countdown " for today cuz boo is in poor condition 😭😭🥺💎🫂 take your time seungkwan. Pls, rest well 🫂🤍
Даже не верится что мунбина больше нет хотя только не давно он выступал и ездил по концертам .Столько хороших воспоминаний осталось о человеке.И эти воспоминания останутся с нами.Что бы продолжать жить и идти дальше .
SinB and Moonbin have been bestfriends for 15 years. Umji was also his friend. I can't imagine how bad they felt about the death of their bestfriend 😔💔
Hope you Rest in peace Moonbin. Just in case if you don't know, he died of cardiac arrest not a suicide. He was said to be sick at that time. Please spread these real reason to the fans.
@@furuyakeifu as far as I know, the family released a statement of the cause of his dead and it was a stroke. He already was having health issues for which he has to take a hiatus before
@@yunhosmile..its not rare..it does happend to teenagers or youngsters in nowadays..since im working in medical line, eventho theres no official statement made of what happend to Moon Bin..i personally believe he died of cardiac arrest or stroke or both..for those who are big fan of moonbin, they know MoonBin is a very busy person in his daily activity..very commited & workoholic person as an Idol..travelling here & there for tour cncert, fan meeting, attend Event/ been invited for tv show, singing or dance practice for solo or with group or collabrate wit other idols..he even also learn & practice others K-Pop Idol dance choreography (everytime if theres a new KPop song release)..practice hours-hours until perfect then upload the video in internet as a sign that to be part in dance challenge & as well as show some support for other K-Pop artists..add other 1 more..he also active go to gym for excercise in order can maintain his stamina, to maintained his body weight as well to be keep fit..so, can u imagine, does anyone know how many hours MoonBin get some sleep & rest..as adult around his age..his body needs at least 6-8 hrs of sleep..so, he might pushed@ force him self to do all those things & neglected about his health..i do think he did go to Doctors for check-up or when his body already start give warning sign & simptom of hypertension@ blood pressure high due to not.enuff sleep & rest..im pretty sure,any doctors surely advice him to get rest for certain period..he might ignore the Doc advice & still proceed with his busy/tight schedule..maybe he does take medication to control his blood pressure but im afraid that he might also took overdose of PainKiller in order to have the strenght to continue do all of his activity frm morning to pass midnite,everyday..eventho not enuff sleep, but with the help of painkiller or any other medication,he still hav the 'energy'..but when his body already give 'warning' & he neglected the sign&simpthom of BreakDown, when it already reached to max limit, thats wat happen where the cardiac arrest occur..if somebody was there, he might still can be save..by doing basic cpr a.s.a.p..or at least called Ambulance & inform that MoonBin suddenly collapse..for sure also the Paramedic will guide & give instruction to the caller on how to perform CPR via phonecall..at least can makesure his Brain get enuff oxygen when the heart is being pumping while waiting for the Paramedic team..take note: if brain didnt received any oxygen more than 5 minutes..that person have a high risk of BrainDeath..OR.. at that time,his blood pressure super high & caused a small vein ruptured in his Brain..then when it ruptured, thats the time he get stroke either full body paralyse or half body paralyse & fall..if his head hit on the floor first, that make it more worst where skull cracked can caused more bleeding & more blood clots in his brain..with that, the chances of survive is low.. Again..this is just my random opinion based on minimal official info..since Moonbin family didnt want to reveal the official caused of death either after done post-mortem or refused for post-mortem..I AM 100% sure its not suicide..
This is really a painful shock to everyone. I still haven't recovered from Astro Rocky's departure from the group and now this happened to Binnie... where we could never see him ever again. 😢😭 I got to know Seungkwan because of Binnie. I super love their friendship. Then I started following Seungkwan and supported him too. I hope kwannie could recover from this, same for me being an Aroha for all these years. May Carats shower Seungkwan with so much love and understanding in this difficult times. Binnie please watch over your besties, Astro members, your sister, your family and your one & only true love Aroha. 💜🤍🕊
Wh isn't? Just another prove that Fanwars are for the behind while they try to get in the hairs of you and mine the Artists they want to hype up or keep down are legitatmely haning out with eachother doing stuff that the Age on ID "just does."
I never ever knew him but i do know that i will never forget him. There is something so special about him. You cant help but love him . Moonbin forever in our hearts❤❤❤❤❤❤
The first thing that I thought about was Sua to be honest, she’s his sister and she said that if he doesn’t answer her call she gets anxious so I feel so much for her. The second people is SinB and Seungkwan. I feel so them. so much
It's incredible that this video just popped up in my feed again today (19/02/24), and just when I was listening to 'what kind of future', I feel devastated
When i heard what happend to moonbin, i was thinking, worrying nit only about his group, but seungkwan. I wasn't worried about how hes going to preform or anything. But his feelings. Its so hard to loose a best friend you have. 😢 i cried watching this. Rest in peace to the smile of sunshine, Moonbin❤
Este niño era hermoso por dentro y fuera hojala,lo hubieran apoyado más el tenía para brillar toda su vida 25 años esta empezando a vivir una persona solo no lo valoraron.
Actually it can be- Ik he is literally like a ray of sunshine always smiling but you never know their true self- Ik its hard to accept this but yea our idols fake it like kwan is also like really bubbly and always easy going but watching him breakdown in in the soop series made us realize how hard he is going on himself for the show for seventeen for carats We must know that not every smile is a happy one- Whatever be the reaaon I believe that moonbin is in a better place now I hope he gets a lot of rest there. We carats will always remember you binnah as the one with the pure soul Rip 😭
nooo, im not really an astro but i love and appreciate every friendship in kpop and i enjoy every funny vids and performance of astro especially moonbin, i am a carat so i also knew that moonbin and kwan are best friends and its making me cry😭💔
This is more reason for seungkwan to Be strong because u know he is in a Better place looking down on u and bieng proud of u . We miss u moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔
I remember when I first saw the news from a friend's status and I thought she was clowning, I am not the biggest follower of astro but I've seen moonbin literally everywhere on TH-cam for years long enough to fall in love with his personality, when the news was confirmed my heart dropped with dread at the thought of him leaving us so soon, leaving his sister,fans and friends I'm still in shock honestly, this is a reminder that idols are humans too even if u don't like them they don't deserve to receive any unnecessary hate for they already have their own worries and pains, RIP ANGEL
Lamentable 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 MOONBIN ASTRO PERFECTO, ARTISTA BRILLANTE, GENIAL, TE EXTRAÑAMOS FOREVER EN LOS ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ QEPD. NIÑO BELLO CON LINDAS ENCANTADORAS SONRISAS.
I feel really bad for Seungkwan. I had a friend leave like Moonbin, we weren't even that close but I still felt like crap... can't imagine what Seungkwan is feeling.
As someone who lost a best friend, it's hard. Really hard. Seungkwan is really strong for enduring the pain. I hope he knows that Binnie is looking on him from above, smiling because he's so proud of who he is today and that he's happy again..
SORRY SULLI, GOO HARA, JONGHYUN, MOONBIN. WE WILL FOREVER MISS YOU. YOU ALL DID WELL. YOU WILL ALWAYS HAVE SPECIAL PLACE IN OUR HEART. YOU NEVER FAILED TO MAKE US HAPPY. WE LOVED YOU GUYS AND WE WILL FOREVER LOVE YOU D MISS YOU. REST IN PIECE 😞😞😭😭 ...........
For the people, Moonbin didn't suicide he had heart problems and recently he was dealing with high blood pressure he had a stroke due to which he passed away🕊️ #RIPMoonbin
@@silvia1234si Don't listen to Person he/she make up lies and false Rumors 🙄 and Moonbin's mom just tweeted on Google Don't spread lies and false Rumors about her son and she just wanted us fans to be happy 😊 not be heartbroken 💔 and Stomach pain and Chest pain isn't Stroke symptoms cause I checked it doesn't say anything about him having Stroke
Everytime I see moonbin's face, I cannot believe he is no longer with us. I am just his fans who look at him from far, yet I feel the loss and regret for losing him. I cannot imagine his family and his friends feelings now.
Please this video is too much..i can't control my tears..why Moonbin you did that..your family, seungkwana, your fans are dying inside too..if this can be possible, i'll surely pray to God for your comeback . . .
Mein kleiner 🌟 moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢i Miss You my Angel 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢i Love You for ever moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢du fehlst jeden Tag 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 jeder Tag ohne dich ist so leer😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 moonbin kannst du mich hören ich vermisse dich so sehr ich liebe dich 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 liebe Grüße aus Berlin 😢😢😢😢😢
Tosday march 11 Its almost a year and I feel like it was yesterday Every 19th of the month 8 pm to 9pm I would just sit outside looking at sky It's coming again i miss you Binnie
My bios left me and his fans and gone forever fly high angle rest in peace 🕊️ we miss you soooooooooooo much Moonbin I hope your in better place now 😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
The first person who comes to my mind when I heard about Moonbin was Seungkwan.. My poor baby will be so devastated😢
Me too, the members are probably consoling him right now...
Same here, the moment i heard the news i was like may god give strength to seungkwan
Me too. And knowing Seungkwan ik he might be bawling his eyes out. And I can't even imagine SinB
I think he is not feeling well he just cancelled his apparition on the pre recording of the mcountdown stage and pledis said he is not feeling well
@@sunshine_hope1579 he must be devastated and probably wants to be at Moonbin's wake... svt also pushed back the release of their mini album after the funeral too.
seungkwan was helping moonbin's parents restuarant, took some time off kpop amd he even mentioned moonbin when he won DAESANG 😭❤️
Sinb literally grew up with them atleast hybe respected seungkwan s friendship allowing him to mourn and then there is sinb s agency she couldn't even attend her best friends funeral my heart hurts for her
What??? Really, poor SinB 😮😢
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I cant imagine those beautiful peoples pain they must be so hurt rn
Can you tell me how wonderful these people are??
@@Ksenia_5684The fans,his family,members and friends
When i heard about moonbin sudden death, the first thing came on my mind is SUENGKWAN and the rest of 98liners😢🥺 as a carat who support their friendships it broke me into pieces 😭. PLEASE STAY STRONG MY BOO🥺
98
Who are in there?
@dungluong1883 SEVENTEEN's Seungkwan, ASTRO's Moonbin, VIVIZ's SinB and Umji, iKON's Chanwoo amd Straykids Lee know
Mine is sua😢
Cha eunwoo was the first person who had come in my mind at that time...😭I still miss him sooo much 😢
OMG SinB was literally best friends with Moonbin too. They've known each other for so many years... they must be heartbroken💔😭🥺
Well basically everyone from 1998 line to 1st to 2nd Kpop Gen had been in contact with him since he had this life since he was a Child.
But obviously it should make sense in our heart and mind if we worry most about anyone in the 1998 line +/- a few birth years.
Y peor Sinb Porqué no la dejaron
Ir al funeral a despedirse de su amigo Moonbin
Ahhhh Amado Artista Moonbin
Todos estamos igual tristes
Qué ser tan especial eras
Dejaste tanto amor
En todos los qué te conocieron
Moonbin 🙏
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
The way he said "ill look for him"😢
When I first heard the news, i couldn't believe it. I was in denial and like most Carats, the first person that came into my mind was Seungkwan because they were such besties, followed by Moonbin's sister, Sua. I don't know much about Moonbin but I know that he was one of the happy pills in the Kpop industry. I've been listening to Circles (by SVT) ever since I came to accept the fact that another talented artist has left us and became a star. It still hurts ngl, but I hope Carats and Arohas and other fandoms will do what we can do now, to comfort and support our idols emotionally right now as they are resting ❤❤❤
I'm so relieved that many artists, including SVT, has postponed their schedules to grief for Moonbin, they definitely need this period to cope with the sudden news. I hope the artists, especially Moonbin's family, relatives, and close friends, will take as long as they need to rest, grief, and cope with this heartbreaking news 🙏 🙏 🙏 And for Seungkwan, I hope both his families will be there to comfort him because he needs them and their emotional support the most right now 🙏🙏🙏
Same
This made me tear up, now seungkwan will be the one looking for you, stay strong moonbin is loved and will always be remembered in our ❤️ heart 😭😭😭🫂
I'm not an aroha but i cry for him....
Meanwhile others had /wanted to MC and had literal performance on stage and many had to go there ways in black attire. I just hope we as Fans can go back to simply say THANK YOU for all what they do for me and you through their melodies, shennanigans while we're breathing the same air as them (again).
💜🤍😪
no cause it shatters my heart that instead of saying sanha, the astro members, or just leaving out the name, he flat out said seungkwan💔 their friendship is so precious and i hope one day in their next lives they can meet again
seungkwan had been feeling low lately, even members had noticed and poke about it on 'in the soop2', if he cried so much when he just had a bad dream about wonu dying I can't imagine the state he must be in right now. I feel so sorry for him to have lost one of his best friends, I loved their friendship so much, im tearing up while writing this, I just want to send a warm hug to him right now, and tell him that everything will be okay even I can't even imagine the pain he must be going through. Uri Boo please stay strong, carats love you much, to moon bin who has become a star, rest well, we will always love and remember you in our hearts, you smile so contagious will always be remembered as well, stay healthy now where you are, we will look after seungkwan well and protect him the way you would've, so dont worry and rest in peace.
He probably looking for you too now Moonbin 😢 Ur okay now right Moonbinnaa ... From now on we never gonna see ur new comeback and there is no more Moonbin anymore to think about that makes me hurt inside .... Moonbinaa rest well now my baby ur doing your best we gonna see you in afterlife... RIP Moonbin 🌹🌹🌹❤
Imagine his sister. Someone you grew up with him, Living together most of your life, and one day you find out.. you won’t ever see them. 😭
It’s horrible. It’s the worst feeling in the world and it never goes away 💔
I pray that Seungkwan and Sinb are doing well...
Moonbin-ah,
I hope you are happy wherever you are.....
You will always be remembered and loved
May you rest in peace binne 💙
Its really true that the moon went to shine with the stars...
Love you 🖤
Seungkwan must be looking for him
I CAN'T-
MOOOOONNNBIIINNNAAAAA PLEASEEEEEE COMEEEEEE BACKKKKKKKKKKK
He can't return anymore....
Rest in peace Moonbin. 🩷 so many people will miss you
We all cried together that day.... but the grief was different.
I read it somewhere but the author said this, “The biggest smiles hide the deepest secrets and the people with the prettiest eyes hide the most tears and the people with the kindest heart hides the most pain.”
So very true.
I am literally shock with the sudden news of moonbin death . I am not a big fan of Astro but I really used to respect them. I hope each and every idol gets to live freely and both mentally and physically healthy. They are the one who cured us from depression but because of such intense pressure they are falling into depression 💜💜
It's been 1 year... I hope he is happy where he is ❤❤
Moonbin is such a kind hearted man😢❤🕊️
I am crying for moonbin after seeing the video...💔
The first person came to my mind was sanha...😢i don't know how he is doing...he lost his most lovely brother....i don't know how he will react when he will be on stage without his binnie hyung 😭😭sanha be strong boy your binnie hyung is always with you 😢
Ahgh this is why i cry all the time I still miss moonbin hopes he is peaceful up there 🕊️
There is no news of our boo 😢😢
Moonbin rip dear 😢😢
Yeah I am worried about him🙁
Seungkwan is not participating in the pre-recording of "Mnet Countdown " for today cuz boo is in poor condition 😭😭🥺💎🫂 take your time seungkwan. Pls, rest well 🫂🤍
I think he's getting an hiatus for long time now.....he doesn't get an hiatus but he's devastated now....
😭🥺🥺
I swear SinB and Seungkwan are really crying hard right now 😭😢
Sinb knew moonbin way before seungkwan did will always break my heart
I’m very heartbroken 💔 I can’t even spend my Eid tommorow but I’ll do it for moonbin ❤
Same💔
Seungkwan oppa wishing your's condition okay and didn't get sick 🥺 Losing a dear friend is very painful but I hope you will strong enough to face it
seungkwan would do anything to go look and find moonbin anyone would for him 😢
Даже не верится что мунбина больше нет хотя только не давно он выступал и ездил по концертам .Столько хороших воспоминаний осталось о человеке.И эти воспоминания останутся с нами.Что бы продолжать жить и идти дальше .
"What if your best friend suddenly disappears?"
"If Seungkwan suddenly disappears, I'll search for him & find him."
🥺♥️
Seungkwan spoke about moonbin at the MAMA awards after winning their first daesabgs, it was so fucking sad😭
Hes gonna be so sad! This made me cry so much! Im not getting over this any time soon 😭
SinB and Moonbin have been bestfriends for 15 years. Umji was also his friend. I can't imagine how bad they felt about the death of their bestfriend 😔💔
Мунбин..скучаю💔😭
светлая память, спи сладко 🤍🕊️🥺
it's so sad...rest in peace moonbin🕊😭
Hope you Rest in peace Moonbin.
Just in case if you don't know, he died of cardiac arrest not a suicide. He was said to be sick at that time.
Please spread these real reason to the fans.
Yeah he also suffered from high blood pressure.
How do you know? Where was this reported?
@@furuyakeifu as far as I know, the family released a statement of the cause of his dead and it was a stroke. He already was having health issues for which he has to take a hiatus before
It’s so rare for someone his age to die from cardiac arrest. He must’ve had some pretty serious health issues. So tragic.
@@yunhosmile..its not rare..it does happend to teenagers or youngsters in nowadays..since im working in medical line, eventho theres no official statement made of what happend to Moon Bin..i personally believe he died of cardiac arrest or stroke or both..for those who are big fan of moonbin, they know MoonBin is a very busy person in his daily activity..very commited & workoholic person as an Idol..travelling here & there for tour cncert, fan meeting, attend Event/ been invited for tv show, singing or dance practice for solo or with group or collabrate wit other idols..he even also learn & practice others K-Pop Idol dance choreography (everytime if theres a new KPop song release)..practice hours-hours until perfect then upload the video in internet as a sign that to be part in dance challenge & as well as show some support for other K-Pop artists..add other 1 more..he also active go to gym for excercise in order can maintain his stamina, to maintained his body weight as well to be keep fit..so, can u imagine, does anyone know how many hours MoonBin get some sleep & rest..as adult around his age..his body needs at least 6-8 hrs of sleep..so, he might pushed@ force him self to do all those things & neglected about his health..i do think he did go to Doctors for check-up or when his body already start give warning sign & simptom of hypertension@ blood pressure high due to not.enuff sleep & rest..im pretty sure,any doctors surely advice him to get rest for certain period..he might ignore the Doc advice & still proceed with his busy/tight schedule..maybe he does take medication to control his blood pressure but im afraid that he might also took overdose of PainKiller in order to have the strenght to continue do all of his activity frm morning to pass midnite,everyday..eventho not enuff sleep, but with the help of painkiller or any other medication,he still hav the 'energy'..but when his body already give 'warning' & he neglected the sign&simpthom of BreakDown, when it already reached to max limit, thats wat happen where the cardiac arrest occur..if somebody was there, he might still can be save..by doing basic cpr a.s.a.p..or at least called Ambulance & inform that MoonBin suddenly collapse..for sure also the Paramedic will guide & give instruction to the caller on how to perform CPR via phonecall..at least can makesure his Brain get enuff oxygen when the heart is being pumping while waiting for the Paramedic team..take note: if brain didnt received any oxygen more than 5 minutes..that person have a high risk of BrainDeath..OR..
at that time,his blood pressure super high & caused a small vein ruptured in his Brain..then when it ruptured, thats the time he get stroke either full body paralyse or half body paralyse & fall..if his head hit on the floor first, that make it more worst where skull cracked can caused more bleeding & more blood clots in his brain..with that, the chances of survive is low..
Again..this is just my random opinion based on minimal official info..since Moonbin family didnt want to reveal the official caused of death either after done post-mortem or refused for post-mortem..I AM 100% sure its not suicide..
Seungkwan's really having hard time now .
Stay strong seungkwan.
Rest in peace Moonbin
We will miss you 🤧
승관이 사라진다면은 찿으려갈것야 친구찾는다 빈아보고싶다많이잘생겼다꽃미남눈웃음준사람사랑한다응원할게요 영상을보니까목소리가예쁘다 언제나그자리에 함께해줘서고마워감사합니다별처럼나비처럼행복했으면좋겠어 민들레꽃홀씨되어훨훨날아다니는새처럼강아지처럼빈아팬이야 빈아사랑해❤❤❤❤❤❤
Moonbin is forever living in my ❤
No matter what happens, i Miss u sooooo much my brother
This is really a painful shock to everyone. I still haven't recovered from Astro Rocky's departure from the group and now this happened to Binnie... where we could never see him ever again. 😢😭 I got to know Seungkwan because of Binnie. I super love their friendship. Then I started following Seungkwan and supported him too. I hope kwannie could recover from this, same for me being an Aroha for all these years. May Carats shower Seungkwan with so much love and understanding in this difficult times. Binnie please watch over your besties, Astro members, your sister, your family and your one & only true love Aroha. 💜🤍🕊
we are all in pain rn, but them as the ones closest to moonbin are surely beyond breaking down. we lost our moon and now he's with the stars 💔
Ikon Chanwoo is also his childhood friend 😢 .
Wh isn't? Just another prove that Fanwars are for the behind while they try to get in the hairs of you and mine the Artists they want to hype up or keep down are legitatmely haning out with eachother doing stuff that the Age on ID "just does."
i miss you moonbin now you are disappeared where will seungkwan and we find you now😭😭😭😭
I never ever knew him but i do know that i will never forget him. There is something so special about him. You cant help but love him . Moonbin forever in our hearts❤❤❤❤❤❤
Yes, always 😭😭😭..
RIP moonbin 😭😭😭. He was a legend and a good friend and my bias I hope you are now happy in heaven cause you can’t be anywhere else
I hope Sinb and Moon sua will take care of each other ❤️🩹❤️🩹
Also Chanwoo and Chani💔😢
The first thing that I thought about was Sua to be honest, she’s his sister and she said that if he doesn’t answer her call she gets anxious so I feel so much for her. The second people is SinB and Seungkwan. I feel so them. so much
It's incredible that this video just popped up in my feed again today (19/02/24), and just when I was listening to 'what kind of future', I feel devastated
When I see moonbin,I am cried😢😢I miss for Moonbin❤❤❤😢😢My angel❤
I can’t stop crying it hurts because I miss him so much and I ever got a chance to meet him every night? Moonbin I miss you
When i heard what happend to moonbin, i was thinking, worrying nit only about his group, but seungkwan. I wasn't worried about how hes going to preform or anything. But his feelings. Its so hard to loose a best friend you have. 😢 i cried watching this. Rest in peace to the smile of sunshine, Moonbin❤
Este niño era hermoso por dentro y fuera hojala,lo hubieran apoyado más el tenía para brillar toda su vida 25 años esta empezando a vivir una persona solo no lo valoraron.
My heart goes out to them including Chanu, Chani, and Gayoung too 🥺🙏
I hope Seungkwan has people who support him, it's really hurts to loose someone you love so dearly
Rest In Peace Moonbin!
I strongly believe he didn't commit suicide. I strongly believe it's not suicide
i hope so too
Actually it can be-
Ik he is literally like a ray of sunshine always smiling but you never know their true self-
Ik its hard to accept this but yea our idols fake it like kwan is also like really bubbly and always easy going but watching him breakdown in in the soop series made us realize how hard he is going on himself for the show for seventeen for carats
We must know that not every smile is a happy one-
Whatever be the reaaon I believe that moonbin is in a better place now I hope he gets a lot of rest there.
We carats will always remember you binnah as the one with the pure soul
Rip 😭
We don't know for sure rn but i hope it wasn't suicide bc it would be sad to see that he was hurting so much and we didn't notice it
He was at hiatus for health issues.
Wow, ur me, I’m you, bcs when I heard the news, this was the first thing that came out of my mouth after being stunned for hours😢😢😢
When moonbin said he’ll go “look for him” all I can think about was how seungkwan can do the same😢😢
Rejoice in all the LOVE that you shared...keep that Joy alive always !!!
Yo también lloro mucho porq lo extraño y me imagino al amigo como debe de extrañarlo todavía más ya q compartieron mucho ❤❤❤❤😢😢😢
nooo, im not really an astro but i love and appreciate every friendship in kpop and i enjoy every funny vids and performance of astro especially moonbin, i am a carat so i also knew that moonbin and kwan are best friends and its making me cry😭💔
This is more reason for seungkwan to
Be strong because u know he is in a
Better place looking down on u and bieng proud of u . We miss u moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔
We carats worldwide will always be here for you our baby Boo❤stay strong
Rest in peace, moonbin. u were such a positive person. We all loved u and will always love u and never forget u.❤😢
My deepest condolences to moonbins friends and family Rest In Peace binnie 😢❤
rest in peace moon😭 we have you in our hearts❤🕊️🤍
Rest in peace moonbin we will never forget you we love you so much and will miss you😢
This is just devastating we miss u moonbin...❤❤
I remember when I first saw the news from a friend's status and I thought she was clowning, I am not the biggest follower of astro but I've seen moonbin literally everywhere on TH-cam for years long enough to fall in love with his personality, when the news was confirmed my heart dropped with dread at the thought of him leaving us so soon, leaving his sister,fans and friends I'm still in shock honestly, this is a reminder that idols are humans too even if u don't like them they don't deserve to receive any unnecessary hate for they already have their own worries and pains, RIP ANGEL
Our poor seungkwan must be so sad, alone, confused, ... moonbin we miss you so much 😭
The fact that they're too sensitive it would be so hard on them to accept it 😭
I remember Seungkwan said that he was so sad and even crying when he dreams of Wonwoo dying
But this time, it's not a dream😭
Lamentable 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 MOONBIN ASTRO PERFECTO, ARTISTA BRILLANTE, GENIAL, TE EXTRAÑAMOS FOREVER EN LOS ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
QEPD. NIÑO BELLO CON LINDAS ENCANTADORAS SONRISAS.
I feel really bad for Seungkwan. I had a friend leave like Moonbin, we weren't even that close but I still felt like crap... can't imagine what Seungkwan is feeling.
98 line is the best!! Moon we love you
As someone who lost a best friend, it's hard. Really hard. Seungkwan is really strong for enduring the pain. I hope he knows that Binnie is looking on him from above, smiling because he's so proud of who he is today and that he's happy again..
You disappeared moonbin..🕊️
moonbinသတိရတယ်chaeunwoo
Please stop crying. It hurts so much to see you cry, I hope they both find comfort 😭
I can't ever imagine suddenly getting news of a close friend gone.. They were always together and suddenly one disappears, it's really so painful.
but then it's him who couldn't find u anymore 😭
Moon what a beautiful soul
SORRY SULLI, GOO HARA, JONGHYUN, MOONBIN.
WE WILL FOREVER MISS YOU.
YOU ALL DID WELL.
YOU WILL ALWAYS HAVE SPECIAL PLACE IN OUR HEART.
YOU NEVER FAILED TO MAKE US HAPPY.
WE LOVED YOU GUYS AND WE WILL FOREVER LOVE YOU D MISS YOU.
REST IN PIECE
😞😞😭😭
...........
I believe them in Heaven 🌈 with our family dog Chico too
For the people,
Moonbin didn't suicide he had heart problems and recently he was dealing with high blood pressure he had a stroke due to which he passed away🕊️
#RIPMoonbin
Foi overdose?
@@silvia1234si Don't listen to Person he/she make up lies and false Rumors 🙄 and Moonbin's mom just tweeted on Google Don't spread lies and false Rumors about her son and she just wanted us fans to be happy 😊 not be heartbroken 💔 and Stomach pain and Chest pain isn't Stroke symptoms cause I checked it doesn't say anything about him having Stroke
Everytime I see moonbin's face, I cannot believe he is no longer with us. I am just his fans who look at him from far, yet I feel the loss and regret for losing him. I cannot imagine his family and his friends feelings now.
Nobody can't imagine how Seungkwan feeling after Moonbin's death💔😭
Moonbin really had brightest smile, Don't know what he hid behind those smile...
Kalau aq jdi seungkwan aq bakalan inget kata2 moonbin ini seumur hidup😢 gak tau gimana rasanya untuk mendem dan nyimpen ini semua😭
Also moon sua would be balling.....😭😭😭😭😭 imean she was with him since they were born 😢😢
Alys in people's ❤️ stay happy own your world moon 🌙
I can understand how he feels ,she was 11 an my best friend,still miss her nowxxxxxx
Please this video is too much..i can't control my tears..why Moonbin you did that..your family, seungkwana, your fans are dying inside too..if this can be possible, i'll surely pray to God for your comeback . . .
Mein kleiner 🌟 moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢i Miss You my Angel 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢i Love You for ever moonbin 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢du fehlst jeden Tag 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 jeder Tag ohne dich ist so leer😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 moonbin kannst du mich hören ich vermisse dich so sehr ich liebe dich 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 liebe Grüße aus Berlin 😢😢😢😢😢
I can’t imagine how moonbin’s friends feel…
Seungkwan & binnie are truly friend , i totally like their friendship 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺❤❤❤❤
Tosday march 11
Its almost a year and I feel like it was yesterday
Every 19th of the month 8 pm to 9pm I would just sit outside looking at sky
It's coming again i miss you Binnie
When i heard the news i can't believe it i cried with my heart out Rest In Peace Moonbin💗🕊️
My bios left me and his fans and gone forever fly high angle rest in peace 🕊️ we miss you soooooooooooo much Moonbin I hope your in better place now 😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
So sorry this happened a loss of any kind is so hard to handle but know he goes to a better place !!!!!