@@RicardoSalonga-qc1vg exactly I’m still in shock I feel very sad for his family and friends who were really close to him .. And thinking of Moon Shua I can’t stop crying 😭 I really hope and pray for her to stay strong..
The hardest thing is i didn't discover him when he was alive, and searching for his name after he died only to find out he was a precious one, that i couldnt love him enough...
It's still less painful than loving him for a long time and witnessing his passing. It's really chocking and heartbreaking watching his videos over again
I don't know if I'm more sorry for those who didn't know him while he was shining here or if I'm more sorry for us that have been suffering his abcense everyday since he was part of our everyday while he was with us.
As a sister myself I would be so lost and terrified if I lost my brother...I hope Sua will stay strong. I cannot imagine the amount of pain and grief Binnie's family and friends are experiencing. Fly high our Moon! As an Atiny I will give all Aroha's a hug 🕊🌕💖
My brother(younger than me for one year too) and I can relate to Moonbin and Sua's relationship. And if ever I'll lose him forever, I won't know what will I feel. Losing someone forever is hard. And rn, I can't imagine what Sua is going through. May Moonbin comfort everyone, may it be on their dreams or any means. I know Moonbin will do that. Keep shining bright, Moonbin. Gain the rest you need up there.
수아는 이렇게 든든한 오빠가 있어서 좋겠다 가정 교육을 잘 받았는지 오빠 앞에서 고개 돌려 술 마시는 수아도 참하고 그걸 보고 기특해서 웃는 오빠도 참 보기 좋은 남매 정말 이 영상 보며 눈물나고 가슴 아프다 사랑스러운 남매에게 왜 이런 시련을 줬는지 하늘이 원망스러울뿐😢😢😢😭😭😭😭
😢😢😢😢😢the love of brother and sister is sooo adorable moonbin moonsua is missing you very much but you are watching over her and is happy to see she is doing well moonsua loves her brother sooo very much 😢😢😢😢
Bin pidió un deseo en el ultimo programa con sua y dijo: "para este 2023 deseo que Sua sea feliz" eso es lo que bin siempre ha querido y seguro sua cumplirá su ultimo deseo. Hermanos Moon por siempre 💜
moonbin will always be by your side moonsua even if he is not here to answer the phone when you call but he will always be by your side taking care of you and supporting billie he loves you so much you guys will always be the best brother forever moon💜💜💜
Can't believe it's been 10 days already ... I just can't ... I miss you so much moonbin🥺❤️ Moon sua ... I hope you stay strong and safe ... I know that the astro members will be her guardians now ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤️
Es un Amor muy lindo de Hermanos , más el no era adivinó pará saber qué IVA a morir, solo Dios sabe cómo y cuando suceden las Cosas 💯💯💯💯🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻✨✨🥇🥇🥇🥇🫰😇😇🙏🙏🕊️🕊️🕊️
And we failed to protect another one I can't imagine how his friends family group and sister are feeling Moon sua is probably hurt from his sudden death Moon sua stay strong for Moonbin because he wouldn't want to see you cry he would want to see you happy and continuing your career and we all are missing him too. Rest in peace Moonbin😢😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭
This made me cryyyyyyyy. We will all miss moonbin. I hate the kpop industry they are killing our beautiful people. They need to change. But this made me cry so muchhhhhh. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Why do I keep getting moonbin recommendations when I do I start crying he’s my bias and only bias in Astro I can never forget him He will shine as a star in the sky
I hope Sua will overcome this😢😢😢 we know it's hard but i hope she can think the brighter side that her oppa is now in a peaceful place doing what Bin love's the most singing and dancing upthere,no more pain and difficulties Bin rest now in paradise,you did very well downhere🤧🤧
Regardless of whatever reason led to his so unexpected disappearance, it's very sad that something like this happened and we can only soothe the pain of the family by keeping a beautiful memory alive
I have siblings and seeing that moon sua lost her oppa it hurts so bad 😭😭 Siblings are the one with whom we can share everything if we have always share such bestie type of bond.... moon sua and bin have shared such bond....💔😭😭 R.I.P MOONBIN 🕊
moonbin i hope you are well sleeping in the moon world, we are all missing you but we respect your decision because only you knew what you were feeling, don't worry because your fans are by your side always and your sister moonsua who loves you, and your star brothers who are still mourning you. agent is really crying because of our beautiful star who died, but it's moonsua who lost his brother with whom they shared stages, created childhood memories together, and that he won't answer the phone when she feels alone, more moonsua! continue with your work because your brother just wants to see you happy, and get where he still intended to get. he is proud of you, and is looking out for us wherever he is i love you so much moonbin😂😂
Still can’t believe he’s gone 😭
Honestly same I am still processing
Me too
I think it's hard to move on even after many year flyes
@@RicardoSalonga-qc1vg exactly
I’m still in shock
I feel very sad for his family and friends who were really close to him ..
And thinking of Moon Shua I can’t stop crying 😭
I really hope and pray for her to stay strong..
Same....
I can't imagine what her sister is feeling right now😭😭😭😭😭
Yg cewe adik cuy
@@Roosjeanej sister = (saudara kandung) kakak/adik cewek
No one can imagine bro....😭😭💔
He was the one who was so close to her heart
Now she lost her angel woh was the reason for her smile 😭😭😭🥺💔🕊
@@Roosjeanej Sister is used to call older/younger female siblings. So it can be both (Kakak/adik)
@@Roosjeanej kak dia bukan indo ye 😂 saya malay btw
The way he said -- "Moon sua be happy in 2023"....... I burst into tears😭😭
Rest in peace our angel 💜
🥺🥺🥺 he will
The hardest thing is i didn't discover him when he was alive, and searching for his name after he died only to find out he was a precious one, that i couldnt love him enough...
same
It's still less painful than loving him for a long time and witnessing his passing. It's really chocking and heartbreaking watching his videos over again
I don't know if I'm more sorry for those who didn't know him while he was shining here or if I'm more sorry for us that have been suffering his abcense everyday since he was part of our everyday while he was with us.
He was the sweetest.
Same here
As a sister myself I would be so lost and terrified if I lost my brother...I hope Sua will stay strong. I cannot imagine the amount of pain and grief Binnie's family and friends are experiencing. Fly high our Moon! As an Atiny I will give all Aroha's a hug 🕊🌕💖
She’s gonna be hurt the most let’s all protect her and pray for her and make his wish for her come true 😭💜 rip moonbin🕊️
24년...빈이 수아..영원하자...
아건밥행!!!
Miss you our angel 🕊❤️
If I can't be close to you, I'll settle for the ghost of you....💔RIP🕊️
Hope God gives her strength, because I can’t stop feeling so sad when I see him in videos, photos… and I didn’t know him till his passing 😢
They will be forever Sibling also he is the Paradise😭💙, hey Sua Bin will protect you always
Moon Sua must be missing her brother so much! Don’t give up Moon Sua! Surely, your brother is sooo proud of you ❤
We are proud of you and support you always😊
His love for his sister was strong, ❤❤❤❤❤❤ beautiful siblings
우리는 네가 보고 싶어 문빈 넌 재밌는 사람이었어 😢
2023년 동생 행복해 졌으면 좋겠다면서 그렇게 무책임하게 가버리는게 어딨냐?
This is making me cryyyyy 😭
I can’t believe he left us so soon 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
So soon...
I feel bad for his sister 😭❤️🩹
Rest well Moobin~🙏
The lyrics literally hit so differently now. I hope you are happy wherever you are now and forever remembered for the happy moments.
2023년이 저리 밝게 시작했는데 그해에 갔다니 너무 가슴아프다...문빈도 다시 그시간으로 살아 되돌릴수있다면...가슴이 아리다..
My brother(younger than me for one year too) and I can relate to Moonbin and Sua's relationship. And if ever I'll lose him forever, I won't know what will I feel. Losing someone forever is hard. And rn, I can't imagine what Sua is going through. May Moonbin comfort everyone, may it be on their dreams or any means. I know Moonbin will do that.
Keep shining bright, Moonbin. Gain the rest you need up there.
I already lost my dad I can't lose him too😭😩😭😩😭😩😢😢😢
동생의 행복을 바랬던 문빈..
그곳에선 문빈 행복하자!꼭!
The feeling of loosing a sibling came back again... I know the feeling of Sua right now.. You cannot just explain it.. I miss my brother too..
It's ok they are in a good place now may all the souls rest in peace ❤
文彬與秀雅，兄妹的這個互動很好 很棒。
수아 언제나 행복했으면 좋겠다
빈이도 언제나 행복했으면 좋겠다..
옆에서 지켜줘야지 예쁜동생 수아을 두고^^
넘 먼곳에 갔어 다시 돌아 온나
수아는 이렇게 든든한 오빠가 있어서 좋겠다
가정 교육을 잘 받았는지
오빠 앞에서 고개 돌려 술 마시는 수아도 참하고 그걸 보고 기특해서 웃는 오빠도 참 보기 좋은 남매
정말 이 영상 보며 눈물나고 가슴 아프다
사랑스러운 남매에게 왜 이런 시련을 줬는지
하늘이 원망스러울뿐😢😢😢😭😭😭😭
now moon sua can't stay happy in 2023.....
rest in peace 🕊️
I can feel the pain of sua 😢🤧
Nothing would ever heal my heart after him ❤️🩹 I feel a forever lasting hole in my heart
😢😢😢😢😢the love of brother and sister is sooo adorable moonbin moonsua is missing you very much but you are watching over her and is happy to see she is doing well moonsua loves her brother sooo very much 😢😢😢😢
I can't hold my tears in my eye my Heart so hurt 😥I miss you beautiful moonbin
🏠🌹😼🤗🥳😘😄🫅🌅🌟🌛🏖️🏝️🏞️🌊🕊️🐠🦭，兩個人兄妹的互動太棒了.
☆The sky gained a star but our hearts lost a little piece of happiness.♡
❀Rest in peace moonbin🖤
Rip MoonBin u will be missing...your brightest smile,your bright eyes..will be missed...❤❤❤
Bin pidió un deseo en el ultimo programa con sua y dijo: "para este 2023 deseo que Sua sea feliz" eso es lo que bin siempre ha querido y seguro sua cumplirá su ultimo deseo.
Hermanos Moon por siempre 💜
This is so unexpected...I can't accept the reality that's his really no more... he's forever in our hearts💜♾️
moonbin will always be by your side moonsua even if he is not here to answer the phone when you call but he will always be by your side taking care of you and supporting billie he loves you so much you guys will always be the best brother forever moon💜💜💜
그대는 우리곁에 있다고 믿습니다!😊
Still can't believe that Moonbin is no longer in the same world with us💔💔😭😭
그래 빈이 소원대로 수아가 행복했으면 좋겠다.....❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I can imagine the pain she is suffering. Losing a brother is not very sad. I lost my brother too. God gives us the strength to carry on. Be strong.
He fought hard and accomplished so much in face of his illness. Bless his soul in the life ahead.
he thought of his sister before himself😭
Can't believe it's been 10 days already ... I just can't ... I miss you so much moonbin🥺❤️
Moon sua ... I hope you stay strong and safe ... I know that the astro members will be her guardians now ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤️
Now Sua is Alone but don't worry we Will Give u support Sua😇
Самая сильная любовь на свете, -- это любовь между братьями и сёстрами!!!
❤Мунбин, ЛЮБИМЫЙ МУНБИН!!!❤
at this moment this video hits different😭😭😭😭
Hermoso mi Moonbin tenia un corazón bello❤❤❤❤ que hermana tan fría, no le abrazaba con la misma ternura !! Vuela alto mi amor❤❤❤❤ te extraño 😢
I dont want to believe he is truly gone, but i cant imagine how much Sua is grieving.
I wonder how hard life becomes for some that they chose to end it !!!
I didn't even followed him that much ...but it still hurts so much !!
Rest in peace, pls be happy too there. We love you so much🤧
we the fans was so sad,cannot imagine how sua feel😢😭
We miss you too😢😢😢
모두 행복 할 거야. 그러니까 비니도 행복해야 해
문남매 보고싶다😢
He was an angel 🕊️
Loosing a sibling is hard because you literally have known them all your life. May he rest in peace. I hope his sister finds happiness again❤
My tears can't stop dropping 😢😭
La vida es tan extraña, él queria que su hermana siempre fuera feliz y sin darse cuenta le dió el dolor más grande de su vida su partida 😢
Es un Amor muy lindo de Hermanos , más el no era adivinó pará saber qué IVA a morir, solo Dios sabe cómo y cuando suceden las Cosas 💯💯💯💯🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻🕺🏻✨✨🥇🥇🥇🥇🫰😇😇🙏🙏🕊️🕊️🕊️
this is so painful to watch😭 RIP moonbin, stay strong sua💕
How can she be happy when you are up in the sky 😢😢🥺
Rest in peace Moon Bin 🕊️😭
Muito obrigado moonbin espero tá feliz por você sempre 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I felt so bad for Moon Sua😢.. It’s the hardest phase to everyone of us losing the very dearest to us😢.. be strong Moon Sua❤
Que hermoso se llevan los hermanos es un amor verdadero tu sonrisa era tierna 🤍💔🕊️😭
- мунбин будь яркой солнца лучика и яркой звездой!!! ❤❤❤😢 ....
I can feel her pain.cause I lost my brother too
And we failed to protect another one I can't imagine how his friends family group and sister are feeling Moon sua is probably hurt from his sudden death Moon sua stay strong for Moonbin because he wouldn't want to see you cry he would want to see you happy and continuing your career and we all are missing him too. Rest in peace Moonbin😢😢😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭
Stay Strong Sua... Love and miss you always and forever Binnie
i cry every time i see it 😢
stay strong sua!!!
I hope sua must be stronger than ever...now he is twinkling star in sky
gonna miss ü my puppycat, i wish i did prayed for u more :'
พี่น้องมุนน่ารักที่สุด😭💜
This made me cryyyyyyyy. We will all miss moonbin. I hate the kpop industry they are killing our beautiful people. They need to change. But this made me cry so muchhhhhh. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
He died of cardiac arrest not suicide
Suka banget liat matanya pas lgi t'senyum dan senyumnya manis pula... Aq ta bisa lagi melihat senyum itu 😭
I will cry😢😢😢....oppa pls rest in peace
Esto es lo más triste. Te esperamos de regreso Moon Bin. ❤😢
this video made me cry
😢
i can't imagine the pain off Moon Sua she’s gonna be hurt the most
I'm just thinking about moon sua. How much pain she feels now. 😔😔
Still can't believe it:(. I just hope Sua and family are always given strength
I hope moon sua and their family stays strong
this is extremely sad i feel awful for her
Why did he leave us 😢 miss you shining moonbin❤
Why do I keep getting moonbin recommendations when I do I start crying he’s my bias and only bias in Astro I can never forget him
He will shine as a star in the sky
I hope Sua will overcome this😢😢😢 we know it's hard but i hope she can think the brighter side that her oppa is now in a peaceful place doing what Bin love's the most singing and dancing upthere,no more pain and difficulties Bin rest now in paradise,you did very well downhere🤧🤧
for me, he's not gone, i just can't believe it. rest in peace moonbin
I don't think he committed suicide, it was due to some illness 💔🥺💔 I don't think he would have left moomsua alone 😭😭Rest beautiful child 😍💔🌹🕊️😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
It's already 11 days and I still can't believe that his gone. Moonbin 😭😭😭💔😭💔
文彬，非常疼愛，他的妹妹秀雅❤秀雅，你一定要很堅強，你哥哥他才會安心，你一定要快樂，文彬，看到了他一定快樂。
Parece mentira que ele não está mais fisicamente entre nós 😭
I can honestly say, if you can watch the interaction between those two and not get choked up, you’ve got no soul.
I CAN’T BELIEVE HE’S GONE😭
It feels like a bad dream he’s gone💔
I don't have any feelings that our stars hero baby Bin is gone. I just don't want to hear that words. Love you baby Bin 😢😢
Please protect Moon Sua, im worried for her 😢
Regardless of whatever reason led to his so unexpected disappearance, it's very sad that something like this happened and we can only soothe the pain of the family by keeping a beautiful memory alive
I have siblings and seeing that moon sua lost her oppa it hurts so bad 😭😭
Siblings are the one with whom we can share everything if we have always share such bestie type of bond.... moon sua and bin have shared such bond....💔😭😭
R.I.P MOONBIN 🕊
moonbin i hope you are well sleeping in the moon world, we are all missing you but we respect your decision because only you knew what you were feeling, don't worry because your fans are by your side always and your sister moonsua who loves you, and your star brothers who are still mourning you. agent is really crying because of our beautiful star who died, but it's moonsua who lost his brother with whom they shared stages, created childhood memories together, and that he won't answer the phone when she feels alone, more moonsua! continue with your work because your brother just wants to see you happy, and get where he still intended to get. he is proud of you, and is looking out for us wherever he is i love you so much moonbin😂😂