People don't realize that they started creating special effects in film almost immediately after it was invented. They literally spliced celluloid film by hand, one frame at a time, in order to achieve this effect
I read somewhere that the dog coming out of the doghouse was state of the art special effects at the time , with other studios trying to figure out just how they did it.
My fave, I think from A Night at the Opera, is them looking over a contract. Chico asks, "What's this?" "That's the Sanity Clause." "Hey, you can't fool me, I know there's no Sanity Claus." My father and I still refer to the fat man in the red suit as "Sanity Claus."
Groucho Marx gave an explanation as to why the movie was called "Duck Soup". "Take two turkeys, one goose, four cabbages, but no duck, and mix them together. After one taste, you'll duck soup the rest of your life."
Duck Soup is my favorite Marx Brothers movie, renowned for being Zeppo's final film. He retired from performing at the ripe age of 32, last seen by moviegoers throwing things at Margaret Dumont as she sang the Freedonia national anthem. Not a bad way to end a career.
@@electrictroy2010 Perhaps if you viewed it in red/blue Cinecolor, they'd look all less wrong? This was, after all, the age before three-strip Technicolor.
@@electrictroy2010 The wig is actually *blonde* but his characters are always described as redhaired. In stage shows, he wore a red wig but it didn't show up as well in black and white so they switched it to a blonde wig to make it look better and they just implied red in dialogue.
In 1971 at my apartments clubhouse when I was ten years old they used to show The Marx Brothers and also Abbott & Costello films on a 16mm projector on Saturday afternoons. I am glad I was allowed the opportunity. Renting a film was not cheap, and this was over tens years before videocassettes.
These productions with colorized old films I loved all my life give me chance to share them with my grandkids in little bites they can appreciate - great editing for the very best bits. Great job! I thank you.
It was red in their first film, 'The Coconuts' ss it had been red in their stage shows. Howerever, when they saw 'The Coconuts' they realised that the red wig didn't show up very well in black and white so after that he always wore a blonde one but within the story his hair was still supposed to be red. Other characters often referred to him as the red headed one. In 'The Story of Mankind' which is in colour he wears a red wig again.
@@electrictroy2010 It's not destroying anything, the original will always be available and be the definitive version. This is an entertaining novelty for those of us who've seen the film a thousand times.
I always thought it mustve been really difficult to work with the marx brothers. They were on a different level. Way ahead of their time. Still the best!
My Dad recorded this on our first VCR back in the 80's. I wore the tape out watching this in my childhood. My favorite zany scene is the one where Zeppo walks into Groucho's office after meeting an exiting Harpo. He goes to take his hat off and grabs nothing as Harpo had somehow cut it neatly in half on the way out.
It's been fifty years since I first saw this film, which is a longer gap of time from its premiere to that moment I first witnessed the film in the eighth grade. The wonderful thing is the color is pretty much exactly as I imagined it from the French blue army uniforms, to Chico's green hat and jacket, and Harpo's fiery orange hair. It was wonderful, and now the moment has passed. I'll just stare into the mirror, that isn't there, looking wistfully at myself, that isn't me. And wonder will I ever have towels that aren't dark ever again?
Nice! The Marx Bros translate well in this technology, as the humor has a little Sunday Funnies quality to it anyway. About 25 years ago I saw "A Night at the Opera" colorized on TBS, and I thought, cool, we'll probably see that version for sale on video in a few months. Instead, it seemed to disappear, and I never saw the colorized version again.
This is really cool! I've always wondered what it would look like in color. I confess I prefer the black and white, but this brought a smile to my face and answered an old curiosity of mine. Thank you!
Some people also call it "colorization" when a movie remake has competent nonwhite actors playing roles that are not historically plausible or not the way the original writer intended it.
Im probably the youngest person in the comments section judging by everyones comments, but i first watched this movie when i was 9 (2014), and watched it again this year (2023), im 18 and its so funny even today, i only watched this movje along with monkey business as they were in a bundle and glad to finally see this movie in colour
Now that I think of it this seems like it’s from a trailer or something where they advertised this re release that was colorized I doubt the guy even has it
@@byHexted You're correct about that "Hexted" if they do it will get taken down but I might be able to download it to my computer before it gets taken down as I have done in the past.
Funny, all the years watching it in black&white, and now seeing it in color, I realized my brain was automatically putting in the colors all along. This is exactly how I've always pictured it. Great job. Just remember, before colonizing a movie, ask yourself if it would improve the movie or not. For example, The Longest Day. The director intentionally chose to shoot it in b&w because he wanted a documentary feel to it. Noir style movies, like Casablanca or The Maltese Falcon, shouldn't be colorized - it would detract from the feel of them. Musicals, comedies, westerns, sure, no question. Dramas, especially Crime dramas, as well as Mystery/Suspense need to be looked at on a case by case basis. SciFi, Fantasy, and Monster movies should be mostly good, but there might be one or two exceptions. Anyway, that's just my thoughts as a serious movie buff. If the technology was available and the budget didn't matter, would the director have gone with color, or stayed with b&w? That's the real question. Of course, with today's technology, doing a mix of the two, like they did in the 1939 Wizard of Oz, would be a piece of cake. Just Sayin'
Hey, That's a what I could use right now! A nice big bowl of surreal! Well, why don't you you ask your Dada to buy you some? He can't afford it... He's too Baroque! I guess that's a Poor Trait to have to exhibit! If you're going to be a Marx Brothers fan, you should learn to think like one! But be careful, bad puns could be awful enough to give you an Art Attack!
Last week here in the UK on Radio 2 saturday early evening Lydia was played on the radio .in 1979 the BBC showed a series of the Marx Brothers film and the last film to be shown was A Day at The Races and guess what happened the final reel was shown twice no digital back then , people though they were seeing the same thing again now this is true and at the end of the film , we have to say there was a mix up The good old BBC said we were caught with the eggs on our faces, the brothers themselves must been watching from upabove
@@robertkincaid ...and you couldn't come up with ONE joke in your reply? I did an entire 'bit' and even came up with original material! Brexit must have really taken the humor out of you people! It seems the the one thing you all could use right now is a "Chaplin!" I'd rather have a 'Tramp' than a 'Trump' any day! Please come up with something! I'd hate to have to get a tailor to cut this thread!
@@h.r.gerrard2960 i had a terrible childhood my parents could not understand me they were Japanese i went to my doctor and he told me your due some pills he said would you like me to put them in a box , yes i said it would save from rolling all the way home, whats the different between Walt Disney and Bing Crosby , Bing sings Walt Dis-ney a Scottish joke there
Harpo was always my favorite. It was explained why he didn't talk, because he didn't have a voice for comedy. There's a tiny clip of him whispering to someone at a funeral & it's true 😮😬😖
I'd could dance with you until the Cow's come home. But on second thought I'd rather dance with the Cow's than than you come home. Here's five dollars keep it under your hat. Nevermind I'll keep it under my hat. The Four Marx Brothers were comedy legends
a flop in 1933 now considered to be one of their best. on second thought I'll dance with the cows 'til you come home." I love how Harpo get the best of Edgar Kennedy.
I used to be against colourising black and white movies because they always look awful. But the technology has come a long way. This is a fun experiment and we always have the black and white original. It really feels like the type of colour they would have in those 30s early colour films I have seen. Looks very authentic.
Great seeing the colours. Love the Marx brothers films. Especially the film with Harpo and Groucho do the mirror sketch. It's really clever stuff and hilarious. 👍😂😅
My all time favorite is when he's ordering trenches to be dug: "Build them up to the waist, and we can save money on pants, actually, build them up to the necks, and they won't need any uniforms. Matter of fact, build them over their heads, and we won't need any soldiers." I butchered it, but that's the jist of it.
amazing work!! I've been wanting to see a colorized marx movie for years!! by any chance you will not have the entire movie in color? You would make me the happiest person in the world!!
@@SlickArmor I feel very sorry for you xD, but I know it's not me you 're disgusted with, but don't give up, i'm sure one day your mother will love you ;)
There is no better than any of this I'm.only 49,,,but the writing and humor is far beyond today's crap god love my father to introducing me to this and all there movies n laurel n hardy and Charlie Chaplin and jack Benny to name a few in those eras. So glad to watch them n what a waste watching today's crap .no comparison God Bless Alll
One of the Marx Brothers zaniest films. The funniest bit was when Harpo got even with a bullying street vendor by washing his feet in the guy's vat of lemonade. 😂
Super cool to see this favorite since childhood in a new light, and awesome job on the color work, but to me it feels bizarre. To me it's like a grilled cheese made with aged gruyere and caviare, maybe it's better but so foreign to what I remember.
That gag with the tattoos is absolutely batshit insane 90 years later.
They cut it too soon! Groucho’s reaction is priceless.
People don't realize that they started creating special effects in film almost immediately after it was invented. They literally spliced celluloid film by hand, one frame at a time, in order to achieve this effect
Fun Fact: Originally, the tattoo was going to be an outhouse & when Groucho would look at it, an arm would poke out & shut the door.
no it wasnt.
I read somewhere that the dog coming out of the doghouse was state of the art special effects at the time , with other studios trying to figure out just how they did it.
"He gets mad because he can't read." was one of the best Marx Bros. lines ever.
Close, but the best was "I once shot an elephant while in my pajamas. How he got in my pajamas i'll never know."
The answer was even better: - Oh I see.
My fave, I think from A Night at the Opera, is them looking over a contract. Chico asks, "What's this?" "That's the Sanity Clause." "Hey, you can't fool me, I know there's no Sanity Claus."
My father and I still refer to the fat man in the red suit as "Sanity Claus."
Groucho Marx gave an explanation as to why the movie was called "Duck Soup".
"Take two turkeys, one goose, four cabbages, but no duck, and mix them together. After one taste, you'll duck soup the rest of your life."
My dad and I used to watch this when I was little. Classic and beautiful how it's in color.
Wait what the hell that dog affect was actually insanely good
yes it was hilarious😂
effect
Yeah, for the time it was incredible!
It's a razorblade and some sticky tape. Beautifuly done though
Duck Soup is my favorite Marx Brothers movie, renowned for being Zeppo's final film. He retired from performing at the ripe age of 32, last seen by moviegoers throwing things at Margaret Dumont as she sang the Freedonia national anthem. Not a bad way to end a career.
Love the colour. It brings it all to life, like watching it for the first time. Brilliant work 👏👏👏🥰
This brilliant. The colour brings the movie to life. Thanks for sharing.
I think I was the only teenager my age that wanted a DVD box set of the Marx Brothers including this movie
I grew up watching those movies, seeing in color brings such a warm feeling! Amazing work! Thank you!
I’m growing up watching these movies. I wish other kids would too
Yeh same as great to see in colour totally different take on the Boys.
Colorization == destroying the original cinematography by the director. Horrible
.
@@electrictroy2010 yeah yeah, sure pal
Only in this awful colorized film is Harpo's wig orange. Harpo was a redhead.
Love how you could hear every sound being made on the stage in older movies.
If you watch Frankenstein (1931) when they are body stealing in the misty graveyard you can hear them walking on a sound stage: thump, thump, thump.
I love this movie! I've never realised that Chico's outfit was green and Harpo's wig was so orange 😉
The colors are all wrong. Wig was supposed to be red
@@electrictroy2010 Perhaps if you viewed it in red/blue Cinecolor, they'd look all less wrong? This was, after all, the age before three-strip Technicolor.
Why do assume Chico's outfit was actually green? In this awful colorized movie it is green.
@@electrictroy2010 The wig is actually *blonde* but his characters are always described as redhaired. In stage shows, he wore a red wig but it didn't show up as well in black and white so they switched it to a blonde wig to make it look better and they just implied red in dialogue.
The robot paints each frame with whatever color it was told to use
Great color work, truly next level. ❤
In 1971 at my apartments clubhouse when I was ten years old they used to show The Marx Brothers and also Abbott & Costello films on a 16mm projector on Saturday afternoons. I am glad I was allowed the opportunity. Renting a film was not cheap, and this was over tens years before videocassettes.
These productions with colorized old films I loved all my life give me chance to share them with my grandkids in little bites they can appreciate - great editing for the very best bits. Great job! I thank you.
Don't you want to see the color scenes too. 'Real color' is what I mean by that.
Groucho truly is timeless, his humor and style work just as well today as anytime.
Oh man🤣 ....that dog in the tattoo gag🤣
I never thought that I’d see a Marx Brothers film in colour! What amazing work, so clever! I didn’t know Harpo’s wig was orange.
Yeah I always pictured it as a blonde wig
It was red in their first film, 'The Coconuts' ss it had been red in their stage shows. Howerever, when they saw 'The Coconuts' they realised that the red wig didn't show up very well in black and white so after that he always wore a blonde one but within the story his hair was still supposed to be red. Other characters often referred to him as the red headed one.
In 'The Story of Mankind' which is in colour he wears a red wig again.
Colorization == destroying the original cinematography by the director. Horrible
.
They don’t know. Colourisation is guess work
@@electrictroy2010Closed minded thing, ain'tcha? Let me guess: you're also religious.
Seeing the boys in color is very interesting. Thanks for uploading this.
This is so impressive! The picture quality in itself, let alone the color! Wonderful new life to a genuine classic
It's the HD transfer available on blu ray.
Colorization == destroying the original cinematography by the director. Horrible
.
@@electrictroy2010 It's not destroying anything, the original will always be available and be the definitive version. This is an entertaining novelty for those of us who've seen the film a thousand times.
I always thought it mustve been really difficult to work with the marx brothers. They were on a different level. Way ahead of their time. Still the best!
My Dad recorded this on our first VCR back in the 80's. I wore the tape out watching this in my childhood.
My favorite zany scene is the one where Zeppo walks into Groucho's office after meeting an exiting Harpo. He goes to take his hat off and grabs nothing as Harpo had somehow cut it neatly in half on the way out.
It's been fifty years since I first saw this film, which is a longer gap of time from its premiere to that moment I first witnessed the film in the eighth grade. The wonderful thing is the color is pretty much exactly as I imagined it from the French blue army uniforms, to Chico's green hat and jacket, and Harpo's fiery orange hair. It was wonderful, and now the moment has passed. I'll just stare into the mirror, that isn't there, looking wistfully at myself, that isn't me. And wonder will I ever have towels that aren't dark ever again?
saw the first marx brothers movie about 1960 ,they did some of the best comedy movies ever done !
Still stands as one of the funniest movies ever made.
I want the Chico spiral glasses so much, they are hilarious😵💫😂
Nice! The Marx Bros translate well in this technology, as the humor has a little Sunday Funnies quality to it anyway. About 25 years ago I saw "A Night at the Opera" colorized on TBS, and I thought, cool, we'll probably see that version for sale on video in a few months. Instead, it seemed to disappear, and I never saw the colorized version again.
Oooh that is trippy. I definitely prefer it in black n white! 😂
This is legendary as are the Marx Brothers. Groucho had some of the best lines which stand up quite well to this very day nearly a centruy later.
Beautiful job
I will never stop laughing at the Marx Brothers movies. Interesting to see Groucho break the fourth wall in that scene
Margaret Dumont never got the recognition she deserved….how she kept a straight face when Groucho was in full flight was priceless.
Duck Soup was the best Marx Bros movie. They of course made other incredible films, but this was the best of the lot.
Absolutely fantastic.
This Movie is rated #1 to aid in recovery from illnesses .
Often wished to see the Marx Brothers films in colour!
Colorized movies have improved over the decades
This is really cool! I've always wondered what it would look like in color. I confess I prefer the black and white, but this brought a smile to my face and answered an old curiosity of mine. Thank you!
Colorization == destroying the original cinematography by the director. Horrible
.
aka "cultural vandalism".
Some people also call it "colorization" when a movie remake has competent nonwhite actors playing roles that are not historically plausible or not the way the original writer intended it.
...and his teeth were blue.
wow -- very tasteful. would love to see the whole film like this. great job!
Brilliant 👏
Im probably the youngest person in the comments section judging by everyones comments, but i first watched this movie when i was 9 (2014), and watched it again this year (2023), im 18 and its so funny even today, i only watched this movje along with monkey business as they were in a bundle and glad to finally see this movie in colour
This is awesome!
I was born 1960 and I enjoy American movie classics...
Thankfully you got Harpo's hair color correct!
Those were the days.
My favorite line from the movie is "Help help, we are three men and one woman trapped in a house. If you can't send help send two more women."
Crazy this classic is public domain - thx so much for this
Mirror scene of this movie is extraordinary...
EXCELLENT! Excellent job done on the colorization. Can one view the full film in color? If so upload to You Tube!! Thank you.
I think one uploading the entire movie they have no rights to is the issue
Now that I think of it this seems like it’s from a trailer or something where they advertised this re release that was colorized I doubt the guy even has it
@@byHexted You're correct about that "Hexted" if they do it will get taken down but I might be able to download it to my computer before it gets taken down as I have done in the past.
@@byHexted You're probably correct about that as well Hexted.
No and no
I Wonder how they did that Gag with the Dog coming out of the Dog house lol
With scissors and film.
Funny, all the years watching it in black&white, and now seeing it in color, I realized my brain was automatically putting in the colors all along. This is exactly how I've always pictured it. Great job. Just remember, before colonizing a movie, ask yourself if it would improve the movie or not. For example, The Longest Day. The director intentionally chose to shoot it in b&w because he wanted a documentary feel to it. Noir style movies, like Casablanca or The Maltese Falcon, shouldn't be colorized - it would detract from the feel of them. Musicals, comedies, westerns, sure, no question. Dramas, especially Crime dramas, as well as Mystery/Suspense need to be looked at on a case by case basis. SciFi, Fantasy, and Monster movies should be mostly good, but there might be one or two exceptions. Anyway, that's just my thoughts as a serious movie buff. If the technology was available and the budget didn't matter, would the director have gone with color, or stayed with b&w? That's the real question. Of course, with today's technology, doing a mix of the two, like they did in the 1939 Wizard of Oz, would be a piece of cake. Just Sayin'
still one of the funniest movies ever!
Harpo is my favorite Marx Brother. He has some of the most hilarious scenes!
Washing his feet in the lemonade 😂
This is totally surreal watching this in colour
Hey, That's a what I could use right now! A nice big bowl of surreal!
Well, why don't you you ask your Dada to buy you some?
He can't afford it... He's too Baroque!
I guess that's a Poor Trait to have to exhibit!
If you're going to be a Marx Brothers fan, you should learn to think like one!
But be careful, bad puns could be awful enough to give you an Art Attack!
Last week here in the UK on Radio 2 saturday early evening Lydia was played on the radio .in 1979 the BBC showed a series of the Marx Brothers film and the last film to be shown was A Day at The Races and guess what happened the final reel was shown twice no digital back then , people though they were seeing the same thing again now this is true and at the end of the film , we have to say there was a mix up The good old BBC said we were caught with the eggs on our faces, the brothers themselves must been watching from upabove
@@robertkincaid ...and you couldn't come up with ONE joke in your reply? I did an entire 'bit' and even came up with original material! Brexit must have really taken the humor out of you people! It seems the the one thing you all could use right now is a "Chaplin!" I'd rather have a 'Tramp' than a 'Trump' any day!
Please come up with something! I'd hate to have to get a tailor to cut this thread!
@@h.r.gerrard2960
@@h.r.gerrard2960 i had a terrible childhood my parents could not understand me they were Japanese i went to my doctor and he told me your due some pills he said would you like me to put them in a box , yes i said it would save from rolling all the way home, whats the different between Walt Disney and Bing Crosby , Bing sings Walt Dis-ney a Scottish joke there
Harpo was always my favorite. It was explained why he didn't talk, because he didn't have a voice for comedy. There's a tiny clip of him whispering to someone at a funeral & it's true 😮😬😖
Harpo is the best.
I'd could dance with you until the Cow's come home. But on second thought I'd rather dance with the Cow's than than you come home.
Here's five dollars keep it under your hat. Nevermind I'll keep it under my hat.
The Four Marx Brothers were comedy legends
a flop in 1933 now considered to be one of their best. on second thought I'll dance with the cows 'til you come home." I love how Harpo get the best of Edgar Kennedy.
My only complaint is: the faces are too orange. Tone it down a bit.
I used to be against colourising black and white movies because they always look awful. But the technology has come a long way. This is a fun experiment and we always have the black and white original. It really feels like the type of colour they would have in those 30s early colour films I have seen. Looks very authentic.
WoW-beautiful colorized-great movie
Great seeing the colours. Love the Marx brothers films. Especially the film with Harpo and Groucho do the mirror sketch. It's really clever stuff and hilarious. 👍😂😅
I would buy the whole film series again in colour if I could.
My all time favorite is when he's ordering trenches to be dug: "Build them up to the waist, and we can save money on pants, actually, build them up to the necks, and they won't need any uniforms. Matter of fact, build them over their heads, and we won't need any soldiers." I butchered it, but that's the jist of it.
An impressive achievement indeed. For me, though, it’s a black and white movie and probably always will be.
I love the Marx Bros.!! The word play is head spinning funny!!!!!!🤣😀😀😀
Excellent Job!
please tel me u have a full version i would pay for seeing that
How can comedy so old have aged so well?
Chico.....be still my heart
amazing work!! I've been wanting to see a colorized marx movie for years!! by any chance you will not have the entire movie in color? You would make me the happiest person in the world!!
Unfortunately I've only colorized these scenes. To do a full movie would take a lot of work.
@@RumbleDogPictures Well, put a price hehe, how much would you charge me for making the entire movie in color?
If you have to ask you can't afford it and prepare to be a sad sack from here on.
@@SlickArmor Better than a sad sack who trolls comment sections
@@SlickArmor I feel very sorry for you xD, but I know it's not me you 're disgusted with, but don't give up, i'm sure one day your mother will love you ;)
i just noticed at a far away shot the cartoon of harpo on his arm isnt colored in but in the close up shot it is
And?
See his hat in the mirror scene!
The only thing missing from this video of Duck Soup is the movie Duck Soup.
Great job thx 👍
I’ve been mewing for 72hrs and finally broke to laugh at the tattoo bit
Tell me anybody ,how can I obtain this coloured film ( or any Marx movie in colour) on British dvd.???
Brilliant ❤️😂
Genius!🧐♥️♥️👍
would love to see the lot in colour has the full film been done?
Would love to see the whole movie in color.
"All I can offer is a Rufus over your head!" 😂
COLOUR ALWAYS THE BEST.
BLACK AND WHITE LACKS THE
BEAUTIE OF THE COLOUR AND
ITS MORE ENJOYABLE.
TO WATCH. CHEERS.
There's so much going on it's exhausting to watch.
People have become stupid looking at their phones all day.
I loved Groucho & Margaret before I read that her reactions were real, she wasn't 'acting' shocked or frustrated 😂😅.
These films should be colorized. Young people often won’t watch black and white.
Restored and colorized films breath new life into many old films. 😊
Truly the greatest generation.
There is no better than any of this I'm.only 49,,,but the writing and humor is far beyond today's crap god love my father to introducing me to this and all there movies n laurel n hardy and Charlie Chaplin and jack Benny to name a few in those eras. So glad to watch them n what a waste watching today's crap .no comparison God Bless Alll
"I was just thinking of all the yaers I;ve wasted collecting stamps" used later ib Double Indemnity
Could you do the full movie or would copyright get in the way?
What do you mean by "precode comedy"?
I didn't know Carrot Top was 115 years old.
Is this tattoo bit where David Blaine got his tattoo magic trick idea from it’s the same premise
My Dudes!😭😭😭😭😭
To mutch pink lol
I prefer the Black and White!(-:
So where's the rest? It's only 90 years old.
One of the Marx Brothers zaniest films. The funniest bit was when Harpo got even with a bullying street vendor by washing his feet in the guy's vat of lemonade. 😂
He knew how to troll him 😂😂
Super cool to see this favorite since childhood in a new light, and awesome job on the color work, but to me it feels bizarre. To me it's like a grilled cheese made with aged gruyere and caviare, maybe it's better but so foreign to what I remember.
Well im 75 and I have yet even to smile at what passes for humour in these films in colour or black and white.
Are you related to the detective in “A Night at the Opera”?
Such a lucky family to not be living over the other side of the Atlantic back then.
You gotta flashlight?
This time, they've gone to far.
"DUCK SOUP" colorized.
Still the best Marx Brothers movie ever. Groucho was the original insult genius comic.