Being comfortable in your skin is never going to be comfortable or easy…if you are not comfortable with being uncomfortable…better stay where you are and be ruled by fear of another human being…we need a change of mindset and start working towards employing ourselves
@@KgaogeloTsweleng I think black people as a whole should normalise being comfortable. But as an individual is it really worth losing your livelihood, your ability to feed your family. I respect people who stand up for themselves no matter the cost but I also understand our brothers and sisters who let things slide for the greater good of their families
Dr Sindane, we need more dialogues outside the institutions to empower our people, it's so sad that majority of our kids who don't reach universities are left out of the intellectual engagements, Dr Mpofu thanks for empowering platform.
if South Africans had less kids and cared for them - parents could have taken the responsibility to make sure their kids excelled in life but many granny's are looking after these fatherless kids . African culture is kids are their wealth - and the state must take care of raising them. Parents must empower their kids not the state. If fathers took responsibility to raise their kids we would not have the problems we have = most african men have kids that are not cared for by them.
He is not empowering anyone but race baiting and fear mongering. This was far from an intellectual engagement but simply demeaning and demonizing another race.
The difficulty thing about us is that once we are in power, we start eating alone, making us families rich and ignoring the poor . We don't c any progress rather than rich politicians it's so sad how we are treated by black people
Furthermore, the DA coalition could be scrutinized, but what are we gaining as poor people under the ANC rather than murder and corruption? Our black leaders are so selfish. Even this coalition is based on the markets, not us black people.
and again @BaneleMancoba check how many previous disadvantaged black employees benefited from bbbee, none, 202 black employees were dismissed by G4S private security company for protesting about the g4s staff share trust which was established in 2005 to benefit them, we went up and down to this black parties asking for assistance in litigating g4s but none of them came to assist us and now they are crying foul
Now you talking. Precisely. That's why the poor voted for the Da. Voters who are black. They flee from the eastern cape to the western cape to look for a better life for all.
@terencelintnaar7595 in the western cape, the health department is the best and education. Go to where our black brothers govern its disgrace, painful 👌 👍
@@BaneleMancobabut never run from the fect that every freely rich black man in South Africa today kissed the white peoples ass. We don’t have self made millionaire, billionaires like Sam Malope who have bankrupted by our current president. And we have allowed the media to bad mouth Zuma the president at least who to bring few black millionaires without kissing white peoples ass
on the ground it is colour blind bt surely classist society. it is us who stil trying to hold on to race i have been around white people who never even look at me as a black person
The problem with being color blind and that rainbow nonsense is you also become blind and ignorant to the social injustices against black people, calling someone black or white is already racisms being asked on a bank form if you african or white what is that
Sadly, you have been led astray. Please check out the economist from Ghana, Dr GBN Ayittey. He explains with evidence, how Comrades are actually the problem, whose policies keep Africa poor whilst they blame imperialism for all the inevitable results of the thinking outlined above. It has nothing to do with race.
Wow, Dr Ntando What an insightful conversation. Thank you so much for oiling our lamps🙏 May you all be blessed with the work you do in speaking our truth...
i don't think all is said to just make people feel bad about themselves or even feel good about themselves he is challenging people to self-introspect and be sincere.
True, far too deep for a modern new way of thinking and living. Allow the new multi party GNU of South Africa for the full expression of our constitution to Fix this country and our its people. Heal the land.
Sure. He is the one who let black South Africans down. He bent to the same forces that are at work right now opting instead to be revered internationally rather than ensuring that the oppressed black majority who fought hard for his freedom.
Standing together means sharing the means of production and the strategic sectors of the economy which are owned and controlled by white people. Are they willing to do that?
Not true! Considering this perpetual plight of impoverished Blacks would have been a factor with Mandela because this is not what he and many other comrades fought for.
I salute Dr Ntando intellectual capacity and the audacity to stand by your intellectual / academic analysis without fear, we need more of people like him
Happy Father's day to all the fathers 🎉🎉! I don't know Dr Sindane but it's difficult for me not to listen to his deep understanding of the topic today I'm just happy to gain insight as a gogo who is always willing to learn, this is so deep & I'm learned already, thank you ❤
I learned a lot from this. Made me read some of Dr Sindane and Prof Madlingozi's articles. I now understand what decoloniality means and its importance in post-apartheid SA. These men are producing excellent scholarship worth reading. Thanks Sizwe. Hopefully Prof Madlingozi will honour your invitation soon. 👊🏾
But if we don't get what it was intended to bring forth in us, its value are lost in a perpetual victimhood. I am also a big Steve Biko fan. It changed how I looked at my own blackness as a young man back in the day.
You got to love the fear mongering of this channel. Ignoring the fact that blackness is not a political ideology. Ignoring the fact that the biggest voter transfer was due to tribalism and not ideology. Ignoring the fact that improving delivery will substantially improve everybody’s lives no matter the ideology. Ignoring the fact that extreme left leaning ideology has not brought sustainable prosperity to any nation. Ignoring the fact that 30 years of left leaning politics in SA has put us in a downward spiral. Ignoring the fact that doing the same thing every time and expecting a different outcome is the definition of insanity.
@mphomathuba2942 I agree with you, we didn't even begin to go left in the 30 years even if the intention was. If you ask the simple question, did justice prevail over the atrocities of the past? Did it really prevail? The honest answer will be NO.
I have listened to this talk three times now. Very grateful for this channel - it's hard-hitting and challenging content. I appreciate having conversations like this and other ones that challenge me and allow me to see the country from the views of others that are not within my immediate context and presented so that I can inform me, even if I don't understand or necessarily agree. There's much of value in this talk. And I appreciate the thought that perhaps the Constitution is perhaps a constitution of compromise and appeasement. But I'm still left with this question - how, as a white person, can I truly relinquish that which makes me white? How do I surrender my white privilege? If I understand that my white privilege comes not just simply from my skin colour, but also from the circumstances of my birth, by the privileges accorded to me by society and my community by virtue of looking, acting, behaving, and living within a context - all of which we might call "whiteness"... how do I simply relinquish that? Some of these things seem to be totally inherent to me. I cannot change my skin color. I cannot erase my family, my history, my upbringing, my context, the fact that I benefited from Apartheid. How can these things be relinquished? I can change my politics, I can change how I see others in my country, I can support land reform, I can support policies that do not benefit me and instead benefit others in greater need with fewer rights and fewer privileges than I have had, hoping that this will benefit them and grant them the basic rights and needs that they were denied by Apartheid (past and, from the perspective of many in our country, ongoing). I could do these things even to my own detriment, understanding that my situation is better than most in our country (most non-whites in our country) can even imagine to ever reach, and that I neither need (or want) more privilege and actively want to divest some of that privilege. I can try to understand and respect the views of others, even if they seem radical and even counter to my own interests. I can try to embody these values to the fullest extent I can. But it seems to me that I cannot erase my whiteness. I cannot be seen as non-white by others, nor erase my white history and heritage. It is part of me, surely. So what does Dr. Sindane mean by this?
My take is through reparations!!! The same way some English (families formerly Slave masters in earlier centuries) are helping slave descendants in former slave plantation areas! Maybe as a starting point.
It was only last week when i stymbled upon this channel. And the interviewer is doing the lord's work. He gives his guests the platform to talk and not interrupt. I applaud you Dr. I cannot live without this channel anymore.
@@nicjordan7300Exactly right, we are overwhelmed with humanities graduates who think they can hypothesise answers to real world problems. We need more engineers and scientists to solve our problems.
You actually don't have a problem with his education but just can't stomach the truths he is dishing out. So the conversation is doing its job - to make the comfortable, uncomfortable, and the uncomfortable, comfortable.
Very informative, concise and educational interview. Dr. Sindane is a real teacher and master in this topic regarding the constitution. His critique is justified and his analysis are to the point. I also like his personal views and analysis of the DA, he is also an outstanding scholar of Steve Biko. Thanks Dr. Mpofu about these interviews and these learned guest who are brave, who question and challenge the status quo. Dr Sindane and Professor Madlingozi interviews and also pre election interview of Andile Mxidama were the greatest of I have listened to.
The Dr nailed it sir appreciate your wisdom you have absolutely opened the eyes of the black majority in this country keep up with the good works Dankie siyabonga
If you don't understand what Ntando has sat there and said..you are exactly given the opportunity to assess yourself. Very clear.We cannot run away from what has shaped life here 🇿🇦
I'm only 45 minutes into the show, and I feel I have drifted from reality thanks to Dr Sindane. It feels like when things go our way, the Constitution is supreme and when they don't, the Constitution is the enemy of the people. I hear a lot of contradictions from the Dr. and victimhood. I will listen on, maybe he will get to the point that all are responsible for their actions and deeds, you are not good or bad based on the color of your skin. With that said I like how he presents his arguments and he really gives food for thought.
it is easy to talk his talk from his position, he should be able to abandon the white mentor... first ... abandon the privilege that he speaks from and more importantly show us what he in his little corner is doing to advance his speak... bayakhuluma .... we nod ... we had 30 years to change that constitution ... abathule
What is victimhood? My parents experienced first hand the terrorism of the apartheid regime, so talking about the past now, you labelled a victim? History has consequences, this victimhood gaslighting is no different from denialism. Jews can bring up the holocaust, they remind us of it all the time, no body labels them victims, actually you can be arrested for holocaust denialism and labelled antisemitic. Apartheid was designated as a crime against humanity. So what was accumulated before 94 is criminal. Or we should just stop being victims and stop fighting for justice and the land and economic reforms.
What is victimhood? Are jews viewed as victims when they talk about their own past? It's just a label reserved for "black" people? The gaslighting never ends. Kaffirs to victims😅😅
Why ANC didn't give the country to black people when they are tired of government because it's too early for whites to rule this country with many people with apertheid scars some are still looking for their love ones who are missing some families didn't receive the remains of their members who died in exile black people are still living in dirty townships while white are still living in clean spacious suburbs even during the campaign no white people visited our houses asking for votes yet they say they like us poor children attend school in townships those who can afford attend in suburbs riding back of vans because they want better education nothing have changed to think DA will change the situation is a dream
2:26 A black Verwoerd. Why do all the supposed thought leaders always proclaim that SA must be a zero sum game. The DA will proof you wrong black Verwoerd. There is enough for us all to thrive.
Great program. Well said Dr. I do hope the Black people of SA will listen to this program and make the right decisions for their future. Viva Viva to the Black People of SA.
This is a must watch interview by every black men, woman and child. Thank you for the episode. This type of conversation needs to continue wherever we gather as black people, ngoba kuse kude engqinibeni. Le nkululeko ayikafiki.
My black brother i been following your shows or should i say podcast for long time, I must say we need more of your kind in this so called SA democracy. We're struggling in the townships of what is happening on the National and Provincial so your Podcast help us in the poor townships which I mean Political we get strength.💪🙏
Mr Sizwe last time I raised a concern about the volume level of your podcast. But listen to this episode now, I can say that it did get better. Thank you for the upgrade on that regard.
SMWX bring back this guy again. We'll learn a lot. When DA says they want qualified people. Do they mean experienced or academically qualified like most black people?
I am yet to understand this talk of “Black interest”, do you mean the interest of the “Black elite” ? Because our interest as the poor are basic, we want a stable economy, crime free, jobs and good education… DA has proven itself to be better in Governance than any other party in South Africa. I don’t care whether they are racist or not. We need to move away from this victim mentality…
The problem you are having is that you are looking things at your own benefiting and you forget that not everyone who are at your position and being lead by a racist it never make you as black person any better besides being an employee and a slave for the racist, maybe you need to look at things differently don't us your feelings because you will never get the truth and that is what we want in order for us to be free from the hands of racist.
Dr. Ntando Sindane, I salute you with much respect for being one of the few academics who cherish the ethos of Africanism despite a lot of knowledge you acquired in your studies. Because many academics are brainwashed by the western teaching as their reference point and they forego the African wisdom of originalism. The agenda to wipe out African ethos through western academia to dictate what is possible and what is desirable has become a dominant reality perpetuated white people. We people like Dr. Ntando Sindane, who out of wisdom and accumulated knowledge remain authentic in bring African interpretation of liberal reality to the mainstream of discussion and true recognition of equality for all.
30 years of opportunities! Where is the outcome ? SAA ,Transnet , Prasa , Eskom are failing???? That is evidence of cadre deployment who know nothing about management
To be fair to the ANC, since its inception in 1910, from John Langalibalele Dube to now Cyril Matamela Ramaphosa, all they wanted was to be included in the government structure! They have never wanted to transform and/or to be in charge of anything except to be part of the governance of this Union of South Africa.
I agree fully, I have said it so many times Anc was never a party designed to protect and uplift South African people. It's a party designed by black elitist who wanted to secure their seat on the table to serve their masters. That's why they are saying they are not a black party because they don't want to saddened their colonial masters. Unfortunately white people in general are racist and will never change let's forget about rainbow nation. It's not a reality.We can only learn to coexist as human beings.
Study Zuma and u will see he is the odd one because he actually transformed Black ppls lives. We saw more participation from the Black communities in the economy.
@musawenkosimakhoba9028 No, he did not transform black people lives. He allowed some few blacks to be rich without any meaningful change. Mbeki and Mandela did the same!
I am a reader of comparative constitutionalism myself and must say this is one of the most thought provoking interviews I have listened to. Dr Sindane keep up with the good work.
This interview was very short yet very long Dr Mpofu . I’m crying how this episode was very short lived . I love Dr Sindane a lot , maybe because of my ardent love for black people . Please call him again maybe to share his thoughts on black consciousness precisely . We need such segment , more especially at this juncture . Biko would be proud .. mor this is my favorite episode .
Sizwe ....i don't have words to thank you and Dr Sindane. actually this is my first listening to his interview. I felt goosebumps at some stage due to his utterances. I learnt soo much today
Don't lie! This windbag is an intellectual dwarf, and he knows it himself. That's why he's resorting to subversive language in an attempt to hide his lack of thought and argument.
the markets is not 3 families, its the whole world deciding if South Africa is stable enough to invest it. that includes cellphones, cars, food, clothes etc...
When white privilege & political supremacy were denounced by the global markets, its beneficiaries didn't consider their dictates at all. White society instead consolidated their efforts & resolve, aligned themselves with selected international allies, skirted sanctions & built domestic industry. That they did until their privilege was so deeply entrenched & shielded that they could negotiate from a position of power during the early nineties. Now when the economical disenfranchised black populace demands transformation, immediate submision to these self same markets are presented as being existential to SA society.
The markets need our land and minerals resources more than we need them. We need good African leaders not the DA. The Sahel countries in north africa are proving it.
The only markets in question here are white supremacy nations, Europe and North America and some countries in Asia, the rest of the world is disgusted with this coalition...we should be working to secure the future market like all major economies are doing in the world, focus heavy invest in Africa, how are we going to do that working with self proclaimed haters of native Africans and their children...
brains with brains....Dr Sindane was given a platform to educate and Dr Mpofu thank you for allowing him to do so ...first time watching an interview on the road i was looking for a playlist on youtube...very informative bafehu
@Porter90 This is a book recommendation, you can read it too. Otherwise your response reflects a racist and supremacist viewpoint that promotes the idea of white superiority.
This interview is not for those who are intellectually challenged and with poor comprehension skills. The man is clear in his analysis and thoughts. Telling it like it is. Thanks Dr Mpofu-Walsh.
@@hueNeo A cog in a broken system, having trouble spinning, because something or someone is causing a jam. The system just needs a good engineer and some maintenance.
He actually said "I have White colleagues, some of whom are friends".....just being specific so that the listener knows that they're definitely not ALL friends of his. Lucky for them.
Keep shining Ntwana, u and the likes of Manyathela just ask and discuss the issues myself and for sure millions of your Audience would like to ask and discuss. When you interviews end, we are fulfilled and we know we are not disillusioned that we have to fight for our True/Holistic liberation of native South Afrikans, Afrika at large & Afrikans in diaspora. Ayeye!!!
Imagine being this guy’s white friend.“You are my friend but you’re a terrible person because you are white and I have a problem with your whiteness.” I left South Africa 16 years ago. I love my country. I miss the people, of all race, but also so happy that my children don’t even give a thought about race and who they are friends with. Do most black South Africans want white people to leave SA? Would you be better off as a nation without any white people there? Is there no way for people to live in harmony? These are all serious questions. I have black friends. I don’t think of them as black. They just my friends.
You are really naive, the reason race issues don't pass is because people like you always want to sweep the matter under the mat. People were hurt, they are carrying deep scars, until we get an apology and compensation race will always be a factor
@@Aplayz42 You are deliberately missing the point. If this video did not make that point clear to you, then I'm afraid there is nothing further that can be done to help you understand.
Another enlightening & thought-provoking discussion Sizwe... Dr Sindane your candid perspective resonates... Your scholarship is revelational - the both of you!
Judge Hlophe was vilified because of being firm about the land issue. He wanted us to resolve the land issue from the day it was stolen, however, the ANC and the system removed him as a judge and denied him his pensions. We lost the ANC long time ago.
John Hlophe was vilified because he protected corruption, harassed women, assaulted a judge, lives a questionable life of immense luxury. why would you defend such a person? the day we africans wake up and realize these elites are only in it for themselves, that day we can restore our dignity
@Porter90kudos for clearly expressing what is in the minds of many (of all colours). what you have expressed here is human nature red in tooth and claw. it's survival of the fittest. it is completely incompatible with law and rights - it is the way the world actually works. it is amoral. it works - that is why the world is as it is today (full of horrors and injustice). but remember, there are no rules - be careful what you stand for.
Please invite Dr Lwazi Lushaba, I'd really like to hear his views about the current affairs. Thus far enjoying the analysis and insights shared on the channel.🔥🔥 AYEYE🔥🔥
As a white person id like to hear someone suggest how someone goes about ontologically committing white suicide? Any suggestions? I’m feeling super guilty about being white.
Iam of black decent..don't need be fearful Dr ..we are a nation of diversity with great talent and gifts to move this country foward..please get up to speed with the moment No black ,colourds or white people will ever be the .majority in this beautiful and measured democracy
Very informative and worth listening to we need more people like Dr Sindane who unapologetically call a spade a spade thank you for a brilliant podcast
@@FHARTZENGIGGLES before Europeans there was no Congo...no private ownership of land....we know exactly, who we are and we know where we come from...we are not confused like you....
Dr Sizwe take no offense to what i am saying, but this is the first time ever that i actually listened to the interview from start to finish. Great content my brother my kind of stuff... Keep it up...
Best advice I can give these guys. Go live in Zimbabwe for a year. Then actually travel Africa for another year. Once you get back to SA you will love it a whole lot more.
What a great interview. Bringing the teachings of Steve Biko to life in 2024. Unpacking the Constitution in a manner the mainstream media shy away from.
This guest, is the best person I have heard......where do u get such people. ""We shouldn't be voting if markets are the ones which determine the direction of the country"""
Instead of wasting money on elections and supporting political parties with their campaigns...that money would've been well spent on addressing POVERTY AND HUNGER among poor people ...who are in the majority in RSA. Their actions are so revealing...they prioritize what's important for them NOT WHAT WILL MAKE RSA A BETTER PLACE FOR ALL WHO LIVE IN IT🤔
@@erickdavid2412The DA and parties that campaigned on the western market control status quo only obtained 25% of the vote. The parties that presented a black empowerment transformation agenda to the voters were given a mandate of 75% by the electorate. In what sense could the current arrangement between the DA/ANC be the will of the people. This is actually a subversion of democracy, by the ANC - lying to their constituency and turn coat on them with 2weeks of the election.
Abolishnists Language is the way to go and suitable to form a Constitution by and for the victims of Apartheid...The Dr nailed it when he said a Constitution should be a Product of and from the People. Dr Sindane thank you and thank you Sizwe❤❤❤
Wow! what an insightful interview, we have brave black academics ❤, thanks Dr for always giving your guest time to elaborate uninterrupted, you are a very skillful interviewer ❤....keep on bringing those insightful interviews, we are learning, becoming bold n conscientized
Ayeye! What I like now is that we're now left with proper political YT channels like SMWX, unlike the crowd of bought/influenced for certain narrative channels that annoyed us during elections🙏🏾. Enjoyed the discussion, thank you❤
Presently, in South Africa, individuals with a criminal record face employment restrictions irrespective of the nature of their offense, excluding them from consideration for roles even if their record does not involve corruption. Similarly, those lacking the requisite qualifications for a particular profession are automatically excluded from interview opportunities. Implementing analogous criteria within parliament would foster integrity, ensuring governance free from malpractice.
Why should people who are oppressed care about clean government that implements policies that are antiblack? If all that matters is clean government, why did we fight against Apartheid? The DA is no different from the NP. It exists to protect white interests. People must stop preaching to the black majority about DA's clean audits as if all of us blacks are stupid. We know about the so called "clean audits", which can be manipulated by the way, but we value our dignity and the liberation struggle by those who came before us, more. That's not going to change. South Africa remains a divided society with blacks being at the worst circumstances. You can argue all you want about the failures of the ANC which we are aware of, but we will not accept a government that is led by a white party that doesn't care about the needs of the black majority. They pretend that Apartheid didn't happen. They are against redressing the inequalities that were born out of Apartheid. They pretentiously claim to be multi racial, which they are not. So people stop preaching to black South Africans about that which you have no clue of. Stop telling black people to accept oppression in 2024.
this is correct - if you look at Asia where countries went from poorer than Africa to developed, they did this through hard work in government. We need this same practical pragmatic approach. THIS is the way to give dignity to all our people
It is our duty to go to rural areas to educate and awaken the sleeping consciousness of our people whom doesn't have access to this type of information, they don't have access to data or wifi and it causes ignorance and lack of information. They are in a box and we need them woke
Bold conversation and I appreciate Dr Sindane's unapologetic expression of his views.
Good to see that the academics and media are crying. Well done SA you have voted correctly!!!
WAIT and SEE!#
Thanks! 🙏🏿🫡
Thank you!
The main problem is not being confident of who we are and relying on others to define who we are…it’s high time we seek to be comfortable in our skin
But what if being comfortable in our skin offends the ones in power, which may lead to one losing a job opportunity?
Being comfortable in your skin is never going to be comfortable or easy…if you are not comfortable with being uncomfortable…better stay where you are and be ruled by fear of another human being…we need a change of mindset and start working towards employing ourselves
@@KgaogeloTsweleng I think black people as a whole should normalise being comfortable. But as an individual is it really worth losing your livelihood, your ability to feed your family. I respect people who stand up for themselves no matter the cost but I also understand our brothers and sisters who let things slide for the greater good of their families
Dr Sindane, we need more dialogues outside the institutions to empower our people, it's so sad that majority of our kids who don't reach universities are left out of the intellectual engagements, Dr Mpofu thanks for empowering platform.
if South Africans had less kids and cared for them - parents could have taken the responsibility to make sure their kids excelled in life but many granny's are looking after these fatherless kids . African culture is kids are their wealth - and the state must take care of raising them. Parents must empower their kids not the state. If fathers took responsibility to raise their kids we would not have the problems we have = most african men have kids that are not cared for by them.
@Porter90 crazy
He is not empowering anyone but race baiting and fear mongering. This was far from an intellectual engagement but simply demeaning and demonizing another race.
This episode needs Part 2. Thank you Sizwe and Dr Sindane
The difficulty thing about us is that once we are in power, we start eating alone, making us families rich and ignoring the poor . We don't c any progress rather than rich politicians it's so sad how we are treated by black people
Furthermore, the DA coalition could be scrutinized, but what are we gaining as poor people under the ANC rather than murder and corruption? Our black leaders are so selfish. Even this coalition is based on the markets, not us black people.
and again @BaneleMancoba check how many previous disadvantaged black employees benefited from bbbee, none, 202 black employees were dismissed by G4S private security company for protesting about the g4s staff share trust which was established in 2005 to benefit them, we went up and down to this black parties asking for assistance in litigating g4s but none of them came to assist us and now they are crying foul
Now you talking. Precisely. That's why the poor voted for the Da. Voters who are black. They flee from the eastern cape to the western cape to look for a better life for all.
@terencelintnaar7595 in the western cape, the health department is the best and education. Go to where our black brothers govern its disgrace, painful 👌 👍
@@BaneleMancobabut never run from the fect that every freely rich black man in South Africa today kissed the white peoples ass. We don’t have self made millionaire, billionaires like Sam Malope who have bankrupted by our current president. And we have allowed the media to bad mouth Zuma the president at least who to bring few black millionaires without kissing white peoples ass
I thought SOUTH AFRICA was COLOUR BLIND from 1994 BUT listning to this guy i see RACISM is still ALIVE and well
on the ground it is colour blind bt surely classist society. it is us who stil trying to hold on to race i have been around white people who never even look at me as a black person
@@mojalefamzananda4511it's so exhausting and we need each other
The majority of whites has never changed it's just that they are afraid of the law.
So that itself calls for the same response.
Go to Cape Town and see if the white there are color blind
The problem with being color blind and that rainbow nonsense is you also become blind and ignorant to the social injustices against black people, calling someone black or white is already racisms being asked on a bank form if you african or white what is that
My God. Am I blessed to have listened to this episode.
@sizwe…..Listen to Jordan Peterson speak about White Privilege, I’d like to see you comment on those ideas.
then get ready for hell, racist
Sadly, you have been led astray. Please check out the economist from Ghana, Dr GBN Ayittey. He explains with evidence, how Comrades are actually the problem, whose policies keep Africa poor whilst they blame imperialism for all the inevitable results of the thinking outlined above. It has nothing to do with race.
Wow, Dr Ntando
What an insightful conversation. Thank you so much for oiling our lamps🙏
May you all be blessed with the work you do in speaking our truth...
Thanks
The ANC brought this onto us
I'm sorry, I hear this intellectual man but some of the things he says DEEPLY saddens me.
Loose use of the term intellectual.
i don't think all is said to just make people feel bad about themselves or even feel good about themselves he is challenging people to self-introspect and be sincere.
It is so really sad to listen to Prof.
True, far too deep for a modern new way of thinking and living.
Allow the new multi party GNU of South Africa for the full expression of our constitution to Fix this country and our its people.
Heal the land.
There's no healing without the redress of grievances.
Mr Mandela would have said stop this racism and stand together as a country...
Sure. He is the one who let black South Africans down. He bent to the same forces that are at work right now opting instead to be revered internationally rather than ensuring that the oppressed black majority who fought hard for his freedom.
Agreed a 110%
That solves what exactly?
Standing together means sharing the means of production and the strategic sectors of the economy which are owned and controlled by white people. Are they willing to do that?
Not true! Considering this perpetual plight of impoverished Blacks would have been a factor with Mandela because this is not what he and many other comrades fought for.
I salute Dr Ntando intellectual capacity and the audacity to stand by your intellectual / academic analysis without fear, we need more of people like him
Happy Father's day to all the fathers 🎉🎉! I don't know Dr Sindane but it's difficult for me not to listen to his deep understanding of the topic today I'm just happy to gain insight as a gogo who is always willing to learn, this is so deep & I'm learned already, thank you ❤
I learned a lot from this. Made me read some of Dr Sindane and Prof Madlingozi's articles. I now understand what decoloniality means and its importance in post-apartheid SA. These men are producing excellent scholarship worth reading. Thanks Sizwe. Hopefully Prof Madlingozi will honour your invitation soon. 👊🏾
Hi where can one read such articles
@@fezilegreg3531 Search their names on Google Scholar and you will find the articles.
You can't go wrong when you study Biko. He's timeless and consummate. I appreciate you gentlemen for giving us another gem. 🫡✨
But if we don't get what it was intended to bring forth in us, its value are lost in a perpetual victimhood. I am also a big Steve Biko fan. It changed how I looked at my own blackness as a young man back in the day.
Biko was a deranged racist. This country went wrong already
A great conversation indeed. Ukufunda akukhulelwa.
You got to love the fear mongering of this channel. Ignoring the fact that blackness is not a political ideology. Ignoring the fact that the biggest voter transfer was due to tribalism and not ideology. Ignoring the fact that improving delivery will substantially improve everybody’s lives no matter the ideology. Ignoring the fact that extreme left leaning ideology has not brought sustainable prosperity to any nation. Ignoring the fact that 30 years of left leaning politics in SA has put us in a downward spiral.
Ignoring the fact that doing the same thing every time and expecting a different outcome is the definition of insanity.
WELL SAID.
Well articulated.
I bet to differ. It's NOT left leaning ideology but rather incompetence and corruption that is to blame. Let's be honest.
@mphomathuba2942 I agree with you, we didn't even begin to go left in the 30 years even if the intention was. If you ask the simple question, did justice prevail over the atrocities of the past? Did it really prevail? The honest answer will be NO.
You people who talk about tribalism, forget that white supremacy is a tribe that sticks together!
I have listened to this talk three times now. Very grateful for this channel - it's hard-hitting and challenging content. I appreciate having conversations like this and other ones that challenge me and allow me to see the country from the views of others that are not within my immediate context and presented so that I can inform me, even if I don't understand or necessarily agree.
There's much of value in this talk. And I appreciate the thought that perhaps the Constitution is perhaps a constitution of compromise and appeasement.
But I'm still left with this question - how, as a white person, can I truly relinquish that which makes me white? How do I surrender my white privilege?
If I understand that my white privilege comes not just simply from my skin colour, but also from the circumstances of my birth, by the privileges accorded to me by society and my community by virtue of looking, acting, behaving, and living within a context - all of which we might call "whiteness"... how do I simply relinquish that?
Some of these things seem to be totally inherent to me. I cannot change my skin color. I cannot erase my family, my history, my upbringing, my context, the fact that I benefited from Apartheid. How can these things be relinquished?
I can change my politics, I can change how I see others in my country, I can support land reform, I can support policies that do not benefit me and instead benefit others in greater need with fewer rights and fewer privileges than I have had, hoping that this will benefit them and grant them the basic rights and needs that they were denied by Apartheid (past and, from the perspective of many in our country, ongoing). I could do these things even to my own detriment, understanding that my situation is better than most in our country (most non-whites in our country) can even imagine to ever reach, and that I neither need (or want) more privilege and actively want to divest some of that privilege. I can try to understand and respect the views of others, even if they seem radical and even counter to my own interests. I can try to embody these values to the fullest extent I can.
But it seems to me that I cannot erase my whiteness. I cannot be seen as non-white by others, nor erase my white history and heritage. It is part of me, surely. So what does Dr. Sindane mean by this?
My take is through reparations!!! The same way some English (families formerly Slave masters in earlier centuries) are helping slave descendants in former slave plantation areas! Maybe as a starting point.
I think you're approaching the topic with far more good faith than the guest of this show.
It was only last week when i stymbled upon this channel. And the interviewer is doing the lord's work. He gives his guests the platform to talk and not interrupt. I applaud you Dr. I cannot live without this channel anymore.
Yoh, when people are over educated, they leave reality and just live somewhere else.
😭😭😭😭😭
STEM degrees are hard, best to go for the low hanging fruit…😅
@@nicjordan7300Exactly right, we are overwhelmed with humanities graduates who think they can hypothesise answers to real world problems. We need more engineers and scientists to solve our problems.
You actually don't have a problem with his education but just can't stomach the truths he is dishing out. So the conversation is doing its job - to make the comfortable, uncomfortable, and the uncomfortable, comfortable.
@@TommyMarxable but didn't you hear him? The solution is simple , just change the constitution it will solve all our problems.
Very sober analysis... more power to the spirit of Steven Bantu Biko speaking through you Dr. Sindane
Very informative, concise and educational interview. Dr. Sindane is a real teacher and master in this topic regarding the constitution. His critique is justified and his analysis are to the point. I also like his personal views and analysis of the DA, he is also an outstanding scholar of Steve Biko.
Thanks Dr. Mpofu about these interviews and these learned guest who are brave, who question and challenge the status quo.
Dr Sindane and Professor Madlingozi interviews and also pre election interview of Andile Mxidama were the greatest of I have listened to.
Happy Father's day to all Fathers
There is only one FATHER. Not on earth
Thanks for reminding me😅
Thank you, and same to you..assuming you also a father or male
@@Thesewingsuccesschannel honor your mother and father on earth...your days will be added....
Cheers to that 🤝
The Dr nailed it sir appreciate your wisdom you have absolutely opened the eyes of the black majority in this country keep up with the good works Dankie siyabonga
Dr. Sindane is very illuminated person... I learned a lot today about SA Constitution...
Watching from Pemba, Cabo Delgado - Mozambique
If you don't understand what Ntando has sat there and said..you are exactly given the opportunity to assess yourself.
Very clear.We cannot run away from what has shaped life here 🇿🇦
I thought I was the only one who is sad in this country .....😢
We are too many
A bottle of Johnny Walker works for me
😂@@Antieverything255
So many of us my brother
Same group.
Thanks!
We must stop racism because we are all South Africans, we must learned to love each other’s
Is too shallow.
I'm only 45 minutes into the show, and I feel I have drifted from reality thanks to Dr Sindane. It feels like when things go our way, the Constitution is supreme and when they don't, the Constitution is the enemy of the people. I hear a lot of contradictions from the Dr. and victimhood. I will listen on, maybe he will get to the point that all are responsible for their actions and deeds, you are not good or bad based on the color of your skin. With that said I like how he presents his arguments and he really gives food for thought.
it is easy to talk his talk from his position, he should be able to abandon the white mentor... first ... abandon the privilege that he speaks from and more importantly show us what he in his little corner is doing to advance his speak... bayakhuluma .... we nod ... we had 30 years to change that constitution ... abathule
What is victimhood? My parents experienced first hand the terrorism of the apartheid regime, so talking about the past now, you labelled a victim? History has consequences, this victimhood gaslighting is no different from denialism. Jews can bring up the holocaust, they remind us of it all the time, no body labels them victims, actually you can be arrested for holocaust denialism and labelled antisemitic. Apartheid was designated as a crime against humanity. So what was accumulated before 94 is criminal. Or we should just stop being victims and stop fighting for justice and the land and economic reforms.
But he is not in parliament 😅😅
What is victimhood? Are jews viewed as victims when they talk about their own past? It's just a label reserved for "black" people? The gaslighting never ends. Kaffirs to victims😅😅
Why ANC didn't give the country to black people when they are tired of government because it's too early for whites to rule this country with many people with apertheid scars some are still looking for their love ones who are missing some families didn't receive the remains of their members who died in exile black people are still living in dirty townships while white are still living in clean spacious suburbs even during the campaign no white people visited our houses asking for votes yet they say they like us poor children attend school in townships those who can afford attend in suburbs riding back of vans because they want better education nothing have changed to think DA will change the situation is a dream
2:26 A black Verwoerd.
Why do all the supposed thought leaders always proclaim that SA must be a zero sum game.
The DA will proof you wrong black Verwoerd. There is enough for us all to thrive.
Great program. Well said Dr. I do hope the Black people of SA will listen to this program and make the right decisions for their future. Viva Viva to the Black People of SA.
This is a must watch interview by every black men, woman and child. Thank you for the episode. This type of conversation needs to continue wherever we gather as black people, ngoba kuse kude engqinibeni. Le nkululeko ayikafiki.
But this people are better off mos their neighborhood are white supremacy🤞
My black brother i been following your shows or should i say podcast for long time, I must say we need more of your kind in this so called SA democracy. We're struggling in the townships of what is happening on the National and Provincial so your Podcast help us in the poor townships which I mean Political we get strength.💪🙏
Mr Sizwe last time I raised a concern about the volume level of your podcast.
But listen to this episode now, I can say that it did get better.
Thank you for the upgrade on that regard.
I believe he is a Dr not Mr
It's really painful to see South Africa in this mess
SMWX bring back this guy again. We'll learn a lot. When DA says they want qualified people. Do they mean experienced or academically qualified like most black people?
I am yet to understand this talk of “Black interest”, do you mean the interest of the “Black elite” ? Because our interest as the poor are basic, we want a stable economy, crime free, jobs and good education… DA has proven itself to be better in Governance than any other party in South Africa. I don’t care whether they are racist or not. We need to move away from this victim mentality…
Amen, I am just so tired of this black victimhood. It makes black people look weak and timid.
@@luxolomagadla2354 excellent 👋🏼👋🏼👋🏼on point
luxolo you are young and lacking nolage shame wait and see ,and you must lean to be a good Lestener
The problem you are having is that you are looking things at your own benefiting and you forget that not everyone who are at your position and being lead by a racist it never make you as black person any better besides being an employee and a slave for the racist, maybe you need to look at things differently don't us your feelings because you will never get the truth and that is what we want in order for us to be free from the hands of racist.
You are are not very bright. And I'm being kind to you.
Very very profound interview! Dr. Academic Radical.
Because of you I will do my LLM in Constitutional Law.
You will find BEE is illegal under constitutional law. I wish everyone to work together. Stop cadre deployment
30 years of opportunities to outshine !! Where is the success as no new hospitals, schools have been built by ANC government for 30 years ????
My lecturer ! Very intelligent man with great wisdom .
Dr. Ntando Sindane, I salute you with much respect for being one of the few academics who cherish the ethos of Africanism despite a lot of knowledge you acquired in your studies. Because many academics are brainwashed by the western teaching as their reference point and they forego the African wisdom of originalism. The agenda to wipe out African ethos through western academia to dictate what is possible and what is desirable has become a dominant reality perpetuated white people. We people like Dr. Ntando Sindane, who out of wisdom and accumulated knowledge remain authentic in bring African interpretation of liberal reality to the mainstream of discussion and true recognition of equality for all.
Why is he wearing a suit ? That is not African.
30 years of opportunities! Where is the outcome ? SAA ,Transnet , Prasa , Eskom are failing???? That is evidence of cadre deployment who know nothing about management
Such a pity to have such racism ...Dr please let's move on for the sake of all South Africans
11.01am
Tell the DA that.
We only forgave the oppressor please we haven't healed nor forgotten Mxm
Stop suppressing us we are over it and this move by the ANC did do you any Favour 😂
Which statements here are not true. What makes this racists
He indeed is a great scholar. We wish to hear more from him. Thank you Dr Ntando Sindane
To be fair to the ANC, since its inception in 1910, from John Langalibalele Dube to now Cyril Matamela Ramaphosa, all they wanted was to be included in the government structure! They have never wanted to transform and/or to be in charge of anything except to be part of the governance of this Union of South Africa.
I agree fully, I have said it so many times Anc was never a party designed to protect and uplift South African people. It's a party designed by black elitist who wanted to secure their seat on the table to serve their masters. That's why they are saying they are not a black party because they don't want to saddened their colonial masters. Unfortunately white people in general are racist and will never change let's forget about rainbow nation. It's not a reality.We can only learn to coexist as human beings.
So why did so many, a lot even loosing their lives because they believed the struggle was for transformation if it was only to be included!?
Study Zuma and u will see he is the odd one because he actually transformed Black ppls lives. We saw more participation from the Black communities in the economy.
@musawenkosimakhoba9028 No, he did not transform black people lives. He allowed some few blacks to be rich without any meaningful change. Mbeki and Mandela did the same!
Which SA are u living at dear, coz u talking nonsense
I am a reader of comparative constitutionalism myself and must say this is one of the most thought provoking interviews I have listened to. Dr Sindane keep up with the good work.
This interview was very short yet very long Dr Mpofu . I’m crying how this episode was very short lived . I love Dr Sindane a lot , maybe because of my ardent love for black people . Please call him again maybe to share his thoughts on black consciousness precisely . We need such segment , more especially at this juncture . Biko would be proud .. mor this is my favorite episode .
Sizwe ....i don't have words to thank you and Dr Sindane. actually this is my first listening to his interview. I felt goosebumps at some stage due to his utterances. I learnt soo much today
Thanks, My Brother, You'll buy Bread❤
Thank you!
This man can make you love the academic world. What an intellectual giant this man is👏👏👏
Don't lie! This windbag is an intellectual dwarf, and he knows it himself. That's why he's resorting to subversive language in an attempt to hide his lack of thought and argument.
Great conversation as usual Sizwe.
Thank you Sizwe with Dr Ntando such a profound discussion I learned a lot today about law rights regarding constitution.
the markets is not 3 families, its the whole world deciding if South Africa is stable enough to invest it. that includes cellphones, cars, food, clothes etc...
When white privilege & political supremacy were denounced by the global markets, its beneficiaries didn't consider their dictates at all.
White society instead consolidated their efforts & resolve, aligned themselves with selected international allies, skirted sanctions & built domestic industry. That they did until their privilege was so deeply entrenched & shielded that they could negotiate from a position of power during the early nineties.
Now when the economical disenfranchised black populace demands transformation, immediate submision to these self same markets are presented as being existential to SA society.
The markets need our land and minerals resources more than we need them. We need good African leaders not the DA. The Sahel countries in north africa are proving it.
The only markets in question here are white supremacy nations, Europe and North America and some countries in Asia, the rest of the world is disgusted with this coalition...we should be working to secure the future market like all major economies are doing in the world, focus heavy invest in Africa, how are we going to do that working with self proclaimed haters of native Africans and their children...
U must go to school so that u can understand
@@MS-cq6dh We cannot be dictated to by the markets. Land expropriation will be a good start
brains with brains....Dr Sindane was given a platform to educate and Dr Mpofu thank you for allowing him to do so ...first time watching an interview on the road i was looking for a playlist on youtube...very informative bafehu
@ racists talking about their sexual fantasies about killing whites. Doesnt take much brain power
Thank you, SMWX, for bringing such interesting intellectuals to discuss what's not covered in the mainstream media. Big up Doc.
For those interested about the Steve Biko part please check out the book Biko wrote “I write what I like”.
@Porter90 This is a book recommendation, you can read it too. Otherwise your response reflects a racist and supremacist viewpoint that promotes the idea of white superiority.
Biko was a deranged racist, Good ridance
@Porter90And this TH-cam cesspool encourages the well known and disgraced white supremacy ethos to thrive.
Good political analyst I ever listen too, non bias and real love africa
THIS ENTIRE CONVERSATION IS ICONIC. Mark this. Clarity of the past, the present, and what is up ahead. Share this far and wide.
totally agree
This interview is not for those who are intellectually challenged and with poor comprehension skills. The man is clear in his analysis and thoughts. Telling it like it is. Thanks Dr Mpofu-Walsh.
You speaking about intellect and shitting the bed with your sentence is priceless. Go to edit and try this again clown😂😂😂
What an interview, awesome, informative, educational, insightful, honest truth.
Thank you Dr Sizwe and to the Dr.
We'll like to hear more
Dr Sindane ("I have white friends") tells his students all the time that they are victims?
But🤔 we are victims of an Injust system, an Injust society, if you ill treated what does it make you?
@@hueNeo A cog in a broken system, having trouble spinning, because something or someone is causing a jam. The system just needs a good engineer and some maintenance.
He actually said "I have White colleagues, some of whom are friends".....just being specific so that the listener knows that they're definitely not ALL friends of his. Lucky for them.
You got it ,my Dr.Feed us more & more until blacks,call a spade,a spade,looking forwad for books,@@markriordan9010
The MK and EFF will govern in 2029
in your dreams. EFF is the worst party ever. The losers of the current election results? WHY? Cause they are useless idiots. They have no leadership
Viva!!! ✊🏽✊🏽
Keep shining Ntwana, u and the likes of Manyathela just ask and discuss the issues myself and for sure millions of your Audience would like to ask and discuss. When you interviews end, we are fulfilled and we know we are not disillusioned that we have to fight for our True/Holistic liberation of native South Afrikans, Afrika at large & Afrikans in diaspora.
Ayeye!!!
Imagine being this guy’s white friend.“You are my friend but you’re a terrible person because you are white and I have a problem with your whiteness.”
I left South Africa 16 years ago. I love my country. I miss the people, of all race, but also so happy that my children don’t even give a thought about race and who they are friends with.
Do most black South Africans want white people to leave SA? Would you be better off as a nation without any white people there? Is there no way for people to live in harmony? These are all serious questions.
I have black friends. I don’t think of them as black. They just my friends.
You are really naive, the reason race issues don't pass is because people like you always want to sweep the matter under the mat. People were hurt, they are carrying deep scars, until we get an apology and compensation race will always be a factor
We are preparing to walk with dompass
We just need white people in SA to relinquish White Privilege. Only then, can we consider you guys as *friends* and not *enemies*
@@Lesg25 Can you please give clarity to me as a white person in South africa what I need to relinquish to remove my privilege?
@@Aplayz42 You are deliberately missing the point. If this video did not make that point clear to you, then I'm afraid there is nothing further that can be done to help you understand.
Thank you Sizwe for being our eye opener and with your guest in studio.
Another enlightening & thought-provoking discussion Sizwe...
Dr Sindane your candid perspective resonates...
Your scholarship is revelational - the both of you!
Judge Hlophe was vilified because of being firm about the land issue. He wanted us to resolve the land issue from the day it was stolen, however, the ANC and the system removed him as a judge and denied him his pensions. We lost the ANC long time ago.
ANC was never a black or African party since 1994, it’s a white owned party same as DA
John Hlophe was vilified because he protected corruption, harassed women, assaulted a judge, lives a questionable life of immense luxury. why would you defend such a person?
the day we africans wake up and realize these elites are only in it for themselves, that day we can restore our dignity
Give the land back to the Koi San then.
the land is not privately owned in Africa...stop spreading European propaganda here....
@@beverleyuntiedt1777you can say that again
Thank you Dr Sindane for being the brave courageous voice👏
The commenter above me (@Porter90) is an... interesting person.
@Porter90kudos for clearly expressing what is in the minds of many (of all colours). what you have expressed here is human nature red in tooth and claw. it's survival of the fittest. it is completely incompatible with law and rights - it is the way the world actually works. it is amoral. it works - that is why the world is as it is today (full of horrors and injustice). but remember, there are no rules - be careful what you stand for.
Thank you Dr Ntando Sindane
Please invite Dr Lwazi Lushaba, I'd really like to hear his views about the current affairs. Thus far enjoying the analysis and insights shared on the channel.🔥🔥 AYEYE🔥🔥
Please Sizwe do call Prof Lushaba
I've been requesting the same...
I second the call to invite Dr Lwazi Lushaba
You like to hear other racists blame whites.
As a white person id like to hear someone suggest how someone goes about ontologically committing white suicide? Any suggestions? I’m feeling super guilty about being white.
Iam of black decent..don't need be fearful Dr ..we are a nation of diversity with great talent and gifts to move this country foward..please get up to speed with the moment No black ,colourds or white people will ever be the .majority in this beautiful and measured democracy
I'm not sure if uve seen the latest statistics. Black Africans are 81.2 percent of the population. So their the clear majority
What are you talking about Blacks are the majority. Just like blacks in America you are not united as a group.
So what?
S.A is a BLACK COUNTRY...
Don't forget history. Land issues in SA say it all. The injustice of that is horrible. If white people want peace, they should resolve that issue
Very informative and worth listening to we need more people like Dr Sindane who unapologetically call a spade a spade thank you for a brilliant podcast
" I don't care if the cat is black or white as long as it can catch mice"
..... as long as you are still the dog that controls mice, right?
100% agree
You are a lost soul. You are not even accountable to what happens in this country. You hate South Africans.
It matters because who will the cat feed the mice to? the black or the white cat?
Only privilege thinksz likes that
Without tackling elephant in the room(land restitution, spatial injusticies, equality), we postpone peace and harmony.
@@mvubu6823transformation of the mind...is a start....
if what you're looking for is EQUALITY, then you've already lost.
Your land is in the congo, Settler
@@FHARTZENGIGGLES before Europeans there was no Congo...no private ownership of land....we know exactly, who we are and we know where we come from...we are not confused like you....
Dont forget Malcolm X , goes very well with steven biko , X was nice and obstructive to this global evil spirit.
Dr Sizwe take no offense to what i am saying, but this is the first time ever that i actually listened to the interview from start to finish. Great content my brother my kind of stuff... Keep it up...
Best advice I can give these guys. Go live in Zimbabwe for a year. Then actually travel Africa for another year. Once you get back to SA you will love it a whole lot more.
Another white person spewing nonsense
You need to see where we are heading causexwe are following their path. We need to course correct.
This guy is making very interesting arguments. It makes you think
"If you have no critics you'll likely have no success". Keep up with the powerful content 🙏🏾
AYEYE! what a beautiful mind to listen to,you are like a breath of fresh air,siyabonga kakhulu
What a great interview. Bringing the teachings of Steve Biko to life in 2024. Unpacking the Constitution in a manner the mainstream media shy away from.
I will vote DA again and again
Yes. Otherwise SA will become Zimbabwe 2.0. And Cuba, Uganda...
Me too forever
Good luck to you😢
@@thandikekana6364keep the luck for you and your black corruption 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You think DA gonna do any good as black people think again Letlo itshola
This guest, is the best person I have heard......where do u get such people.
""We shouldn't be voting if markets are the ones which determine the direction of the country"""
The DA got the 2nd most votes. The point is the people voted to go with the markets
@@erickdavid2412 ANC had options and it was forced into premeditated marriage by Stellenbosch mafia controlling markets
Its markets who provides jobs, not ideology.
Instead of wasting money on elections and supporting political parties with their campaigns...that money would've been well spent on addressing POVERTY AND HUNGER among poor people ...who are in the majority in RSA.
Their actions are so revealing...they prioritize what's important for them NOT WHAT WILL MAKE RSA A BETTER PLACE FOR ALL WHO LIVE IN IT🤔
@@erickdavid2412The DA and parties that campaigned on the western market control status quo only obtained 25% of the vote.
The parties that presented a black empowerment transformation agenda to the voters were given a mandate of 75% by the electorate.
In what sense could the current arrangement between the DA/ANC be the will of the people. This is actually a subversion of democracy, by the ANC - lying to their constituency and turn coat on them with 2weeks of the election.
Abolishnists Language
is the way to go and suitable to form a Constitution by and for
the victims of Apartheid...The Dr nailed it when he said a Constitution should be a Product of and from the People.
Dr Sindane thank you and thank you Sizwe❤❤❤
This one masterbates to killing whites.
@@FHARTZENGIGGLES As he should
@sizwe, this interview tops my charts 🙏 thank you for bringing such a brilliant intellect. He’s a rare species
I agree and we need such minds
This conclusion is what Africans need to do by including our cultural beliefs in our constitution
You mean your cultural belief of raping babies to cure aids, being racist, calling for genocide, and making rape legal?
Sizwe wee need to have a part. 2 of this conversation because Dr Ntando's thought is very important ij enlightening society
The show was informative, thumbs up to DR. Sindane.
I look forward to all your videos. I think every young person in South Africa should watch them. Thank you!!
What an enlightening interview. Can I pose a question to Dr Sindane, are you involved in any political activities?
Wow! what an insightful interview, we have brave black academics ❤, thanks Dr for always giving your guest time to elaborate uninterrupted, you are a very skillful interviewer ❤....keep on bringing those insightful interviews, we are learning, becoming bold n conscientized
Ayeye! What I like now is that we're now left with proper political YT channels like SMWX, unlike the crowd of bought/influenced for certain narrative channels that annoyed us during elections🙏🏾. Enjoyed the discussion, thank you❤
Yoh... Dr Ntando Sindane. I salute.
Without truth ,there can be no freedom, only the friend of the truth can or will accept the truth.
This was brilliant, thank you Siz.
Okay i enjoyed this conversation between Dr Ntando Sindane & Sizwe.... Spread the🔥🔥🔥🔥Ayeye
How about some policies that would deliver clean government and jobs? And discuss who can best deliver on these?
Presently, in South Africa, individuals with a criminal record face employment restrictions irrespective of the nature of their offense, excluding them from consideration for roles even if their record does not involve corruption. Similarly, those lacking the requisite qualifications for a particular profession are automatically excluded from interview opportunities. Implementing analogous criteria within parliament would foster integrity, ensuring governance free from malpractice.
Why should people who are oppressed care about clean government that implements policies that are antiblack? If all that matters is clean government, why did we fight against Apartheid? The DA is no different from the NP. It exists to protect white interests. People must stop preaching to the black majority about DA's clean audits as if all of us blacks are stupid. We know about the so called "clean audits", which can be manipulated by the way, but we value our dignity and the liberation struggle by those who came before us, more. That's not going to change. South Africa remains a divided society with blacks being at the worst circumstances. You can argue all you want about the failures of the ANC which we are aware of, but we will not accept a government that is led by a white party that doesn't care about the needs of the black majority. They pretend that Apartheid didn't happen. They are against redressing the inequalities that were born out of Apartheid. They pretentiously claim to be multi racial, which they are not. So people stop preaching to black South Africans about that which you have no clue of. Stop telling black people to accept oppression in 2024.
Many live in other lands who could be delivering.
They can’t. It’s just communist nonsense. Even China doesn’t apply such nonsense.
this is correct - if you look at Asia where countries went from poorer than Africa to developed, they did this through hard work in government. We need this same practical pragmatic approach. THIS is the way to give dignity to all our people
It is our duty to go to rural areas to educate and awaken the sleeping consciousness of our people whom doesn't have access to this type of information, they don't have access to data or wifi and it causes ignorance and lack of information. They are in a box and we need them woke