Quick change lacing? ETA: I'm surprised you came up with this idea without having seen it first. It gets used by costumers who need to be able to quickly remove an outer garment to display an inner one for a quick costume change, like a truly invisible (and much faster) zip
I highly recommend that any time you wash the shorter skirt, you toss the extension in, too, so they fade equally. Any time I split up a blouse/skirt in wearing, I now wash both. Long ago I had a set and after 4 years, the difference made it impossible to wear them together.
As someone who struggles a lot with impulse shopping things when I have a perceived need, I really appreciate seeing the creative ways you use materials! For example, a piece of cardboard for a seam guide, or some card stock for a seam ruler. I hope you'll forgive me saying, because I mean this in the most genuine and heartfelt way, but seeing that you can get the incredible results you get while incorporating literal garbage into the process makes me feel a LOT more comfortable about moving beyond the incessant urge to have every perfect tool for every situation. Y'know? (Also really neat project, thanks for sharing!)
Absolutely! We do NOT need 90% of what companies try to sell us. What was the mantra from the Great Depression? Something like use it up, wear it out, and make do? Shannon definitely Makes do. 😂
Thank you, this comment has made me SO happy!! The thought that I can have this effect on even ONE person out there through my channel makes it all worth it! I was apparently just *born* thrifty, and the concept of impulse shopping is simply not something that occurs to me (I say this without judgement, just as a description of myself) it comes quite naturally to me to look around and see what I can use that I already have. That, plus I'm cheap, lazy, and impatient - if I don't have to spend money, leave my house, or delay the project to get something new when I can use a substitute, that's 100% what I'll do 🤣. And it's just a bonus side effect that it's good for the planet (although I do think I have some "eco-anxiety" too).
I would try to make trousers and a waistcoat from that lovely brownish plaid/check fabric. If I didn't have enough fabric for both items, I'd make the trousers wide leg.
I'd do a burn test on the fibres as I'm thinking it's wool. I had similar and had made a skirt in the 80s so I was interested to hear what others would make. 😊
The final effect is stunning! It definitely isn't quick to lace up, but as long as you aren't on a runway attempting to mimic a quick change dress, it probably isn't much of an issue. I can actually think of lots of reasons to want a shirt like this (or even a pair of capris or shorts). For starters, it could be an easy way to convert day wear to night wear and reduce packing weight on trips, or just reduce the clothing load / change up your clothing.
No, for me at least, it's not an issue because I've attended a historical event roughly 0 times in my life, and will be lucky to attend even a few in my lifetime, so I don't mind doing the extension for those limited events! Would I want to do it every day? No, but even if it was once a season, to go from summer skirt to winter skirt, let's say, that'd be totally fine!
Having to unpick any seam sucks, but having to unpick hand sewn seams really sucks. Its a shame the trim situation didn't work out as originally planned but the floof trim does suit the time period better. A very ingenious way to transform the two!
The skirt is so pretty! I'd have used a separating zipper (or a series of them since you probably can't get one long enough for a hem) or carefully spaced out snaps/poppers. Because I've never heard of button loop trim it wouldn't have ever occurred to me that there was an "easy" lace up option. Or that one could lace up something horizontally at all, to be honest.
Thank you! Unfortunately, a zipper would affect the drape of the skirt pretty significantly, and could be great if you wanted a bit stiffer of a hemline, but since I love the flowy, drape-y look, wasn't going to be a great option for me in this case!
@@ShannonMakes sorry i didnt mean to imply that you should have used a zipper, just that that is what would have come to my mind if I wanted to make a convertible skirt.
@@ShannonMakes ha, I'm so so sorry. I don't want to offend anyone by accident (only on purpose 🤣). Sometimes I find it difficult to express the correct tone through writing. I meant to convey that I thought it was a very creative solution and that, self disparaging, I'd only have thought of a more pedestrian option. And now I'm the most annoying person on the internet.🤦♀️
@nataliestanchevski4628 Nope. Not the most annoying. That's reserved for people who insist that we are quite daft and they are very rude about it. When we communicate, there is inflection caused by pitch up or down, volume, and body language. 🤔 Emojis sometimes help. For instance, a glimpse of the things I like.🕊🫖🐈⬛📚🦋🥧☕️🌧🌹💞🐑🦌 Blessings on all your endeavors, including communication!🖖🤝
I am really impressed with the amount of work that went into this skirt, especially since you had to remove the trim. Your button loop trim solution is genius, and the resulting skirt is gorgeous!
I would use this gorgeous brown plaid to make a split skirt and waitcoat combo! I know you said enough skirts for now but its not technically a skirt, its secret pants!! :p Also taking note of you great idea of transformable skirt. The "waste" of fabric is the main thing holding me back in making fully historical clothes but this is an awesome compromise!
Yup, it's a lot of resources (time is a resource too) going to something that will hardly ever be worn, right?! This does help alleviate that feeling though, at least for me!!
I haven’t seen the button loop tape, but that’s a genius idea! I’m hoping to make a linen short-sleeve shirt, but be able to attach full sleeves if I want to wear it later in the year or want the additional sun protection, but I wasn’t sure If buttons would create sagging between them or require so many to be tedious. I even considered plastic snaps, but worry about pulling them apart on a lighter weight fabric.
I don't know how much this would affect your sleeves - if its a lighter weight fabric, it'd definitely add some weight onto the ends of your short sleeves (although less circumference, so less weight than on my hem)... definitely worth a shot, for sure!
I would have tried hook and eye tape, but the button loops make for a much softer finish than either hook and eye or snap tape. The only qualm I have is that white loops would have been a better choice because they would be less visible if you are are not wearing the extension but sitting so that the inside of the hem shows.
Very clever! As for that houndstooth fabric, I can't shake the image of a cape with leather or leather-look trim and toggle closure. A warm lining would make it a practical garment for fall/winter. Can't wait to see what you decide to make!
If you want the base skirt to have some pizazz, you can add lace trim to the underside of the seam that hangs down over where the extention would go. The only caveat is that it might be itchy, since it would be on the inside of the skirt when you have the extention. I would have sewn on loops instead of the black stuff, maybe with ribbons so it looks like a trim detail, or hidden fabric loops under the seam of the hem. It is a beautiful skirt, and looks fun to make!
It would have taken SO long to sew on loops individually though! I'm glad this stuff comes on a roll, so I can just run one line of stitches to hold all the loops on! 🤣🪡
Oh. Cool! That will work for turning my summer shirt into my fall shirts. Sleeves. This kind of thing is would also be for the winter, when you need to choose between insulation and wind blocking (while looking fabulous in an ankle length skirt) or keeping your skirt out of the mire. and wool skirts are always more expensive than any other kind, so saving money. Alternatives. Edging lace, ribbon insert lace, and eyelet hole trim. Also might work for. Attaching a bodice and skirts for a dress. Detachable collars. And cuffs. Those shirt tail (micro skirt thing) for wearing under sweaters. Just with no elastic. Changing out your sleeves, or reversible sleeves, Medieval style. Those ball gowns that look like a cocktail dress with a fishtail of tool flounce coming out from under the knees. Making it for All occasions. Removable quilted liner for a cape. A flounce for your cape. Extra length for your hooded mantle. Flounce. I can't think of anything more.
@anjabeyer3812 having worked with them, I don't see anything here that my lace set-up wouldn't be able to handle. Obviously there are always exceptions, like maybe if your cape is full floor length and you don't sew the button loops in properly enough, then yea, but if it's like an elbow length one, or even maybe waist length, I don't think it'd be a problem.
@@ShannonMakes I was thinking a dramatic silky train coming out the back of a short mantle, or out of the ventilation panel on the upper back of a jacket. It could probably even be used with wedding dresses. You know how they like the massive train for the wedding, but then button it up somehow for the reception. There. I thought of another thing.
I am 100% going to use this button loop idea for removeable sections! My wardrobe is about 60% handmade and I'm looking to increase that percentage but I've been debating for months how to make separating pieces because I always want to wear pieces year round in a very changeable climate. This will be amazing for extending skirts like you did, extendable sleeves (The button on method didn't really work for me) making dresses/pinafores that can be skirts, or trousers into dungarees! I'm super excited to give this a try, thank you for sharing your processes with us!
This is such a goid idea, i would totally use it for skirts with the long version for winter and the shorter one for summer. I sow a lot in leggings coz thats what i mostly wear beneath my skirts 😊
if you really miss the white stripes, you could add a thick white band to the tuck above the middle ruffle, and then thick bands on the hem of the shorter skirt, and on the extension. so the shortened skirt would end with a white band on the hem, then when you add the extension, there'd be 3 bands total. i'd hold them up about 3-5mm or so from the fold of the tuck/hem, just so it looks more like a design than an afterthought, and then it would also cover the machine stitching if you feel like you want/need to do so.
I saw a pair of tricot under-pants, effectively Capri leggings, to wear under wool pants in a course I took back in the '80s. It not only keeps itchy wool off your legs, it helps preserve the fabric from body moisture, etc. It's effectively washable lining for every pair of wool pants, no fuss no muss.
I was thinking you might use buttons and loops. I've seen early Edwardian petticoats with removable flounces that use buttons and buttonholes concealed beneath a tuck, but loops might be a bit faster to make. I didn't expect you to use the method you did in the end, but I have seen something similar used historically, again for undergarments. Some combinations had lace beading or eyelets at the waistline so that one could run a ribbon through the corset cover, drawers, and petticoat, connecting and disconnecting them as needed. Very clever!
If you want a trim for the short length that isn't visible on the full length, you might try putting the buttonholes under a pleat above the trim. That way, you can lace the extension in so that it covers the trim for the shorter version. It wouldn't have to be a super deep pleat either - just enough to hide the genius underneath!
This is totally genius! I've already seen the "secret" in one of your recaps or sth, very early in my watching of your content, so no guess from me, but it's a very clever solution. And the skirt looks great both in long version (very elegant and stylish!) and the short one (cute and sort of nicely embelished by the black line of the buttonloop peeking through while it twirls).
I never would have guessed that attachment method! It's genius! I've never heard of buttonhole tape before. Fascinating. I always learn something from your videos. 😊
I've finally, finally got to this video! This is fricking genius! From the glimpse of the flipped up hem in the opening, my guess would have been using ribbon threaded through lace, but this looks even better, much sturdier. Magnets would definitely be too heavy, and I've always hated the reality of zip-off trouser legs because the zips are so stiff. I would absolutely use this to make a modern skirt to suit many occasions - I'm required to attend a fancy dinner a couple of times a year with my mother in law, yet I hate buying or making clothes that will be worn so infrequently. I'm really embracing having fewer items that work flexibly together, and this is a brilliant solution for skirts and trousers, maybe even tunic-to-dress and skirt-to-pinafore. My brain is whirling happily with possibility! Thank you! I've been thinking about this video since it came out, but life exploded a lot and I had no brain for YT. It has absolutely lived up to the months of anticipation! Btw, is there a link to the button loop you used?
I just love when you come out with new videos. You seem like you'd be an absolute blast to have a stich and B*tch party with. Just taught my kids how to make stuffed dolls last week. 😊
My mind is BLOWN. This is genius !! Much more efficient, elegant and quick to convert than the methods I was planning to use for my own convertible skirt. Now I have to get my hands on some buttonhole trim. Or I guess I could also sew vertical buttonholes on the hidden hem of the main skirt and the top edge of the extension, and thread the ribbon through that. Either way, the idea of connecting the two parts with a ribbon, instead of a zipper, velcro, basting stitches, buttons or what have you is really, really clever and surprising !
Adorable skirt, and a genius attachment solution!! I also recommend washing the pieces together, since I've had one piece of a set fade on me. And now I'll tell you honestly, I had to stop the video and crow about that piece of cardboard you taped onto the sewing machine. I have bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome and can't physically keep my fabric straight as I sew. That is one GENIUS idea which is going to make things so much easier for me!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Thank you, and good tip! And if you plan on using the fabric guide a lot, they make magnetic metal ones that you can readjust to various positions… I don’t usually need such a guide, so tape and cardboard work just fine for me, but it’s annoying to reposition, so maybe the metal one would serve you better.
I think the skirt(s) is/are adorable! The white trim was cute, but the lacy flounce is next level. And your idea of the button trim lacing was genius. I couldn't have predicted that you would do that, and I haven't seen it elsewhere. I really appreciate your attention to detail and your careful marking, pinning, and ironing. It makes my little crafty heart happy to see planning and skill go into constructing a garment. Though there's something to be said for "winging it" and "failing upward", it also gives me anxiety to watch folks who fly by the seat of their pants instead of learning how to do something properly. I'm of the opinion that you can (and sometimes should) ignore the rules - but only if you know what they are to begin with.
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoy the channel and the planning/attention to detail... it's exactly how I like my sewing too! Well, most of the time at least. Although as I write this, I'm literally scripting out a video on perfectionism in sewing and how it can absolutely kill one's sew-jo 🤣🤣 so I hesitate to endorse this level of planning and skill for everyone all across the board, because that'd probably just prevent a lot of people from even getting started! But it doesn't get in my way, I really like taking my time and paying attention to the little things!
This turned out so cool from the intro, I thought you had used hook and eye tapes. I was not expecting the cool lace up technique. From the last video, the only thing I could think of was a really long zipper, like those zip up the side pants. Lol. This is much better.
I love how it looks with the extension (you can't tell at all) and your solution is super creative. I do miss the stripes on the shorter version, though. They were so cute.
Ooooh i love the idea! It reminds me of those zip-up convertible outdoors cargo pants/shorts! Perhaps, if you make the daily skirt shorter, you could have two different extensions : the longer one (like here) and then a shorter one with white stripes?
This is brilliant. I have been puzzling over how to do the same thing. Make a skirt with a removable highly embellished “ flounce” or wide hem. The best I had come up with was to essentially make 2 skirts or a plain shorter skirt and essentially a full length petticoat with the embellished hem. I was also planning on using a walking skirt pattern but am now considering this one. (Thoughts?) thank you!
That works well, in the eighties there was a short-lived prairie romantic fashion with an A-line skirt and a petticoat with all the flounce (broderie anglaise) on the petticoat making it ankle length.
Great idea!! There's not too much difference in the walking skirt pattern versus this one... you can see this one flares out when you twirl starting from the bottom of the gores, whereas a walking skirt should flare out starting more from the waist. Some walking skirts are quite volume heavy in the back, whereas this one only has that one small box pleat. They're both great options... this one is maybe a bit more "fit and flare" to use a more modern term!
Ooooh! I did not know that button hole trim was a thing and I now want some I've also recently drafted a walking skirt that I was going to make two different length skirts out of, so this vid has definitely given me some more options to think about.
First time to see the button loops 😂 great idea. I also like the use of the frills, I have some I bought and have not been able to find a use for it 😂. Watch out granddaughter. 😊
Both the short and historical length of the skirt turned out so prettty and flattering, and the lacing system is so clever! If I had the energy and time (and wardrobe space) I'd try to make it right now but, alas, it will have to go to my ever growing sewing projects procrastination list. First I have to finish my Hobbit bodice to go with my hobbit skirt tough... As for the thrifted fabric, a "Sherlock Holmes" cape/coat would look so good with this pattern! And mayber you'd even have enough scraps left to make a matching hat for a compelte Sherlock look.
What a fabulous idea! My daughter still wears dresses, now as shirts, I made for her at 1 year old as an almost 5 year old. You've opened up an entire new world of possibilities for me, thank you!
That's BRILLIANT! I've seen "button-on" swags and other decor on Victorian and Edwardian clothing, but doing the whole hem! It's almost like a "bayaleuse", but not under the train.
I'm guessing zippers! Darn!! That's brilliant!! Way better than zippers! I love the story stick idea as well! I'm with you the material screams cape to me. Oh the last point is a pain for new sewers. I remember in the late 80's patterns had the regular instructions stitch, grade, and overcast or serge the seam. While I was doing the construction I was wishing for a serger! Which I soon for and am still using! I love the skirt and the versatility of the addition. The button tape is really a brilliant solution to the problem of drape. The white trim looked lovely on the main skirt but yeah not so much on the full length.
Yea, I don't know how to get around that last point though, right, because you can't really expect companies (especially the small, individually owned ones) to give a comprehensive list of alternative ways to finish everything off... it'd be SO much work! And especially because Black Snail is kinda all about the historical finishes, they put so much work into telling you how to do it historically; that's kinda their thing. But yea, if you don't want to use those methods, and you are just starting off sewing, you might feel a bit lost on how ELSE to construct the garment! (and yes, I do love my serger... doesn't get that much use, but when I do pull it out, I'm always happy)
I have been actually experimenting with a similar technique, but I like long skirts- so using something similar for adding different kinds of decorative trim.
Brilliant hack with the cardboard guide, I'm gonna use that... I can't sew a straight line on a machine even with stitch lines drawn on the fabric... tape on the machine deck doesn't help but an actual physical edge might! Life's all about the workarounds, and I like making do with what I have. Been thinking about maybe drawstrings in boning channels to hike up a hem like a set of window blinds when I get tired of tripping over it... my in-laws laughed at me this summer when I had to go climb up on something and instead of putting on pants or something sensible, I just grabbed the back hem of my broomstick skirt, brought it up between my legs and crammed it down the waistband to get it all out of my way for a moment... Love how that turned out, but I kind of agree about embellishent, the base layer is a bit plain. Next time, Gadget, next time!!! Cause you know you're going to do it again when you find the right fabric that grabs you and shakes you and points at a pattern and says "TURN ME INTO A THIS!!" That thrifted fabric made me think "pantsuit" before you even said you were all skirted out. Maybe the limited yardage, you could make some vintagey trousers and a cute vest to go with? Ugh, tailoring!!
I love my cardboard guides, but I have to say that if you plan on using them constantly, I might recommend buying (or keeping your eye out in thrift stores for) a magnetic metal one - the magnet makes it reuseable and adjustable a bit more than the cardboard and tape. I don't use the cardboard guides that often, as I am usually pretty good with straight lines, so I don't mind just grabbing scraps (and I do have a metal one around here, I swear, but I've lost it), but like I said, if you plan on making constant use of it, maybe consider a metal one! I've seen plenty in 2nd hand shops!
You could make short extensions to add decoration or embellishment. Love the ingenuity of using the cardboard tools and other finds. Houndstooth fabric would make a great waistcoat or short jacket.
Thank you, and yes, one could definitely make shorter extensions for other aesthetic options! Glad you enjoyed it, and hope you stick around and check out some of the other fun projects on the channel!
I love Ur problem solving ways. By speaking of them asU go I learn + now I just give it a go! For the new brown fabric, I can see U wearing a vest-trouser combo. I really like U in vests! Ciao!
That houndstooth fabric is hard to think of something other than a skirt or cape. #Capetember!! Perhaps a shrug/bolero? Vest or dickie? If a vest or shrug or something on the shoulders I'd love to see a complementary pocket (detachable?) or trim to pull a dark academia outfit together. Spats? Ruffly bracelet/gauntlets?
I always enjoy figuring out new ways to do stuff for myself and then later doing some extensive research and finding, that other people have had the same thought process in the past !!! BTW The Buttonholetrim idea, is something I have found Bourlesque dancers do to make their clothing removable. SO whilst the intention is different, at some point some Bourlesque tailors had a similar problem and needed to do similar research as you did with the same kind of thought process - ugh I love that so much xD
I love your videos and once again I was glued to the tv watching you make this gorgeous skirt. I love the ruffles for the bottom portion. I also thought the white trim was beautiful. I can't decide! Lol! I've learned so much from you. Ty so much for all your tips, tricks, info and advice you give us all the time. BTW... keep making your home improvement videos!. Your dark purple wall is my favorite color!
21:10 Oh i have a pair of leggings that look just like riding pants made from that fabric! Super cute with zipper detailing on the leg and pockets. Mine opens on the back up to the knee, but you can also just have an optional side slit! I mixed in suede to make it more of a riding pant too, totally up to you!
So creative! Just a tidbit - make sure you wash the extension every time you wash the main skirt. Otherwise, you could end up with different shades of fabric.
The houndstooth fabric would make a great riding culottes (split riding skirt). The pattern I have and want to use is Folkwear’s split riding skirt/pants. The historical pattern looks great! If you haven’t seen it, take a look! Field’s Fabrics sells it, as does JoAnn’s online. Love your skirt. Thanks for the video!
Unfortunately I don't have enough yardage, I don't think, and it's not the right drape, but I DO have a split skirt pattern (the one from Black Snail) in the archives already, just waiting for me ot make it one day!
I think this technique was very successful! Not to mention pure genius! This pattern is on my “to-do-sometime” list, but as I wear all my skirts at ankle to toe length I wouldn’t use the extension. I think the outcome of your experiment with this was great as the skirt looks awesome on you at either length.
Oh my gosh this is brilliant! I've had a transformation dress idea in my head for a while now but struggled to know how to create quick-release gathers that turn into just regular full fabric, and threading button loop trim with a ribbon (or cord) is PERFECT for that. (You can get different spacing of button-loop trim, so putting the one with 1/2" spacing onto 1/4" trim would result in 2x gathers.)
Very clever application of the idea, and I'm so intrigued to see the specific garment that you're making... please do share images of the project (in progress and/or finished results)!! I'd love to see them
This is definitely something I will do in the future.... I retire this November so I have many plans and this type of skirt is a perfect addition to them!
Ive actually seen some detachable sleeves done on medieval outfits that have a similar feel to what you did, as far as making the bottom of the short one have some decoration I think Id have made the 'buttonhole' lace style trim as I have seen that on some garments so you could find some that would work for that and give it a slight pop
Thanks for your two video showing this lovely skirt, I did enjoy watching them, I think I need to seriously review my stash box and as I need some new skirts this looks to be just the ticket. (I've just had a the thought of turning up to a fun meeting in the short version, disappearing and then reappearing in the longer version). Just a little tip, when undoing stitching just use the seam ripper for a few stitches. We were taught to take a length of the thread (just enough to get a good grip on) and jerk it sharply in the direction of the sewing, this will pull out some of the stitching, turn to the other side and repeat. When we needed to undo any long bits of stitching we didn't have time for seam rippers or even scissors.
That might work for machine stitching, but it doesn't work for hand stitching, and it definitely doesn't work for hand stitching as small as what I did on my trim 🥲
Love the thought of turning up with one skirt, then reappearing with the other (although I'd be tempted to do the reverse; show up long, then come back with the short)!!
Although it's a slight pain in the tuckus, if you're not going to be wearing the historical extension very often you could just reapply the white trim back onto the base skirt (maybe in a slightly more baste-y manner) and remove it when a more historical look is called for. Not only would that be a good solution for folks who are 90% history bounding with occasional forays into historical dress, it's also historically-accurate-adjacent, as many trims were sewn onto less-frequently-washed exterior garments with the expectation that they would be removed from those garments for the occasional laundering and then sewn back on afterward.
Well I hand sew pretty fast, and that was 4 hours of work… with a bit more baste-y stitches (but not too much, so that the trim is still held flat to the skirt), maybe 2,5-3 hours? Definitely possible, especially since I don’t plan on wearing the extension hardly ever (introvert who lives in Canada without any events to go to😂), but there are people in the comments questioning -politely- if even the 10 mins to lace on the extension is worth it!! Very valid point, tho, about it being a historical practice… reminds me how much we’re all so used to speed and efficiency, and how good we really have it, in ways we don’t even think about often!
I just watched this video and I love the concept. But my thought was why not use snap tape. FIY It is what parents put on clothing pants or onsees that provides a quick way to change a diaper. I recently used the metal snaps on twill tape to easily remove a 4.5 foot pillowcase for washing and replacing it. For this skirt I would have used the plastic snap tape like the ones for babies.
I didn't use it because 1) if I stepped on my hem, I'd risk part of it unsnapping (hi, I can be both quite clumsy and adventurous🤣), 2) I feel like it's heavier than button loop trim, 3) it might be stiffer and therefore affect the drape more? probably depends on what brand --like the button loops-- and that some are softer than others, and 4) I just personally don't love doing up lots of snaps. BUT I do think that, if button loop trim wasn't a thing, that snap tape might be my second pick!
That material would make a gorgeous fitted vicotian jacket with slightly puffed sleeve heads and a bit of a pleated peplumb for the back. Some fun brass vintage style buttons would go amazingly with those warm earthy colors as well! So enjoy the videos, have a great day!
Can you make a tutorial on how to thread the two pieces together?! I have a convertible dress with snaps to add sleeves and length and this loop ribbon seems like a much better option for me.
Its so easy that it doesn't need a tutorial. You can see how it went together at 12:06 (and you can see how it comes apart in the reveal, which is literally the reverse of how it goes together). You alternate the loops between the top and bottom of the skirt, and thread a ribbon through. I used a giant needle, you could use a safety pin.... whatever works!
You could actually add on the white stripes above the ruffles and above the pleating and I think it would actually blend the layers together really well. Kind of like the pinstripe around the hems of some Victorian skirts.
@@ShannonMakes I was starting to dig the stripes before but I think mixed with the tulle it'll actually be balanced out more than before but I could be wrong.
Another fabulous project with lots of clever techniques and work arounds! Like you, I was sad to see the white trim come off the shirt skirt because I truly thought it looked fabulous. At the same time, I totally agree that it just didn’t look right with the extension. All that beautiful hand stitching shot to hell though; what a shame. 😔
Well fortunately I adore that type of mindless hand stitching, so it was a pleasure to do (the original sewing, not the taking off)! It's a bit like knitting, which... I've been known to sit down and just knit. Not knit anything, specifically, just knit to knit (while watching TV) and then frog it and just start knitting again. That was clearly before I had a TH-cam channel, and I had much more free time on my hands 🤣🤣
I love this. I am always looking for different types of clothes binding since I'm not a fan of some of the common types for various reasons. I would definitely keep a crafting needle (the dull kind with big eye) with the extension piece to make the lacing process faster.
I dint wrote my guess down because I saw your solution in the intro (didnt know it was button loop trim, but thought some lace with loops though...) but I would never have guessed THAT solution! Its genius. Nothing I plan on trying my self in near future because I like my skirts long, but Im sure its good to know a solution like this exists! Sad you had to remove the trim, but I totally understand your reasoning and I agree. maybe you could make detachable trim with magnets? (im joking!)
Liking one's skirts long does definitely eliminate the need for this technique (although some people have talked about using it for summer vs winter lengths for when it's warmer/cooler out, or on sleeves... might be too heavy for sleeves, but I'd love to see it tried)!!
So the button lace that you used reminded me of a zipper method which I could of seen being a good way of attaching the bottom, (or using snaps if you were not leaning to historical). As for that fabric, I would love to see some sort of shrug or shoulder cloak with it. Nothing to fancy, but still in your historical feel.
So the reason I didn't use a zipper was that they're so stiff that it would have really affected the hemline and the drape, which I didn't want. But if you didn't mind that, or if you wanted to stiffen the hem up, that could be a great option!
Downright brilliant thinking 🎉 Love it when a plan come together. ❤ I made a similar trim with ⅛” ribbon for "corset" tie loops, a borrowed, wear-it-once prom dress that would not close on a slightly larger girl. I sewed on 3 x 5" cards for accurate spacing, just folding ribbon back and forth in front of the needle. Using silk thread to attach it, the original garment was completely unaltered when the trim was pulled out.
This is such a cool solution! Hopefully you can make another skirt with the white trim since it did look so good on the midi skirt! I appreciate that you take the time to get your project done well! ❤🎉❤
That's such a creative way of attaching the bottom of the skirt! I would never thought of that, and it's genius! About the fabric, I see it as 40s style jacket, I had something similar but made in 90s (in 40s cut) and it was very versatile garment, perfect for autumn.
Thank you! 😊I already have plans for a 40s style Eisenhower jacket, but lots of ppl have been suggesting jacket with a peplum, so that could be looked into!!
@@ShannonMakes It could look good with peplum, however, I think this fabric would be also cool as Eisenhower jacket! Maybe even with contrasting collar?
I am thinking "Velcro." Velcro could make your skirt stiff (not drape the way you want). However, Velcro might keep the hem from being torn loose from the bottom of the skirt (or keep the skirt from being torn loose from the waistband). My long 1950's skirts were damaged a lot on the playground and in the classrooms (I worm them patched back to school).
I love it. I think your technique for attaching the bottom ruffle is genius. I think I want to make this skirt, but I may try adding a row of skinny trim above each ruffle to see how it looks. I only found your channel 2 days ago, and have watched 6-7 videos. I really enjoy your creativity!
Thank you! So glad you're enjoying all the videos, thank you for taking the time to check out the archives - there truly are some really fun projects in there!
this is brilliant brilliant brilliant omg ❤ i might try this because I have project it would be perfect for!! (floor length fantasy bell sleeves xD) and leave a bodkin permanently at end of the ribbon with a little pocket for it in the extension piece? I am?? pretty excited??? I was considering snaps, or hooks and eyes but I already actually have some loop tape HECK yeah
If the pattern pieces have notches on them, they are there to match up pieces. If you want to cut off the notches, just chalk them onto the seam allowance, then you match single notch to single notch, double to double....
I am... well aware of what notches are, I've been sewing for decades. I'm a little confused where this comment is coming from, as I didn't mention notches in the video, to my recollection?
Love your creativity! I never saw your solution before. I like the simplicity and light weight of it, also easy in the wash. I'm tall and clothes seem to get shorter every year. I could switch back and forth as I like! Thank you for the idea!
As much as I absolutely can't relate with the idea of being tall, or clothing being too short (I'm constantly treading on and wearing out my pants' hems), I'm glad that you see the application for this in your life, and I hope you use it!!
Yes, would LOVE the baker boy hat... and of course the trousers/knickerbockers! I'm not sure it has the right drape for trousers, though... feels quite stiff. Shall investigate!
The result is amazing! You did a fantastic job, and I can't even imagine the annoyance of having to remove the trim. Still, I was looking at the final result, and I think that you still might be able to add the white trim, as you did before, and then add a thinner one at the bottom of the extension, maybe? Whatever you do, I'm sure the end result will look amazing anyway ❤
I dunno, I spent well over an hour playing with options, spread out across a couple days to give distance/perspective, and at that point, I had to throw up my hands and accept that I personally didn't like any options that I found... maybe one day I'll go back and rethink about it, but if I'm honest... probably not, lol!
@@ShannonMakes that's fair! It still looks great and you did an amazing job ❤️ thanks for sharing all these videos, they are really fun and informative to watch 😊
I live the rip-cord button loop and ribbon. I've used a similar- but not exactly the same- technique for a corset that needed to be removed very quickly. I laced a spiral through each side of the corset grommets, staggered that loop, and used a zip tie down the center so it could be yanked out with ease.
📣ALL RIGHT, FOLKS! Guesses go here! How am I going to do it⁉
Button loops?
Edit: yesss! But two lines and a ribbon is genius!
Quick change lacing?
ETA: I'm surprised you came up with this idea without having seen it first. It gets used by costumers who need to be able to quickly remove an outer garment to display an inner one for a quick costume change, like a truly invisible (and much faster) zip
Did you use a separating zipper? 😊
Snaps
I was going to say zipper
I highly recommend that any time you wash the shorter skirt, you toss the extension in, too, so they fade equally. Any time I split up a blouse/skirt in wearing, I now wash both. Long ago I had a set and after 4 years, the difference made it impossible to wear them together.
Great tip! I would NEVER have thought of that, but it makes total sense now that you pointed it out!
I came here to say this! Ah the Voice of Experience! Well done.
Great advice! I learned this lesson the hard way with my husband’s zip-off golf pants! 🙄😜🤣
Especially with blue dyes, they tend to fade faster in my experience.
As someone who struggles a lot with impulse shopping things when I have a perceived need, I really appreciate seeing the creative ways you use materials! For example, a piece of cardboard for a seam guide, or some card stock for a seam ruler. I hope you'll forgive me saying, because I mean this in the most genuine and heartfelt way, but seeing that you can get the incredible results you get while incorporating literal garbage into the process makes me feel a LOT more comfortable about moving beyond the incessant urge to have every perfect tool for every situation. Y'know? (Also really neat project, thanks for sharing!)
Absolutely! We do NOT need 90% of what companies try to sell us. What was the mantra from the Great Depression? Something like use it up, wear it out, and make do? Shannon definitely Makes do. 😂
Thank you, this comment has made me SO happy!! The thought that I can have this effect on even ONE person out there through my channel makes it all worth it!
I was apparently just *born* thrifty, and the concept of impulse shopping is simply not something that occurs to me (I say this without judgement, just as a description of myself) it comes quite naturally to me to look around and see what I can use that I already have. That, plus I'm cheap, lazy, and impatient - if I don't have to spend money, leave my house, or delay the project to get something new when I can use a substitute, that's 100% what I'll do 🤣. And it's just a bonus side effect that it's good for the planet (although I do think I have some "eco-anxiety" too).
@@DawnDavidson "Use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without."
I would try to make trousers and a waistcoat from that lovely brownish plaid/check fabric. If I didn't have enough fabric for both items, I'd make the trousers wide leg.
oooh, lovely indeed!
This is exactly what I was going to say.
I was going to suggest a waistcoat 😊
Walking skirt and fitted waist coat.
The thrift shop hounds tooth/plaid would make a gorgeous long fitted vest - especially with a contrasting shawl collar.
wowza! yes!
I'd do a burn test on the fibres as I'm thinking it's wool. I had similar and had made a skirt in the 80s so I was interested to hear what others would make. 😊
I was thinking that as well, with a flat cap.
The final effect is stunning! It definitely isn't quick to lace up, but as long as you aren't on a runway attempting to mimic a quick change dress, it probably isn't much of an issue. I can actually think of lots of reasons to want a shirt like this (or even a pair of capris or shorts). For starters, it could be an easy way to convert day wear to night wear and reduce packing weight on trips, or just reduce the clothing load / change up your clothing.
No, for me at least, it's not an issue because I've attended a historical event roughly 0 times in my life, and will be lucky to attend even a few in my lifetime, so I don't mind doing the extension for those limited events! Would I want to do it every day? No, but even if it was once a season, to go from summer skirt to winter skirt, let's say, that'd be totally fine!
Love those "I woke up this morning and remembered" moments! Proves our brain is working even when we're asleep.
What a brilliant concept to extend a skirt! I would use this to make non-history bounding skirt more versatile too!
True!!
Having to unpick any seam sucks, but having to unpick hand sewn seams really sucks. Its a shame the trim situation didn't work out as originally planned but the floof trim does suit the time period better. A very ingenious way to transform the two!
Thank you 🤗!! Must be quite late for you, I feel like you're normally a Saturday morning viewer (in my time zone, I mean)!
@@ShannonMakes usually sat morning yes but it popped up and I watched. It was around 11pm ish I think.
The skirt is so pretty! I'd have used a separating zipper (or a series of them since you probably can't get one long enough for a hem) or carefully spaced out snaps/poppers. Because I've never heard of button loop trim it wouldn't have ever occurred to me that there was an "easy" lace up option. Or that one could lace up something horizontally at all, to be honest.
Thank you! Unfortunately, a zipper would affect the drape of the skirt pretty significantly, and could be great if you wanted a bit stiffer of a hemline, but since I love the flowy, drape-y look, wasn't going to be a great option for me in this case!
@@ShannonMakes sorry i didnt mean to imply that you should have used a zipper, just that that is what would have come to my mind if I wanted to make a convertible skirt.
Oh yea, sorry, I didn't mean to come off as defensive in my comment either, I was just ruminating on the option/explaining why I didn't choose it! 🫶💙
@@ShannonMakes ha, I'm so so sorry. I don't want to offend anyone by accident (only on purpose 🤣). Sometimes I find it difficult to express the correct tone through writing. I meant to convey that I thought it was a very creative solution and that, self disparaging, I'd only have thought of a more pedestrian option. And now I'm the most annoying person on the internet.🤦♀️
@nataliestanchevski4628 Nope. Not the most annoying. That's reserved for people who insist that we are quite daft and they are very rude about it.
When we communicate, there is inflection caused by pitch up or down, volume, and body language. 🤔 Emojis sometimes help. For instance, a glimpse of the things I like.🕊🫖🐈⬛📚🦋🥧☕️🌧🌹💞🐑🦌
Blessings on all your endeavors, including communication!🖖🤝
I am really impressed with the amount of work that went into this skirt, especially since you had to remove the trim. Your button loop trim solution is genius, and the resulting skirt is gorgeous!
Thank you so much!!
I would use this gorgeous brown plaid to make a split skirt and waitcoat combo! I know you said enough skirts for now but its not technically a skirt, its secret pants!! :p Also taking note of you great idea of transformable skirt. The "waste" of fabric is the main thing holding me back in making fully historical clothes but this is an awesome compromise!
Yup, it's a lot of resources (time is a resource too) going to something that will hardly ever be worn, right?! This does help alleviate that feeling though, at least for me!!
I haven’t seen the button loop tape, but that’s a genius idea! I’m hoping to make a linen short-sleeve shirt, but be able to attach full sleeves if I want to wear it later in the year or want the additional sun protection, but I wasn’t sure If buttons would create sagging between them or require so many to be tedious. I even considered plastic snaps, but worry about pulling them apart on a lighter weight fabric.
I don't know how much this would affect your sleeves - if its a lighter weight fabric, it'd definitely add some weight onto the ends of your short sleeves (although less circumference, so less weight than on my hem)... definitely worth a shot, for sure!
I would have tried hook and eye tape, but the button loops make for a much softer finish than either hook and eye or snap tape. The only qualm I have is that white loops would have been a better choice because they would be less visible if you are are not wearing the extension but sitting so that the inside of the hem shows.
Agreed white might be less visible, but I really don’t mind the black. If I could wave a wand, tho, and turn it white… I probably would 🤣🤣
Wow, this is awesome! Never would've guessed this is how it could be done. If the button loop was in white it wohld look just like it was planned
for growing girls who want to history bound this is a GREAT idea!!
Thank you 🥰♥️
Very clever! As for that houndstooth fabric, I can't shake the image of a cape with leather or leather-look trim and toggle closure. A warm lining would make it a practical garment for fall/winter. Can't wait to see what you decide to make!
I had a similar thought, with a kinda lady Sherlock cape?
If you want the base skirt to have some pizazz, you can add lace trim to the underside of the seam that hangs down over where the extention would go.
The only caveat is that it might be itchy, since it would be on the inside of the skirt when you have the extention.
I would have sewn on loops instead of the black stuff, maybe with ribbons so it looks like a trim detail, or hidden fabric loops under the seam of the hem.
It is a beautiful skirt, and looks fun to make!
It would have taken SO long to sew on loops individually though! I'm glad this stuff comes on a roll, so I can just run one line of stitches to hold all the loops on! 🤣🪡
Oh. Cool! That will work for turning my summer shirt into my fall shirts. Sleeves.
This kind of thing is would also be for the winter, when you need to choose between insulation and wind blocking (while looking fabulous in an ankle length skirt) or keeping your skirt out of the mire. and wool skirts are always more expensive than any other kind, so saving money.
Alternatives.
Edging lace, ribbon insert lace, and eyelet hole trim.
Also might work for.
Attaching a bodice and skirts for a dress.
Detachable collars.
And cuffs.
Those shirt tail (micro skirt thing) for wearing under sweaters. Just with no elastic.
Changing out your sleeves, or reversible sleeves, Medieval style.
Those ball gowns that look like a cocktail dress with a fishtail of tool flounce coming out from under the knees. Making it for All occasions.
Removable quilted liner for a cape.
A flounce for your cape.
Extra length for your hooded mantle.
Flounce.
I can't think of anything more.
Fantastic and nearly exhaustive list of options, I love it!!
I think the laces would not be strong enough for some options.
@anjabeyer3812 having worked with them, I don't see anything here that my lace set-up wouldn't be able to handle. Obviously there are always exceptions, like maybe if your cape is full floor length and you don't sew the button loops in properly enough, then yea, but if it's like an elbow length one, or even maybe waist length, I don't think it'd be a problem.
@@ShannonMakes I was thinking a dramatic silky train coming out the back of a short mantle, or out of the ventilation panel on the upper back of a jacket.
It could probably even be used with wedding dresses. You know how they like the massive train for the wedding, but then button it up somehow for the reception.
There. I thought of another thing.
@@ShannonMakes what can I say, you get me thinking.
Brilliant! Convertible clothing is my newest passion and I’m so glad you can read my mind 😃
LOVE that!! Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching 💙💙
I am 100% going to use this button loop idea for removeable sections! My wardrobe is about 60% handmade and I'm looking to increase that percentage but I've been debating for months how to make separating pieces because I always want to wear pieces year round in a very changeable climate. This will be amazing for extending skirts like you did, extendable sleeves (The button on method didn't really work for me) making dresses/pinafores that can be skirts, or trousers into dungarees! I'm super excited to give this a try, thank you for sharing your processes with us!
Oooh, that's fantastic! Please feel free to share photos of the garments with me if you do end up using this technique, I'd love to see!
This is such a goid idea, i would totally use it for skirts with the long version for winter and the shorter one for summer. I sow a lot in leggings coz thats what i mostly wear beneath my skirts 😊
Thank you! Seasonal skirts for the win!
if you really miss the white stripes, you could add a thick white band to the tuck above the middle ruffle, and then thick bands on the hem of the shorter skirt, and on the extension. so the shortened skirt would end with a white band on the hem, then when you add the extension, there'd be 3 bands total. i'd hold them up about 3-5mm or so from the fold of the tuck/hem, just so it looks more like a design than an afterthought, and then it would also cover the machine stitching if you feel like you want/need to do so.
I saw a pair of tricot under-pants, effectively Capri leggings, to wear under wool pants in a course I took back in the '80s. It not only keeps itchy wool off your legs, it helps preserve the fabric from body moisture, etc. It's effectively washable lining for every pair of wool pants, no fuss no muss.
I was thinking you might use buttons and loops. I've seen early Edwardian petticoats with removable flounces that use buttons and buttonholes concealed beneath a tuck, but loops might be a bit faster to make.
I didn't expect you to use the method you did in the end, but I have seen something similar used historically, again for undergarments. Some combinations had lace beading or eyelets at the waistline so that one could run a ribbon through the corset cover, drawers, and petticoat, connecting and disconnecting them as needed. Very clever!
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for the tidbit about the historical precedent!
If you want a trim for the short length that isn't visible on the full length, you might try putting the buttonholes under a pleat above the trim. That way, you can lace the extension in so that it covers the trim for the shorter version. It wouldn't have to be a super deep pleat either - just enough to hide the genius underneath!
nice!! thank you! 😊
This is totally genius! I've already seen the "secret" in one of your recaps or sth, very early in my watching of your content, so no guess from me, but it's a very clever solution.
And the skirt looks great both in long version (very elegant and stylish!) and the short one (cute and sort of nicely embelished by the black line of the buttonloop peeking through while it twirls).
I never would have guessed that attachment method! It's genius! I've never heard of buttonhole tape before. Fascinating. I always learn something from your videos. 😊
Thank you! And it's button loop trim, just in case you even need to order/search for it!
I've finally, finally got to this video! This is fricking genius! From the glimpse of the flipped up hem in the opening, my guess would have been using ribbon threaded through lace, but this looks even better, much sturdier. Magnets would definitely be too heavy, and I've always hated the reality of zip-off trouser legs because the zips are so stiff. I would absolutely use this to make a modern skirt to suit many occasions - I'm required to attend a fancy dinner a couple of times a year with my mother in law, yet I hate buying or making clothes that will be worn so infrequently. I'm really embracing having fewer items that work flexibly together, and this is a brilliant solution for skirts and trousers, maybe even tunic-to-dress and skirt-to-pinafore. My brain is whirling happily with possibility! Thank you!
I've been thinking about this video since it came out, but life exploded a lot and I had no brain for YT. It has absolutely lived up to the months of anticipation!
Btw, is there a link to the button loop you used?
I just love when you come out with new videos. You seem like you'd be an absolute blast to have a stich and B*tch party with. Just taught my kids how to make stuffed dolls last week. 😊
awww, thank you!!! Congrats on passing the skill on to your kids!
using the button eye tape and ribbon is such a genius idea!
Thank you!! 💙💙
Very clever! I like the ruffles more than the white stripe, but that’s just a personal preference. Well done!
Thank you! 😊 And fair enough, everyone's aesthetics are different! 💙
"one historically adequate garment" - you're speaking my language! Very interesting video, thank you.
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching!
My mind is BLOWN. This is genius !! Much more efficient, elegant and quick to convert than the methods I was planning to use for my own convertible skirt. Now I have to get my hands on some buttonhole trim. Or I guess I could also sew vertical buttonholes on the hidden hem of the main skirt and the top edge of the extension, and thread the ribbon through that. Either way, the idea of connecting the two parts with a ribbon, instead of a zipper, velcro, basting stitches, buttons or what have you is really, really clever and surprising !
Thank you!!! Glad you enjoyed it
@@ShannonMakes yeah, you're probably right :)
Adorable skirt, and a genius attachment solution!! I also recommend washing the pieces together, since I've had one piece of a set fade on me. And now I'll tell you honestly, I had to stop the video and crow about that piece of cardboard you taped onto the sewing machine. I have bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome and can't physically keep my fabric straight as I sew. That is one GENIUS idea which is going to make things so much easier for me!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Thank you, and good tip! And if you plan on using the fabric guide a lot, they make magnetic metal ones that you can readjust to various positions… I don’t usually need such a guide, so tape and cardboard work just fine for me, but it’s annoying to reposition, so maybe the metal one would serve you better.
I would never have guessed in a squillion years!! LOVE it! Now I'm think-thinking about how/where to use the technique in my projects!
Ahhh love that!! If you DO use it in your sewing, please please share it with me!!
That scissor snipping sound is soo satisfying.
I think the skirt(s) is/are adorable! The white trim was cute, but the lacy flounce is next level. And your idea of the button trim lacing was genius. I couldn't have predicted that you would do that, and I haven't seen it elsewhere. I really appreciate your attention to detail and your careful marking, pinning, and ironing. It makes my little crafty heart happy to see planning and skill go into constructing a garment. Though there's something to be said for "winging it" and "failing upward", it also gives me anxiety to watch folks who fly by the seat of their pants instead of learning how to do something properly. I'm of the opinion that you can (and sometimes should) ignore the rules - but only if you know what they are to begin with.
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoy the channel and the planning/attention to detail... it's exactly how I like my sewing too! Well, most of the time at least. Although as I write this, I'm literally scripting out a video on perfectionism in sewing and how it can absolutely kill one's sew-jo 🤣🤣 so I hesitate to endorse this level of planning and skill for everyone all across the board, because that'd probably just prevent a lot of people from even getting started! But it doesn't get in my way, I really like taking my time and paying attention to the little things!
This turned out so cool from the intro, I thought you had used hook and eye tapes. I was not expecting the cool lace up technique. From the last video, the only thing I could think of was a really long zipper, like those zip up the side pants. Lol. This is much better.
Thank you!! Glad you enjoyed the surprise!!
I love how it looks with the extension (you can't tell at all) and your solution is super creative. I do miss the stripes on the shorter version, though. They were so cute.
Thank you so much!! Totally agree about the stripes tho!
Ooooh i love the idea! It reminds me of those zip-up convertible outdoors cargo pants/shorts!
Perhaps, if you make the daily skirt shorter, you could have two different extensions : the longer one (like here) and then a shorter one with white stripes?
True, true... interesting solution!
This is brilliant. I have been puzzling over how to do the same thing. Make a skirt with a removable highly embellished “ flounce” or wide hem. The best I had come up with was to essentially make 2 skirts or a plain shorter skirt and essentially a full length petticoat with the embellished hem. I was also planning on using a walking skirt pattern but am now considering this one. (Thoughts?) thank you!
I like this idea, too! And it would be great in winter to add that extra petticoat layer. Shorter skirt in summer, longer skirt extension for winter.
That works well, in the eighties there was a short-lived prairie romantic fashion with an A-line skirt and a petticoat with all the flounce (broderie anglaise) on the petticoat making it ankle length.
Great idea!! There's not too much difference in the walking skirt pattern versus this one... you can see this one flares out when you twirl starting from the bottom of the gores, whereas a walking skirt should flare out starting more from the waist. Some walking skirts are quite volume heavy in the back, whereas this one only has that one small box pleat. They're both great options... this one is maybe a bit more "fit and flare" to use a more modern term!
Ooooh! I did not know that button hole trim was a thing and I now want some
I've also recently drafted a walking skirt that I was going to make two different length skirts out of, so this vid has definitely given me some more options to think about.
You are so welcome! If you do use the technique, I'd love to see the results, please share them with me!!!
First time to see the button loops 😂 great idea. I also like the use of the frills, I have some I bought and have not been able to find a use for it 😂. Watch out granddaughter. 😊
LOLLL watch out, here come the frills!!
Both the short and historical length of the skirt turned out so prettty and flattering, and the lacing system is so clever! If I had the energy and time (and wardrobe space) I'd try to make it right now but, alas, it will have to go to my ever growing sewing projects procrastination list. First I have to finish my Hobbit bodice to go with my hobbit skirt tough...
As for the thrifted fabric, a "Sherlock Holmes" cape/coat would look so good with this pattern! And mayber you'd even have enough scraps left to make a matching hat for a compelte Sherlock look.
"sewing projects procrastination list" ....love that!
Re: Sherlock... so you're saying I can/should finally match my dog?! 🐶🕵️♀️
What a fabulous idea! My daughter still wears dresses, now as shirts, I made for her at 1 year old as an almost 5 year old. You've opened up an entire new world of possibilities for me, thank you!
You're very welcome!
That's BRILLIANT!
I've seen "button-on" swags and other decor on Victorian and Edwardian clothing, but doing the whole hem!
It's almost like a "bayaleuse", but not under the train.
I'm guessing zippers!
Darn!! That's brilliant!! Way better than zippers!
I love the story stick idea as well! I'm with you the material screams cape to me. Oh the last point is a pain for new sewers. I remember in the late 80's patterns had the regular instructions stitch, grade, and overcast or serge the seam. While I was doing the construction I was wishing for a serger! Which I soon for and am still using!
I love the skirt and the versatility of the addition. The button tape is really a brilliant solution to the problem of drape. The white trim looked lovely on the main skirt but yeah not so much on the full length.
Yea, I don't know how to get around that last point though, right, because you can't really expect companies (especially the small, individually owned ones) to give a comprehensive list of alternative ways to finish everything off... it'd be SO much work! And especially because Black Snail is kinda all about the historical finishes, they put so much work into telling you how to do it historically; that's kinda their thing. But yea, if you don't want to use those methods, and you are just starting off sewing, you might feel a bit lost on how ELSE to construct the garment! (and yes, I do love my serger... doesn't get that much use, but when I do pull it out, I'm always happy)
I have been actually experimenting with a similar technique, but I like long skirts- so using something similar for adding different kinds of decorative trim.
Love that!
I like that idea too as a way to change up the look of let say a plain black skirt
Brilliant hack with the cardboard guide, I'm gonna use that... I can't sew a straight line on a machine even with stitch lines drawn on the fabric... tape on the machine deck doesn't help but an actual physical edge might! Life's all about the workarounds, and I like making do with what I have.
Been thinking about maybe drawstrings in boning channels to hike up a hem like a set of window blinds when I get tired of tripping over it... my in-laws laughed at me this summer when I had to go climb up on something and instead of putting on pants or something sensible, I just grabbed the back hem of my broomstick skirt, brought it up between my legs and crammed it down the waistband to get it all out of my way for a moment... Love how that turned out, but I kind of agree about embellishent, the base layer is a bit plain. Next time, Gadget, next time!!! Cause you know you're going to do it again when you find the right fabric that grabs you and shakes you and points at a pattern and says "TURN ME INTO A THIS!!"
That thrifted fabric made me think "pantsuit" before you even said you were all skirted out. Maybe the limited yardage, you could make some vintagey trousers and a cute vest to go with? Ugh, tailoring!!
I love my cardboard guides, but I have to say that if you plan on using them constantly, I might recommend buying (or keeping your eye out in thrift stores for) a magnetic metal one - the magnet makes it reuseable and adjustable a bit more than the cardboard and tape.
I don't use the cardboard guides that often, as I am usually pretty good with straight lines, so I don't mind just grabbing scraps (and I do have a metal one around here, I swear, but I've lost it), but like I said, if you plan on making constant use of it, maybe consider a metal one! I've seen plenty in 2nd hand shops!
You could make short extensions to add decoration or embellishment. Love the ingenuity of using the cardboard tools and other finds. Houndstooth fabric would make a great waistcoat or short jacket.
Thank you, and yes, one could definitely make shorter extensions for other aesthetic options! Glad you enjoyed it, and hope you stick around and check out some of the other fun projects on the channel!
Idea for your new fabric: jacket, shortish, maybe with some styling like the corset hoodie, but not identical.
love that!
I love Ur problem solving ways. By speaking of them asU go I learn + now I just give it a go! For the new brown fabric, I can see U wearing a vest-trouser combo. I really like U in vests! Ciao!
Love that! So glad to hear you enjoy the videos and you learn things and feel inspired to just try it all out... that's PERFECT!!
That houndstooth fabric is hard to think of something other than a skirt or cape. #Capetember!! Perhaps a shrug/bolero? Vest or dickie? If a vest or shrug or something on the shoulders I'd love to see a complementary pocket (detachable?) or trim to pull a dark academia outfit together. Spats? Ruffly bracelet/gauntlets?
It's definitely giving dark academia vibes!! 💯
I always enjoy figuring out new ways to do stuff for myself and then later doing some extensive research and finding, that other people have had the same thought process in the past !!!
BTW The Buttonholetrim idea, is something I have found Bourlesque dancers do to make their clothing removable. SO whilst the intention is different, at some point some Bourlesque tailors had a similar problem and needed to do similar research as you did with the same kind of thought process - ugh I love that so much xD
Love that, thanks for sharing!
I love your videos and once again I was glued to the tv watching you make this gorgeous skirt. I love the ruffles for the bottom portion. I also thought the white trim was beautiful. I can't decide! Lol! I've learned so much from you. Ty so much for all your tips, tricks, info and advice you give us all the time.
BTW... keep making your home improvement videos!. Your dark purple wall is my favorite color!
You are so welcome!
21:10 Oh i have a pair of leggings that look just like riding pants made from that fabric! Super cute with zipper detailing on the leg and pockets. Mine opens on the back up to the knee, but you can also just have an optional side slit! I mixed in suede to make it more of a riding pant too, totally up to you!
Love that! Lots of people want some sort of pants, and I love that!!
So creative! Just a tidbit - make sure you wash the extension every time you wash the main skirt. Otherwise, you could end up with different shades of fabric.
Thank you! That's a great point!
The houndstooth fabric would make a great riding culottes (split riding skirt). The pattern I have and want to use is Folkwear’s split riding skirt/pants. The historical pattern looks great! If you haven’t seen it, take a look! Field’s Fabrics sells it, as does JoAnn’s online. Love your skirt. Thanks for the video!
Unfortunately I don't have enough yardage, I don't think, and it's not the right drape, but I DO have a split skirt pattern (the one from Black Snail) in the archives already, just waiting for me ot make it one day!
I think this technique was very successful! Not to mention pure genius! This pattern is on my “to-do-sometime” list, but as I wear all my skirts at ankle to toe length I wouldn’t use the extension. I think the outcome of your experiment with this was great as the skirt looks awesome on you at either length.
Thank you!! ☺️
Oh my gosh this is brilliant! I've had a transformation dress idea in my head for a while now but struggled to know how to create quick-release gathers that turn into just regular full fabric, and threading button loop trim with a ribbon (or cord) is PERFECT for that. (You can get different spacing of button-loop trim, so putting the one with 1/2" spacing onto 1/4" trim would result in 2x gathers.)
Very clever application of the idea, and I'm so intrigued to see the specific garment that you're making... please do share images of the project (in progress and/or finished results)!! I'd love to see them
For that new fabric, some wide legged, pleated pants would be [chef's kiss] I think!
21:04 How about a vest with a newsboy cap set. I love Newsboy caps in the autumn. :D
SO true! (I don't look great in caps, but that doesn't stop me from wearing them!)
This is definitely something I will do in the future.... I retire this November so I have many plans and this type of skirt is a perfect addition to them!
Love that! I would love to see photos of the projects you use this technique on, if you're into sharing... and happy retirement!!
The plaid is definitely giving Sherlock vibes so a cape (maybe with matching hat?) there’s also some potential to make a cape that is also a skirt
So I can finally match my dog!! 🕵️♀️
Absolutely clever idea to use the button loops to achieve the results you were going for! I love the skirt in both lengths.
Thanks so much! 😊
Ive actually seen some detachable sleeves done on medieval outfits that have a similar feel to what you did, as far as making the bottom of the short one have some decoration I think Id have made the 'buttonhole' lace style trim as I have seen that on some garments so you could find some that would work for that and give it a slight pop
The technique was used in the 30/40s in some lingerie patterns, to connect the camisole to the knickers, to cut back on bulk right at the waist.
That's very neat to know! Thanks!
Thanks for your two video showing this lovely skirt, I did enjoy watching them, I think I need to seriously review my stash box and as I need some new skirts this looks to be just the ticket. (I've just had a the thought of turning up to a fun meeting in the short version, disappearing and then reappearing in the longer version). Just a little tip, when undoing stitching just use the seam ripper for a few stitches. We were taught to take a length of the thread (just enough to get a good grip on) and jerk it sharply in the direction of the sewing, this will pull out some of the stitching, turn to the other side and repeat. When we needed to undo any long bits of stitching we didn't have time for seam rippers or even scissors.
That might work for machine stitching, but it doesn't work for hand stitching, and it definitely doesn't work for hand stitching as small as what I did on my trim 🥲
Love the thought of turning up with one skirt, then reappearing with the other (although I'd be tempted to do the reverse; show up long, then come back with the short)!!
Wow! What an effort for a skirt, but so pretty. I have never seen or heard of your fastening meathod. So clever!
Thank you so much!
I've actually been considering using this kind of trim for corset type closures on dresses because I'm scared of grommets xd
You can also just use a buttonhole strip like I did on my 1890s Sports Corset (video in my catalogue if desired)!
Although it's a slight pain in the tuckus, if you're not going to be wearing the historical extension very often you could just reapply the white trim back onto the base skirt (maybe in a slightly more baste-y manner) and remove it when a more historical look is called for. Not only would that be a good solution for folks who are 90% history bounding with occasional forays into historical dress, it's also historically-accurate-adjacent, as many trims were sewn onto less-frequently-washed exterior garments with the expectation that they would be removed from those garments for the occasional laundering and then sewn back on afterward.
Well I hand sew pretty fast, and that was 4 hours of work… with a bit more baste-y stitches (but not too much, so that the trim is still held flat to the skirt), maybe 2,5-3 hours?
Definitely possible, especially since I don’t plan on wearing the extension hardly ever (introvert who lives in Canada without any events to go to😂), but there are people in the comments questioning -politely- if even the 10 mins to lace on the extension is worth it!!
Very valid point, tho, about it being a historical practice… reminds me how much we’re all so used to speed and efficiency, and how good we really have it, in ways we don’t even think about often!
I just watched this video and I love the concept. But my thought was why not use snap tape. FIY It is what parents put on clothing pants or onsees that provides a quick way to change a diaper. I recently used the metal snaps on twill tape to easily remove a 4.5 foot pillowcase for washing and replacing it. For this skirt I would have used the plastic snap tape like the ones for babies.
I didn't use it because 1) if I stepped on my hem, I'd risk part of it unsnapping (hi, I can be both quite clumsy and adventurous🤣), 2) I feel like it's heavier than button loop trim, 3) it might be stiffer and therefore affect the drape more? probably depends on what brand --like the button loops-- and that some are softer than others, and 4) I just personally don't love doing up lots of snaps.
BUT I do think that, if button loop trim wasn't a thing, that snap tape might be my second pick!
The concept is brilliant and I think the skirt turned out beautifully!
Thank you!! I was quite happy with the final results 🥰🥰
Waistcoat with mushrooms embroidered onto them. Perfect for autumn.
Sounds very similar to my cape from last CAPEtember!!
That material would make a gorgeous fitted vicotian jacket with slightly puffed sleeve heads and a bit of a pleated peplumb for the back. Some fun brass vintage style buttons would go amazingly with those warm earthy colors as well! So enjoy the videos, have a great day!
Oooh yes, love the brass button idea! Good color combo, and it's definitely giving autumn vibes!
Can you make a tutorial on how to thread the two pieces together?! I have a convertible dress with snaps to add sleeves and length and this loop ribbon seems like a much better option for me.
Its so easy that it doesn't need a tutorial. You can see how it went together at 12:06 (and you can see how it comes apart in the reveal, which is literally the reverse of how it goes together). You alternate the loops between the top and bottom of the skirt, and thread a ribbon through. I used a giant needle, you could use a safety pin.... whatever works!
So fabulous! The best creative solution ever!!
Thank you!!
You could actually add on the white stripes above the ruffles and above the pleating and I think it would actually blend the layers together really well. Kind of like the pinstripe around the hems of some Victorian skirts.
But that's where it was before, and what I was trying to match in that middle section there, and it just really wasn't working visually for me 😭
@@ShannonMakes I was starting to dig the stripes before but I think mixed with the tulle it'll actually be balanced out more than before but I could be wrong.
Your imagination amazes me. I love watching what you are doing and what you will come up with next. Love this skirt idea.
Thank you so much!
Another fabulous project with lots of clever techniques and work arounds! Like you, I was sad to see the white trim come off the shirt skirt because I truly thought it looked fabulous. At the same time, I totally agree that it just didn’t look right with the extension. All that beautiful hand stitching shot to hell though; what a shame. 😔
Well fortunately I adore that type of mindless hand stitching, so it was a pleasure to do (the original sewing, not the taking off)!
It's a bit like knitting, which... I've been known to sit down and just knit. Not knit anything, specifically, just knit to knit (while watching TV) and then frog it and just start knitting again. That was clearly before I had a TH-cam channel, and I had much more free time on my hands 🤣🤣
I love this. I am always looking for different types of clothes binding since I'm not a fan of some of the common types for various reasons. I would definitely keep a crafting needle (the dull kind with big eye) with the extension piece to make the lacing process faster.
I dint wrote my guess down because I saw your solution in the intro (didnt know it was button loop trim, but thought some lace with loops though...) but I would never have guessed THAT solution! Its genius. Nothing I plan on trying my self in near future because I like my skirts long, but Im sure its good to know a solution like this exists!
Sad you had to remove the trim, but I totally understand your reasoning and I agree. maybe you could make detachable trim with magnets? (im joking!)
Liking one's skirts long does definitely eliminate the need for this technique (although some people have talked about using it for summer vs winter lengths for when it's warmer/cooler out, or on sleeves... might be too heavy for sleeves, but I'd love to see it tried)!!
Very clever attachment method. The skirt turned out so well!
Thank you so much! Glad you enjoyed it!
So the button lace that you used reminded me of a zipper method which I could of seen being a good way of attaching the bottom, (or using snaps if you were not leaning to historical).
As for that fabric, I would love to see some sort of shrug or shoulder cloak with it. Nothing to fancy, but still in your historical feel.
So the reason I didn't use a zipper was that they're so stiff that it would have really affected the hemline and the drape, which I didn't want. But if you didn't mind that, or if you wanted to stiffen the hem up, that could be a great option!
Shannon, it is gorgeous and brilliant! Just like you!
Wow, thank you! 😊😊
Downright brilliant thinking 🎉 Love it when a plan come together. ❤
I made a similar trim with ⅛” ribbon for "corset" tie loops, a borrowed, wear-it-once prom dress that would not close on a slightly larger girl. I sewed on 3 x 5" cards for accurate spacing, just folding ribbon back and forth in front of the needle. Using silk thread to attach it, the original garment was completely unaltered when the trim was pulled out.
Wonderful!
This is such a cool solution! Hopefully you can make another skirt with the white trim since it did look so good on the midi skirt! I appreciate that you take the time to get your project done well! ❤🎉❤
Thank you!! 🥰
That's such a creative way of attaching the bottom of the skirt! I would never thought of that, and it's genius!
About the fabric, I see it as 40s style jacket, I had something similar but made in 90s (in 40s cut) and it was very versatile garment, perfect for autumn.
Thank you! 😊I already have plans for a 40s style Eisenhower jacket, but lots of ppl have been suggesting jacket with a peplum, so that could be looked into!!
@@ShannonMakes It could look good with peplum, however, I think this fabric would be also cool as Eisenhower jacket! Maybe even with contrasting collar?
I am thinking "Velcro." Velcro could make your skirt stiff (not drape the way you want). However, Velcro might keep the hem from being torn loose from the bottom of the skirt (or keep the skirt from being torn loose from the waistband). My long 1950's skirts were damaged a lot on the playground and in the classrooms (I worm them patched back to school).
Once again your creativity and ingenuity astonish me!
Awww, thank you!
I love it. I think your technique for attaching the bottom ruffle is genius.
I think I want to make this skirt, but I may try adding a row of skinny trim above each ruffle to see how it looks.
I only found your channel 2 days ago, and have watched 6-7 videos. I really enjoy your creativity!
Thank you! So glad you're enjoying all the videos, thank you for taking the time to check out the archives - there truly are some really fun projects in there!
this is brilliant brilliant brilliant omg ❤ i might try this because I have project it would be perfect for!! (floor length fantasy bell sleeves xD) and leave a bodkin permanently at end of the ribbon with a little pocket for it in the extension piece? I am?? pretty excited??? I was considering snaps, or hooks and eyes but I already actually have some loop tape HECK yeah
That's a great idea!!! Love it, and love the bodkin with the dedicated pocket... please, please share photos of the finished project with me!
Seconding the bodkin pocket love. I can't explain why it charms me so much, but it does.
If the pattern pieces have notches on them, they are there to match up pieces. If you want to cut off the notches, just chalk them onto the seam allowance, then you match single notch to single notch, double to double....
I am... well aware of what notches are, I've been sewing for decades. I'm a little confused where this comment is coming from, as I didn't mention notches in the video, to my recollection?
Brilliant and creative! And the final products are so cute!
Thanks so much! 😊
Absolutely LOVE this and would wear it all the time. Great work!
This. Is. Brilliant. ❤
I was wondering about attaching skirt extension myself but the best idea I had were buttons. This is just so much better!!
Thank you!!
Love your creativity! I never saw your solution before. I like the simplicity and light weight of it, also easy in the wash. I'm tall and clothes seem to get shorter every year. I could switch back and forth as I like! Thank you for the idea!
As much as I absolutely can't relate with the idea of being tall, or clothing being too short (I'm constantly treading on and wearing out my pants' hems), I'm glad that you see the application for this in your life, and I hope you use it!!
That beautiful houndstooth fabric would make a gorgeous waistcoat and Baker Boy Hat or if you have enough, a pair of Knickerbockers!
Yes, would LOVE the baker boy hat... and of course the trousers/knickerbockers! I'm not sure it has the right drape for trousers, though... feels quite stiff. Shall investigate!
The result is amazing! You did a fantastic job, and I can't even imagine the annoyance of having to remove the trim.
Still, I was looking at the final result, and I think that you still might be able to add the white trim, as you did before, and then add a thinner one at the bottom of the extension, maybe?
Whatever you do, I'm sure the end result will look amazing anyway ❤
I dunno, I spent well over an hour playing with options, spread out across a couple days to give distance/perspective, and at that point, I had to throw up my hands and accept that I personally didn't like any options that I found... maybe one day I'll go back and rethink about it, but if I'm honest... probably not, lol!
@@ShannonMakes that's fair! It still looks great and you did an amazing job ❤️ thanks for sharing all these videos, they are really fun and informative to watch 😊
I live the rip-cord button loop and ribbon. I've used a similar- but not exactly the same- technique for a corset that needed to be removed very quickly. I laced a spiral through each side of the corset grommets, staggered that loop, and used a zip tie down the center so it could be yanked out with ease.
That's a great idea! Love the ingenuity!