Robin looked so fantastic for this concert. His face wasn't sunken in and he had some weight on his legs. He looked healthy and handsome. The most fantastic voice I've ever heard.
Oh, Robin was smoking at this point in his life. This concert was pure gold, every minute, but I find my attention is drawn embarrassingly often from the awesome music to Robin’s hotness. In particular I am oddly obsessed with his gorgeous full lips and his still fairly pronounced overbite. I am not a well woman but I find it very sexy the way his teeth kind of touch his bottom lip as they do at the end of this song. Not well at all.
Even though Robin was always special, I wish I had been a better fan and appreciated him more when he was alive. You don't know what you have until it's taken away from you.💔
Always liked the early Bee Gees music. Took a while for me to accept the 70's disco Bee Gees. When I was a kid I would often sing to Robin's voice. I always liked practicing the reverb in my voice like Robin used to do on the early music. Used to get quite good at it. Their music was special. Very different style. Loved it.
Yes, I agree. Robin was my favorite but I too didn't appreciate that beautiful voice enough. Such a loss. I'd love to have known his thoughts behind this song.
Robin is NATHANIEL ROBERTO'S idol he has a version of this beautiful song please watch him if you have time and if it's ok with you please subscribe it would be a great help for him thank you 🙏
My Son fell out of bed hurting his head, he died from a brain bleed three weeks later, after his funerial I was driving around going crazy, and I put the radio in my car on, the radio was playing this song by Robin Gibb, ( I started a joke ) that was 7 years ago. It gives comfort every time I hear Robin Gibb singing it..
Have you seen Melbourne, 1974 ? It’s what made me fall in love with BEEGEES, And the Sun Will Shine…. Best live performance of all time period, in my opinion, Robin was so insanely talented!
A sad, deep song about someone who doesn’t fit in. Who can’t relate to this song? And the way he sings it with so much emotion that it makes you want to cry. There will never be another you. RIP Robin Gibb
A masterpiece beyond measure. And a performance that is difficult to to find the proper words to describe the excellence robin gives in his delivery. It brings you to your knees at its beauty and songwriting extraordinaire. Thank you. Rare, indeed!
I have two that I have a difficult time saying one is better than the other. This live version and the A&E Live by Request version are in a tie for me. I just can't choose. Love them both.
@@DougCeleste Do a search for Bee Gees A&E Live By Request I Started a Joke. It's the second and third videos that come up on the list. It's been posted more than once. If you haven't seen that whole show, it's really pretty good, and they do several songs from their last album This Is Where I Came In.
@@mrsjake1828 thank you! I didn't know the entire A&E show was available on YT. Only saw some parts from it... especially the one with B.Joel request and the twins reply to him😉. Again thank you.
Robin received a 10 minutes standing ovation..! GIGANTIC angel voice ! singing bird, voice from another world..! No one can challenge Robin whining voice.. I cry every single time Robin was singing ! BG’s FOREVER 💔🙏💔🙏💎🇬🇧🎤🎼🎸
The effing brilliance of Robin Gibb at its finest, to me. Most highly under-rated vibretto and songwriter. I find this song to be quite a masterpiece since that album on an lp laying on my living room floor at age 15 , 48 years ago. I miss him this weekend terribly.
It's hard to believe that anyone Fan or No Fan, Any Age, Any Gender, of Any Race not feel something. The Song in general can be interpreted in many ways making it unique to each Listener. His incredible Vocals and Style in this Live Performance pushes the Feeling and Emotion to an unbelievable Higher Level !!!!!! R I P Dear One, and Thank You For Your Contribution's and Gifts To Music.😘😘😘😇😇😇
Look, listen and learn all ye vocalists: the emotion, the treatment of the lyrics, the tone. You don't hear the song, you experience it! And no auto tune needed! Just classic - pure talent!
What I love, Barry and Maurice were in the dark, Barry had his back to the camera, to give Robin his due. Such an amazing voice. We who have followed the BeeGee's for decades a know that each brother was special. We all know Barry and his amazing falsetto, but Robin was just as good, he had such an amazing voice. The brothers knew that, and made sure he was never overlooked. Maurice never took the lead, shame really, he just seemed to prefer being in the background. This is not the only song that Robin sang, not by a long shot. That incredible voice is heard through out. Just listen to the music, yes, old as it may seem now, 2020, but anyone who considers themselves an authority on popular music, may want to revisit the BeeGee's, and actually listen.
Luv, luv, luv the BeeGees forever...wishing Barry the best of health n happiness 2023! I will forever be grateful for all the music from the 4 BeeGees...
That part touches me as well. The song that started my love of Robin's voice,this song and the Beegees in general. I was 10 or 11 when I first heard it. Tom Jones show. It stopped me in my tracks. Thank you Robin!
I've been a fan since I was just a kid. 50 now. I remember when he passed away I sobbed. It hit me so hard. Same with Maurice and even their baby brother, Andy, but with Robin it hurt so much. No one ever will have a voice quite like that. Thank you Robin and all the BeeGees for gifting the world what your beautiful music. It will last forever. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I feel you maam. and I feel sorry for idolizing them late. but that doesn't mean I don't know them because my parents often played their songs when I was little. Well i am 34 now. I also like robin the most & I think I could fall in love with him if I lived at that time hehehe.
@@indriasteria ❤️. I feel the same way. I've always been a sucker for a musician and Robins voice gives me goosebumps all over. 😀. My daughter is 23 and I love it when I hear her listening to the classics. The other day she was listening to The Mamas and the Papas and it was a proud moment for this mama. It's just proof that music will always stand the test of time for generation after generation. Long after they're gone. 🙏💯🤘
I personally fealt that Robin had the better voice for ballads this one and saved by the bell along with Massachusetts are exceptional hits due to Robin's voice 👌 😮
Robin Gibb has a voice that sends chills down my spine. This song highlights his voice more than many others and it is tragic that he did not sing alone more often.
Magnificent live performance. 20 years later, in the original key, no auto-tune, no production tricks, just that angelic voice. Robin was an incredible musician; gone far, FAR too soon.
I can't ever get thru this without tearing up..Robin, we miss you, there will never be another you. This perfect heavenly song. Perfect angelic voice, a beautiful man.
It's amazing how his voice cuts right through the music. When I was in 7th grade a friend and I went to the record store. I told him that this is the best song ever since I was a Bee Gees fan. He bought it the 45 and the next day he wasn't happy with me, I was busting up. After all these years I still say that it's one of the best songs ever.
Hi Gary. Not sure if this counts as seeing The Bee Gees but, I was walking with a girl friend across Trafalgar Square, might have been 1969, when we saw the Bee Gees being filmed miming to a track called Dreams (I think). Not one of their best. Wish it had been I Started A Joke. This song seems to rip right into you in an unexpected way. Jon
Eu amo muito, muito bee Gees, amo muito também a voz maravilhosa do Robin, que Deus os abençoe sempre, seja em qualquer lugar ou dimensão que eles estejam! Ouvindo esta linda canção: Fortaleza - Ceará, Brasil (bairro Parangaba) às 6:45a.m. de: 08/02/2024(quinta)
Desde España. Por supuesto qu se ama esta voz, está música, esta maravillosa persona. Robin geeb está vivo en los corazones grandes y llenos de paz. La vida sigue y deseo amor y paz a todo el 🌍🌎
More than 40 years ago this song gave me goosebumps, today it still does. Robin’s voice was put in there by angels themselves. What a beautiful song sang by the most beautiful voice.
I love how you could hear a pin drop in there while he was singing and afterwards the crowd erupted. The more he smiled and bowed, the more the crowd got louder and louder. He knew he was loved, not just for having one of the most beautiful vocals in the world but being a wonderful person as well.
Happy, Healthy, Gorgeous, Sexy, and a voice like a angel..so incredible. The heartbreaking part is there can NEVER EVER be another Robin. No one can ever replicate.
@@robertaclark2996 I come here about every 2 weeks to watch, marvel and listen to the most beautiful ballad ever written by the most talented singer, the angels are happy again, they got there Robin back in the choir.
No Robin the joke was never on you.thru the years you made us happy you made us smile with your beautiful voice.the day you died the world cried.the joke was on us 😢 3:18
Our sweet, sweet angel! Still so loved and missed by millions of his fans. No one will ever come close to our precious songbird's angelic voice. Love you always!
Meu Deus q saudades desse tempo...ouvindo bee gees em 2023 ouvindo Robin cantando com tanta saúde...não da pra acreditar q ele já foi....amo demais bee gees..❤❤❤❤
Rest in peace Robin Gibb! Owner of an amazing and inimitable voice, you were not a joke! He was one of the greatest vocalists of all time! The joke is us. The world seems to be a big joke...
This song always reminds me of more mellow poignant times when life was less hectic and had a brighter future. I love these videos where Robin looks directly into the video for just a second with a small smile, and it's like you are there and your eyes connect and he sees you, it becomes so personal. It is also very sad that he is no longer here❤️
Such a unique, pure and angelic voice that makes you feel the emotion of every word being sung. There will never be a trio as successful as the Beegees. I am glad to have been born in the era when the lyrics was meaningful, understandable and impactful.
Over 5 million views, so many people love this man's voice , well he was simply genius. Through 5 decades and he still makes so many people happy in these difficult times, I hope Barry knows just how much we appreciate their music.
Есть музыкальные коллективы , которым не подвластно время. Современность , для ихнего творчества , не имеет времени . Они , легенда , а легенды , живут вечно.
The most stunning voice ever! Do you ever hear someone on all those talent shows doing a Robin song? NO, BECAUSE THEY CANT! His voice was to hard to replicate! To unique, Angelic, Vibrato and more...we will never hear a voice like this again.
@@itscrochetday1444 I come to listen to this version here and there. Can't ever get thru it without tearing up. This is live and he is complete perfection. No one can ever replace. I heard a few try, but it is just not the same.
A musical legend...he was something special as where his brothers and there will never be another vocalist like Robin, such a beautiful haunting voice ❤ and sadly all we have now is vastly overated awlful singers who cannot be mentioned in the same breathe as the Bee Gees.
@@ceciliaolsson7987 Hi, Cecilia. Lately, the song "For Whom the Bell Tolls" is one of my current favs. Robin's vocal performance just takes it to a 10+.
Verdade! Ninguém, canta lindamente como Robin Gibb, agente, só reconhece o valor quando perdemos, poderia ser uma fa melhor, para meu amado e querido Robin! Uma música linda, triste, profunda, que só ele, sabia cantar, interpretar com todo talento ,amor, profundidade, obrigada Robin, por todo seu legado! Te amaremos para sempre! Estará eternamente em nossos corações 💕 ❤e vidas! Y love you! Robin, descanse nos bra de Deus! Beijos 💋
Robin looked so fantastic for this concert. His face wasn't sunken in and he had some weight on his legs. He looked healthy and handsome. The most fantastic voice I've ever heard.
Oh, Robin was smoking at this point in his life. This concert was pure gold, every minute, but I find my attention is drawn embarrassingly often from the awesome music to Robin’s hotness. In particular I am oddly obsessed with his gorgeous full lips and his still fairly pronounced overbite. I am not a well woman but I find it very sexy the way his teeth kind of touch his bottom lip as they do at the end of this song. Not well at all.
@@beeharbour totally get you. His overbite is really sexy. He also has such a sweet smile.
this was when he looked his best, i dont know what happened after that , illness or mo’s death, but he aged very fast.
@@lindarusso2557Mo died in 2003 so it was not that
Robin is fine ❤
Even though Robin was always special, I wish I had been a better fan and appreciated him more when he was alive. You don't know what you have until it's taken away from you.💔
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
I didn’t discover the wonders of these three brothers’ music until years after Robin and Mo had passed
Always liked the early Bee Gees music. Took a while for me to accept the 70's disco Bee Gees. When I was a kid I would often sing to Robin's voice. I always liked practicing the reverb in my voice like Robin used to do on the early music. Used to get quite good at it. Their music was special. Very different style. Loved it.
Yes, I agree. Robin was my favorite but I too didn't appreciate that beautiful voice enough. Such a loss. I'd love to have known his thoughts behind this song.
He was always my favorite Bee Gee
Nobody could sing like Robin. You are greatly missed.
Robin is NATHANIEL ROBERTO'S idol he has a version of this beautiful song please watch him if you have time and if it's ok with you please subscribe it would be a great help for him thank you 🙏
Já ouvi muitas vezes, mas é uma versão mágica que não pode faltar Quem ouvir por favor me dê um joinha
Pra que?
My Son fell out of bed hurting his head, he died from a brain bleed three weeks later, after his funerial I was driving around going crazy, and I put the radio in my car on, the radio was playing this song by Robin Gibb, ( I started a joke ) that was 7 years ago. It gives comfort every time I hear Robin Gibb singing it..
So sorry for your loss
My heart bleeds for you. This song is so plaintive and real. Listening to it never gets old.
What a wonderful way to try and get memories sorry
Physical reaction: Robin's vibrato reaches in and hugs my heart. Your son reached in and found the radio channel just for your aching heart.
😊@@JaneAustensWorld
Only Robin can sing this song
Sinto Mike Patton Faith no more gave it a good shot.
ES VERDAD!! la he oído por otros cantantes y la destrozan!! SOLO LOS BEE GEES PUEDEN CANTAR SUS CANCIONES, SON PERFECTOS!!!
No, Barry AND Maurice can sing this song stupid you know nothing about the bee gees.
@@gabzz9004 Sorry.........there's only one version...others give it a good try
Yep - zero remakes of this classic
My gosh, what a voice!!! Thank God for recordings so we can enjoy this over and over, year after year!!! Thank you, Robin!!!
Have you seen Melbourne, 1974 ? It’s what made me fall in love with BEEGEES, And the Sun Will Shine…. Best live performance of all time period, in my opinion, Robin was so insanely talented!
this is true voice of singing & no auto tune at all..... sound like u enter heaven for sure
@@debbiekritikos6746 No I haven't Debbie, but I'm going to definitely check it out tonight!!!! Thank you!!!!!! ❤
@@havok9001 You are SOOO right!!!!!!!!! ☺
I would've loved to go and see a show with the Bee Gees 😔 🇿🇦
Robin was the best singer.. I love his voice..
A sad, deep song about someone who doesn’t fit in. Who can’t relate to this song? And the way he sings it with so much emotion that it makes you want to cry. There will never be another you.
RIP Robin Gibb
Every time I hear this song, I Always remember Ludwig Boltzmann or Alan Turing.
Yes. There are certain entertainers who seem to be one of a kind and probably ARE!....
I feel it.
A masterpiece beyond measure. And a performance that is difficult to to find the proper words to describe the excellence robin gives in his delivery. It brings you to your knees at its beauty and songwriting extraordinaire.
Thank you. Rare, indeed!
Very good I Love the accent and I really love their music 🎶 God Bless Robin Gibb❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
For me, this is the BEST live version of this beloved song that I have ever heard! NO ONE could sing this song like Robin could!
I have two that I have a difficult time saying one is better than the other. This live version and the A&E Live by Request version are in a tie for me. I just can't choose. Love them both.
@@mrsjake1828 I cannot find that A&E version on YT. I would LOVE to hear it to compare it to this LOVELY version.
@@DougCeleste Do a search for Bee Gees A&E Live By Request I Started a Joke. It's the second and third videos that come up on the list. It's been posted more than once. If you haven't seen that whole show, it's really pretty good, and they do several songs from their last album This Is Where I Came In.
@@mrsjake1828 I just heard it and thanks for the reply. What a lovely version of the beloved Bee Gees song.
@@mrsjake1828 thank you! I didn't know the entire A&E show was available on YT. Only saw some parts from it... especially the one with B.Joel request and the twins reply to him😉.
Again thank you.
Robin had a fantastic voice.Nobody could sing this song as he did.
@scottwilliams1709Asi es como dice usted
Robin received a 10 minutes standing ovation..! GIGANTIC angel voice ! singing bird, voice from another world..! No one can challenge Robin whining voice.. I cry every single time Robin was singing !
BG’s FOREVER 💔🙏💔🙏💎🇬🇧🎤🎼🎸
❤I agree 100% that his voice so beautiful and those high notes!!!!!!!
M enam.oraaaaaa
El mes gran!!!!!!!
Robins Stimme ist einfach nicht zu übertreffen ,es ist sehr traurig das er nicht mehr unter uns ist.
Same with you..we are a big fan of Robin..i'm so happy for him
Robin, you were a genius...thank you for this amazing tune...the whole world is crying now
Hello friend, how are you doing today? ??
Yes he surly is missed 🥲
Scammer
One of the best solo performances I've ever heard love it....And that's no joke.
Best bee gees song by a mile Kevin ..
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
i miss the voice of my father's voices and the voice is coming to me
Seriously
Till now same as always 2021😍😘😘
He was so awesome, that whole place was quiet while he was singing. This song always brought me to tears when I was younger.
Hello Debbee how are you doing?
Same with me I mean I'm only 25 now but I use to listen to this when I was 8
I now sing this song to my beautiful gf who is unfortunately passing slowly from brain cancer she's only 26
@@christianpech795 oh my gosh, I am so sorry. Robin's son played this song as Robin was dying.
The effing brilliance of Robin Gibb at its finest, to me. Most highly under-rated vibretto and songwriter. I find this song to be quite a masterpiece since that album on an lp laying on my living room floor at age 15 , 48 years ago. I miss him this weekend terribly.
The level of thought to write this lyric is something else. And then there's the music and voice.
I feel the chills on my skin while he was singing that song. His voice was very unique and crystallized. We miss you so much Robin 😭💕
He was one of a kind
Indeed and wish he was still here z
-@@reneelouiseazzopardi2073 What a beautiful voice. One of a kind, that can't be replaced. Unbelievable.
It's hard to believe that anyone Fan or No Fan, Any Age, Any Gender, of Any Race not feel something. The Song in general can be interpreted in many ways making it unique to each Listener. His incredible Vocals and Style in this Live Performance pushes the Feeling and Emotion to an unbelievable Higher Level !!!!!! R I P Dear One, and Thank You For Your Contribution's and Gifts To Music.😘😘😘😇😇😇
@@dickbackus2004 yes, he is always the songbird that we know and he is the one who have this kind of talent. Really a blessing 💗
Look, listen and learn all ye vocalists: the emotion, the treatment of the lyrics, the tone. You don't hear the song, you experience it! And no auto tune needed! Just classic - pure talent!
Well put. Surprisingly enough, I have been told myself that folks don't really hear the song when I sing as well and yet remember the experience.
What I love, Barry and Maurice were in the dark, Barry had his back to the camera, to give Robin his due. Such an amazing voice. We who have followed the BeeGee's for decades a know that each brother was special. We all know Barry and his amazing falsetto, but Robin was just as good, he had such an amazing voice. The brothers knew that, and made sure he was never overlooked. Maurice never took the lead, shame really, he just seemed to prefer being in the background. This is not the only song that Robin sang, not by a long shot. That incredible voice is heard through out. Just listen to the music, yes, old as it may seem now, 2020, but anyone who considers themselves an authority on popular music, may want to revisit the BeeGee's, and actually listen.
Absolutamente de acuerdo!!
Extraordinarios!! I LOVE YOU SO MUCH, DEAR BEE GEES!!
Shut up stoop
@@MsShoosh1 shut up
40 years old robin still sounds like he's 20's years old
Luv, luv, luv the BeeGees forever...wishing Barry the best of health n happiness 2023! I will forever be grateful for all the music from the 4 BeeGees...
I played this on repeat for 3 days. How relaxing and beautifully sung. It’s perfectly spoken and full of emotion.
👍 auch ich tue es immer wieder, es ist voller Emotionen.
I don't think i can ever listen to this beautiful voice from this angel without crying. We miss you so much Robin. It is apparent right here.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
🖤😢
I agree Robin, is my favorite Beegee. This song & Massachusetts are the very best of all their wonderful songs.
@@shaykatz5648 Yes, Mass as well, we also must add "Saved by the bell", a classic showing what he had solo.
Yup. We all LOVE ❤️ the Bee Gees.
when he finished the song, and smiled at the audience, it really warmed my heart. R.I.P. Robin Gibb
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Me too! I was so happy for the response of the audience because it made him seem so proud!!
That part touches me as well. The song that started my love of Robin's voice,this song and the Beegees in general. I was 10 or 11 when I first heard it. Tom Jones show. It stopped me in my tracks. Thank you Robin!
Love the smile!
Me too! Oh Robin you deserved that
response from the audience!!
I love that smile of yours ❤R.I.P
Robin
I've been a fan since I was just a kid. 50 now. I remember when he passed away I sobbed. It hit me so hard. Same with Maurice and even their baby brother, Andy, but with Robin it hurt so much. No one ever will have a voice quite like that. Thank you Robin and all the BeeGees for gifting the world what your beautiful music. It will last forever. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
I feel you maam.
and I feel sorry for idolizing them late.
but that doesn't mean I don't know them because my parents often played their songs when I was little. Well i am 34 now.
I also like robin the most & I think I could fall in love with him if I lived at that time hehehe.
@@indriasteria ❤️. I feel the same way. I've always been a sucker for a musician and Robins voice gives me goosebumps all over. 😀. My daughter is 23 and I love it when I hear her listening to the classics. The other day she was listening to The Mamas and the Papas and it was a proud moment for this mama. It's just proof that music will always stand the test of time for generation after generation. Long after they're gone. 🙏💯🤘
I personally fealt that Robin had the better voice for ballads this one and saved by the bell along with Massachusetts are exceptional hits due to Robin's voice 👌 😮
❤
I was a kid back in the early 60s when these guys first started out….almost 60 yrs later and they are still my English band/group
Robin Gibb has a voice that sends chills down my spine. This song highlights his voice more than many others and it is tragic that he did not sing alone more often.
Couldn’t agree more - the unique vibrato in his voice gives me goosebumps…❤ Such a talented singer…❤
Magnificent live performance. 20 years later, in the original key, no auto-tune, no production tricks, just that angelic voice. Robin was an incredible musician; gone far, FAR too soon.
Damn his vocals are out of this world, this is so majestic!
Born in 1956.... it’s amazing to have had this beautiful singing to grow up with!🍃🌸🍃
Born in 1961 I agree growing up with this music😁
Born in 1980. Music is eternal, timeless, everlasting. Can you NOT feel that?!!
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
100 % AGREE !!!!!!!👍
I loved Robin's voice. It was so unique!❤
Yes Robin was so truly amazing 💞
WOW, my jaw just dropped! This was just perfect, smooth as silk.
Robin had the most beautiful, unique voice. My favorite BGs songs often had him singing lead. Miss you, beautiful man.♥️
Have you heard Robin sing Fly rings around the moon? It’s hauntingly beautiful.
I can't ever get thru this without tearing up..Robin, we miss you, there will never be another you. This perfect heavenly song. Perfect angelic voice, a beautiful man.
What a cool 😎 dude and the voice sadly missed Robin
Your one of the kind
Shine bright like the diamond 💎 you are 🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉I 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
It's amazing how his voice cuts right through the music. When I was in 7th grade a friend and I went to the record store. I told him that this is the best song ever since I was a Bee Gees fan. He bought it the 45 and the next day he wasn't happy with me, I was busting up. After all these years I still say that it's one of the best songs ever.
Robin has always been my favorite 😇
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
A unique gorgeous high male voice - every note so full of emotion. This and Massachusetts are my favourites. I cry every time I hear Robin sing them.
Robins voice was so pure and heart rendering. I don't think anyone's voice could match his
True
The Greatest Song Ever Wrote and Sung. God Blessed us with The Bee Gees
His voice is enough to give you Goose bumps
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Crazy just crazy beautiful.!!!
Amo amo amo esses caras
And amazing he does it so effortless!
One could say... Robin bumps 💓
Magic. Robin Gibb had a magic voice. It went all the way through your ears and into your heart. Iconic.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
One of Robins greatest performances Brilliant!
Robin was always my favorite Bee Gee ❤ He had a voice that I found warm and it just touched me.
Robin was one of the most amazing voice's in the world! RIP. I wish I could have seen them perform a live show. It must have been incredible.
I saw them in concert in Atlanta in 1979. I will never forget that voice that Robin had!
It was
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Same here but in Los Angeles in 1979. Unforgettable
Hi Gary. Not sure if this counts as seeing The Bee Gees but, I was walking with a girl friend across Trafalgar Square, might have been 1969, when we saw the Bee Gees being filmed miming to a track called Dreams (I think). Not one of their best. Wish it had been I Started A Joke. This song seems to rip right into you in an unexpected way. Jon
His voice was so perfect here.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
His voice always was perfect.Just like him.
Every time I watched the Bee gees may heart Is aching huh...the best forever Bee gees❤️❤️❤️
This is one of those majestic performances that just fills your eyes with tears cherishing that time in our history
I could listen to this over and over again. It's so pure what a voice👏👏👏👏
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Robin Gibb had the voice of an Angel. Simply fantastic Performance.
So sad that we've lost him.
RIP!
Alguém escutando esse hino em 2023?
I love Bee Gees.
Ouvindo em fevereiro 2024 ❤❤❤❤❤
Eu amo muito, muito bee Gees, amo muito também a voz maravilhosa do Robin, que Deus os abençoe sempre, seja em qualquer lugar ou dimensão que eles estejam!
Ouvindo esta linda canção:
Fortaleza - Ceará, Brasil (bairro Parangaba) às 6:45a.m. de: 08/02/2024(quinta)
#2024
Yes. 2024 also
Desde España. Por supuesto qu se ama esta voz, está música, esta maravillosa persona. Robin geeb está vivo en los corazones grandes y llenos de paz. La vida sigue y deseo amor y paz a todo el 🌍🌎
I just love him - the most sensitive. talented, unique in the whole world/ his songs go deep in your heart and stay there forever. RIP Robin.
What a beautiful job he did on that song. RIP Robin, you so deserve the applause you got at the end!
More than 40 years ago this song gave me goosebumps, today it still does. Robin’s voice was put in there by angels themselves. What a beautiful song sang by the most beautiful voice.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Heb hem te laat ontdekt. Wat een talent en lieve en mooie man. Is in mijn hart voor altijd ❤❤❤😘
How right you are. It's a fantastic song.
I agree with every word, Random Ami, it does exactly the same for me. Robin was 'Simply The Best' !
Nunca vi uma expressão tão sabia, verdade a voz dele é "angelical".
Only the wonderful, singer, song writer Robin Gibb could sing this song. Love his voice. RIP Robin.
He puts his everything into every performance of that song. Bravo. Bravo!
I love how you could hear a pin drop in there while he was singing and afterwards the crowd erupted. The more he smiled and bowed, the more the crowd got louder and louder. He knew he was loved, not just for having one of the most beautiful vocals in the world but being a wonderful person as well.
Hello friend, how are you doing today
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Happy, Healthy, Gorgeous, Sexy, and a voice like a angel..so incredible. The heartbreaking part is there can NEVER EVER be another Robin. No one can ever replicate.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
@@reynaldcriso8641 Thank you, I checked it out, very pretty.
@@dyanshane thank u for watching my idol.
No no-one can sing like Robin. RIP Robin
@@robertaclark2996 I come here about every 2 weeks to watch, marvel and listen to the most beautiful ballad ever written by the most talented singer, the angels are happy again, they got there Robin back in the choir.
No Robin the joke was never on you.thru the years you made us happy you made us smile with your beautiful voice.the day you died the world cried.the joke was on us 😢 3:18
You expressed my sentiments exactly. Robin you are missed.
What a great performance. This voice is my favorite since the late sixties.
Robins vocals were simply the best!
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Absolutely brilliant, one of the best songs EVER,sung by one of the best voices EVER!
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Who can't love the Bee Gees. They are the best. And thank you so much for all your beautiful music. Love it 😊❤
That applause is so well deserved. INMHO, best concert rendition of this song. Robin was on point that day, as he always was. RIP Robin.
My favourite Robin song . Excellent performance.Robin voices soaring.Your voices was fabulous and magnificent 💖.I love you Robin forever and Always.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Mine as well
Erika Kovacs, What about Korda Gyorgy?
YES YES YES ROBINS VOICE FOREVER IN MY HEART AND SOUL.
No cellphones, no cameras. Just eyes and ears are enough for live like this. Missing the old days. 😥
I was at that concert.. Pure magic
And no standing ovation. They've lost their meaning from overuse.
The good ole days when music had a tune.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Yes, what a pleasure to finally see people watching the REAL person instead of through their phone! Life was better then...sigh. Miss the "old" days.
Not only beautiful voice ,
So handsome!!!
You are loved .
Miss you so much !!
RIP .
Wow, gave me goosebumps at the end. Loved Robin's contagious smile and his unique beautiful wonderful voice, he surely is missed.
He was the perfect person to sing this song.🙏💚
Robin Homem Abençoado esta Musica deixa-me com o Coração apertado e partido triste,saber que ele já nos deixou🙏🤎🤎💚💚😥😥
@@rhondaeverett8284 - He wrote it too.
Our sweet, sweet angel! Still so loved and missed by millions of his fans. No one will ever come close to our precious songbird's angelic voice. Love you always!
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
So true Laurie.
The tremendous reaction from the audience opened my floodgates. Could this be the best performance by any singer ever?
Marcelo Ciarro - I will see if I can find any of her performances on TH-cam. It would be nice to see her.
Meu Deus q saudades desse tempo...ouvindo bee gees em 2023 ouvindo Robin cantando com tanta saúde...não da pra acreditar q ele já foi....amo demais bee gees..❤❤❤❤
é uma voz incrivel a do Robinn
Che tempi meravigliosi, ho ancora i loro 48 giri.
This will be the song at my funeral.
Can't stay away from this performance. He's just... wow. Lost for words Beautiful One. x
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Rest in peace Robin Gibb! Owner of an amazing and inimitable voice, you were not a joke! He was one of the greatest vocalists of all time! The joke is us. The world seems to be a big joke...
Robin owns that song and no one else should ever try to sing it.
Not even Orbison
This song always reminds me of more mellow poignant times when life was less hectic and had a brighter future. I love these videos where Robin looks directly into the video for just a second with a small smile, and it's like you are there and your eyes connect and he sees you, it becomes so personal. It is also very sad that he is no longer here❤️
Man what a talent. Great performance.
❤❤ Robin you will never be forgotten ever❤
Hello Jeanine how are you doing?
I think he has the purest voice I ever heard !
I love it when for just a moment (2:18) he looked into the camera and gave us all a little smile. It broke my heart. Robin is one-of-a-kind. ❤
This is marvelous, the song, it's music, the melody, the lyrics, Robin's voice, and this song was compoused by him, by the way.
unbelievable vocals from Robin during this concert.. what a legend
Such a unique, pure and angelic voice that makes you feel the emotion of every word being sung. There will never be a trio as successful as the Beegees. I am glad to have been born in the era when the lyrics was meaningful, understandable and impactful.
Wow This is so damn beautiful. I cried every time I heard this masterpiece. Out of this world. And Iam 23 years old
I love how casual he is, blue jeans and a regular shirt and that billion dollar voice! RIP Robin!!
Slash G&R - He has his fingers in his pocket for much of this concert and looks like, "Oh, there's people here so I guess I'll sing". Effortless!
Over 5 million views, so many people love this man's voice , well he was simply genius. Through 5 decades and he still makes so many people happy in these difficult times, I hope Barry knows just how much we appreciate their music.
Hello friend, how are you doing today
Robin was magic in a bottle didn't know what we had and then he was gone before we even could imagine Rest in Peace 💟💟💟
Есть музыкальные коллективы , которым не подвластно время. Современность , для ихнего творчества , не имеет времени . Они , легенда , а легенды , живут вечно.
🙏👌👌👌👌👌👌🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝как вы ПРАВЕЛЬНО СКАЗАЛИ!!!!У ЛЕГЕНДЫ НЕТ ВРЕМЕНИ!!!!!!!
Falou tudo amo essa música 🎶
Concordo a💯por cento: Criativos,Modernos" com vozes e a Música são incomparáveis ⏳⏳❤❤❤❤❤
Wow! I just realized, after hearing someone else sing this song, that some songs are meant for only some people. RIP Robin
Hello friend, how are you doing today? ??
I find it hard to listen to this without crying so beautiful
What a Beautiful Legendary Voice. R.I.P ...😭😭😭🙏🙏🕊🕊🕊
Hello friend, how are you doing today? ??
Quite possibly one of the best ballads ever, and his vocals were flawless:)
Agreed!
A purely brilliant vocal performance. So sadly missed RIP Robin 🌹
What a beautiful man he was and a beautiful, unique voice!!!!! Unbelievable, from another planet, I would say!!! Miss you my dear!!!!!!!
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
The most stunning voice ever! Do you ever hear someone on all those talent shows doing a Robin song? NO, BECAUSE THEY CANT! His voice was to hard to replicate! To unique, Angelic, Vibrato and more...we will never hear a voice like this again.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
@@reynaldcriso8641 Very nice acoustic version, give it a listen people.
This is so true. His voice is the epitome of UNIQUE
@@itscrochetday1444 I come to listen to this version here and there. Can't ever get thru it without tearing up. This is live and he is complete perfection. No one can ever replace. I heard a few try, but it is just not the same.
Beautiful song, beautiful man, beautiful voice!
My favorite Bee Gee's song of all time. RIP, Robin Gibb.
A musical legend...he was something special as where his brothers and there will never be another vocalist like Robin, such a beautiful haunting voice ❤ and sadly all we have now is vastly overated awlful singers who cannot be mentioned in the same breathe as the Bee Gees.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Agreed! Simply breathtaking voice.
Well said you
This song and Robin's performance of it brings tears to my eyes everytime.
Me too. How are you,Virginia?
@@ceciliaolsson7987 Hi, Cecilia. Lately, the song "For Whom the Bell Tolls" is one of my current favs. Robin's vocal performance just takes it to a 10+.
I agree with you 🥺🎶
Love that song, excellent interpretation 🥰🎹👍RIP Robin🙏😇
Verdade! Ninguém, canta lindamente como Robin Gibb, agente, só reconhece o valor quando perdemos, poderia ser uma fa melhor, para meu amado e querido Robin! Uma música linda, triste, profunda, que só ele, sabia cantar, interpretar com todo talento ,amor, profundidade, obrigada Robin, por todo seu legado! Te amaremos para sempre! Estará eternamente em nossos corações 💕 ❤e vidas! Y love you! Robin, descanse nos bra de Deus! Beijos 💋
Yes I admit that. This was from the 60’s. Robins voice has never lost its greatness. Sounds same as back then.😢😢😢💕💕💕🙏💖😘😘😘
Hello friend, how are you doing today? ??
Robin has an amazing voice.
th-cam.com/video/JOM-9buVu6s/w-d-xo.html
Gigante e Inolvidable Robin Gibb !!!! Gracias BEE GEES ´!!!!
ROBIN ERA FANTÁSTICO, JAMAIS SERÁ ESQUECIDO.