This makes me wonder: why people who did not lived in communist country idealize communism so much? The main issue with communism is... 1. Planned economy being abused from lower levels - how? If you had produced e.g. 100 L of milk in month, then to get praise from local party commissar you report 150L produced. Then this commissar motivated by the same thing like you would report 1500 L (instead of 1000L), and his higher ups would do similar. Effect? Central Committee gets information about having countrywide overproduction of milk (they see in reports extra 50%), so they export 50% of milk and... after that there is shortage of milk. So, they pay this like: 1. pay for overproduction in reports, e.g. 100 000 USD 2. earn from export of supposed overproduction, e.g. 100 000 USD 3. face shortage of milk and choice: import milk for 200 000 USD or not import it. So, this is planned economy - weakest link is always humans :) The other issue is with human mentality - if something belongs to all and no one is paying directly for repairs, then they care not for it. I observed this a lot like up to 20-25 years after iron curtain fall. Now it is slowly changing - people started to care (because if they destroy something, they need to pay for repairs).
Not so fun fact: When the Germans told Stalin that he can have Yakov back in return for Field Marshal Paulus’s release, Stalin said, “I will not trade a field marshal for a lieutenant.”
At the funeral of his first wife, Stalin said, "She died and with her died my last warm feelings for humanity." This villain origin story is the same as Darth Vader's.
Except Stalin’s son didn’t save him from the dark side. In fact, Stalin let the Nazis torture his son when given the offer to free his son. Vader had a redemption, Stalin didn’t
"Oh to be young and to feel love's keen sting". Makes you wonder how differently Stalin would have become if his wife lived a little longer. Or if his dad wasn't such a dick. 😢
It is said when the Germans asked Stalin to trade his son, Yakov for Paulus (commander of the 6th army in Stalingrad). Stalin replied: “I would never trade a general for a lieutenant”. His son died in Nazis POW camp but he never betrayed his father or his country. He remained loyal till the end and even attempted a prison break once.
His son was not loyal he had defected from soviet army once or twice and then sent to battlefield forcefully. The truth is stalin never defected his motherland. His people the soviet people were above or equal to his own son.
Ironically, if Stalin became a priest, he may have been persecuted and even executed as part of the church during the October Revolution if it still happened.
Ruturaj Shiralkar Yeah he did play a big part in the funding and many other things that gave them a better chance. We may even still have a Tsar today if Joseph became a priest.
Stalin was not of a ”poor peasant family”. In fact, they were rather privileged. The proof of this is that both his parents were literate, whereas the literacy rate was very low in Georgia at that time. In addition, Stalin’s father was fluent in 4 languages (Georgian, Russian, Armenian & Turkish).
That is not true. Stalin was dyslexic, he never spoke Turkish and Armenian and he wasn't even fluent in Russian until he was like 50 years old... Also his family was not privileged, his father had a profession (shoemaker) which was rare in Gori so they were not serfs or peasants but still very much low class. Also, his mother was a mistress of a powerful land owner in Gori which is the only reason they afforded to send him to study in Tbilisi. If by privileged you mean compared to other people at the time who were basically slaves then yes but it's not really a privilege though is it?
@@HabboCoolcattim but you are right about the thompson but not the m1 garand. But besides most of when they showed that, if even at all, was not in 1941.
@@williamfriberg4651 kulaks and gulags are different things : A kulak is a rich person. A gulag is a prison set mainly in Siberia to "rehabilitate" the ennemies of USSR.
It is amazing to me that people can spend 10 minutes talking about how evil and murderous the communist revolution and then end the episode wishing that the world adopt a new communist utopia.
Uh, can I get a turkey sandwich with bourgeoisie cheese on it, oh and can I also get some marinara sauce. Thanks, but can you make it toasted? Add a large drink and some chips please, wait don't forget the cookie.
That doesn't make it right. The communists killed far more people than the Nazis, the Allies just let USSR take Eastern Europe after the war. In my eyes, the Allies and USSR were the true evils of WW2.
Bruh it literally isn’t what it was about.Stalin used it for power and made Stalinism and communist dictators use the same excuse to keep power and money.
@@clarkstrange2142 Imagine where Russia would have been today without with the Tsardom being in power for the 20th century, certainly not where it is today. Stalin's rule was brutal and inhumane but his 5 year plans saw the greatest economic benefit for Russia, even so much that a huge empire torn from WW1 and a civil war was able to send humans into space while still being able to provide the basic needs, such as housing and Healthcare (something the US even today struggles to so) for a large population
When my grandma was small at 3 am 2 soldiers came to their house and took them in Siberia and she and her family stayed there for 2 years. When Stalin died she could go home free.
"Hey man, tell the person in charge of giving people jobs not to let that idiot Stalin take power. By the way, who did I put in charge of giving people jobs?" "That would be Stalin, sir." "... *_BLUGH"_* UhhhhHHH-OH, HELLO! I did not expect this response! *_MUAH_* ❤😘
you americans seem to not decide either if people was rich or poor under communism. sometimes you joke about how everything was free, and sometimes people had nothing to eat
Adding some clarifications to the content discussed, it is urgent to point out that the “success” of Stalin - the man who used to boast of having taken the U.R.S.S. "from the plow to the atomic bomb in just one generation" - compared to Gorbachev's failure shows that a socialist economy is unable to function with a minimum of efficiency without requiring a massive dose of political violence. In an attempt to reform a decadent regime, Gorbachev proceeded more quickly with the process of political openness in the hope of removing the predictable resistance that the Soviet bureaucracy would create to economic reform measures, as was fully proven by the failed coup attempt. in the USSR in August 1991 - which ended up precipitating the final crisis of socialism and the dissolution of the USSR itself. Having restored several freedoms (creed, expression, organization, party, etc.) that had been abolished in his country since the time of Vladimir Lenin, Gorbachev's opening process can be defined as a kind of attempt to "deleninize" the U.R.S.S. While Gorbachev went ahead with his policy of "one step forward" (towards capitalism) and two steps back (back to socialism), his Chinese parallel - Deng Xiaoping - adopted a logic diametrically opposed to that of Gorbachev: he prioritized the achievement of economic prosperity (adopting capitalism in practice) precisely to delay any attempt at political opening, as was evident with the acceleration of the economy. reforms after the Tiananmen Square massacre. It is important to note that it was Karl Marx himself who, in his Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, discerned the scenario in which the conditions for a social revolution process are formed, describing it as follows: “At a certain stage in its development, the material productive forces of society contradict existing production relations or - which is just their legal expression - with the property relations in which they have operated until then. From the forms of development of the productive forces, these relations are transformed into fetters of them. So, it is a time of social revolution. '* By rejecting the pursuit of profit maximization as an instrument to stimulate innovation, socialist countries ended up condemning themselves to obsolescence. Thus, they lost the chance to incorporate the productivity gains made possible by technological progress. That is why the capitalist countries managed to provide a greater rise in the standard of living of their population, even without pursuing the egalitarian ideal. Therefore, until the “final crisis of socialism” (to paraphrase K. Marx's own definitions once again), it was only a matter of time. But religious fanatics do not give up on their faith, even against the indisputable proof of the facts, which completely refute it! What has always happened to human society since the time of chipped stone is that technological development does not require human beings to dedicate themselves to certain activities, which start to be carried out in a more intensive way, with increased productivity of decline in the contingent of hand. -employed labor, eliminating certain jobs with the aid of the developed technology. But the jobs eliminated are offset by the increased employment of labor in more technologically developed sectors. This is basically what happened when the advent of the Industrial Revolution helped to increase the productivity of the extractive and agricultural sector - notably from the advent of agro-industry - while reducing the need for the employment of human labor in these sectors. , which makes up the primary sector of the economy. At the same time, the Industrial Revolution moved the economically active population to the secondary sector of the economy (handicrafts, industry and manufacturing). This process was first noticed by the Austrian economist Joseph Alois Schumepeter, who defined it as a kind of "creative destruction" - that is: technological progress destroys job opportunities in some sectors, but also creates new opportunities in other sectors! The problem is that Schumpeter was a pessimist, who detested the Soviet regime, but strongly believed that he embodied the "future of humanity". Schumpeter did not realize that he had found the key to explain why capitalism does not self-destruct in an immense crisis of overproduction, as K. Marx predicted it would happen: instead, it evolves, creating the conditions for the overcoming of technological civilization. industrial and the subsequent advent of a technological civilization of a post-industrial character, in the same way as the Industrial Revolution had already done with the agricultural or pre-industrial civilization. Therefore, we can conclude that from the invention of the first chipped stone tools to artificial intelligence and space travel, human history is not driven by a notorious and highly questionable "class struggle", but by technological progress: since it discovered how handling fire and producing tools, including the wheel, human evolution has become more technological and less biological, unlike other animals. The main reason for this phenomenon is that, with the help of the technology we have created, the human race has gradually become less subject to the limitations imposed by nature. It was by obstructing this mechanism of human evolution - disregarding the importance of maximizing profit in an industrial technological society - that the so-called "socialist mode of production" proved unable not only to compete with capitalism, but even to survive. Therefore, it is easy to deduce that this is a mere question of TIME until the so-called "21st century socialism" in Venezuela ends up following the same path as its counterpart of the last century. However, if there are still economic reforms, it is possible that it will survive for some time. To paraphrase Marx once again, it can be said with certainty that socialism is a system full of contradictions, which bears the germ of its own destruction: it is the system that digs its own grave! * Reproduced according to MARX, K. Preface to the Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, organized by Florestan Fernandes and published under the title K. Marx: Teoria e processo histórico da revolução social, In Marx & Engels, Great Social Scientists Collection , História, vol. 36. São Paulo: Ática, 1983. p. 232. Edição comemorativa do centenário da morte de Karl Marx. Obs .: Adaptation made from a text of my authorship published in issue nº 72 of the Magazine of the Brazilian Association of Intellectual Property - RABPI in September 2014.
But Stalin tried to resign 4 times? Trotsky was *literally* voted out of the Party? And he tried to “consolidate” power his whole life? Why is it that these types of Videos never seem to need to provide sources?
I can’t believe I watched 10 minutes of the worst graphics I’ve ever seen-which make light of stalins villainy-only to hear the narrator apologize to Marx because Stalin misinterpreted his manafesto!? I can’t even, the ignorance.
Don't listen to this propaganda, yes there was famine, and there was death, but he turned the country from an agricultural crippled empire, into the only Superpower on earth challenging the USA. You really think that the USSR would still be able to fight off Germany without a man like Stalin, ordering the country to fight the invaders, 34 Million men rose proudly to fight for him and fight for the country.
2:09 little error here, priests from orthodox church and generally orthodox christians make the sign of cross from touching the forehead to lower middle of the chest to *right arm* and *lastly* left arm, somewhat different from catholic version of it.
I still can't believe there's people who really believe this as some sort of defence of communism. How many more millions have to die before people realise their stupidity? How many more communist regimes have to descend into a totalitarian nightmare before these people realise: yes it is the philosophy that's a fault?
I just thought Oversimplified threw in that "My father used to punished me severely" line as a joke but after hearing the opening lines about Stalin's childhood was real, I was surprised and points to people like Avery Lopez-Baines for pointing that out as well. Have a nice day. =)
When people say "true Communism," what they mean is the imaginary Communism which they or another had envisioned. True Communism is implemented Communism. The real-life attempts which created real-life results.
@@sierra1513 there can be a better society, but what some call "true communism" can't be achieved. You act like it's the only way, when it's not even an option
It's generally accepted that the Zinoviev letter that claims Lenin turned against Stalin was a fraud, Lenin's common law wife wrote many of the disparaging letters against Stalin rather than Lenin himself, and that Lenin himself originated much of the terror methods Stalin was famous for. Stalin had actually adopted his pseudonym around 1912, before the revolution. Interestingly enough I've read some accounts that suggested Trotsky was initially offered the position of General Secretary but scoffed at the idea of taking the role suggesting it goes to Stalin.
@@theholydm2040 "Yes, these people have X and these other people don't have X. Thus it's perfectly fine for me to steal X from the people who have it and give it to people who don't have it." Besides, it's their grain. Other people have no right to it.
@@psyxypher3881 it was done in order to prevent the starvation of industrial cities that do no produce their own food. The grain was not theirs, it belonged to the state, one of the main differences between communist and capitalism. Plus, most Kulaks were not murdered, they simple starved to death just like everybody else.
psyxypher There was a famine going on because of the drought, if you’re in charge of providing the people with food in that situation then it’s a logical thing to take some of the food from people who have more than they need and give it to those who have none.
imagine owning a business and sharing your wealth equally then you go bankrupt and all your employees refuse to help you thats why people arent paid as much
What is the best way to produce a happier society? Do "they" even want us to be happy?
In USSR, you MUST BE happy
Happiness is found within a person not always the society they live in
This makes me wonder: why people who did not lived in communist country idealize communism so much?
The main issue with communism is...
1. Planned economy being abused from lower levels - how? If you had produced e.g. 100 L of milk in month, then to get praise from local party commissar you report 150L produced. Then this commissar motivated by the same thing like you would report 1500 L (instead of 1000L), and his higher ups would do similar. Effect? Central Committee gets information about having countrywide overproduction of milk (they see in reports extra 50%), so they export 50% of milk and... after that there is shortage of milk.
So, they pay this like:
1. pay for overproduction in reports, e.g. 100 000 USD
2. earn from export of supposed overproduction, e.g. 100 000 USD
3. face shortage of milk and choice: import milk for 200 000 USD or not import it.
So, this is planned economy - weakest link is always humans :)
The other issue is with human mentality - if something belongs to all and no one is paying directly for repairs, then they care not for it. I observed this a lot like up to 20-25 years after iron curtain fall. Now it is slowly changing - people started to care (because if they destroy something, they need to pay for repairs).
I am at peace when I watch your videos.
Socialism@ Comunism . = Discipline based on common sense.
Hapiness is not real inless is shared.
Everyone gangsta until Stalin photoshops you out a picture
I *will* photoshop you in the *GULAG*
And then in real life...
@@xaviere2008 haha impostor
western imperialist red army marching as we speak!
@@xaviere2008 Don't you dare use Capitalist software . It will ruin my revolution .
Vladimir Lenin We net again, Comrade...
*OH SO NOW YOU WANNA TALK TRASH ABOUT ME*
Than tell me where are you from Amxanago stalin
@@YouthForEuropeGeorgia ქართველია :)
why would you use your weather powers against those innocent kulaks?
@@gigipapal6445 xineli iyos tu kqia
Literally the facts buddy.
0:52 This enraged his father, who punished him severely
This also enraged his father, who punished him severely
Someones watching oversimplified huh?
My oversimplified brudda
most anticipated crossover in the history of crossovers
What is this, a crossover episode?
EDIT: 何????? Biggest response I've gotten on a reply, thank you! ありがと！
WE just went out of the room and OUR boy made such a mess .
Sorry dad.
WE HATED YOU LENIN STALIN SHALL RISE
Motherrussia
@jake weigel oh mah gawd ITS MEGA OOF
Should of executed Stalin and put in Trotsky.
I’ve already seen 10 accounts with the name “Joseph Stalin”
They're imposters, as Stalin is already dead.
@@ipapachubbs8609 Yeah I know
Ricegum Ate Kong oof
@@green_razor8569 *Ah a man of a similar IQ*
Ricegum Ate Kong lol
What I learned- if Hitler's art teacher and stalins highschool teacher didn't expell/reject them, the world would've been way different
So their teachers are responsible for world war 2 and genocide .... it’s all making sense now..
@@potatogamer3830 so the lesson is don't go to school so u don't start ww3 got it
Dude seriously
what did I do?
@@zixizhang8356 You skipped Gulag
my son didn't die he just went to the GREAT GULAG IN THE SKY
Joseph Stalin You didn‘t care less didn‘t you?
Can I have some food?
Maybe?
@@hospitalfood583 Give me ur adress then I'll send a sack of potatos and some corn
@@astr.4 Go commit capitalism
Not so fun fact: When the Germans told Stalin that he can have Yakov back in return for Field Marshal Paulus’s release, Stalin said, “I will not trade a field marshal for a lieutenant.”
Then he said he had no son by that name
Why did stalin hate his son?
@@faramundusfrankia9153 he placed his country above his son !! An ounce weakness exposed in war will consume your fate !
@@faramundusfrankia9153 afraid of future overthrow
Actually he said “many of my comrades loved ones are in a German prison, how would it look if I traded my son while they continue to rot their?
“Aye Stalin you’re really messed up, what’s wrong with you.”
“My father used to punish me severely”
FrostHD dude, uncool.
Ah yes a man of Oversimplified
A man of culture I see. . .
😂😂
*spank
Capitalist country: *exists*
Soviet Russia: “Your free trial of being alive has now come to an end”
Evariste Galois it was the Soviet Union and included 14 other countries besides Russia?
Evariste Galois .da
@@nonogin5280 But who was the power house of all of the countries?
U have been on r/makemesuffer
@@alexhennigh5242
The mitochondria!
that does not look like stalin at all, that character design should be sent to the gulags
Why can I only give one like to this?
@@iancuvlad7368 i-don-t-kn-owe.
(Means: "i don't know")
Ching Chong I like onion
Your profile pic fortnite
Thus no one cares bout ur opinion
I might send the character design to gulag
Joseph Vissarionovich Stalin yes great leader
morality:
Be VERY carefull on which one of your kids you want to beat
i got beat up alot by stepmom and army dad, ill spare anybody in this comment section
Yep
@@Mystic_Gohan97 loll
Luis Sanchez
Dang
Yeah
Stalin's Most Heinous Act: Stealing candy from a baby
Wanna have a free pass to gulag?
Ha Ha!
do g sss How about one for you?
Sory but not funny
G_lag
"A single death is a tragedy, a thousand deaths is statistic."
- Joseph Stalin
He was a tyrant but also a genius.
That’s not even his quote
Ok
@@NickAndriadze most tyrants are
@@NickAndriadze how do you think they got there?
In America u Laugh at president
In Soviet Russia Stalin Laughs at u
One Eyed Killer nobody laughs at trump
@@Khloya69 lol Ye Nobody laughs at Trump but Trump laughs at himself
Goku_ Black_DBS I think u mean urself, loser. I don’t like my own comments.
Yep that's True
One Eyed Killer ha
At the funeral of his first wife, Stalin said, "She died and with her died my last warm feelings for humanity." This villain origin story is the same as Darth Vader's.
Except Stalin’s son didn’t save him from the dark side. In fact, Stalin let the Nazis torture his son when given the offer to free his son. Vader had a redemption, Stalin didn’t
@@JaketheJust Stalin and Vader have similar villian origin stories, but unlike Vader, Stalin didn't get a redemption arc.
Stalin was reddit and cringe
"Oh to be young and to feel love's keen sting". Makes you wonder how differently Stalin would have become if his wife lived a little longer. Or if his dad wasn't such a dick. 😢
Yeah.... no.
Teacher: What classes are you struggling with recently?
Me: The Bourgeois
Teacher: What
Me: What
Karl Marx: Nice
Thank you furry, very cool
Gulag
Me too
It is said when the Germans asked Stalin to trade his son, Yakov for Paulus (commander of the 6th army in Stalingrad). Stalin replied: “I would never trade a general for a lieutenant”. His son died in Nazis POW camp but he never betrayed his father or his country. He remained loyal till the end and even attempted a prison break once.
His son was not loyal he had defected from soviet army once or twice and then sent to battlefield forcefully. The truth is stalin never defected his motherland. His people the soviet people were above or equal to his own son.
@@Akshayattr1
MY OWN SON GOT LOCKED UP IN PRISON.
AND I DIDN'T SAVE HIS LIFE.
😠😡👿😈
-Joseph Stalin(ERB)
To be fair to the guy, he had an amazing mustache.
yes he does... why does every evil person in history have an amazing mustache?
YES.
True
Yeah... but unfortunately, that was ruined by another brutal "man of steel".
True.
Ironically, if Stalin became a priest, he may have been persecuted and even executed as part of the church during the October Revolution if it still happened.
Ruturaj Shiralkar Yeah he did play a big part in the funding and many other things that gave them a better chance. We may even still have a Tsar today if Joseph became a priest.
Nah, it wouldn’t be as successful.
Only certain churches were persecuted for working with the bourgeoisie other than that they were pretty fine
E
@Sanctus Paulus Stalin didn't actually live in luxury, he just had some cars(that he doesn't actually own) and an office(that he doesn't actually own)
That’s not terrifying. The TH-cam rewind is.
old joke
It’s not a joke. *Its serious*
OurLordTachanka TIME TO GET SERIOUS (plz get it)
I will always get it
Yaaa it’s rewind time
Joseph Stalin
The man who had unlimited n-word passes
Thanks for making a video about me. You get 2 more grams of grain .
I am the real stalin блять
So no gulag?
Stalin's real name is იოსეფ სტალინ
Hello papa
@@hh-fy3sn Georgian is such an interesting language, it's not Cyrillic nor is it Arabic.
Stalin was not of a ”poor peasant family”. In fact, they were rather privileged. The proof of this is that both his parents were literate, whereas the literacy rate was very low in Georgia at that time. In addition, Stalin’s father was fluent in 4 languages (Georgian, Russian, Armenian & Turkish).
That is not true. Stalin was dyslexic, he never spoke Turkish and Armenian and he wasn't even fluent in Russian until he was like 50 years old... Also his family was not privileged, his father had a profession (shoemaker) which was rare in Gori so they were not serfs or peasants but still very much low class. Also, his mother was a mistress of a powerful land owner in Gori which is the only reason they afforded to send him to study in Tbilisi. If by privileged you mean compared to other people at the time who were basically slaves then yes but it's not really a privilege though is it?
I grew up poor in America but if by poor you mean African child starving with no water or food or clothes then yeah I’m rich…
"McDonalds adverts in russia during ww2"
*Im stalin' it*
Isn't it written in the book of blyat "Thou shalt not take lord Stalin's name in vain"? To the gulag with you!
Im mussolini'it
@@klotildapremtaj6255 baldi basics 1.0
Since when did the Soviets have Thompsons and M1 garands?
since 1941 when americunts supplied them with it.
@@HabboCoolcattim I don't think they were in 1941 during the parts where they showed the Thompsons
@@HabboCoolcattim but you are right about the thompson but not the m1 garand. But besides most of when they showed that, if even at all, was not in 1941.
They pressed x overtop of it
the same era in which ethnic georgians had blonde hair or black african skin
Rich people and kulaks: *exist*
Soviets: your free trial of being alive has ended. Renew?
*no* *no*
Its called gulag
@@williamfriberg4651 kulaks and gulags are different things :
A kulak is a rich person.
A gulag is a prison set mainly in Siberia to "rehabilitate" the ennemies of USSR.
the kulaks weren’t even that rich they were still peasants just abit more wealthy
@@charlottewaring8039 I stand corrected
Thats right, kulaks were something along on what we call today middle and upper middle class
Stalin: Man of steel
Iron man: Am I a joke to you
iron man is rusted
*superman left the group*
Man of steel is Superman not iron man....
@@Menibor1 You must be fun at parties...
@@Mgaffo222 you must be Carlos mencia or Amy Schumer..... stealing old jokes smh
Some non-Communist country : **still exists**
USSR : ur free trial of living is coming to an end comrade
Some democratic socialist country exists:
America: it's free real estate
Its some way true. The way Putin is leading Russian, its more like back to USSR rather than making Russian a better place
Indonesia :i'm gonna be a Communist
Also Indonesia:nvm
I grew in georgia and exact same city stalin was born.
*Nobody cares but okay*
Lukson
You grew up in Gori??
გორიდან ხარ?
მეც ქართველი ვარ, მაგრამ გორიდან არა ;)
Lukson u mean 1 guy care
@@geowebdesigner8303 which language is this? 😮
Random Guy: Stalin, I’m hungry
Stalin: Hi hu- *(Clears throat)* I know..
Lol
Gulaged
@Random guy Hi almost dying
*we know
@Joseph Stalin *we have been gulag'ed
This narrator doesn't BREATHE! Not even after the end of the story, where he mends the last line with thanking the sponsor...
Or, there's software available with filters that quickly and efficiently remove certain resonant artifacts.
editing
Soviets using american Thompsons.
nice.
And they were on Facebook...
And americans using soviet submarines (Another Video)
Only in some parts, they were using PPSh-41's
Just about to say that
*_i can hear soviet national anthem in the comments section...._*
Государственный гимн СССР
Mr X2 Soyuz neurishimi
@@fahoodie1852 respublik svobodnikh
NKVD KGB
Splotila naveki
NKVD KGB
Da strasvouyetsozdanny
I’m not scared of him........
This enraged your father, who punished you harshly
Your not scared of him but you blew ur brains out when his army took ur city
And it eventually lead to your downfall.
But your afraid of america
Isn’t Mussolini your BFF?
It is amazing to me that people can spend 10 minutes talking about how evil and murderous the communist revolution and then end the episode wishing that the world adopt a new communist utopia.
Exactly man
Ya they just don’t want to work
Right
I had to watch the end again I couldn’t believe it , actually disgusting
@Robert Williamson Socialism and communism are different.
Nobody:
Stalin:
Absolutely nobody:
Stalin: iS ThAt CoLoUrEd WaTeR I sEe
1:34 bourgeoisie sounds like a type of cheese on my sandwich
Yes And it's very fancy.
Bourgeoisie cheese is always found sandwiched between slices of proletariat bread.
Uh, can I get a turkey sandwich with bourgeoisie cheese on it, oh and can I also get some marinara sauce. Thanks, but can you make it toasted? Add a large drink and some chips please, wait don't forget the cookie.
*Americans*: every fckg french word sounds like a type of cheese
Can I get some mortel cheese on that?
My family calls him uncle Stalin because we’re all Georgian 😂
He was called uncle Joe by the Americans.
mets var kartveli
We call him r.kelly
@@diido-swagins687 Apparently, you believe on of thousands lies about Stalin.
მე ეგ კაცი მაინც მძულს
That fact that he was from a poor and bad family and he became probably the most powerful man of his time is actually motivating
Most of the dictators had similar background.
Same with austrian painter
Bros getting ideas 💀😬
@@TomBrennan183you mean the psychopath ?😂
We have to admit that Stalin helped to defeat Nazis
History In 5 Minutes you have a point
That doesn't make it right. The communists killed far more people than the Nazis, the Allies just let USSR take Eastern Europe after the war. In my eyes, the Allies and USSR were the true evils of WW2.
taavidude no germany started the war and still killed millions of innocents...
@Somarik Green And that is why they should have never helped Soviet Union in the first place.
The commies were worse than the nazis
*"BuT iT wAsNt ReAl CoMmUnISm"* @ 10:00 Unbelievable. Still making excuses for these murderous dictators. 🤦🏿♂️
Bruh it literally isn’t what it was about.Stalin used it for power and made Stalinism and communist dictators use the same excuse to keep power and money.
Lonewolf 3638 it doesn’t work bruh
@@clarkstrange2142 Imagine where Russia would have been today without with the Tsardom being in power for the 20th century, certainly not where it is today. Stalin's rule was brutal and inhumane but his 5 year plans saw the greatest economic benefit for Russia, even so much that a huge empire torn from WW1 and a civil war was able to send humans into space while still being able to provide the basic needs, such as housing and Healthcare (something the US even today struggles to so) for a large population
дебил
As a Georgian person, the way you pronounced his surname cracked me up🤣🤣🤣
Capitalism: The Infographics Show
Communism: *The Potatographics Show*
I got an adventure communist ad the moment I saw this comment
@@dottore5823 lol
Poland
144pgraphics
🥁🥁🥁🥁🥁🥁🥁🥁😆😂😂😂
My grandpa and other members of my family lived and suffered under this monster.
Yea this is internet no one really cares, you are lucky its not twitter
@@izawa9211 what a pointless comment..
@@AGriz3521 was it to me
Are you in America?
Are you in America?
When my grandma was small at 3 am 2 soldiers came to their house and took them in Siberia and she and her family stayed there for 2 years. When Stalin died she could go home free.
I never really died.
"Dude, you're messed up"
"My father used to punish me severely"
This enraged his father
the amount of zooms and out zoom is giving me motion sickness
I'll explain it to you in one sentence.
So basically Stalin was like, "Enemies, I don't think so."
More like everybody gets Shot.
In communist Russia Stalin terrifies you
-4 Subscribers with 1 video you sure about that?
In current Russia, Putin scares you.
You mean the Stalinist Russia? The only communist Russia was under Lenin.
In you Russia Stalin communist terrifies
@@Masterchuh5 Stalinism and communism dont have anything in common.
How to become a dictator :
-get punished severely by your father
-get kicked out of a school
-grow a menacing mustache
2:29 "Blah blah blah, blah, blah blah blah blah blah."
No wonder the Russians took to him with strong arguments like that.
Ikr? I mean how else are you supposed to reply to that?!
"Hey man, tell the person in charge of giving people jobs not to let that idiot Stalin take power. By the way, who did I put in charge of giving people jobs?"
"That would be Stalin, sir."
"... *_BLUGH"_*
UhhhhHHH-OH, HELLO! I did not expect this response! *_MUAH_* ❤😘
This enraged his father, who punished him severely
@@supermariojames9720 which led to more economic downturn
Oversimplified
XD
This statement enraged Stalin, who punished Lenin’s body severely.
Dark humor is like food, not everybody gets it. (Communist Russia)
You speak ill against glorious Communism. To the gulag with you.
He in gulag now, he will suffer
you americans seem to not decide either if people was rich or poor under communism. sometimes you joke about how everything was free, and sometimes people had nothing to eat
Comrade Iosef Stalin Haie about YOU go to the gulag?
Hii gulag
Adding some clarifications to the content discussed, it is urgent to point out that the “success” of Stalin - the man who used to boast of having taken the U.R.S.S. "from the plow to the atomic bomb in just one generation" - compared to Gorbachev's failure shows that a socialist economy is unable to function with a minimum of efficiency without requiring a massive dose of political violence. In an attempt to reform a decadent regime, Gorbachev proceeded more quickly with the process of political openness in the hope of removing the predictable resistance that the Soviet bureaucracy would create to economic reform measures, as was fully proven by the failed coup attempt. in the USSR in August 1991 - which ended up precipitating the final crisis of socialism and the dissolution of the USSR itself. Having restored several freedoms (creed, expression, organization, party, etc.) that had been abolished in his country since the time of Vladimir Lenin, Gorbachev's opening process can be defined as a kind of attempt to "deleninize" the U.R.S.S.
While Gorbachev went ahead with his policy of "one step forward" (towards capitalism) and two steps back (back to socialism), his Chinese parallel - Deng Xiaoping - adopted a logic diametrically opposed to that of Gorbachev: he prioritized the achievement of economic prosperity (adopting capitalism in practice) precisely to delay any attempt at political opening, as was evident with the acceleration of the economy. reforms after the Tiananmen Square massacre.
It is important to note that it was Karl Marx himself who, in his Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, discerned the scenario in which the conditions for a social revolution process are formed, describing it as follows:
“At a certain stage in its development, the material productive forces of society contradict existing production relations or - which is just their legal expression - with the property relations in which they have operated until then. From the forms of development of the productive forces, these relations are transformed into fetters of them. So, it is a time of social revolution. '*
By rejecting the pursuit of profit maximization as an instrument to stimulate innovation, socialist countries ended up condemning themselves to obsolescence. Thus, they lost the chance to incorporate the productivity gains made possible by technological progress. That is why the capitalist countries managed to provide a greater rise in the standard of living of their population, even without pursuing the egalitarian ideal. Therefore, until the “final crisis of socialism” (to paraphrase K. Marx's own definitions once again), it was only a matter of time. But religious fanatics do not give up on their faith, even against the indisputable proof of the facts, which completely refute it!
What has always happened to human society since the time of chipped stone is that technological development does not require human beings to dedicate themselves to certain activities, which start to be carried out in a more intensive way, with increased productivity of decline in the contingent of hand. -employed labor, eliminating certain jobs with the aid of the developed technology. But the jobs eliminated are offset by the increased employment of labor in more technologically developed sectors.
This is basically what happened when the advent of the Industrial Revolution helped to increase the productivity of the extractive and agricultural sector - notably from the advent of agro-industry - while reducing the need for the employment of human labor in these sectors. , which makes up the primary sector of the economy. At the same time, the Industrial Revolution moved the economically active population to the secondary sector of the economy (handicrafts, industry and manufacturing).
This process was first noticed by the Austrian economist Joseph Alois Schumepeter, who defined it as a kind of "creative destruction" - that is: technological progress destroys job opportunities in some sectors, but also creates new opportunities in other sectors!
The problem is that Schumpeter was a pessimist, who detested the Soviet regime, but strongly believed that he embodied the "future of humanity". Schumpeter did not realize that he had found the key to explain why capitalism does not self-destruct in an immense crisis of overproduction, as K. Marx predicted it would happen: instead, it evolves, creating the conditions for the overcoming of technological civilization. industrial and the subsequent advent of a technological civilization of a post-industrial character, in the same way as the Industrial Revolution had already done with the agricultural or pre-industrial civilization.
Therefore, we can conclude that from the invention of the first chipped stone tools to artificial intelligence and space travel, human history is not driven by a notorious and highly questionable "class struggle", but by technological progress: since it discovered how handling fire and producing tools, including the wheel, human evolution has become more technological and less biological, unlike other animals. The main reason for this phenomenon is that, with the help of the technology we have created, the human race has gradually become less subject to the limitations imposed by nature. It was by obstructing this mechanism of human evolution - disregarding the importance of maximizing profit in an industrial technological society - that the so-called "socialist mode of production" proved unable not only to compete with capitalism, but even to survive. Therefore, it is easy to deduce that this is a mere question of TIME until the so-called "21st century socialism" in Venezuela ends up following the same path as its counterpart of the last century. However, if there are still economic reforms, it is possible that it will survive for some time.
To paraphrase Marx once again, it can be said with certainty that socialism is a system full of contradictions, which bears the germ of its own destruction: it is the system that digs its own grave!
* Reproduced according to MARX, K. Preface to the Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, organized by Florestan Fernandes and published under the title K. Marx: Teoria e processo histórico da revolução social, In Marx & Engels, Great Social Scientists Collection , História, vol. 36. São Paulo: Ática, 1983. p. 232. Edição comemorativa do centenário da morte de Karl Marx.
Obs .: Adaptation made from a text of my authorship published in issue nº 72 of the Magazine of the Brazilian Association of Intellectual Property - RABPI in September 2014.
Thanks
You wrote a book
Great
That's a very long winded way of saying socialism and communism never works and only creates poverty, hatred and death for the those not in power.
@@barnabiswirley2132 sometimes it needs to be explained in depth. Especially if it comes from a philosopher.
But Stalin tried to resign 4 times?
Trotsky was *literally* voted out of the Party?
And he tried to “consolidate” power his whole life?
Why is it that these types of Videos never seem to need to provide sources?
These types of videos are either propaganda or use propaganda as sources
Fernix Indeed.
Because this channel doesnt care about facts. Like just watch the my vs ak47 video. It is wrong with almost all the facts
@@fernix918 I don't think you even understand what the term "propaganda" defines as.
@@BattleGir Would you like to publish your critique instead of running your mouth?
Stalin had a real life death note
anyone: i don't like stalin's mousta-
stalin: GULAG
Who ever write this, needs to learn the History of the Russian Revolutions(s).
Yep they didn't mention that the Socialists were ousted by Lenin and his legion of doom.
Yes
Facts.
Stalin's rules came long after the Russian Revolution was over in 1921.
“Cool moustache, Wario”
Trying to beat the mad monk you'll be sorry yo.
gulag for you
Have a free gulag ticket
Monkey Slogan yo daddy beat you like dog and now your evil
Spider Boy your from georgia sweet georgia and history books unfold ya
Stalin is very cash money
Stalin didn't get the money for himself , it was invested for the Soviet Union
He is rich but most his money was invested to the USSR
Rapzer 2.0 yes
Mao has joined the chat
New Soviet leader exist:
Stalin: i’m bout to ruin this whole man’s career
You have to pit end not ruin or else you will get 0 likes
When Stalin steals the kids lollipop:
This man has to be put down
I will report this to Stalin gulag for you comrade
10:07
Actually, he did.
He did implement the philosophy of communism through and through.
Agreed this video has a hidden twist of secret agenda to it
I can’t believe I watched 10 minutes of the worst graphics I’ve ever seen-which make light of stalins villainy-only to hear the narrator apologize to Marx because Stalin misinterpreted his manafesto!? I can’t even, the ignorance.
when you get your infos out of wikipedia this video will come out
I feel like ive learnt more about history from infographics in four weeks than history at school over 4 years haha
Don't listen to this propaganda, yes there was famine, and there was death, but he turned the country from an agricultural crippled empire, into the only Superpower on earth challenging the USA. You really think that the USSR would still be able to fight off Germany without a man like Stalin, ordering the country to fight the invaders, 34 Million men rose proudly to fight for him and fight for the country.
@Cali_ Kid tell me 1 thing that was wrong in what I said
@@ecksdee1637 Thanks bro!I made the USSR to the Super Power!
@@ecksdee1637
*Im now joining this 7 month old argument*
The CIA’s Cold War version of history anyway.
1.8k haters???
🔺🔻🔺🔻🔺🔻🔺🔺🔻
*_*SENT THEM TO OUR GULAG!*_*
🔺🔺🔻🔺🔻🔺🔻🔺
🔴🔧🔴⛏️🔴⚒️🔴⚒️🔴 ⚒️
*Y e s*
Tyler Natividad GUUUULAG
ATTENTION EVERYONE! Your savior has returned. Together we will wipe capitalism off of the face of the earth and MAKE THE UNION GREAT AGAIN!
@@DeepFriedKangaroo2no
Half of them are my soilders
What's missing in G_LAG?
U
lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
“Far right elements of the socialist party.”, I’m sorry what?
@@Dextroverse_princess Probably worse, they probably believe the whole "Stalin killed 20 million"
@@diegotorres2101 only 700k
He's biased against Trump and Republicans. He's made it obvious
@@diegotorres2101 Didn't he ?
@@vigbokwe69 I'm gonna need evidence that all deaths of the Holodomor were on purpose, if any of them at all
Germany: is that boss music?
Russia: *insert some hardbass here*
This enraged his father who punished him severely
And you mean...
Papa Stalin or super mario
This is beautiful
Oversimplified?
@@thewhackster4489 oversimplified 😎
Did you just call my Father "Super Mario"? To the gulag with you.
This is blyatiful
If Lenin didn’t meet stalin COMMUNISM would be A whole lot different lol 😂
Did you not get the part where Lenin was doing almost the same thing? Check the Netflix doc The Russian Revolution
I K N O W . He ruined my glorious revolution .
@@michaelkent7102 Off to the Gulag you go .
@@dragindeeznuts2525 You brought him idiot...😂😂
All Communist countries end up being brutal. It's because for it to work you must force people to do things they didn't want to do. It never works.
Stalin: kills millions
Putin: Hold my beer
My grand grandparents were taken to a gulag in Siberia but when Stalin died they were sent back.
Wait, the Red army using capitalist Capitalist Thompson?!?!
I was about to write the same thing maybe they liked it more
It's the PPSh-41
Lend lease
In the episode about the protection of the President of The United States, our Secret Service snipers have Dragunov rifles.
No, its not american guns, its the soviet-made PPSH-41 Sub Machine gun
2:09 little error here, priests from orthodox church and generally orthodox christians make the sign of cross from touching the forehead to lower middle of the chest to *right arm* and *lastly* left arm, somewhat different from catholic version of it.
Lol did he basically just say the “true communism” has never been implemented argument?
because it never was.
@@legaltowter9811 tbf it's true
Yes, absolute stupidity
I still can't believe there's people who really believe this as some sort of defence of communism. How many more millions have to die before people realise their stupidity? How many more communist regimes have to descend into a totalitarian nightmare before these people realise: yes it is the philosophy that's a fault?
No people, people defended communism because of the memes
When Stalin enters your house, you're the guest.
These animations are priceless!!!! You can actually learn by only watching!!!!
0:55 This enraged his father, who punished him severely.
where was this from????
i dont remember please tell me
Oversimplified, look it up uncultured swine.
@@generalviewer8347 Oversimplified
This video has no many inaccuracies and missing details.
that amount of power and no immediate consequences to your actions will obviously lead to an addiction of greed.
I can't belive you did this Video.
Yes
A half lit cigarette hanging over the typewriters mouth... these animations are PERFECT 💀
ok
Nobody:
The Infographics Show:
Joseph 𝙎𝙏𝘼𝙒𝙇𝙄𝙉
I'm convinced that if you're a Russian leader and your last name ends with "in" then you're automatically a remnant of the USSR.
If your name end with in time to get out
Trotskin
Stalin wasn't Russian. He was Georgian and his real name didn't end in "in"
1:11 - black child at Georgian school in late XIX century - interesting :D
oofff u noticed that????
They had to reach their "daily diversity quota" even though it didn't make any sense.
Stalin: what u gonna do about it.
Me: REVERSE CARD
Stalin:
So basically you are Stalin now
Stalin: +10 cards for you
NOW GO TO GULAG!!!!
Captain Foxy lll is gwy
I just thought Oversimplified threw in that "My father used to punished me severely" line as a joke but after hearing the opening lines about Stalin's childhood was real, I was surprised and points to people like Avery Lopez-Baines for pointing that out as well. Have a nice day. =)
I hope you have a nice day aswell
@@jakefryer7507 Thank you. =)
Psychiatrist: "Stalin, why do you behave this way?"
Stalin: "My father used to punish me severely."
Now go to gulag
I was in the middle of watching ur Viking video lol
But Triton 64! The Russians didn't establish Communism, the Vikings did!
@@steele_heart77 about as factual as most of this video.
When people say "true Communism," what they mean is the imaginary Communism which they or another had envisioned.
True Communism is implemented Communism. The real-life attempts which created real-life results.
You must be a sad hopeless creature to think people should not hope for a better society
@@sierra1513 there can be a better society, but what some call "true communism" can't be achieved. You act like it's the only way, when it's not even an option
"Death is a preferable alternative to Communism"
- An awesome robot
DEMOCRACY IS NON-NEGOTIABLE
-same awesome robot
Saint Stalin Communist detected in TH-cam comments, initiating directive 7395 DESTROY ALL COMMUNISTS
It's generally accepted that the Zinoviev letter that claims Lenin turned against Stalin was a fraud, Lenin's common law wife wrote many of the disparaging letters against Stalin rather than Lenin himself, and that Lenin himself originated much of the terror methods Stalin was famous for.
Stalin had actually adopted his pseudonym around 1912, before the revolution.
Interestingly enough I've read some accounts that suggested Trotsky was initially offered the position of General Secretary but scoffed at the idea of taking the role suggesting it goes to Stalin.
I still can't fathom how people can justify murdering the Kulaks...the people who grew the food and knew how to farm.
Yeah I can't fathom how they punished the people who were hoarding grain while the rest of the nation was starving.
@@theholydm2040 "Yes, these people have X and these other people don't have X. Thus it's perfectly fine for me to steal X from the people who have it and give it to people who don't have it."
Besides, it's their grain. Other people have no right to it.
@@psyxypher3881 it was done in order to prevent the starvation of industrial cities that do no produce their own food. The grain was not theirs, it belonged to the state, one of the main differences between communist and capitalism. Plus, most Kulaks were not murdered, they simple starved to death just like everybody else.
@@torp6845 Okay so now you're defending genocide and theft, I just hope you know that.
psyxypher There was a famine going on because of the drought, if you’re in charge of providing the people with food in that situation then it’s a logical thing to take some of the food from people who have more than they need and give it to those who have none.
Stop dropping your politics into videos. By the way, if you’re watching this on the smart device you’re getting quite the reward for your labor.
America will eventually collapse nothing you do or say will change this.
imagine owning a business and sharing your wealth equally then you go bankrupt and all your employees refuse to help you thats why people arent paid as much
Meanwhile Churchill: Sir, you forgot me.