Thanks for watching! 🙏 Let's discuss your theories: What do you think about Tabatha being Miranda's reincarnation? How will Boyd's Parkinson's affect his role as the town's protector? What's really happening with Fatima and the Lady in Kimono? If you're new here and enjoy FROM theories & breakdowns, don't forget to subscribe! New episode analysis every week. 🎬
I think Victor and Tabitha are sister and brother because you can see that the dress worn by Victor's sister in episode 9 and the dress worn by Tabitha in the nightmare in episode 6 are similar.
Yes, but I thought it was a pretty clever way to deal with the situation. Don't get me wrong, this show stopped being good after season 1, but these last 2 episodes were better. It's like their way of telling us that the characters need to find the answers and not us the audience (Victor) or the writers (BIW) just give it to them. And they're not theorizing and sharing their thoughts with millions of people so it might take a while, but they'll get there. If only they ditched so much useless dialogue, this show would be awesome.
Only the last 5 minutes of this episode was good. i was hoping something crazy would happen, and that cop is frustrating me. This episode had too much unnecessary talking
I love Jade just correcting Fathers, calling them out to look out for their kids better. Hes just out there breaking generational trauma. He should consider running a therapy course once he gets out. Call out bad parents, and put them back on track with looking out for and connecting better with their kids.
That actor has always (at least in this series) done a fabulous job. He kept the same demeanor through and through. Even in season 1 when you first see him you think he’s a creep but then you learn that he’s just a really old kid and his performance just does not let up!
I can’t help but believe that Boyd doesn’t actually have Parkinson. We know that this place has knowledge of their lives out in the real world and this could just be a way of the town to further try to break Boyd. When he’s telling Kenny (i think) that he has Parkinson and that his clock is ticking he mentions that his dad got it around the same age Boyd is now. But he also says that it’s not supposed to be hereditary. Just like Fatima wasn’t supposed to be able to have a child, Boyds’ Parkinson could be something that the town uses to mess with their minds.
But like That seems far fetched I only say this because his father had it and it’s hereditary Boyd definitely got grays in his hair and beard If he’s aging, and if he’s in his late 40s or early 50s (the character I mean) Then he could very well just be developing Parkinson’s
@@righteousgaming5207I see what you’re saying but Parkinson only has a few cases that are reported as hereditary. It’s very rare, about 10-15% of reported cases are caused by genetics. And i’m not sure why the show would make it a point to mention that it’s not supposed to be hereditary and then not take this route. Of course I could be completely wrong but to me it makes more sense.
Relax guys. Its not the usual regular Mystery thriller cinema we used to watch. This is psychological horror flick. Human conversations are key to explain things and show how impactful it s before and after tragedy. There are 100s of fast paced movies/series out there. This is unique and rare. Dont spoil it by making creators to rush things
Thank god, one normal comment that summs up my personal opinion. I hate when people complain that this is a boring show cause it literally isnt. The conversations are the key to understanding the characters and I don't get why people can't see it
The people who are moaning should just realise that not everything is meant for them. This is a classic psychological thriller. There is a lot of talking in movies like Silence of the Lambs. If that was released in this time that Oscar winning movie would be panned for “not enough violence”. People just want to see monsters shred everyone every episode. They are horrifically impatient too.
@@lsmetankalthe conversations: -look at me! -its gonna be ok - everything is fine -what is wrong with you - I don't want to talk about it - its not your fault
This show’s title is “FROM”, it’s very obvious, the bottle tree is literally a family tree. Everybody is connected to their ancestors. The dates are the birthdays of the resurrected family members for the past generations. The victims are the Anghkooey kids. the villains are the one who sacrificed them. The actors now are the parents of the kids from multiple generations making them pay for what their ancestors did “FROM” their past life
make sense, its like those stories people talks about Salem where the witches curse all the people in town and continue in generation kinda. Some religion and beliefs in ancient time, children was already chosen as sacrifice before being born and they grow up in another environment than the other children. Maybe thats why the children was born in the dark and killed in the dark, if they seen sunlight they would be tainted and unvalid for sacrifice. And the nr is a family tree that would make sence. I only need to remember the number one of them was named..
Samee!!!! I wonder what the other one meant when she said "That's not how it works Rendall" with the talisman...perfect opportunity for man to have asked "how does it work, and everything else!?"..haha, i think they sick enough to explain the rules to him
@giornoGiovanna555 they have to be in an enclosed space. Remember when Fatima saved herself and Ellis by closing the doors to the foyer and putting up the talisman?
@@RahYisrael99 I do, but even in enclosed spaces they have to be place in a certain way..maybe certain area, like you can't just have it in your house then say you're safe, so how does it work is still a question..like they told Rendall if it falls from the bus door its over..so it can be by the door but placed in a high area, middle.??we don't know...but again, my statement wasn't mainly on the talisman, but Rendall using that opportunity to ask how the rules work..not just to do with the talisman but in everything..like is it their choice to only come out at night like they choose to walk instead of running to catch their prey?? Rules
The acting in this episode was probably the best of the entire show so far. Sometimes there are weaker links between some of the less talented actors on the show, but everyone in this episode was truly excellent, in particular the actress who plays Fatima did a phenomenal job.
your bugging! horrible acting. Besides the past 3 episodes being dragged out and not giving any info of whats going on. Fatima isn't trying to escape, Elgin isn't being tuff enough to keep her there. it all seem fake!
@tashaenadekle imagine she just discovered she's Miranda and feels sorry for what victor has been through and decides she wants to be with him and her husband (victor's dad) causing conflict between her real husband and victor's dad.
Elgin has that “Im sold out to a cult” glaze in his eyes. He is reverent to this thing haunting him. He is doing a phenomenal acting job, but I wanted to clobber him this entire episode lol. Come on Fatima! Cutting his hand was going to do WHAT?
It's not beautiful, it's awful story. Tabitha is younger probably then victor and she is reincarnation of his mother. It's way more better for she to be his sister
I think smiley ran because it didn't want her to escape though the tree.. Remember the town knows what you're are thinking he probably knew she was going to save the children
@@deer5647 the kimono lady is trying to shut Fatima because victor and Tabitha us outside that room and they won't hear her. That's why she has put her hand on Fatima.
@@deer5647 💯 . I just hope she doesn't become one of those monsters or get attacked by one of them if she were to die. She was traumatized enough even before she entered "From town" (her father was shot in front of her eyes as she said in season 1) . The character deserves a good ending at least !
Most people have been complaining that nobody talks to each other, then in this episode we get some answers through conversations, and folks don't like it 🤷♀️
i know its a "tv show" but the lack of conversations is not real. all the charters or on their on quest or dealing with there own problems. Acosta is the most real person thus far
I like watching these types of channels, including this channel, after watching the latest episode. Something I'm noticing nobody else pointing out is that once Sara completed that little statue her brother gave her and that Kenny's broke in a fit of rage, that's when the voices came back. I wonder if there's a correlation there of some sort.
Well the main plot is: The only way to go out if town is to go through a faraway bottle tree at NIGHT. Smiley run and riped miranda apart when she was about to do this. But the aim of that soul was not fulfilled. She died in 1978 and hence reincarnated thriugh tabitha who born at the same time in 1978, she was brought to the town when she was at the same age as miranda was when she died. Tabitha's son is ethan (in her previous life her son was victor,) and her daughter is julie (in prev life it was eloise). Now tabitha has to fulfill the aim of miranda... also you will know in further episodes that everyone here is for a reason...like jade, elgen, boyd, etc...they are reincarnated and brought back so that they can prevent the massacre once again that they wasn't able to prevent in their previous life.. things are happening again, for Example elgen said baby saved us/jelped us "ONCE BEFORE"...so the history is repeating itself giving previous souls a chance to fulfill their past tasks.
@@princessjulle1719 I'm thinking we're probably like on loop number 4 to 5 and this current group in fromville are the closest to breaking this loop so that's why thing is changing so I think everyone is a reincarnation of people that were in from ville and have died before, And the monsters know this
Smiley running at full Sprint threw me for surprise 😲 Not at one point did we see the monsters run, but YIKES! if they can run its honestly over for everyone
Smiley had to run to stop Miranda from entering the tree. Also, the old lady was practically floating when she was after Ethan and Julie the night they let the animals loose. The monsters can do whatever they need to do. Just like they let Boyd off Smiley. Cowboy monster was standing behind him the entire time.
Come on be smarter than that It doesn't work that way ! Remember when they kept Randall. He was waving the talisman to their faces and what did they say......
Jade is Christopher and his visions are his other previous incarnations. Tabitha is Miranda and has other previous incarnations. From is Lost and has had other incarnations (mostly soaps that never end).
I really don't understand how people say "oh, all 50 minutes were a waste of time, the whole season was for nothing". Like omg, this is what the show IS. It was the same way 2 seasons before that and tbh, we got more answers in this seasons than we ever got in the previous 2. This show is great and I really like that characters don't get killed off every episode just for the "action" and shock value.
@@zkupnext_9294 Idk where my previous comment went but whatever. We found out Victor's backstory(i feel like he is an important character), we found out that Tabitha made it out and it wasn't just a dream, we kinda found out how the bottle trees work and what happens if the person just goes in. The whole thing about Fatima's pregnancy is actually going fast and I bet we'll get the answer in the next episode. We found out about Thomas' death. We learned who threw the rope to the Boyd like 2 seasons ago. At least those stuff were adressed. And characters talk to each other this season. Like actually have full on conversations about their visions and stuff. People were complaining about this so much and now that we got it - everyone's upset once again. This show was never meant to have fast pace and action happening every second. For god's sake it's literally made by the people who made Lost so what fast pace are people expecting If you are getting bored easily - this is not for you and that's okay but it's just really funny that everyone is sitting here, saying how bad everything is and then watching the next episode just to cry about it
@@BEYONDPREMIEREthat is what I was thinking about her being the sister. What if the sister saw the moms death but escaped through the tree and forgot all about it till now. Like how she has been remembering the town more as a child, Tabitha inherited from Miranda and Julie from Tabitha.
She’s obviously vics sis …why else would she be in the story ..if she’s not vics sis then Vic having a sister would be pointless cuz the story doesn’t change at all wether she’s there or not so clearly tabitha is his sis …that’s why she has the visions cuz of her mom that’s why she had the visions of this place as a kid which were actual experiences not a vision that’s why she was able to leave that’s why she was connected with her dad Henry ..the story has never showed us themes of reincarnation..
@@luechmillionzexactly because when I ask people how was she reincarnated?? They don’t have evidence or a clear answer at all. It would’ve shown that the mom was having a argument with victors dad and taking the kids to run away as end up in the town in FROM because of that tree (I forgot the town name). The bracelet he had as a kid like his mother meaning she could’ve learned how to make them. Just because she has a accent doesn’t mean they aren’t related (lmao they are actors it’s probably hard for her to do an American accent but who cares) we seen a 1 or 2 scenes of Eloise, I wish victor have his memory triggered so he can explain omg your my sister because he is definitely older than her mane by a few years or so but they’ll see unless all our theories are wrong
are we sure tabitha is not eloise? i dont understand the flashbacks as a child if she was miranda. its almost like she has visions of both eloise and miranda.
Well we saw Eloise as a child and tabitha as a child and they both look different. If tabitha and Eloise as a child was in fromville of the same timeline they’d look identical but Tabitha being reincarnated Miranda makes since. Tabitha has had flashbacks of Miranda’s life not Eloise. Also, Tabitha is around the same age as a reincarnated Miranda would be. She’s not as old as Victor meaning she was born around the time Victor lost his mother. That coupled with her having flashbacks as Miranda and also being “chosen” makes much more sense than her being Eloise.
@@lamb8343 well im not even sure its that she is eloise but im more just not sure she is miranda. i thought maybe her dream at the red rocks could be like eloises death but seen through her self rather than the 3rd person like her miranda death vision like its clear she has these visions, but i dont think that makes you a reincarnation. like boyd obviously isnt reincarnated from the priest and he sees his wife as well, people say christopher is jade because he sees the symbol but he also sees like 5 other dead people. and viktor sees people like in the cave or the boy in white. so i just think thats a little too far of a stretch currently. but it is possible it just seems everyone kind of has visions or dreams like boyds wife also had weird dreams that made her go nuts
@@mattgilbert7347OH yes this makes more sense. I was thinking it was Tabitha Astral projecting as a child but forgot the clothes did not fit. It was past memories of another past life.
I get tired of people complaining. I love this show. If enjoy the character development. I love the mystery. Each episode had a purpose and I never was bored. When you tie all the episodes together, its pretty action packed. You guys just want to watch mosters kill and kill without character development.
No, we just want the story to move forward. Nothing happens for 50min I don't need to see people die, nothing is happening. From the first episode of this season till now, not many things changed.
What was the purpose of S3 e7 ? Only 30 seconds of that episode were useful where tillie got shanked. Entire and I mean literally the entire episode other than those 30 seconds was characters talking with each other
Its because i wanted it to remain a horror/mystery show where people get stuck in a town hiding from "Vampires" figuring out a way to kill them or escape and maybe some suspense where if they bite you but dont kill you, they turn into servants, so you never know whose a servant unless you find a bite mark. All this talking doll, music box, Anhkooyey shit is throwing the whole thing off. If they take it back to the original thing that pulled people into the show then it could last for 6 seasons.
It’s also now obvious that there are two entities at odds with each other over this town. One is the BIW and entity. From season 1 I now think the voices Sara heard in Kill The Boy was meant to kill the BIW. And that’s the other entity at work at that time speaking through Sara. In this episode it’s again the other entity speaking through Sara warning the town that they will not save Sara in time. The BIW saving Victor from chopping down the tree because that Far Away Tree holds significance in maybe escaping the town. The show is twisted in how people in the town are representing the spirits of past people that was there in the town. But it’s all very twisted.
That was a pretty good last 5 mins of the episode. The first 52 mins however... i legit FF'd through most those meaningless convos between the characters and didn't miss a step. Sigh. I had such high hopes for this show and especially this season.
Lol yes! I was waiting for him to give some info about what he knew about the numbers or Jade would say something seeing Christopher & the dummy .... then the subject was changed🤦♀️😒
But they never say that the creatures are eating the people. And the creatures are never seen eating the people. Donna even mentions in the beginning of the first season how the monsters just like to kill and rip people apart. I noticed a lot of people say the monsters are eating people so I re-watched the first two seasons to see if I missed anything indicating that the creatures are eating the people they kill. There's nothing about them eating anybody
This episode was great! Tabitha is Miranda confirmed. Everything thing is changing, getting closer to the end of another cycle. I truly believe Jim taking Ethan to the RV is a huge set up for finale reveals. I've had a theory that Victor, Ethan and BIW are all connected and after this episode im about 90% sure they are setting it up. Victor definitely has more memories to conjure up and I believe it's going to be crazy!
I have a theory about the boy in white changing, what if he keeps changing until he finally becomes the man in the yellow suit.. similar to the ending of little nightmares 2.
I believe it’s Tabatha is Eloise not Miranda. Eloise ran out after Miranda. Eloise is also the one that Miranda is whispering in the ear to saying I love you guys so much. We also witness Miranda‘s death through the eyes of Eloise the way that she screams after realizing what’s going on indicates that she saw what happened and was horrified. Plus Victor never found Eloise’s body. I do not believe that Tabatha is a reincarnation of Miranda. I believe she is Eloise. Not even from another timeline, but just is Eloise. And just like Victor she has blocked out the traumatic parts of her life in order to cope and move forward with her life. This is also why she was broughtback to Fromville. The bracelet and the song can be explained away by the fact that her parents probably listen to this song over and over again, and that she saw the bracelet. She even noted that she made a mistake when making the bracelet, which means that she learned it from her mom.
1 hour of nothing, this is what I was worried about. I skipped forward on 99% of it. Just watch the trailer and you'll know enough about the one hour episode to make theories.
I'm assuming it was on purpose but the " you'll never be alone here " line showing up again was nice. I get the feeling that line will have deeper meaning as the show goes on. Maybe that's the line in the story that gave the children hope? Just a thought.
I think mirandas death in the final scene should have been from the hands of some one superior to the monsters.More like...she teleported somewhere underground where the main villian lives and she discovers something there and trys to run back but gets killed my him or his monsters.The way they showed or talked about her as an important person that kind of death (just got killed by smiley) seemed a bit less.
The most frustrating part of this show is every character keeping information from everyone else..Of all the supernatural and unexplained shit they've all been through why are they all keeping secrets still? Like why did Julia say it was just a bad dream? It's unnecessary. They should have everyone in the town get together and share all of their visions, experiences etc. And put it all together to see if there's a pattern... But it's interesting. There are 2 forces playing against each other. The kids in white are showing themselves n helping Tabitha and Victor. The evil side are showing themselves to Eldridge, whispering to Sarah and antagonizing Jim via Thomas.. Lastly reading the description of the next episode it sounds like Fatima won't make it as it states that Boyd suffers the loss of someone close..
Right? All this time they were just choosing to walk slowly... that's actually terrifying when you think about it... I will discuss it in my ending explained video.
This has literally always been the case. From the opening where she basically flies through the window, to attacking Frank in the box. This isnt new information, he just did it from slightly further away this time.
Imagine Miranda was in fact there as a child then escaped making her lose her memories. Then she grew up only to get stuck in the town again, proceeded to die then get reincarnated as Tabitha. Either that or something else keeps reincarnating over and over. Probably the mother of the Angkhooey kids trying to set her kids free but fails every time continuously reincarnating through different women. The angkhooey kids are definitely the only good entities here. All along theyve been trying to get Tabitha to remember who she really is coz thats what angkhooey actually means , "remember." The Boy in white for sure has no good intentions The message that Sarah got was probably meant for the boy in white. Hes physical form is connected to the tree somehow maybe thats why hes a bit panicked about Vic trying to cut down the tree. Hes also probably holding Eloise captive because we don't know what happened to her unless if shes been turned into that lady ( Fae creature that spoke to Victor and then Henry almost identifying her ). If the boy in white really wanted to help, he would have helped ages ago. Hes definitely the entity pulling the strings coz how did he get to where Tabitha was when she Escaped. It means hes the one thats choosing who gets to come to fromville and is watching both Fromville and the outside world all at once.
@Henrique.Souza0601 the tree doesn't lead to "out there," the tree sends people to wherever it wants or where the entity wants. What actually sent Tabitha out was the BIW pushing her out the lighthouse which is also in the confides of fromville. The boy in white seems to be the only entity that actually allows people that use the tree to go to specific areas. Now I'm not saying that he's evil but I highly doubt he is all good either . I feel like he's giving this idea that he's a good person by helping when he can or when he wants to. Explain how this boy is supposedly good after people died and he decided to just play on a merry-go-round and smile at Victor like nothing happened? He left Victor to fend for himself for so long. And the biggest question is why he was capable of being outside of Fromville. The only other possibility is that he is in fact a puppet for the real entity if he isn't the actual antagonist. It would make sense for an evil entity to take the shape of an innocent looking boy vs an adult
its not a question anymore tabitha is miranda her age is same as time victor stayed in town after miranda gone and sorry she is not ellios in any multiverse beacuse elliois would be much older around same as victor may be 3 year young but still very old
I am not convinced, I think she is Eloise, and the scene with Smiley was what she witnessed, not how she died, As Eloise, she say Smiley kill Miranda, then went into the tree and escaped via the lighthouse. but woke up in the real world and like Victor, blocked her memories. We will probably find out that Tabitha was adopted and does not have memories from before she was adopted.
Even the music changed when Tabitha started having her flashbacks. This episode could've been 20 minutes longer. I don't appreciate the drip feed of perspective and information. Season 2 was definetly stronger 😐
What we learn in this episode. Tabitha had flashback of the past life - Miranda. BIW was angry about cutting the tree...something to think about...and he refuse to answer any questions, he does look angry about it too, like he wants to punish them... Elgin has gone insane. Voices that get involved if they are monsters that walk at night, that would mean humans could never actually hide, they choose not to kill some....And we learn they choose to walk, they can run, Smiley run to Miranda, so it was a choice not a rule....Makes me think about other things, if there are any rules or just their choices to make it more fun for them. Finally Jim act like a good father and husband and now I am afraid his healing is over and ....he might not live for long. The children clearly wants Tabitha to remember, not sure if they wanted to take her to Fatima or make her remember...
You picked up on so much! The BIW’s anger over the tree and refusing to answer questions was so intense. The monsters choosing to walk instead of run really changes things, makes you wonder what other rules are just choices. And yeah, Jim stepping up feels like a red flag for his fate... hopefully he makes it!
@@BEYONDPREMIERE I hope it too.. I wish all of them come out alive to be honest....who knows maybe my first theory that all of this is some kind of game/simulation/entertainment is true..but that could be final plot twist, it could connect all dots.... All of this stuff that is happening could be the quests...the reason why BIW is mad is that they are not paying the game and their parts so this could be a reason why he ended them all. I do not believe Christopher got mad and killed them all, he told BIW that he does not believe him and that everything and everyone lie there. From what we have seen this 3 seasons, all entities, people, ghosts, monsters or what ever they are LIE and manipulate them, usually for entertainment, could be something deeper. We do have some answers and plot is going somewhere, but they are doing it that way that we can not be sure what big mystery is. We get answers for small ones tho. Small ones are connected to the big one. I just told my friend today, after this show we all could become detectives or go to the mental hospital and rehabilitation. But I love it, it has not been a tv show this good that make me think, very hard, workout for a brain. This is fun. Real fun, not just watching like a zombie some tv show and not even thinking. This is quality. Sorry for my English, it is not perfect, not my primary language and I did not use google to fix mistakes.
@@caskncream 100% agree...I am conviced that he is the one who controls lot of things there. Faraway trees for one, or should we call them fast travel trees, like we have in the games....And it even have a loading screen of fallen tree and crows every time someone is loading into the game....just saying...it could be the big mystery at the end. That was my first theory and the more clues we get , the more it fits, but...not enough clues still.
I know we will eventually get the answers but these scenes like the ones with Henry and Jade or Donna and Acosta are exactly the reason everyone's so frustrated. It is completely UNNECESSARY.
I got chills when I found out that Miranda is probably Victor’s sister! Because she said that she use to have to hide behind the rock pillars and then she got the flashback touching Victor! I think somehow Miranda had escaped and forgotten about it till she got back in the town! I absolutely ❤ this show! The hour feels like 10 mins!
I don’t understand after the incident with Sarah why they didn’t start having at least weekly town meetings to see if anyone else is hearing voices or having dreams
I noticed that in the Tabitha flashback when Miranda was recing to the Farway Tree that Eliose was not with her. And what a trip! Smiley is the monster who killed her. I'm getting the vibe that Acosta is the reincarnation of Eloise, but that doesn't seem possible because has no past memories of ever being in Fromville
i think tabitha is actually eloise. That was my take when I watched it. she has memories of being their when she was little and eloise is not confirmed dead.
Boy in White said to Christopher that “the answers to the end are in the beginning.” we know the symbol looks like roots, but how could anyone be able to look at the sky through roots? the symbol looks like the view you'd get if you were looking through a hole FROM BELOW A FALLEN TREE, like the one everyone saw at the beginning. A tree falls on a road, someone stops to check it out but they hear children voices, that person gets through the hole, discovering the sacrifice chamber and the kids. Then, that person tell the kids something that gave them hope (going to get help or something?) but that chosen one never returns and the children get killed. So they keep bringing more people hoping eventually, one of the stranded will save them. Also: what if the word "Anghkooey" is actually an acronym like N Q E?
It's like a story thats need to finish, like a quest that's need to solve, if your in the middle of the story or quest if you push high enough, something will push back. Like victor said " this never happened before the snow, what if the boy in white puberty had to do with the story or quest that his changing according to the story, the dancing doll the Chinese women the monster in the wood the things out there that worse than the monster...... Damn i love this series it's keep me overthink 😂😂
Right? The story feels like a puzzle where every push triggers something new. The Boy in White changing could be tied to all these weird events. This show really gets your brain working! 😂
@BEYONDPREMIERE I think Tabitha can't be Miranda or her reincarnation. She is the same age as Victor. I think she is Eloise, Victor's sister. If you remember, when Victor's mom ran out of the basement, Eloise went out too. In the last scene of this episode, we saw Tabitha's memories - she saw her mother (Miranda) being killed by Smiley Face. I think she tried to hide in the Faraway Tree, and she escaped (went through the tree) back to real life. It was a big trauma for her, which is why she couldn't remember it all her life. The only "memory" she had, the nightmare about the three rocks, but that wasn't just a dream; it was a flashback, because she saw them when she was living there!
That’s such an interesting theory! If Tabitha is Eloise, it would explain her childhood memories and the nightmare about the rocks being flashbacks. Escaping through the Faraway Tree makes sense, especially with the trauma blocking her memory. ..... I still have hope is reincarnation.
I like Jade, he’s the most interesting person on the show by a long shot. The actress who plays Julie is a friggen rocket. Besides that, this show has just gotten so, so bad. I’m going to say that Tabitha is not Miranda, she is the daughter. Her vision is from Miranda’s daughter’s point of view hence why Miranda dies but her daughter is not shown. The reason the boy in white sends Tabitha back is to find Henry fully knowing they would arrive back in the town.
I've always thought that Eloise had left the cellar to chase Miranda and that Miranda was dead near the tree because they were getting chased by the monsters and Miranda sacrificed herself for Eloise to enter the tree, but this episode clearly shows us that Eloise didn't went after her mother.. but we see her leaving the cellar. Miranda told them to hide somewhere where Christopher didn't knew, I'm thinking maybe victor didn't told us the full story that the BIW was telling Christopher, and he told him he had to sacrifice the children (Eloise & Victor) and that's why Miranda had them hidden in the cellar... Sadly enough Eloise got out, what if Christopher (Jade's previous reincarnation or role) and I also believe all Jade's visions are his last lifes like Henry told Miranda had seen. The one eyed dude drinking blood from the small skull is OG Jade (Christopher) maybe Christopher found Eloise and ended up sacrificing her 👀😮
So Henry is Tabitha's father and Victor is her brother which means Henry is Ethan's and Julie's grandfather and Victor is their uncle. Ever since Tabitha met Henry, I started believing that she was Eloise and it turned out to be true💯
@mrheartwell812 makes no sense. Miranda was never in Fromville as a kid but Eloise was. Tabitha had nightmares about Fromville as a kid. She's now remembering that she had those nightmares of Fromville as a kid because she was actually there as a kid as Eloise. This wouldn't be possible if she was reincarnated Miranda. The director even showed us Miranda getting killed by Smiley from the audience POV of what Eloise witnessed. If it was Miranda's POV, the scene of her dying would've looked different.
MAN I JUST figured it out Tabetha is Victor's Sister she is seeing what she saw, not victors moms memory....cant explain why Victor's dad wouldn't know his daughter tho, he really has not mentioned having a daughter much or asked what happened to his daughter. Like he already knows she got out
@grahamdavis8777 why not? That's a memory of her previous incarnation waaay back in history. That kid was wearing Puritan-era clothes. That kid was not Miranda.
it was funny how the Boy in white replied to Victor that he is different too the Boy in white aged several years Victor went from being a child to an old man
Tabitha dreamed of the 3 red rocks while she was a little girl. Her dreams was of her as a girl not an adult woman. So if she was reincarnated miranda, that would not make sense. Her dreams were her remembering herself as Eloise seeing the rocks. The phone call home to the mother was to make us think that Tabitha wasnt adopted. I was hoping the mother would trace were the phone call was made and come looking for tabitha. The mother would be stopped by the tree and end up in fromville, and ultimately tell Tabitha that she was adopted. I just think it makes more sense to be Eloise than reincarnated.
@@jeffreytempleton3213 There seems to be different cycles in from vill that must have been on 1800s Miranda, It seems like there's been a loop in fromville all the people there are reincarnations being brought back over and over
@VSMOKE1 I get it, but I'm not sure I'm a fan of the reincarnation theory. I would like it more if they are descendants of the original cursed people. And not everyone, some people are there just because they were with the "reincarnated." If it is reincarnation, I think it would be cool if they are ultimately the reincarnated souls of the children....not probably likely but a different twist. The children's souls keep coming back, and they have to set themselves free. I think people are coming up with such good theories that I hope the ending doesn't disappoint. I was a "Lost" watcher and wasn't really satisfied with its ending. I know everybody wants answers, but I'm hoping one of the seasons flashes back to another Era in from. What if now that Tabitha is revealed, next season starts in the past. Again, probably not happening, but I think it would be cool...
@jeffreytempleton3213 I can dig the reincarnation theory because it really hasn't been done on television now if they would have gone like an alien route I would have been probably on your boat I can't stand it, But with reincarnation it does leave a lot of mystery which is what a lot of people want
I already know the last episode isn’t gonna give us any answers, they still gotta find Fatima, still gotta see if she gives birth or not and maybe Tabitha will have more flashbacks… can’t wait for something crazy to happen and be left with more questions and no answers next week!!!
In the season finale, one of the biggest revelations is about the true nature of the monsters. It is revealed that the monsters are not just supernatural creatures, but rather people who were once trapped in the town and have become corrupted by its dark influence. The creatures that have been terrorizing the survivors were once ordinary humans who had died and been transformed by the malevolent forces controlling the town. The survivors also discover more about the town’s strange cycle, realizing that they are essentially being manipulated by a mysterious entity that controls the supernatural occurrences within the town. The people trapped there are part of a much larger, more complex system than they initially thought, where their deaths or suffering seem to fuel the town's power. In a shocking turn, one of the main characters turns out to have a key role in the town's power structure, potentially offering a way out - or sealing their fate forever. These revelations leave the survivors in a dire situation, with the knowledge that escaping might not be as simple as they thought, and even worse, the forces of the town are more sinister and in control than anyone imagined.
I think Tabitha is Victor's sister....we haven't seen how she supposedly died, I think she got out as a kid and was adopted by someone else after returning home. Notice that they never show her face when they have flashbacks but we have seen Tabitha as a kid...and we know she remembers being in Fromville before. Also, the connection Victor has with Ethan can only be that he is actually his uncle!!
Every conversation is import. Henry and Jade shows how "Victor is not broken and shaped by this place" Donna and Acosta shows how Acosta is still an outsider. Shes still "The Cop" and shes good outside but shes helpless here.
I'm not sure it's a foregone conclusion that Tabitha is Miranda. She could also be Eloise. Unlikely, I agree, but Eloise didn't stay in the root cellar, and perhaps she followed Miranda and saw her death, escaped (or was sent out of the town one way or another), and became Tabitha.
You are mistaken. Tabatha is not the reincarnation of Miranda, but Victor's sister. She probably went through the tree, lost her memories and was adopted by another family. That's why in a previous episode she faintly remembers seeing the red stones as a child.
2nd, if Tabitha is Miranda reincarnated, so supposedly she was supposed to enter the tree and not Christopher to only bring back Henry? Or see the tree she(Miranda)made herself? After Tabitha entered the tree, she traveled to the light house, and nothing was there, and then again, what was the only way the boy in white mentioned because pushing Tabitha?
I was struggling so hard to not fall asleep. The downhill of this season is crazy. 1 episode left. So frustrating to see this season end with NOTHING good.
Remember the dream that Tabatha repeatedly has as a child dressed in colonial costume and she was frightened at the blooded rocks? It is a spiritual connection to Miranda. Tabatha is the next Cromenockle. Not a reincarnation of Miranda. Used for the next level of the game. Miranda was able to draw down her visions of previous cromenockles I believe. Not reincarnations. It is the Cromenockle for the next round gets the opportunity to save the children. Tabatha has different dreams and visions than Miranda has. I hope it makes sense
Thanks for watching! 🙏 Let's discuss your theories:
What do you think about Tabatha being Miranda's reincarnation?
How will Boyd's Parkinson's affect his role as the town's protector?
What's really happening with Fatima and the Lady in Kimono?
If you're new here and enjoy FROM theories & breakdowns, don't forget to subscribe! New episode analysis every week. 🎬
Why she gotta b a reincarnation instead of Victor's sister
@@elr1147 Because of the age, doesn't match.
@BEYONDPREMIERE but we don't kno how old they are?
Let’s just call the lady in the kimono ame onna because yeh just search it up it connects to when Fatima licking her fingers from Nicky’s blood
I think Victor and Tabitha are sister and brother because you can see that the dress worn by Victor's sister in episode 9 and the dress worn by Tabitha in the nightmare in episode 6 are similar.
Victor's conversation with the Boy In White was a metaphor for me and this show.
😂😂
Lmao
Yes!! I feel the same way. 😆
Right? We're all Victor at this point, begging for some clear answers...
Yes, but I thought it was a pretty clever way to deal with the situation. Don't get me wrong, this show stopped being good after season 1, but these last 2 episodes were better. It's like their way of telling us that the characters need to find the answers and not us the audience (Victor) or the writers (BIW) just give it to them. And they're not theorizing and sharing their thoughts with millions of people so it might take a while, but they'll get there.
If only they ditched so much useless dialogue, this show would be awesome.
Only the last 5 minutes of this episode was good. i was hoping something crazy would happen, and that cop is frustrating me. This episode had too much unnecessary talking
I second that! I was so mad when it ended lmao
They’re just egging us on at this point
Lol thought I was the only one i was so upset after and now 1 episode left
the whole season has too much unnecessary talking
@@komongkomongyes you are right
The boy in white should have been like: "Of course I'm changing. Well, I'm going through puberty, Duh!"
I’m about ask Julie to go to the movies 😂
@@BEYONDPREMIERE dude what?
Edit: I'm dumb, you're commenting as The BIW... right? Lol
Victor (Scott Mcord) acted his butt off again in this episode. I felt his emotions. Jade nailed it when talking to Henry about Victor 👏👏
Victor's emotional scenes were incredible... Scott McCord keeps delivering! That conversation between Jade and Henry about him was perfect too.
I love Jade just correcting Fathers, calling them out to look out for their kids better. Hes just out there breaking generational trauma. He should consider running a therapy course once he gets out. Call out bad parents, and put them back on track with looking out for and connecting better with their kids.
That actor has always (at least in this series) done a fabulous job. He kept the same demeanor through and through. Even in season 1 when you first see him you think he’s a creep but then you learn that he’s just a really old kid and his performance just does not let up!
I can’t help but believe that Boyd doesn’t actually have Parkinson. We know that this place has knowledge of their lives out in the real world and this could just be a way of the town to further try to break Boyd. When he’s telling Kenny (i think) that he has Parkinson and that his clock is ticking he mentions that his dad got it around the same age Boyd is now. But he also says that it’s not supposed to be hereditary. Just like Fatima wasn’t supposed to be able to have a child, Boyds’ Parkinson could be something that the town uses to mess with their minds.
But like
That seems far fetched
I only say this because his father had it and it’s hereditary
Boyd definitely got grays in his hair and beard
If he’s aging, and if he’s in his late 40s or early 50s (the character I mean)
Then he could very well just be developing Parkinson’s
@@righteousgaming5207I see what you’re saying but Parkinson only has a few cases that are reported as hereditary. It’s very rare, about 10-15% of reported cases are caused by genetics. And i’m not sure why the show would make it a point to mention that it’s not supposed to be hereditary and then not take this route. Of course I could be completely wrong but to me it makes more sense.
Relax guys. Its not the usual regular Mystery thriller cinema we used to watch. This is psychological horror flick. Human conversations are key to explain things and show how impactful it s before and after tragedy. There are 100s of fast paced movies/series out there. This is unique and rare. Dont spoil it by making creators to rush things
Wise
Thank god, one normal comment that summs up my personal opinion. I hate when people complain that this is a boring show cause it literally isnt. The conversations are the key to understanding the characters and I don't get why people can't see it
The people who are moaning should just realise that not everything is meant for them. This is a classic psychological thriller. There is a lot of talking in movies like Silence of the Lambs. If that was released in this time that Oscar winning movie would be panned for “not enough violence”. People just want to see monsters shred everyone every episode. They are horrifically impatient too.
Its ok for 1,2 or 3 episodes,and not one by one,BUT 9 episodes of stupid talking ,on and on and all the same is not good!!!
@@lsmetankalthe conversations:
-look at me!
-its gonna be ok
- everything is fine
-what is wrong with you
- I don't want to talk about it
- its not your fault
This show’s title is “FROM”, it’s very obvious, the bottle tree is literally a family tree. Everybody is connected to their ancestors. The dates are the birthdays of the resurrected family members for the past generations. The victims are the Anghkooey kids. the villains are the one who sacrificed them. The actors now are the parents of the kids from multiple generations making them pay for what their ancestors did “FROM” their past life
This one is spot on!
make sense, its like those stories people talks about Salem where the witches curse all the people in town and continue in generation kinda. Some religion and beliefs in ancient time, children was already chosen as sacrifice before being born and they grow up in another environment than the other children. Maybe thats why the children was born in the dark and killed in the dark, if they seen sunlight they would be tainted and unvalid for sacrifice. And the nr is a family tree that would make sence. I only need to remember the number one of them was named..
Things go in cycles, FROM 1506
no the numbers are what allows them to travel through trees without the risk of randomization
The numbers r music
The biggest moment of this episode for me, "SMILY RUNNING!!!!"
Samee!!!! I wonder what the other one meant when she said "That's not how it works Rendall" with the talisman...perfect opportunity for man to have asked "how does it work, and everything else!?"..haha, i think they sick enough to explain the rules to him
😂 The monster said it doesn't work like that because He wasnt in a structure. That's so obvious! Like how can you be so clueless @@giornoGiovanna555
@giornoGiovanna555 they have to be in an enclosed space. Remember when Fatima saved herself and Ellis by closing the doors to the foyer and putting up the talisman?
smily will run again
@@RahYisrael99 I do, but even in enclosed spaces they have to be place in a certain way..maybe certain area, like you can't just have it in your house then say you're safe, so how does it work is still a question..like they told Rendall if it falls from the bus door its over..so it can be by the door but placed in a high area, middle.??we don't know...but again, my statement wasn't mainly on the talisman, but Rendall using that opportunity to ask how the rules work..not just to do with the talisman but in everything..like is it their choice to only come out at night like they choose to walk instead of running to catch their prey?? Rules
The acting in this episode was probably the best of the entire show so far. Sometimes there are weaker links between some of the less talented actors on the show, but everyone in this episode was truly excellent, in particular the actress who plays Fatima did a phenomenal job.
I agree 100% I was questioning Tabitha the actress acting and also Fatima's However they pulled it off in this episode, hopefully they can keep it up.
Agreed! Also loved Jade and Henry’s interaction. Jade is definitely my favorite character.
your bugging! horrible acting. Besides the past 3 episodes being dragged out and not giving any info of whats going on. Fatima isn't trying to escape, Elgin isn't being tuff enough to keep her there. it all seem fake!
Did anyone else notice Tabitha pulling herself from her daughter while simultaneously reaching out for victor in the final scene ?
Yes! I’m like hmmm that’s strange
@tashaenadekle imagine she just discovered she's Miranda and feels sorry for what victor has been through and decides she wants to be with him and her husband (victor's dad) causing conflict between her real husband and victor's dad.
@@amosreynolds7789 I doubt she has all the memories & feelings just specific ones.
@@amosreynolds7789bruh what😂
I was thinking Victor her brother
Elgin has that “Im sold out to a cult” glaze in his eyes. He is reverent to this thing haunting him. He is doing a phenomenal acting job, but I wanted to clobber him this entire episode lol.
Come on Fatima! Cutting his hand was going to do WHAT?
Should of did him like she did Tilly 😂😂😂😂
I thought Fatima was going to stab him in the face🤦♀️
Ngl I thought she cut his finger off and I thought she was gonna be looking at it and get real hungry and eat it
@@mjl7437 That would have been epic 💯
@@caskncream 😂😂💀
It's so beautiful to see that, Tabitha has not only Miranda's memories but also Miranda's feelings and emotions.
I was thinking she Victor sister
@@nicolesright4800 same but she continued to have Miranda's flashbacks, implying that she is Miranda's reincarnate
Wish It, Want It, Do It
It's not beautiful, it's awful story. Tabitha is younger probably then victor and she is reincarnation of his mother. It's way more better for she to be his sister
@@giornoGiovanna555 was it miranda's flashback or was it just eloise remembering her mom being killed when she chased after her?
Those monsters can run . Only when they are in their monstor form
We knew that though. They only walk because they like playing with their food.
They could always run, they just chose not to...which I love!
That’s fucked
I agree I think that’s why the monster was able to get up on father Kharti so quickly
I think smiley ran because it didn't want her to escape though the tree.. Remember the town knows what you're are thinking he probably knew she was going to save the children
Elgin several times said "It's going to save the town", so he cares more about the place, not the people.
Yeah his words are suspicious... always about the town, never about saving the people...
Could he meant town as the collective of people?
@@deer5647 the kimono lady is trying to shut Fatima because victor and Tabitha us outside that room and they won't hear her. That's why she has put her hand on Fatima.
@@deer5647 yep. notice his shirt has a black crow on it. we know what that means.
My boy Elgin went full serial killer vibes this episode 😂😂
I disliked Fatima for a couple of episodes but seeing this I truly feel bad for her and props to the actress Pegah Ghafoori, she nailed the acting!
The way she played Fatima's emotional scenes was so powerful... completely changed how I see her character!
@@deer5647 me too. And I'd be really sad if she dies.
@@deer5647 💯 . I just hope she doesn't become one of those monsters or get attacked by one of them if she were to die. She was traumatized enough even before she entered "From town" (her father was shot in front of her eyes as she said in season 1) . The character deserves a good ending at least !
Most people have been complaining that nobody talks to each other, then in this episode we get some answers through conversations, and folks don't like it 🤷♀️
Obviously you think it's just about talking that's not what people were saying they need to talk about important shit
@VSMOKE1 not obviously but that is how you learn about each other's experiences that the show is explaining to you through their talking.
Sometimes, it's just meaningless conversations eating up time
i know its a "tv show" but the lack of conversations is not real. all the charters or on their on quest or dealing with there own problems. Acosta is the most real person thus far
@@mjl7437 exactly
I like watching these types of channels, including this channel, after watching the latest episode. Something I'm noticing nobody else pointing out is that once Sara completed that little statue her brother gave her and that Kenny's broke in a fit of rage, that's when the voices came back. I wonder if there's a correlation there of some sort.
Well the main plot is:
The only way to go out if town is to go through a faraway bottle tree at NIGHT. Smiley run and riped miranda apart when she was about to do this. But the aim of that soul was not fulfilled. She died in 1978 and hence reincarnated thriugh tabitha who born at the same time in 1978, she was brought to the town when she was at the same age as miranda was when she died. Tabitha's son is ethan (in her previous life her son was victor,) and her daughter is julie (in prev life it was eloise). Now tabitha has to fulfill the aim of miranda... also you will know in further episodes that everyone here is for a reason...like jade, elgen, boyd, etc...they are reincarnated and brought back so that they can prevent the massacre once again that they wasn't able to prevent in their previous life.. things are happening again, for Example elgen said baby saved us/jelped us "ONCE BEFORE"...so the history is repeating itself giving previous souls a chance to fulfill their past tasks.
This ^
@@princessjulle1719 I'm thinking we're probably like on loop number 4 to 5 and this current group in fromville are the closest to breaking this loop so that's why thing is changing so I think everyone is a reincarnation of people that were in from ville and have died before, And the monsters know this
Elgin feeling some type of emotions after Ellis mentioned 😮his mom died there, probably means something toon
Tabitha went through it during the day
bruh itd be crazy if they could only escape during nighttime. diabolic
Smiley running at full Sprint threw me for surprise 😲
Not at one point did we see the monsters run, but YIKES! if they can run its honestly over for everyone
Right? They never ran before.... and now Smiley is sprinting like that. Everyone's in trouble....
Most of the time it seems like it's all a game for them. That time she got too close to something.
He was really trying to stop her. Miranda was on to something. Most of the time they enjoy playing with the humans.
@@KingOfEthanopiaexactly.
Smiley had to run to stop Miranda from entering the tree. Also, the old lady was practically floating when she was after Ethan and Julie the night they let the animals loose. The monsters can do whatever they need to do. Just like they let Boyd off Smiley. Cowboy monster was standing behind him the entire time.
Why is it that they don’t put a talisman in front of the cave entrance?
Thought that as well, but...they probably dug the tunnels so they could probably dig a way out (if there isnt other exit's already)
Come on be smarter than that
It doesn't work that way ! Remember when they kept Randall. He was waving the talisman to their faces and what did they say......
Did anyone notice the secret room, where Fatima is, changed in size? It's twice the size of when we first saw it.
ur tripping
@@MagnusErikAlexanderJohansson definitely tripping the room the same size
One thing I just noticed no one's talking about smiley running we've never seen them run
i noticed thst aswell
Jade is Christopher and his visions are his other previous incarnations.
Tabitha is Miranda and has other previous incarnations.
From is Lost and has had other incarnations (mostly soaps that never end).
Haha yeah... looks like reincarnation is definitely part of it after everything we've seen! 😅
I really don't understand how people say "oh, all 50 minutes were a waste of time, the whole season was for nothing". Like omg, this is what the show IS. It was the same way 2 seasons before that and tbh, we got more answers in this seasons than we ever got in the previous 2.
This show is great and I really like that characters don't get killed off every episode just for the "action" and shock value.
👏👏👏 Very well said!
And what are those answers we got?
So what answers did we get so far ?
List the answers for the people who missed em ig
@@zkupnext_9294 Idk where my previous comment went but whatever. We found out Victor's backstory(i feel like he is an important character), we found out that Tabitha made it out and it wasn't just a dream, we kinda found out how the bottle trees work and what happens if the person just goes in. The whole thing about Fatima's pregnancy is actually going fast and I bet we'll get the answer in the next episode. We found out about Thomas' death. We learned who threw the rope to the Boyd like 2 seasons ago.
At least those stuff were adressed. And characters talk to each other this season. Like actually have full on conversations about their visions and stuff. People were complaining about this so much and now that we got it - everyone's upset once again.
This show was never meant to have fast pace and action happening every second. For god's sake it's literally made by the people who made Lost so what fast pace are people expecting
If you are getting bored easily - this is not for you and that's okay but it's just really funny that everyone is sitting here, saying how bad everything is and then watching the next episode just to cry about it
What if Tabitha is Victor’s sister, when she saw Victor’s mother was through her eyes as a child
That’s a fascinating idea! But we focus on Miranda's last moments not Eloise...
@@BEYONDPREMIERE also the child actors used for Eloise and Tabitha were not same.
@@BEYONDPREMIEREthat is what I was thinking about her being the sister. What if the sister saw the moms death but escaped through the tree and forgot all about it till now. Like how she has been remembering the town more as a child, Tabitha inherited from Miranda and Julie from Tabitha.
She’s obviously vics sis …why else would she be in the story ..if she’s not vics sis then Vic having a sister would be pointless cuz the story doesn’t change at all wether she’s there or not so clearly tabitha is his sis …that’s why she has the visions cuz of her mom that’s why she had the visions of this place as a kid which were actual experiences not a vision that’s why she was able to leave that’s why she was connected with her dad Henry ..the story has never showed us themes of reincarnation..
@@luechmillionzexactly because when I ask people how was she reincarnated?? They don’t have evidence or a clear answer at all. It would’ve shown that the mom was having a argument with victors dad and taking the kids to run away as end up in the town in FROM because of that tree (I forgot the town name). The bracelet he had as a kid like his mother meaning she could’ve learned how to make them. Just because she has a accent doesn’t mean they aren’t related (lmao they are actors it’s probably hard for her to do an American accent but who cares) we seen a 1 or 2 scenes of Eloise, I wish victor have his memory triggered so he can explain omg your my sister because he is definitely older than her mane by a few years or so but they’ll see unless all our theories are wrong
are we sure tabitha is not eloise? i dont understand the flashbacks as a child if she was miranda. its almost like she has visions of both eloise and miranda.
Well we saw Eloise as a child and tabitha as a child and they both look different. If tabitha and Eloise as a child was in fromville of the same timeline they’d look identical but Tabitha being reincarnated Miranda makes since. Tabitha has had flashbacks of Miranda’s life not Eloise. Also, Tabitha is around the same age as a reincarnated Miranda would be. She’s not as old as Victor meaning she was born around the time Victor lost his mother. That coupled with her having flashbacks as Miranda and also being “chosen” makes much more sense than her being Eloise.
@@lamb8343 well im not even sure its that she is eloise but im more just not sure she is miranda. i thought maybe her dream at the red rocks could be like eloises death but seen through her self rather than the 3rd person like her miranda death vision
like its clear she has these visions, but i dont think that makes you a reincarnation.
like boyd obviously isnt reincarnated from the priest and he sees his wife as well, people say christopher is jade because he sees the symbol but he also sees like 5 other dead people.
and viktor sees people like in the cave or the boy in white.
so i just think thats a little too far of a stretch currently. but it is possible it just seems everyone kind of has visions or dreams like boyds wife also had weird dreams that made her go nuts
We saw at least three of her lives.
Tabitha
Miranda
An unnamed girl from the Puritan era (not Miranda)
@@mattgilbert7347OH yes this makes more sense. I was thinking it was Tabitha Astral projecting as a child but forgot the clothes did not fit. It was past memories of another past life.
Who Eloise
I get tired of people complaining. I love this show. If enjoy the character development. I love the mystery. Each episode had a purpose and I never was bored. When you tie all the episodes together, its pretty action packed. You guys just want to watch mosters kill and kill without character development.
No, we just want the story to move forward. Nothing happens for 50min
I don't need to see people die, nothing is happening. From the first episode of this season till now, not many things changed.
What was the purpose of S3 e7 ? Only 30 seconds of that episode were useful where tillie got shanked. Entire and I mean literally the entire episode other than those 30 seconds was characters talking with each other
@@DmadPsfacts
Absolute snooze fest
Its because i wanted it to remain a horror/mystery show where people get stuck in a town hiding from "Vampires" figuring out a way to kill them or escape and maybe some suspense where if they bite you but dont kill you, they turn into servants, so you never know whose a servant unless you find a bite mark. All this talking doll, music box, Anhkooyey shit is throwing the whole thing off. If they take it back to the original thing that pulled people into the show then it could last for 6 seasons.
It’s also now obvious that there are two entities at odds with each other over this town. One is the BIW and entity. From season 1 I now think the voices Sara heard in Kill The Boy was meant to kill the BIW. And that’s the other entity at work at that time speaking through Sara. In this episode it’s again the other entity speaking through Sara warning the town that they will not save Sara in time. The BIW saving Victor from chopping down the tree because that Far Away Tree holds significance in maybe escaping the town. The show is twisted in how people in the town are representing the spirits of past people that was there in the town. But it’s all very twisted.
That was a pretty good last 5 mins of the episode.
The first 52 mins however... i legit FF'd through most those meaningless convos between the characters and didn't miss a step.
Sigh. I had such high hopes for this show and especially this season.
Yea this season definitely let me down!!!!
Season 3 of From. All build up and very little pay off.
It's like a movie's worth of good stuff. But I still watch. I even enjoy some parts.
But soooo much filler
Yeah the last 5 mins with Smiley running were intense... but all those conversations before could've been tightened up a bit...
The conversations weren't meaningless. They just won't have much meaning till next episode
When the puberty boy in white showed up i gasped. Even his demeanor is giving teenage dirtbag 😂
😂
I like how they bait us Henry seem like he knew something about the numbers in the bottle
Lol yes! I was waiting for him to give some info about what he knew about the numbers or Jade would say something seeing Christopher & the dummy .... then the subject was changed🤦♀️😒
Henry is suspicous
But they never say that the creatures are eating the people. And the creatures are never seen eating the people. Donna even mentions in the beginning of the first season how the monsters just like to kill and rip people apart.
I noticed a lot of people say the monsters are eating people so I re-watched the first two seasons to see if I missed anything indicating that the creatures are eating the people they kill. There's nothing about them eating anybody
Maybe they drink their blood but would the bodies not be much paler?
Your exactly right. They def don't eat people. They rip them apart. That's all we have seen
They probably rip them open looking for something...or just eat their heart??😮
This episode was great! Tabitha is Miranda confirmed. Everything thing is changing, getting closer to the end of another cycle. I truly believe Jim taking Ethan to the RV is a huge set up for finale reveals. I've had a theory that Victor, Ethan and BIW are all connected and after this episode im about 90% sure they are setting it up. Victor definitely has more memories to conjure up and I believe it's going to be crazy!
I have a theory about the boy in white changing, what if he keeps changing until he finally becomes the man in the yellow suit.. similar to the ending of little nightmares 2.
Cant wait to watch from in its full setting instead of waiting every week
I believe it’s Tabatha is Eloise not Miranda. Eloise ran out after Miranda. Eloise is also the one that Miranda is whispering in the ear to saying I love you guys so much. We also witness Miranda‘s death through the eyes of Eloise the way that she screams after realizing what’s going on indicates that she saw what happened and was horrified. Plus Victor never found Eloise’s body. I do not believe that Tabatha is a reincarnation of Miranda. I believe she is Eloise. Not even from another timeline, but just is Eloise. And just like Victor she has blocked out the traumatic parts of her life in order to cope and move forward with her life. This is also why she was broughtback to Fromville. The bracelet and the song can be explained away by the fact that her parents probably listen to this song over and over again, and that she saw the bracelet. She even noted that she made a mistake when making the bracelet, which means that she learned it from her mom.
1 hour of nothing, this is what I was worried about. I skipped forward on 99% of it. Just watch the trailer and you'll know enough about the one hour episode to make theories.
Yeah I agree, the pacing wasn’t ideal this episode... I tried to highlight the key things you need to know to prepare for the next one in my video.
I'm assuming it was on purpose but the " you'll never be alone here " line showing up again was nice.
I get the feeling that line will have deeper meaning as the show goes on.
Maybe that's the line in the story that gave the children hope? Just a thought.
Now, we just need Jade to touch Jasper to find out that he is Christopher
Right? If Jade just touches Jasper and we find out he’s Christopher, that would be such a twist! 😂
@ Jade has been in From as all the characters that he saw.
I think Jasper will talk to Jade
Jasper scared the hell out of me again😅
The man who plays the character Victor is an amazing actor. Sara is still my favorite character.
@@mrrightnow1532 the acting of Jade and Victor is incredible 🙌
@@BEYONDPREMIERE i agree. Everyone is doing an amazing job on this show.
They are setting up Jim for the sacrifice 😢. RIP
lol now he says he’s all in. Too late MF
Yep. He dead.
Just when we're getting Season 1 Jim back, they will take him away from us 😢
I think mirandas death in the final scene should have been from the hands of some one superior to the monsters.More like...she teleported somewhere underground where the main villian lives and she discovers something there and trys to run back but gets killed my him or his monsters.The way they showed or talked about her as an important person that kind of death (just got killed by smiley) seemed a bit less.
The most frustrating part of this show is every character keeping information from everyone else..Of all the supernatural and unexplained shit they've all been through why are they all keeping secrets still? Like why did Julia say it was just a bad dream? It's unnecessary.
They should have everyone in the town get together and share all of their visions, experiences etc. And put it all together to see if there's a pattern...
But it's interesting. There are 2 forces playing against each other. The kids in white are showing themselves n helping Tabitha and Victor.
The evil side are showing themselves to Eldridge, whispering to Sarah and antagonizing Jim via Thomas..
Lastly reading the description of the next episode it sounds like Fatima won't make it as it states that Boyd suffers the loss of someone close..
You didn't mention that we learned that the Nightmare Monsters can run and move real fast if they want to.
They always move and have more strength in monster form.
Guy in box
Right? All this time they were just choosing to walk slowly... that's actually terrifying when you think about it... I will discuss it in my ending explained video.
@@colt5189 the priest to. They even shown in the barn, they need to be in monster form to have strength and move fast.
This has literally always been the case.
From the opening where she basically flies through the window, to attacking Frank in the box. This isnt new information, he just did it from slightly further away this time.
Imagine Miranda was in fact there as a child then escaped making her lose her memories. Then she grew up only to get stuck in the town again, proceeded to die then get reincarnated as Tabitha.
Either that or something else keeps reincarnating over and over. Probably the mother of the Angkhooey kids trying to set her kids free but fails every time continuously reincarnating through different women.
The angkhooey kids are definitely the only good entities here. All along theyve been trying to get Tabitha to remember who she really is coz thats what angkhooey actually means , "remember." The Boy in white for sure has no good intentions
The message that Sarah got was probably meant for the boy in white. Hes physical form is connected to the tree somehow maybe thats why hes a bit panicked about Vic trying to cut down the tree. Hes also probably holding Eloise captive because we don't know what happened to her unless if shes been turned into that lady ( Fae creature that spoke to Victor and then Henry almost identifying her ). If the boy in white really wanted to help, he would have helped ages ago. Hes definitely the entity pulling the strings coz how did he get to where Tabitha was when she Escaped. It means hes the one thats choosing who gets to come to fromville and is watching both Fromville and the outside world all at once.
I believe she has been reincarnated multiple times not just one time.
That's a cool idea about angkhooey... could explain why memories are such a big part of this season...
Tabitha could have astral projected as a child to Fromville just like Julie did.
Man the BIW literally stopped Victor from chopping the tree that leads to out of there. How in hell do you still think he is evil? Smh
@Henrique.Souza0601 the tree doesn't lead to "out there," the tree sends people to wherever it wants or where the entity wants. What actually sent Tabitha out was the BIW pushing her out the lighthouse which is also in the confides of fromville. The boy in white seems to be the only entity that actually allows people that use the tree to go to specific areas. Now I'm not saying that he's evil but I highly doubt he is all good either . I feel like he's giving this idea that he's a good person by helping when he can or when he wants to. Explain how this boy is supposedly good after people died and he decided to just play on a merry-go-round and smile at Victor like nothing happened? He left Victor to fend for himself for so long. And the biggest question is why he was capable of being outside of Fromville. The only other possibility is that he is in fact a puppet for the real entity if he isn't the actual antagonist. It would make sense for an evil entity to take the shape of an innocent looking boy vs an adult
I think you're wrong about this. I'm pretty sure Tabitha is Victor's sister
its not a question anymore tabitha is miranda
her age is same as time victor stayed in town after miranda gone
and sorry she is not ellios in any multiverse beacuse elliois would be much older around same as victor may be 3 year young but still very old
Yeah the ages add up perfectly for Tabitha being Miranda... Eloise would be way older by now...
I am not convinced, I think she is Eloise, and the scene with Smiley was what she witnessed, not how she died,
As Eloise, she say Smiley kill Miranda, then went into the tree and escaped via the lighthouse. but woke up in the real world and like Victor, blocked her memories.
We will probably find out that Tabitha was adopted and does not have memories from before she was adopted.
The reincarnation is connected to the tabathas bracelet being 2. Prolly Moranda from a different time
Exactly!
Well one question was answered. Miranda never reached the Far Away tree. She never went through.
Ladies and gentlemen, we now have a show again! Thank god
Another mostly dead rubber stretched out episode setting up more mysteries.
Too much unnecessary talking
I agree I was more interested in Fatima story and the monsters trolling Boyd
Even the music changed when Tabitha started having her flashbacks.
This episode could've been 20 minutes longer. I don't appreciate the drip feed of perspective and information. Season 2 was definetly stronger 😐
Does the talisman really work? Or the monsters are just toying around and doing it for fun?
We know they love to play. Imagine the horror I they just grab the talisman & go " sike" 😱🤯☠
I bet you there are 3 are 4 cliffhangers in this episode. I remember the days, when there only use to be, 1.
we only have questions at this point and no answers
we got answers dumbass
@@bubsrt lol you mad at opinions lololool so childish
What we learn in this episode. Tabitha had flashback of the past life - Miranda. BIW was angry about cutting the tree...something to think about...and he refuse to answer any questions, he does look angry about it too, like he wants to punish them... Elgin has gone insane. Voices that get involved if they are monsters that walk at night, that would mean humans could never actually hide, they choose not to kill some....And we learn they choose to walk, they can run, Smiley run to Miranda, so it was a choice not a rule....Makes me think about other things, if there are any rules or just their choices to make it more fun for them.
Finally Jim act like a good father and husband and now I am afraid his healing is over and ....he might not live for long.
The children clearly wants Tabitha to remember, not sure if they wanted to take her to Fatima or make her remember...
You picked up on so much! The BIW’s anger over the tree and refusing to answer questions was so intense. The monsters choosing to walk instead of run really changes things, makes you wonder what other rules are just choices. And yeah, Jim stepping up feels like a red flag for his fate... hopefully he makes it!
BIW had his fists balled up all crazy. Hes about to unleash chaos. I don’t trust him.
@@BEYONDPREMIERE I hope it too.. I wish all of them come out alive to be honest....who knows maybe my first theory that all of this is some kind of game/simulation/entertainment is true..but that could be final plot twist, it could connect all dots.... All of this stuff that is happening could be the quests...the reason why BIW is mad is that they are not paying the game and their parts so this could be a reason why he ended them all. I do not believe Christopher got mad and killed them all, he told BIW that he does not believe him and that everything and everyone lie there. From what we have seen this 3 seasons, all entities, people, ghosts, monsters or what ever they are LIE and manipulate them, usually for entertainment, could be something deeper. We do have some answers and plot is going somewhere, but they are doing it that way that we can not be sure what big mystery is. We get answers for small ones tho. Small ones are connected to the big one.
I just told my friend today, after this show we all could become detectives or go to the mental hospital and rehabilitation. But I love it, it has not been a tv show this good that make me think, very hard, workout for a brain. This is fun. Real fun, not just watching like a zombie some tv show and not even thinking. This is quality.
Sorry for my English, it is not perfect, not my primary language and I did not use google to fix mistakes.
@@caskncream 100% agree...I am conviced that he is the one who controls lot of things there. Faraway trees for one, or should we call them fast travel trees, like we have in the games....And it even have a loading screen of fallen tree and crows every time someone is loading into the game....just saying...it could be the big mystery at the end. That was my first theory and the more clues we get , the more it fits, but...not enough clues still.
Characters are aging faster than we get answers
tabitha is hot
I know we will eventually get the answers but these scenes like the ones with Henry and Jade or Donna and Acosta are exactly the reason everyone's so frustrated. It is completely UNNECESSARY.
I got chills when I found out that Miranda is probably Victor’s sister! Because she said that she use to have to hide behind the rock pillars and then she got the flashback touching Victor! I think somehow Miranda had escaped and forgotten about it till she got back in the town! I absolutely ❤ this show! The hour feels like 10 mins!
I don’t understand after the incident with Sarah why they didn’t start having at least weekly town meetings to see if anyone else is hearing voices or having dreams
I noticed that in the Tabitha flashback when Miranda was recing to the Farway Tree that Eliose was not with her. And what a trip! Smiley is the monster who killed her. I'm getting the vibe that Acosta is the reincarnation of Eloise, but that doesn't seem possible because has no past memories of ever being in Fromville
Sarah didn't start hearing voices again until once she put that ornament together. She's been voice free since Kenny smashed it.
Boyd's not going anywhere, he's the face of the show, he'll be around up till the end.
That’s what I thought about Ned Stark. Surprise.
i think tabitha is actually eloise. That was my take when I watched it. she has memories of being their when she was little and eloise is not confirmed dead.
@@ValexieDesigns so reincarnation of Eloise?
@@BEYONDPREMIERE No, I was thinking same Eloise from the same time line. No reincarnation at all.
Boy in White said to Christopher that “the answers to the end are in the beginning.” we know the symbol looks like roots, but how could anyone be able to look at the sky through roots? the symbol looks like the view you'd get if you were looking through a hole FROM BELOW A FALLEN TREE, like the one everyone saw at the beginning. A tree falls on a road, someone stops to check it out but they hear children voices, that person gets through the hole, discovering the sacrifice chamber and the kids. Then, that person tell the kids something that gave them hope (going to get help or something?) but that chosen one never returns and the children get killed. So they keep bringing more people hoping eventually, one of the stranded will save them.
Also: what if the word "Anghkooey" is actually an acronym like N Q E?
the boy in white is the director of the show)) the viewers are screaming help us - you have to guess for yourself
It's like a story thats need to finish, like a quest that's need to solve, if your in the middle of the story or quest if you push high enough, something will push back. Like victor said " this never happened before the snow, what if the boy in white puberty had to do with the story or quest that his changing according to the story, the dancing doll the Chinese women the monster in the wood the things out there that worse than the monster...... Damn i love this series it's keep me overthink 😂😂
Right? The story feels like a puzzle where every push triggers something new. The Boy in White changing could be tied to all these weird events. This show really gets your brain working! 😂
@BEYONDPREMIERE
I think Tabitha can't be Miranda or her reincarnation.
She is the same age as Victor.
I think she is Eloise, Victor's sister. If you remember, when Victor's mom ran out of the basement, Eloise went out too. In the last scene of this episode, we saw Tabitha's memories - she saw her mother (Miranda) being killed by Smiley Face. I think she tried to hide in the Faraway Tree, and she escaped (went through the tree) back to real life. It was a big trauma for her, which is why she couldn't remember it all her life.
The only "memory" she had, the nightmare about the three rocks, but that wasn't just a dream; it was a flashback, because she saw them when she was living there!
That’s such an interesting theory! If Tabitha is Eloise, it would explain her childhood memories and the nightmare about the rocks being flashbacks. Escaping through the Faraway Tree makes sense, especially with the trauma blocking her memory. ..... I still have hope is reincarnation.
@@BEYONDPREMIERE in this show anything can happen! 😁
Eloise wouldn't recognize her own father when Victor did it right away? 😅
@@hsblw_6 exactly! haha
idk... she spoke to and called her mom when she got out. how would she just forget that her mom and brother were in the town if she escaped?
What did elign mean when he said the baby saved /helped us once before?
he didn't say the baby o gess he said maybe the baby is honna save us like anything before happen to save us
I like Jade, he’s the most interesting person on the show by a long shot. The actress who plays Julie is a friggen rocket. Besides that, this show has just gotten so, so bad. I’m going to say that Tabitha is not Miranda, she is the daughter. Her vision is from Miranda’s daughter’s point of view hence why Miranda dies but her daughter is not shown. The reason the boy in white sends Tabitha back is to find Henry fully knowing they would arrive back in the town.
I've always thought that Eloise had left the cellar to chase Miranda and that Miranda was dead near the tree because they were getting chased by the monsters and Miranda sacrificed herself for Eloise to enter the tree, but this episode clearly shows us that Eloise didn't went after her mother.. but we see her leaving the cellar.
Miranda told them to hide somewhere where Christopher didn't knew, I'm thinking maybe victor didn't told us the full story that the BIW was telling Christopher, and he told him he had to sacrifice the children (Eloise & Victor) and that's why Miranda had them hidden in the cellar... Sadly enough Eloise got out, what if Christopher (Jade's previous reincarnation or role) and I also believe all Jade's visions are his last lifes like Henry told Miranda had seen. The one eyed dude drinking blood from the small skull is OG Jade (Christopher) maybe Christopher found Eloise and ended up sacrificing her 👀😮
I guess season 4 will be past of old folks.. If they are stretching
wäre toll
Hope not... we need answers, not more stretching of the story into the past...
So Henry is Tabitha's father and Victor is her brother which means Henry is Ethan's and Julie's grandfather and Victor is their uncle. Ever since Tabitha met Henry, I started believing that she was Eloise and it turned out to be true💯
she is miranda reincarnated
@mrheartwell812 makes no sense. Miranda was never in Fromville as a kid but Eloise was. Tabitha had nightmares about Fromville as a kid. She's now remembering that she had those nightmares of Fromville as a kid because she was actually there as a kid as Eloise. This wouldn't be possible if she was reincarnated Miranda. The director even showed us Miranda getting killed by Smiley from the audience POV of what Eloise witnessed. If it was Miranda's POV, the scene of her dying would've looked different.
MAN I JUST figured it out
Tabetha is Victor's Sister she is seeing what she saw, not victors moms memory....cant explain why Victor's dad wouldn't know his daughter tho, he really has not mentioned having a daughter much or asked what happened to his daughter. Like he already knows she got out
Tabitha is Miranda reincarnated
The timeline doesn't quite work for that... Eloise would be much older than Tabitha if she was Victor's sister...
@@mattgilbert7347 But that wouldnt make sense with her memories of being a child and the 3 red stones/totems.
@grahamdavis8777 why not? That's a memory of her previous incarnation waaay back in history. That kid was wearing Puritan-era clothes. That kid was not Miranda.
@@grahamdavis8777 like Jade, she's had memories or "visions" of more than one previous incarnation
it was funny how the Boy in white replied to Victor that he is different too
the Boy in white aged several years
Victor went from being a child to an old man
I'm just here to watch the video today. Cheers!
Glad you’re here!
Me talking to the writer of FROM 12:10
Hahaha
Tabitha dreamed of the 3 red rocks while she was a little girl. Her dreams was of her as a girl not an adult woman. So if she was reincarnated miranda, that would not make sense. Her dreams were her remembering herself as Eloise seeing the rocks. The phone call home to the mother was to make us think that Tabitha wasnt adopted. I was hoping the mother would trace were the phone call was made and come looking for tabitha. The mother would be stopped by the tree and end up in fromville, and ultimately tell Tabitha that she was adopted. I just think it makes more sense to be Eloise than reincarnated.
@@jeffreytempleton3213 There seems to be different cycles in from vill that must have been on 1800s Miranda, It seems like there's been a loop in fromville all the people there are reincarnations being brought back over and over
@VSMOKE1 I get it, but I'm not sure I'm a fan of the reincarnation theory. I would like it more if they are descendants of the original cursed people. And not everyone, some people are there just because they were with the "reincarnated." If it is reincarnation, I think it would be cool if they are ultimately the reincarnated souls of the children....not probably likely but a different twist. The children's souls keep coming back, and they have to set themselves free.
I think people are coming up with such good theories that I hope the ending doesn't disappoint. I was a "Lost" watcher and wasn't really satisfied with its ending. I know everybody wants answers, but I'm hoping one of the seasons flashes back to another Era in from. What if now that Tabitha is revealed, next season starts in the past. Again, probably not happening, but I think it would be cool...
@jeffreytempleton3213 I can dig the reincarnation theory because it really hasn't been done on television now if they would have gone like an alien route I would have been probably on your boat I can't stand it, But with reincarnation it does leave a lot of mystery which is what a lot of people want
How u find ep 9? on prim is only 7ep out
All the seasons including the new seasons and episodes are on mgm plus you have to pay for a subscription or you can do a free trial
@@nubianbeauty8844 thx
I already know the last episode isn’t gonna give us any answers, they still gotta find Fatima, still gotta see if she gives birth or not and maybe Tabitha will have more flashbacks… can’t wait for something crazy to happen and be left with more questions and no answers next week!!!
In the season finale, one of the biggest revelations is about the true nature of the monsters. It is revealed that the monsters are not just supernatural creatures, but rather people who were once trapped in the town and have become corrupted by its dark influence. The creatures that have been terrorizing the survivors were once ordinary humans who had died and been transformed by the malevolent forces controlling the town.
The survivors also discover more about the town’s strange cycle, realizing that they are essentially being manipulated by a mysterious entity that controls the supernatural occurrences within the town. The people trapped there are part of a much larger, more complex system than they initially thought, where their deaths or suffering seem to fuel the town's power.
In a shocking turn, one of the main characters turns out to have a key role in the town's power structure, potentially offering a way out - or sealing their fate forever.
These revelations leave the survivors in a dire situation, with the knowledge that escaping might not be as simple as they thought, and even worse, the forces of the town are more sinister and in control than anyone imagined.
I think Tabitha is Victor's sister....we haven't seen how she supposedly died, I think she got out as a kid and was adopted by someone else after returning home. Notice that they never show her face when they have flashbacks but we have seen Tabitha as a kid...and we know she remembers being in Fromville before. Also, the connection Victor has with Ethan can only be that he is actually his uncle!!
Every conversation is import.
Henry and Jade shows how "Victor is not broken and shaped by this place"
Donna and Acosta shows how Acosta is still an outsider. Shes still "The Cop" and shes good outside but shes helpless here.
I'm not sure it's a foregone conclusion that Tabitha is Miranda. She could also be Eloise. Unlikely, I agree, but Eloise didn't stay in the root cellar, and perhaps she followed Miranda and saw her death, escaped (or was sent out of the town one way or another), and became Tabitha.
You are mistaken. Tabatha is not the reincarnation of Miranda, but Victor's sister. She probably went through the tree, lost her memories and was adopted by another family. That's why in a previous episode she faintly remembers seeing the red stones as a child.
But how did Eloise randomly become Colombian, then? Hah.
2nd, if Tabitha is Miranda reincarnated, so supposedly she was supposed to enter the tree and not Christopher to only bring back Henry? Or see the tree she(Miranda)made herself? After Tabitha entered the tree, she traveled to the light house, and nothing was there, and then again, what was the only way the boy in white mentioned because pushing Tabitha?
To my mind, Tabita is Viktor's sister. She just somehow forget everything regarding this place
Off topic I find the music in the background where they were toasting to Fatima soo wholesome man
Say, I counted 60 people at the meeting plus three out on their own.
Is 63 the correct number of people who live in the town these days?
Idk if it was a continuity error but Fatima wasn't preggo the whole time, shots bounced back and forth with her with a baby bump and not.
I was struggling so hard to not fall asleep. The downhill of this season is crazy. 1 episode left. So frustrating to see this season end with NOTHING good.
this show would've been better if each season had 6 episodes rather than 10
I think the last episode will be Boyd telling everyone in particullary that his clock is ticking =)))
Or Fatima will give birth to a child (or monster, whatever)
The Boy in white mad about some shit that happen 40 years ago lol try again help now
😂😂 facts wtf
If he did show will end
Remember the dream that Tabatha repeatedly has as a child dressed in colonial costume and she was frightened at the blooded rocks? It is a spiritual connection to Miranda. Tabatha is the next Cromenockle. Not a reincarnation of Miranda. Used for the next level of the game. Miranda was able to draw down her visions of previous cromenockles I believe. Not reincarnations. It is the Cromenockle for the next round gets the opportunity to save the children. Tabatha has different dreams and visions than Miranda has. I hope it makes sense
For some reason, I think Julie is the reincarnation of Elois and Ethan is the boy in white, Jade is Christopher...
when Fatima was in the room with Elgin she could have gotten out so easily 🤦♂️. also it looks like Jim is finally not being a moron
The baby in her tummy would just make her double over again or the Lady in the Kimono would drag her back.
She yelled "its impossibile" "its impossible"