This movie is produced in China and the ruling CCP is a political rival of the Kuomintang now currently based in Taiwan along with some islands are the last remaining territories under the ROC. The portrayal of the ROC flag has to be done vaguely. The movie also got criticized as a propaganda tool to glorify the Kuomintang as well the 'failure' of portraying "the class oppression within the ranks of the Kuomintang army, the misdeeds of its officers and its evil oppression of the people" This shows that there is still some animosity between the CCP and Kuomintang. In Chinese movies, Kuomintang is portrayed as greedy and corrupt. The same goes to CCP portrayed in Taiwanese movies. This movie is the 3rd version of portraying the defense of Sihang Warehouse by ROC soldiers. The first version is 1938 and the 2nd one is 1976.
Nope, 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳, no matter what side your on, they are all chinese and that is what all matters, the west and politics separate us but we stand united by blood, culture and language.
do you know the real chinese in taiwan is remaning of kmt that escape to island ，most of them is descendent from Japanese during ww2，so that’s why they hate china
It was in one of the deleted scenes. There was a taiwanese who shouted at Japan soilders and cursing them with Japanese language. He was immediately mistaken for a Japanese spy by the angry people on the other side of the river. Then they hanged him on that pole, which was what you saw in the scene.
No matter how many westerners or politicians try to separate us, the truth remains, there is no fake or real China, there is only one China, the islanders and mainlanders will unite one day.
Unite under the Republic of China, a democratic republic with representation for all, not under an authoritarian regime plagued by few privileged ones.
Nope, 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳, no matter what side your on, they are all chinese and that is what all matters, no matter how the west and politics separate us, we stand united by blood, culture and language.
@@jeremiahmontejo9625 If what you are saying is the CCP is trying to take credit for what the national army did in defending our motherland, then you are absolutely right. Bandit Mao actually thanked the Japanese in 1973 for invading China during WWII because it weakened the national army and thus made the CCP's path to power possible. Even in the movie, the national flag is not clearly shown, which is ashamed and an insult to our forefathers who bled to save the nation.
@@johnfu3850 …finally I found actual people, not mindless wumaos. The end captions of this movie really is misleading the public, for the filmmakers being forced to say that the CCP lead the War of Resistance. And of course the infamous censoring of the national flag
@@rayray6490 the real pity is nowadays, our brothers from the motherland are being taught that the CCP is leading a great government. When youtube had the entire 八佰 movie available, I was there arguing with two people who dared to claim the CCP did not kill anyone in Tianneman Square in 1989. I kept on having to remind myself that they were my fellow countrymen whose minds had been poisoned by the CCP. I fear what the next generation of our people will be like. Will they continue to worship Bandit Mao like a god? Or will they finally realize the crimes he and his party committed against the motherland?
@@johnfu3850 Indeed, censorship exists within Chinese films, and one regarding the KMT would be considered controversial. It is also true that KMT's efforts were downplayed by the Chinese government for quite a long time. However, while censorships also happened to this movie, it still portrayed the Nationalist forces as heroes defending China and acknowledged KMT's contribution in the Sino-Japanese War. Compared to past Chinese military films, this one was far more realistic and well-made. It was soaking of patriotism, but at the same time tackled the "war is hell" theme and one could argue it's more anti-war than anything. The fact that this was allowed to air, despite the postpone and the censorship, could be interpreted as a change in the Chinese media climate. Film producers are constantly exploring beyond the limit of what China consider as "appropriate", and I think it is fair to hold high hopes for Chinese media to be more open about these kinds of stuff over time.
@@infinitecanadian the Chinese are fighting a losing war against the Japanese, they want to raise International attention about the war and the warehouse is situated on the border with the Shanghai International Settlement which contain mostly Westerner, they choose this location so International Journalists can record and show the world what is happening in China in order to gather humanitarian and possibly military supply from the world to help stop the Japanese expansion. That why they chose to fight such an disadvantaged battle.
@@infinitecanadian there's actually two reasons why they didn't just leave. number one, they were covering the retreat from Shanghai and number two, they wanted to make a show for the western world to try and gain support against the Japanese.
山川壯麗，物產豐隆，炎黃世胄，東亞稱雄。
毋自暴自棄，毋故步自封，光我民族，促進大同。
創業維艱，緬懷諸先烈；守成不易，莫徒務近功。
同心同德，貫徹始終，青天白日滿地紅。
同心同德，貫徹始終，青天白日滿地紅。
日落旗不落. 人亡國不亡.
Respect from Aistralia 🇦🇺❤️🇹🇼
说白了台湾还是中国一部分
4:23 สามหลักการแห่งประชาชน วางรากฐานให้พรรคเรา(พรรคก๊กมินตั๋ง)
เราใช้หลักการนี้เพื่อสร้างสาธารณะรัฐขึ้นมา จึงได้มาซึ่งความสงบสุข
เหล่านักรบทั้งปวง จงเข้าสู่สนามรบเพื่อประชาชนเถิด
เช้าค่ำไม่ได้หยุดพัก จงทำตามหลักการนี้
จงพากเพียรและจงกล้าหาญ ซื่อสัตย์และจงภักดี
จิตเดียวใจเดียว จักนำพาปวงชนจนอวสาน
เป็นเพลงที่ผมชอบมากๆเพลงนึงเลย
ใช่
ดูแลตัวเองดีดีนะ
谢谢你
รู้ไหมว่าเป็นเพลงอะไร?
The filmmaker made the ROC flag and anthem not very clear in the movie. But the scene still conveys the spirit. Well done:
This movie is produced in China and the ruling CCP is a political rival of the Kuomintang now currently based in Taiwan along with some islands are the last remaining territories under the ROC. The portrayal of the ROC flag has to be done vaguely. The movie also got criticized as a propaganda tool to glorify the Kuomintang as well the 'failure' of portraying "the class oppression within the ranks of the Kuomintang army, the misdeeds of its officers and its evil oppression of the people" This shows that there is still some animosity between the CCP and Kuomintang. In Chinese movies, Kuomintang is portrayed as greedy and corrupt. The same goes to CCP portrayed in Taiwanese movies. This movie is the 3rd version of portraying the defense of Sihang Warehouse by ROC soldiers. The first version is 1938 and the 2nd one is 1976.
Yea it was still clear that it is the ROC flag nevertheless tho. You can clearly see the sun on the flag.
@@Imbrojeff2361It is very ambiguous, only slightly visible in a few frames.
不如把你美利坚灯塔国的国旗竖起来吧
@@doutu4624 he said the flag is not very clear why are you offended so much?
who here noticed the music in the background is the ROC anthem
It'd be wrong for it to be anything else for a flag raising ceremony. But kind of sucks they made it fade into the background.
They guy with the cornet you mean ?
Meee!
不能忘记
這部片拍得很感人，以商業片來說沒什麼錯
但史實還是要提一下ＸＤ
升旗與護旗那場戲，拍得蕩氣回腸。但與事實差距較大。事實上，謝晉元考慮到日軍可能對升旗發起進攻和幹擾，僅組織了十幾人上倉庫天台舉行了升旗儀式。日軍雖然也確實出動了一架戰機想擊落國旗，但沒成功就撤出了，主要還是顧忌到對岸的租界。多名戰士用肉身擋子彈護旗的情節是不存在的，日軍戰機為擊落國旗從北側俯衝掃射，打死數名對岸租界內平民的事件更是子虛烏有。
QNMLGB
Im not even chinese but this speaks to me
Same.
🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🙋🏻♂️🙋🏻♂️🙋🏻♂️
Solute to Republic of China!
Nope, 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳, no matter what side your on, they are all chinese and that is what all matters, the west and politics separate us but we stand united by blood, culture and language.
do you know the real chinese in taiwan is remaning of kmt that escape to island ，most of them is descendent from Japanese during ww2，so that’s why they hate china
@@Lvisredalin Communism unalived alot of people. There's alot of shedded innocent blood under the CCP Flag
@@Lvisredalin Communism kills more people that National Socialism or any form of political party. Thats a CCP flag so I don't respect it
My favorite movie 😀❤️👍
排队自爆场面，逃兵磕头片段。久违的感动。我的眼睛湿了。敬在营的军人们，敬之前为保家卫国战斗过的军人们，敬为国家大义牺牲的烈士们。😭
中華民國萬歲, 國軍萬歲
上報國家與領袖，下答人民與部屬
不管怎样，中国现在越来越强大，不辜负这些英雄
Its communist
Wrong China. The CCP were hiding in the hills and happily watching the KMT fight and die for china while this happened.
此【日本－戰鬥機】算是命大啊，不像【八百壯士＿台灣版（１９７５年）】一樣，【中華民國＿國軍】的機槍連＿連長：【雷雄】手持【Ｍ１９１９－機關槍】把【日本－戰鬥機】給打到爆炸。
看了這片段，終於知道以前看到拚命守護國旗不倒照片，這背後的原因了😭😭
5:33 hold up... why is there someone lynched by the wire cable?
I guess we will never know
A wire worker fixing the wires?
It was in one of the deleted scenes. There was a taiwanese who shouted at Japan soilders and cursing them with Japanese language. He was immediately mistaken for a Japanese spy by the angry people on the other side of the river. Then they hanged him on that pole, which was what you saw in the scene.
@@o.oo.o2111 wow what an unfortunate mistake 💀
@@o.oo.o2111 wild
民國 建國113年
雙十節
中華不亡
中華民國生日快樂
For Taiwan 🇹🇼
My brother, the flag in your comment is the real Chinese national flag. And one day, we will raise it properly on the motherland.
Amen
这是中华民国的国旗。不是台湾的国旗。这是中国的国旗！
For Republic of China!
我是一個驕傲的中華民國子民，我是一個驕傲的中國人!
this is china tho
No matter how many westerners or politicians try to separate us, the truth remains, there is no fake or real China, there is only one China, the islanders and mainlanders will unite one day.
Unite under the Republic of China, a democratic republic with representation for all, not under an authoritarian regime plagued by few privileged ones.
@@Voltaire8559 It wouldn't work in mainland. There will be actually be civil wars, MUCH MORE.
@@Voltaire8559民主共和国不可能这么快让中国实现中华民族伟大复兴，也不会让全国人民脱贫,你要知道中国不是韩国不是日本，中国是一个人口巨大版图巨大的国家，而且中国政府不是你嘴里的独裁,而是由少数思想正确，以国家为前提的政治家，组成的政府
@@Voltaire8559i feel like this would be vulnerable to an ultra-nationalist government
Communism does. Even in other countries. They where divisive and manipulative
這些軍人如果今天活著，一定對中華民國失望透了，變成今天這樣，都快亡了，還在一個小島上被搞分裂，這些犧牲的軍人看了一定氣死了。
Be patient my brother. The righteous China will reign again on the motherland
当年的国军是伟大的，现在的国军是耻辱的，当年升青天白日旗是侮辱日本人的，也是守住最后尊严的，现在台湾为日本降青天白日旗，简直就是莫大的耻辱，谁曾想，有朝一日，国人会对日本鞠躬尽瘁，把日军对国人一切的耻辱抛之脑后，先不说你是哪里人，但你们的先辈确确实实是国军的后代，做人真的没一点底线
唉，中华不振啊！
It is a matter of time, brother
實際上是意識形態不同,民族大義又如何,當時國共內戰,戰後清算多少抗日的國軍,講什麼都不用
共產黨毫無人性只是鬥爭的機器
每次看都流淚，日本真他媽王x蛋
🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼
Nope, 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳, no matter what side your on, they are all chinese and that is what all matters, no matter how the west and politics separate us, we stand united by blood, culture and language.
@@Lvisredalin example of victors writing history by using the prc flag. I'd prefer RoC than the censoring and state infiltrating ccp
@@pictobloxer5412RoC is like that
for SHANGHI!!!!!
Was thare actually a blimp?
5:30 I thought they didn't have enought bullets at that time ? They didn't have enought of everything.
Depends on the unit, time, and place. The 88th were one of the better equipt units.
🇹🇼
Long live the republic of china
4:20
😢😢😢
明明是過去的歷史，明明是中華民國不會亡，硬要柪成中華不會亡
你听到那些老兵说了？ 格局真tm小。抗战的士兵全是大陆人，你们台湾还出台籍日本兵 真TM恶心
For Taiwan.
中華民國萬歲
🇯🇵VS🇨🇳
下面评论都写着For Taiwan，笑死我了都忘了自己叫中华民国了么？这么自卑？
🇹🇼 true china
你是自己多自卑才这么疯癫
@@BasedlocationNobody cares....🤣🤣
@@BasedlocationChina🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
中國國旗無落日
Historical distortionism, to prevent the envy of ccp to the bravery of the true chinese armed forces
@@jeremiahmontejo9625 If what you are saying is the CCP is trying to take credit for what the national army did in defending our motherland, then you are absolutely right. Bandit Mao actually thanked the Japanese in 1973 for invading China during WWII because it weakened the national army and thus made the CCP's path to power possible. Even in the movie, the national flag is not clearly shown, which is ashamed and an insult to our forefathers who bled to save the nation.
@@johnfu3850 …finally I found actual people, not mindless wumaos. The end captions of this movie really is misleading the public, for the filmmakers being forced to say that the CCP lead the War of Resistance. And of course the infamous censoring of the national flag
@@rayray6490 the real pity is nowadays, our brothers from the motherland are being taught that the CCP is leading a great government. When youtube had the entire 八佰 movie available, I was there arguing with two people who dared to claim the CCP did not kill anyone in Tianneman Square in 1989. I kept on having to remind myself that they were my fellow countrymen whose minds had been poisoned by the CCP. I fear what the next generation of our people will be like. Will they continue to worship Bandit Mao like a god? Or will they finally realize the crimes he and his party committed against the motherland?
@@johnfu3850 Indeed, censorship exists within Chinese films, and one regarding the KMT would be considered controversial. It is also true that KMT's efforts were downplayed by the Chinese government for quite a long time. However, while censorships also happened to this movie, it still portrayed the Nationalist forces as heroes defending China and acknowledged KMT's contribution in the Sino-Japanese War. Compared to past Chinese military films, this one was far more realistic and well-made. It was soaking of patriotism, but at the same time tackled the "war is hell" theme and one could argue it's more anti-war than anything. The fact that this was allowed to air, despite the postpone and the censorship, could be interpreted as a change in the Chinese media climate. Film producers are constantly exploring beyond the limit of what China consider as "appropriate", and I think it is fair to hold high hopes for Chinese media to be more open about these kinds of stuff over time.
I hope these Chinese were so happy after Japan got bomb twice
Literally japan raped and killed so many chinese and experimented on asians that was karma lol
It’s just a flag. It’s funny how much they are willing to sacrifice for a piece of cloth.
You didn't know the history of this event aren't you ? They could easily evacuated from the warehouse if they want
@@giathuanleviet4138 Then why didn't they?
@@infinitecanadian the Chinese are fighting a losing war against the Japanese, they want to raise International attention about the war and the warehouse is situated on the border with the Shanghai International Settlement which contain mostly Westerner, they choose this location so International Journalists can record and show the world what is happening in China in order to gather humanitarian and possibly military supply from the world to help stop the Japanese expansion.
That why they chose to fight such an disadvantaged battle.
@@infinitecanadian there's actually two reasons why they didn't just leave. number one, they were covering the retreat from Shanghai and number two, they wanted to make a show for the western world to try and gain support against the Japanese.
@@Ganaidhm Enough to die for?
Dumbest part of the movie, I was enjoying it until the flag scene, what a waste of life, should have just waited the 2 days to raise it.
You don’t quite understand the meaning of raising that flag.
Its their own flag and their own land. 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼
the whole point of the battle was to inspire the chinese nation and the outside world, so raising the flag is kinda a big deal in that goal.
Even today, when we see the flag raising scene, we all feel proud of being chinese and proud of what our forefathers did to defend the motherland.
Movie made no sense in the end it’s a Chinese propaganda towards the west
No, it is a brilliant war movie showcasing the chinese resistance against japanese aggressors.
how?
bro probably never studied history 💀
Its based on real history, but dramatized.
🤓
護旗戰爭最高境界