The Forgotten Member of BTS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2023
- BTS are a great example of what it means to take your life from rags to riches but they were initially made out of 8 members, not 7. keep watching to find out the details of the most tragic trainee story in the history of kpop! stay tuned and subscribe to kookielit for more kpop news and videos.
Instagram: bit.ly/3NWCjW1
Twitter: bit.ly/3NyjmJS
Facebook: bit.ly/3OhuslH
#kpop #kpopnews #KOOKIELIT - บันเทิง
To say this is the most tragic trainee story is crazy this is basically the most common trainee story for every group that debuted there are probably hundreds to thousands of people who were scraped and rid of
Also not to mention the idols who do debut that aren’t popular or even some who have some popularity who is in more debt then even someone who took out loans for an Ivy League college and hasn’t earned a pay check in years
Yeah, but this is his story. It’s also BTS. He had a change to be in the biggest boy band in the world. I think it’s similar, as you say, but it’s a little different only because of the circumstances and the group involved.
They are calling it most tragic because BTS is the most popular group in the world right now with millions of fans, that trainee could have had it all if he wasn't kicked out at the last minute, its tragic in that sense🤷♀️
@@JiaPia3 this is his story reported by someone else who made a title stating this is the most tragic story. Also I get you saying that it’s the circumstances I get that it is bts but to say it’s the saddest doesn’t make sense because he is not the only person who didn’t make the cut for bts. Also when you have kids who been in the industry since 9-11 years old who couldn’t live their childhood years and it all went to waste cause they didn’t debut or people who are literally offing themselves after all the time and energy they put in going to waste of the fact that they lost their dream and been set back in life because the piles of debt in they name I still stand on what I said.
@@BELIEVER78989 I get that it is bts but to say it’s the saddest doesn’t make sense because he is not the only person who didn’t make the cut for bts. Also when you have kids who been in the industry since 9-11 years old who couldn’t live their childhood years and it all went to waste cause they didn’t debut or people who are literally offing themselves after all the time and energy they put in going to waste of the fact that they lost their dream and been set back in life because the piles of debt in they name I still stand on what I said.
I believe Jonghyun, Goo Hara and Sulli was the most tragic story in kpop. Moonbin was a stab in the heart for me because he was always so cheerful.
I don't think I'll ever get over the fact that we lost some amazing artists and humans. Please don't put so much pressure on your idols, they are going through a lot already ❤
Moonbin was an amazing idol 😭 RIP 🙏🏻💜
I miss Jonghyun so much. He’s my bias since 2012.
Moonbin wasn’t suicide, nothing was ever confirmed but any said it was cardiac arrest
@@iamthebreadgenie exactly, I'm quite annoyed at this channel for using such clickbaits. Even though the channel portrays someone considerate in terms of videos, those headlines are disgusting.
I watched the original video and it was brutal. You could feel how badly he missed belonging to that group of friends. It was really challenging for him to get used to a desk job when he was so close to living his dream as an entertainer. But, you end up really admiring his inner strength. It is impossible for you not to root for this guy.
The saddest part is that he doesn’t have a continued friendship with any of the members
tbh i feel like they r still friends but its just not mentioned cos of privacy reasons of the members.
The saddest thing was when he break the news to his mother she fainted
It genuinely sucks that he was not able to live out his dream with one of the biggest names in K-Pop, but I'm very glad that he's living a happy productive life. I wish him all the best 🖤
not one but biggest like bts is probably biggest celebrities on earth right now
The 0 views really caught me out of guard
Same but theres 22
This reminds me of artists who had trained in other labels but left that label they trained after being cut from the lineup, for instance T-ara members Soyeon was a SM Trainee almost debut in Girls' Generation alongside Stella Kim and Coed School and F-VE Dolls former member Chanmi (now soloist Heo Chanmi), they all left the lineup for different reasons, Soyeon found success in T-ara, Chanmi as a soloist, Stella lives a normal life and she's active on Instagram, Hyomin was almost in Wonder Girls when she trained in JYP, she was supposed to replace Hyuna but Yubin was added instead, she joined MBK (then name Core Contents Media) and became a T-ara member, even Qri who had trained in a another company as part of a band found success in T-ara, Hongseok debut in Pentagon after he was eliminate from Mix & Match when he was under YG, Jinho 2nd Main Vocalist of Pentagon found success in the group after leaving SM and it's Ballad group, Miyeon debut in (G)I-DLE, Youngheun debut in BlackSwan after Stellar disband before she debut (now she's no longer in the group after she and Judy were forced to graduate), Jinny debut in Secret Number after being removed from Blackpink's lineup and leaving YG, Jang Hanna debut as a soloist, Moon Sua debut in billlie, Jang Hyunseung almost debut in BigBang but was dropped, he joined Cube and debut in Beast till his departure now he's a soloist and his stage name is ABLE after leaving Cube, Ella who had debut in Cherry Bullet with the stage name Mirae has left before the group reached it's 1 year anniversary (now she and member Satbyeol had left due to health reasons), Dani an MBK trainee has left the label after numerous delays of her debut and now lives a normal life, Sojin (now Jo Gabin) used to trained in BigHit alongside GFriend debut as a member of 9Muses under Star Empire till their disbandment,
Poor dani..she deserved better..i thought she already debut when she collab with f-ve dolls on stage..but she didnt make it..😢
@@odd6088Honestly, she deserves better, MBK wasted her talents alongside Shannon, SPEED, F-VE Dolls, DIA
This just shows that BTS were truly destined to be 7. That being said, I still feel bad for him. I hope he's able to reunite with them some day. The members of BTS are very humble and loving so I'm sure they'd be happy to see their old friend again.
You’re just not well in the head ,if after hearing about a trainee’s experience and your first thought is to go “haha screw your feelings and mental health ,bts were meant to be 7” …all this mental health bs that armies claim their faves care about ,and your fandom can’t grasp the basic decency of empathy ,loser fandom
@@woodzie988 I wasn't making fun of his experience at all, I even mentioned that I hope he's able to see them again, but sure bud, whatever helps your bitterness lmfao
Oh i knew about him year ago, but let's not forget when there are a lot of trainees out there lost their stardom due to final line up and i could write an essay about them but somehow the them found their ways to stardom for example 5 girls from PinkPunk (BlackPink origin lineup) are all debuted now, Linzy of Fiestar supposed to join 2NE1 lineup, and other ex trainees that managed to get stardom, congratulations to them! But mind you there are some who haven't gotten their stardom, or chose to live normal life. The most infamous one i could think right now is Stella Kim who almost to debut with Girls Generation, she was rumored to be the center of the group due to her visual and outstanding body proportion, unfortunately something happened that she chose to drop out from the training and live normal life, although SNSD has debuted she is still in touch with Sooyoung though. Sadly, due to her popularity when she was an SM trainee, she had to face criticism from the public after she left the company, wherever she goes people would say "oh she didn't make it into SNSD lineup because she's fat" and other heartbreaking words, search her name up to find out more about her and she also spilled the tea about SM and Kpop industry. Don't worry, she is doing fine, IMO she took the L just like Jessica did and succeeded😁
its most tragic bcoz bts is not just kpop level but probably biggest celebrities on earth like they are obviously biggest group in world so like not getting in group or being removed and than that group become the biggest band in world is really something not common with other random kpop groups
back then they are not even guaranteed to biggest kpop group. basically this man just jealous. we don't even know his real trainee life. is he really talented? is he really have good behaviour?
they can call it tragic because bts is big now. if not? he will not gonna say anything
@@hilight3142
This isn’t even remotely tragic and you’re dramatizing this as if getting cut isn’t an every day reality for trainees. BTS’ line up changed multiple times before the final debut team was selected, as far back when they were the three members of (pre-debut) BPB in 2010.
Jihoon doesn’t even describe not being selected in for BTS as tragic, and there’s no guarantee that his addition would have brought them the same success they see today. Save the word “tragic” for actual tragic situations, not a former trainee who had no guarantee of future financial success. This video is disrespectful to him and those who the word should actually apply.
This is the most possible trainee story u hear who doesn't debut and not saying it's good but that's how trainee period works for them.. debut or no debut and they all are also well aware of it.. in my pov just bcoz he didn't debut with bts, doesn't make his story MOST tragic.. coz there are many actual heartbreaking tragic stories that we can't even bare imagining
its most tragic bcoz bts is not just kpop level but probably biggest celebrities on earth like they are obviously biggest group in world so like not getting in group or being removed and than that group become the biggest band in world is really something not common with other random kpop groups
@@hilight3142 ummm bro read the title of the video it says MOST tragic story in KPOP HISTORY.. So here I'm talking about any other TRAINEE IN KPOP and not related to bts..don't glorify it by connecting bts to it..u should understand the title first
thats literally y hthey said tragic trainee story. cos tbh it is sad being that close and then not debuting to his mum collapsing.
And another fact is that he didn't even know all the members. Like you said he did. He didn't know Jimim cus jiminwas only a trained half an year before he debuted. So you said that he was dropped one year before so they weren't 8
He can be a soloist tho
tru but im guessing at the time bighit barely had enough to support a boy group. not only that but he said that he couldnt bring himsellf to debut away from the boys since he was rlly close to them, which is also y he didnt join another company. + being a soloist is pretty hard sine kpop stans usually like and focus more on groups. so he would probably would never had a chance of not being able to ever perform on the same music stage as them which means barely seeing them.
The fact that BTS stayed thru Bighit nearly going bancrupt says something about BTS tenacity to succeed and thats why BTS member deserves every bit of success they are reaping now even on their solo projects.
Making fiftyfifty look bad... 😢
My opinions is joining industries working with all blood, sweat and tears, R&B, Raps skills both in transition, GHOON skills become more important with groups, learning skills, industries need change ages limits joining in, 18-Up with high schools diplomats-colleges levels. Both of males and females equally.
It’s just another common trainee story of those who doesn’t make it
yeah bc it's really common to almost debut in bts great thinking you've got there
@@simonemg23 He’s not the only one who trained with BTS, there are other trainees who didn’t make it either to join the debut. The only difference is this guy is looking for clout because he was interviewed by VICE and wanted some attention about this. This thing happens all the time in kpop, people train together, grow a friendship and then some make it to the debut line and others don’t because they didn’t qualify enough according to the CEO. Same thing with big groups like exo, lesserafim, blackpink, seventeen, txt etc. I’m NOT discrediting what BTS have accomplished but I am saying this dude in the video didn’t come forward with that interview until BTS hit the market real hard. Why? Because he want attention. He’s not special, he’s just a ex trainee 🤦🏼♀️ Seoham from KNK trained with BTS as well but when he understood he won’t make it in BigHit and couldn’t join BTS debut he fought for his dream and joined another agency. KNK never made it big and he later left the group and now he’s becoming a well known actor and has recently hit 1M followers on Instagram from his acting. That’s a big step! He didn’t give up but this guy in the video DID and wants a sob story about it now. Also, making the title “The most tragic trainee story in K-Pop History” like what? There are people who have trained since they were kids but never make it and later off themselves because they put their whole youth into becoming an idol etc. Thousands of cases that are way more tragic than his.
@@Maria-ed3jo yes there are, but they weren't supposed to debut WITH bts they just trained with them that's the difference
This video reminds me of one of your video about Le Sserafim's forgotten member Haruka. And (g)i-dle's forgotten member. I feel so bad for them. They were literally close friends. But had to leave the company.
How many times is this story going to be told? Heard the same thing 2 years ago...and before that also.
Can we talk about how Kim Ji Hun perfectly fits in bts?
He said he really miss their friendship i hope he able to meet bts someday 😢❤
I hope they still talk behind the scenes
Edit: well I should have watched the video full through I hope they all get together again nad hangout
Most of this i remember 😥
Everyone knows about it pretty much
Park Seoham from KNK & Semantic Error also trained with BTS
He was my bias in KNK, but even tho he left, I'm happy he was able to act in something like that. I'm not sure that his acting career would have taken off the way it did if he ended up in BTS. There would be no time for it.
This isnt the most tragic at allllllllllll. This is just one who failed
I FEEL SAD FOR HIM 🥺
"The Most Tragic" tittle is big exaggeration 😒
If he was in bts right now then he was also enjoying his life successfully but I think it's not in his fate bts destined to be 7 and always stick togather and I'm so happy they achieved everything despite so many hardships and suffering they never gave up I'm so proud of my boys
Yeah but the guy who almost debut with them worked hard and go through the same hardships and didn't achieved nothing, all was for nothing, I know that this happens with alot of people but is still sad, they impute so much hope in his mind that he was gonna debut with bts and he was throw away suddenly
@@Mariana_MiraiThat’s how kpop industry works, your spot is never secured.
To some extent I feel bad but this sort of thing is so common I feel like anybody who tries to join the industry has to expect it.
In reality, a very ordinary trainee story. The only thing a bit sad was that he got removed from the lineup so late and the group achieved great success.
This could have also be the fate of Yeosang and WooYoung of #ATEEZ when they left Bighit as TXT trainees. But they promised one anothe that they will fail together or be successful together. And also saying "Let's perform in BIG Concerts and be successful" 😥
That is what it is.
Some are destined some are NOT
regardless in which company or group you end up debuting 🎉💪
To: Yeosang and WooYoung who never gave up their dreams. Cheer 🎉🥳🥂👏
#ATEEZ
same with heeseung he was supposed to debut with txt but didnt make it to final line up
it's been a few days since the VMAs and still no word of congratulations for Stray Kids, TXT and Blackpink from you 🤨
WHY R THERE ONLY 3 COMMENTS!?!??!?!?!😊
Cause u are too Early☺️
She deleted comment if you correct her mistake on this video.
We get it was harf
Why did I think this was going to be about Kidoh lol
ikr?
The fact he almost part of the super amazing BTS😢
I see why people hate this channel on kpop twitter ........
Too bad. He’s gorgeous btw.
Sounds like a “please feel sorry for me story. “
No it isnt he mentioned in the original video that he thought bts wouldnt be as successful if he debuted with bts and he said he was proud of the boys. Please dont spread misleading info which may lead to him getting hate for no reason. If he really wanted people to feel sorry for him he wouldve made this video sooner and not only after someone approaches him to make this vid
The video title is crazy...
They might have ended up being dragged down by him had he joined. It wasn’t meant to be
Bro really missed big time.....
Thanks to how kpop was getting more & more popular bcz of 2nd gen that paved the way, bts became more popular especially in the 2020's.
Hah??
Girl what??
😂😂😂
BTS paved the way keep crying about it😁
@user-dq6wd9lp8f we all can see who's actually crying tho🤡
This could've been Miyeon if she didn't pick herself up and got herself successful as well
The seven members of BTS were destined to be, it was written in the stars for them. For the other trainees, their fate was not, they are happy for BTS, they praise them highly but they will always be left wondering what could have been
True
💃💃💃
.Well BTS still close friends with childhood friends.. So there's no excuse for why he ain't that close anymore, because BTS still have friends from before they were famous.
Sometimes people just drift apart. It's very common for adults to not have the same friend group they had as kids. It's nothing bad it's just life.
Did it occur to you that maybe they felt staying close with him would hurt him? And that he felt trying to stay close to them would hurt them? So due to unspoken feelings, they drifted apart? It's a pretty common thing. Each party thinks the other would be better of without them, but it's not true. Sad when people don't communicate what ends up being mutual feelings.
Not most tragic, Jimin failed many tests but his persistence on improving and making the cut is a trait the company looks for. His life as a trainee is the same with hundreds of others. Some past trainees move on to work behind the scenes as they are talented enough. This trainee you are showing just didn't have enough skill development and perseverance to grow in the industry. One step away from stardom? He could not comprehend the pressure BTS had to go through with the media and haters all around after they debuted. He could not pass the first step, nevermind the many hurdles throughout the years. Mr. Bang made the right choices! Not dumping on this ex trainee but he showed he was not cut out for this line of work. Great that things worked out for him. Instead of constantly looking back on regrets (not really since he wasn't talented enough) be grateful for what you have now and look/work forward to a brighter future.
You don’t know what happened behind the scene so please don’t talk about the man as if you know more that the rest of us. You are speculating and you are being smug and judgemental. It ain’t cute.
11 COMMENTS
Good for him honestly ,looking at the bigger picture, you could’ve ended up having loser fans like armies ,so he ultimately won
and here we have ,the first loser harassing ppl ,plz i dont have the energy for the likes of you , dont bother@heydudehiiii
just admit you are jealous bcoz your fav isnt biggest group in the world but bts is
ARMYs in your comments be woke, fam ☠️
Anyhow, I honestly I agree he shouldn't regret anything! He is living a quiet life and he is pursuing something he enjoys!
@heydudehiiii another loser
Lmfao😂 bitterness has taken over your entire soul