I mean, "Glass Onion" isn't even particularly obscure about its trolling. It's jam-packed with references to other Beatles songs. And the metaphor of a glass onion is suggests that people are trying to pull back the layers on something that's actually transparent.
Those who only take a joke for a joke and the serious only seriously, he and she have actually misunderstood both. Quote from danish poet and humorist Piet Hein _Den, som kun tar spøg for spøg_ _og alvor kun alvorligt_ _han og hun har faktisk fattet_ _begge dele dårligt_ Trolling is never JUST trolling. John Lennon was attracted to surrealism. It was not a coincidence that he fell in love with an avant garde performance artist. Yoko Ono's art is full of humor if you look closely.
"I am the egg man" is a Lewis Carroll reference too. While Lewis Carrol didn't invent Humpty Dumpty, the character appears in Through the Looking Glass. Given that the "egg man" line comes right before the walrus line, it's pretty clear that Lennon is thinking of the Lewis Carroll version. Lennon also references his own music in the line "See how they fly like Lucy in the sky."
"I am the Eggman" may also be a future vision, as it foreshadows 1991's Sonic the Hedgehog, where one of the characters from that game was named Dr. Eggman, a pure coincidence.
@@matthewjones8398 There’s no question about it. In fact, the song “Dr. Robert” was originally supposed to be titled “Dr. Robotnik” but they couldn’t get the future copyright clearance so he had to settle on a much more boring drug dealing doctor.
@@CantTellYou Perhaps that Sega wasn't willing to lend over one trademark, possibly Yuji Naka (one of Sonic's three co-creators) refused to relent and turned down the request.
John Lennon, as many other great writers, knew how to take the sounds of the words and turn those into good melodies, the words themselves just as a abstract idea. I think this is what made his nonsense so great, Kurt Cobain also did this a lot.
One of the Beatles best songs not just the lyrics which are silly fun but musically it’s one of their most complexly written with its chord progression.
I had John's book of poems "In His Own Write' and found it to be not only whimsical but obviously self serving. He writes what he likes because he can. His humour is dark and also very light. I'm sure the Jabberwocky was something he could very much identify with. I found great joy in the book as a teen.
beyond what you would call the rhythm and musical quality that lyrics have, there is an emotional quality behind every single word and they're combinations that surreal songwriters use. they challenge and play with language itself and give emotions without having "real meaning". which i personally really like :) great video btw
Ian MacDonalds essential book on The Beatles - Revolution in the Head - One of the finest explanation and atomization of I am the Walrus. Ian expands on the fairly obscure anger embedded within the lyrics and hammered home with the incredibly powerful music accompanying his caustic singing. As the saying goes “ Once you hear it you can’t unhear it”. Genius.
John Lennon loved surrealism. It was not a coincidence that he fell in love with an avant garde performance artist. Yoko Ono's art is full of humor if you look closely.
Marcel Duchamp wrote a signature on an upside-down urinal and placed in an art gallery with the title "Fountain" Modern art has been trolling for a long time.
Really good stuff! Thank you. I also wanted to chime in -- I enjoy lyrics that are somewhat diaphanous, but evoke emotions or memories. That they give a sense of their meanings, but are not too specific allows the listener to apply their own thoughts and memories to the song. Making the listener an active part of the song. Also, there's a documentary -- about the making of Imagine, I think, where this kind of unhinged man who has read all sorts of nonsense into Lennon's songs is confronting Lennon, and Lennon says, "Hey, man, they're just words. They don't mean anything." I love that!
My dad used to yell "dripping from a dead dog's eye" when this played just to watch me make a gross out face. I think that makes sense that I love it so much since I loved Alice in Wonderland so much.
This is one of the top 5 Beatle songs..which makes it in the top 5 of all time songs considering ..there's A Day in The Life, Straw Fields, Eleanor Rigby, I am The Walrus and Hey Jude.
What about tomorrow never knows? That's my personal favorite Beatles song and can easily be argued to be one of the most important songs of all time, the amount of experimentation in that track is insane for 1966, and it's just a great song even if you ignore the amount of influence it had
So there I was, listening to how beautifully you're analyzing this song, and wondering why you're analyzing it at all, given how the video started. Then, bam, 6:36, you explain why. Well done!
It’s always hilarious that John made I Am The Walrus and Glass Onion to make fun of the conspiracy theorists reading too deep into their songs, and yet they somehow still believed that these songs were hinting at Paul’s death. You’ll still find these nut jobs today who believe that “the walrus was Paul” means that Paul died. Some people are just too stupid for their own good. 🤡
Wow, so many negative comments. To address a few, your unique narrative delivery is great. Please dont change it. "I am the Walrus" is one of the best Lennon/Beatles songs. The lyrics are incredible. Thanks for posting.
it’s like you read my mind! i’ve been thinking about this topic for days, as i recently began reading “in his own write”. his writing style is nonsensical and strange. i love how he can use so many words to say what is essentially nothing at all. i’ve been trying to make nonsensical art pieces inspired by john’s work and as it turns out, creating nonsense is a lot harder than it looks.
"Sitting on a cornflake waiting for the van to come corporation t-shirt stupid bloody Tuesday man you been a naughty boy you let your face grow long" I have always associated these lyrics when I was having a crap day at work. Used to sing it to myself when I was quite literally sitting on some rock, waiting for the boy with the van coming to pick me up after a long shift, wearing a you guessed it a company t shirt the boss would make us wear and yes it's only stupid bloody Tuesday still got Wed Thur and Fri to go before the weekend and you can bet I had a long face by that point! I never thought this song to be nonsensical in my life I always seen it as pure genius and often wondered to myself how the hell did he know what I was going through 40 years before I even went through it 🤯 the man was nothing but genius he just knew 💙
For a long time, thought Mr. Tambourine Man was just a bunch of fun fantasy lines. Singing it last night, I suddenly got it. I now know what the song is about and there isn’t an unmeaningful line.
Regarding the anecdote about song inspiration , I think Glass Onion was the song about which John said “let the f*****s work that one out” when he was deliberately trolling to mess with people (especially about the Paul is dead conspiracy) and written as a response to people trying to analyze I am the Walrus. Regardless, thank you for your reliably entertaining and informative videos!!
I have three categories for what makes a song enjoyable, and those are 1. Fun, which is how fun a song is to listen to, 2. Good, which is the talent of the musicians playing the song, and 3. Meaningful, which is how much the piece makes you think. A song only needs fit into one category to be enjoyable. I Am The Walrus fits squarely and solely in Category 1.
Stupid bloody Tuesday is another reference to a passage in one of the Alice books. There was something about a corkscrew and a hippopotamus. The lyric in I Am The Walrus is a kind of surrealist poem, involving a lot of free association. Regardless of Lennon's original intent it turned out to be a fine piece. It has meaning but it isn't linear.
Lennon was just entering another musical prime when he was murdered. The whole Double Fantasy album is sublime, and songs like Borrowed Time show that he was experimenting with a reggae sound. Still a huge loss.
7:30 those concentric circles looks like the ones in the 20k COP bill. It was also used masterfully in Bailando Triste by Nicolas y los fumadores, give it a listen
Long time ago, I looked for on Google a photo of John Lennon on acid. And yes, there was one. He was wearing a Blue Jean jacket, matching jeans, a shirt with something interesting on it. I think tie-dye and His plane circle glasses. Found it once and could never find it again. Pretty sure I typed same words looking back for it. There’s a bunch of Photos of The Beatles I’ve seen on the Internet and can never find again.
You should do a video on the Velvet Underground’s song Pale Blue Eyes. It’s such a beautiful love song, but has so much to it, adultery, forbidden love, and learning to accept you can never be with the one you love. It’d be cool to see you unpack the song and the real story that inspired it.
That song is kind of in a disguise, it comes off as a such a sweet and simple love song, but it has layers to it. I’d be very interested in seeing a deep dive of Pale Blue Eyes! Hopefully it happens because I’ve yet to see someone do that
This video explains a lot of things very well, and taken together, it also adds up to what I think is a very good explanation of why Frank Zappa liked it. Even covered it one time. Ike Willis is singing, and his voice fits it to a T.
Apparently, it took two weeks for John Lennon to write down the first sentence “I am he as you are he, as you are me and we are all together” (he was tripping).
I do find it intesting how this type of song does exist in more modern generations, spesficly Ive always though of "Records on my Fingers" from Phineas and Ferb. Even though Doof is just trying to tell people that he is literary being controlled by a platepus and nothing more, the audince were able to turn it into something more profound and something that they can relate to
"I am he as you are as you are me and we are all together" It reminds of African philosophy Ubuntu, which says "I am because we are". Maybe this association has nothing to do with it, but I remembered it. Even more so because today's Western industrial culture preaches such an individualistic way of being.
I'll never forget how Paul McCartney came up with Sergeant Pepper. He apparently misheard someone say "pass the salt and pepper" and thought he heard "Sergeant Pepper". That's how I learned that sometimes lyrics are just lyrics.
The original rhyme was “yellow belly custard green snot pie, all washed down with a dead dogs eye” well, at least in Liverpool, my uncle used to say it to my mum when they were eating to make her feel sick 😂
I think, the reason why Lennon could have written 'I am the Walrus' it's a counterculture that thrived in 60s-70s and had a huge, enormous value on pop culture of America, Britain etc. Maybe Beatles have controversial' and sarcastic lyrics not only because of John's infatuation of nonsense and psychedelic, the other reason is the time which the Beatles were stars and artist either
This song, IMO, was unmistakably about how much Lennon hated being famous, while being expected to be grateful for his fame. Whether he was conscious of this message or not. When I listen to it, I see references to fans, groupies, police holding back crowds, miserable bus tours, the depersonilization of being an idol, etc.
You cannot always expect artists to know what their own art means. Artists sometimes are like stenographers, taking dictation for an unknown muse that they do not understand. Impressionistic expression is an exploration of a subconscious world that does not lend itself to straightforward translation. The artist might say, "half of what I say is meaningless", but there are nonetheless reasons for the images that thrust into their minds.
There's a term in film theory called the unreliable narrator, who leads you down the wrong path so you are surprised by the ending because you believed, or sympathized with the story being told in voice-over, ignoring the story being told visually. Lennon wants you to believe he is just another guy with nothing to say, which couldn't be farther from the truth.
The infamous, iconic 17th and final episode of "The Prisoner" was aired less than two months after "I am the Walrus" was released..Patrick McGoohan had to go into hiding for a couple of weeks, the English public could only take so much Kafkaesque absurdism at the time
could also mention john lennon’s nonsense book, “in his own write”, he wrote a few years before this, before the beatles had quite gotten to psychadelia. i think it’s interesting to see through that how his journey in nonsense evolved from something like Please Please Me to I Am The Walrus.
i know this is not true but i like to head canon the "all together" line foreshadows "come together" on abbey road, since the beatles are always very self-referential.
This is honestly what sets the Beatles apart from a lot of other bands and artists. John Lennon can make a song with absolutely insane lyrics and no actual meaning and still make it a great song that is listenable to all. I mean just look at early Pink Floyd. They were arguably more psychedelic and “out there” than the Beatles, yet most of their early albums are terrible. You can’t tell me with a straight face that you think the songs on Piper At The Gates of Dawn and Umaguma are better than anything on Sgt Pepper’s and Magical Mystery Tour. The Beatles were able to push the boundaries of music while still making amazing songs that are actually easy to listen to.
I've always thought that the story about Lennon writing "I am the Walrus" as nonsense to frustrate a teacher at his old school doesn't make any sense considering that Lennon was known at his school for writing all sorts of clever stuff and was exposed to Lewis Carroll, etc. in that very school.
Does anyone want to talk about the significance of John's line, "the walrus was Paul" from glass onion? Was Lennon vilifying Paul as this was the era where he really became the business man in the group? There is also something to be said about the stories surrounding Paul yelling at the producers during obla di obla da perhaps leading to their eventual departure. Even Harrisong's, we all know obla di bla da line in "savoy truffle" is pointed at Paul negatively.
I think Aesop Rock is a kinda Bob Dylan of his time in terms prose that feels massively cryptic but is definitely not nonsense. Rap is a really great medium for writing like that.
you mentioned how silly he was but didn't show the picture of him walking all goofy 0/10
Yoko would walk "goofy" when John drank
He makes a goofy face at 2:56 if that counts
@@xp7575he was way more than drunk...
"silly" he was an asshole
the absolute madman
I'm not in walrus, Skyler.
I AM the walrus.
Goo goo choo
A man opens his Magical Mystery Tour and gets Goo Goo Gajoob’d and you think that of me? No
I am the Man who Goo Goo Gajoob’s
@@KryzeSkywalker salute to you brilliant sir
Before the Kendrick Drake beef we got the John Lennon English Teachers beef
And the John Lennon Paul McCartney beef lol
@@implicitdifferentiationyea honestly the two of them were the first real music beef, diss tracks and all.
Nice pic
And the John Lennon frank zappa beef lol
John just straight up said 'Let's troll'
This is what I have always said about "Glass Onion".
Lennon was trolling.
I mean, "Glass Onion" isn't even particularly obscure about its trolling. It's jam-packed with references to other Beatles songs. And the metaphor of a glass onion is suggests that people are trying to pull back the layers on something that's actually transparent.
great song regardless
Those who only take a joke for a joke and the serious only seriously, he and she have actually misunderstood both.
Quote from danish poet and humorist Piet Hein
_Den, som kun tar spøg for spøg_
_og alvor kun alvorligt_
_han og hun har faktisk fattet_
_begge dele dårligt_
Trolling is never JUST trolling.
John Lennon was attracted to surrealism. It was not a coincidence that he fell in love with an avant garde performance artist. Yoko Ono's art is full of humor if you look closely.
The walrus was Paul
I love it when the cellos enter and John sings "sitting on my English Garden, waiting for the sun".
"I am the egg man" is a Lewis Carroll reference too. While Lewis Carrol didn't invent Humpty Dumpty, the character appears in Through the Looking Glass. Given that the "egg man" line comes right before the walrus line, it's pretty clear that Lennon is thinking of the Lewis Carroll version.
Lennon also references his own music in the line "See how they fly like Lucy in the sky."
Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds also took inspiration from Lewis Carroll.
"I am the Eggman" may also be a future vision, as it foreshadows 1991's Sonic the Hedgehog, where one of the characters from that game was named Dr. Eggman, a pure coincidence.
@@matthewjones8398 There’s no question about it. In fact, the song “Dr. Robert” was originally supposed to be titled “Dr. Robotnik” but they couldn’t get the future copyright clearance so he had to settle on a much more boring drug dealing doctor.
@@CantTellYou Perhaps that Sega wasn't willing to lend over one trademark, possibly Yuji Naka (one of Sonic's three co-creators) refused to relent and turned down the request.
"I am the Walrus" feels like a Syd Barrett song
But actually good
Syd Barrett looked up to and was influenced by Lennon
So glad someone said this!
@@georgelucas2571 Syd wrote at leastLeast 3 good songs.. Arnold'Layne. see Emily Play and the incredible Astronomy Domonie
Lennon had dogshit writing. Sydney barret could actually write
John Lennon, as many other great writers, knew how to take the sounds of the words and turn those into good melodies, the words themselves just as a abstract idea. I think this is what made his nonsense so great, Kurt Cobain also did this a lot.
I kept thinking of Kurt Cobain this whole video. He utilized ‘nonsense’ or the subversion of expected phrases a lot in his songwriting.
One of the Beatles best songs not just the lyrics which are silly fun but musically it’s one of their most complexly written with its chord progression.
I had John's book of poems "In His Own Write' and found it to be not only whimsical but obviously self serving. He writes what he likes because he can. His humour is dark and also very light. I'm sure the Jabberwocky was something he could very much identify with. I found great joy in the book as a teen.
beyond what you would call the rhythm and musical quality that lyrics have, there is an emotional quality behind every single word and they're combinations that surreal songwriters use. they challenge and play with language itself and give emotions without having "real meaning". which i personally really like :)
great video btw
Ian MacDonalds essential book on The Beatles - Revolution in the Head - One of the finest explanation and atomization of I am the Walrus. Ian expands on the fairly obscure anger embedded within the lyrics and hammered home with the incredibly powerful music accompanying his caustic singing. As the saying goes “ Once you hear it you can’t unhear it”. Genius.
In hindsight John was just a talented man who just loved to take the piss out of the world through his talent of music.
So much more than that but yea that’s a bit of Lennon
John Lennon loved surrealism.
It was not a coincidence that he fell in love with an avant garde performance artist.
Yoko Ono's art is full of humor if you look closely.
“The ballad of John and yoko” really is an insanely awesome video. I got nebula just to watch it
John invented trolling before trolling was invented.
Marcel Duchamp wrote a signature on an upside-down urinal and placed in an art gallery with the title "Fountain"
Modern art has been trolling for a long time.
Tragic how we didn’t get to see Lennon on twitter.
He'd be a just stop oil protester.
@@insertgenericusernamehere2402 nah hes more than just that
Yea
He would’ve been so annoying on twitter, or just had someone on his team tweeting ads and promos for him
@@Bumbaclartios maybe both
Really good stuff! Thank you. I also wanted to chime in -- I enjoy lyrics that are somewhat diaphanous, but evoke emotions or memories. That they give a sense of their meanings, but are not too specific allows the listener to apply their own thoughts and memories to the song. Making the listener an active part of the song. Also, there's a documentary -- about the making of Imagine, I think, where this kind of unhinged man who has read all sorts of nonsense into Lennon's songs is confronting Lennon, and Lennon says, "Hey, man, they're just words. They don't mean anything." I love that!
My dad used to yell "dripping from a dead dog's eye" when this played just to watch me make a gross out face. I think that makes sense that I love it so much since I loved Alice in Wonderland so much.
He is the walrus
The walrus was Paul
The walrus wasssss meeee
@@TheGalterinone”I was the Walrus/But now I’m John.”
But now he's just John
This is the video I've been waiting for from polyphonic, always great content
This is one of the top 5 Beatle songs..which makes it in the top 5 of all time songs considering ..there's A Day in The Life, Straw Fields, Eleanor Rigby, I am The Walrus and Hey Jude.
What about tomorrow never knows? That's my personal favorite Beatles song and can easily be argued to be one of the most important songs of all time, the amount of experimentation in that track is insane for 1966, and it's just a great song even if you ignore the amount of influence it had
Penny Lane is the greatest pop song ever made. Standard Beatles perfection.
I love your work! You really elevate being a TH-camr to an art
“See how they run like pigs from a gun, feels fun” polyphonic droppin bars
So there I was, listening to how beautifully you're analyzing this song, and wondering why you're analyzing it at all, given how the video started. Then, bam, 6:36, you explain why. Well done!
It’s always hilarious that John made I Am The Walrus and Glass Onion to make fun of the conspiracy theorists reading too deep into their songs, and yet they somehow still believed that these songs were hinting at Paul’s death. You’ll still find these nut jobs today who believe that “the walrus was Paul” means that Paul died. Some people are just too stupid for their own good. 🤡
If John realized the walrus was the villain, would that make "the walrus was Paul" a subtle jab at Paul?
@@MyNameIsNeutron He said somewhere that it was meant to be a compliment to Paul.
Wow, so many negative comments. To address a few, your unique narrative delivery is great. Please dont change it. "I am the Walrus" is one of the best Lennon/Beatles songs. The lyrics are incredible. Thanks for posting.
it’s like you read my mind! i’ve been thinking about this topic for days, as i recently began reading “in his own write”. his writing style is nonsensical and strange. i love how he can use so many words to say what is essentially nothing at all. i’ve been trying to make nonsensical art pieces inspired by john’s work and as it turns out, creating nonsense is a lot harder than it looks.
Every time you alternate between "Lennon" and "Lenin", I chuckle sooo hard 😃
Been watching a long time, showed your stuff to my friends, great channel, one of my favorites.
Great that you're back!
One of my favorite Beatles songs!
"Sitting on a cornflake waiting for the van to come corporation t-shirt stupid bloody Tuesday man you been a naughty boy you let your face grow long"
I have always associated these lyrics when I was having a crap day at work. Used to sing it to myself when I was quite literally sitting on some rock, waiting for the boy with the van coming to pick me up after a long shift, wearing a you guessed it a company t shirt the boss would make us wear and yes it's only stupid bloody Tuesday still got Wed Thur and Fri to go before the weekend and you can bet I had a long face by that point!
I never thought this song to be nonsensical in my life I always seen it as pure genius and often wondered to myself how the hell did he know what I was going through 40 years before I even went through it 🤯 the man was nothing but genius he just knew 💙
so good to see the channel is back :)
For a long time, thought Mr. Tambourine Man was just a bunch of fun fantasy lines. Singing it last night, I suddenly got it. I now know what the song is about and there isn’t an unmeaningful line.
I love your work so much. Thanks for coming back.
Well the last ten minutes went by in a flash. Another top notch video. You're a magician dude!
Some of the remarks made here about sincerity/mockery///serious/nonsense really capture how I feel about Ween.
My man!
Regarding the anecdote about song inspiration , I think Glass Onion was the song about which John said “let the f*****s work that one out” when he was deliberately trolling to mess with people (especially about the Paul is dead conspiracy) and written as a response to people trying to analyze I am the Walrus. Regardless, thank you for your reliably entertaining and informative videos!!
i was thrilled to see you cover this. Next: the Harrison-Dylan connection!
I have three categories for what makes a song enjoyable, and those are 1. Fun, which is how fun a song is to listen to, 2. Good, which is the talent of the musicians playing the song, and 3. Meaningful, which is how much the piece makes you think. A song only needs fit into one category to be enjoyable. I Am The Walrus fits squarely and solely in Category 1.
Stupid bloody Tuesday is another reference to a passage in one of the Alice books. There was something about a corkscrew and a hippopotamus. The lyric in I Am The Walrus is a kind of surrealist poem, involving a lot of free association. Regardless of Lennon's original intent it turned out to be a fine piece. It has meaning but it isn't linear.
You are so good at this. I hope it is rewarding much more than it is taxing.
I've always enjoyed this song. Thank you for making this video.
The world was robbed by John's death. Its impossible to put into words how influential he was on art and culture. What an incredible man.
how I missed this style of essay ❤
Lennon was just entering another musical prime when he was murdered. The whole Double Fantasy album is sublime, and songs like Borrowed Time show that he was experimenting with a reggae sound. Still a huge loss.
Brilliant analogy, well thought through
My all time fave Beatle's tune...goo goo ga jube
7:30 those concentric circles looks like the ones in the 20k COP bill. It was also used masterfully in Bailando Triste by Nicolas y los fumadores, give it a listen
Goo goo g'joob!
Long time ago, I looked for on Google a photo of John Lennon on acid. And yes, there was one. He was wearing a Blue Jean jacket, matching jeans, a shirt with something interesting on it. I think tie-dye and His plane circle glasses. Found it once and could never find it again. Pretty sure I typed same words looking back for it. There’s a bunch of Photos of The Beatles I’ve seen on the Internet and can never find again.
You should do a video on the Velvet Underground’s song Pale Blue Eyes. It’s such a beautiful love song, but has so much to it, adultery, forbidden love, and learning to accept you can never be with the one you love. It’d be cool to see you unpack the song and the real story that inspired it.
That song is kind of in a disguise, it comes off as a such a sweet and simple love song, but it has layers to it. I’d be very interested in seeing a deep dive of Pale Blue Eyes! Hopefully it happens because I’ve yet to see someone do that
John was trolling before trolling was a thing lmao
Thank you once again for making something worth watching.
This video explains a lot of things very well, and taken together, it also adds up to what I think is a very good explanation of why Frank Zappa liked it. Even covered it one time. Ike Willis is singing, and his voice fits it to a T.
Lyric analysts: Wtf John, this song is just a bunch of nonsense!
John Lennon: That’s the point.
the lyrics sound cool helped by the interesting melody, singing etc lol
The Beatles’ most complex chord progression. John was a genius composer, every major chord is here and key changes galore
Apparently, it took two weeks for John Lennon to write down the first sentence “I am he as you are he, as you are me and we are all together” (he was tripping).
I do find it intesting how this type of song does exist in more modern generations, spesficly Ive always though of "Records on my Fingers" from Phineas and Ferb. Even though Doof is just trying to tell people that he is literary being controlled by a platepus and nothing more, the audince were able to turn it into something more profound and something that they can relate to
I've been on Nebula a few years now and subscribe to Lindsay and to Big George. Recommended.
I enjoyed this song during my college years.
PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO ON SHOCKING BLUE!!! 💙🗣️💙
"I am he as you are as you are me and we are all together"
It reminds of African philosophy Ubuntu, which says "I am because we are".
Maybe this association has nothing to do with it, but I remembered it. Even more so because today's Western industrial culture preaches such an individualistic way of being.
All in all is all we are
I'll never forget how Paul McCartney came up with Sergeant Pepper. He apparently misheard someone say "pass the salt and pepper" and thought he heard "Sergeant Pepper". That's how I learned that sometimes lyrics are just lyrics.
But at 1962, A band called Billy Pepper nd the Pepperpots invented the name, sooooo what's the point?
The original rhyme was “yellow belly custard green snot pie, all washed down with a dead dogs eye” well, at least in Liverpool, my uncle used to say it to my mum when they were eating to make her feel sick 😂
I think, the reason why Lennon could have written 'I am the Walrus' it's a counterculture that thrived in 60s-70s and had a huge, enormous value on pop culture of America, Britain etc. Maybe Beatles have controversial' and sarcastic lyrics not only because of John's infatuation of nonsense and psychedelic, the other reason is the time which the Beatles were stars and artist either
Okay, it's very simple:
Everybody.
Was.
On.
Drugs.
Back then.
John Lennon was such a talent that a song he wrote expressly to fuck with people is still amazing.
Here's another clue for you all, the Walrus was Paul.
And almost 60 years later we're here doing the very same thing that led him to write this song in the first place. Cause or consequence?
Great video
I hope you do more videos about john lennon
When I was a kid I thought Semolina Pilchard was a British movie star from the 60s.
"It seems to sum up so much what the hippies were trying to say" sounds musical 6:17
what a lovely video!
You should do an addendum on the Rutles’ “Piggy in the Middle”
John later created a meta comment on the Walrus issue with Glass Onion in the White Album.
I am the Walrus is also really unusual and engaging musically. The nonsense lyrics are not only sonically engaging, they are also psychedelic images.
I see a polyphonic video, I click.
This song, IMO, was unmistakably about how much Lennon hated being famous, while being expected to be grateful for his fame. Whether he was conscious of this message or not.
When I listen to it, I see references to fans, groupies, police holding back crowds, miserable bus tours, the depersonilization of being an idol, etc.
Always nice to see you
What if he wasn't the eggman, they weren't the eggman and he wasn't the walrus?
I like this song 🎵 I'm the Walwus on the Magical Mystery Album in 1967 . RIP 🙏 🪦 John Lennon and George Harrison 🙏 🪦 😢 💔.
You cannot always expect artists to know what their own art means. Artists sometimes are like stenographers, taking dictation for an unknown muse that they do not understand.
Impressionistic expression is an exploration of a subconscious world that does not lend itself to straightforward translation. The artist might say, "half of what I say is meaningless", but there are nonetheless reasons for the images that thrust into their minds.
Lovely video!
There's a term in film theory called the unreliable narrator, who leads you down the wrong path so you are surprised by the ending because you believed, or sympathized with the story being told in voice-over, ignoring the story being told visually. Lennon wants you to believe he is just another guy with nothing to say, which couldn't be farther from the truth.
4:55 1960s freeze frame profile
The infamous, iconic 17th and final episode of "The Prisoner" was aired less than two months after "I am the Walrus" was released..Patrick McGoohan had to go into hiding for a couple of weeks, the English public could only take so much Kafkaesque absurdism at the time
I hate that photo of JL smiling like a madman you put in here. Its so scary, and I'm mad you lingered on it for so long... twice! Great video
Wait til you see Obey the Walrus
I thought it was just record of an acid trip.
could also mention john lennon’s nonsense book, “in his own write”, he wrote a few years before this, before the beatles had quite gotten to psychadelia. i think it’s interesting to see through that how his journey in nonsense evolved from something like Please Please Me to I Am The Walrus.
i know this is not true but i like to head canon the "all together" line foreshadows "come together" on abbey road, since the beatles are always very self-referential.
This is honestly what sets the Beatles apart from a lot of other bands and artists. John Lennon can make a song with absolutely insane lyrics and no actual meaning and still make it a great song that is listenable to all.
I mean just look at early Pink Floyd. They were arguably more psychedelic and “out there” than the Beatles, yet most of their early albums are terrible. You can’t tell me with a straight face that you think the songs on Piper At The Gates of Dawn and Umaguma are better than anything on Sgt Pepper’s and Magical Mystery Tour. The Beatles were able to push the boundaries of music while still making amazing songs that are actually easy to listen to.
I've always thought that the story about Lennon writing "I am the Walrus" as nonsense to frustrate a teacher at his old school doesn't make any sense considering that Lennon was known at his school for writing all sorts of clever stuff and was exposed to Lewis Carroll, etc. in that very school.
Does anyone want to talk about the significance of John's line, "the walrus was Paul" from glass onion? Was Lennon vilifying Paul as this was the era where he really became the business man in the group? There is also something to be said about the stories surrounding Paul yelling at the producers during obla di obla da perhaps leading to their eventual departure. Even Harrisong's, we all know obla di bla da line in "savoy truffle" is pointed at Paul negatively.
I think Aesop Rock is a kinda Bob Dylan of his time in terms prose that feels massively cryptic but is definitely not nonsense. Rap is a really great medium for writing like that.
How would you feel about doing a vid pn piper at the gates of dawn?
i miss him man