Why Wilbur Soot's Response to the Allegations Failed

Twitch streamer and musician Wilbur Soot was hit with allegations of abuse from a former girlfriend. And he responded to them, horribly. But why?
Timestamps
0:00 Intro
2:20 Part 1: Respect the Audience
6:10 Part 2: A Confusing Foray
8:09 Part 3: Inappropriate Bolstering
10:53 Part 4: Bad Logic
13:49 Part 5: The Consequence of Such Bad Rhetoric
Editor's Note: At 4:15, the phrase "Expectations to any self-defense should meet" obviously shouldn't have "to" in it. Missed that in editing.
My Twitter: x.com/shrixper
Citations:
1. William Patrick Spencer Gold (@WilburSoot), “In the past week a series of allegations have been made over my conduct from an ex-girlfriend. I want to emphasise that although I feel it fair to offer my…,” X, February 27, 2024, / 1762505851699380353 .
2. Cheyenne R. Ubiera, “TH-camr Wilbur Soot’s Ex-Girlfriend Shubble Slams His Apology as He Denies ‘Abuse’ and Insists Biting Was ‘Playful,’” U.S. Sun, updated on February 28, 2024, www.the-sun.com/news/10520291....
3. Ibid.
4. Ibid.
5. B. L. Ware and Wil A. Linkugel, “They Spoke in Defense of Themselves: On the Generic Criticism of Apologia,” Quarterly Journal of Speech 59, no. 3 (1973): 277.
6. Dream, “The Truth,” December 19, 2023, TH-cam video, 1:15 to 1:40, • The Truth .
7. Gold, “In the past week a series of allegations have been made.”
8. Ibid.
9. Ibid.
10. Ibid.
11. Wikipedia, s.v. “Hanlon’s Razor,” accessed March 17, 2024, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon'....
12. SootHouse, “David’s Birthday (50K Subs),” October 22, 2017, TH-cam video, 3:59, • David's Birthday (50k ... .
13. Aristotle, Rhetoric 1.1.1355b1-3.
Sub count when this video was posted: 9

[@Shrixper]

Forgot to say subscribe, like, leave a comment, and give me all your money.

[@sylviathegreat]

this is amazing idk why this doesnt have more views

[@birb125]

I do like the discussion being built more on formatting.
Found this through shorts, hope you do well!

[@Blizito8]

Excellent work being clear and concise on your arguments. I laughed at you when you said you were reading that rhetoric book for fun, but it's obvious that you are using it for a much higher purpose. Great video!!

[@XFadedXSunX]

The reason it sucked is because it was self centered. But the problem is it’s not even an apology. It’s a statement that shares his side of the story and that’s why it’s about him. He never admitted to abuse. Only biting which Shubble said was completely consensual and she agreed to everything he did

[@AGNAB712]

comment for algo, great video