Yes! Not to mention they had a camera on them practically everyday and all that footage was posted on their TH-cam channel, Twitter, Instagram and TikTok. We got to know their personalities and how damn hard they worked. It added to their appeal immensely.
@@deettekearns9092 brohh i hate this fact about big hit they film everything about bts and a lot of the time we have the cameraman or woman but 99% they don't talk i found this creep exemple with IU the cameraman talks with her alot i found less creep
For me what stood out to me the most are their humility and grounded artists. They are just nice human beings, and yes of course their talents and their genuine love for each other and towards ARMY. Its just so humbling watching them, i wish i have kids of my own to share my BTS experience with them.They’re group of people who can help changed people to be better human beings.🫰💜
Nice to see Rolling Stone discussing BTS in a way that is respectful and takes them seriously. As ARMYs we've seen western media mock and disrespect BTS and the fandom as they gained popularity. As we appealed to radio stations in 2016-17 and the songs grew in the western world, we were accused of being bots, children, hysterical teens. The media weren't interested in the fact that BTS members were instrumental in the writing of their songs etc, instead we heard bigoted insults about 'Manufactured dolls' and a whole lot of racist stereotypes about men, beauty standards etc. To see an interview this respectful and knowledgeable is truly refreshing. As someone who's been an ARMY since 2016 this still feels shocking to see and I feel so much appreciation for Rolling Stone and their informed coverage of BTS
The world never knew how to appreciate these golden boys... I'm happy that their fandom is the biggest one in the world, so they receive the love & support they actually need. Otherwise you have stupid moments like an interviewer making racists jokes about BTS at the grammy and being amazed by RM only for is 'english' that he learned from FRIENDS...
Pharell and RM did a interview for rolling stone that was much better than this. I'm happy to see them being talked about, don't get me wrong, but isn't it better to have people that have done better research than these ?
Yeah they really did their research and knew the things they were saying, not just reading out facts or something like that. It's VERY refreshing to see and I hope all ARMY see this video!!
BTS is a group most people do not realize have a massive and decade old artistic legacy. Along with their solos there are roughly 500+ tracks with easily above 10 genres. Fans include rock nerds, hiphop nerds, alternative music listeners, r&b, pop, ballad enthusiasts, etc. And especially those genres with deep history (say hiphop); hiphop heads that know bts in and out have recognized they really know and respect the history and even declare them as folks of the culture. Their experimental nature, really open doors for indie artists especially those in Korea. What does all this result? For many of us bts introduces kinds of music we never imagined existed and then teach us about those in that genre to be respected. Their legacy is beyond just the 7 of them; almost a sub culture for enthusiasts of all forms of art. All these words and yet i barely explained 5% of every nuance that adds into their legacy. Only those who experience it without prejudice will trully understand it. So if that many factors exist, then one could conclude that atleast one out of the many may attract an audience. There success is the epitome of just that.
Bring me so much joy to hear BTS being discussed seriously, respecting them as true artists and their journey. They really are a once in a lifetime artists. Proud to be ARMY.
Thank you for giving bangtan the credit they deserve. They really did release dynamite, butter, and permission to dance as a response to how bad things were during covid. Even in the worst time for the world they’re still thinking about how to lift army’s spirits. You can’t help but love that kind of earnestness.
Bts is pretty underrated and people may not believe it. They never did anything to appeal the music industry(payola) which's very rare to see in such a crazy world. I love these guys for this💜
I looked up BTS a few years ago just because I kept hearing about them but didn’t even know what they were or anything at all about Korea of KPop. I looked them up in the way I do a hundred topics in politics, history, pop culture, science etc. I watched a video and was like, okay, sure. Then I watched another video and another video and another video 😂 I was completely sucked in. I have never been a “fan” of anything before. I have never understood heavy interest in celebrities. I have never been interested in the musicians/performers on a personal level, just enjoying music I like and not feeling any loyalty or interest beyond that. I was not even at all a fan of boy bands back in my teen years. I can’t explain it but BTS just totally took me away even while I thought it was silly of me and not seeming on the surface like something I would like at all. I haven’t stopped consuming their content every single day since and am genuinely completely a loyal fan. ❤ They are so talented and charming and magnetic and interesting and they just bring a lot of fun. I really think it’s the same as how a lot of people feel about sports. I never cared about sports but now I follow BTS like they are my favorite NFL team. 😅
And for what it’s worth their English language songs that took off here are among my least favorite. It was Spring Day, Blood Sweat and Tears, and then B sides that really clinched my fan status. It’s taken me a lot more time to appreciate Dynamite and Butter in the context of why they made them and just loving to see them in all sorts of performances because I just love BTS and want to see whatever they offer.
@@laurenm.6320I'm an Army since 2014 so I've witnessed all the eras and I do agree with you, the English tracks are definitely my least favorite ones, an they aren't actually even bad songs, they are great well-made pop hits, but just not my cap of tea and don't think they show the charm and skills of BTS to be honest which is a shame since most people seem to get to know them through those first which leaves that cookie-cutter image to them when in fact their discography is far from that....I hoped other songs would be the ones to blow up first but we can't have it all lol so we should just be grateful with what we have now
My thoughts are the same. I check on them every day to see what’s new, what they’re doing, how they’re doing, and listen to their songs. I’m even studying their Korean language and the history of their country. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Oh man, me too exactly. Fandom culture was a complete eye roll to me until I decided I needed to know the names of these boys after checking out a couple of their music videos 😂
As an army, I’ve become so TERRIFIED of videos like this because so often BTS are insulted and their success is belittled down to dynamite alone. I’m so so happy you guys are so informed and took so much time to understand them, their artistry and their history. Excellent video!! And each point was so true!
I only got in to BTS a little over a year ago after sleeping on them for years and they completely blew me away. They're pure talent I've never seen any group that's as skilled or versatile as they are. They literally do it all, cover all genres, make their own music, and have the most meaningful powerful concepts and lyrics that've managed to help millions of people all over the world. Not to mention their humble genuine selves and their unmatched bond with each other and with Army. They've transcended the k-pop label a long time ago and even though they've been the biggest group in the world for years I still believe that their skills are very underrated unfortunately because of the "k-pop stereotypes". I feel really bad for anyone who judges them off of their 3 pop English songs that they released during the pandemic to cheer people up and that don't represent their music at all. They have no idea what they're missing out on.
You're a baby (maybe toddler 🤔) army🫶🫶 im always curious how chapter 2 army find the guys. Did you decide to check them because of a solo song/album you came across, group music or something else like a variety show video ?
@@g100-w6j None of the above actually 😁 The first time I checked them out was around 2018. I listened to mic drop and boy with love since I was a fan of both Steve Aoki and Halsey. I liked mic drop and didn't like boy with love. I unfortunately judged them, thought they were too poppy and never listened to them ever again. Fast forward to last year I sometimes watch reaction videos of my favorite artists and I'd often find BTS pop up so I wanted to understand the hype. I decided to give them a final chance so I started watching both songs and interviews. Their interview on Fallon and their carpool karaoke were some of the first videos I saw and their personalities and charms specially Jimin's made me want to learn more. Within a few days I was completely in love with everything about them and I regretted not having given them a chance earlier. It was exactly a couple of days before Jimin released Face and I had no idea they'd be releasing so much stuff during the military I'm trying to catch up on as much of their content as possible it's not easy 😂
@user-vv7hc7kb5o None of the above actually 😁 The first time I checked them out was around 2018. I listened to mic drop and boy with love since I was a fan of both Steve and Halsey. I liked mic drop and didn't like boy with love. I unfortunately believed in the stereotypes, thought they were too poppy and never listened to them ever again. Fast forward to last year I sometimes watch reaction videos of my favorite artists and I'd often find BTS pop up so I wanted to understand the hype. I decided to give them a final chance so I started watching some interviews then songs. Their personalities and charms specially Jimin's made me want to learn more. Within a few days I was completely in love with everything about them and I wished I'd given them a chance earlier. It was exactly a couple of days before Jimin released Face and I had no idea they'd be releasing so much stuff after so I'm trying to catch up on as much of their content as possible it's not easy 😂
I actually agree. BTS is a wild ass band. I won't lie, I did judge them off their English music and hated on them for a while bcz I generally just don't like K-pop. Just a year ago, I decided to be more open about my music taste and decided to check out bts since im a big j cole fan. I was literally stunned about their whole discography and individual stories so I decided to check out other K-pop groups, but they just didn't feel as genuine in music as bts, they almost felt like pretty faces with talents but no determination for music. I don't think I'll like kpop any day but I geniunly appreciate and support bts as people and as artists
As an older ARMY and music freak all my life, I am so grateful to BTS for bringing me into something entirely new for me and teaching me the Korean culture in the meantime! I first saw them on SNL and just was so curious because I hadn’t seen anything like them EVER - first of all, talented dancers, amazing and cool vocals, and so bright and gorgeous looking… I mean who could compare? I’ve watched them grow over the last 5+ yrs with their talent, their artistry and growing from boys to young men and I’m they are the most delightful refreshing thing in my life - no joke! They gave me smiles and laughter during the pandemic whenever all were a bit scared about what was our future and they are the friendliest and most caring of their fans I have ever seen in my life. It’s astounding to me. I think that maybe a big appeal besides the music to western fans because most western artists are not like that at all. It’s beautiful and genuine and you can see these guys real personalities and souls which they share fairly openly. Rolling Stone a magazine I have been reading for most of my life, giving space to this band that means to world to me makes me feel proud and I hope we get lots more content about BTS because they honestly deserve it more than a lot of others! 💜
I think the reason why they are phenomenal is their genuine passion for music. Many people resonates with their music because they have always been true to their craft.
I was familiar with BTS before the pandemic, but during lockdown, I truly think they saved me. Every Army finds BTS when they need them and I definitely needed them at that time.
Bts are beyond kpop now they are world star and its all because of their song ,their performance, positive messages to world, bring joy and help people cope from problems and save people's life❤bring them to love without any language barrier which is what they did and have a global impact and this is all possible because they are so down to earth people ,they are great artist, THE LEGENDS.
I also think it’s important to mention that BTS never even planned on releasing dynamite. They had planned to enlist after MOTS tour in 2020, but covid ruined that plan. So instead, they changed everything in order to stick around with armys during such a hard time. I just find that really beautiful. And the fact that it blossomed into a new level of success for them was just a bonus!
@emilwandel they're tour would have start in April and looks like wrapped up in October. They didn't have the extension at the time so Jin would have to be put in his enlistment for Dec 2020
@@everything_purple What made you say they aren't ARMY? They know ARMY details. 😅Just because you disagree with their timeline? 🤷♀ It's ok to not agree... "I think you must not be ARMY if you don't write the acronym in all caps." 🤭That was a harsh joke because I didn't think it was worth getting aggressive over such a little thing. People like those who left because they didn't want BTS to sing in English are the ones to distrust. 😠
The biggest reason why they are so popular and succesfull is definitely their genuine passion for their art, be it writing, producing, singing, rapping or dancing, as well as their family-like bond.. They are so genuine and humble people and fans can actually feel that they're not doing this for the money.. 💜💜
The impact BTS has on the global market as korean artists is something we will never see again since now a lot of kpop artists have started to merge different culture just to target more audience, it sounds great at first but on a deeper note it takes away the value of kpop as a core. I think the members closeness and respect toward their culture as an all korean members group also has an impact on their over all image as kpop acts, the boys do release english music for international fans but they also maintain their originality by sticking to their mother tongue which I believe maximises my respect for them as artists and individual, it also shows the boys really are in it for their fans and passion not for chart passions. I hope their country people treat them better and understand their value rather than finding reasons to put them down, cause BTS have provided the global recognition to kpop and korean culture that it has today.
@@suprabhasuprabhaswain one of the great achievements of BTS is the way they've combined Korean and English lyrics so seamlessly to create a bilingual hybrid so that their songs can have international reach, not so much for the markets but to find a wider audience. Of course they're not the first Korean artists to create bilingual pop music, but they have elevated it to smother level. And it means they have been able to focus on their own culture while appealing to an international audience, something that ABBA could not do, as they basically had to use all English lyrics and global themes for their international releases. I mention ABBA because I'm old enough to remember just how huge they were (apart from in the US), in their day the biggest pop group globally since the Beatles (even my jazz-loving dad was impressed when he read that in the NZ Herald). ABBA never did crack the US market though, as that would have required a lot more touring than Agnetha was willing to do as a mother.
One key factor we need to remember. Because of media was shifting and changing. BTS was brought up grass root. Far from original international network pipeline. Which caused big frictions between network TVs and music industry with BTS. BTS changed the game. With such backgrounds resulting later even making their own IT media platform. Dope G.O.A.T
Personally I am not a person who is into music. Like I listen to many song but it doesn’t hit me. Like listening to romantic or sad song doesn’t make me feel anything. But BTS is different. I could relate to their songs. I have cried & laughed, it's just feels like even without telling anything they comforts us like they know us. That's why their song & they are so close to my heart. Even though we have different language we share the same feelings. I am really waiting for their 2025 comeback.
BTS success is based on so many factors Its not just their music its bcuz of the people they are ..their behavior, their message, their down to earth nature and always trying their best to give something to fans and make feel armys their value...its actually very hard to decode but yes fans love them and Bts has made huge impact on their lives including myself...they are true example of underdogs those start from nothing to everything...sometimes their fans are called out for overprotective nature yes it is there but people dont understand its is bcuz fan know their lifestory and what they went through and how badly world treated them in the beginning of their career..So even a single feeling of anything wrong against the members make them alert...Bts will never loose fans bcuz of how loyal members and armys are for each other (leave the obsessed fans ofcourse those go overboard sometimes) and always be the example of nobody to legends..and i wont ever get tired to defend them no matter what the world opinion is..
I’m becoming an BTSARMYMOM 2018 when I listened to a spring day song I cried I felt sadness. Even though the lyrics is korean. I’am a BTS ARMYMOM forever. I'm 52 yrs old💜💜💜
Spring Day🎉 The Queen! And yes, they did Dynamite to make us happy and bring light to a dark time. I was already a huge fan, and this was a great moment for all of us… It’s been great to see their growth individually-I love them all so much for their artistry, their talent, and what great musicians they are. Looking forward to their return as a whole group. 2025, let’s go! 💜🥳
Now ask why radio refuses to play almost anything by BTS on the radio. Oh wait I know the answer - Payola. Billboard needs to stop counting radio plays.
@@debbiel.wilk1824 yes, because american artists use payola / the industry profits back from them lol. bts indeed proved they dont need to play along with these cheap tactics.
BTS is Worldwide Sensation and Global Phenomenon. BTS is the reason why kpop is something right now. No one comes close to their level of success and popularity
1:26 I almost fell over hearing you say bangtan rose globally being exactly themselves and never comprising- I want to seriously thank you both from the heart for recognizing that dynamite wasn’t grasping for western validation, selling out, etc etc - calling it a victory lap meant so much to me, I’m so relieved to hear RS speak accurately about our 7
I stanned Big Bang but after Seungri was arrested for the Burning Sun incident, I stopped listening to K-Pop. Several years later, I started listening to Fire and it was on repeat on my playlist but I really don't know who sang it. After I researched at youtube, I discovered who BTS is and I've been a proud ARMY ever since. I love how they are so authentic, effortlessly hilarious and great artists. Borahae!
For ARMY its all 7 members and if one missing than its not bts. Bts did it because of all OT7 💜 and each members have their own contribution and shines in❤️ They respect and love each other's a lot and all these make bts today a legend. BTS FOREVER BORAHAE
It must also be said that the members of BTS are an antidote to toxic masculinity, and I think it is very refreshing to American female fans such as myself.
Bts are bts they don't want them to compare with beatles because bts wanted their own name and don't want to compare with someone...they are also a fan of beatles but they want to be THE BTS to world and having their own identity, which they definitely did they became THE bts whom world know now🤴
@@Teamo.bora. But the Late Show homage skit was all about recognising that BTS were the biggest thing since the Beatles to hit the American pop music scene, and that they were performing on exactly the same stage as the Beatles. It was not at all suggesting that they're any kind of copy of the Beatles, simply that they are as culturally significant on an international scale as the band that defined a decade and a generation all those years ago, and have remained relevant to this day. BTS are poised to leave a similar legacy, and that Beatles skit was a playful nod to their achievement and projected trajectory. How these well-meaning but blinkered music journos could get it so wrong is beyond me. They're looking for insults to get righteously offended about, where none were intended and none were given.
Agree, BE Album is BTS‘ Bohemian Rhapsody, I loved watching them create every aspect of it during lockdown and they would have group meetings in their “teams” and Yoongi painting/designing his album cover will always be my favourite clip.
I LOVED seeing a thoughtful and INFORMED discussion on BTS!! THANK YOU ROLLING STONE!! Thank you to these two two people (I didn’t catch your names) for truly researching BTS and understanding before talking about them. One of the best BTS discussions I’ve seen by American media. Thank you.
It was my understanding that BTS dressed in the style of the Beatles because they had just matched a Beatles record, and because they were performing in the Ed Sullivan Theater, where the Beatles made their American debut. It wasn't my impression that the intent was to make them more palatable to a western audience - they already had a huge American fandom. It was just a bit emphasizing that their massive popularity rivals that of The Beatles (and giving Colbert the chance to do his Ed Sullivan impression)
Why i love BTS. I'm american and have been Army since 2014. Its the lyrics. Plain and simple. Then the personalities. They are real and genuine in their love for each other which you feel it and see it and their love for us. Who does what they have done in this next chapter for us? What artist? None. We only hear from artists here in the US if they drop a album, then you don't here from them for 2 years. They are the real deal. No one will ever be like them. I understand people sometime will hate the fan base. Its only because the different cultures and lack of english and english slang and not understanding the meaning of what they are saying. Then because of the lack of understanding they go into attack mode. Of course then their is the obssessed Solo's and hater's that are possers. For anyone that is not in the fan base, it can seems we are a bunch of crazy people. But if they took the time to get to know us they would realize we are really educated. They just need to be open minded and respectful
After 11 years, BTS still has this relevant impact especially in this era where we are witnessing their individual growth as they enter their chapter 2.
Yes.. jimin is charting #1 in global spotify now for 2 days, who is raising every where breaking many records, broke spotify record in South Korea for any Kpop song, going viral.... All this when he is not evn around for promoting his song.
Yes.. jimin is charting #1 in global spotify now for 2 days, who is raising every where breaking many records, broke spotify record in South Korea for any Kpop song, going viral.... All this when he is not evn around for promoting his song.
Army’s please god it’s a great little video about their impact and their growth within music, it’s a positive video. Don’t go into it thinking it’s bad!
The impact of Dynamite deserves to be highlighted again and again! BTS is a one of kind group, and everyone involved in their path to global success deserves high praise! Thanks for the mention of the BEATLES, and how the only thing they really have in common is they are a boy group, but everything else from their music to performance is unique and probably can't be recreated! Bang Shi Hyuk and his team made lighting strike in the same place 7 times, with these 7 amazing young men (writing, producing, rapping, dancing, charm!)
Thank you for the professional conversation. BTS is beyond kpop. They transcend languages and races because of their genuine personalities, their lyrical poetry and incomparable stage presence. BTS is the only artist I listen to because they're the only ones that give me that whole package 💜💜
They appeal to ALL ages and every gender identity!! I’m 48 and obsessed with BTS. They are my life!! Amazing, beautiful inside and out, extremely funny, insanely talented guys! They have so much content (legit, it’s unbelievable how much content they have), they absolutely love their fans, they love each other like brothers and they really do become like family to us ARMYs. They make such a difference to my life. I honestly don’t know where I’d be or how I’d be without them, they literally saved my life 🥹💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
I love BTS not only for their TALENT and MUSIC but also for the love they have for ARMY 💜 The bond is unbreakable and transcends all race and age...They certainly are a phenomenon and I can't wait for them to come back!
Michelle Kim perfectly described BTS’ story and the depth of their lyrics. And both hosts really had a real knowledge of BTS history and their music. It’s rare in western media to find this respectful and thoughtful discussion about BTS so thank you Rolling Stone!
I thought it was a cute bit. We don't usually get guest bits with non-English speakers (I think we only saw them do more than one with Corden and Fallon), and Colbert's team went all out to recreate the Beatles' stage. I also saw it as a nice way to celebrate the theatre, itself, and how it's been around to see pop culture celebrate music from the Beatles to BTS.
Seeing BTS’ “entrance” into the western market as their VICTORY LAP by acknowledging their already established legacy long before Dynamite is everything
Thank you for this; it's extremely refreshing to listen to people discuss BTS, actually take them seriously, and discuss their incredible organic rise to popularity. Dynamite was such a specific moment of triumph in the midst of such a terrible year, and while I will always feel it's a bit bittersweet that they got their first #1 with an all-English track, no one can question how amazing it is! I'll always be grateful to BTS because I found them at a point in my life when I had really lost my joy in life and they brought it back - I was 35 then and I'm 42 now, but I love them even more now than I did on day 1. Appreciate you taking time to unpack all of this!
Thanks for the discussion. I would be interested in seeing a response to this from, for example, Bang Si Hyuk (BTS' founder) and now Chairman of Hybe. OR, from RM or Suga or J-Hope or any of the other members actually, but RM as the leader in particular. I found BTS through Black Swan - the artfulness and beauty of the song and the meaning as well drew me in. Now full ARMY since 2021 when I found them and never looking back. Best group in history, and not like any other "Boy Band" I've heard in the past. I wish the US would get over whatever stigmas they have and PLAY BTS ON THE RADIO!! I rarely listen anymore on radio and instead use Spotify.
From what I eard , you have to pay to have your music played in mainstream media. BTS dont need to pay anybody😅 and they dont need those mms 😊 Found them on YT
@@ghyslainemichaud9978 I agree - they shouldn't have to, and I don't want them to, pay anyone to have their songs played. I found them on YT also, through Black Swan. :)
really wish radio hosts weren’t so focused on money and discrimination based on language or other things. bts’s music (group and solo) is too good not to play it on the radio! (black swan is definitely top 3 of my favorite bts songs too!)
@@artmxyt It's not the radio hosts - though there have been some that are pretty prejudiced. I'm told that about 99% of all radio stations in the US were bought up into two companies. I only remember the smaller one - iHeartRadio - unfortunately. Understanbly this is about money and the hosts get playlists they have to work through. They are usually not music experts or music lovers any more if they ever were. You buy a CF you can decide the music that plays before and after. You sponser an event of the radio station and they will play your music. This is the legal part. But there is also the illegal PFP part aka. Payola. Boracity magazine has made a few essays about this.
Rob Sheffield knows what he is talking about, being part of Rolling Stone magazine for almost 30 yrs. Music and its evolution over time, has gone through so many changes and so many impactful artists has appeared.
They brought out talent in music and dance, more so the message of hope and positivity in the most uncertain and stressful time globally when things felt gloomy and sad. At the same time they were the type of youth who though had angst and depression were pushing and hoping for better.
BTS really impacted the world and they help thousands of people around the world with the wonderful message of self-love that we all need. Personally, I am more than grateful to know about them and enjoy their music. 💜💜💜
It’s so very very refreshing and heartwarming, having someone talking about BTS, who actually knows what they are all about. Thank you! 🙏🏻 I applaud you!
Love the 1st half of the interview. It was organically intellectual and kind as well as respectful. The concept of world-building as a connective force and energy for creating the beautiful synergistic connection of BTS & ARMY. All the members contributed to lyric composition. Even if it was a phrase or message. And all of them read high level intellectial and mental wellness works that gave them this strong dedication to the depth and purpose of their message. And everything has always been ARMY centric. What makes us happy, helathy, emotionally well. Thats what sets them apart and makes them gorgeously unique. Ive been ARMY since eqley 2014 and as a then 48 yo Indian mother, i somehow found myself connecting to and enjoying their work, personalities and content. Forward to 2024 and they have physiacally changed my life and career.
Their sincere, honest, humble and clean image and comraderie speaks volumes and is as legendary as their music, vibe and overall performance. There is no other group like them. They kept me sane through the pandemic and still today. They are “dynamite”. personified. I respect this interview. Well done Rolling Stone fir a balanced opinion piece.
I am so pleasantly surprised by this video. I don't usually expect for mainstream sources to treat them with this much respect and knowledge. Great work guys!
Thank you for such a thoughtful podcast! I am really looking forward to what BTS can evolve into when they are back together and each found their own flavour in their solo projects. Exciting times ahead!🎉💜💜💜
This was a really great discussion. SO nice to see BTS get such respect from Rolling Stone (and iHeart, even though they don't even add BTS songs to the corporate playlists for the most part). My only complaint is mentioning BTS and New Jeans in the same podcast, let alone the same sentence. They rode into the industry on their sunbaes' backs, then stabbed them in the back.
I'm impressed - in just half an hour you managed to cover so much of what made a cerebral fiftysomething westerner like me become a passionate BTS fan in 2020. Next time I want to explain it to someone I may just send them this link....
I am 41 yr old and im starting love BTS 2023 only they are different among other boyband or artist i cant elaborate all as far as i know they attract ,they hypnotized your soul when u started watching them they have a good soul and u inlove with the 7 of them i really enjoy watching them everyday💜💜💜
The sincerity and respect of this discussion feel healing for me. As the interview kept going my admiration and gratitude kept growing. Thank you for the time and careful thought put into this analysis/tribute video. I hope the word spreads among ARMY so we can give you our appreciation.
The conversation is very mature and beautiful. Thank you for talking about BTS. 💜 I am a Dynamite ARMY, met them when I underwent depression during COVID. Their RUN BTS show was so funny that they were the reason I could laugh so hard at that time. Love them til now. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
BTS ganó credibilidad conmigo a partir del discurso de RM de 2018 en la ONU, eso me hizo escuchar su música. Nunca me gustó el estereotipo del Idol de Kpop, pero ese discurso y las letras de sus canciones lo hicieron para mí. RM tiene una profundidad musical que cerró el trato para mí y luego me hizo caer en el grupo completo.
Thank you for this interesting discussion 💜 I'm ARMY since junuary 2022 and I'm sure I will be fan of them always :) Btw Jimin has released new album named "MUSE" It's great. Especially title track "Who".
Honestly anyone can become that big but while in the process of becoming big they forget their roots but BTS has been acknowledging their roots ever since it's really hard to stay humble while you have achieve that level of sucess even the most popular kpop girl group forgot their roots and the fact that they WROTE their life in songs is what makes people connect cause we live like e/o we have same issues and they connect with us and not to forget the fact they had to prove those people who didn't believe them and I'm proud to say they did 🤍
Thank you for this video. I appreciate the research, care and, above all, the respect you place on BTS, the members and their beautifully diverse discography 💜
![ILLSLICK - WINTER IS COMING [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dwTMeM1zIhQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I think the appeal of BTS is obviously their talent and music, but also their friendship and family like dynamic.
Yes! Not to mention they had a camera on them practically everyday and all that footage was posted on their TH-cam channel, Twitter, Instagram and TikTok. We got to know their personalities and how damn hard they worked. It added to their appeal immensely.
BTS really PAVED THE WAY for other k artists including black pink,,,to enter into pop industry
@@deettekearns9092 brohh i hate this fact about big hit they film everything about bts and a lot of the time we have the cameraman or woman but 99% they don't talk i found this creep exemple with IU the cameraman talks with her alot i found less creep
For me what stood out to me the most are their humility and grounded artists. They are just nice human beings, and yes of course their talents and their genuine love for each other and towards ARMY. Its just so humbling watching them, i wish i have kids of my own to share my BTS experience with them.They’re group of people who can help changed people to be better human beings.🫰💜
Their lyrics as well
Nice to see Rolling Stone discussing BTS in a way that is respectful and takes them seriously. As ARMYs we've seen western media mock and disrespect BTS and the fandom as they gained popularity. As we appealed to radio stations in 2016-17 and the songs grew in the western world, we were accused of being bots, children, hysterical teens. The media weren't interested in the fact that BTS members were instrumental in the writing of their songs etc, instead we heard bigoted insults about 'Manufactured dolls' and a whole lot of racist stereotypes about men, beauty standards etc. To see an interview this respectful and knowledgeable is truly refreshing. As someone who's been an ARMY since 2016 this still feels shocking to see and I feel so much appreciation for Rolling Stone and their informed coverage of BTS
The world never knew how to appreciate these golden boys... I'm happy that their fandom is the biggest one in the world, so they receive the love & support they actually need. Otherwise you have stupid moments like an interviewer making racists jokes about BTS at the grammy and being amazed by RM only for is 'english' that he learned from FRIENDS...
Pharell and RM did a interview for rolling stone that was much better than this. I'm happy to see them being talked about, don't get me wrong, but isn't it better to have people that have done better research than these ?
Yeah they really did their research and knew the things they were saying, not just reading out facts or something like that. It's VERY refreshing to see and I hope all ARMY see this video!!
@@LPnerdThe other interview wasn't mainly focused on BTS as a group.
@@LPnerdthis is a good interview. Honestly you can click off. It won't hurt feelings.
"They didn't cross over to North America. North America crossed over to them." No other statement has ever been more correct.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP-
@@himaririku9254😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@himaririku9254 😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Keep crying 😂@@himaririku9254
BTS is a group most people do not realize have a massive and decade old artistic legacy. Along with their solos there are roughly 500+ tracks with easily above 10 genres. Fans include rock nerds, hiphop nerds, alternative music listeners, r&b, pop, ballad enthusiasts, etc. And especially those genres with deep history (say hiphop); hiphop heads that know bts in and out have recognized they really know and respect the history and even declare them as folks of the culture. Their experimental nature, really open doors for indie artists especially those in Korea. What does all this result? For many of us bts introduces kinds of music we never imagined existed and then teach us about those in that genre to be respected. Their legacy is beyond just the 7 of them; almost a sub culture for enthusiasts of all forms of art. All these words and yet i barely explained 5% of every nuance that adds into their legacy. Only those who experience it without prejudice will trully understand it. So if that many factors exist, then one could conclude that atleast one out of the many may attract an audience. There success is the epitome of just that.
Bring me so much joy to hear BTS being discussed seriously, respecting them as true artists and their journey. They really are a once in a lifetime artists. Proud to be ARMY.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,
@@himaririku9254Dupek
Thank you for giving bangtan the credit they deserve. They really did release dynamite, butter, and permission to dance as a response to how bad things were during covid. Even in the worst time for the world they’re still thinking about how to lift army’s spirits. You can’t help but love that kind of earnestness.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP,,,.
@@himaririku9254 then makesure your fav deserve and recognize
Bts is pretty underrated and people may not believe it. They never did anything to appeal the music industry(payola) which's very rare to see in such a crazy world. I love these guys for this💜
Exactly! As V once said, there were many opportunities for them to take a shortcut to success but they never took it.
@@gloss39 a stable success required time.... V knows that shortcut is never going to give them that stable and respectful success which BTS have rn.
I looked up BTS a few years ago just because I kept hearing about them but didn’t even know what they were or anything at all about Korea of KPop. I looked them up in the way I do a hundred topics in politics, history, pop culture, science etc. I watched a video and was like, okay, sure. Then I watched another video and another video and another video 😂 I was completely sucked in. I have never been a “fan” of anything before. I have never understood heavy interest in celebrities. I have never been interested in the musicians/performers on a personal level, just enjoying music I like and not feeling any loyalty or interest beyond that. I was not even at all a fan of boy bands back in my teen years. I can’t explain it but BTS just totally took me away even while I thought it was silly of me and not seeming on the surface like something I would like at all. I haven’t stopped consuming their content every single day since and am genuinely completely a loyal fan. ❤ They are so talented and charming and magnetic and interesting and they just bring a lot of fun. I really think it’s the same as how a lot of people feel about sports. I never cared about sports but now I follow BTS like they are my favorite NFL team. 😅
And for what it’s worth their English language songs that took off here are among my least favorite. It was Spring Day, Blood Sweat and Tears, and then B sides that really clinched my fan status. It’s taken me a lot more time to appreciate Dynamite and Butter in the context of why they made them and just loving to see them in all sorts of performances because I just love BTS and want to see whatever they offer.
You speak my mind.
@@laurenm.6320I'm an Army since 2014 so I've witnessed all the eras and I do agree with you, the English tracks are definitely my least favorite ones, an they aren't actually even bad songs, they are great well-made pop hits, but just not my cap of tea and don't think they show the charm and skills of BTS to be honest which is a shame since most people seem to get to know them through those first which leaves that cookie-cutter image to them when in fact their discography is far from that....I hoped other songs would be the ones to blow up first but we can't have it all lol so we should just be grateful with what we have now
My thoughts are the same. I check on them every day to see what’s new, what they’re doing, how they’re doing, and listen to their songs. I’m even studying their Korean language and the history of their country. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Oh man, me too exactly. Fandom culture was a complete eye roll to me until I decided I needed to know the names of these boys after checking out a couple of their music videos 😂
I feel like clapping . That’s the first time I’ve heard praise for BTS in a measured and respectful way. Thank you
I like what he said.. BTS did not cross over North America, North America crossed over to BTS💜
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP.
@@himaririku9254 ummm… 🤔
@@himaririku9254Obudź się słoneczko wysoko nie wypada tak dalej spać
@@himaririku9254join the winners even one solo of BTS members kill all kpop industry in billboard charts. Keep crying
BTS is a once in a lifetime phenomenon - the talent, artistry, positive influence. Their discography is extensive and very impressive.
As an army, I’ve become so TERRIFIED of videos like this because so often BTS are insulted and their success is belittled down to dynamite alone. I’m so so happy you guys are so informed and took so much time to understand them, their artistry and their history. Excellent video!! And each point was so true!
I knew when he said "they did it by being themselves, not compromising anything"...I was like 'ok, ok, you get it!"
I only got in to BTS a little over a year ago after sleeping on them for years and they completely blew me away. They're pure talent I've never seen any group that's as skilled or versatile as they are. They literally do it all, cover all genres, make their own music, and have the most meaningful powerful concepts and lyrics that've managed to help millions of people all over the world. Not to mention their humble genuine selves and their unmatched bond with each other and with Army.
They've transcended the k-pop label a long time ago and even though they've been the biggest group in the world for years I still believe that their skills are very underrated unfortunately because of the "k-pop stereotypes". I feel really bad for anyone who judges them off of their 3 pop English songs that they released during the pandemic to cheer people up and that don't represent their music at all. They have no idea what they're missing out on.
You're a baby (maybe toddler 🤔) army🫶🫶 im always curious how chapter 2 army find the guys. Did you decide to check them because of a solo song/album you came across, group music or something else like a variety show video ?
@@g100-w6j None of the above actually 😁 The first time I checked them out was around 2018. I listened to mic drop and boy with love since I was a fan of both Steve Aoki and Halsey. I liked mic drop and didn't like boy with love. I unfortunately judged them, thought they were too poppy and never listened to them ever again.
Fast forward to last year I sometimes watch reaction videos of my favorite artists and I'd often find BTS pop up so I wanted to understand the hype. I decided to give them a final chance so I started watching both songs and interviews. Their interview on Fallon and their carpool karaoke were some of the first videos I saw and their personalities and charms specially Jimin's made me want to learn more. Within a few days I was completely in love with everything about them and I regretted not having given them a chance earlier. It was exactly a couple of days before Jimin released Face and I had no idea they'd be releasing so much stuff during the military I'm trying to catch up on as much of their content as possible it's not easy 😂
@user-vv7hc7kb5o None of the above actually 😁 The first time I checked them out was around 2018. I listened to mic drop and boy with love since I was a fan of both Steve and Halsey. I liked mic drop and didn't like boy with love. I unfortunately believed in the stereotypes, thought they were too poppy and never listened to them ever again.
Fast forward to last year I sometimes watch reaction videos of my favorite artists and I'd often find BTS pop up so I wanted to understand the hype. I decided to give them a final chance so I started watching some interviews then songs. Their personalities and charms specially Jimin's made me want to learn more. Within a few days I was completely in love with everything about them and I wished I'd given them a chance earlier. It was exactly a couple of days before Jimin released Face and I had no idea they'd be releasing so much stuff after so I'm trying to catch up on as much of their content as possible it's not easy 😂
@@g100-w6j I was also wondering how long do I have to be a fan until I'm no longer a baby Army 🤔
I actually agree. BTS is a wild ass band. I won't lie, I did judge them off their English music and hated on them for a while bcz I generally just don't like K-pop. Just a year ago, I decided to be more open about my music taste and decided to check out bts since im a big j cole fan. I was literally stunned about their whole discography and individual stories so I decided to check out other K-pop groups, but they just didn't feel as genuine in music as bts, they almost felt like pretty faces with talents but no determination for music. I don't think I'll like kpop any day but I geniunly appreciate and support bts as people and as artists
As an older ARMY and music freak all my life, I am so grateful to BTS for bringing me into something entirely new for me and teaching me the Korean culture in the meantime! I first saw them on SNL and just was so curious because I hadn’t seen anything like them EVER - first of all, talented dancers, amazing and cool vocals, and so bright and gorgeous looking… I mean who could compare? I’ve watched them grow over the last 5+ yrs with their talent, their artistry and growing from boys to young men and I’m they are the most delightful refreshing thing in my life - no joke! They gave me smiles and laughter during the pandemic whenever all were a bit scared about what was our future and they are the friendliest and most caring of their fans I have ever seen in my life. It’s astounding to me. I think that maybe a big appeal besides the music to western fans because most western artists are not like that at all. It’s beautiful and genuine and you can see these guys real personalities and souls which they share fairly openly. Rolling Stone a magazine I have been reading for most of my life, giving space to this band that means to world to me makes me feel proud and I hope we get lots more content about BTS because they honestly deserve it more than a lot of others! 💜
I think the reason why they are phenomenal is their genuine passion for music. Many people resonates with their music because they have always been true to their craft.
@@kateorioza940 All of them.
I was familiar with BTS before the pandemic, but during lockdown, I truly think they saved me. Every Army finds BTS when they need them and I definitely needed them at that time.
Me and you sister. I was in a very bad place and they saved me ❤
i am so glad they found u when u needed support. hugs.
Ohh..me too..
Bts are beyond kpop now they are world star and its all because of their song ,their performance, positive messages to world, bring joy and help people cope from problems and save people's life❤bring them to love without any language barrier which is what they did and have a global impact and this is all possible because they are so down to earth people ,they are great artist, THE LEGENDS.
I also think it’s important to mention that BTS never even planned on releasing dynamite. They had planned to enlist after MOTS tour in 2020, but covid ruined that plan. So instead, they changed everything in order to stick around with armys during such a hard time. I just find that really beautiful. And the fact that it blossomed into a new level of success for them was just a bonus!
They wanted to tour the 7 album first. Black Swan and On never got properly toured. So enlistment without covid would have happened earliest 2022.
@@emilwandelNot really, you're probably not army but what BTS said matches with all that op said 😊
@emilwandel they're tour would have start in April and looks like wrapped up in October. They didn't have the extension at the time so Jin would have to be put in his enlistment for Dec 2020
@@everything_purple What made you say they aren't ARMY? They know ARMY details. 😅Just because you disagree with their timeline? 🤷♀ It's ok to not agree...
"I think you must not be ARMY if you don't write the acronym in all caps." 🤭That was a harsh joke because I didn't think it was worth getting aggressive over such a little thing. People like those who left because they didn't want BTS to sing in English are the ones to distrust. 😠
The biggest reason why they are so popular and succesfull is definitely their genuine passion for their art, be it writing, producing, singing, rapping or dancing, as well as their family-like bond.. They are so genuine and humble people and fans can actually feel that they're not doing this for the money.. 💜💜
The impact BTS has on the global market as korean artists is something we will never see again since now a lot of kpop artists have started to merge different culture just to target more audience, it sounds great at first but on a deeper note it takes away the value of kpop as a core. I think the members closeness and respect toward their culture as an all korean members group also has an impact on their over all image as kpop acts, the boys do release english music for international fans but they also maintain their originality by sticking to their mother tongue which I believe maximises my respect for them as artists and individual, it also shows the boys really are in it for their fans and passion not for chart passions. I hope their country people treat them better and understand their value rather than finding reasons to put them down, cause BTS have provided the global recognition to kpop and korean culture that it has today.
@@suprabhasuprabhaswain one of the great achievements of BTS is the way they've combined Korean and English lyrics so seamlessly to create a bilingual hybrid so that their songs can have international reach, not so much for the markets but to find a wider audience. Of course they're not the first Korean artists to create bilingual pop music, but they have elevated it to smother level.
And it means they have been able to focus on their own culture while appealing to an international audience, something that ABBA could not do, as they basically had to use all English lyrics and global themes for their international releases. I mention ABBA because I'm old enough to remember just how huge they were (apart from in the US), in their day the biggest pop group globally since the Beatles (even my jazz-loving dad was impressed when he read that in the NZ Herald). ABBA never did crack the US market though, as that would have required a lot more touring than Agnetha was willing to do as a mother.
One key factor we need to remember. Because of media was shifting and changing. BTS was brought up grass root. Far from original international network pipeline. Which caused big frictions between network TVs and music industry with BTS.
BTS changed the game.
With such backgrounds resulting later even making their own IT media platform. Dope G.O.A.T
They're no longer just K. World artist would be appropriate.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP.
Yess- Worldwide Artists for sure😮
Ok, but why in this interview?? @@himaririku9254
@@himaririku9254idź na swój kanał tylko się nie utop
Or global
This woman must be an Army !
A very knowledgeable ARMY. Go girl!!!💜
ARMY💜BTS RELATIONSHIP IS MORE THAN A FAN❤
Sure she knows everything!!
@@debbiel.wilk1824 yes, and she is obviously an RM bias and Suga bias wrecker 😎🤣🤣🤣🤣✌️✌️✌️
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP
Personally I am not a person who is into music. Like I listen to many song but it doesn’t hit me. Like listening to romantic or sad song doesn’t make me feel anything. But BTS is different. I could relate to their songs. I have cried & laughed, it's just feels like even without telling anything they comforts us like they know us. That's why their song & they are so close to my heart. Even though we have different language we share the same feelings. I am really waiting for their 2025 comeback.
BTS success is based on so many factors Its not just their music its bcuz of the people they are ..their behavior, their message, their down to earth nature and always trying their best to give something to fans and make feel armys their value...its actually very hard to decode but yes fans love them and Bts has made huge impact on their lives including myself...they are true example of underdogs those start from nothing to everything...sometimes their fans are called out for overprotective nature yes it is there but people dont understand its is bcuz fan know their lifestory and what they went through and how badly world treated them in the beginning of their career..So even a single feeling of anything wrong against the members make them alert...Bts will never loose fans bcuz of how loyal members and armys are for each other (leave the obsessed fans ofcourse those go overboard sometimes) and always be the example of nobody to legends..and i wont ever get tired to defend them no matter what the world opinion is..
I’m becoming an BTSARMYMOM 2018 when I listened to a spring day song I cried I felt sadness. Even though the lyrics is korean. I’am a BTS ARMYMOM forever. I'm 52 yrs old💜💜💜
And yet we refuse to play them on the radio and recognize the true ICONS they are. Yep, ICONS at the MJ, MDNA, The BEATLES level. 100%
Spring Day🎉 The Queen! And yes, they did Dynamite to make us happy and bring light to a dark time. I was already a huge fan, and this was a great moment for all of us…
It’s been great to see their growth individually-I love them all so much for their artistry, their talent, and what great musicians they are. Looking forward to their return as a whole group. 2025, let’s go! 💜🥳
As good as Dynamite is, it's not close to anyone of their best songs. In fact, I think Butter is better.
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP.
Of all boy bands... they are an exception, that's for sure.🔥🔥🔥
BTS PAVED THE WAY 🤘👑
BTS are unique artists. Their appeal is global. Their relationship with ARMY is authentic & wonderful.
Now ask why radio refuses to play almost anything by BTS on the radio. Oh wait I know the answer - Payola.
Billboard needs to stop counting radio plays.
@@PyrateSilly No , because radio likes American singers . BTS is far superior to these people !
@@debbiel.wilk1824Payola for sure
@@debbiel.wilk1824 yes, because american artists use payola / the industry profits back from them lol. bts indeed proved they dont need to play along with these cheap tactics.
@@debbiel.wilk1824 where are you from?
exactly! happy to see that their are people who can still see the facts!
My purple heart is pouring with pride for what BTS has accomplished 💜
BTS LEGEND 🔥
No group can replace BTS
They have tried, but no one was successful!
BTS IS BEYOND KPOP 💜
BTS is Worldwide Sensation and Global Phenomenon. BTS is the reason why kpop is something right now. No one comes close to their level of success and popularity
BTS gives me the warmth of home , world class performance and top notch entertainment!! 💜 APOBANGPO💜💜💜
1:26 I almost fell over hearing you say bangtan rose globally being exactly themselves and never comprising- I want to seriously thank you both from the heart for recognizing that dynamite wasn’t grasping for western validation, selling out, etc etc - calling it a victory lap meant so much to me, I’m so relieved to hear RS speak accurately about our 7
Proud to be a Hardcore ARMY & very proud of my 7 Idols 💜
Same.
Me too!
Same, I’m an OG International ARMY & True ARMY (OT7) Borahae 💜💜💜💜💜
I stanned Big Bang but after Seungri was arrested for the Burning Sun incident, I stopped listening to K-Pop. Several years later, I started listening to Fire and it was on repeat on my playlist but I really don't know who sang it. After I researched at youtube, I discovered who BTS is and I've been a proud ARMY ever since. I love how they are so authentic, effortlessly hilarious and great artists. Borahae!
For ARMY its all 7 members and if one missing than its not bts. Bts did it because of all OT7 💜 and each members have their own contribution and shines in❤️
They respect and love each other's a lot and all these make bts today a legend.
BTS FOREVER
BORAHAE
Facts, OT7 or nothing 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
It must also be said that the members of BTS are an antidote to toxic masculinity, and I think it is very refreshing to American female fans such as myself.
OMG this statement was exactly how I have felt.for.years!! Being from the US and having to see, read, hear is a complete turn off.
Bts are bts they don't want them to compare with beatles because bts wanted their own name and don't want to compare with someone...they are also a fan of beatles but they want to be THE BTS to world and having their own identity, which they definitely did they became THE bts whom world know now🤴
Periodt 💯
EXACTLY!
@@Teamo.bora. But the Late Show homage skit was all about recognising that BTS were the biggest thing since the Beatles to hit the American pop music scene, and that they were performing on exactly the same stage as the Beatles.
It was not at all suggesting that they're any kind of copy of the Beatles, simply that they are as culturally significant on an international scale as the band that defined a decade and a generation all those years ago, and have remained relevant to this day. BTS are poised to leave a similar legacy, and that Beatles skit was a playful nod to their achievement and projected trajectory.
How these well-meaning but blinkered music journos could get it so wrong is beyond me. They're looking for insults to get righteously offended about, where none were intended and none were given.
I liked this conversation. But it has the same issue than many discussions about "BTS during the pandemic": they forget BE
Yup, unfortunately so...and it's actually one of their best ever albums....
Agree, BE Album is BTS‘ Bohemian Rhapsody, I loved watching them create every aspect of it during lockdown and they would have group meetings in their “teams” and Yoongi painting/designing his album cover will always be my favourite clip.
I LOVED seeing a thoughtful and INFORMED discussion on BTS!! THANK YOU ROLLING STONE!! Thank you to these two two people (I didn’t catch your names) for truly researching BTS and understanding before talking about them. One of the best BTS discussions I’ve seen by American media. Thank you.
It was my understanding that BTS dressed in the style of the Beatles because they had just matched a Beatles record, and because they were performing in the Ed Sullivan Theater, where the Beatles made their American debut. It wasn't my impression that the intent was to make them more palatable to a western audience - they already had a huge American fandom. It was just a bit emphasizing that their massive popularity rivals that of The Beatles (and giving Colbert the chance to do his Ed Sullivan impression)
Yes, that is why...💜
Why i love BTS. I'm american and have been Army since 2014. Its the lyrics. Plain and simple. Then the personalities. They are real and genuine in their love for each other which you feel it and see it and their love for us. Who does what they have done in this next chapter for us? What artist? None. We only hear from artists here in the US if they drop a album, then you don't here from them for 2 years. They are the real deal. No one will ever be like them. I understand people sometime will hate the fan base. Its only because the different cultures and lack of english and english slang and not understanding the meaning of what they are saying. Then because of the lack of understanding they go into attack mode. Of course then their is the obssessed Solo's and hater's that are possers. For anyone that is not in the fan base, it can seems we are a bunch of crazy people. But if they took the time to get to know us they would realize we are really educated. They just need to be open minded and respectful
After 11 years, BTS still has this relevant impact especially in this era where we are witnessing their individual growth as they enter their chapter 2.
Yes.. jimin is charting #1 in global spotify now for 2 days, who is raising every where breaking many records, broke spotify record in South Korea for any Kpop song, going viral.... All this when he is not evn around for promoting his song.
Yes.. jimin is charting #1 in global spotify now for 2 days, who is raising every where breaking many records, broke spotify record in South Korea for any Kpop song, going viral.... All this when he is not evn around for promoting his song.
Army’s please god it’s a great little video about their impact and their growth within music, it’s a positive video. Don’t go into it thinking it’s bad!
i was worried about this. thanks for sharing!
I was definitely worried lol
Haven’t seen any negative comments. So far.
It is bad, it's xenophobic at best and perhaps these people should have done a little bit of research.
@@LPnerd
What video did you watch lol
The impact of Dynamite deserves to be highlighted again and again! BTS is a one of kind group, and everyone involved in their path to global success deserves high praise! Thanks for the mention of the BEATLES, and how the only thing they really have in common is they are a boy group, but everything else from their music to performance is unique and probably can't be recreated! Bang Shi Hyuk and his team made lighting strike in the same place 7 times, with these 7 amazing young men (writing, producing, rapping, dancing, charm!)
Thank you for the professional conversation. BTS is beyond kpop. They transcend languages and races because of their genuine personalities, their lyrical poetry and incomparable stage presence. BTS is the only artist I listen to because they're the only ones that give me that whole package 💜💜
BTS is LEGEND👑💜
They appeal to ALL ages and every gender identity!! I’m 48 and obsessed with BTS. They are my life!! Amazing, beautiful inside and out, extremely funny, insanely talented guys! They have so much content (legit, it’s unbelievable how much content they have), they absolutely love their fans, they love each other like brothers and they really do become like family to us ARMYs. They make such a difference to my life. I honestly don’t know where I’d be or how I’d be without them, they literally saved my life 🥹💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Man I love BTS
Dynamite actually introduced me to BTS
Can't wait for them to return next year
I love BTS not only for their TALENT and MUSIC but also for the love they have for ARMY 💜 The bond is unbreakable and transcends all race and age...They certainly are a phenomenon and I can't wait for them to come back!
BTS is a phenomeon! legends of the 21st century 💜
When pple get to know BTS and discover they had an entire discography full of gems and the US public was just THAT late to the party
Michelle Kim perfectly described BTS’ story and the depth of their lyrics. And both hosts really had a real knowledge of BTS history and their music. It’s rare in western media to find this respectful and thoughtful discussion about BTS so thank you Rolling Stone!
@7:11 Colbert had them in Beatles Kit because it was a performance in the Ed Sullivan Theater. He, himself, was in Sullivan Cosplay.
I thought it was a cute bit. We don't usually get guest bits with non-English speakers (I think we only saw them do more than one with Corden and Fallon), and Colbert's team went all out to recreate the Beatles' stage.
I also saw it as a nice way to celebrate the theatre, itself, and how it's been around to see pop culture celebrate music from the Beatles to BTS.
BTS has devoted fans. Their fans will support ANYTHING they do. That's loyalty!
BTS=THE BEST TALENT ON THE WORLD
Seeing BTS’ “entrance” into the western market as their VICTORY LAP by acknowledging their already established legacy long before Dynamite is everything
Thank you for this; it's extremely refreshing to listen to people discuss BTS, actually take them seriously, and discuss their incredible organic rise to popularity. Dynamite was such a specific moment of triumph in the midst of such a terrible year, and while I will always feel it's a bit bittersweet that they got their first #1 with an all-English track, no one can question how amazing it is! I'll always be grateful to BTS because I found them at a point in my life when I had really lost my joy in life and they brought it back - I was 35 then and I'm 42 now, but I love them even more now than I did on day 1. Appreciate you taking time to unpack all of this!
It’s their hard work and sincerity for music, dance, art, fan, family, content and everything else!
Bts is now beyond and above k pop ........
Queen Spring day is mentioned!!!!❤
I am glad finally people who know about true BTS and their history talking about them.
Thanks for the discussion. I would be interested in seeing a response to this from, for example, Bang Si Hyuk (BTS' founder) and now Chairman of Hybe. OR, from RM or Suga or J-Hope or any of the other members actually, but RM as the leader in particular. I found BTS through Black Swan - the artfulness and beauty of the song and the meaning as well drew me in. Now full ARMY since 2021 when I found them and never looking back. Best group in history, and not like any other "Boy Band" I've heard in the past. I wish the US would get over whatever stigmas they have and PLAY BTS ON THE RADIO!! I rarely listen anymore on radio and instead use Spotify.
From what I eard , you have to pay to have your music played in mainstream media. BTS dont need to pay anybody😅 and they dont need those mms 😊 Found them on YT
@@ghyslainemichaud9978 I agree - they shouldn't have to, and I don't want them to, pay anyone to have their songs played. I found them on YT also, through Black Swan. :)
really wish radio hosts weren’t so focused on money and discrimination based on language or other things. bts’s music (group and solo) is too good not to play it on the radio! (black swan is definitely top 3 of my favorite bts songs too!)
@@artmxyt Agreed!
@@artmxyt
It's not the radio hosts - though there have been some that are pretty prejudiced.
I'm told that about 99% of all radio stations in the US were bought up into two companies. I only remember the smaller one - iHeartRadio - unfortunately.
Understanbly this is about money and the hosts get playlists they have to work through. They are usually not music experts or music lovers any more if they ever were.
You buy a CF you can decide the music that plays before and after.
You sponser an event of the radio station and they will play your music.
This is the legal part.
But there is also the illegal PFP part aka. Payola.
Boracity magazine has made a few essays about this.
Rob Sheffield knows what he is talking about, being part of Rolling Stone magazine for almost 30 yrs. Music and its evolution over time, has gone through so many changes and so many impactful artists has appeared.
They brought out talent in music and dance, more so the message of hope and positivity in the most uncertain and stressful time globally when things felt gloomy and sad. At the same time they were the type of youth who though had angst and depression were pushing and hoping for better.
Y’all really know your stuff. (Thank you Rob Sheffield-you’re a legend!) Love your comments!
BTS really impacted the world and they help thousands of people around the world with the wonderful message of self-love that we all need. Personally, I am more than grateful to know about them and enjoy their music. 💜💜💜
It’s so very very refreshing and heartwarming, having someone talking about BTS, who actually knows what they are all about. Thank you! 🙏🏻 I applaud you!
Love the 1st half of the interview. It was organically intellectual and kind as well as respectful. The concept of world-building as a connective force and energy for creating the beautiful synergistic connection of BTS & ARMY. All the members contributed to lyric composition. Even if it was a phrase or message. And all of them read high level intellectial and mental wellness works that gave them this strong dedication to the depth and purpose of their message. And everything has always been ARMY centric. What makes us happy, helathy, emotionally well. Thats what sets them apart and makes them gorgeously unique. Ive been ARMY since eqley 2014 and as a then 48 yo Indian mother, i somehow found myself connecting to and enjoying their work, personalities and content. Forward to 2024 and they have physiacally changed my life and career.
Wow, Army here.
Their sincere, honest, humble and clean image and comraderie speaks volumes and is as legendary as their music, vibe and overall performance. There is no other group like them. They kept me sane through the pandemic and still today. They are “dynamite”. personified. I respect this interview. Well done Rolling Stone fir a balanced opinion piece.
I am so pleasantly surprised by this video. I don't usually expect for mainstream sources to treat them with this much respect and knowledge. Great work guys!
Thank you for such a thoughtful podcast! I am really looking forward to what BTS can evolve into when they are back together and each found their own flavour in their solo projects. Exciting times ahead!🎉💜💜💜
So glad this was recommended to me. Didn't realize Rolling Stone magazine had a YT channel. Great honest content!
This was a really great discussion. SO nice to see BTS get such respect from Rolling Stone (and iHeart, even though they don't even add BTS songs to the corporate playlists for the most part).
My only complaint is mentioning BTS and New Jeans in the same podcast, let alone the same sentence. They rode into the industry on their sunbaes' backs, then stabbed them in the back.
I'm impressed - in just half an hour you managed to cover so much of what made a cerebral fiftysomething westerner like me become a passionate BTS fan in 2020. Next time I want to explain it to someone I may just send them this link....
And woman number 2 - also an Army ! 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
I am 41 yr old and im starting love BTS 2023 only they are different among other boyband or artist i cant elaborate all as far as i know they attract ,they hypnotized your soul when u started watching them they have a good soul and u inlove with the 7 of them i really enjoy watching them everyday💜💜💜
I’m so proud being an ARMY!
The fact that Spring Day was mentioned! Thank you for that.
Great conversation. Thank you for the closer look.
The sincerity and respect of this discussion feel healing for me. As the interview kept going my admiration and gratitude kept growing. Thank you for the time and careful thought put into this analysis/tribute video. I hope the word spreads among ARMY so we can give you our appreciation.
Here I am from america, discovering the best group that is out there and nothing could be better so greatful to had gave them a chance. ❤❤❤😅😅
The conversation is very mature and beautiful. Thank you for talking about BTS. 💜 I am a Dynamite ARMY, met them when I underwent depression during COVID. Their RUN BTS show was so funny that they were the reason I could laugh so hard at that time. Love them til now. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
BTS ganó credibilidad conmigo a partir del discurso de RM de 2018 en la ONU, eso me hizo escuchar su música. Nunca me gustó el estereotipo del Idol de Kpop, pero ese discurso y las letras de sus canciones lo hicieron para mí. RM tiene una profundidad musical que cerró el trato para mí y luego me hizo caer en el grupo completo.
They are legends !!BTS is unstoppable 🎉
Thank you for this interesting discussion 💜
I'm ARMY since junuary 2022 and I'm sure I will be fan of them always :)
Btw Jimin has released new album named "MUSE"
It's great. Especially title track "Who".
Spring Day and Dynamite makes us happy and it’s their number 1 hit !! They deserve all the credits and how much their music inspire us 💜
Thank you for the respect you're showing to BTS! It's good to see a discussion based on facts!
Honestly anyone can become that big but while in the process of becoming big they forget their roots but BTS has been acknowledging their roots ever since it's really hard to stay humble while you have achieve that level of sucess even the most popular kpop girl group forgot their roots and the fact that they WROTE their life in songs is what makes people connect cause we live like e/o we have same issues and they connect with us and not to forget the fact they had to prove those people who didn't believe them and I'm proud to say they did 🤍
BTS loves me and says so in every song. That's why I love BTS right back.
Each member has their own charms and very talented 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
BTS is the bestt!!!
Thank you for this video. I appreciate the research, care and, above all, the respect you place on BTS, the members and their beautifully diverse discography 💜