*Not a role that's exactly in the Lyric Baritone repertoire, but Dimitri has enough darkness in his sound, a strong enough lower register, and an intelligent approach to singing an aria normally associated with bigger, heavier voices.*
Merril era della vecchia scuola , grandissimo verdiano .... Altro pianeta di fronte agli altri due, bravi, preparati ma senza la struttura baritonale necessaria per Verdi... Vedi Warren, Tagliabue, Campolonghi e ovviamente Bastianini e Cappuccilli. Credo di averne dimenticato qualcuno ma era come indicazione.. Questo era l' olimpo dei baritoni della seconda metà del secolo scorso... Sulla prima siamo addirittura nel mito specie per alcuni nomi che molti neppure conoscono più... Peccato!!!
что вам написать??как в 89 я подарила мужу дочь, а дима подарил миру свой изумительный голос!и вот его нет!а я есть,мне тоже обещали смерть,если откажусь от операции,на сердце.несправедливо!он был нужнее!!!!
Now his voice is much fuller,deeper, technically equipped with pinpoint frasing and incomparable breathcontrol. Take his artistic growth and superb vocal technique. lyrical is not better than Verdian- just a different genre. Now this is a gorgeous baritone'in top of his form, able to sing as dramatic as lyric roles perfectly( see his new records- for example, arias and duets wiht R.Fleming in S.-Petersburg and Pushkin' romances).
@@Опера-ы9с Кто тут дурак, время покажет. Ждать осталось недолго. Спорить же с экзальтированными фанатами, способными слышать только самих себя, совершенно бессмысленно.
I preferred his earlier years, this here for example is much more into the repertoire. Opera is not only super fortissimo. He surely had a huge voice and he tried to Impress all the time. Younger Hvorostosvky was better. Either way he was one of the greatest ever. R.I.P.
@@WarrioRAbsolutE He was a huge talent, but his voice was on the small side. The voice was dark but ultimately light, and he progressively tried to make it sound more dramatic like Ettore Bastianini. It worked in recordings, but made him sound muffled live. I heard him a few times sing with Sondra Radvanovsky, and whenever they sang together, he was completely inaudible. I am with you: I prefer his earlier performances (like this one) when he was still singing within himself.
@Mityatya1994 I'm sorry, I was replying to user qqweerttzuui, who wrote "long live the CCCP", himself being from Spain. And yes, eastern Europe, central Europe and central Asia were occupied by bad people who happened to be leaders of USSR. Is it possible to love a country and hate its politicians?
It is truly sad that he chose to continue down the path of poor technical training. The German/Nordic school of training has now robbed him of this former beauty.
thats not true, im not a fan of saying better in music, but his voice really was better. its not darker today! it has always been dark! but nowadays he sings with much pressure und doesnt have this brilliance and float anymore.
He's not better younger, you like him better younger. Darker is not worse. Now his voice is much fuller. Compare his newest Tchaikovsky CD to the preceding romances CDs - both as for the voice AND for the interpretation, the newer is much superior. Not counting his artistic growth, you're basically saying that lyrical is better than Verdian. That may be true for you (and that's perfectly fine! Like I prefer baritones to tenors :-) ), but, please, don't generalize.
@frufruJ And do you know, what you're talking about? What countries ware occupied by USSR? Eastern Europe? Nonsense. Please, stop slinging mud at USSR. Make music, not animosity.
Time is a cruel mistress... and our boy Dmitri is a stud! But is it better to look good or sing good? My bet is that he would wish this performance to go away--as another comment said "It's not good". He is much better now--better musically. This is breathy and out of tune. His Italian has also improved. Cruel indeed!
There's some truth in what you're saying, but you're comparing apples to oranges. The singers you mentioned were all DRAMATIC Baritones. Naturally their voices were larger, more dramatic, more exciting. Dimitri's advantages are a gorgeous sound and incredible style and musicality.
Dmitri Hvorostovsky sems to evolve fastly into a crier and yeller like Pavarotti. He will never reach the sensitive voice of Juan Pons and the overwhelming presentation of Leo Nucci even remotely.
One of the most beautiful voices I ever heard.
He is the greatest opera singer in his time. It is such a shame that many overrated sopranos and tenors got more attention that they deserved.
Right said
Tenía solo 27 años y ya era un genio. Que triste Dima que te fuiste tan pronto. Amor eterno
Long live the silver fox Hvorostovsky! He had a voice like no other.
He dead
This is an amazingly brillian rendition! I also like "early Dmitri" more - the voice is like shining, supple and resonant!
Dimitri is great from the begining to the end of his life! Glorious! Great! The best forever!
Сколько же много в него бог вложил генеальности,какое проникновение, мощьолубина погружения.ВЕликое счастье жить в одно время с гением-в нем все
Una interpretazione grande al pari della bella voce. Grazie.
Слушаю любимого Д. Хворостовского каждый день и не могу на слушаться и наглядеться
Fiatalon is nagyon tehetséges volt gyönyörű hang 🌹🌹🌹✨️😢
*Not a role that's exactly in the Lyric Baritone repertoire, but Dimitri has enough darkness in his sound, a strong enough lower register, and an intelligent approach to singing an aria normally associated with bigger, heavier voices.*
My endless love💔❤️
Великолепно! Светлая память артисту....
LOVE HIM!!! Rip! Him and Juan pons Alvarez ooooo goals
I had the great fortune to see Robert Merrill and Sheryl Milnes in concert. Dmitri is awesome.
Merril era della vecchia scuola , grandissimo verdiano .... Altro pianeta di fronte agli altri due, bravi, preparati ma senza la struttura baritonale necessaria per Verdi... Vedi Warren, Tagliabue, Campolonghi e ovviamente Bastianini e Cappuccilli. Credo di averne dimenticato qualcuno ma era come indicazione.. Questo era l' olimpo dei baritoni della seconda metà del secolo scorso... Sulla prima siamo addirittura nel mito specie per alcuni nomi che molti neppure conoscono più... Peccato!!!
Two of the most gorgeous baritone sounds ever!
What an amazing concert...
Голос Д. Хворостовського це цінність планети і зразок високої вокальної культури.
Absolutely beautiful, wonderful! THx frufruJ ! YF Luiz
Quelle belle voix!
Excellent!
Maravilloso, increíble, que expresión.
el es muy bueno...... muchos gracias
amazing!!!
Just found this. Thank you FrufruJ for posting the original lyrics and a translation to english.
Świetny baryton......b.dobre wykonanie.....
Please,stop arguing about Dima! He died three days ago! RIP my dear friend.
@Erick Alijah fuck off bots
❤
EXQUISITO
Sokszor elgondolkodom,hogy a Jó Isten milyen csodákat tud teremteni.
что вам написать??как в 89 я подарила мужу дочь, а дима подарил миру свой изумительный голос!и вот его нет!а я есть,мне тоже обещали смерть,если откажусь от операции,на сердце.несправедливо!он был нужнее!!!!
Живите, пока вам не будет сто лет, и, может, последний голос, который вы услышите, будет голос Дмитрия Хворостовского..
Наталья Тодорова
Все мы нужны кому-то. Спросите ваших близких кто им нужнее...
Now his voice is much fuller,deeper, technically equipped with pinpoint frasing and incomparable breathcontrol.
Take his artistic growth and superb vocal technique.
lyrical is not better than Verdian- just a different genre.
Now this is a gorgeous baritone'in top of his form, able to sing as dramatic as lyric roles perfectly( see his new records- for example, arias and duets wiht R.Fleming in S.-Petersburg and Pushkin' romances).
Dmitry Khvorostovsky has huge technical shortcomings, and this, unfortunately, will never be corrected. Records have fixed it forever.
@@petrokhymych6443 ты дурак?
@@Опера-ы9с Кто тут дурак, время покажет. Ждать осталось недолго. Спорить же с экзальтированными фанатами, способными слышать только самих себя, совершенно бессмысленно.
I preferred his earlier years, this here for example is much more into the repertoire. Opera is not only super fortissimo. He surely had a huge voice and he tried to Impress all the time. Younger Hvorostosvky was better.
Either way he was one of the greatest ever. R.I.P.
@@WarrioRAbsolutE He was a huge talent, but his voice was on the small side. The voice was dark but ultimately light, and he progressively tried to make it sound more dramatic like Ettore Bastianini. It worked in recordings, but made him sound muffled live. I heard him a few times sing with Sondra Radvanovsky, and whenever they sang together, he was completely inaudible. I am with you: I prefer his earlier performances (like this one) when he was still singing within himself.
That mic is for recording, genius. :-)
@Mityatya1994 I'm sorry, I was replying to user qqweerttzuui, who wrote "long live the CCCP", himself being from Spain. And yes, eastern Europe, central Europe and central Asia were occupied by bad people who happened to be leaders of USSR. Is it possible to love a country and hate its politicians?
Yes
It is truly sad that he chose to continue down the path of poor technical training. The German/Nordic school of training has now robbed him of this former beauty.
I like more the Swedish-Italian style represented by Erland Hagegård and Jussi Björling
thats not true, im not a fan of saying better in music, but his voice really was better. its not darker today! it has always been dark! but nowadays he sings with much pressure und doesnt have this brilliance and float anymore.
He's not better younger, you like him better younger.
Darker is not worse. Now his voice is much fuller. Compare his newest Tchaikovsky CD to the preceding romances CDs - both as for the voice AND for the interpretation, the newer is much superior.
Not counting his artistic growth, you're basically saying that lyrical is better than Verdian. That may be true for you (and that's perfectly fine! Like I prefer baritones to tenors :-) ), but, please, don't generalize.
Time is a cruel mistress,,,but Dmitri isn't exactly chopped liver these days,,,,,
Too long and drawn out...the whole piece is NOT legato. Once it hits the D flat section, that style is more appropriate, and his A flat is spot-on.
Мuslim Magomaev. "Si può, si può?..." Prologue from I Pagliacci (Leoncavallo) hat mich stark beeindruckt. Hvorostovsky
enttäuschte mich.
Tiny ingolata voce
I hope that mic is OFF.
It's for recording.
@frufruJ
And do you know, what you're talking about?
What countries ware occupied by USSR?
Eastern Europe? Nonsense.
Please, stop slinging mud at USSR.
Make music, not animosity.
Yeah, as long as they're killing their own millions and not occupying other countries. You don't know what you're talking about.
Time is a cruel mistress... and our boy Dmitri is a stud! But is it better to look good or sing good? My bet is that he would wish this performance to go away--as another comment said "It's not good". He is much better now--better musically. This is breathy and out of tune. His Italian has also improved. Cruel indeed!
and also he is not really innovativ anymore, where are the musical ideas today?
Прекрасно, но для меня лучшее исполнение этой партии это П.Г. Лисициан, к счастью, запись сохранилась
А как Вам Тито Гобби?
послушал. как то не тянет на лучшее. хворост, конечно, еще хуже.
@@Алексей-и5ш2б Х. пафосный и на полтона ниже поет
@@Illariya_pavlovna это не важно, дело в самом качестве пения
Ernesto Petti
th-cam.com/video/b308q-twxg4/w-d-xo.html
я не знаю языки
long live the CCCP!!!!
This is not the voice a baritone...
What is it?
no es para el
Mario del Monaco lo canta mejor
Es un tenor. No se puede comparar peras con manzanas.
En serio?
Obvio que no se puede comparar, aun así un tenor dramático lo canta mejor.
th-cam.com/video/b308q-twxg4/w-d-xo.html
@@watekemanHe performed it badly. Listen to a real rendition by Paoli Silveri.
Sad that listeners think this singing is so great. He is mediocre compared to the likes of Bastianini, Macneil, Capuccilli and Warren.
His G# is impressive tho
There's some truth in what you're saying, but you're comparing apples to oranges. The singers you mentioned were all DRAMATIC Baritones. Naturally their voices were larger, more dramatic, more exciting. Dimitri's advantages are a gorgeous sound and incredible style and musicality.
He is not a real baritone
Stfu
What is he then?
No. He is a fabulous baritone
What is a "real baritone"?
А еще позже это был самый настоящий баритон, актер, музыкант. Им и остался навсегда
Non è il suo ruolo
Mah...senza lode e senza infamia. Il tempo non ha aggiunto molto alla sua tecnica ed ha tolto freschezza al suo canto. Comunque c'è ben di peggio.
Sicuramente Ernesto Petti è migliore.
th-cam.com/video/Xdw2VeTtbpI/w-d-xo.html
Наверное очень классно...только что послушала арию Канио...басков...впечатлило больше.
facercheto, значит, Басков - это Ваш уровень. Продолжайте слушать дальше.
Очен смешно 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dmitri Hvorostovsky sems to evolve fastly into a crier and yeller like Pavarotti. He will never reach the sensitive voice of Juan Pons and the overwhelming presentation of Leo Nucci even remotely.
you will never reach...anything. gtfo.
insanely insular comment.
Pavarotti, a "crier and a yeller"? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dead Russian..........
Fuck you
It,s not good...