What did you think of Dune Part 2? To try everything Brilliant has to offer for free for a full 30 days, visit brilliant.org/midnight or click on the link in the description. You’ll also get 20% off an annual premium subscription.
Loved it! I think some book pureists will be annoyed with the ending, but imo Denis did a good job for his version of Dune and the message he wanted to send. I was a bit disappointed with the ending because I love the book ending with Chani and Jessica, but I get that it didn't fit with his vision of the story.
I'll admit while watching Dune i started wondering how expensive this movie was compared to recent super hero movies. I was blown away by the fact that it has a smaller budget.
@@MoManiaTV not speaking for them but The Creator has amazing visuals, especially given the budget, but I just couldn't get into it and a lot of that was due to how the movie was edited. The editing caused the pacing of the movie to feel fast though it was definitely a film that wanted to have those intimate character moments.
That's not always the case. Tony Gilroy isn't familiar with Star Wars and he made the best thing on the franchise since Empire Strikes Back. Sometimes you need someone that isn't totally familiar that can bring new blood. I'm kind of an iconoclast tho, so that's really a personal opinion. I thing we just need good writers and give them time.
The bigger problem is the studios themselves, they're run by executives who don't know anything about movies, never mind fiction and they carelessly hire the wrong people, or they hire the right people and handicap them with non-stop interference. The Dark Tower (2017) is a good example, the director was apparently a *massive* Stephen King fan, and a capable director, he still gave us one of the worst King adaptations ever, because the studio had no faith in the source material.
That was ALWAYS the key. Almost every flop in the last ten years is because they DON'T stay true to the source material or DON'T care about it... they want to tell their own story, that speaks to them.
When I first saw Dune 1, it is soooo magnetic that I went to read the books immediately. For Dune2, it is the only film so far in my life that I want to watch it a second time directly.
Nice. I saw SW Ep 7 three or four times. Nothing beats an epic movie multiple times in theater. Hopefully Dune 3 is strong and doesn’t stain the trilogy like SW did
Dune has some of the best CGI I've ever seen. None of it feels cartoony or triggers that part of the brain where you go, "Well that's obviously fake." Absolutely loved both parts!
2 of my favorite movies, but did we all forget the original vision Paul has of himself in the gold armor rolling around and fighting? That was really bad and I'm really curious why. Wouldn't put it past general pandemic rushes
Lol yeah that scene *really* stands out in a pair of movies where almost all the effects are amazing. Especially after all the action set pieces in part 2 looked *so* much better.
@1999studios When you see his face in that scene, it definitely could've looked better. Overall though, that's a small drop a in large pond of VFX that are absolutely beautiful, better than most in my opinion, and worth appreciating.
@@1999studiosI remember this scene, but I didn't pay attention to it in the cinema. It seemed to me that the quality has improved since the release of the trailer. It's hard to remember now
There's almost an old Hollywood epic feel to Dune. The way it only has dialogue when it needs but has so much non verbal spectacle to build the world and give it that scale and lived in feeling is amazing.
@@AweSean-wv3xo Villeneuve actually de-Islamized Dune by a lot. You had the concept of Jihad along with Arabic names for Fremen in the books and whatnot. Some of the things in the book, if adapted to the screen would've probably caused all of social media to seethe and review bomb the movie to oblivion.
Honestly, his films remind me SO MUCH of cinema from the 60s and 70s. Naturally, they didn't have ornithopters and CG sandworms, but the attention to visual detail feels like a callback to the masters of the past. And you're right, a lot of "blockbuster" filmmakers just don't shoot for that these days.
Everyone says it’s a cgi v practical debate but more of a pre-production v post production. Too many current blockbusters have been rushed to get shot so little sets, costumes and script edits have been made and it’s all pushed to post prediction for the vfx to carry everything
Indeed. I still find it insane that the time travel suits in Avengers:Endgame were CGI! Not because the filmmakers thought it would look better, but simply because they hadn’t finalized the suit design when they were filming. And then they had the nerve to remove a month of work the VFX teams desperately needed
Look at a film like the Creator. That film cost $80 million and looks way better than some films with 3 times the budget. I was sad to hear that it flopped because I think it's incredible. Why don't more films use the same methods as Dune and the Creator when it comes to VFX since it's cheaper and looks better.
@@Coolcoolcooldude Ye, saw that movie twice in the theatres. Absolutely stunning piece of filmmaking. Kinda wish the story was better, but I would happily take 100 movies like The Creator as opposed to the majority of modern day blockbusters
This is also telling when movies like BALLERINA finished filming over a year ago but not releasing until June 2025, MISSION IMPOSSIBLE 7 & 8 began shooting just before Covid-19 hit, CPT. AMERICA 4 finished filming last year but still years away from coming out, and I’m sure others…
@@Coolcoolcooldude The Creator has significant stumbles in the pacing, no way around it... but saying it lacked vision or that it didn't try to make an "atmosphere" to its world and didn't succeded in some parts is downright a lie.
@@poindextertunes I honestly expected it to hit trilogy status since they were only about 35-40% of the way through the abridged version of the book with part 1. Instead we got 3 immersive hours that felt like it had only been one.
I actually felt like a kid again watching this film. Just felt like something spectacular, immersive and exciting, which I haven’t seen in a very long time
Same thing here, I’m reminded of the time my family and I went to watch Revenge of the Sith in the theater, I’m not complaining about bad characters doing bad choices, not complaining about poor CGI uses, not complaining about the blatant agenda that’s been shoved into the media without even a single concern whether the story will be good or not. I am simply mesmerized by everything that was happening, visually, sonically, and emotionally. It’s been years since I last stepped in a theater, DUNE revived that sense of happiness that the cinema used to fill me with, just pure, simple, joy.
What I said elsewhere is that it's the first movie I'd seen in a while where it felt like the CGI effects were in service of an artistic vision, rather than like shiny keys being jangled trying to entertain a baby. Just being able to sit in a movie theater and feel a movie wash over you rather than feel your mind picking restlessly at the creators' choices feels incredibly luxurious. I enjoyed it a lot.
Dune and Dune Part Two completely blew me away. It has the scale, love and care that EVERY blockbuster movie should have, and having a director that knows how to approach the project is key to that. I am so thrilled by these movies and can only hope they mean a change in the way Hollywood makes these big budget movies
Honestly am already exited for the final part this movie is most certainly one of my favorites especially when it comes to scenery acting and the story
Dune Part One was honestly mediocre imo. Sure, pretty to look at but I fell asleep halfway through. That said, Dune Part Two completely changed my mind. It was nothing short of a spectacle seeing this film in IMAX and furthermore, the story in the second film had me hooked way more than the first.
@@el_chapolman5023 You fell asleep to Dune? How? The first film was fantastic. If you can't handle a slower pace, and need the action of the second film, I'm not sure what you're really even getting out of the franchise. Both are great, neither are mediocre. Watch it again.
@@HEARTS-OF-SPACEOh, definitely! The second film reignited my interest in the series, and I’m certainly going to rewatch the first film. And probably appreciate it more this time around. Cheers👍
I actually shed tears while watching Dune part 2. My girlfriend asked if I was okay and was worried at why I was crying. I had a hard time explaining to her that it wasn't the plot or the events of the movie... But it was that someone took a book/story that is very important to me and treated it with enthusiasm and respect. So many marvel movies, Star wars movies, hell even just remakes in general have let me down with the lack of detail and passion, and to see this treatment gave me hope for the future of movies. I felt engaged, enchanted, enveloped while watching this movie and I haven't felt that in a while.
I watched it with a couple friends the first time, but the second time watched it alone, and I felt this. This is the type of passion that Frank Herbert's work deserved.
I stayed as credit rolled out and swallowed tears too, so happy DV nailed it, thinking this is the right movies/message for our times and how many who never read the saga will be surprised at the following movies. I am so glad there will be another generation discovering this masterpieces and digesting its warnings.
@@martina764 funny you are saying that because I also had a headache the next day when I woke up, but I think it was because of the 02 mojitos and the beer I had the night before lol
I saw this movie, and I have kept having flashbacks from certain scenes. I think that you made me understand why my subconscious is still trying to tell me what a beautiful experience it was and I should cherish it more
My favorite part about Dune is that it feels like a cinematic VISION... It doesn't feel formulaic or as if it's trying to meet a certain studio's quota. Everyone who worked on Dune seems to understand what makes the project so special, and as I was sitting in the theater, I could FEEL that. I know so many people in the audience are hungry for stories and projects that feel like they were handled with love and care. And Dune IS that film.
People complain about being sick of remakes, reboots, and sequels....until one comes along that they love. The problem hasn't been hollywood's insistence on being mostly "unoriginal", it's studio execs cranking out product for the sake of it without genuine passion for the work. Like you said, these two films clearly came from a place of genuine adoration for the material. When a talented filmmaker genuinely loves and understands the material, and the studio execs give them reign to create, then you're far more bound to get a work of art.
As someone who regularly invites friends over for "watch all 3 extended editions of LotR in a day, everyone bring snacks". I'm excited in a few months to add a Dune part 1&2 watch straight through w/ friends.
Several scenes in this movie left me watching in open-mouthed amazement, it's such a well-crafted movie. And the music and sound design is absolutely brilliant along with it.
Dune 1&2 are the perfect examples of what happens when a great director with a clear vision is given creative control over a project they are truly passionate about/understand. Villeneuve has quite literally waited his whole life to make these movies, as he drew out an entire storyboard for Dune when he was a kid!
Absolutely!!! He’s taken the approach that peter Jackson did with LOTR and kept as close to the source material as possible while also doing some cinema creative choices that made sense for the big screen and specific pacing
@@Tsar-Czar that's also what happens when you add woke content appropriately and don't slap it together for the sake of reaching woke people like disney does.
What he says at the 2:00 mark is a really interesting point. Lord of the Rings and Pirates looked so impressive for their time, we were all wondering how CGI would change the way movies were made. Fast-forward 20 years, and it barely changed - if anything it got worse, with most big budget movies looking 10x worse than Return of the King. CGI simply stopped being impressive since it flatlined and even degraded since 2003. Dune is the first movie since that actually looks like a big step forward for CGI. It pushes the technology further creatively without looking fake or overdone. It's probably the best I've seen.
@@holocron_vfx I’m a viewer of movies, and I can tell you that most CGI looks like absolute dogshit. All I need is eyes and a brain to confirm that, no knowledge of computer graphics required. At no point did I claim to be an expert in CGI.
@mrsnulch I am a VFX artist who works in the movies you're viewing and I can tell you that can't confirm shit. Guys like you are the cutest. You watch a movienand make a list "hey look this is CG, that is CG, and over there more CG. Digital technology sucks". Meanwhile your movies have tons and tons more VFX shots that you don't even see because they're well made. So let me know better what's dog shit and what not. I know. You don't.
@@holocron_vfx I don't mean to disrespect your line of work, CGI is crucial to modern filmmaking but when it's used too heavily it breaks my immersion. Basically all Marvel movies of the past 10 years like Thor and Black Panther for example look like computer games to me, same with the Hobbit films. The Disney live action remakes are technically incredible, but look uncanny when human actors interact with the CGI animals. Same with Planet of the Apes. LOTR and Dune are more convincing, possibly because they use computer graphics strategically with real footage instead of rendering entire scenes in CGI. You can say what you want on a technical level as a VFX artist, but viewers can tell when everything they are seeing is VFX, even when it's really well done.
@@mr.snulch Yeah you don't disrespect our work, yet we are the scapegoat of the industry, being blamed every time a movie sucks because studio executives want to do more with less, especially after the catastrophic strikes last year which forced multiple studios to close down. You want to talk about movies looking like video games? Go watch the video essay "why attack of the clones looks like a video game". Then you can click over to Hugo Guerra's "what's with all the CGI hate". And this is my last reply to you. Just by using the acronym 'CGI' you prove what an ignorant clown you are.
For me, Dune part 2 was more about Paul’s fall than his rise. Yes, he frees the Fremen, becomes the emperor, ends the Harkonnen bloodline, all of that. And yet, he goes on to kill billions, all because the Fremen believe in their savior. The movie is one big gom jabbar test. Become their Lisan al Gaib, or watch as Feyd annihilates them. Paul has gotten to the point where he _cannot_ take his hand out of the box, even if the Harkonnen threat has been silenced, and the pain will build forever as the Fremen lead the holy war across the universe. And yes, it was such an awesome story to witness.
The fall really hasn’t even started yet. He didn’t even lose a child like he did in the original book. But Chani’s discontent is certainly strong foreshadowing
@@miz4535yea agreed, everything everywhere all at once, whilst in a very different realm of sci-fi (arguably it's a philosophical mindfuck, for want of a better word) left me with an equally satisfied and persistent feeling of 'wow' upon leaving the theatre.
I watched this movie in 4D and the wind that was blown in our faces had a slight hint of cinnamon and chili, kinda how id expect spice to smell, this was an amazing touch
There is something quite ironic in *Dune* going from a movie that's infamous because the studios interfered with the director (a high profile director like David Lynch nonetheless) to a movie that shows you what happens when the studios don't interfere and let the director do his thing
While that is true, Lynch was recorded as confirming that he'd actually never read the book. So I do believe that even without studio intervention in his version, Villeneue would have been the better movie. If only because of his respect and passion for the source.
@@SomeTH-camTraveler My guess is that is hit or miss. By always following a formula, they can guarantee a movie that will pay itself, being safer. However, that doesn't generate good films - which is not their goal.
When I left the theater, I was hit hard by the "This is what cinema should be". It feels authentic and fleshed out in a way that the mass produced marvel films just can't hit nowadays
I listened to an interview with Villaneuve after Dune II came out. I can't quote him, but he said that he wished that he didn't have to use any dialog and could just tell story with visuals. The care with which he composes his shots is exacting and it shows.
There's something really poetic about the success of the Dune movies, the story of which subverts traditional hero narratives by showing the inevitable dangers of following a charismatic hero, and the decline of comicbook movies. I'll always like my capeshit, and so I'll still check out CBMs, (eventually probably) but there's something really symbolic happening here lol.
I really liked the ending. Previous versions have gone for the heroic triumph feel-good ending and skipped the "...and then he launched an interstellar religious war that killed billions" which is not only something that Paul tried to prevent throughout the majority of the film, even to the point of basically contemplating suicide so he doesn't take that step, but forms a critical part of the future of that universe.
@@hermanubis96 ? Hmm? The context and specifics are in the comment itself. Frank Herbert, through Dune, deconstructs and comments on charismatic figures and the hero narrative. I just thought it's a funny turn of events that the decline of Cape flicks, which rely on traditional hero stories, coincided with a successful adaptation of Dune.
This film felt like it had an actual soul and was made by people who truly loved it and wanted it to be the best that it could possibly be. Most blockbuster movies feel like they came off the corporate assembly line with people who are just here for their paycheck. We need more of the former and no more of the latter.
Agreed. But a lot of that assembly line you speak of is the studios' fault more than the filmmakers. All studios see is dollar signs so they hire whoever they can to crank out product...and the writers and filmmakers jump on board just because they don't want to pass up the [potentially once-in-a-lifetime] opportunity, only to then be boxed in by whatever parameters the execs force them to stick to. I love A24 but I can see them turning into a similar machine in the next 5-10yrs if they're not careful.
Too many people have watched too many cookie-cutter Blockbuster so the studios did not need to produce different movies. I am so glad that in 2023 most DC/Marvel films flopped because now we might have a chance to see different kind of blockbusters again.
Captain Midnight: you should give directors the latitude to fulfill their creative vision without constantly interfering. Studio Executives: “The power to destroy a thing is the ultimate control over it.”
Dune and Part 2 are the first movies that I can recall actually reccomending people specifically to see in theatres. Most movies I feel are just as good on your home tv, but these Dune films feel like blockbusters and I feel actually warrant the trip to a theatre to see them on the big screen. It's just an entirely different feeling from the movies that we've been getting and I'm totally here for, give us more Dune tier movies.
@@happydogg312a home stereo is going to sound better than the theater? How? These films are mixed specifically for the theater, it’s the ideal environment.
@@happydogg312 lol it happens. I will say that I'm a big proponent of the home theater. I think sound is the most overlooked part of the home viewing experience, but I don't think it can ever be better than going to the movies.
@@happydogg312 that's awesome that you have such a sick setup. It's unfortunate your local theaters don't have their systems in order, but I don't know if it's fair to compare your setup to something that's clearly not working correctly. The other thing that we can't recreate at home is the sheer scale of the theater...especially IMAX. But hey, I totally get it. If I was in your situation it'd be hard to get me to leave too lol.
My good friend, as an everyday french speaker from Quebec (from where Denis is from) let me save you from the avalanche of comments you are sure to receive: it is Ville-neuVE. The VE at the end is important to the pronounciation. Much love your review and analysis was execeptional and very entertaining.
I was looking for someone saying this. For those not familiar with the the pronunciation, try pronouncing it to rhyme with how a Londoner would say "nerve" or "serve" (i.e. without pronouncing the letter R). Not a perfect equivalent but it gets you most of the way there.
Its so important to actors to have practical sets to work with too. Despite all the advances weve made you'll always get a more genuine performance when the actors can really feel like they are IN the world (and it lifts some burdens from the VFX team too, they can complement and enhance without being expected to hold up the entire film setting on their dwindling time budgets). Every film school teaches not to rely on fixing things in post, proper planning and communication is essential for a production to flow. I'm very much hoping dune's success will help prove this going forward.
Sometimes when I see how Marvel movies are made, where it's literally an entire green room and actors just dressed in mo cal suites, and each "shot" is just them jumping off something or having half a conversation, I feel sorry for them. How are they supposed to act if they have no idea where they are or what they're meant to be doing? They don't even know what the scene will look like, and don't even have the costumes to even get in character
As someone who read the books, he absolutely made changes. But what he added made sense and kept the plot moving forward. What he took away was nowhere near egregious. Excellent adaptation.
What i love about dune is just the whole universe and the themes that play in it. Villeneuve changes some of the story but he keeps the themes the same and he really works inside of Herberts world. I remember people scolding Paul for not wearing the mouthpiece of his stillsuit all the time in the desert, but i ubderstand why there is little to no mouthpieces used in the movie, and its okay because the other themes are still there
Yeah. I don't like comparing Lynch's attempt to Danny's attempt much, but one difference was very clear to me. When I was watching Lynch's version, I often found myself asking, "Why was it changed and how does it benefit the idea?" When I was watching Dune pt. 2, I found myself repeatedly nodding. "Yes, it was changed, but I can totally see why."
@@andrewmelnikov292 Agree. I was totally bamboozled by the use of projectile weapons (guns) which were made redundant with the introduction of shield technology after the Butlerian wars. The whole point of blades is explained in the book "the slow blade penetrates the shield". (That whole preceding par qualifies me as a geek virgin level 398 btw) But, it made for amazing cinema and elevated the battle scenes to epic! Also, the still-suits are just ridiculously inadequate... but hey, awesome cinema.
@@glenmale1748Tbf it makes sense for the guns. Fremen don't use shields, and I think if I remember right projectiles were used against big and moving targets. Hence also the laser usage. The look of the stillsuites have a simple reason: you can't act awesome on the screen if you have something in your mouth and are not identifiable at all.
As a VFX artist I am really glad you mentioned that it's better if the VFX "enhances" the vision instead of "substitutes" for it. When there are many versions on a single shot or asset ( in bigger shows that over measured in 100s ) it often feels like the client doesn't know what he/she wants. Also what's often the case is that the director is not trusted enough by the studio as they are often "just" hired to direct something but then the studio would like to see things differently
I don't go to the movie theatre often (once every few years), and I haven't had the pull to go more than once for any movie ever. But I'll be going back to watch Dune 2 again. Something about it is primal. The way it is filmed, the colors used, the sound of the score, the threads of stories incorporated, the pace, it all draws you in for a complete experience. The most enjoyable art I have seen on film that I can remember.
I just wanted to congratulate you on an amazing video that I am happy someone made. Dune Part 2 was a breath of fresh air in a dying industry. There hasn’t been a film that felt this complete and awe inspiring in years. If people are still watching Star Wars after watching Dune 1 & 2, then they are not fans of the medium and what it should be. Great video. Agreed with absolutely all of it. Let’s hope for Dune 3
I can’t remember which youtuber said this recently, but I agree with them that the solution isn’t better high budget movies, the solution is smaller lower budget films and more of them. From a financial standpoint it actually spreads out the risk by reducing that financial impact and investment of a single failure. On the creative side, more small films will allow more writers and directors to develop their art and style in relative creative freedom, allowing studios to better evaluate who is worth greater investment in future projects.
That youtuber must be pretty uninformed about the current state of the movie industry then. Smaller films are much less profitable than big budget films, because their advertising budget has to be suitably low to their actual budget, and that means it draws much less of an audience to the theater than a big budget movie. With the average consumer only going to the movies once or twice a year, and the profit from streaming after the movie is out of theater being a pittance, more small budget movies would just doom them all to fail. The industry would need to rework to make movies profitable once they leave cinema in order to make any of that possible.
@@DoctorJammer Messiah can be done, it'll have to be a political thriller with Paul's position as Emperor at stake. Plans within plans to subdue him. I can see it being done in a 2-3 hour film (preferably closer to 3). People won't be ready to have their perception of Paul and his Ji'had crushed. Learning that they are supporting a villain with the heaviest of crowns. I hope they keep some of the more philosophical lines regarding prescience from Paul. I also hope Scytale, Irulan, Erick and Gaius's conversation in the opening chapter is kept in as the intro to Dune Messiah, it just sets the whole tone for the book.
I’ve heard a business perspective that supports your point: We should be rewarding spectacular failures more than mediocre successes. In other words, it is better to shoot for the stars, which will invariably result in some complete misfires, because it has the potential for greatness. Whereas mediocre, safe successes are less likely to fail but also have a much lower ceiling
The key difference is that the spectacular failures have a palpable soul; it feels like someone actually cared about the project and hoped it would succeed (rather than trying to forcibly _make_ it succeed). They gave it their all then handed it over to the audience with their fingers crossed. But these corporate films that are focus-grouped towards supposedly guaranteed success have all the soul systematically drained from them by sackings, rewrites, reshoots, retools that sometimes continue to change things until days before a film's release, because instead of passionate spontaneity the suits want the leeway to alter the film however and whenever they want in response to new "market research" - or as is more often the case, something like one of the non-creative executive's kids telling them that this one thing was cool, so now they HAVE to include it in order to stay "fresh" and "relatable". If they get lucky and cast a charismatic, likeable actor - someone like Will Smith, Jason Bateman, Denzel Washington, Ryan Reynolds - they can sometimes make it work, but when they're stuck with the likes of Dakota Johnson, Brie Larson, John David Washington or Jared Leto, then the film's total lack of inspiration becomes too blatant to tolerate for 90% of the audience.
Dr midnight thank you so much for giving some extra dune content that isn’t spastic or insane like the other TH-camrs. Thank you bud. Was a huge fan and am a huge fan of your content
The entire time while I was watching this movie which is *almost* a masterpiece was, “how did any studio let this be made.”, and I think that itself is telling of Hollywood today.
While I can recognize a lot of the malfeasance that corporate entities contribute to current cinema, what exactly about dune made it seem unmakeable in this corporate environment? I'm ignorant of the details/politics of the industry and I really loved both movies despite knowing nothing about the books, so like what do these execs hate so much? Truly curious bc a lot of people say this but I guess I don't get it bc I just like it?
Your points reminded me of Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness. It was so clear when there was a scene that was allowed to be guided by Sam Raimi's vision rather than Marvel's. And those ended up being my favorite parts of the movie.
No offence but how can you even mention that movie in the same sentence as this. They’re not even in the same universe of competence or writing. That movie was probably the worst marvel movie iv watched, but then again I haven’t watched Thor 4 or quite a few of the worse rated ones.
@NakulKrishna I wasn't comparing it to Dune? Or even putting it in the same league? I was only referring to the mention in the video that studios have pretty much quelled a lot of artistic expression from directors and they don't allow them to portray their own aesthetics or visions. It squashes any sort of uniqueness or originality to a project. Doctor Strange MoM was by no means a masterpiece. I was just saying that the best scenes in the movie were ones clearly allowed to carry Sam Raimi's vision. That's it.
Dennis Villeneuve is probably my favorite director. He's all about cinematic and a mature audience. He doesn't explain everthing but he shows everything you just have to look close enough. But just the compositons he creates are incredible and truly what cinema should be.
I saw it first screening on opening day and haven't stopped thinking about it. I'm going back to see it again in an hour. This feels like when Lord of the Rings was out.
I love Dune, I started reading the book before part one came out and just couldn't put it down. It never talked down to the reader, and I think Denis really captured that beautifully. The movies don't spoon feed exposition it weaves it into the story naturally, like the training holograms in the first one. I loved the detail of the desert mouse, knowing the nod to Muad'Did. I think dune pt 1 & 2 will go down as sci-fi classics. I hope Hollywood learns the right lessons here: let go and trust the process.
One of the best things about Dune part 1 and part 2, is that it wasn't trying to push an agenda. The viewers could lose themselves in the film and the story etc without being reminded that they are watching a film and the world is broken.
*Dune: Part Two, as I expected from Denis Villeneuve, was absolutely phenomenal. It’s a movie that reminds me of why I love cinema because it’s all about taking risks, being ambitious and being creative unlike most modern Hollywood where it’s all about making cash-grabs, reboots and unnecessary remakes of classics. It just goes to show the sad and depressing state of modern cinema.*
@@SWOTHDRA yes the book has a special chapter on how to adapt it being a movie, which artistic choices do, in which ways, how to re tell such a complex story and so on.. come on dude, don't be bittered reducing all of this work in "duh... filming a book ..." , or at least please bring some arguments
Villeneuve is a true auteur director in every sense of the term, except for one... He's not an insufferable tyrant to his cast and crew. He proves that auteurs can produce game-changing cinema, without being abusive dictators. That's another lesson Hollywood needs to learn from this master.
3:34 Another commendable aspect of D.V.'s craft is that he is so prepared through the script and storyboard that he doesn't bother shooting much coverage. He knows what shots he want and thus doesn't waste resources on unnecessary shots.
Havin seen it on IMAX, this is an incredible experience. Im not the biggest fan of Dune, but i am on Denis and his work. Hes pittch perfect for it, a match in heaven.
I LOVE that you immediately mentioned Lord of the Rings and Pirates of the Carribean, because those are the exact same comparisons I drew in my head watching both Dune and then Dune 2. It feels like it's been some time since we had something new release on that scale in the fantasy/sci-fi genre. I'm so glad we got it here with a rather faithful adaptation of a literary classic, it gives me hope going forward that someday, we may be given equally impressive adaptations of other classic tales. I for one could go for a faithful movie adaptation of The Wheel of Time or any number of Brandon Sandersons works.
I’ve always struggled for actors names but in the past I was always able to recognise and tell you the name of any movie within just a few seconds. It was my special talent, and used to amuse my dad no end - he’d be watching something, I’d walk in and identify it. But these days I genuinely struggle to do that, the reliance on green screens to do so much makes them all often look very similar. I’m a huge Dune fan so I’m really glad to see these break that trend and do well
I fell in love with Villeneuve with Arrival which i saw three times in cinema. I had soooo much hope that we'd see more quality sci fi movies after this. He did not disappoint, I am now a devoted fan.
Stunning movie. Some of my favorite scenes was paul gaining the respect and admirations from the fremens. Then watching him become a cold and calculated politician when he’s talking to the emperor and stating he will marry his daughter.
IMHO to answer question in 0:55 - because most budgeted film are not based on a script/plot with substance. This film was based in a very influential 900 book series. It has complexity, depth, breadth, it is intriguing, it uses plenty of imagination, it plays and explores with various human issues, etc.
I had such high expectations for it because part 1 became one of my favorite sci fi films of all time. Initially I didn’t think it was as good as part 1 but the longer I’ve sat with it the more I realize how much I enjoyed it. It’s one of those films you could watch for another 2 hours and still be fully engaged.
Just saw it a second time last night. It's not as good as the first (part 1 was really frugal with its dialogue), but it's absolutely leagues better than anything I've seen in the theaters since part 1.
Watched dune 2 in imax just 2 hours ago and can confidently say this movie was spectacular. A movie hasn’t blown me away like this one in years maybe decades. I can’t even think of another movie that made me feel so transported. Unbelievable work from everyone involved in this, the visuals, sound design, music, acting, pacing, characters, sense of scale all amazing.
Dune is my Game of Thrones, my Star Wars and my Lord of the rings! It’s a much needed break from Marvel and DC for me. It’s refreshing and feels like a psychedelic dream, thrusted into the far possible future.
Dune is my Lord of the Rings, and Lord of the Rings. In my opinion the movie trilogies that they spawned are the best adaptations of epics ever. It's so evident how much they respect and understand the source material.
Dune Part Two is my favorite sci-fi movie of all time. It has amazing action, characters, score, performances, sound design and some of the best cinematography I’ve ever seen in a movie.
@@simongravel7407possibly not. But I would ask you to consider re-watching ANY star wars film soon after taking in this masterpiece of filmmaking. I did, and the stark contrast in just all filmmaking facets, really, in hindsight, shows how blessed we are to have Villeneuve at the helm and forefront of the sci-fi film genre this era.
@@simongravel7407yk what is cool fun fact tbh it might be really known but I didn’t until like a few days😭💀but Star Wars is inspired by the dune books.
I think you hit the nail on the head with how Dune is a new vision. It's a movie that looks distinct frame by frame which marks it as something that will last. The fact that it was a huge success and was worth going to the theater just is awesome. I agree with you that it will influence the shows and movies going forward.
I loved Dune Part 2, most thrilled I've felt in a movie theater in a LONG time. The only thing that comes close is Everything Everywhere All At Once, and that mostly about the interpersonal dynamics of one family. I love creative martial arts scenes, but the action in Dune Part 2 was so gripping and tense. And I love that it captured some of my favorite things about the book: the feeling I had while reading it, the themes, the characters. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I already want to see it again!
When I first caught an un-subtitled broadcast of Polytechnique (2009) on Canadian TV many years ago, it really struck me as powerful, original and especially humane filmmaking. Who could have guessed what Denis Villeneuve would go on to achieve.
Total fan, this was a great B-day treat for me. I loved the first one, and I've loved all the previous movies, books, and TV series. The second one was fantastic. At the end of the first one, it was a total cliff hanger and I immediately did a web search to see if part 2 was in the works. I hope they continue to create new movies and content in this fantasy world. I'd enjoy seeing some more sequels, maybe some TV series, and some video games.
That baffles me that someone could be "hit or miss Villeneuve" with Prisoners, Sicario, Arrival, 2049, and Dune 1 and 2, he has been on an unrivaled modern hot streak. No other director right now has made that many EXCELLENT films in a row, not even Nolan
Overwhelming? I literally couldn’t remember a single scene. It was so mind blowing… I walked out of that theater with my brain, completely erased, only knowing that I must return immediately to the 70 mm IMAX Chinese theater ASAP… During my second viewing, I was absolutely blown away, once again.
I'd like to add how much I love Schwarzenegger's Conan and how well its aged because of its huge amount of practical work. The few shoddy CGI scenes could be fixed in a week for a remaster.
Something VERY unique to Dune 1 & 2 is how many extreme telephoto/compression shots there are, building a sense of scale of how large the world is. Villeneuve and Cinematographer Greig Fraser littered both movies with so many of these money shots and nobody talks about it. Not many films are shot this way. Examples - 0:10, 2:04, 3:45, 5:14, 6:36, 7:26, 8:15, 8:50
Fraser getting snubbed for what he did on The Batman was absurd and sorta felt like punishment for being a superhero movie. It absolutely looked better than Roger Deakins Empire of Light, and arguably better than Tar and Elvis. Whether it could've won vs Bardo and Western Front is a dice roll, imo. Here's hoping Villeneuve and Fraser continue to work together, but even if they don't, Fraser deserves a lot of recognition going forward.
We've been Dune fans in my family since 1995. My 10 year old brother was obsessed, he's read every book even the ones written by Fanks son. My brother made his own school project movie...Dune in 5 minutes or less that year. His version was genius and made me get interested in it and then more sci-fi. These films stayed true to the source material and was amazing.
I liked it, it felt more like an ant man movie aka the original ant man and then kang, but yes marvels worse, she hulk worse, loki alright, secret invasion meh
When I watched Dune Part 1 with my fiancée, I loved it. But she very much did not like the film, since she never was into sci-fi and found the film’s pacing and dialogue not suited to her tastes. But in the end, she still recognized the impressiveness of the quality of the film-from the score to the cinematography or CGI. For her (and I’m sure some other audience members), this movie may not have resonated with them story-wise, but it can still leave a unique impression and stylistic style they can recognize and appreciate, like you described.
This was extremely well said. Put what I was feeling into words. It’s not wanting no cgi it’s wanting a vision. The dialog scenes in Dune 2 contain almost zero over the shoulder shot a shot b coverage. It’s all planned.
Watching it in IMAX was really something else. The movie is beautiful, sure, but holy shit it sounds incredible. The soundtrack and sound effects are out of this world.
Villeneuve started as true indie; he said in an interview he never expected to jump over to AAA film making and was happy doing small movies forever. He just got a lucky break and never lost his integrity, always staying as true as possible to his vision. That strength is what has garnered a loyal and strong fanbase around Science Fiction. Unlike other directors that dabble in everything, and then do a science fiction film here and there (like Spielberg), Villeneuve's strength IS science fiction and it's why he's so exciting and his voice is so strong. I think if George Miller hands Villeneuve the torch to make the next Mad Max movie, after the latest Furiosa film coming out, I think Villeneuve's touch would elevate Mad Max to even higher standards, which is crazy because Fury Road set that bar so high already, but I do think only Villeneuve would be able to do it justice in the same way he did for Blade Runner 2049.
I agree with you, but Villeneuve probably has a love-hate relationship with the desert after shooting Dune, and he still has to shoot Sicario 3 which is also in the desert. Idk if he would love to make a Mad Max movie at this point 😂
I agree with the video and I also like how you talked about Shogun because when me and my friends were talking about dude I also introduced the Shogun part into the conversation.
Fuck, man. I loved it so much. I can’t wait to see it again. Probably Denis’s best work, on par with 2049 for me, which is already super high praise considering that 2049 is my favorite sci-fi movie ever.
Hearing you talk about instant recognition of Dennis Villeneuve style and young directors not getting a chance made me remember about J.J. Abrams. They're the same age and relatively young directors compared to 20+ years older Spielberg and Cameron. How contrasting directions their careers took.
I've watched Denis Villeneuve's films since "Incendies". It was already clear then how talented he was. His photography is so clean, it's almost immaculate. Every shot is framed so purposefully. I'm delighted to see he's been given the reigns on such high-stakes films and has suceeded masterfully. I came out of Dune the same way I came out after Mad Max : Fury Road or PotC : At World's End ; in a dream-like state, hovering above the ground from the experience. This is what you call du grand cinéma !
I like that in general the action scenes are economical and not overlong but still breathtaking. I think that that helped save some budget. And also let the other scenes-including those about religion. romance, politics, philosophy, and culture-breathe…
Just saw this movie and it was incredible. The best movie I have seen in a long time. I love the pacing. Everything feels natural and nothing is forced on you. They did a fantastic job of letting characters and scenes express themselves. Nothing was rushed, it felt real. It’s an instant favorite for me, I think this is a huge wake up call for Hollywood.
Dune 2 might just be my favorite movie of all time now. The sound design, score, cinematography, editing, pacing, performances, chemistey between actors, symbolism, themes, messaging, parallelism, and narrative changes from book was all incredible. The changes to Chani especially improves clairty. It's no coincidence Denis has Chani be the first voice you hear in Part 1 and her face be the last thing you see in Part 2. Another aspect I weirdly like about the movie is the textures. 😅 But it's sad how many people misinterpret the movie. Depressing how more people go to see mediocre Marvel and Star Wars content than Dune. I honestly don't understand how Shakespeare survived.
As a massive fan of the Dune novels and lore, I was blown away at how beautiful this movie was. I am very aware of how complicated the plot really is, but this movie brings it to life without losing too much.
I hardly watch movies, or series, or anything on the visual medium anymore. Dune 2 rekindled my love of film. Dune primed it and this just sent it home. Finally, a movie that encourages me to really think. That didn't give all the answers and let me ponder it. That I just needed to process on the way home and that I haven't stopped thinking about since.
Took the words right out of my mouth! I hardly watch new movies or TV shows anymore. Anytime I do it's always a massive disappointment. I'm so glad that wasn't the case with Dune 1 and 2
@@Overcroxin an interview Denis mentioned he wanted to give some time to Timothee and Zendaya to "age up" a bit, so I think that may be likely if he follows through with Rama
@@duvetboa Will they ? I mean, they are already a full decade older than the characters, are they really going to change significantly at this point ? Chalamet was perfect to play teenager Paul, but I have a really difficult time imagining him as adult Paul at any point in his life.
There were so many innovative moments (like filming the Arena sequence in Infrared) that completely complemented the scene and made it feel otherworldly and completely fresh - George Romero in Mad Max Fury Road had a similar blending of practical and visual FX that just worked to make a visceral holistic vision and reinforce a mood. I hope we can get more bold and creative projects like you suggest.
I loved how they handled Fayde Rautha, and Paul's sister in particular. Both were exceedingly well done , and I think the departures or expansions from the book were a plus there.
What's really interesting about Villeneuve's Dune films Is that they feel less like a typical action blockbuster (not like there's anything inherently wrong with that) and feel More in line with the old school épics of David Lean or Cesar B. Demille, you know Long films with spectacular visuals and locations but with a fundamentaly very operatic sort of storytelling at it's core
Dune part 2 suffered from the same problem as the first. At the 2:hour mark I felt like act 1 was finished and the film was about to begin in earnest and then they wrapped it up and left me wishing for another 4 hours. I hope the box office take encourages them to make more films a like this and I would love to see a few more Dune books represented in this style.
@@lennynero635 what exactly is it what makes the pacing screenplay suffer? I extremely like that he's not going the route of every movie, placing a cut everywhere because it's easier to fill in some time this way or correct failed shots. He's imo also the only director, that shots movies not with the actors in it's center but for the scenery.
@@CptBlaueWolke Some of my pet peeves (felt the same about BR 2049 to some extent): - it is never really shown how Paul‘s knowledge helps the Fremen in battling the Harkonnens - Paul is very reluctant to become the leader of the Fremen but then suddenly drinks the worm juice in the next scene - suddenly the Harkonnens know where the Fremen‘s hideout is attack it (I know that Feyd has taken over command but there is no scene establish gaining this new knowledge because he is more effective than Rabban) - the movie spends a long time explaining the importance of the water basin for the Fremen but when it is destroyed the sorrow and grief of the Fremen is not shown at all - Paul becoming an experienced Fremen warrior is basically only hinted at - it is never established why they use the nukes in the way the use them (I think they did in the 1984 version) - the build-up to the final battle is great but then everything goes by so fast and the army of the Emperor poses no real threat Still a good movie, but it could have been even better. Defintely need to rewatch in the future.
@@lennynero635 I wish there was more to the climactic battles, but on the other hand the a lot of the sardaukar did get nuked, squashed by a mountain then eaten by sandworms. For my part I really missed a lot of the ecological talk from the first film, and the garden in the palace among other things. But I have similar gripes with LOTR and they're still some of my favourites anyway.
The last time I felt like I felt at screening for Dune 2 was when I was a kid and seeing Lord of the Rings from the big screen for the first time. It was that moment when you realized in the movies that you were truly seeing something bigger than anything you ever expected, something that would shape a generation of moviegoers and influence scores of young film makers. It was truly cinema.
What did you think of Dune Part 2?
To try everything Brilliant has to offer for free for a full 30 days, visit brilliant.org/midnight or click on the link in the description. You’ll also get 20% off an annual premium subscription.
I hope we get more Dune films.
I hope we got more medium movies
aestHetic
I found Zendaya wildly over rated, sulky and annoying.
Loved it! I think some book pureists will be annoyed with the ending, but imo Denis did a good job for his version of Dune and the message he wanted to send. I was a bit disappointed with the ending because I love the book ending with Chani and Jessica, but I get that it didn't fit with his vision of the story.
I'll admit while watching Dune i started wondering how expensive this movie was compared to recent super hero movies. I was blown away by the fact that it has a smaller budget.
Facts. How much outright larceny was involved with the other so called blockbusters
The Creator cost 80 million
@@evgenkhersonets880i never ended up watching that, was it a good movie?
@@MoManiaTV not speaking for them but The Creator has amazing visuals, especially given the budget, but I just couldn't get into it and a lot of that was due to how the movie was edited. The editing caused the pacing of the movie to feel fast though it was definitely a film that wanted to have those intimate character moments.
@@MoManiaTV for the budget it had compared to superhero films the visuals were on a different level
Finding a director that loves the source material I think is the key to future. Not just getting big names
A director with talent really really helps though
a director with talent and equal love of the source material is the true key.
That's not always the case. Tony Gilroy isn't familiar with Star Wars and he made the best thing on the franchise since Empire Strikes Back. Sometimes you need someone that isn't totally familiar that can bring new blood. I'm kind of an iconoclast tho, so that's really a personal opinion. I thing we just need good writers and give them time.
The bigger problem is the studios themselves, they're run by executives who don't know anything about movies, never mind fiction and they carelessly hire the wrong people, or they hire the right people and handicap them with non-stop interference. The Dark Tower (2017) is a good example, the director was apparently a *massive* Stephen King fan, and a capable director, he still gave us one of the worst King adaptations ever, because the studio had no faith in the source material.
That was ALWAYS the key.
Almost every flop in the last ten years is because they DON'T stay true to the source material or DON'T care about it... they want to tell their own story, that speaks to them.
When I first saw Dune 1, it is soooo magnetic that I went to read the books immediately.
For Dune2, it is the only film so far in my life that I want to watch it a second time directly.
Nice. I saw SW Ep 7 three or four times. Nothing beats an epic movie multiple times in theater.
Hopefully Dune 3 is strong and doesn’t stain the trilogy like SW did
me too, I'm 50 years old and Dune 2 is the ONLY film I've ever paid to see at the theatre twice.
@@nickh4676Star Wars bad
@@OrangeJungle gotta disagree. ST and BOBF has been bad, but other projects have ranged from average to damn good
@@nickh4676 nah ik im kidding
Dune has some of the best CGI I've ever seen. None of it feels cartoony or triggers that part of the brain where you go, "Well that's obviously fake." Absolutely loved both parts!
2 of my favorite movies, but did we all forget the original vision Paul has of himself in the gold armor rolling around and fighting? That was really bad and I'm really curious why. Wouldn't put it past general pandemic rushes
Lol yeah that scene *really* stands out in a pair of movies where almost all the effects are amazing. Especially after all the action set pieces in part 2 looked *so* much better.
@1999studios When you see his face in that scene, it definitely could've looked better. Overall though, that's a small drop a in large pond of VFX that are absolutely beautiful, better than most in my opinion, and worth appreciating.
@@1999studiosI remember this scene, but I didn't pay attention to it in the cinema. It seemed to me that the quality has improved since the release of the trailer. It's hard to remember now
They did the worms justice. They looked fantastic and believable.
There's almost an old Hollywood epic feel to Dune. The way it only has dialogue when it needs but has so much non verbal spectacle to build the world and give it that scale and lived in feeling is amazing.
This is particularly significant considering that Dune is based on Lawrence of Arabia.
@lapineee Dune 2 will make you convert to Islam fr
@@AweSean-wv3xo Villeneuve actually de-Islamized Dune by a lot. You had the concept of Jihad along with Arabic names for Fremen in the books and whatnot. Some of the things in the book, if adapted to the screen would've probably caused all of social media to seethe and review bomb the movie to oblivion.
It felt like an actual movie
Yep, very Ben Hur-esque
Honestly, his films remind me SO MUCH of cinema from the 60s and 70s. Naturally, they didn't have ornithopters and CG sandworms, but the attention to visual detail feels like a callback to the masters of the past. And you're right, a lot of "blockbuster" filmmakers just don't shoot for that these days.
Everyone says it’s a cgi v practical debate but more of a pre-production v post production. Too many current blockbusters have been rushed to get shot so little sets, costumes and script edits have been made and it’s all pushed to post prediction for the vfx to carry everything
Indeed. I still find it insane that the time travel suits in Avengers:Endgame were CGI! Not because the filmmakers thought it would look better, but simply because they hadn’t finalized the suit design when they were filming. And then they had the nerve to remove a month of work the VFX teams desperately needed
Look at a film like the Creator. That film cost $80 million and looks way better than some films with 3 times the budget. I was sad to hear that it flopped because I think it's incredible. Why don't more films use the same methods as Dune and the Creator when it comes to VFX since it's cheaper and looks better.
@@Coolcoolcooldude Ye, saw that movie twice in the theatres. Absolutely stunning piece of filmmaking. Kinda wish the story was better, but I would happily take 100 movies like The Creator as opposed to the majority of modern day blockbusters
This is also telling when movies like BALLERINA finished filming over a year ago but not releasing until June 2025, MISSION IMPOSSIBLE 7 & 8 began shooting just before Covid-19 hit, CPT. AMERICA 4 finished filming last year but still years away from coming out, and I’m sure others…
@@Coolcoolcooldude The Creator has significant stumbles in the pacing, no way around it... but saying it lacked vision or that it didn't try to make an "atmosphere" to its world and didn't succeded in some parts is downright a lie.
Dude, this video came out the exact second I left the cinema.
Are you the Lisan Al Gaib?
It is as the prophecy is written!
As it's written!
He shall know your ways!
As is written
*surprised pikachu face* as written..
I absolutely cannot wait until this comes out on 4K and I can watch both parts together, as one film. It’s gonna be insane.
The first one is pace so much slower than part 2. That switch up at the intermission is gunna be crazy
@@poindextertunes I honestly expected it to hit trilogy status since they were only about 35-40% of the way through the abridged version of the book with part 1. Instead we got 3 immersive hours that felt like it had only been one.
It's gonna be the new LOTR marathon.
I watched it in VR back to back and HOOOBOY it's an experience!!!
th-cam.com/video/EQkq3PVbe9I/w-d-xo.html
I actually felt like a kid again watching this film. Just felt like something spectacular, immersive and exciting, which I haven’t seen in a very long time
exactly the feeling I had. Never felt this way anymore since I watched Lord of The rings..
and it didn’t even feel too long in spite of being 3 hours!
Same thing here, I’m reminded of the time my family and I went to watch Revenge of the Sith in the theater, I’m not complaining about bad characters doing bad choices, not complaining about poor CGI uses, not complaining about the blatant agenda that’s been shoved into the media without even a single concern whether the story will be good or not.
I am simply mesmerized by everything that was happening, visually, sonically, and emotionally. It’s been years since I last stepped in a theater, DUNE revived that sense of happiness that the cinema used to fill me with, just pure, simple, joy.
I said the same to my wife after we left the theatre. It felt like a spectacle, as a good film should.
EXACTLY. I legit thought, this is why cinemas exist. For movies like this and for actors like Timothy, legendary next generation actor in the making
What I said elsewhere is that it's the first movie I'd seen in a while where it felt like the CGI effects were in service of an artistic vision, rather than like shiny keys being jangled trying to entertain a baby. Just being able to sit in a movie theater and feel a movie wash over you rather than feel your mind picking restlessly at the creators' choices feels incredibly luxurious. I enjoyed it a lot.
Great take on this. 🍻
Same with Lord of the Rings. Expert use of CGI.
Long awaited sci-fi for adults. CGI effects was one thing but also lack of those cringy dialogues was very refreshing.
@karolstopinski8350 exactly, it feels like the first truly Adult scifi I've watched in a very long time.
Dune and Dune Part Two completely blew me away. It has the scale, love and care that EVERY blockbuster movie should have, and having a director that knows how to approach the project is key to that. I am so thrilled by these movies and can only hope they mean a change in the way Hollywood makes these big budget movies
Honestly am already exited for the final part this movie is most certainly one of my favorites especially when it comes to scenery acting and the story
Dune Part One was honestly mediocre imo. Sure, pretty to look at but I fell asleep halfway through. That said, Dune Part Two completely changed my mind. It was nothing short of a spectacle seeing this film in IMAX and furthermore, the story in the second film had me hooked way more than the first.
@@el_chapolman5023 You fell asleep to Dune? How? The first film was fantastic. If you can't handle a slower pace, and need the action of the second film, I'm not sure what you're really even getting out of the franchise. Both are great, neither are mediocre. Watch it again.
@@HEARTS-OF-SPACEOh, definitely! The second film reignited my interest in the series, and I’m certainly going to rewatch the first film. And probably appreciate it more this time around. Cheers👍
@@el_chapolman5023 That's good to hear! Enjoy!
I actually shed tears while watching Dune part 2. My girlfriend asked if I was okay and was worried at why I was crying. I had a hard time explaining to her that it wasn't the plot or the events of the movie... But it was that someone took a book/story that is very important to me and treated it with enthusiasm and respect. So many marvel movies, Star wars movies, hell even just remakes in general have let me down with the lack of detail and passion, and to see this treatment gave me hope for the future of movies.
I felt engaged, enchanted, enveloped while watching this movie and I haven't felt that in a while.
This comment got a few tears out of me
I haven’t even read the books (only listened to some of an audiobook of the first book)
but Villeneuve’s Dune is peak fiction.
I watched it with a couple friends the first time, but the second time watched it alone, and I felt this. This is the type of passion that Frank Herbert's work deserved.
Thank you! It’s nice to read a critique that does not jump to the problem is “woke”
I stayed as credit rolled out and swallowed tears too, so happy DV nailed it, thinking this is the right movies/message for our times and how many who never read the saga will be surprised at the following movies. I am so glad there will be another generation discovering this masterpieces and digesting its warnings.
When the screen began to fade to black, I nearly cried out because, even after 3 hours, I wanted it to continue.
same! just watched it last night I am really considering watching it again haha
same, if i hadn't had an headache i would have liked to keep watching it (im also gonna rewatch it as soon as it' available)
@@martina764 my ears were ringing for hours afterwards
@@martina764 funny you are saying that because I also had a headache the next day when I woke up, but I think it was because of the 02 mojitos and the beer I had the night before lol
the movie isn’t even 3 hours long
I saw this movie, and I have kept having flashbacks from certain scenes. I think that you made me understand why my subconscious is still trying to tell me what a beautiful experience it was and I should cherish it more
My favorite part about Dune is that it feels like a cinematic VISION... It doesn't feel formulaic or as if it's trying to meet a certain studio's quota.
Everyone who worked on Dune seems to understand what makes the project so special, and as I was sitting in the theater, I could FEEL that.
I know so many people in the audience are hungry for stories and projects that feel like they were handled with love and care. And Dune IS that film.
People complain about being sick of remakes, reboots, and sequels....until one comes along that they love. The problem hasn't been hollywood's insistence on being mostly "unoriginal", it's studio execs cranking out product for the sake of it without genuine passion for the work.
Like you said, these two films clearly came from a place of genuine adoration for the material. When a talented filmmaker genuinely loves and understands the material, and the studio execs give them reign to create, then you're far more bound to get a work of art.
What a great comment sheesh
Amen🙌
The atmosphere masterful woven to the story is second to none.
And by Vision, you have to include decades of story boarding and writing, like with Furry Road
As someone who regularly invites friends over for "watch all 3 extended editions of LotR in a day, everyone bring snacks". I'm excited in a few months to add a Dune part 1&2 watch straight through w/ friends.
wish i could have friends like you..
Had the whole gang over to watch part 1 with pizzas and wings then drove 15 minutes to the theatre to watch part 2 in IMAX. Best decision ever
@@romanfedorowycz4090sounds like 100/10 day💯🔥😮💨
Just wait til he makes Messiah
SAME
Several scenes in this movie left me watching in open-mouthed amazement, it's such a well-crafted movie. And the music and sound design is absolutely brilliant along with it.
Dune 1&2 are the perfect examples of what happens when a great director with a clear vision is given creative control over a project they are truly passionate about/understand. Villeneuve has quite literally waited his whole life to make these movies, as he drew out an entire storyboard for Dune when he was a kid!
I appreciate that the movie has diversity yet you don't feel hit over the head with it. It seems natural not forced.
Hopefully we get a similar magical fruit for the Red Rising Netflix series, Ender's Game Remake, and The Dark Tower Remake 🙏
Absolutely!!! He’s taken the approach that peter Jackson did with LOTR and kept as close to the source material as possible while also doing some cinema creative choices that made sense for the big screen and specific pacing
@@Tsar-Czar that's also what happens when you add woke content appropriately and don't slap it together for the sake of reaching woke people like disney does.
and then he ignores basic premises of Dune to make an action movie, seems he sold out his vision for $
The arena scene with Feynman-Rautha was so intense in the theater it had my heart rattling. The score was amazing and Oscar worthy again.
> Feynman-Rautha
Surely you're murdering, Mr. Feynman-Rautha!
wtf does feynman gotta do wit it
@@honkhonk8009get of the crack and reread their comment..
What he says at the 2:00 mark is a really interesting point. Lord of the Rings and Pirates looked so impressive for their time, we were all wondering how CGI would change the way movies were made. Fast-forward 20 years, and it barely changed - if anything it got worse, with most big budget movies looking 10x worse than Return of the King. CGI simply stopped being impressive since it flatlined and even degraded since 2003.
Dune is the first movie since that actually looks like a big step forward for CGI. It pushes the technology further creatively without looking fake or overdone. It's probably the best I've seen.
Another one here trying to be an expert on visual effects. That's what you call "CGI"
@@holocron_vfx I’m a viewer of movies, and I can tell you that most CGI looks like absolute dogshit. All I need is eyes and a brain to confirm that, no knowledge of computer graphics required. At no point did I claim to be an expert in CGI.
@mrsnulch I am a VFX artist who works in the movies you're viewing and I can tell you that can't confirm shit. Guys like you are the cutest. You watch a movienand make a list "hey look this is CG, that is CG, and over there more CG. Digital technology sucks". Meanwhile your movies have tons and tons more VFX shots that you don't even see because they're well made. So let me know better what's dog shit and what not. I know. You don't.
@@holocron_vfx I don't mean to disrespect your line of work, CGI is crucial to modern filmmaking but when it's used too heavily it breaks my immersion. Basically all Marvel movies of the past 10 years like Thor and Black Panther for example look like computer games to me, same with the Hobbit films. The Disney live action remakes are technically incredible, but look uncanny when human actors interact with the CGI animals. Same with Planet of the Apes.
LOTR and Dune are more convincing, possibly because they use computer graphics strategically with real footage instead of rendering entire scenes in CGI.
You can say what you want on a technical level as a VFX artist, but viewers can tell when everything they are seeing is VFX, even when it's really well done.
@@mr.snulch Yeah you don't disrespect our work, yet we are the scapegoat of the industry, being blamed every time a movie sucks because studio executives want to do more with less, especially after the catastrophic strikes last year which forced multiple studios to close down.
You want to talk about movies looking like video games? Go watch the video essay "why attack of the clones looks like a video game". Then you can click over to Hugo Guerra's "what's with all the CGI hate". And this is my last reply to you. Just by using the acronym 'CGI' you prove what an ignorant clown you are.
For me, Dune part 2 was more about Paul’s fall than his rise. Yes, he frees the Fremen, becomes the emperor, ends the Harkonnen bloodline, all of that. And yet, he goes on to kill billions, all because the Fremen believe in their savior. The movie is one big gom jabbar test. Become their Lisan al Gaib, or watch as Feyd annihilates them. Paul has gotten to the point where he _cannot_ take his hand out of the box, even if the Harkonnen threat has been silenced, and the pain will build forever as the Fremen lead the holy war across the universe.
And yes, it was such an awesome story to witness.
🥱
@@SWOTHDRAare you gurney trying to put up his tent? For you seem to lack any understanding of the ways of the desert.
Amazing comment
The fall really hasn’t even started yet. He didn’t even lose a child like he did in the original book. But Chani’s discontent is certainly strong foreshadowing
Harkonnen line has not ended, because he is both Harkonnen and Atreides.
Havent been to the theaters since avengers endgame.
Dune 2 was worth every penny
Endgame was garbage but you missed plenty of films in between.
@miz4535 endgame was great, and I didn't miss anything, I caught everything just on streaming. Dune 2 however that was worth seeing in theaters
@@miz4535yea agreed, everything everywhere all at once, whilst in a very different realm of sci-fi (arguably it's a philosophical mindfuck, for want of a better word) left me with an equally satisfied and persistent feeling of 'wow' upon leaving the theatre.
Same. The combination of how lacking Endgame was, COVID and the rapidly aggressive death of good cinema did that to me as well.
Godzilla Minus One was worth watching in theaters
I watched this movie in 4D and the wind that was blown in our faces had a slight hint of cinnamon and chili, kinda how id expect spice to smell, this was an amazing touch
There is something quite ironic in *Dune* going from a movie that's infamous because the studios interfered with the director (a high profile director like David Lynch nonetheless) to a movie that shows you what happens when the studios don't interfere and let the director do his thing
You'd think Hollywood would've learned 20 years ago with Lord of the Rings and its mountain of Oscars, but noooooo...
While that is true, Lynch was recorded as confirming that he'd actually never read the book. So I do believe that even without studio intervention in his version, Villeneue would have been the better movie. If only because of his respect and passion for the source.
Sorry, I need serotonin @@SomeTH-camTraveler
@@SomeTH-camTraveler My guess is that is hit or miss. By always following a formula, they can guarantee a movie that will pay itself, being safer. However, that doesn't generate good films - which is not their goal.
When I left the theater, I was hit hard by the "This is what cinema should be". It feels authentic and fleshed out in a way that the mass produced marvel films just can't hit nowadays
I listened to an interview with Villaneuve after Dune II came out. I can't quote him, but he said that he wished that he didn't have to use any dialog and could just tell story with visuals. The care with which he composes his shots is exacting and it shows.
There's something really poetic about the success of the Dune movies, the story of which subverts traditional hero narratives by showing the inevitable dangers of following a charismatic hero, and the decline of comicbook movies.
I'll always like my capeshit, and so I'll still check out CBMs, (eventually probably) but there's something really symbolic happening here lol.
I really liked the ending. Previous versions have gone for the heroic triumph feel-good ending and skipped the "...and then he launched an interstellar religious war that killed billions" which is not only something that Paul tried to prevent throughout the majority of the film, even to the point of basically contemplating suicide so he doesn't take that step, but forms a critical part of the future of that universe.
What a vague comment lmfao. What is the poetry/symbolism here? Be specific
The rise of Dune coincides with the fall of Star Wars too, interestingly enough
@@vs6584Star Wars fell in 1983, more than anything
@@hermanubis96
? Hmm? The context and specifics are in the comment itself. Frank Herbert, through Dune, deconstructs and comments on charismatic figures and the hero narrative.
I just thought it's a funny turn of events that the decline of Cape flicks, which rely on traditional hero stories, coincided with a successful adaptation of Dune.
This film felt like it had an actual soul and was made by people who truly loved it and wanted it to be the best that it could possibly be.
Most blockbuster movies feel like they came off the corporate assembly line with people who are just here for their paycheck.
We need more of the former and no more of the latter.
Nailed it!
Agreed. But a lot of that assembly line you speak of is the studios' fault more than the filmmakers. All studios see is dollar signs so they hire whoever they can to crank out product...and the writers and filmmakers jump on board just because they don't want to pass up the [potentially once-in-a-lifetime] opportunity, only to then be boxed in by whatever parameters the execs force them to stick to.
I love A24 but I can see them turning into a similar machine in the next 5-10yrs if they're not careful.
Too many people have watched too many cookie-cutter Blockbuster so the studios did not need to produce different movies. I am so glad that in 2023 most DC/Marvel films flopped because now we might have a chance to see different kind of blockbusters again.
Dune 2 was my favourite cinema experience since the first matrix. I was blown away from start to finish.
Captain Midnight: you should give directors the latitude to fulfill their creative vision without constantly interfering.
Studio Executives: “The power to destroy a thing is the ultimate control over it.”
Dune and Part 2 are the first movies that I can recall actually reccomending people specifically to see in theatres. Most movies I feel are just as good on your home tv, but these Dune films feel like blockbusters and I feel actually warrant the trip to a theatre to see them on the big screen. It's just an entirely different feeling from the movies that we've been getting and I'm totally here for, give us more Dune tier movies.
@@happydogg312a home stereo is going to sound better than the theater? How? These films are mixed specifically for the theater, it’s the ideal environment.
@@happydogg312 lol it happens. I will say that I'm a big proponent of the home theater. I think sound is the most overlooked part of the home viewing experience, but I don't think it can ever be better than going to the movies.
@@happydogg312 Impossible to get that bass at your home. Like no fucking way unless you are a sound nerd and dropped thousands on it
@@happydogg312 that's awesome that you have such a sick setup. It's unfortunate your local theaters don't have their systems in order, but I don't know if it's fair to compare your setup to something that's clearly not working correctly. The other thing that we can't recreate at home is the sheer scale of the theater...especially IMAX. But hey, I totally get it. If I was in your situation it'd be hard to get me to leave too lol.
My good friend, as an everyday french speaker from Quebec (from where Denis is from) let me save you from the avalanche of comments you are sure to receive: it is Ville-neuVE. The VE at the end is important to the pronounciation. Much love your review and analysis was execeptional and very entertaining.
I was looking for someone saying this. For those not familiar with the the pronunciation, try pronouncing it to rhyme with how a Londoner would say "nerve" or "serve" (i.e. without pronouncing the letter R). Not a perfect equivalent but it gets you most of the way there.
Its so important to actors to have practical sets to work with too. Despite all the advances weve made you'll always get a more genuine performance when the actors can really feel like they are IN the world (and it lifts some burdens from the VFX team too, they can complement and enhance without being expected to hold up the entire film setting on their dwindling time budgets). Every film school teaches not to rely on fixing things in post, proper planning and communication is essential for a production to flow. I'm very much hoping dune's success will help prove this going forward.
Practical sets are better but take time to plan and build
Watching Timothee talk about just walking through a desert, and how it made him feel better as an actor. Is lovely.
Sometimes when I see how Marvel movies are made, where it's literally an entire green room and actors just dressed in mo cal suites, and each "shot" is just them jumping off something or having half a conversation, I feel sorry for them.
How are they supposed to act if they have no idea where they are or what they're meant to be doing? They don't even know what the scene will look like, and don't even have the costumes to even get in character
Thor in multiple clips here looked like he's filmed by a webcam in a business call with a cool background but without green screen.
As someone who read the books, he absolutely made changes. But what he added made sense and kept the plot moving forward. What he took away was nowhere near egregious.
Excellent adaptation.
What i love about dune is just the whole universe and the themes that play in it. Villeneuve changes some of the story but he keeps the themes the same and he really works inside of Herberts world. I remember people scolding Paul for not wearing the mouthpiece of his stillsuit all the time in the desert, but i ubderstand why there is little to no mouthpieces used in the movie, and its okay because the other themes are still there
Yeah.
I don't like comparing Lynch's attempt to Danny's attempt much, but one difference was very clear to me.
When I was watching Lynch's version, I often found myself asking, "Why was it changed and how does it benefit the idea?"
When I was watching Dune pt. 2, I found myself repeatedly nodding. "Yes, it was changed, but I can totally see why."
@@andrewmelnikov292 Agree.
I was totally bamboozled by the use of projectile weapons (guns) which were made redundant with the introduction of shield technology after the Butlerian wars. The whole point of blades is explained in the book "the slow blade penetrates the shield".
(That whole preceding par qualifies me as a geek virgin level 398 btw)
But, it made for amazing cinema and elevated the battle scenes to epic!
Also, the still-suits are just ridiculously inadequate... but hey, awesome cinema.
@@andrewmelnikov292Watched david lynch's dune after the first Dune, felt like a comedy show to me.
@@glenmale1748Tbf it makes sense for the guns. Fremen don't use shields, and I think if I remember right projectiles were used against big and moving targets. Hence also the laser usage.
The look of the stillsuites have a simple reason: you can't act awesome on the screen if you have something in your mouth and are not identifiable at all.
What really blew me away was the use of scale and the color palette. Truly an epic production.
As a VFX artist I am really glad you mentioned that it's better if the VFX "enhances" the vision instead of "substitutes" for it.
When there are many versions on a single shot or asset ( in bigger shows that over measured in 100s ) it often feels like the client doesn't know what he/she wants.
Also what's often the case is that the director is not trusted enough by the studio as they are often "just" hired to direct something but then the studio would like to see things differently
This is the biggest issue with working with clients in any creative media.
I don't go to the movie theatre often (once every few years), and I haven't had the pull to go more than once for any movie ever. But I'll be going back to watch Dune 2 again. Something about it is primal. The way it is filmed, the colors used, the sound of the score, the threads of stories incorporated, the pace, it all draws you in for a complete experience. The most enjoyable art I have seen on film that I can remember.
I just wanted to congratulate you on an amazing video that I am happy someone made.
Dune Part 2 was a breath of fresh air in a dying industry. There hasn’t been a film that felt this complete and awe inspiring in years.
If people are still watching Star Wars after watching Dune 1 & 2, then they are not fans of the medium and what it should be.
Great video. Agreed with absolutely all of it. Let’s hope for Dune 3
I can’t remember which youtuber said this recently, but I agree with them that the solution isn’t better high budget movies, the solution is smaller lower budget films and more of them. From a financial standpoint it actually spreads out the risk by reducing that financial impact and investment of a single failure. On the creative side, more small films will allow more writers and directors to develop their art and style in relative creative freedom, allowing studios to better evaluate who is worth greater investment in future projects.
That youtuber must be pretty uninformed about the current state of the movie industry then. Smaller films are much less profitable than big budget films, because their advertising budget has to be suitably low to their actual budget, and that means it draws much less of an audience to the theater than a big budget movie. With the average consumer only going to the movies once or twice a year, and the profit from streaming after the movie is out of theater being a pittance, more small budget movies would just doom them all to fail. The industry would need to rework to make movies profitable once they leave cinema in order to make any of that possible.
you are probably talking about Critical Drinker, he mentioned it in a video.
I hope so. I'm hyped for Dune Messiah. Hope they get around to the other books, too.
*SPOILERS* GIVE US THE MEGAWORM
I'm more worried. Those books are even more "unfilmable."
@@pablolacalle6098 *GOD EMPEROR*
I don't know if the modern audience is ready for the later books on film format... especially with Children of Dune.
@@DoctorJammer Messiah can be done, it'll have to be a political thriller with Paul's position as Emperor at stake. Plans within plans to subdue him. I can see it being done in a 2-3 hour film (preferably closer to 3).
People won't be ready to have their perception of Paul and his Ji'had crushed. Learning that they are supporting a villain with the heaviest of crowns. I hope they keep some of the more philosophical lines regarding prescience from Paul. I also hope Scytale, Irulan, Erick and Gaius's conversation in the opening chapter is kept in as the intro to Dune Messiah, it just sets the whole tone for the book.
Well done. Excellent essay on a film that i absolutely enjoyed. So well done! Bravo to all those involved in the production of this masterpiece
Hollywood needs auteurs like Villeneuve more than ever
Thank god for drugs
Im not seeing the greatness. I thought dune. 1 was ok, but 2 was worse. And I want no more Zendaya at all
The guy barely makes original films, he can't be called an auteur
@@ousamahachoumi838 Sounds like you don't know what an auteur filmmaker is. Both by thinking that Villeneuve isn't one and by your choice of argument.
@@ceasarsaran8573 How so?
I’ve heard a business perspective that supports your point: We should be rewarding spectacular failures more than mediocre successes. In other words, it is better to shoot for the stars, which will invariably result in some complete misfires, because it has the potential for greatness. Whereas mediocre, safe successes are less likely to fail but also have a much lower ceiling
The key difference is that the spectacular failures have a palpable soul; it feels like someone actually cared about the project and hoped it would succeed (rather than trying to forcibly _make_ it succeed). They gave it their all then handed it over to the audience with their fingers crossed.
But these corporate films that are focus-grouped towards supposedly guaranteed success have all the soul systematically drained from them by sackings, rewrites, reshoots, retools that sometimes continue to change things until days before a film's release, because instead of passionate spontaneity the suits want the leeway to alter the film however and whenever they want in response to new "market research" - or as is more often the case, something like one of the non-creative executive's kids telling them that this one thing was cool, so now they HAVE to include it in order to stay "fresh" and "relatable".
If they get lucky and cast a charismatic, likeable actor - someone like Will Smith, Jason Bateman, Denzel Washington, Ryan Reynolds - they can sometimes make it work, but when they're stuck with the likes of Dakota Johnson, Brie Larson, John David Washington or Jared Leto, then the film's total lack of inspiration becomes too blatant to tolerate for 90% of the audience.
Dr midnight thank you so much for giving some extra dune content that isn’t spastic or insane like the other TH-camrs. Thank you bud.
Was a huge fan and am a huge fan of your content
The entire time while I was watching this movie which is *almost* a masterpiece was, “how did any studio let this be made.”, and I think that itself is telling of Hollywood today.
While I can recognize a lot of the malfeasance that corporate entities contribute to current cinema, what exactly about dune made it seem unmakeable in this corporate environment? I'm ignorant of the details/politics of the industry and I really loved both movies despite knowing nothing about the books, so like what do these execs hate so much? Truly curious bc a lot of people say this but I guess I don't get it bc I just like it?
Your points reminded me of Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness. It was so clear when there was a scene that was allowed to be guided by Sam Raimi's vision rather than Marvel's. And those ended up being my favorite parts of the movie.
No offence but how can you even mention that movie in the same sentence as this. They’re not even in the same universe of competence or writing. That movie was probably the worst marvel movie iv watched, but then again I haven’t watched Thor 4 or quite a few of the worse rated ones.
@NakulKrishna I wasn't comparing it to Dune? Or even putting it in the same league? I was only referring to the mention in the video that studios have pretty much quelled a lot of artistic expression from directors and they don't allow them to portray their own aesthetics or visions. It squashes any sort of uniqueness or originality to a project. Doctor Strange MoM was by no means a masterpiece. I was just saying that the best scenes in the movie were ones clearly allowed to carry Sam Raimi's vision. That's it.
@@NakulKrishna Aw. I liked it.
@@NakulKrishna Multiverse was pretty good. It just wasn't about those silly fans theories the "fans" wanted.
@@ShadowSonic2Nah there’s plenty of reasons to dislike it.
Dennis Villeneuve is probably my favorite director. He's all about cinematic and a mature audience. He doesn't explain everthing but he shows everything you just have to look close enough. But just the compositons he creates are incredible and truly what cinema should be.
I saw it first screening on opening day and haven't stopped thinking about it. I'm going back to see it again in an hour. This feels like when Lord of the Rings was out.
I love Dune, I started reading the book before part one came out and just couldn't put it down. It never talked down to the reader, and I think Denis really captured that beautifully. The movies don't spoon feed exposition it weaves it into the story naturally, like the training holograms in the first one. I loved the detail of the desert mouse, knowing the nod to Muad'Did. I think dune pt 1 & 2 will go down as sci-fi classics. I hope Hollywood learns the right lessons here: let go and trust the process.
One of the best things about Dune part 1 and part 2, is that it wasn't trying to push an agenda. The viewers could lose themselves in the film and the story etc without being reminded that they are watching a film and the world is broken.
*Dune: Part Two, as I expected from Denis Villeneuve, was absolutely phenomenal. It’s a movie that reminds me of why I love cinema because it’s all about taking risks, being ambitious and being creative unlike most modern Hollywood where it’s all about making cash-grabs, reboots and unnecessary remakes of classics. It just goes to show the sad and depressing state of modern cinema.*
It’s always been the case
Just people refuse to take off the rose tinted glasses
Villeneuve said that cinema is creating pictures. As simple as that, the cinematography and composition in Dune is superb.
He filmed a book....
@@SWOTHDRA yes the book has a special chapter on how to adapt it being a movie, which artistic choices do, in which ways, how to re tell such a complex story and so on.. come on dude, don't be bittered reducing all of this work in "duh... filming a book ..." , or at least please bring some arguments
@@supermario10033 the story is overhyped , so is the movie. Its not complex at all
Villeneuve is a true auteur director in every sense of the term, except for one...
He's not an insufferable tyrant to his cast and crew.
He proves that auteurs can produce game-changing cinema, without being abusive dictators.
That's another lesson Hollywood needs to learn from this master.
His work on Blade Runner 2049 absolutely sold me on him.
Great point. In all his promotional material he seems like just a nice dude
@@muffinman3052 Yeah, and the cast talk up how much they enjoyed making the film. That doesn't happen without a director who likes his staff.
This. I remember I watched a panel with the entire cast of Prisoners, considering how dark the material was, they all were really, really happy.
Yeah, after doing some research on Kubrick, it's gonna be hard to watch and adore his movies.
3:34 Another commendable aspect of D.V.'s craft is that he is so prepared through the script and storyboard that he doesn't bother shooting much coverage. He knows what shots he want and thus doesn't waste resources on unnecessary shots.
Havin seen it on IMAX, this is an incredible experience. Im not the biggest fan of Dune, but i am on Denis and his work. Hes pittch perfect for it, a match in heaven.
I saw it in Dolby Cinema. It looked great!
I watched Arrival afterward, for the first time. I'm def a fan of V and I'll be checking out his other works.
@@jadelygem Sicario, Incendies and Blade Runner 2049 are some of his other works worth checking out. All great films IMO.
I LOVE that you immediately mentioned Lord of the Rings and Pirates of the Carribean, because those are the exact same comparisons I drew in my head watching both Dune and then Dune 2. It feels like it's been some time since we had something new release on that scale in the fantasy/sci-fi genre. I'm so glad we got it here with a rather faithful adaptation of a literary classic, it gives me hope going forward that someday, we may be given equally impressive adaptations of other classic tales. I for one could go for a faithful movie adaptation of The Wheel of Time or any number of Brandon Sandersons works.
I’ve always struggled for actors names but in the past I was always able to recognise and tell you the name of any movie within just a few seconds. It was my special talent, and used to amuse my dad no end - he’d be watching something, I’d walk in and identify it. But these days I genuinely struggle to do that, the reliance on green screens to do so much makes them all often look very similar.
I’m a huge Dune fan so I’m really glad to see these break that trend and do well
I fell in love with Villeneuve with Arrival which i saw three times in cinema. I had soooo much hope that we'd see more quality sci fi movies after this. He did not disappoint, I am now a devoted fan.
Arrival was bonkers. An hour after finishing the film I was still shocked. Truly underrated.
Stunning movie. Some of my favorite scenes was paul gaining the respect and admirations from the fremens. Then watching him become a cold and calculated politician when he’s talking to the emperor and stating he will marry his daughter.
If Chani remained in love and devoted to Paul even after that, the ending could have been FAR more impactful. Overall, beautiful looking movie. 9.5/10
IMHO to answer question in 0:55 - because most budgeted film are not based on a script/plot with substance. This film was based in a very influential 900 book series. It has complexity, depth, breadth, it is intriguing, it uses plenty of imagination, it plays and explores with various human issues, etc.
I had such high expectations for it because part 1 became one of my favorite sci fi films of all time. Initially I didn’t think it was as good as part 1 but the longer I’ve sat with it the more I realize how much I enjoyed it. It’s one of those films you could watch for another 2 hours and still be fully engaged.
Just saw it a second time last night. It's not as good as the first (part 1 was really frugal with its dialogue), but it's absolutely leagues better than anything I've seen in the theaters since part 1.
Watched dune 2 in imax just 2 hours ago and can confidently say this movie was spectacular. A movie hasn’t blown me away like this one in years maybe decades. I can’t even think of another movie that made me feel so transported. Unbelievable work from everyone involved in this, the visuals, sound design, music, acting, pacing, characters, sense of scale all amazing.
The sponsor transition was very brilliant
Dune is my Game of Thrones, my Star Wars and my Lord of the rings! It’s a much needed break from Marvel and DC for me. It’s refreshing and feels like a psychedelic dream, thrusted into the far possible future.
Dune is my Lord of the Rings, and Lord of the Rings. In my opinion the movie trilogies that they spawned are the best adaptations of epics ever. It's so evident how much they respect and understand the source material.
Dune Part Two is my favorite sci-fi movie of all time. It has amazing action, characters, score, performances, sound design and some of the best cinematography I’ve ever seen in a movie.
Star Wars is Sci Fi like Dr. Pepper is a doctor
@@Zoroasterisk Would I be the sci-fi fan I am today without the infatuation I developed for Star Wars when I was a kid? Probably not.
@@simongravel7407possibly not. But I would ask you to consider re-watching ANY star wars film soon after taking in this masterpiece of filmmaking. I did, and the stark contrast in just all filmmaking facets, really, in hindsight, shows how blessed we are to have Villeneuve at the helm and forefront of the sci-fi film genre this era.
@@simongravel7407yk what is cool fun fact tbh it might be really known but I didn’t until like a few days😭💀but Star Wars is inspired by the dune books.
I’d like a gene Wolfe movie next 😊
I think you hit the nail on the head with how Dune is a new vision. It's a movie that looks distinct frame by frame which marks it as something that will last. The fact that it was a huge success and was worth going to the theater just is awesome. I agree with you that it will influence the shows and movies going forward.
I loved Dune Part 2, most thrilled I've felt in a movie theater in a LONG time. The only thing that comes close is Everything Everywhere All At Once, and that mostly about the interpersonal dynamics of one family. I love creative martial arts scenes, but the action in Dune Part 2 was so gripping and tense.
And I love that it captured some of my favorite things about the book: the feeling I had while reading it, the themes, the characters. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I already want to see it again!
When I first caught an un-subtitled broadcast of Polytechnique (2009) on Canadian TV many years ago, it really struck me as powerful, original and especially humane filmmaking. Who could have guessed what Denis Villeneuve would go on to achieve.
Total fan, this was a great B-day treat for me. I loved the first one, and I've loved all the previous movies, books, and TV series. The second one was fantastic. At the end of the first one, it was a total cliff hanger and I immediately did a web search to see if part 2 was in the works. I hope they continue to create new movies and content in this fantasy world. I'd enjoy seeing some more sequels, maybe some TV series, and some video games.
Having read the book shortly after watching Part One, Dune Part 2 was very much among my most anticipated upcoming movies, and it more than delivered.
That baffles me that someone could be "hit or miss Villeneuve" with Prisoners, Sicario, Arrival, 2049, and Dune 1 and 2, he has been on an unrivaled modern hot streak. No other director right now has made that many EXCELLENT films in a row, not even Nolan
Hit or Miss in terms of how profitable his movies are, not the quality of the movies themselves.
@@ShadowSonic2 Captain Midnight definitely made it seem like he was talking about quality
Overwhelming? I literally couldn’t remember a single scene. It was so mind blowing… I walked out of that theater with my brain, completely erased, only knowing that I must return immediately to the 70 mm IMAX Chinese theater ASAP… During my second viewing, I was absolutely blown away, once again.
I'd like to add how much I love Schwarzenegger's Conan and how well its aged because of its huge amount of practical work. The few shoddy CGI scenes could be fixed in a week for a remaster.
I just rewatched that last week! Funny you should mention it, and agreed.
CGI scenes in Conan the Barbarian (1982)?
@@lennynero635 maybe not CGI, let's call them SFX I'm thinking of the spirits trying to take Conan whilst Valaria holds him down & fights them off.
Something VERY unique to Dune 1 & 2 is how many extreme telephoto/compression shots there are, building a sense of scale of how large the world is. Villeneuve and Cinematographer Greig Fraser littered both movies with so many of these money shots and nobody talks about it. Not many films are shot this way. Examples - 0:10, 2:04, 3:45, 5:14, 6:36, 7:26, 8:15, 8:50
Fraser getting snubbed for what he did on The Batman was absurd and sorta felt like punishment for being a superhero movie. It absolutely looked better than Roger Deakins Empire of Light, and arguably better than Tar and Elvis. Whether it could've won vs Bardo and Western Front is a dice roll, imo. Here's hoping Villeneuve and Fraser continue to work together, but even if they don't, Fraser deserves a lot of recognition going forward.
We've been Dune fans in my family since 1995. My 10 year old brother was obsessed, he's read every book even the ones written by Fanks son. My brother made his own school project movie...Dune in 5 minutes or less that year. His version was genius and made me get interested in it and then more sci-fi. These films stayed true to the source material and was amazing.
Ant Man 3 will keep being brought up for the next decade on how half-assed it feels. Cannot wait for Dune: Messiah.
Agreed. Antman 3 feels like the "Hello Dolly" of the MCU (although that might better fit The Marvels).
I liked it, it felt more like an ant man movie aka the original ant man and then kang, but yes marvels worse, she hulk worse, loki alright, secret invasion meh
When I watched Dune Part 1 with my fiancée, I loved it. But she very much did not like the film, since she never was into sci-fi and found the film’s pacing and dialogue not suited to her tastes.
But in the end, she still recognized the impressiveness of the quality of the film-from the score to the cinematography or CGI. For her (and I’m sure some other audience members), this movie may not have resonated with them story-wise, but it can still leave a unique impression and stylistic style they can recognize and appreciate, like you described.
This was extremely well said. Put what I was feeling into words. It’s not wanting no cgi it’s wanting a vision. The dialog scenes in Dune 2 contain almost zero over the shoulder shot a shot b coverage. It’s all planned.
Seeing Dune Part 2 again tomorrow. My buddy missed it opening weekend, so I'm taking him to see it in IMAX. Hope we get part 3 soon D:
Maybe in a few years. Denis says he needs to make something else before coming back to the DUNE universe.
Watching it in IMAX was really something else. The movie is beautiful, sure, but holy shit it sounds incredible. The soundtrack and sound effects are out of this world.
Villeneuve started as true indie; he said in an interview he never expected to jump over to AAA film making and was happy doing small movies forever. He just got a lucky break and never lost his integrity, always staying as true as possible to his vision.
That strength is what has garnered a loyal and strong fanbase around Science Fiction. Unlike other directors that dabble in everything, and then do a science fiction film here and there (like Spielberg), Villeneuve's strength IS science fiction and it's why he's so exciting and his voice is so strong.
I think if George Miller hands Villeneuve the torch to make the next Mad Max movie, after the latest Furiosa film coming out, I think Villeneuve's touch would elevate Mad Max to even higher standards, which is crazy because Fury Road set that bar so high already, but I do think only Villeneuve would be able to do it justice in the same way he did for Blade Runner 2049.
I agree with you, but Villeneuve probably has a love-hate relationship with the desert after shooting Dune, and he still has to shoot Sicario 3 which is also in the desert. Idk if he would love to make a Mad Max movie at this point 😂
I agree with the video and I also like how you talked about Shogun because when me and my friends were talking about dude I also introduced the Shogun part into the conversation.
I watched Alien and Predator this week and I sometimes forget how good practical effects look!
Fuck, man. I loved it so much. I can’t wait to see it again. Probably Denis’s best work, on par with 2049 for me, which is already super high praise considering that 2049 is my favorite sci-fi movie ever.
2049 was outstanding! Loved Arrival too.
Hearing you talk about instant recognition of Dennis Villeneuve style and young directors not getting a chance made me remember about J.J. Abrams. They're the same age and relatively young directors compared to 20+ years older Spielberg and Cameron. How contrasting directions their careers took.
I've watched Denis Villeneuve's films since "Incendies". It was already clear then how talented he was. His photography is so clean, it's almost immaculate. Every shot is framed so purposefully. I'm delighted to see he's been given the reigns on such high-stakes films and has suceeded masterfully.
I came out of Dune the same way I came out after Mad Max : Fury Road or PotC : At World's End ; in a dream-like state, hovering above the ground from the experience. This is what you call du grand cinéma !
just want to say that every big picture film made by him won numerous oscars.
I like that in general the action scenes are economical and not overlong but still breathtaking. I think that that helped save some budget. And also let the other scenes-including those about religion. romance, politics, philosophy, and culture-breathe…
Just saw this movie and it was incredible. The best movie I have seen in a long time. I love the pacing. Everything feels natural and nothing is forced on you. They did a fantastic job of letting characters and scenes express themselves. Nothing was rushed, it felt real. It’s an instant favorite for me, I think this is a huge wake up call for Hollywood.
Dune 2 might just be my favorite movie of all time now. The sound design, score, cinematography, editing, pacing, performances, chemistey between actors, symbolism, themes, messaging, parallelism, and narrative changes from book was all incredible. The changes to Chani especially improves clairty. It's no coincidence Denis has Chani be the first voice you hear in Part 1 and her face be the last thing you see in Part 2.
Another aspect I weirdly like about the movie is the textures. 😅
But it's sad how many people misinterpret the movie. Depressing how more people go to see mediocre Marvel and Star Wars content than Dune. I honestly don't understand how Shakespeare survived.
Great visuals, great acting, sticks close to the source material…great stuff! 😎
As a massive fan of the Dune novels and lore, I was blown away at how beautiful this movie was. I am very aware of how complicated the plot really is, but this movie brings it to life without losing too much.
I hardly watch movies, or series, or anything on the visual medium anymore. Dune 2 rekindled my love of film. Dune primed it and this just sent it home. Finally, a movie that encourages me to really think. That didn't give all the answers and let me ponder it. That I just needed to process on the way home and that I haven't stopped thinking about since.
Took the words right out of my mouth! I hardly watch new movies or TV shows anymore. Anytime I do it's always a massive disappointment. I'm so glad that wasn't the case with Dune 1 and 2
I hope Denis Villeneuve gets to direct RENDEZVOUS WITH RAMA
Because he's perfect
Pretty sure he’s already attached to it
There's a chance it may even come out before Dune 3, since it might be further along, but remains to be seen.
@@Overcroxin an interview Denis mentioned he wanted to give some time to Timothee and Zendaya to "age up" a bit, so I think that may be likely if he follows through with Rama
@@duvetboa he also said he’s going to do 1 or 2 movies before it
@@duvetboa Will they ? I mean, they are already a full decade older than the characters, are they really going to change significantly at this point ? Chalamet was perfect to play teenager Paul, but I have a really difficult time imagining him as adult Paul at any point in his life.
There were so many innovative moments (like filming the Arena sequence in Infrared) that completely complemented the scene and made it feel otherworldly and completely fresh - George Romero in Mad Max Fury Road had a similar blending of practical and visual FX that just worked to make a visceral holistic vision and reinforce a mood. I hope we can get more bold and creative projects like you suggest.
I hadnt been to the cinema to watch any film in probably close to 10 years, ive been to see dune 2 twice and would absolutely go again
Dune could be the next The Lord of the Rings.
100%
I don’t think it’ll ever reach the audience of those movies, but among the book audience it’s already considered space LoTR
Lord of the Dunes
Heresy.
Be done with this bungalar.
I loved how they handled Fayde Rautha, and Paul's sister in particular. Both were exceedingly well done , and I think the departures or expansions from the book were a plus there.
What's really interesting about Villeneuve's Dune films Is that they feel less like a typical action blockbuster (not like there's anything inherently wrong with that) and feel More in line with the old school épics of David Lean or Cesar B. Demille, you know Long films with spectacular visuals and locations but with a fundamentaly very operatic sort of storytelling at it's core
Excellently put
Dune part 2 suffered from the same problem as the first. At the 2:hour mark I felt like act 1 was finished and the film was about to begin in earnest and then they wrapped it up and left me wishing for another 4 hours.
I hope the box office take encourages them to make more films a like this and I would love to see a few more Dune books represented in this style.
Dune 2 definitely suffered from pacing/screenplay problems but everything else so just so good that it is still a great movie going experience.
That's not his fault, it's how the book ends (and dune 1 wouldnt be anywhere near appropriate to the books if it was just one movie).
@@lennynero635 what exactly is it what makes the pacing screenplay suffer? I extremely like that he's not going the route of every movie, placing a cut everywhere because it's easier to fill in some time this way or correct failed shots. He's imo also the only director, that shots movies not with the actors in it's center but for the scenery.
@@CptBlaueWolke
Some of my pet peeves (felt the same about BR 2049 to some extent):
- it is never really shown how Paul‘s knowledge helps the Fremen in battling the Harkonnens
- Paul is very reluctant to become the leader of the Fremen but then suddenly drinks the worm juice in the next scene
- suddenly the Harkonnens know where the Fremen‘s hideout is attack it (I know that Feyd has taken over command but there is no scene establish gaining this new knowledge because he is more effective than Rabban)
- the movie spends a long time explaining the importance of the water basin for the Fremen but when it is destroyed the sorrow and grief of the Fremen is not shown at all
- Paul becoming an experienced Fremen warrior is basically only hinted at
- it is never established why they use the nukes in the way the use them (I think they did in the 1984 version)
- the build-up to the final battle is great but then everything goes by so fast and the army of the Emperor poses no real threat
Still a good movie, but it could have been even better. Defintely need to rewatch in the future.
@@lennynero635 I wish there was more to the climactic battles, but on the other hand the a lot of the sardaukar did get nuked, squashed by a mountain then eaten by sandworms.
For my part I really missed a lot of the ecological talk from the first film, and the garden in the palace among other things. But I have similar gripes with LOTR and they're still some of my favourites anyway.
The last time I felt like I felt at screening for Dune 2 was when I was a kid and seeing Lord of the Rings from the big screen for the first time. It was that moment when you realized in the movies that you were truly seeing something bigger than anything you ever expected, something that would shape a generation of moviegoers and influence scores of young film makers. It was truly cinema.