Mahomes is not playing well, come on. Stop with this idolisation. You lost me here. Clearly you are just parroting the commentators, think for yourself. What Mahomes was and how he is playing this year are chalk and cheese.
I never said he was, I struggle to ding him to much since last season he started slow and turned it on in the playoffs, if this was purely this season he would easily be bottom 10 but after the past few weeks I would sertainly have lamar and maybe even Burrow over him
Your list is a complete joke. I have a feeling you’d rank these QBs the way you’re ranking them no matter what season or week it was. And Russ isn’t declining. In fact, his pocket presence is as sharp as ever. His arm is as accurate as ever, and he can still move outside the pocket as well. Mahomes has more INTs than TDs, yet you rank him at #1? What a joke! Russ was statistically a borderline top 10 last year and didn’t look as sharp as he has over his first two games of this season. Ignore last year’s QBR, as it is an offensive statistic treated as a QB statistic.
I put russ at 16 after 1 game of him this season, thats crazy. Russel Wilson's tape this season has been top 10 I would love to see him finish the season strong so I cam move him up. Curius where you had mahomes last season when he sucked, before he went on to win the superbowl.
@@Touchback-Football: Mahomes was still a top-10 QB last year. I’d say about 9th or 10th. I had Russ at about 11th. Records count too, but Russ was being sabotaged. People have called me crazy for two years but I still believe Russ is elite. Mahomes has game-managed his way to two SBs, so I have to give him credit for knowing when to lean on his supporting players. That’s a high-level skill. Most people treat game-management as a degrading concept but 7 of the top-10 QBs ever were game managers.
Week 7, his first game back two of Pickens' "highlight catches" were drastic under-throws. He had to reach behind the shoulder of a defender for one, another was so terrible it bounced twice off the defender's helmet. This was *after* Russ got into his groove. The next week he almost lost a TD by under-throwing Austen who had to stop in his tracks to catch a pass. Russ isn't being forced to move on these plays. He got most of the benefits of the team having worked out most of its worst o-line kinks before he got into games. Fun fact, of the 3 guys who make most of their YT $ making weekly QB assessment videos, at least 2 have pointed out multiple times that Arthur Smith 1) reduced the amount of snaps Pickens was on & 2) he was dragging his feet on much of the other long routes he *did* get reps on, causing them to suspect that *Smith **_told Fields & Pickens that_** he wasn't to be targeted on those routes.* The instant Russ started, Pickens was back in full time & was never dragging his feet, & was targeted for the 1st time in at least 3 weeks. One never knows what Tomlin is or isn't aware of, but Smith is playing favorites again like he did to the detriment of Bijan Robinson in ATL. If he'd been doing any of this to punish Pickens, he'd have continued no matter who the QB was. He's been undermining Fields.
I understand a lot of the arguments I'm hereing, but not this one. Burrow has been elite his whole career when healthy and in this season has out preformed allen. While I went through Josh's tape I saw so many dropped ints and he also has had multiple games where he can't complete a pass to save his life. You need to understand Burrow is that guy
I totally understand where you are coming from, last season I also dropped mahomes significantly however he backed it up in the playoffs. If he sells his team in the playoffs this season he will plumit significantly.
Trevor should be only one position behind him because Trevor doesn’t have a tush push or the same weapons and playing at a similar level. Hurst could do NOTHING without his weapons against a below average Tampa defense. He exposed himself for how terrible he really is.
If Tom Brady threw as many interception as Mahomes , Belcheic, would've benched him.especially win your got beat Bad at home by the Broncos ROOKIE quarterback..That's right Rookie beat you all day.. your defense saved you.
completely agree the defense is bailing him out. i think come playoff time he will definitely start pulling his weight which is why at the time i posted this he was still one for me which was like 3 weeks ago
Josh Allen is undoubtedly amongst the top two or three in the league. He and Mahomes stand at the pinnacle along with whichever young gun happens to have the hot hand of the moment--right now Goff comes to mind. Lamar Jackson shouldn't even be in the top-ten.
BWAHAHAHAHA! Lamar leads all QB's in passer rating, passing yards, TD's and Total QB Rating. His TD-Int ration is 9:1. Allen is 20 points behind in passer rating with TD:Int of 18:5, and averaging 20 fewer passing yards per game. Mahomes is even further behind Jackson in passer rating, trailing him by 25 points 117.9 vs 93. His TD:Int ratio is twice as bad as Allen's at 18:11. But those two guys are the pinnacle, and Jackson is chopped liver. Your opinion seems to be grossly uninformed.
@ where tf you been lol you not watchin 2024? Wwith the steelers 4-2 totd10 1300+ tot yards? Last i saw pat wasnt even that high at 6 games jus cus dude got benched due to a clause dont mean shit he was literally talked about being one of the best this year at his last game and Dub i might add if you got time get every teams qb stats up to week 6 then check back young man🤨😪
Yeah they doing off past years Bias because Lamar doesn’t fit your corny black dude he looks different and talk different Patrick fits how they want a qb to be square and talk proper
The thing I’m most mad bout was the Goff in top 10 at all he is a worse purdy his team around him and the play calling carry’s if you watch film he actually miss a bunch of reads also stafford is top 3 I personally have him 2
@@Touchback-Football I like your videos a lot bud, they are great dont get me wrong but your rankings here are weak. you missed on a bunch, of good qbs
Hey, I get it! Hurts at 26 definitely riles up some debate, and I respect the passion. Stick around-there’s a lot more breakdowns coming. Who knows, maybe I’ll win you over! If you’re down for more takes, hit that sub and let’s keep the convo going!
Mahomes is 27 for me
lol
My top 5.
1. Goff
2. Allen
3. Jackson
4. Burrow
5. Stroud.
Mahomes isn't even in the top 20. The chiefs are undefeated because of their defense.
Stroud hasn't been good in like the last month
Don’t think mahomes should be a top 5 qb rn tbh
fair but we did this last year
@@Touchback-Footballso this was based on 2023 then and just posted the video late?
Mahomes is not playing well, come on. Stop with this idolisation. You lost me here. Clearly you are just parroting the commentators, think for yourself. What Mahomes was and how he is playing this year are chalk and cheese.
I never said he was, I struggle to ding him to much since last season he started slow and turned it on in the playoffs, if this was purely this season he would easily be bottom 10 but after the past few weeks I would sertainly have lamar and maybe even Burrow over him
Your list is a complete joke. I have a feeling you’d rank these QBs the way you’re ranking them no matter what season or week it was. And Russ isn’t declining. In fact, his pocket presence is as sharp as ever. His arm is as accurate as ever, and he can still move outside the pocket as well.
Mahomes has more INTs than TDs, yet you rank him at #1? What a joke! Russ was statistically a borderline top 10 last year and didn’t look as sharp as he has over his first two games of this season.
Ignore last year’s QBR, as it is an offensive statistic treated as a QB statistic.
I put russ at 16 after 1 game of him this season, thats crazy. Russel Wilson's tape this season has been top 10 I would love to see him finish the season strong so I cam move him up. Curius where you had mahomes last season when he sucked, before he went on to win the superbowl.
@@Touchback-Football: Mahomes was still a top-10 QB last year. I’d say about 9th or 10th. I had Russ at about 11th. Records count too, but Russ was being sabotaged.
People have called me crazy for two years but I still believe Russ is elite. Mahomes has game-managed his way to two SBs, so I have to give him credit for knowing when to lean on his supporting players. That’s a high-level skill. Most people treat game-management as a degrading concept but 7 of the top-10 QBs ever were game managers.
Week 7, his first game back two of Pickens' "highlight catches" were drastic under-throws. He had to reach behind the shoulder of a defender for one, another was so terrible it bounced twice off the defender's helmet. This was *after* Russ got into his groove.
The next week he almost lost a TD by under-throwing Austen who had to stop in his tracks to catch a pass. Russ isn't being forced to move on these plays.
He got most of the benefits of the team having worked out most of its worst o-line kinks before he got into games. Fun fact, of the 3 guys who make most of their YT $ making weekly QB assessment videos, at least 2 have pointed out multiple times that Arthur Smith 1) reduced the amount of snaps Pickens was on & 2) he was dragging his feet on much of the other long routes he *did* get reps on, causing them to suspect that *Smith **_told Fields & Pickens that_** he wasn't to be targeted on those routes.* The instant Russ started, Pickens was back in full time & was never dragging his feet, & was targeted for the 1st time in at least 3 weeks.
One never knows what Tomlin is or isn't aware of, but Smith is playing favorites again like he did to the detriment of Bijan Robinson in ATL. If he'd been doing any of this to punish Pickens, he'd have continued no matter who the QB was. He's been undermining Fields.
Great work on the video my man
thanks bro
You put burrow over allen? Wtf is wrong with you. I want my 17 minutes back.
I understand a lot of the arguments I'm hereing, but not this one. Burrow has been elite his whole career when healthy and in this season has out preformed allen. While I went through Josh's tape I saw so many dropped ints and he also has had multiple games where he can't complete a pass to save his life. You need to understand Burrow is that guy
Mahomes shouldn’t even be top 10.
I totally understand where you are coming from, last season I also dropped mahomes significantly however he backed it up in the playoffs. If he sells his team in the playoffs this season he will plumit significantly.
Do you watch the games lmao Hurts at 26 is wild…..Trevor Lawrence over him is wild
Yeah I'm pretty low on hurts he relies to much on go routes and the tush push. Turn on tlaws tape this season he has looked very solid.
Trevor should be only one position behind him because Trevor doesn’t have a tush push or the same weapons and playing at a similar level. Hurst could do NOTHING without his weapons against a below average Tampa defense. He exposed himself for how terrible he really is.
@@smmsmiley2125 Hurts just wins 🦅🦅🦅
@@Touchback-Football Y’all can have style Hurts just wins🦅🦅🦅….Y’all will be running through coaches fuckin around with TLAW and his pretty tape😂😂😂
Not sure about a sub 90 passer rating in the top 10 like stafford
Watch the film Stafford is elite
My top 5 are #1 lamar Jackson #2 Lamar Jackson #3 Lamar Jackson #4 Lamar Jackson and #5 Lamar Jackson
Fair enough I agree
Almost perfect only one should be higher russell Wilson s/b 11 or 12 and Daniel's s/b behind Russell. Otherwise, nice job !...
This was like 3 weeks ago, russ would surtainly move up if I did this again today
The game against the Strouds aside goff is playing mvp
i dont think he was before the 5 int game tho, he would definitely be top 3 but lamar is playing out of his mind right now
I agree with you not putting any raiders quarterback on here 😭 those mf’s are terrible but RN4L 🏴☠️
good situation for a qb weapons wise if yall can find a rb tho
Mahomes this season stats make him not even close to number 1. Josh allen and Lamar are fighting for best QB this season.
I would probably have lamar and Burrow overr him if ire did it today
this list aged so bad in just 4 weeks😭
Sadly
If Tom Brady threw as many interception as Mahomes , Belcheic, would've benched him.especially win your got beat Bad at home by the Broncos ROOKIE quarterback..That's right Rookie beat you all day.. your defense saved you.
completely agree the defense is bailing him out. i think come playoff time he will definitely start pulling his weight which is why at the time i posted this he was still one for me which was like 3 weeks ago
more picks than touchdowns and gets number 1 LOL
Where did you have him last season before he went on a tear in the playoffs
Josh Allen is undoubtedly amongst the top two or three in the league. He and Mahomes stand at the pinnacle along with whichever young gun happens to have the hot hand of the moment--right now Goff comes to mind. Lamar Jackson shouldn't even be in the top-ten.
I mean I did have allen at 4 but you are just wrong on lamar, hands down playing the best football right now
BWAHAHAHAHA!
Lamar leads all QB's in passer rating, passing yards, TD's and Total QB Rating. His TD-Int ration is 9:1. Allen is 20 points behind in passer rating with TD:Int of 18:5, and averaging 20 fewer passing yards per game. Mahomes is even further behind Jackson in passer rating, trailing him by 25 points 117.9 vs 93. His TD:Int ratio is twice as bad as Allen's at 18:11. But those two guys are the pinnacle, and Jackson is chopped liver. Your opinion seems to be grossly uninformed.
geno is at least top 20 he leads the league in passing yards
stats arent everything, he leads the league in drop backs and sucks early on and normally digs them in a hole
Flip 1 and 2 give you a A
Yeah at this point I agree, lamar has balled out since this and mahomes hasn't gotten any better
Purdy is better than 14
yeah i have him better then 18 of the ones on the list
No Jayden Daniels? Maybe you should google him.
Literally number 9 dude
Lost me at JF 23 and caleb 19?! I felt like It was seeming sus little by little🤨
Caleb would be lowered if I re did this lis/ based on recent weeks but I think fields at 23 is pretty common ranking
@ caleb lower justin before benching was a top 10 qb and lead the league
fields was never top 10 what are you on dude
@ where tf you been lol you not watchin 2024? Wwith the steelers 4-2 totd10 1300+ tot yards? Last i saw pat wasnt even that high at 6 games jus cus dude got benched due to a clause dont mean shit he was literally talked about being one of the best this year at his last game and Dub i might add if you got time get every teams qb stats up to week 6 then check back young man🤨😪
Oh and dont forget he also lead the division til lamar finally caught up for the tie never passed us😴
Nix at 25? You’re a hack my friend.
This is a month old he will definitely be higher in the next one
I saw the comment that you put Mahomes at 1 and now i aint watching this shit
This is a month old 😆 we all expected mahomes to do something by now. If I re did it today he would definitely not be 1
Yeah they doing off past years
Bias because Lamar doesn’t fit your corny black dude he looks different and talk different Patrick fits how they want a qb to be square and talk proper
Mahomes voice pisses me off actually, it's more based on him winning back to back to back superbowls. And lamar is like my 3rd favorite qb.
lololol RACE CARD? Back away from your crack pipe.
Hw tf dak 15?! Oh God your bad at this🫣
I have no idea if you think this is way to high based on how bad he has been this season or to low based on his mvp runner up last season
The thing I’m most mad bout was the Goff in top 10 at all he is a worse purdy his team around him and the play calling carry’s if you watch film he actually miss a bunch of reads also stafford is top 3 I personally have him 2
love the stafford love however goff has been the most accurate passer this season and purdys tape vs the chiefs was awful
this is terrible
How so?
@@Touchback-Football I like your videos a lot bud, they are great dont get me wrong but your rankings here are weak.
you missed on a bunch, of good qbs
Hahaha strout is way over rated hahaha the jets beat them come on now
i cant see into the future bro
@ well then don’t try to predict the future simple as that 😂 blessed day
@@DreamzCee805 he didnt bruh stop being so stupid
Jalen Hurts at 26? Find a day job my dude
Hey, I get it! Hurts at 26 definitely riles up some debate, and I respect the passion. Stick around-there’s a lot more breakdowns coming. Who knows, maybe I’ll win you over! If you’re down for more takes, hit that sub and let’s keep the convo going!
This is horrible
why?