Wayne Rooney's Ruthless Man Utd KEEP or SELL List | REACTION
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- Wayne Rooney would build Manchester United's squad around Bruno Fernandes and the young players, in what would be a completely ruthless approach.
Which players would you argue should be kept and who should go? Leave your lists in the comments because this one should be interesting to hear what everyone thinks.
Watch Rooney and Keane's full comments on Sky Sports here: • Rooney, Keane & Cole o...
👹 Join our Discord server, the home of the UPTV community! ➡️ / discord
⚔️ Become a Member: bit.ly/UPTVMembership
🎤 Listen to the United Peoples Podcast: bit.ly/UnitedPeoplesPodcastLi...
✅ Follow us on TikTok, Instagram & Twitter: linktr.ee/unitedpeoplestv
#manchesterunited #manutd #mufc - กีฬา
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A1XXYbV048k/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Week 1 Day 2 // GEN vs T1 | PRX vs TLN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZkFjjJNwzH0/mqdefault.jpg)
Which players would you argue should be kept and who should go? Leave your lists in the comments because this one should be interesting to hear what everyone thinks.
Watch Rooney and Keane's full comments on Sky Sports here: th-cam.com/video/3lrhqMyApzM/w-d-xo.html
I'd keep Onana, Dalot, Lisandro, Kambwala, Mainoo, Amrabat, Bruno, Garnacho, Amad and Hojlund, and wouldn't be sad if anyone else left.
bruno also
you forgot to mention Shaw....I would keep him, if not as first choice (because of injuries) than at least as a valuable squad player
Martinez has been a complete and utter disaster in the EPL. Has one of the worst records of any Utd CB in the entire history of the club. Souness was right about the guy. He has been found out repeatedly and we are regularly humiliated whenever he starts
@@jhpfdijtuiweruot 😂 if you're going to fish, you need better bait bud
Dalot has been a model pro and probably 2nd 3rd best RB in the league. Guy is criminally underrated
Fr
Answered your own question there. We need best players in the league to win the league, not 2nd or 3rd best. Lol
Dalot need to go
@jhpfdijtuiweruot we never have and never will have the best player in the league in EVERY position...
The best teams and squads aren't assembled that way...
@@VolTheProducer And I never said that we had or that we would have. If Dalot is one of our best players but he is only 3rd best in his position, there is a serious problem in the squad that needs addressing
Rashford is holding United hostage. Get rid of him. We dont need some single "Superstar" who takes on all responsability up front. I've seen more heart from Amad and Garnacho in one game than the whole season from Rashford.
100% bro!!! Rashford is the biggest waste of space!
Garnacho not good enough
@@josiahflame7477 Sorry but if you think Garnacho isnt good enouough, then you are insane. The guy is fast, can dribble and pass the ball. His technique is there he just needs time and he will be a monster for United.
Does it anger anyone else that he earns 16Mil a year from United
@@josiahflame7477Even Stevie Wonder could see his potential! Garnacho is a 19 year old!
How do we even have Dalot on the sell list?
Right? He's probably my POTY. The Chelsea game is really the only bad performance I can think of that he had this season. He's been consistently very good
@@purplebutterfly314he’s been good bro but his consistent switching off at the back post has cost us so many goals bro Bruno’s my POTY mate just my opinion though bruva
So true. He's arguably our POTS this year, the most consistent and he's criminally underrated by fans and pundits alike.
Dalot is a good backup RB but I think other players need to go before him.
1 reason why u think Rashford deserve super amount of money? Why, What did he achieve? incredibly instable performance up & down for 7 seasons plus off pitch issues.
He had a good contract year, played footsy with psg and got his big payday. Now he's retired.
Has a 5 year contract.
@@ieuanhughes-vq7qm you can have 15 year contract it doesn't mean anything if you're trash
@@omranmkv
Chelsea [breathing intensifies].
@@omranmkvI think calling him trash is pretty ridiculous. Might make you feel big.....maybe it just facilitates your need to vent. But its ridiculous. Hes had a crap season and hasn't lived up to his potential.
If we sell Shaw then Rashford should be sold too, Rashford is nothing without luke Shaw at left back
Could sell them as a package deal
PL homegrown rules will prevent that sadly.
Both can go
As much as I want rashford to go, with the injury problems I'd sooner sell shaw and other players who can't stay fit before I started selling big money players like rashford. What use is a player who's always injured
Any left back
If Ineos means business, they should sell Rashford first thing.
Pure profit under FFP.
There's two parts to that
Find a buyer first and get him to agree with it. It’s not as easy as that. The big mistake was giving him that 5 year contract.
In his entire Man Utd career, Rashford has scored a goal every 3 games
Dalot is excellent. He can play left back right back or midfield. Good attitude rarely injured.
Happening brother :) Totally agree build team round Bruno, Kobbie, Garnacho, Hojlund!
Amad tooo
and dalot
Wayne Rooney's picks make sense. Keep Bruno Fernandes-he’s like the glue holding my IKEA furniture together. Mainoo, Hojlund, and Garnacho? They’re the shiny new gadgets with loads of promise.
Onana and Mason Mount? They need more time; after all, Rome wasn’t built in a day. Rashford’s form, though, is as unpredictable as my Wi-Fi signal, maybe it’s time for a reboot. Rooney's strategy of balancing Bruno with emerging talents is spot on!
I'd cash in on the Rash if I were a Manc mate, it's not that he's crap but the relationship between him and the club has turned toxic to the point that neither side is behaving professionally anymore. Get him out while he's worth some cash, someone like PSG will give you 60-70 mil for him which as an academy player will seriously help with FFP, not to mention taking a huge salary out of that too. I'd also kick Sancho and Antony into touch and build around that lad that played against us on your right wing the match before the Toon game, he looks really promising and was your best player. Your board is going to have to eat some big losses before building a new team, we've all been there but it's hard to get the money men to grow a pair and make the hard choices. Until they do your situation will remain as it is, like ours was for a decade until 4 years ago.
@@darthwiiziusSelling Marcus Rashford this summer could be justified for several reasons: his high market value can fund other signings, his inconsistent performance might not suit team needs, he may not align with the manager’s strategy, selling him could create opportunities for others, it could prevent losing him for free if his contract is expiring, and frequent injuries might warrant selling while his value is high.
@@carlboss8105
It might be best for all parties, he gets the chance to rebuild his career and Utd get to move onto their squad rebuild in earnest.
@@carlboss8105these players are not leaving United they’re on big contracts. Players are welling to run down their contracts because they know other teams won’t be dumb to give them that kind of wages. Maguire said “nah mate pay me 11M” 😂 United shot themselves in the foot.
@@Abdi-libaax While it's true that players like Rashford or Harry Maguire might prefer to run down their contracts due to high salaries, the club still holds some leverage. By making it clear that they are not part of the long-term plans and potentially reducing their playing time, the club can create a situation where the players might prefer to leave to continue their careers actively elsewhere. Additionally, clubs interested in their services might offer competitive wages to entice them.
Do you believe keeping players who aren't fully committed to the club's future, potentially disrupting team morale and performance, is beneficial in the long run?
I would take Amrabat on loan again if possible. Hes not really had a chance and he has been a great pairing with Mainoo the last couple of games
You have said what's on my mind. He's not been given a good run of games (in his preferred defensive midfield position) by Ten Hag. Extending his loan deal wouldn't do any harm. United just needs to sign a new first choice defensive midfielder while keeping Amrabat as a squad player (back up).
You do realize that his loan fee for this season was 10m? He’s been poor all season bar the last two games. Is two good games enough to make him a Manchester United player next season? Sometimes it feels like I support a different Manchester United team.
@@joeonuoha135 I just get the feeling that if he gets a run of game in this position he could prove to useful for us, even if it's a bench player. 10 mil is peanuts in football now and I just think we'll regret it if we don't give him a real chance
@@joeonuoha135 My brother, most times at the beginning of the season he's been played out of his position. Whenever he plays in his preferred defensive midfield position he's been quite decent. Ten Hag has not given him a run of games in the team likewise Amad. Amrabat in my personal opinion will be a relatively good squad player while United signs a new first choice defensive midfielder. United can also request for his loan deal to be extended for another year. His lack of games is mostly Ten Hag's fault because he's not rotated Amad and Amrabat enough and this could be one of the many reasons why there's been numerous injury cases this season. This is just my opinion though.
He's supposed to be a free agent this summer so I'd wonder if we'd need to pay any sort of fee to retain him. I'd keep him, especially if we only sign 1 CDM this summer.
Rashford should definitely go!!
Man when I think of what a player Rooney was and I look at what we have now . Enough said.
And the players around him. Rooney was severely underrated for a big chunk of his carreer because he was surrounded by legends. Once they started to get traded off and retire is when people really started to give him his proper dues.
horrendous take on Dalot. one of the best players this season
His final decisions in the final third are garbage. How many good crosses or passes which led to goals he made this season.?
you reckon ? lol
@@sammyboy114 Yes. A goal doesn't change that fact he is a bang average wing back and not up to United level.
Only thing the club missing is the RUTHLESSNESS! 💯
What about Dan Gore
Given his injury out on loan I can see why he was excluded. I think we should loan him out to a Championship side next season and see where he is next summer. Arguably that's what we should have done a year ago too.
Ngl MASON MOUNT needs a chance to prove, his injuries hindered him, give him one more season
Who?
@@playedout148 😃😃😃
It’s idiots like this who have no clue and sink United even further. Mount ain’t nowhere near United quality
It's just ridiculous the financials around him. 50-60 million for a squad player and with Varane, Martial and likely Casemiro leaving this summer he'll be the top earner at the club with 250K a week. For comparison sake, Bruno makes 240K a week, that's absolutely mad.
He’s a coward who is pretending to be injured
Love the brutal honesty by Wayne
I agree with your list but bayindir should prob be kept. Hasnt had any action other than one game. He is a good goalie and can be a a stalwart one at that
I'd keep Dalot and Martinez. Dalot played out of his skin this season
Pretty much agree with who to build the team around, obviously we can only release so many per transfer window, that starts with the obvious big earners who are on the decline/out of contract etc, Verane, Casemiro, Sancho, martial , Erikksen & Rashford if we get a offer of 80million plus…
I’d keep Evans for another season, just as cover and a seasoned pro around these younger players. He’s done a good job for us considering probably no one thought including himself that he would play this much this season.
Good to hear an expert take from the Legendary Birmingham Gaffer
Took them all the way from play offs to relegation 😂
@@SK-ix8jbit’s the players fault
Just because he can't manage doesn't mean he doesn't know a thing or two about football. Name me one United superstar/legend that went on to be a very good manager? I'll wait...
I hope we sell Rashford this summer. I just don't think the return is good enough, nor his assists.
“Consider myself a reasonable united fan” your one of the few on this app that are that’s why we are here haha
Can you maybe do a video describing all the tasks of the new recruits in Management? i. e. Director of football, technicel director etc.
United do not want to under go the transition time, they need to give the coach a chance to build his team
This club is years away. It'll take years just to implement a proper plan for signing and getting rid of players.
there are 3 types of players in this list. 1st type that should not be sold at all. 2nd type that should be sold without any second thought and last but not least, 3rd type that should be sold but circumstances will not allow us to. I don't have to name the players because you guys already know those names.
Pretty lazy of you not to share your lists?
Newcastle fan here, I definitely feel you need a re-model of your squad and especially when watching the games you've had against us, I do agree with your keep/sell list, ManU needs a fresh start with some key players to stay + young players who've got the potential. Hence it makes sense you're trying to get Ashworth from us.
you need consistent players like our Anthony Gordon in your squad that will prove their value for money, players like Rashford and Casimero have been pricy tags with inconsistencies
Where do you get those posters?
Mate I totally agree with you. I just wanted to add that I would also keep players that didn't play due to injuries. I think when they finally adapt to the team playstyle they could give us a lot. I would also keep sancho because we saw what he's capable of during his time at Dortmund...
I'm sure INEOS would of had a plan and asked Ten Hag what it would take in it's simplest form to create the way he had the Ajax team playing because I'm sure that is what they would want.
Have to agree with the 'Keep List' but out of the 'sell list' (which I doubt even half will be gone this summer) I'd keep out of the not updated list of Dalot, Mount, Shaw, Bayindr, and Heaton as Dalot can obviously work in the system while Mount and Shaw can potentially add quality cover and there's no harm in keeping our 2 sub goalkeepers unless they are looking to leave.
Mate Shaw has been injured more than Martial. He needs to go too. If not this summer in the one after that. He's a good player, but availability is key to having a successful season.
@@tomvanvenrooij1811 I do agree and that's why I said he and Mount could provide quality cover as I think if Shaw didn't have as heavy a workload and happy with the sub role then I think it's a no brainer to keep him and he's a good center back as well.
But we certainly need to replace him in the first team and maybe next season can help Harry Amas who has the potential to be top quality.
Basically i agree with Rayne and Sam list. We feel the urgency to do that. But it need more deep thinking about the details, bcoz it's easy to sell/terminate contract or terminate loan deal. The problem is: are we going to get our target players for the specific position?!?
Like we sell 4 CB, are we getting 4 CB? Or sell Case n terminate Amrabat loan then we don't have a decent DM?
I think the management will think this through and i hope next Sam video about this issue will include this problem and other details.
a lot of it also depends on who can we actually get in to replace some of the ones leaving?
Pellestri is a decent player think he should be kept only thing we need is a flare winger one who does trickery, omari forson is good enough he proved it against bayern in pre season if he can make the vayern players afraid at such a young age.
Been bang average in Spain
Might be a bit weird but Rooney kinda reminds me a bit of Jimmy Carr - bare with me - in the sense that I knew him for his 'job' but in recent years he's had the opportunity to talk a bit and I'm kinda liking what I'm hearing.
I agree with the argument thinking 3 years ahead and being realistic but I wouldn't get rid of Lindelof right away, give 1-2 more years (there are many on that lost that need to go first...) as I believe he has potential. Lisandro for sure keep btw
Except for Bruno, Garanacho, Mainoo, Hoilland, Onana, Martinez, & Dalot, I'd get rid the remaining 26 😳
agree with the list of argue to keep, though I would argue for Mount just because he should be hitting his peak years and Premier League proven. in terms of raising the floor (eliminating liabilities) we need 1-2 CBs depending if Licha can stay fit, 1 LB since malacia is so uncertain and Shaw's injury record, 1-2 CMs and a striker to compete with Hojlund. so basically the spine of the team needs major reinforcements. I'd argue keep Rashford but if a big offer comes in that helps fund all these more important positions then I'm selling.
Dalot is young, consitent, plays for the badge, never had any comportemental problem. He is what we need, a soldier who plays for the team not for himself
I'd be keeping Onana, Dalot, Martinez and Mount long-term. Short term keep list for those who can still be improved on etc. would be Shaw, Amrabat, Mctominay, Antony, maybe Malacia at a push. The rest I would be happy to sell, particularly Rashford.
Only like 5 -6 players I would pick and actually build team around who actually play for the badge
I'd argue to keep AWB as well as a squad player... any elite team needs quality in depth and his attributes are unique... necessary for certain games where we face a ruthlessly dangerous left winger ... like what he did to stifle Saint-Maximin in the FA Cup final when he'd been tearing Dalot apart or what he did to Sterling, etc... different weapon
The Diego Dalot vs wanbissaka won't be even relevant if wanbissaka didn't have an English passport. Dalot is easily our player of the season by a mile.
I'd say Onana, Dalot, Martinez, Mainoo, Bruno, Hojlund, Garnacho and Amad have to stay. Mount should get another year, I'd keep Amrabat for the right price, as a squad player and I'd give Jonny Evans and Heaton another year each. The rest can be sold for the right price
We have to keep the best 11 of this current squad till next summer. We're not selling and buying 40+ players this Summer.
I would keep:
Onana
Dalot
Maguire (Would've been Varane)
Martinez
Shaw
Amrabat
Mainoo
Fernandes
Diallo
Garnacho
Hojlund
*Mount as a wildcard.
The rest can go permanently or on loan.
I would move Andre Onana, Mason Mount, Lisandro Martinez, and Diogo Dalot to players that we should keep the rest that I haven't added or weren't already on the keep list can go.
were can I find that youth drawing behind you?
Agree with you!! In addition to that I'll Keep one or two seasons for Bayandir(Bench player), McTominay (Bench player), Maguire(Bench player), Shaw (Not first option) and Rashford. Mount and Antony I don't think we are gonna find a proper buyer this summer we should keep and hope they improve. Sorry to see pellistri go, but I think Amad won the spot.
Maguire and mcshite will fetch good fees been here for long enough we need a full clear out
Players to buy - Goalkeepers Diogo Costa, Marco Carnesecchi, Aaron Ramsdale
Defenders - Tobido, Jarrad Branthwaite, Jeremie Frimpong, lnacio, Dumfries
Midfielders - Amadou Onana, Hjulmand, Xavi Simons
Forwards - Olisie, Watkins, Pedro Goncalves, Sesko, Gyokeres
Onana? 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I know is a dream list Man Utd will be lucky to have at least 5 players from there.
Khephren Thuram and Manu Kone for midfield. Saying branthwaith, says enough btw.
there are lot of ucl club players from your list
its hard to hire them unless utd spend crazy amount of money in transfer fee and salary offer
utd have to be smart in the upcoming transfer window
get rid of the problematic and useless players
sign quality but rather cheap / free players
focus to fixing your medical, stadium issue etc
utd has to try as hard as they could to secure ucl spot next season
Love the channel man
Great stuff, but you need players back who can win you the EPL and the players that you can trust to reach that level will go to other clubs. Leaving you deopndant on great scouting, young talents and lucky guesses, or maybe someone with a desire to play for the badge or trainer. You will have to undo the damage slow. Gradual mprovement will bring more options. Right now, Liverpool, Arsenal and City are to far ahead.
I strongly agree with WRoony about this , if united don’t go Europe next season it will be difficult to sing high quality players, but we can build the team from young players we have in the academy they’ve shown a good promise , so sure sell everyone els
We should opt for brexit so we can focus on rebuilding, the league, domestic cups and youyh
So let's find the high quality players before they are recognised as such. Like JR said.....let's find the next Mbappe etc
Keep
Gk : Onana , Heaton
Def : Martinez , Maguire , Kambwala, Shaw , Malacia , Dalot , You have Alvaro Fernandez on loan at Benfica so for lb next season if either of malacia or shaw is injured you can try out Fernandez there plus Dalot can play at lb so it wont be much of an issue.
Midfield : Bruno , Scott , Mainoo , Mount . We certainly need a new cdm fit and firing a young prospect or maybe in his prime depending on the market who is available .Depth for Mainoo and others as well we can look at the free market for sure to increase the squad depth .
Attack : Hojlund , Garnacho , Amad , Rashford , Sancho/Antony . Some people may have doubts over Rashford but he is still an important member of the team I would give him one last chance to prove his worth but a good offer for him can be accepted . We need a backup no 9 a bit different from Hojlund though just to add versatility in attack . Now my opinion for keeping Sancho is that Rashford and Garnacho can compete for the LW spot and Amad and Sancho for RW , given we need to spend for players in midfield and defence I think i would make sense to keep Sancho/ Antony for one more season but a suitable offer can still be taken for either of the two.
I might agree to some of your suggestions but not for the defense line. We need to change those defenses line if not we are still going to remain mid club next season
Shaw needs to be first player out of the door sick of his injuries
@@Mosshk i think if we will still require atleast 2 transfer windows to clear out the deadwood . Some of Eth signings have been poor so it will take some time to build a full functioning squad
I'd say Sancho can be the first to piss off. He clearly doesn't want to be here else he would have apologized back when he had the chance.
@@tomvanvenrooij1811 Among the forwards most likely to leave is Sancho and Pellestri. Martial has been confirmed so these 3 are gonna go
Rooney and Rio started this player power thing with Moyes. Lets not forget😢
i would like to see Onana with an actual stable defence. i feel some of his mistakes have been from panic where he doesnt feel confident in the guys infront of him which is understandable he has faced so many shots he should not be facing simple as.
Mount i want to see more off next season to actually decide if hes cut out long term he is still on younger side. Martinez i hope his injury issues this season are behind him and if so then he is another i keep otherwise i would look to offload him say in 2025 if hes still being injured alot and i think thats why Rooney has them on his "sell" list. its because based on this season a few of those have been out injured too much.
I was going bonkers when i seen diogo dalot and lisandro martinez on the rooyne's sell list. Both are veryvery good players that fit in manchesters new project.
onana have been underrated this season, people judge him on his mistakes and not the games were he 1 man saved unitet
Tried to be realistic due to financial restrictions and if ETH wants to promote youth:
Onana - Keep
Bayindir - Keep
Heaton - Gone
Mee/ Vitek - Bench warm for 1st team because ETH refuses to play anyone else even in cup games
Dalot - Keep
AWB - Sell summer 25/26
Maguire - Sell summer 25/26
Lindelof - Sell in the summer
Martinez - Keep
Evans - 1yr extension as cover for 24/25
Varane - Gone
Kambwala - Keep/ possibly sell 25/26
Shaw - Sell in the summer
Malacia - Sell summer 25/26 (give him a season to return to full fitness and recoup as much of his value as possible)
Williams - Sell
Fernandez - Likely being sold to Benfica, but keep for 24/25 season if possible
Amass - Give more opportunities in the 1st team for 24/25 season
Amrabat - Another season long- loan as cover if recruitment is bad in the summer
Eriksen - Sell
Van De Beek - Sell
Casemiro - Sell
Hannibal - Sell
Mount - Sell but unlikely to go after a year so sell in 25/26
Mainoo - Keep
Fernandes - Keep
Mctominay - Sell
Gore - 1st team opportunities 24/25
Forson - More 1st team opportunities 24/25
Amad - Keep
Pellestri - 1st team opportunities 24/25 / sell 25/26 if doesn’t make the cut
Antony - Sell
Sancho - Sell
Rashford - Sell (if large offer comes along)
Greenwood - Sell
Garnacho - Keep
Hojlund - Keep
Wheatley - 1st team opportunities 24/25
Hugill - 1st team opportunities 24/25
Lacey - train with 1st team/ cup cameos 24/25
Biancheri - train with 1st team/ cup cameos 24/25
Of course we cannot get rid of all the players, but I don't think we should build team around Bruno too. We should keep players those who don't want to play all the game :). like Tominy and Evan, reason is we need to keep someone willing sit on bench and don't complain.
Starting 11 keep: Hojlund, Garnacho, Amad, Bruno, Mount (needs to play at least another season even if we end up selling), Mainoo, Dalot, Malacia, Martinez, Evans (until we buy replacement), Bayindr - sell everyone else absolutely
You are reasonable fan mate, great content!
He’s going to be 30, been at the club 4 years…(some of the worst)…and we should build around him. Wise owl.
he’s only missed one game in his utd carrer…..‘prob our best player…. and we need mature players …
Great video Sam
You can't build a team around Bruno. You can have Bruno in the side but his age means any final phase to a rebuild will see him well into his 30s and past his prime. By all means keep him and build around him but be damned sure he has an understudy that can step up once he can't no more.
I would add Dalot, Onana, Martinez, Wan Bissaka, Maguire, McTominay and Hannibal to the keep list. Realistically, we are not getting rid of 75% of the squad in one window, and somehow I get the feeling that we won't be offloading Maguire just yet.
He's talking not just about this summer but long term, wan bissaka, mc tominay, Hannibal and Maguire all are not good enough.
Agree with your list 100% wouldn't add any others too it,
Agree with you on the keeping list but still i would not keep Mason Mount in the list because come next season it will be more difficult for him and i think he will be injured again come next season so you need to sell him in this window
It's very clear that Utd is gonna become a transition team instead of a position team and I think Onana can do the job. Would've rather Utd have never signed him BUT he's here now and there's no point in signing another expensive keeper.
I would keep McTom as a squad player (if he doesn't mind). I always love players that play for the badge. That character is so rare these days.
How many important goals did Scott McTominay score for us as a DMF?! True Natural Captain.
Also one more chance for mount, malacia, kwambala n martinez...
Think Hannibal needs another chance but agree with the rest of the list. A lot of players there that need to go lift that floor as well as the ceiling.
Why sell Altay Bayindr ?. We haven't seen much of him to say if he's good or not & Who would you buy who is willing to be a backup keeper ??
I agree with you...ans the list... don't hesitate to sale Rashford. He should be sold. The culture after Sir Alex must be routed out completely
It feels incredible that the man United ex-player pundits like Neville and now Rooney are finally backing the manager and calling out the players. They have been the problem for years and it doesn't matter when people say, "yeah but 8/11 of these players didn't play for Mourinho and Ole". Its not about that! Its about the fact that some of these players were in the dressing room, downing tools and being in the club for so long have made them an influential player who can convince the new players to down tools too!
It's called a mob mentality! Thankfully we have players like Mainoo, Amrabat and Bruno who aren't that sort and always try. But you can't say the same about Casemiro or Rashford.
Agree with your keep list and would add Shaw. He's a machine when fit. Medical staff need to learn how to keep him that way. Nobody else really impresses as United quality.
The biggest problem for united is that there is more money in football than there are good players, i.e. clubs with deep pockets are all fishing in the same pond. This doesn’t need to be a problem if you have your scouting in order.
On the Sell List Keep: Dalot, Pellistri, Malacia, Amrabat, Martinez, Hannibal, Heaton, Wan Bissaka and Shaw
I think that Onana, Dalot, Martinez, Hannibal and Pellistri all should stay. A case could be made also for McTominay but he's a squad player.
Bruno could be the one that holding the team back as well. Not that he is a bad player, but his style of play actually the opposite of ETH style of play. ETH currently just working on magic with what he has. The kind of players that Erik want/need to build around is the like of De Ligt, Frenkie De Jong & Kvaratskhelia. At this point i rather play Sancho(if he really want to play for us) or replace him with Napoli’s Kvaratskhelia, rather than Ganarcho. Ganarcho rarely connect with our striker & always try to score by himself. He sucking on player like Vini Jr from Real Madrid clearly show he will just use Man Utd as stepping stone. Too bad, he may not have what it takes to be like his idol, Cristiano.
Keep
GK - onana, Bayindir
DEF - dalot, martinez, kambwala
MID - Mainoo, bruno, mount
FWD - amad, garnacho, hojlund
Sell the rest
Sign
1 Left back
2 centre backs
2 defensive midfielders
1 striker
promote 5-6 youngsters from the youth academy to fill in the gaps
amass
jackson
ogunneye
gore
oyedele
collyer
wheatley
There are no guarantees than any new player will perform better than the existing, so putting 2/3 of the A-squad on the chopping block is ruthless and does not make any sense! What style of play is getting Manchester United back into the top 4 and which players will fit and able to handle that profile, physically, intellectually and mentally with proper balance of age, experience and team spirit all season long, not just 5 games.
I think you can't judge Mount on an injury plagued season, especially when you hired our old doctor who we used to refer to as: "Doctor Death", ☠ should be the first person you should ship out. If I were a Manc I'd probably want to keep Amrabat for a season more but not if that means a big transfer and a big 3-4 year contract, for that I'd look elsewhere for someone better to build the midfield around for the long slog back to the top. I think the Rash is a good player but he needs to be outed now because the relationship between both him and the club has turned toxic and you're all just holding each other back at this point, could he come good? Maybe, but as often as not these things don't resolve themselves so better to cash in while he still has value because another season like this and he'll be worth less than a bag of chips.
So far Hojlund hasn't been clinical enough only 9 goals in 29 matches and United need a striker who can get over 15 goals
Dalot shouldn't even be in consideration for sale, he's been great and is a solid performer.
Have been telling the exact same thing lol
i would keep, onana , dalot, lisandro, bissaka, luke shaw, cott, ( best of one of this three, casemiro, amrabet and erikisen) mount, pleistri, rashford and sancho, i like antony only because he is brazilian
For me yes we should keep Onana but that shouldn’t stop us from looking to sign a world class keeper. One of the keepers at Madrid will lose a job. Costa or Kobel would also be interesting.
Apart from the green sheet,
Wan Bissaka, Martinez, Onana and Pilistri are the ones I may keep
Agree with your list, however I would keep Mctominay and Amrabat. I feel Mctominay is a good squad player, he can feature in the less important cup games, cover for injuries etc, we can keep him for squad depth until we get better players in his position.
Amrabat has been disappointing this season but he has shown good performances these last few games, I feel there is a solid player in him, just needs more game time and get used to the league. So I would keep him for one more season.
I would keep Dalot however we should definitely sign a new RB that would compete with the best RBs in the league, and Dalot doesn't seem to be doing that, imo.
No mcshite needs to go he’s been here for way too long we need better if we are going to compete he will fetch a decent transfer fee aswell
Gettttt rid, amrabat as well. All not bloodh good enough man, what have we become?
@@mancunianproscout1090 this is the problem fans who are ten hag in will blame the players and say we need a full clear out but want to keep crap players like maguire and Scott mcshite
@@leemccccccc999 I swear, wth man, we need to offloadddd alllll the crapp, allllll, otherwise we will be in the same cycle again and again and again. I'm k.o, next year we need to pump teams. Get in warriors, sell all the shitty players.
@@mancunianproscout1090 100 percent agree, some of our fan base are very thick
The board has been dragging to sell players for more than 5 years now. That's why we still have this long list of players that aren't good enough.
Martial should have been gone 2 years ago.
Scott MC 5 years ago.
Luke shaw 4 years ago.
Rashford 2 years ago.
Maguire last transfer window.
Linderlof 2 years ago.
Wanbissaka never should have even bought him.
For a change, the players are to account
We got onana for his ball distribution ability but he’s not even top five in the league for passing imo he gives the ball away nearly every time he kicks he’s an incredible keeper tho
Dalot should stay.
It would be a bit unfair to sell Mount given he’s been unfortunate with injuries.
Onana should stay, Mctominay too.
I would sign Amrabat for 20m only.. its impossible to find a player better than him with this price + we've been struggling with an actual CDM that knows how to retain the ball, secure backline and give freedom to the midfielders to have depth up front.
Lets be generous with 280-320M. Now if all them players left you'd need to replace 22 players for 320M that's an average of 15M a player. United if everything goes okay will sell or let the contracts expire at about 3-5 players a year so, its going to take 4-7 years to clear out this current bunch and that's if you can find the additional resources to buy better players.
I would add Amrabat, Mount & Altay to the "keep list"
Why is nobody speaking about martinez on that list? Thats crazy he should be kept the best ball playing defender we have
malacia not injured is great
pellistri to keep the squad young now that garnacho plays both sides
but need bigger defenders in the middle
100% Agree with Dalot, can play rightand left back, has been absolute quality this season, onana is what you said, fully disagree with Martinez, is not quality that wins the premier is consistency, you obviously still need quality preferably world class, but the player needs to be available and fit all or most of the season. Come an offer for him United would be crazy not to accept.