25:55 They say in ancient times, shineys would secretly direct the player in the right direction, a sort of hidden indicator of the correct path. Those bright days have long since been erased as shineys are now a symbol of hopelessness and failure. RIP shiney hints. You will be missed most.
Everyone was pinging me like crazy to get me to upload my first level for Carl. A while ago Bearware and I had a contest to determine who had a worse first level, because neither of us thought there could be a worse level than our first. I "won" that contest unanimously.
Carl's favourite trolls are the ones where it's the same thing twice in a row, but I always liked the ones that make you work just hard enough to think you've avoided the troll.
This is such a great idea....but it needs one tiny little change. You should do this in MM1. Show the progression of troll levels back to the golden MM days!
"I should be able to guess all the trolls from now on." Guesses no trolls because the meta was so bad that nothing was right and there was just a bunch of pipe spam in multiple levels
Although it can not be denied that those creators have improved some of the trolls you fell for are still pretty great because it seems so obvious. Those levels play on the knowledge you haven't gained :D
Why did this video feel like I missed most of it? It keeps jumping to sections where Carl already knows of a room, when it’s the first time we see it in the video. Or sometimes it just skips over certain parts in general. Love the video regardless!
2:13 Carl gets mushroom and falls right into a troll. 2:45: Carl gets mushroom AGAIN. And deserved that one. (And the realization is so well timed). 3:18: OMG CARL, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
A little while ago I booted up MM2 for the first time in like a year and decided to pick up with a level from Carl's playlist sight unseen. It was the Ocean of Ugh. I was very confused on how the troll meta had evolved
Even after a half a year break from mario content, after I started watching Carl again... All he's learned is just these 3 things 1) 2) Nothing 3) How amazing.
Really these first troll levels aren't worse than the elaborate ones. They just take out all the bells and whistles. They're really all "looks like one kinda obvious thing, but then a real solution is slightly different" or "do I go right away or wait a little first"
The perfect thing about a troll level newbie like wilfred is that falling for his trolls hurts even more. Additionally, it's almost like he's unreadable. Thr simplicity of the level is also insult to injury too lmao.
Not going to lie, seeing this style of level/troll and Carl falling for all of them gave me this weird sense of nostalgia, even tho it has not been THAT long. Thanks for the video!.
"That is definitely something that troll levels don't do that much anymore is just difficult platforming sections." Who wants to bet he will end up regretting THAT comment?
Pretty sure I see possible cheese in the last one. If you get the fake goal, hit the invis blocks, get CP1'd, and get all the way back to the fake goal, you can walk over the invis blocks to the goal.
I like how you can see the progression of the level. At the beginning its pretty much hot garbage only midway through there are some rare gems and by the time you are almost done, every troll has some thought behind it
My day was pretty shitty and then you came along... Laughing and getting trolled and sharing this love with us My day is a million times better now Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Love you always
Here it is. The first ever level that troll makers made in Super Mario Maker. Some can be good, some can be thrown in the trash can as Carl lights it up on fire.
Carl needs to work for the militarys bomb defusing dep. Just give him a map of the area and let him say "Theres no way that theres a mine HERE" and immediately clear the area he points at
I'm shocked you didn't to Potatochan's first troll level, since I don't think you ever did that one. It was a little rough around the edges, but still very high quality.
The title made me think of Shirakami's house. Not a good troll level(hence why I'm not gonna try to recommend it). But it was both a first level and a troll level. Also, one of those levels that only got played because the creator is famous outside of Mario Maker XD
I'm not sure if I watched u or Dave playing this level in MM1, but it was before 3 days on YT and it could be worth to do a side by side failing comparisson. 😂😂😂😂 If it was you, the dying-moments were similar. And yes, you learnt nothing. ❤️🤗 Hugs from Austria.
16:28 ah yes the infamous go in a key door and come out of a pipe trick No offense, but the cuts in this video seemed quite aggressive (small parts of some of the levels were cut out)
To forgiving me the last Carl my moments of darkness or I am currently in the same house with my ex that I had just broken up with, in a time when I'm not as close as I am with my family anymore, and where I just feel stuck doing the same old job and I don't want to be in anymore, but your videos have brought me at least a couple moments in my life to laugh and enjoy if there's still a happiness out there for me. Thank you.
At the end of my physics lecture, I asked the professor: “What happened before The Big Bang?”
She said, “Sorry. There is no Time.”
Pog
Oh dear God.
:kappa:
Carl you're da best
Hold me
“Troll levels have gotten a lot better.
But I haven’t” -Larl 2021
Wilfred: Makes Forty Trolls.
Carl: Avoids 39 trolls. Falls for one troll 39 times.
Did you mean "falls for every trolls 40 times each one"
No! That's what's so weird about Wilfred!
Fc🎉rfcrfcfcvyvygygygyllvygvyvyvyvgvv yvcrcrrcr
M
25:55 They say in ancient times, shineys would secretly direct the player in the right direction, a sort of hidden indicator of the correct path. Those bright days have long since been erased as shineys are now a symbol of hopelessness and failure.
RIP shiney hints. You will be missed most.
The meta is so far behind that it's ahead
It's streets ahead!
there just is no meta really
Everyone was pinging me like crazy to get me to upload my first level for Carl. A while ago Bearware and I had a contest to determine who had a worse first level, because neither of us thought there could be a worse level than our first. I "won" that contest unanimously.
Ending looked beautiful though
Carl's favourite trolls are the ones where it's the same thing twice in a row, but I always liked the ones that make you work just hard enough to think you've avoided the troll.
"Yours was a tolerable length" - CarlSagan42
Never knew Carl was into those kinds of things 😏
Hey, if he swings that way, which I’m fairly certain he doesn’t, I won’t judge.
'Tis what she hath proclaimed
"That is a thing troll levels don't do anymore: hard platforming"
*Carl's last two hell levels flashbacks*
those were not troll levels though, just garbo
was one of the hell levels "HOT CARL"
The only troll in Carl's levels now is getting you to play them.
flashback too the rom hacks
This is such a great idea....but it needs one tiny little change. You should do this in MM1. Show the progression of troll levels back to the golden MM days!
Really enjoyed 45 minutes of Carl calling old levels bad as he repeatedly gets outsmarted by the oldest meta.
Why do ducks have tail feathers Mr. Larl? To hide their butt quacks!
These levels make you appreciate just how amazing Symplectic was - remember he created Symptoms of Stupidity when the rest were making these...
didn’t he make the original Twice Twice as well
@@thatoneguy9582 yes, Trollja Vu
@@איתןשיi think he mean the actual original twice twice, in MM1 (larl does everything twice twice)
"I should be able to guess all the trolls from now on." Guesses no trolls because the meta was so bad that nothing was right and there was just a bunch of pipe spam in multiple levels
33:50 can we talk about this cut though that was fantastic
Carl is just a great troll tester. If he doesn't find it, it's not a good troll.
A "Return to Mario Maker 1 to see bad trolls" viedo actually sounds kinda fun.
10:07 "What is he doing?"
"He's beginning to believe"
7:33 "This is better than Carl's levels", the old ones or the toxic hot garbage we love to see him make recently ?
All of the above
Yes
Had a rough day at school, thank you for the upload!
Edit: thank you so much for the wonderful thoughts everyone
Same here
Good luck Kyle! School can be a drag sometimes
Everything is finite, so stick with it! Hope you have more good days to come
Yeah I have about 10" of snow outside, there was no school today for my nephew.
Sending you some
Although it can not be denied that those creators have improved some of the trolls you fell for are still pretty great because it seems so obvious. Those levels play on the knowledge you haven't gained :D
Carl's mind hasn't grown since
And, eventually, he stopped thinking
What happened then? Well, in Whoville they say, that the Carl’s small mind, grew zero sizes that day.
No u
ah, so the "hot garbo" in the title was referring to Carl's understanding of trolls, not the actual level itself
No u
"so what I tried to do the first time, was just find a hole."
Don't feel bad, Carl. That's pretty much how everyone's first time goes.
16:28 enters door, 16:29 exists pipe. probably just a skipped transmission room.
Why did this video feel like I missed most of it? It keeps jumping to sections where Carl already knows of a room, when it’s the first time we see it in the video. Or sometimes it just skips over certain parts in general. Love the video regardless!
2:13 Carl gets mushroom and falls right into a troll.
2:45: Carl gets mushroom AGAIN. And deserved that one. (And the realization is so well timed).
3:18: OMG CARL, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
8:17
Fun fact: if Carl went down to that 50 coin, then it is a softlock.
Trust me, I saw Geek play this level.
I'm shocked to hear this. _Shocked._
So can someone explain 16:28 to me.
Edit I've decided its the evil editor keeping all the good content to himself.
Now we need Carl to remade his own first troll level.
Defender already did. Carl fell for several of the trolls in it!
A little while ago I booted up MM2 for the first time in like a year and decided to pick up with a level from Carl's playlist sight unseen. It was the Ocean of Ugh. I was very confused on how the troll meta had evolved
Carl: ":D that's it???"
Carl, literally 1 second later: *dies*
Even after a half a year break from mario content, after I started watching Carl again... All he's learned is just these 3 things
1)
2) Nothing
3)
How amazing.
You’d think with the 1000’s of hours of experience at least one thing would stay in the Carl box that is this mans head. And yet here we are
Really these first troll levels aren't worse than the elaborate ones. They just take out all the bells and whistles. They're really all "looks like one kinda obvious thing, but then a real solution is slightly different" or "do I go right away or wait a little first"
Agreed. Sometimes the simplest and most primitive of setups can be one of the best.
except that Aether level actually was trash. DO NOT PLAY indeed
but the difference is that elaborate setups are funnier and if a troll level isn't funny it's just bad.
@@SavageGreywolf Nah, AetherPi's level was pretty decent.
Modern ones do a much better job of hinting the player, so you don't feel lost with nowhere to go.
30:00
I think the wall of thwomps was supposed to hit the on/off switch and make you fall into the spikes
The perfect thing about a troll level newbie like wilfred is that falling for his trolls hurts even more. Additionally, it's almost like he's unreadable. Thr simplicity of the level is also insult to injury too lmao.
me remaking my hot garbo trolls be like: ok we have content
Not going to lie, seeing this style of level/troll and Carl falling for all of them gave me this weird sense of nostalgia, even tho it has not been THAT long.
Thanks for the video!.
Agreed
How long until the arrows lie?
One second later
Whats with the backwards arrow?
Troll Levels have come a long way. Carl hasn't.
Carl, I think we all know what you must do now right? *SMM1 troll levels*
12:15 Well that didn't age well!
12:34 Nevermind! xD
42:00 Power move.
That transition at 33:50 was really clean
"That is definitely something that troll levels don't do that much anymore is just difficult platforming sections."
Who wants to bet he will end up regretting THAT comment?
if larl just hit the damn switch on that bearware level instead of thinking he was being a smart ass by going through the door without hitting it
been binging carls videos for the whole day and now I get to watch the new stuff
Hey Carl your videos bring me so much joy, thank you for everything
Young Carl looks like a commercial photo for fanta in the 90s
Weird but accurate 😳
Pretty sure I see possible cheese in the last one. If you get the fake goal, hit the invis blocks, get CP1'd, and get all the way back to the fake goal, you can walk over the invis blocks to the goal.
I like how you can see the progression of the level. At the beginning its pretty much hot garbage only midway through there are some rare gems and by the time you are almost done, every troll has some thought behind it
Lmao Captain Stabbin with the worlds worst haircut
I can't stop cracking up over "If this CP-Zero'd me....that would be.....tasty" 🤣
My day was pretty shitty and then you came along...
Laughing and getting trolled and sharing this love with us
My day is a million times better now
Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Love you always
The best part was easily when you kept grabbing the mushroom towards the beginning
1:50 ah yes the kaizo block, the good troll
They may suck, but these old troll levels are the foundation of troll society.
Every time he forgets everything he's learned, just remember that this man is a fucking scientist and we should be terrified.
THATS what I call a true ending ;)
This had me laughing as much as your "Chat controls Mario" video and that was the most I laughed in a vid of yours (or ever). Thanks for making my day
I completely lost it to this: th-cam.com/video/zBEqjzxhSkM/w-d-xo.html
That underwater level reminds me of my own first troll level.
Toad being endlessly tickled to death.
Here it is. The first ever level that troll makers made in Super Mario Maker. Some can be good, some can be thrown in the trash can as Carl lights it up on fire.
I remember the troll water level! i remember you banning him lol at least I think you did lol
Troll levels have come a long way. Not so sure the players have caught up yet.
11:26 the alternative was clearly without pants, carl.
That thumbnail pic is something I did not know I needed to see
good to have confirmation that AetherPi was always like this
That cut at 33:50 is beautifull
Cool, my friend designed that horse on the teamliquid shirt on the preview picture :D
Carl needs to work for the militarys bomb defusing dep. Just give him a map of the area and let him say "Theres no way that theres a mine HERE" and immediately clear the area he points at
I'm shocked you didn't to Potatochan's first troll level, since I don't think you ever did that one. It was a little rough around the edges, but still very high quality.
8:54 Nice bike there
So glad you uploaded today keep on making theese vids please
Carl never sees my comments ive seen every video 10 times
At 16:25 he entered a door came out of a pipe ? Or was that a cut or smthing
Should make a series of this
Thanks for the video, my guy.
Hi Carl, I just wanted to say that my life would be happier if you uploaded more often
Carl's ready for that hot queso
no matter how dumb the troll level is, Carl falls for every troll, hook, line and sinker
37:38 Jank Ass P-Switch sounds like a great song
The title made me think of Shirakami's house. Not a good troll level(hence why I'm not gonna try to recommend it). But it was both a first level and a troll level. Also, one of those levels that only got played because the creator is famous outside of Mario Maker XD
A nice trip down memory pain
33:50 woah! How did aether delete the launcher? What a crazy setup!
26:02 A half-hearted compliment from a bed partner: 'yours was a tolerable length'
When the setup is suspicious! 😳
so I'm rewatching old troll levels and I'm wondering, what was Bearware doing during Smm1. also, I wanna see 3Goods first level
man this is so nostalgic
I'm not sure if I watched u or Dave playing this level in MM1, but it was before 3 days on YT and it could be worth to do a side by side failing comparisson. 😂😂😂😂 If it was you, the dying-moments were similar. And yes, you learnt nothing. ❤️🤗 Hugs from Austria.
16:28 ah yes the infamous go in a key door and come out of a pipe trick
No offense, but the cuts in this video seemed quite aggressive (small parts of some of the levels were cut out)
gotta love a happy ending
To forgiving me the last Carl my moments of darkness or I am currently in the same house with my ex that I had just broken up with, in a time when I'm not as close as I am with my family anymore, and where I just feel stuck doing the same old job and I don't want to be in anymore, but your videos have brought me at least a couple moments in my life to laugh and enjoy if there's still a happiness out there for me. Thank you.
Fuck I'm so high
P.S. I'm using speech-to-text
Dude.... I remember these, all of them. I cannot stress long enough that I've been watching you for about 4 years...
Any chance that you'd revisit MM1 for the first levels of some old trollmakers?
Andy (Carl) looks like the human version of Spongebob
Of course, it was fish before anything else!
Sometimes watching Carl struggle so hard is just painful
1:13 Carl talking dirty to a mole
This is so old that the jumpscare at 8:46 is actually real!
I suddenly miss all the overlay pipes from MM1. Sure it was annoying at times but they were put to good use with some good troll designs.