I think the line, "During times when there's peace he belonged to the wolrd", is just reimferming the message that he did good for the wold prior to the war.
his wife clara was herself a genius in chemistry,first women to ever hold a phd in chemistry in germany ,so she knew what he was doing and was disgusted by his work and begged him to stop
Great reaction as always! I do believe however that Haber did not invent mustard gas (I know chlorine gas he did and phosgene, but the first synthesis of mustard gas is usually attributed to Frederick Guthrie in 1860, although it could have been made as early as 1822). I am not 100% sure, but I also though he eventually left Germany after the war due to the Nazi's coming to power (and there being no place for a Jewish person like himself, in contrast to the German Empire, which (while rife with antisemitism) allowed all peoples to ascend the ranks based on merit). His story perfectly demonstrates the truly dual nature of most people in history, and so I would say he is both a sinner and a saint, or even better yet, simply human. Can't wait for more Sabaton reactions!
Hay Noah! Thank you so much for your insight on things! It is possible he fled to Switzerland for multiple reason ofc! and about the mustard gas, ill have to look into it and read more about it! do you have any suggestions on next Sabaton reactions?
@@EvyTheFox That is true and most likely right (he was certainly a broken man by the end of his life). All Sabaton songs are so good (and I as well am fascinated by war time history so much), which makes it hard to chose, but I am quite partial myself to Valley of Death, No Bullets Fly, and Firestorm (one a story about the Bulgarians bravery and tenacity in WW1, the second a tale about humanity and mercy in WW2, and the third about the atrocities all sides sometimes inflict in war, in this specific case the allied bombings of German civilians in WW2, which can far more innocent people than Germany ever did during say the Blitz). 😊
@@AlfredFJones1776 While it was undoubtedly nowhere near the levels it reached leading up to and during the second world war, there is much evidence nonetheless to suggest it was very much present and part of the culture of the Kaiserreich and Weimar Republic.
Fritz Haber actually did created mustard gas, chlorine gas, and phosgene gas for warfare, (Him creating it for warfare is probably why he was credited for making it) I'm actually pretty sure Ammonia was one of the main ingredient for all three gases, I know it is in mustard gas, which would make sense seeing as he was the one that was able to create a synthesis of ammonia from its elements.
@@EvyTheFox no need to apologize 😊 live your life, that always comes first. I am just happy you still find time to share your insights. I enjoy that since your Rammstein „Deutschland“ reaction (more like analysis).
Thank god, you reacton and comments restore my faith a little of the education system. I begun to wonder if there was one out there..thank you so much for that alone
Great reaction as always, one thing I want to point out is that there is no proof that the suicide of his wife was due to his creations, it was mostly because she was frowned upon by society because, despite being a brilliant mind, she was expected to be a house wife, not a scientist, and it's supposed that such hostility, despite the support of her colleagues, caused her to take her own life
The process was Haber is famous for has been theorized by other before him but no-one had been able to make it work. Haber was able to make it work. And the Owner of the Tech industri company 'BOSCH' (Which is still around today 100+ years later), had the Industri to make the work large scale and he was also able to improve the process and make it safer and more effective by using another core. This was before World War 1. Then WW1 broke out. Haber was a Patriot for his home country, Germany (Prussia). So he wanted to help his country, One thing he did that is not spoken off alot, is the manufacturing of gunpowder. Haber was able to make a process that made gunpowder. Gunpowder needed 'Saltpeper' to be made and Germany was mostly land lock off from the import of saltpeper by sea by the UK and neutral land powers around it. Haber was able to use the same process he made Ammonia from the 'Haber-Bosch' process to make 'nitrates', that is basicly was saltpeper, and make gunpowder from that. nitrates is if I understand it correct, something from Ammonia. Which we could make from Nitrogen and Hydrogen. And we have alot of in the atmosphere. So, Haber was able to make gunpowder from 'Thin-Air'. After that, he made chemical weapons for the army. Haber felt no problem with toxic gases as weapons. a part of a quote from him on the matter was; ''Death was Death''. Whatever from gas, bombs or flying metal objects. Its to be noted however, that Germany was not the first country to use chemical weapons in WW1. It was France. Although they only used 'Tear Gas', it was still gas on a massive scale. only thing the Germans did was use a toxic gas instead.
Radio Tapok, Russian rock band, which do the same things, about history of Russia , and WW2, just see it, Khalhin gol, Мясной бор, высота 776, it is also amazing,and thanks for your opinion, you do a great job
@@EvyTheFox as a brazillian, I'd recommend Smoking Snakes, there aren't many reactions of this one, a forgotten story even in my country and Lady of the Dark, of their last album, really interesting story any sabaton song, really have a nice day and weekend! waiting for the next vid
Yay! A new fox reaction 🦊. Your knowledge of historic facts and analysis throughout the song is always spot on 👍. Great reaction vid 😊. The song itself gives a very interesting perspective, I have to admit the lyrics made me think deeper about it. Hard to say if he was a sinner or a saint. He could have guessed imho his inventions would be used for this kind of purpose. Then again, at that scale? He didn’t “pull the trigger” himself of course. So, saint, no - sinner, dunno. Flawed like every one of us I’d say.
the only thing he didn't know that his creations would be used for is the holocaust Haber at first converted the fertilizer into gunpowder, because during war a scientist "belongs to his fatherland", and then thought to make chemical weapons to scare the enemy into surrendering (similar to the intention behind the gatling gun) not only that, but the day after his wife shot herself and their son found her in the garden, he had a train to one of the fronts where he would instruct soldiers on how to deploy the gas
@@EvyTheFox Always have suggestions for a great channel.... One of the best channels to be honest. You who like history and seem to be into darker history, why not take on the masters of evil, Slayer. And add the horrible historylesson to the lyric video. Angel of death by Slayer. About Josef Mengele. No good musicvideo but a fantastic raw song and important topic. By the way, what is your work? If you do not mind me asking. You seem to travel some. Take care! m.th-cam.com/video/zZ-gACw_GQM/w-d-xo.html
Hi evy! i'm happy to have encountered your channel, i really enjoyed your reaction to this and every song from sabaton you've heard until now! it's really great to see someone who's actually interested about history to react to their songs as i can really see the joy their songs bring to you because of their historical content apart, of course, from how absolutely amazing they sound. i've been a big Sabaton fan for the last year, and I'd love to recommend you some of the best songs that, in my opinion, take you for a good ride about the different types of songs this amazing band make. • "Christmas Truce" • "The Unkillable Soldier" • "Lifetime at War" (or/and the swedish live version of it "En Livstid i Krig) • "Night Witches" • "The Final Solution" • "Primo Victoria" • "Dreadnought" • "Lady of the Dark" • "Versailles" • "No Bullets Fly" • "Blood of Bannockburn" those are my personal recommendations for a lot of variety on Sabaton. I know you won't react to all of them on TH-cam but it'd be amazing if you listened to them and reacted to most of them, i really loved your reactions
Great reaction! But i think that the lyrics "during times where theres peace he belong to the world" "during war he belong to his place of birth" doesnt mean what u said Personally, i think that its a reference to a scientific rule that is every new things discovered by a scientific must be shared to the world. And for me the "belong to the world" is for that rule but the "belong to his place of birth" is an infringement of this rule because when there's war, u dont want to share informations with ur enemy. Thats what i think, i might be wrong, i dont claim the truth but what i think. But great reaction!
thats the amazing thing about music, right? we all read into it in our own way and visions! thats why i started these videos, to discuss together and expand our visions
@@EvyTheFox yes, thats what i think to! And thats why i love sabaton so much, their lyrics are always great! They know how to make a composition who fits perfectly with the lyrics! And last thing, i read sometimes that they make war "great" but i havemy idea about it. For me, some songs glorify a soldier or a division in an army, but they are almost always with a pov from outside, like someone telling what he or they did, like telling a story
Nice reaction and great background information, this song rly is something else from especially Sabaton, the refrain still let's my blood freeze and gives me real adrenaline shocks, this evil undertone is rly deadly alone
You should check out Sabaton's animated story videos for No Bullets fly and Red Baron . Those, besides Christmas Truce and Steel Commanders are some of the best produced videos.
@@EvyTheFox Please do. Neither you or we watching will regret it :) Also, their animated video for "No Bullets Fly" and "Night Witches" are some of the most emotional videos I've seen from them. They're amazing. I also agree with reacting to "Christmas Truce", but I would save it for december just for the moods ^^
Great analysis. The ziklon was a cyanide-based insect and rodent killer created in 1914, but it was unstable in its gas form. The cristal form called B was discovered in 1922 and was used during the 1920s and 1930s for sanitizing crop storages and the cargo holds of merchant vessels. The nazis tested it on humans in 1941. After WW2, ziklon B was still produced under different commercial names and is still used for sanitizing purposes in several countries. The factory in France was shut down by the government in 1988, the production still continues in the Czech republic under the name Uragan.
The qoute about belonging to the world during peace-time and to his place of birth (his fatherland) while wartime is not about escape but is about that he had to work for his country not for humanity at all . Also if i good remember he not working in creation of Ziklon B but his students. Still he is a true father of modern chemical warfare.
Hello miss evy, new subby here. A little correction. Capital of east prussia was Königsberg (english: King Mountain) which is todays enclave of Russia and called Kaliningrad. About the half of the east prussian territory is todays russia. Nice reaction.
I know, i should start again. Ive been doing concert photography lately and moved to a different country so i kinda been offline for a long time. Any suggestions on videos i should do?
Without "Father" there would not be "the attack of the dead men". That's interesting, in a way :) Also, the irony of a Jewish man creating what would kill millions of his kin. Makes me think of the eagle and the arrow: "The haft of the arrow had been feathered with one of the eagles own plumes. We often give our enemies the means of our own destruction.” - Aesop
he's no saint, but his contribution to the current world population can't be denied also, there was no indication that his wife was against the invention and use of chemical weapons, and it's more likely that she killed herself because back then women were still expected to stay at home and raise kids, with her not taken seriously by other scientists of the time
Just another song by sabaton to remind you, warfare is hell on earth. Nothing is too far, there is a no price that promises victory that will go unpaid in blood. Reminds me of the current conflicts were chemical weapons are infact being used alongside cluster munitions and phosphorus. War truly is the condoned slaughter of human life
yes, its insane that, even with all the history knowledge we have and share, war is still upon us and it is still possible in these days. the use of chemical and nuclear wapons does scare me for the future of all of us, but also the planet we are living on
Greate analyses, But i have noticed that you are Belgian, Then i must recommend Sabaton "Race to the Sea", This was the moment when WW1 changed from a moving war to a entrenched war, (Trench warfare ) and all because of the belgians :)
Great video Evy! Before I heard this song I didn't know that Fritz Haber was the one who created chlorine gas. I don't think it's something that was tought in my school and I've never looked into that part of the war. Also, thank you for mentioning that he was the invented Zyklon B, that was used in the concentration camps, because that fact I had missed. Another really great thing about this song is that Sabaton mentions the Manifest of the 93 which is a manifest signed by 93 german scientists at the beginning of the war, where they stated their support of the German war effort, so Haber wasn't the only scientist trying to create inventions of war. He just happened to be really good at it. My interpretation of why Haber fled the country is that he was in charge of a University in Germany when Hitler came to power and since they couldn't arrest Haber, because he was too well known, they forbid him to hire jews. Haber resigned because of this and fled from Germany to escape the Nazis. As for if he's a sinner or saint, I'm gonna agree with several ohters of the coment's: He's neither. Creating a way to chemically produce Amonium is great and is huge for being able to grow crops. Then there's the chlorine gas, which from my understanding he created in the hopes that it would shorten the war, which backfired, but he had no ill intentions. In the end he just tried to handle the situation the way he thought was right.
Could you Please react to HammerFall - Hammer of Dawn or One Against the World, They are a Swedish band. Both Catchy and melodic, Highly recommend it 😁
Honestly we can’t said he is wrong or right. Yeah his creation does brought destruction but also were used for greater good. If we want to blame him for creating one of the most dangerous weapons in the world, we might as blame the one who created Nuclear Bomb, the most dangerous weapon in the world. In the end, he is just a scientist doing his job in the his era
I feel like it's somewhat hypocritical to criticize Haber for what he did. Poison gas is definitely one of the most controversial and dark weapons of warfare. But the Haber-Bosch has probably helped feed millions, if not billions of people. And it isn't like other countries were any better. Hiram Maxim created numerous inventions. But he's most known for the Maxim gun, one of the first successful and mass produced machine guns. A weapon responsible for hundreds of thousands of deaths since it's invention. You want to test human ingenuity? Tell us to make something that can be used to kill our fellow man. We're all sinners and saints.
Everyone is a baseline sinner, that's unavoidable. Is it too much to say that he is both? A man's right to defend his homeland is respectable, in my opinion.
Donations are by no means expected, but are much appreciated! All proceeds will go into improving my stream: streamelements.com/evythefox/tip
Have you tried out Stream yards ? It's great to stream on it .
@@APOLLOPATRIOT no i actually use OBS studios to stream on twitch and record my YT videos
@@EvyTheFox ah
@@EvyTheFox But hey you make outstanding stuff keep on the grind soldier 👋 !
I think the line, "During times when there's peace he belonged to the wolrd", is just reimferming the message that he did good for the wold prior to the war.
I think in the history-video they mentioned that it was his own creed? Bot of the sentences actually I think.
his wife clara was herself a genius in chemistry,first women to ever hold a phd in chemistry in germany ,so she knew what he was doing and was disgusted by his work and begged him to stop
I didnt know that she was a genius in chemistry herself, thank you for sharing that
@@EvyTheFox its only sad that she later killed herself,why tho isnt entirely clear
It’s fox history lessons!! I mean fox reaction! 🎉🎉
Great reaction as always! I do believe however that Haber did not invent mustard gas (I know chlorine gas he did and phosgene, but the first synthesis of mustard gas is usually attributed to Frederick Guthrie in 1860, although it could have been made as early as 1822). I am not 100% sure, but I also though he eventually left Germany after the war due to the Nazi's coming to power (and there being no place for a Jewish person like himself, in contrast to the German Empire, which (while rife with antisemitism) allowed all peoples to ascend the ranks based on merit). His story perfectly demonstrates the truly dual nature of most people in history, and so I would say he is both a sinner and a saint, or even better yet, simply human. Can't wait for more Sabaton reactions!
Hay Noah! Thank you so much for your insight on things! It is possible he fled to Switzerland for multiple reason ofc! and about the mustard gas, ill have to look into it and read more about it!
do you have any suggestions on next Sabaton reactions?
@@EvyTheFox That is true and most likely right (he was certainly a broken man by the end of his life). All Sabaton songs are so good (and I as well am fascinated by war time history so much), which makes it hard to chose, but I am quite partial myself to Valley of Death, No Bullets Fly, and Firestorm (one a story about the Bulgarians bravery and tenacity in WW1, the second a tale about humanity and mercy in WW2, and the third about the atrocities all sides sometimes inflict in war, in this specific case the allied bombings of German civilians in WW2, which can far more innocent people than Germany ever did during say the Blitz). 😊
The Kaiserreich wasn’t as rife with antisemitism as you might think.
@@AlfredFJones1776 While it was undoubtedly nowhere near the levels it reached leading up to and during the second world war, there is much evidence nonetheless to suggest it was very much present and part of the culture of the Kaiserreich and Weimar Republic.
Fritz Haber actually did created mustard gas, chlorine gas, and phosgene gas for warfare, (Him creating it for warfare is probably why he was credited for making it) I'm actually pretty sure Ammonia was one of the main ingredient for all three gases, I know it is in mustard gas, which would make sense seeing as he was the one that was able to create a synthesis of ammonia from its elements.
Yes!
We need more EvyFacts!
Love it!
Keep it up!
thankyouuuu
oh nice, she is alive :-) glad to see you doing videos again.
sorry i've been quiet for a bit, i have been all over the world by now for work haha
@@EvyTheFox no need to apologize 😊 live your life, that always comes first. I am just happy you still find time to share your insights. I enjoy that since your Rammstein „Deutschland“ reaction (more like analysis).
Great exploration, as always. Love this song. Rock on.
Just seeing the knowledge you have in your repertoire leads me to believe that the Western European educational system is top notch.
Thanks from sweden on your reaction on Sabaton 😍
Thanks from Belgium for watching my video 🥰
Thank god, you reacton and comments restore my faith a little of the education system. I begun to wonder if there was one out there..thank you so much for that alone
Great reaction as always, one thing I want to point out is that there is no proof that the suicide of his wife was due to his creations, it was mostly because she was frowned upon by society because, despite being a brilliant mind, she was expected to be a house wife, not a scientist, and it's supposed that such hostility, despite the support of her colleagues, caused her to take her own life
Hey Will! Thank you for sharing this story! I didnt know much about his wife her story!
Humans, all humans are capable of cruelty and kindness in equal measure.
no one is a greater embodiment of this truth than Fritz Haber
This is very true!
The process was Haber is famous for has been theorized by other before him but no-one had been able to make it work. Haber was able to make it work. And the Owner of the Tech industri company 'BOSCH' (Which is still around today 100+ years later), had the Industri to make the work large scale and he was also able to improve the process and make it safer and more effective by using another core.
This was before World War 1.
Then WW1 broke out. Haber was a Patriot for his home country, Germany (Prussia). So he wanted to help his country,
One thing he did that is not spoken off alot, is the manufacturing of gunpowder. Haber was able to make a process that made gunpowder. Gunpowder needed 'Saltpeper' to be made and Germany was mostly land lock off from the import of saltpeper by sea by the UK and neutral land powers around it. Haber was able to use the same process he made Ammonia from the 'Haber-Bosch' process to make 'nitrates', that is basicly was saltpeper, and make gunpowder from that. nitrates is if I understand it correct, something from Ammonia. Which we could make from Nitrogen and Hydrogen. And we have alot of in the atmosphere. So, Haber was able to make gunpowder from 'Thin-Air'.
After that, he made chemical weapons for the army. Haber felt no problem with toxic gases as weapons. a part of a quote from him on the matter was; ''Death was Death''. Whatever from gas, bombs or flying metal objects.
Its to be noted however, that Germany was not the first country to use chemical weapons in WW1. It was France. Although they only used 'Tear Gas', it was still gas on a massive scale. only thing the Germans did was use a toxic gas instead.
Radio Tapok, Russian rock band, which do the same things, about history of Russia , and WW2, just see it, Khalhin gol, Мясной бор, высота 776, it is also amazing,and thanks for your opinion, you do a great job
The fact his process also help build up a few famous explosive compounds still in use today.
Interesting analysis and a good example of someone creating both good and evil!
You are so knowledgable, hope you do more Sabaton songs.
Thank you! Def planning on it!
Thank you for your well experienced analysis and your incredible knowledge about our history. Greatings from a smal Town in Germany 😊
Thank you! And thank you for watching
"In times of peace you belong to the world...in times of war you belong to the place of your birth" ... there's nothing more to add I think...
Nice to see you back. Great reaction, please keep on doing them. weiter so
Thank you! Sorry its been a while, i work as a tech for woodworking machinery, mostly cnc, and ive been travelling all over the world lately 🙈
great reaction! your analysis was very interesting
hope to see more sabaton around here, keep up!
hey Gustavo!! any suggestions maybe ??
@@EvyTheFox as a brazillian, I'd recommend Smoking Snakes, there aren't many reactions of this one, a forgotten story even in my country
and Lady of the Dark, of their last album, really interesting story
any sabaton song, really
have a nice day and weekend!
waiting for the next vid
Very interesting topic from a philosophical perspective in this song.
What I have read it was Cyclone A he invented and then the Nazis modified it and got Cyclone B.
Yay! A new fox reaction 🦊. Your knowledge of historic facts and analysis throughout the song is always spot on 👍. Great reaction vid 😊. The song itself gives a very interesting perspective, I have to admit the lyrics made me think deeper about it. Hard to say if he was a sinner or a saint. He could have guessed imho his inventions would be used for this kind of purpose. Then again, at that scale? He didn’t “pull the trigger” himself of course. So, saint, no - sinner, dunno. Flawed like every one of us I’d say.
great take on the song my dear Ninja
the only thing he didn't know that his creations would be used for is the holocaust
Haber at first converted the fertilizer into gunpowder, because during war a scientist "belongs to his fatherland", and then thought to make chemical weapons to scare the enemy into surrendering (similar to the intention behind the gatling gun)
not only that, but the day after his wife shot herself and their son found her in the garden, he had a train to one of the fronts where he would instruct soldiers on how to deploy the gas
Finally back. Very Nice. I have missed your videos.
aaaahw Andreas, that is so kind! do you have some suggestions for the next video?
@@EvyTheFox Always have suggestions for a great channel.... One of the best channels to be honest. You who like history and seem to be into darker history, why not take on the masters of evil, Slayer. And add the horrible historylesson to the lyric video. Angel of death by Slayer. About Josef Mengele. No good musicvideo but a fantastic raw song and important topic. By the way, what is your work? If you do not mind me asking. You seem to travel some. Take care!
m.th-cam.com/video/zZ-gACw_GQM/w-d-xo.html
❤
Hi evy! i'm happy to have encountered your channel, i really enjoyed your reaction to this and every song from sabaton you've heard until now! it's really great to see someone who's actually interested about history to react to their songs as i can really see the joy their songs bring to you because of their historical content apart, of course, from how absolutely amazing they sound. i've been a big Sabaton fan for the last year, and I'd love to recommend you some of the best songs that, in my opinion, take you for a good ride about the different types of songs this amazing band make.
• "Christmas Truce"
• "The Unkillable Soldier"
• "Lifetime at War" (or/and the swedish live version of it "En Livstid i Krig)
• "Night Witches"
• "The Final Solution"
• "Primo Victoria"
• "Dreadnought"
• "Lady of the Dark"
• "Versailles"
• "No Bullets Fly"
• "Blood of Bannockburn"
those are my personal recommendations for a lot of variety on Sabaton. I know you won't react to all of them on TH-cam but it'd be amazing if you listened to them and reacted to most of them, i really loved your reactions
Thank you so much! Ill def go through your list for future videos!
Great reaction!
But i think that the lyrics "during times where theres peace he belong to the world" "during war he belong to his place of birth" doesnt mean what u said
Personally, i think that its a reference to a scientific rule that is every new things discovered by a scientific must be shared to the world.
And for me the "belong to the world" is for that rule but the "belong to his place of birth" is an infringement of this rule because when there's war, u dont want to share informations with ur enemy.
Thats what i think, i might be wrong, i dont claim the truth but what i think.
But great reaction!
thats the amazing thing about music, right? we all read into it in our own way and visions! thats why i started these videos, to discuss together and expand our visions
@@EvyTheFox yes, thats what i think to!
And thats why i love sabaton so much, their lyrics are always great! They know how to make a composition who fits perfectly with the lyrics!
And last thing, i read sometimes that they make war "great" but i havemy idea about it.
For me, some songs glorify a soldier or a division in an army, but they are almost always with a pov from outside, like someone telling what he or they did, like telling a story
Nice reaction and great background information, this song rly is something else from especially Sabaton, the refrain still let's my blood freeze and gives me real adrenaline shocks, this evil undertone is rly deadly alone
You should check out Sabaton's animated story videos for No Bullets fly and Red Baron . Those, besides Christmas Truce and Steel Commanders are some of the best produced videos.
thank you so much for the recommndations!! i'll look into it!!
@@EvyTheFox Please do. Neither you or we watching will regret it :)
Also, their animated video for "No Bullets Fly" and "Night Witches" are some of the most emotional videos I've seen from them. They're amazing. I also agree with reacting to "Christmas Truce", but I would save it for december just for the moods ^^
note: chlorine gas and yperite aka mustered gas are not the same, as is explained in the sabaton histroy video about this song
love your reaction. Great work
Thankyou ❤️
Great analysis. The ziklon was a cyanide-based insect and rodent killer created in 1914, but it was unstable in its gas form. The cristal form called B was discovered in 1922 and was used during the 1920s and 1930s for sanitizing crop storages and the cargo holds of merchant vessels. The nazis tested it on humans in 1941. After WW2, ziklon B was still produced under different commercial names and is still used for sanitizing purposes in several countries. The factory in France was shut down by the government in 1988, the production still continues in the Czech republic under the name Uragan.
Thank you for sharing this information!
The qoute about belonging to the world during peace-time and to his place of birth (his fatherland) while wartime is not about escape but is about that he had to work for his country not for humanity at all . Also if i good remember he not working in creation of Ziklon B but his students. Still he is a true father of modern chemical warfare.
Thats also a great interpertation of the song! I wish i could ask Sabaton how they actually meant it haha 😁
Hello miss evy, new subby here. A little correction. Capital of east prussia was Königsberg (english: King Mountain) which is todays enclave of Russia and called Kaliningrad. About the half of the east prussian territory is todays russia. Nice reaction.
Hey Adoryn! Welcome to the channel! Hope you'll find some videos you like! Thank you for sharing your information!
@@EvyTheFox good morning, you are very fast ✌️
@@EvyTheFox You have no patreon. You should think about it. The most people who support YT Channels are very kind and unique, do not fear them.
@@adoryntriggerhappy thats a great idea, ill look into it! Thanks
@@adoryntriggerhappy i added my twitch donation link to the pinned comment for now
Evy, you should become a historical advisor for Sabaton, you are brilliant!
U are the kindest! I really appreciate your comment
War has always been a great reason to bring science forward.
True, it also shows how something can be great for humanity but in wrong hands destroy humanity
I think he was just a human who did what he thought was right so not a sinner not a saint just a very smart human in the end.
Yes i do believe thats a good way to look at it
Bedankt
NINJA!!!
@@EvyTheFox ❤️🦊
Cool thing is I have SABATON autograph 💥🔥I enjoy war and history yeahyeyeyeye!
Oooeeeeef love it!
It's a shame you stopped uploading :/ Honestly this was one of the best reactions to this I've ever seen.
I know, i should start again. Ive been doing concert photography lately and moved to a different country so i kinda been offline for a long time. Any suggestions on videos i should do?
@@EvyTheFox I personaly would appreciate the sabaton live performance of en livstid et krig from gothenburg
Without "Father" there would not be "the attack of the dead men". That's interesting, in a way :)
Also, the irony of a Jewish man creating what would kill millions of his kin. Makes me think of the eagle and the arrow: "The haft of the arrow had been feathered with one of the eagles own plumes. We often give our enemies the means of our own destruction.” - Aesop
he's no saint, but his contribution to the current world population can't be denied
also, there was no indication that his wife was against the invention and use of chemical weapons, and it's more likely that she killed herself because back then women were still expected to stay at home and raise kids, with her not taken seriously by other scientists of the time
Just another song by sabaton to remind you, warfare is hell on earth. Nothing is too far, there is a no price that promises victory that will go unpaid in blood. Reminds me of the current conflicts were chemical weapons are infact being used alongside cluster munitions and phosphorus. War truly is the condoned slaughter of human life
yes, its insane that, even with all the history knowledge we have and share, war is still upon us and it is still possible in these days. the use of chemical and nuclear wapons does scare me for the future of all of us, but also the planet we are living on
so glad you knew his name....something is totally going wrong with german education system....Fritz who?....
You should react to Five Finger Death Punch song called Living A Dream. I listen to that every day yeahyeyeyeye 🔥!
You'll listen to a billion bands but you'll never find anything close to Sabaton, awesome video
they are def unique and amazing!
Greate analyses,
But i have noticed that you are Belgian,
Then i must recommend Sabaton "Race to the Sea",
This was the moment when WW1 changed from a moving war to a entrenched war, (Trench warfare )
and all because of the belgians :)
Thank you for the recommendation! Ill look into it!
Great video Evy!
Before I heard this song I didn't know that Fritz Haber was the one who created chlorine gas. I don't think it's something that was tought in my school and I've never looked into that part of the war. Also, thank you for mentioning that he was the invented Zyklon B, that was used in the concentration camps, because that fact I had missed.
Another really great thing about this song is that Sabaton mentions the Manifest of the 93 which is a manifest signed by 93 german scientists at the beginning of the war, where they stated their support of the German war effort, so Haber wasn't the only scientist trying to create inventions of war. He just happened to be really good at it.
My interpretation of why Haber fled the country is that he was in charge of a University in Germany when Hitler came to power and since they couldn't arrest Haber, because he was too well known, they forbid him to hire jews. Haber resigned because of this and fled from Germany to escape the Nazis.
As for if he's a sinner or saint, I'm gonna agree with several ohters of the coment's: He's neither. Creating a way to chemically produce Amonium is great and is huge for being able to grow crops. Then there's the chlorine gas, which from my understanding he created in the hopes that it would shorten the war, which backfired, but he had no ill intentions. In the end he just tried to handle the situation the way he thought was right.
Hey Martin! Thank you for your amazing reaction and thank you for sharing the extra information!
Prush sha
Quick question. Ever heard of folk metal?
and if not? I suggest you check out Bloodywood
I actually met the guys from bloodywood last summer, they are super kind! I had their limited edition LP signed for my boyfriend
@@EvyTheFox aw hell yes!!! I Love that band!!!!
@@EvyTheFox well then ... how about Arka'n Asrafokor?
Could you Please react to HammerFall - Hammer of Dawn or One Against the World, They are a Swedish band. Both Catchy and melodic, Highly recommend it 😁
I'll have a look 😁 thank you for recommanding
@@EvyTheFox No problem :D
Honestly we can’t said he is wrong or right. Yeah his creation does brought destruction but also were used for greater good. If we want to blame him for creating one of the most dangerous weapons in the world, we might as blame the one who created Nuclear Bomb, the most dangerous weapon in the world. In the end, he is just a scientist doing his job in the his era
very good take on it and i feel like you are completely right so
I feel like it's somewhat hypocritical to criticize Haber for what he did.
Poison gas is definitely one of the most controversial and dark weapons of warfare.
But the Haber-Bosch has probably helped feed millions, if not billions of people.
And it isn't like other countries were any better.
Hiram Maxim created numerous inventions. But he's most known for the Maxim gun, one of the first successful and mass produced machine guns.
A weapon responsible for hundreds of thousands of deaths since it's invention.
You want to test human ingenuity? Tell us to make something that can be used to kill our fellow man.
We're all sinners and saints.
Everyone is a baseline sinner, that's unavoidable. Is it too much to say that he is both? A man's right to defend his homeland is respectable, in my opinion.
It is def not too much! I think its a great take on him as a person
...wer so´n Fass aufmacht, sollte die Gesichte aber auch zu ende erzählen! ...Fritz Haber...