Just like everybody else, I've had some not-so-good whiskies, but I can't say that I regretted buying them. If anything, I would've probably regretted not buying them and wonder forever "what if". I stay away though from cool looking decanters; they're most likely compensating for something.
I would say my most regretted purchases would be the Dalmore range in general. It happened back in my early days of collecting, so I didn’t know better, but Dalmore King Alexander III at 40% was not worth $300… That applies to the rest of their range too, since I have bought and tried them all (not necessarily a good thing).
I’m gunna be honest I love Irish Whiskey, it’s my favorite I’ve tried so many and love so many…but some 5-8 year old Irish Whiskey is some of the best I’ve ever had. I look at how young Waterford is and seriously appreciate what they are doing. Youth doesn’t mean bad but there is a whole lot of bad young whiskey.
There is a slight hissing sound. You probably need to hit the noise reduction button. Here is my list: (1) ALL of the Connemarra, the Cask Strength is worse that the 12. They taste like gasoline. (2) Glyph Molecular Whisky. To call this "whisky" is an insult to whisky. (3) Sonoma Bourbon Whiskey. It is too damn young, tastes like pencil shavings. (4) Dingle Irish Whiskey, batch 4. I think it may be corked but Whisky Jason in Germany had similar notes. It is just nasty. (5) Proper Twelve. It is 100% pure shite.
Truth be told, the risk of having Buyer's Remorse grows exponentially past about $60 with Scotch, past $100 it's more likely than not. With bourbon & rye, the remorse sets in past $40, and the entire category tops out at about $70 IMHO.
That is why I pay 100 dollars a year for an SMWS membership. They have a wide selection of single cask, age stated scotch and other spirits. I have had a few that I didn't get on with as well but that is a matter of my taste, not the quality of the product.
@@billmonteith1161 I'm familiar with them, and perhaps I'll join someday, but I can't justify it right now. They have some decently-priced bottles given their pedigrees, but they still aren't inexpensive...generally speaking.
I know Scotch better than Bourbon, so for under $60 I can find peated gems like Ardbeg 10, Ledaig 10, and possibly Port Charlotte 10, and I can find unpeated ones like Craigellachie 13, Bunnahabhain 12, Deanston 12, and Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban 14. I'd argue that between those bottles you have about 90+% of what the entire category of Scotch Single Malt has to offer ✌️
There's been many whiskies I've not enjoyed but never regretted just due to the fact that deep down I'd always wonder what it could have been if I never ended up trying it. As with all life's disappointments I try to learn from them and figure out what I didn't like so I don't go for bottles like that again. I refer to these bottles as Monday sippers, they may not be enjoyable but they'll teach you something of value.... Or just taste bad. Either way cheers and I enjoyed this video, would love to see one of whiskeys you wish you bought sooner!
My first ever bourbon was Elijah Craig Small Batch($50 CDN) and I loved it. A few months later I saw a bottle of Angels Envy($80 CDN) and bought it. It looks better than it tastes. I now have a bottle that my friends enjoy more than I do. I just thought my 2nd bottle would be better than my 1st. Live and learn.
Thank you for a fun review list 🤗 I did make my regretable buys when I just started out exploring whisky, but then I didn't know that, because I didn't have anything to compare it with. Most of the regrets were bottom shelf blends. But there were definitely some that I would buy today, just to enjoy a no-brainer whisky. After that I started to watch ALOT of videos of Daniel and Rex, and Horst Luening, just to get a bit more oriented in the whisky universe. After that I started to make more well thought out choises. I started to follow more whiskytubers in both whisky and bourbon universe that seemed to have about the same taste as I have, along with really educational and fun videos made by warm personality whiskytubers like yourself 🤗 So the ones I regret now isn't many at all. But I was a bit dissatisfied with Glen Moray Peated, HP12, Talisker Storm, Jura 12, Buffalo Trace, Bulleit Bourbon. They're not bad, but didn't tickle me the right way 🙃
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary Thanks for your reply. Yes the 10yo is definitely better. But for me I rather choose T. Skye over Storm. Skye for me is more similar to 10yo, but not as complex and deep in the notes. Storm for me is a bit "hollow" in lack for better word. I think the peat/smoke notes is separate to the rest of the notes. They're not as intertwined as I like the notes to be.
Those samurai and Chinese decanters are pretty wild to have on a shelf even if the contents are crap. My wife has bought me a few howlers with Crabbies Yardhead being the worst “single malt” I’ve ever tasted.
I really liked the regular 1792 as an everyday drinker. I think I drank half the bottle the first night. Worst bourbon I ever bought was Jefferson’s very small batch. It is like drinking heavily Oaked piss. Would rather drink military star bourbon.
Wild turkey : Took me a long time to finish, and stopped me from even trying the 101 for a long time, which i love Glenmorangie 12 ( could not finish bottle) Tomatin 12 ( could not finish bottle)
There’s a reason why marketing works. Most whiskies above the $75.00 threshold aren’t dissimilar from less expensive ones. The liquid inside is nothing but hype. Usually. Stick with whiskey $30-60 and you ll never be disappointed.
Jefferson’s Voyage 26 is the only one I’ve tried. Had it at a bar in Kentucky and it was actually delicious. I’ve tried to find a bottle of that specific voyage but had no luck.
I’m a few years into whisky and still don’t often spend more than £40-£50 on a bottle. I’m still learning what I like and there’s plenty of good whisky below and around this price point. I’ve had the occasional whisky that’s disappointed but it doesn’t hurt my wallet too much at these prices.
I couldn’t agree more man. I try to finish every bottle before I buy another one too if I can. Whisky is so volatile, along with the numerous factors that influence our perceptions. I feel like I haven’t given something a decent chance unless I finish it. And to be honest some whiskies do better as a good mouthful swirled and chewed not just sipped to find their characteristics
I have a 1972 SiB that I feel the same way. Ive gotten a couple bottles that have set me apart. A 21-05 MMCS I got noses fantastic drinks sour. Also sometimes buying cheap will bite you like Buskers Green label and Johnny Walker Red. I have had good luck with some $100 whiskeys and haven't been disappointed yet, but I know its coming haha.
Join the club. I've bought several whiskeys that I regret buying. The two that stand out to Me are The Singleton single malt Next to undrinkable, straight or mixed. The only reason I keep drinking it is I paid good money for it. Also Glen Moray Port cask finish. Again expected a decent flavor and nose . No such luck.A harsh flavor and no aroma.
2 come to mind. 1:black bottle, although not disgusting, it's a flat peated blend. 2:Nikka Days, not expensive, but so light, you'll think it's whisky-flavoured lemonade.
Like or Dislike: Like. Like virtually all TH-cam viewers, I'm a sucker for titles that promise an exciting rant, and this video delivers on that promise.
My Disappointments are Arran Sauternes, Almost every Glenmorangie,Arran Amarone, Cragganmore 12, Connemara 12, Tyrconell, Jim Beam Double oak, West Cork malt, Monkey Shoulder blended whisky.
Gotta becareful with Japanese whisky, some is complete crap. Shibui and Matsui are pour down the drain after the first sip. Stick with Nikka and Suntory.
This is a fun idea! One that comes to mind is the Maker's Mark Cinnamon Dolce, the distillery exclusive. It didn't taste bad, but i liked Maker's 46 a lot more, and it's less than half the price
Good video, thanks for posting it. I have only two purchases I regret: The Famous Grouse Smokey Black. I like some whiskeys (bourbons and Scotches, etc.) better than others, but so far the Smokey Black is the only whiskey I have actively disliked. Next is Johnnie Walker Black Label. Just disappointing, and it was relegated to be a mixer along with the JW Red Label.
I'm not all that far into whiskey, maybe tried 110+ different ones. But I have had three major disappointments so far, and thankfully they didn't cost an arm and a leg. 1. Auchentoshan American Oak - After enjoying this with a friend at a bar years and years ago, I felt nostalgic and bought a bottle on offer. I hated this. Barrel bitter, too young, very ethanol-driven. Ended up using it when frying minced beef, where it imparted some welcome notes of sweetness. But really hated this otherwise. 2. Kinahan's Small Batch - "An Irish whiskey at 46%? Count me in!", I thought. Yeah, well, this thing tasted of soap and cardboard, somehow. I tried water, letting it aerate, nothing helped. It was quite simply the worst whisky I'd ever had up to that point. 3. Bunnahabhain Eirigh Na Greine - it was on offer, and I loved Bunna 12, so I wanted to try different expressions. The red wine dominates and not in a good way. It is tannic, astringent, and doesn't even take water that well. I've since tried the Cruach Mhona (decent, the peat is kinda minty somehow) and the An Cladach (decent balance of bourbon and sherry flavors), and really wish I had gone for the Toiteach a Dha or Stiuredair instead of the Eirigh Na Greine. Generally speaking, I'm still looking for a German whiskey that hits my palate. I've been thoroughly underwhelmed thus far.
Just watched this Video and I agree with the comment there are more Whiskey's I regret NOT Buying 10X more than ones I regret Buying. The biggest recent regret is Bunnahabhain An Cladach Travel Exclusive. I LOVE Bunn 12 so was looking forward to this. Got home and Meh. The salt in the wound comes from you get ONE CHOICE ON the way back at Duty Free. Should have picked up either of the other travel exclusives JD Single Barrel 100proof or WT 12.
I learned very early into my alcohol buying adventure to NEVER buy based on the bottle or "story" and many times if I see too much of a story I just put it back on the shelf because most of the time a story just means its inadequate and they are trying to get you to want to like it versus just liking it. If I want a cool bottle I look for that in a vodka or rum that can be buried into cocktails. Also, when I m looking at buying an expensive bottle I ll call around to a few local bars and ask if they have it and try a pour before buying a bottle. Id rather pay for an expensive pour then buying the bottle if I like it then having an 80 dollar bottle of disgusting. This plan has saved me money in the long run because worse case scenario you are out 8-20 dollars versus 20-100 dollars.
I don't feel like this is a crazy one, but I found the Elijah Craig 18 very disappointing. It's not bad, but I didn't think it offered a ton over the standard EC and couldn't justify it's 5X price. Price aside, I prefer the ECBP. Still a fun one to have in the collection.
I’ve had three regular 1792s, 2 were very good 1 was off profile & I did not enjoy it. I recently got a store pick & it’s outstanding. If you can find one(even a regular bottle) at a good price which is around $40 I would still recommend it- may be some minor issues with consistency.. Kaiyo cask strength finished in Mizenura - very good!
Did not like Buffalo Trace (albeit a store pick) and did not like Eagle Rare 10. Everyone seems to go wild for BT distilled stuff but they are 0/2 for me.
@@LeatherDaddy97 There definitely was no "it" factor. I prefer Wild Turkey, Four Roses, Elijah Craig... pretty much I've found other bourbons enjoyable compared to BT core.
Disappointments have included Glen Moray Chardonnay Cask, 1792 Small Batch (banana), Barrell Dovetail (I didn't like it outright, but the $100 price made it a very poor purchase indeed), Old Forester 1910 (especially considering how good 1920 is), Stranahan's Single Malt, Woodford Reserve Wheat (I love wheated, but hated this).
Mizunara - 'a fairly old' means around 200 years old ))) I don't regret buying, but rather here's my bitter disappointment list: 1. Glenmorangie D'or. I had Sauternes wine, it was truly the nectar of gods, but whiskey was more burn and alcohol than taste. Perhaps my expectations were just too high. 2. Hyde No 5 The Aras Cask. It's just pure nail polish on a nose and a palate. You'll be better off with vodka. I don't even dare to try any other of their products. 3. Robert Burns Single Malt from Arran. It may taste relatively OK, but holy crap! We didn't even finish the bottle with my friend and we both had one of the worst hangovers ever. It's like Arran didn't wanna all the heads and tales from the good stuff go to waste. The bottle was purchased from a reputable source tho and it doesn't make sense to make a crappy copy of such unpopular and mostly unknown whiskey that even if someone's gonna buy it, it'll be a once in a lifetime experience. Didn't even get buzzed. Never again. 4. Fujimi - just a fancy overpriced mixer. 5. This one is seriously unfortunate coz I love peat. I'm not a whiskey expert by any means, that's probably why Ardbeg Uigedail and Corryvreckan as well as Talisker Dark Storm felt like just a stronger versions of a standard 10 year old, but for a significantly higher price. They are fine peat-bombs by any means, but I expected a little more. Perhaps I'm just spoiled by Octomore, coz that thing is just.. can't really put it into words. Avoided regrets: I bought a shot of Macallan 12 in a bar and happy that I didn't spent 60+ eur on a whole bottle.
Matsui is known for not using Japanese whisky and yes, avoid Yamato! My most disappointing whiskies have been Green Spot which was really bland and a 1996 Signatory bottling of Clynelish that had been aged in a sulfurous cask.
so far i have thankfully not had anything that was so bad i had to pour it down the sink. But i was alittle let down with the glenfeddich 12 nice full fruity aroma and no substance. Same with the johnnie walker High rye, had really light on taste that only lasted like 2-3 seconds then flat water. On another note, my current best and favorite was an Elija Craig 18Year. It was $360 but i WOULD NOT hesitate to buy another bottle or 2 if i find it again. It was like a super smooth creamy vanilla ice cream, nose was the same to me, it was just enjoyable all the way around. If you see one i highly recommend getting it.
Thank you for this. I was so disappointed that the New Hampshire liquor stores ran out of Glenmorangie 'Cake' before I could get a bottle. I am SO relieved that it was nothing but marketing nonsense!
Love the video as always. First let me start off by saying I’m a Scotch Lover, but I have a bottle of Buffalo Trace that I was saving for today. That being said I have to say... I’m not a fan. Like many other comments from your viewers I can’t say I regret it because at least I can say I tried it. I will occasionally have a bourbon but I expected soooo much more.
I've had a few disappointments that I won't buy again: Definitely agree with you about Jefferson's Ocean, and I'll also add their Small Batch to the list too. I'm also not a fan of: Blade and Bow, Basil Hayden's Kentucky Straight, Four Roses Single Barrel, Nelson's Green Briar, Willett Pot Still Reserve, and Woodinville straight bourbon. I found each of them to either be boring or just to sharp of an alcohol blast / single dimensional.
Connemara is my #1 least enjoyed whisky lmao. I literally have had a bottle sitting on my shelf for 8 years without being served other than when i want to have a laugh at people bc no one enjoys that bottle. Great video man
Timely topic as I just pulled a handful of bottles to give away because I can't stand them and I'm done trying to like them. I've tried to see if any of these got better over time so I"ve tasted them all about 3 times now, but nope they still don't do it for me. Bowman Brothers, Rebel Yell 100, Mayor Pingree Red Label, a Larceny pick and a Tumblin' Dice pick. Chattanooga port cask and Isaac Bowman. I really like Woodinville Port finished, but every single other port finished whiskey I have had has a terrible burnt rubber note. I happen to have a 1792 BiB pick and it's been sitting at just over half full for almost 2 years now. I just don't have any desire to go back to it.
You are the reason why I haven't bought Connemara 12, eventhough I really like the regular Connemara. Something similar happened to me with the Maker's 46 and Larceny. Both of these bourbons cost me double of what the basic Maker's is. But they are not twice as good. I was also disappointed by Glencadam 15. A good whisky, but why did I pay as much as I did...
Taste is always subjective. The only one so far is Haig clubman with orange, I looked at it so many times and finally took it home and it was awful. The fake orange overpowered everything and is undrinkable
I'm a big fan of Old Gran Dad 114, and since I usually water it down to tame the heat, I thought I'd try the regular 80 proof under the assumption that it would still be good and I wouldn't have to add water to drink it. Bottom line is that the regular Old Grand Dad is one watery bourbon--weak flavor and thin mouthfeel. Think of Jim Beam White Label watered down to 40 proof. I only paid around 20 bucks for it and I still feel ripped off.
@@burkec33 That $23 dollars would have been better sunk into Wild Turkey 101. Can't beat tha Turk! Journey goes far and wide, always circles back somehow to that fabulous drinkable bird ... Wild Turkey. Believe it! Cheers .....
@@jamesnorwood4084 Unfortunately, I paid almost $40 for that swill. Totally agree with you in WT101. It grew on me as I drank more of it. Now you are making me want another bottle ….
I have a store pick Ocean. I like it but I'm not finding anything from the voyage influence. I caught it on sale luckily. If I paid full price I would regret it but I do enjoy it enough where I'm Ok with it but wish it had an obvious character
Smokehead, I tried it while having a great night at a bar with a friend, which may have influenced my enjoyment. I bought a bottle, and at home realised there's not a lot going on under the smoke.
Nikka days , it's not a bad whiskey but I like very bold obvious flavours . In comparison from the barrel is just super thick and juicy and even my uneducated buds good taste and feel the difference. Even beam/suntory etc being the most Japanese yet Glasgow written on the bottle loses its magic a little. English version of laphroaig 10 and buffalo trace watered to 40% made these more average also
Cant say that people should avoid the whisky that I don’t like. One thing I learned in Scotland vacations is that everyone has a different palate. The whisk which I think are terrible are loved by others.
Johnnie Walker Black label was a big disappointment for me, and the one that surprised me that I liked at first but quickly got to a sort of regret was the Deanston Virgin Oak. I had heard nothing but good things about the virgin oak, it seemed like a cool idea (did make a decent old fashioned though), but the whisky itself just didn't do it for me after a few pours. Luckily not an expensive bottle.
The Matsui you have I think is a bad batch or counterfeit, as its a VERY young whisky, and yours appears to be far too dark compared to what's on my shelf, which is so pale it could be mistaken (by a novice) for new make. Matsui has real potential...and comparing its capturing of Mizunara to Glendalough-13 I think is unfair and almost bordering on category mistake as the Irish whiskey spent 92% of its time in ex-bourbon, whereas the cask interaction of matsui w/ mizunara is exclusive. Apart from this, thanks for the great post
The worst mistake I made so far was a Bulleit 123.4 barrel proof bourbon. It was only $40 so no big loss financially but the flavor was like drinking a Hall's cough drop. I had heard Bulleit rye was really good so I thought the barrel proof bourbon would be a for sure thing. And I won't say I will never buy any Bulleit products again either, just a little bit leary at this point. BTW I drank it all anyway lol! OGD114 was another one that I didn't like. What's strange about that is that the flavor profile was great but even a small pour gave me a headache every time I tried it. Not sure why but it's something I wouldn't buy again.
Here's a thought, sir: why not do something Ralfy suggested in one of his videos: create an "Infinity" blend out of these 6 bottles? I know some are whisky, some bourbon (what''s the real difference?) and such but if you're not interested in drinking them anymore but don't want to throw them out why not just combine them into one blend - just for the experiment of it - and try drinking that? You might get lucky and create something really good (or really awful). I think that'd be a hoot~! Let us know if you decide to try this
There are several ways to dispose whiskey you hate: 1. Give away to your friends who don't give af and drink everything that burns. 2. Use it for cooking. 3. My favorite: if you like peat, just get the cheapest heavily peated whiskey like Laphroaig Select or Ardbeg Wee Beastie and mix it one to one. From experience making a fancy concoction even from good whiskeys fails 9 times out of 10. I always end up just 'peating' up my infinity bottles.
I too made the Connemara 12 mistake Why didn't your video come out a month sooner!?!?! But I think the whiskey I most regret buying are the ones on my shelf that I just don't want to drink. They were paths and directions in the journey of finding what I like and enjoy but they aren't all winners. Sad but true.
Great video!!! Thankfully I haven't had any of those. I had the regular Connemara which was my induction to peat. But since my love is now Port Charlotte 10. Connemara is just mehhh 😂😂 Cheers Bill!!!
Love the channel, you helped me get into whiskeys during the beginning of the pandemic. Id love to see reviews on Michters American Whiskey, Russels Reserve Single Barrel, and Knob Creek 120 Proof Single Barrel. All stock its from me and would love to hear your opinion.
For me it was Longbranch from Wild Turkey and Pinhook the whisky that looks like a wine bottle. Longbranch just is not good and pinhook I had in a really good old fashion at a Bar so I picked up a bottle. should have keep my money on both!
Great video. I am with you on the Yamato. I bought their special edition cask strength, which was less than 50%,decanter bottle. It was horrible. I also disliked the Jack Daniels Gold, and the Whistle Pig Roadstock. Major let downs.
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary The Yamato special edition says its cask strength at 43% which is a joke. But I still gave it a try lol. The bottle is absolutely beautiful. It's heavy clear cut glass reminiscent of lead crystal decanters.
Here is another one folks are going to disagree with, but I bought a bottle of Knob Creek 9 Cask Strength and was very disappointed. I am no stranger to cask strength and like many offerings, however I found it to be almost undrinkable (alcohol and burnt caramel is all I got). It was not super expensive, but since I can't drink and enjoy it it is a regret. I know many people enjoy it though.
I'm very very early into this whisk(e)y journey and so far the only one I regret is a Jameson IPA tester - it might as well have been bath water. Fortunately everything else I've purchased so far has at least been good and a number are excellent. All this information that's out here on these interwebs is really useful ! Thank you.
I had a few... Maker's Mark was meh! Dalmore 12 and Balvenie Double wood was meh and also overpriced here in Finland. Don't get me wrong, these are fine whiskies but for me a bit dull at the price. Glendalough double barrel had a weird palate at first (like burnt clutch) but when the bottle got older it openned really nice to be that sweet single pot triple stilled irish doing nothing more what Jameson wouldn't do about 10€ less/bottle. I have to admit that many whiskies came dull to me after Lagavulin 16 but some are also bit too harsh for me like Ardbeg ten and those two octomores I've tasted. I have high hopes for Port Charlotte 10 and Ardbeg Uigeadail. Peace and love.
My biggest mistake was Lot 40. I tried every possible way to finnish that bottle...only splash of Ardbeg 10 over powered the taste of dill pickle. Just bad bad whisky for me. #whiskeyregret
In order: 1. Jim Beam Single Barrel. Holy $h!7 was this a bad whiskey. It was all the worst parts of Jim Beam turned up to 11. This became exclusively a cocktail bottle to get it off my shelf quickly. 2.Angel's Envy. Everyone talked about how great it was and it was awful. Wife and I both hated it. Weird bitter note (not barrel tannin bitter, think more like chemical bitter) that ruined the rest of what was a pretty bog-standard bourbon. It would have been completely unremarkable except for that strange bitter note. I was so, so thankful I got it at Costco and didn't pay full price for it. Ended up using it almost exclusively in coffee to help bury the off-putting flavors. 3. Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 24. Vorage 23 was pretty good, if a little unremarkable given the price, but especially in an A-B comparison with more traditional bourbons the Voyage 23 had some very clear briny notes and other flavors that set it apart. But the 24 just isn't good at any price. 4. I didn't buy it with my own money, but the Breckenridge bourbon. I get more interesting flavors out of an $18 bottle of Evan Williams BiB than anything I got out of the $60 bottle of Breckenridge. Not a BAD whiskey, but not even close to worth the price. 5. Redemption Bourbon and Rye. Just completely uninteresting MGP products. I've had good MGP whiskies. These are not in that group. Also, as you guessed in your video, I have to take issue with the 1792 BiB being on your list. I found it to have a lot of leathery, earthy, and woody notes in it that I really enjoyed, with not a lot of the traditional sweet bourbon characteristics. Their full proof is good, the small batch is ok, and the sweet wheat is meh. But I love the unique flavor profile of the BiB. It's so unlike most other bourbons, which I really appreciate. Haven't seen it on a shelf here in months which makes me sad, but it's on my list of "Buy it when I see it."
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary maybe? I wondered that about the Angel’s Envy since everyone seemed to love it, but I tried it at a bar in another state and found that same bitter note. Entirely possible that the 1792 just doesn’t jibe with your palate for whatever reason.
I've had Jameson as someone recommended. The taste of it felt so metallic on my pallate, not at all gingerbread taste that everyone said it had. I had the feeling something was off with my taste buds, tried it again different occasion, same result, Jameson for me definitely a no no...
I don’t like the Barton profile and hate the 1792 small batch I have. (Picked up the bib and FP today at total wine hoping they are different). I regret the peerless bourbon I bought, just tastes like rubbing alcohol. Discovery series 4 was a huge disappointment and it sits almost full in the corner to this day. And finally, Sam houston 15 (I got 2 bottles at secondary pricing and the longer I have it the more I taste that Barton funk)… should have gotten a second remus V instead of that SH15.
I agree with most of your takes but I really like my bottle of Tale of Winter. Also, I've never had a bad bottle of 1792 Bottled in Bond. I love it. Could your bottle be corked? I get lots of banana from the bottles I've purchased. Nevertheless, you have a great channel! Regarding peated Irish, Teeling BlackPitts. Don't you agree that it's wonderful?
The only reason 1792 doesn't make my regret list is that it's no more expensive than Jack Daniels Single Barrel or SiB BP. It taste almost the same but is less viscous (I prefer the JD). As for my most regretted bottles, I would say Hudson Baby Bourbon, and believe it or not, the 2017 release of George T. Stagg for which I unfortunately paid over $400. It sits on my shelf for whiskey knowledgeable guests to try but it just wasn't any good to me. I also think Blanton's Straight From the Barrel is not that great.... What I've learned is that I get very selective on bourbons that get above $100 (pre-inflation prices). They generally aren't that special over a $40-$80 bourbon. Scotch has so much more variety for the money.
I bought a bottle of Tobasco-flavored Dickel solely for the reason that it was on sale for $6. I quickly understood why it was on sale for $6. I never thought I’d ever be so upset with a $6 purchase, but I was tempted to take it back to the store and attempt to return it out of principle. I didn’t even want to disrespect the weeds in my yard by using it to kill them, so I keep it on my shelf as a prank bottle to give shots to my friends. Tobasco Dickel makes Fireball seem like Glenlivet 18.
Everyone of your subscribers will be able to form a list of the naff whiskys they have bought/tried. Its part of the journey. Not everyone will label it 'regret' but for sure everyone experiences whisky disappointment ! (Dalmore expressions for more... Not a fan)
Does the 1792 bottled in bond taste like the old Very Old Barton bottled in bond? My theory is that they stopped producing VOB BIB so they could make more money by putting it in pricier 1792 bottles.
Larceny, just the normal bottle of Larceny is probably the worst standard offering I've ever bought. It just smells of straight nail polish remover, it's bitter, it doesn't have any redeeming qualities. I gave up trying to drink it and demoted it to cooking bourbon.
I've had a few disappointments and stinkers, but none that have cost much so far. I'll start with Haig Club Single Grain Scotch Whisky, terrible stuff, even as a mixer you need to literally drown it or cover it up with bitters to make it palatable. Next up Yamazakura Blended Whisky roughly the same price as Suntory Toki but makes Haig Club seem like an upgrade. Finally for most disappointing; Weller Special Reserve. It's not really bad just bland. Tastes like a very muted or faded Eagle Rare 10. There's just not enough going on to make it a sipper but it does a solid job as a mixer. I paid it $40 CAD which is pretty cheap, but still feel I overpaid. At that price there's so many better options like Elijah Craig Small Batch, Maker's Mark, even Bulleit!
None of late comes to mind (I'm more discerning now I guess), but a number of disappoiting Signatory Vintages bottlins in the golden (chill-filtered) and silver (non-chillfiltered) tubes come to mind, like an Imperial 16YO. Actually there's a more recent one that I remember, their Edradour 2011 (10YO) that is matured in sherry casks from beginning to end. Someone on the web recommended it, so: Duh! It smells and tastes like soy sauce. The guy who owns SV also ones Edradour, which added to the disappointment.
Mine is Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition. It smells so damn amazing. Delicate fruits like pears, apples, and banana. Maybe but tasting it there is no fruit at all. In fact, all I taste is barrel char. I made an old fashioned and the char even overpowered my old fashioned. Now I mix it 50/50 with 15 year Dickel and the sweet vitamin flavor (which I like) knocks the char down to a tolerable amount.
I usually try and do "research" on trial drams at the bar first but some are just unavailable. Paul John Bold was really good at the bar maybe I didn't have enough or something because the bottle I got was fairly harsh and meh the whole way through pretty much. Luckily I finished it so I could justify replacing it with the Amrut Fusion - SUPER GOOD! Definitely lives up to it's good reputation.Other bottles I don't regret but just wonder "what if" are great ones stuck at 40% like Hibiki Harmony and Laphroaig 10 (although I do want to try the CS at some point as I hear it's god-tier stuff). Angel's envy was good but I felt a little overpriced for the bottle.
I have a couple, Old tub has a better use of being a target on a shooting range. Broken barrel peated whiskey is also absolutely horrid. Luckily they are not super expensive.
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.82[2/2] เมาท์มอยกับ 3 สาวเพื่อนซี้ ที่พร้อมขยี้พ่อหมีได้ทุกเมื่อ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Wwn7WnylNtQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Just like everybody else, I've had some not-so-good whiskies, but I can't say that I regretted buying them. If anything, I would've probably regretted not buying them and wonder forever "what if". I stay away though from cool looking decanters; they're most likely compensating for something.
Good list. We don't only need top 5 or top 10 whisky lists but also ones like these so that we know what to avoid!
Completely agree!
I would say my most regretted purchases would be the Dalmore range in general. It happened back in my early days of collecting, so I didn’t know better, but Dalmore King Alexander III at 40% was not worth $300… That applies to the rest of their range too, since I have bought and tried them all (not necessarily a good thing).
I'm so glad that someone shares the same opinion of Dalmores. Dross...
I’m gunna be honest I love Irish Whiskey, it’s my favorite I’ve tried so many and love so many…but some 5-8 year old Irish Whiskey is some of the best I’ve ever had. I look at how young Waterford is and seriously appreciate what they are doing. Youth doesn’t mean bad but there is a whole lot of bad young whiskey.
redbreast 12 is one of my favorites
There is a slight hissing sound. You probably need to hit the noise reduction button. Here is my list: (1) ALL of the Connemarra, the Cask Strength is worse that the 12. They taste like gasoline. (2) Glyph Molecular Whisky. To call this "whisky" is an insult to whisky. (3) Sonoma Bourbon Whiskey. It is too damn young, tastes like pencil shavings. (4) Dingle Irish Whiskey, batch 4. I think it may be corked but Whisky Jason in Germany had similar notes. It is just nasty. (5) Proper Twelve. It is 100% pure shite.
Yea I was in a big hurry today. Totally forgot to clean up the audio
Truth be told, the risk of having Buyer's Remorse grows exponentially past about $60 with Scotch, past $100 it's more likely than not. With bourbon & rye, the remorse sets in past $40, and the entire category tops out at about $70 IMHO.
I think past 40 is where you get into the best bourbons
That is why I pay 100 dollars a year for an SMWS membership. They have a wide selection of single cask, age stated scotch and other spirits. I have had a few that I didn't get on with as well but that is a matter of my taste, not the quality of the product.
Totally agree. I partnered with them because their stuff is awesome!
@@billmonteith1161 I'm familiar with them, and perhaps I'll join someday, but I can't justify it right now. They have some decently-priced bottles given their pedigrees, but they still aren't inexpensive...generally speaking.
I know Scotch better than Bourbon, so for under $60 I can find peated gems like Ardbeg 10, Ledaig 10, and possibly Port Charlotte 10, and I can find unpeated ones like Craigellachie 13, Bunnahabhain 12, Deanston 12, and Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban 14. I'd argue that between those bottles you have about 90+% of what the entire category of Scotch Single Malt has to offer ✌️
There's been many whiskies I've not enjoyed but never regretted just due to the fact that deep down I'd always wonder what it could have been if I never ended up trying it. As with all life's disappointments I try to learn from them and figure out what I didn't like so I don't go for bottles like that again. I refer to these bottles as Monday sippers, they may not be enjoyable but they'll teach you something of value.... Or just taste bad. Either way cheers and I enjoyed this video, would love to see one of whiskeys you wish you bought sooner!
Great idea for a video!
My first ever bourbon was Elijah Craig Small Batch($50 CDN) and I loved it. A few months later I saw a bottle of Angels Envy($80 CDN) and bought it. It looks better than it tastes. I now have a bottle that my friends enjoy more than I do. I just thought my 2nd bottle would be better than my 1st. Live and learn.
Apparently the Barrel Proof is much, much better.
Thank you for a fun review list 🤗
I did make my regretable buys when I just started out exploring whisky, but then I didn't know that, because I didn't have anything to compare it with. Most of the regrets were bottom shelf blends. But there were definitely some that I would buy today, just to enjoy a no-brainer whisky.
After that I started to watch ALOT of videos of Daniel and Rex, and Horst Luening, just to get a bit more oriented in the whisky universe. After that I started to make more well thought out choises. I started to follow more whiskytubers in both whisky and bourbon universe that seemed to have about the same taste as I have, along with really educational and fun videos made by warm personality whiskytubers like yourself 🤗
So the ones I regret now isn't many at all.
But I was a bit dissatisfied with Glen Moray Peated, HP12, Talisker Storm, Jura 12, Buffalo Trace, Bulleit Bourbon.
They're not bad, but didn't tickle me the right way 🙃
Interesting. I think the only one from your list I'd disagree with was the Talisker... but the 10 is better so I can see your point
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary
Thanks for your reply.
Yes the 10yo is definitely better. But for me I rather choose T. Skye over Storm. Skye for me is more similar to 10yo, but not as complex and deep in the notes.
Storm for me is a bit "hollow" in lack for better word. I think the peat/smoke notes is separate to the rest of the notes. They're not as intertwined as I like the notes to be.
Sky isn't available in my area sadly
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary
Hope you'll find it some day. I think it has a good value for what it is 🤗
Four roses small batch select. Tastes like prechewed spearmint gum
Those samurai and Chinese decanters are pretty wild to have on a shelf even if the contents are crap. My wife has bought me a few howlers with Crabbies Yardhead being the worst “single malt” I’ve ever tasted.
I really liked the regular 1792 as an everyday drinker. I think I drank half the bottle the first night. Worst bourbon I ever bought was Jefferson’s very small batch. It is like drinking heavily Oaked piss. Would rather drink military star bourbon.
Glenfiddich 21. Rum cask. 40%. Nothing wrong with the taste. But just meh..
Prefer the Balvenie 14 at half the price.
Wild turkey : Took me a long time to finish, and stopped me from even trying the 101 for a long time, which i love
Glenmorangie 12 ( could not finish bottle)
Tomatin 12 ( could not finish bottle)
There’s a reason why marketing works. Most whiskies above the $75.00 threshold aren’t dissimilar from less expensive ones. The liquid inside is nothing but hype. Usually. Stick with whiskey $30-60 and you ll never be disappointed.
Jefferson’s Voyage 26 is the only one I’ve tried. Had it at a bar in Kentucky and it was actually delicious. I’ve tried to find a bottle of that specific voyage but had no luck.
I’m a few years into whisky and still don’t often spend more than £40-£50 on a bottle. I’m still learning what I like and there’s plenty of good whisky below and around this price point. I’ve had the occasional whisky that’s disappointed but it doesn’t hurt my wallet too much at these prices.
Same.
I consider myself as a starter in whisky terms and aiming for those bellow 50$ mark up until when i'll be more prone to try those > 50$ whiskys.
I couldn’t agree more man. I try to finish every bottle before I buy another one too if I can. Whisky is so volatile, along with the numerous factors that influence our perceptions. I feel like I haven’t given something a decent chance unless I finish it. And to be honest some whiskies do better as a good mouthful swirled and chewed not just sipped to find their characteristics
I have a 1972 SiB that I feel the same way. Ive gotten a couple bottles that have set me apart. A 21-05 MMCS I got noses fantastic drinks sour. Also sometimes buying cheap will bite you like Buskers Green label and Johnny Walker Red. I have had good luck with some $100 whiskeys and haven't been disappointed yet, but I know its coming haha.
I’m a huge fan of the 1792 bib I think it’s the sweet spot for the brand. Full proof is just too hot and grainy. The store picks though 🤤
Join the club. I've bought several whiskeys that I regret buying. The two that stand out to Me are The Singleton single malt Next to undrinkable, straight or mixed. The only reason I keep drinking it is I paid good money for it. Also Glen Moray Port cask finish. Again expected a decent flavor and nose . No such luck.A harsh flavor and no aroma.
I think you got a skunked bottle of 1792 BIB. I just poured some and it’s a nice everyday supper. Not too complex but great balance.
Had lots of great Ardbegs, but my Wee Beastie took a bite out of me..
2 come to mind. 1:black bottle, although not disgusting, it's a flat peated blend. 2:Nikka Days, not expensive, but so light, you'll think it's whisky-flavoured lemonade.
Like or Dislike: Like. Like virtually all TH-cam viewers, I'm a sucker for titles that promise an exciting rant, and this video delivers on that promise.
I regret buying only one Proper 12. Some other whiskeys I probably will never buy again but it's good for the experience.
This comment confuses me. Are you not able to get more Proper 12? I mean... Im not suggesting you do... just seems strange to regret it
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary no sorry, I meant to say I'm regretting buying Proper 12.
Oooo I get it. Phew. Was about to ask you kindly, but firmly, to leave
My Disappointments are Arran Sauternes, Almost every Glenmorangie,Arran Amarone, Cragganmore 12, Connemara 12, Tyrconell, Jim Beam Double oak, West Cork malt, Monkey Shoulder blended whisky.
Try Indian grain whiskey and you will appreciate these ones
Really appreciate this and I agree with the Jefferson's. Not impressed with their products.
Gotta becareful with Japanese whisky, some is complete crap. Shibui and Matsui are pour down the drain after the first sip. Stick with Nikka and Suntory.
This is a fun idea! One that comes to mind is the Maker's Mark Cinnamon Dolce, the distillery exclusive. It didn't taste bad, but i liked Maker's 46 a lot more, and it's less than half the price
Good video, thanks for posting it. I have only two purchases I regret: The Famous Grouse Smokey Black. I like some whiskeys (bourbons and Scotches, etc.) better than others, but so far the Smokey Black is the only whiskey I have actively disliked. Next is Johnnie Walker Black Label. Just disappointing, and it was relegated to be a mixer along with the JW Red Label.
Funny you've just given 2 of your worse whiskeys that are my father's favourites
@@andrewplayer4407 different tastes make for better horse racing! 😊 I don’t DISlike JW Black Label, it just disappointed me.
I'm not all that far into whiskey, maybe tried 110+ different ones. But I have had three major disappointments so far, and thankfully they didn't cost an arm and a leg.
1. Auchentoshan American Oak - After enjoying this with a friend at a bar years and years ago, I felt nostalgic and bought a bottle on offer. I hated this. Barrel bitter, too young, very ethanol-driven. Ended up using it when frying minced beef, where it imparted some welcome notes of sweetness. But really hated this otherwise.
2. Kinahan's Small Batch - "An Irish whiskey at 46%? Count me in!", I thought. Yeah, well, this thing tasted of soap and cardboard, somehow. I tried water, letting it aerate, nothing helped. It was quite simply the worst whisky I'd ever had up to that point.
3. Bunnahabhain Eirigh Na Greine - it was on offer, and I loved Bunna 12, so I wanted to try different expressions. The red wine dominates and not in a good way. It is tannic, astringent, and doesn't even take water that well. I've since tried the Cruach Mhona (decent, the peat is kinda minty somehow) and the An Cladach (decent balance of bourbon and sherry flavors), and really wish I had gone for the Toiteach a Dha or Stiuredair instead of the Eirigh Na Greine.
Generally speaking, I'm still looking for a German whiskey that hits my palate. I've been thoroughly underwhelmed thus far.
Just watched this Video and I agree with the comment there are more Whiskey's I regret NOT Buying 10X more than ones I regret Buying. The biggest recent regret is Bunnahabhain An Cladach Travel Exclusive. I LOVE Bunn 12 so was looking forward to this. Got home and Meh. The salt in the wound comes from you get ONE CHOICE ON the way back at Duty Free. Should have picked up either of the other travel exclusives JD Single Barrel 100proof or WT 12.
I learned very early into my alcohol buying adventure to NEVER buy based on the bottle or "story" and many times if I see too much of a story I just put it back on the shelf because most of the time a story just means its inadequate and they are trying to get you to want to like it versus just liking it. If I want a cool bottle I look for that in a vodka or rum that can be buried into cocktails.
Also, when I m looking at buying an expensive bottle I ll call around to a few local bars and ask if they have it and try a pour before buying a bottle. Id rather pay for an expensive pour then buying the bottle if I like it then having an 80 dollar bottle of disgusting. This plan has saved me money in the long run because worse case scenario you are out 8-20 dollars versus 20-100 dollars.
Trying at a bar has always been a great solution to the $100 unknown problem
I don't feel like this is a crazy one, but I found the Elijah Craig 18 very disappointing. It's not bad, but I didn't think it offered a ton over the standard EC and couldn't justify it's 5X price. Price aside, I prefer the ECBP. Still a fun one to have in the collection.
I’ve had three regular 1792s, 2 were very good 1 was off profile & I did not enjoy it. I recently got a store pick & it’s outstanding. If you can find one(even a regular bottle) at a good price which is around $40 I would still recommend it- may be some minor issues with consistency.. Kaiyo cask strength finished in Mizenura - very good!
Did not like Buffalo Trace (albeit a store pick) and did not like Eagle Rare 10. Everyone seems to go wild for BT distilled stuff but they are 0/2 for me.
Its because its smooth and neutral
@@LeatherDaddy97 There definitely was no "it" factor. I prefer Wild Turkey, Four Roses, Elijah Craig... pretty much I've found other bourbons enjoyable compared to BT core.
@@tsubakichan ive found im not a four roses fan, but definitely agree on turkey and elijah craig. I prefer both to buffalo trace.
Disappointments have included Glen Moray Chardonnay Cask, 1792 Small Batch (banana), Barrell Dovetail (I didn't like it outright, but the $100 price made it a very poor purchase indeed), Old Forester 1910 (especially considering how good 1920 is), Stranahan's Single Malt, Woodford Reserve Wheat (I love wheated, but hated this).
Most new NAS Japanese Whiskies of the past 4+ years are bad IMHO (better stick to the Coffey Malt/Grain and the Nikka from the Barrel).
Mizunara - 'a fairly old' means around 200 years old )))
I don't regret buying, but rather here's my bitter disappointment list:
1. Glenmorangie D'or. I had Sauternes wine, it was truly the nectar of gods, but whiskey was more burn and alcohol than taste. Perhaps my expectations were just too high.
2. Hyde No 5 The Aras Cask. It's just pure nail polish on a nose and a palate. You'll be better off with vodka. I don't even dare to try any other of their products.
3. Robert Burns Single Malt from Arran. It may taste relatively OK, but holy crap! We didn't even finish the bottle with my friend and we both had one of the worst hangovers ever. It's like Arran didn't wanna all the heads and tales from the good stuff go to waste. The bottle was purchased from a reputable source tho and it doesn't make sense to make a crappy copy of such unpopular and mostly unknown whiskey that even if someone's gonna buy it, it'll be a once in a lifetime experience. Didn't even get buzzed. Never again.
4. Fujimi - just a fancy overpriced mixer.
5. This one is seriously unfortunate coz I love peat. I'm not a whiskey expert by any means, that's probably why Ardbeg Uigedail and Corryvreckan as well as Talisker Dark Storm felt like just a stronger versions of a standard 10 year old, but for a significantly higher price. They are fine peat-bombs by any means, but I expected a little more. Perhaps I'm just spoiled by Octomore, coz that thing is just.. can't really put it into words.
Avoided regrets: I bought a shot of Macallan 12 in a bar and happy that I didn't spent 60+ eur on a whole bottle.
Matsui is known for not using Japanese whisky and yes, avoid Yamato! My most disappointing whiskies have been Green Spot which was really bland and a 1996 Signatory bottling of Clynelish that had been aged in a sulfurous cask.
so far i have thankfully not had anything that was so bad i had to pour it down the sink. But i was alittle let down with the glenfeddich 12 nice full fruity aroma and no substance. Same with the johnnie walker High rye, had really light on taste that only lasted like 2-3 seconds then flat water.
On another note, my current best and favorite was an Elija Craig 18Year. It was $360 but i WOULD NOT hesitate to buy another bottle or 2 if i find it again. It was like a super smooth creamy vanilla ice cream, nose was the same to me, it was just enjoyable all the way around. If you see one i highly recommend getting it.
Thank you for this. I was so disappointed that the New Hampshire liquor stores ran out of Glenmorangie 'Cake' before I could get a bottle. I am SO relieved that it was nothing but marketing nonsense!
Hate to say it, but the Cake was good... the Winter wasn't.
Love the video as always.
First let me start off by saying I’m a Scotch Lover, but I have a bottle of Buffalo Trace that I was saving for today. That being said I have to say... I’m not a fan. Like many other comments from your viewers I can’t say I regret it because at least I can say I tried it. I will occasionally have a bourbon but I expected soooo much more.
Laphroaig price and the peat was the only note. Say, overstated.
I've had a few disappointments that I won't buy again: Definitely agree with you about Jefferson's Ocean, and I'll also add their Small Batch to the list too. I'm also not a fan of: Blade and Bow, Basil Hayden's Kentucky Straight, Four Roses Single Barrel, Nelson's Green Briar, Willett Pot Still Reserve, and Woodinville straight bourbon. I found each of them to either be boring or just to sharp of an alcohol blast / single dimensional.
Connemara is my #1 least enjoyed whisky lmao. I literally have had a bottle sitting on my shelf for 8 years without being served other than when i want to have a laugh at people bc no one enjoys that bottle. Great video man
Timely topic as I just pulled a handful of bottles to give away because I can't stand them and I'm done trying to like them. I've tried to see if any of these got better over time so I"ve tasted them all about 3 times now, but nope they still don't do it for me. Bowman Brothers, Rebel Yell 100, Mayor Pingree Red Label, a Larceny pick and a Tumblin' Dice pick. Chattanooga port cask and Isaac Bowman. I really like Woodinville Port finished, but every single other port finished whiskey I have had has a terrible burnt rubber note.
I happen to have a 1792 BiB pick and it's been sitting at just over half full for almost 2 years now. I just don't have any desire to go back to it.
You are the reason why I haven't bought Connemara 12, eventhough I really like the regular Connemara. Something similar happened to me with the Maker's 46 and Larceny. Both of these bourbons cost me double of what the basic Maker's is. But they are not twice as good. I was also disappointed by Glencadam 15. A good whisky, but why did I pay as much as I did...
You're doing yourself a service!
Little Book ch 5, Penelope toasted heavy toast, Shenks, nulu toasted, any smoke wagon, weller single barrel... All regrets
Taste is always subjective. The only one so far is Haig clubman with orange, I looked at it so many times and finally took it home and it was awful. The fake orange overpowered everything and is undrinkable
I'm a big fan of Old Gran Dad 114, and since I usually water it down to tame the heat, I thought I'd try the regular 80 proof under the assumption that it would still be good and I wouldn't have to add water to drink it. Bottom line is that the regular Old Grand Dad is one watery bourbon--weak flavor and thin mouthfeel. Think of Jim Beam White Label watered down to 40 proof. I only paid around 20 bucks for it and I still feel ripped off.
I did the Jeff small batch because of all the hype & it was cheap. Verdict ... little better than colored water.
Just bought this yesterday. I entirely agree with your description. Never tasted such a bland bourbon.
@@burkec33 That $23 dollars would have been better sunk into Wild Turkey 101. Can't beat tha Turk! Journey goes far and wide, always circles back somehow to that fabulous drinkable bird ... Wild Turkey. Believe it! Cheers .....
@@jamesnorwood4084 Unfortunately, I paid almost $40 for that swill. Totally agree with you in WT101. It grew on me as I drank more of it. Now you are making me want another bottle ….
Never tried the 1792 BiB but I do like the Full Proof when I can find it at under $50
00:35 Connemara 12: Bought it in Germany for around 45 USD equivalent.
For that price I consider it decent (but nothing special)
Agreed on the 1792, and I've always been curious about Jefferson's ocean. lately been going with Russell's reserve cause its pretty cheap in Hi.
I have a store pick Ocean. I like it but I'm not finding anything from the voyage influence. I caught it on sale luckily. If I paid full price I would regret it but I do enjoy it enough where I'm Ok with it but wish it had an obvious character
Nope. 1792 BIB is crap in my opinion. I've had a couple of store picks and I didn't find them any better. Great vid.
Thanks! Glad to get some support!
Smokehead, I tried it while having a great night at a bar with a friend, which may have influenced my enjoyment. I bought a bottle, and at home realised there's not a lot going on under the smoke.
The cask strength is good
Nikka days , it's not a bad whiskey but I like very bold obvious flavours .
In comparison from the barrel is just super thick and juicy and even my uneducated buds good taste and feel the difference. Even beam/suntory etc being the most Japanese yet Glasgow written on the bottle loses its magic a little. English version of laphroaig 10 and buffalo trace watered to 40% made these more average also
I wasn't a fan of my 1792 BIB pick, it was just okay. Now the two different 1792 FP picks I have are great!
Cant say that people should avoid the whisky that I don’t like. One thing I learned in Scotland vacations is that everyone has a different palate. The whisk which I think are terrible are loved by others.
Johnnie Walker Black label was a big disappointment for me, and the one that surprised me that I liked at first but quickly got to a sort of regret was the Deanston Virgin Oak. I had heard nothing but good things about the virgin oak, it seemed like a cool idea (did make a decent old fashioned though), but the whisky itself just didn't do it for me after a few pours. Luckily not an expensive bottle.
My friend bought 4 Bttls.The Yamazaki 35 Year Old Single Malt Whisky five years ago about per bottle $7k at
Total wine
The Matsui you have I think is a bad batch or counterfeit, as its a VERY young whisky, and yours appears to be far too dark compared to what's on my shelf, which is so pale it could be mistaken (by a novice) for new make. Matsui has real potential...and comparing its capturing of Mizunara to Glendalough-13 I think is unfair and almost bordering on category mistake as the Irish whiskey spent 92% of its time in ex-bourbon, whereas the cask interaction of matsui w/ mizunara is exclusive. Apart from this, thanks for the great post
I've been there before. As long as you don't tell your wife how much it costs, it doesn't actually count.
Life Pro Tips
Couldn’t agree more on that 1792
The worst mistake I made so far was a Bulleit 123.4 barrel proof bourbon. It was only $40 so no big loss financially but the flavor was like drinking a Hall's cough drop. I had heard Bulleit rye was really good so I thought the barrel proof bourbon would be a for sure thing. And I won't say I will never buy any Bulleit products again either, just a little bit leary at this point. BTW I drank it all anyway lol! OGD114 was another one that I didn't like. What's strange about that is that the flavor profile was great but even a small pour gave me a headache every time I tried it. Not sure why but it's something I wouldn't buy again.
Here's a thought, sir: why not do something Ralfy suggested in one of his videos: create an "Infinity" blend out of these 6 bottles? I know some are whisky, some bourbon (what''s the real difference?) and such but if you're not interested in drinking them anymore but don't want to throw them out why not just combine them into one blend - just for the experiment of it - and try drinking that? You might get lucky and create something really good (or really awful). I think that'd be a hoot~! Let us know if you decide to try this
There are several ways to dispose whiskey you hate:
1. Give away to your friends who don't give af and drink everything that burns.
2. Use it for cooking.
3. My favorite: if you like peat, just get the cheapest heavily peated whiskey like Laphroaig Select or Ardbeg Wee Beastie and mix it one to one.
From experience making a fancy concoction even from good whiskeys fails 9 times out of 10. I always end up just 'peating' up my infinity bottles.
I too made the Connemara 12 mistake
Why didn't your video come out a month sooner!?!?! But I think the whiskey I most regret buying are the ones on my shelf that I just don't want to drink. They were paths and directions in the journey of finding what I like and enjoy but they aren't all winners. Sad but true.
I have a video on connemara 12. Learn from this. Always check the dic first :)
Great video!!! Thankfully I haven't had any of those. I had the regular Connemara which was my induction to peat. But since my love is now Port Charlotte 10. Connemara is just mehhh 😂😂
Cheers Bill!!!
Mmm Port Charlotte 10
If you like port Charlotte, Kikkoman 100% Islay will be a great purchase
Love the channel, you helped me get into whiskeys during the beginning of the pandemic. Id love to see reviews on Michters American Whiskey, Russels Reserve Single Barrel, and Knob Creek 120 Proof Single Barrel. All stock its from me and would love to hear your opinion.
Good to hear. I have a couple of those on hand. I'll get to it sooner than later!
For me it was Longbranch from Wild Turkey and Pinhook the whisky that looks like a wine bottle. Longbranch just is not good and pinhook I had in a really good old fashion at a Bar so I picked up a bottle. should have keep my money on both!
I'm totally surprised by the 1792 Bottled In Bond. It's supposed to be aged for a at least 4 years, in new oak. How could they go wrong?
I've heard a lot of people tell me that I may have a bad bottle. Enough so that I think I do. Apparently the single barrel releases are spectacular
Great video. I am with you on the Yamato. I bought their special edition cask strength, which was less than 50%,decanter bottle. It was horrible. I also disliked the Jack Daniels Gold, and the Whistle Pig Roadstock. Major let downs.
Whitelpig roadstock was one I've heard bad things about too. Bummer.
And what kind of CS is under 50%?
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary The Yamato special edition says its cask strength at 43% which is a joke. But I still gave it a try lol. The bottle is absolutely beautiful. It's heavy clear cut glass reminiscent of lead crystal decanters.
Jeez... 43% cask strength? Maybe they added water before aging :)!
I just saw Glenmorangie's newest "Tale of" whisky - "A Tale of the Forest." I'm hoping it's more exciting than "Winter"!
I bought it! Hoping to review it in the next couple of weeks. I'm super backlogged right now!
Here is another one folks are going to disagree with, but I bought a bottle of Knob Creek 9 Cask Strength and was very disappointed. I am no stranger to cask strength and like many offerings, however I found it to be almost undrinkable (alcohol and burnt caramel is all I got). It was not super expensive, but since I can't drink and enjoy it it is a regret. I know many people enjoy it though.
I'm very very early into this whisk(e)y journey and so far the only one I regret is a Jameson IPA tester - it might as well have been bath water. Fortunately everything else I've purchased so far has at least been good and a number are excellent. All this information that's out here on these interwebs is really useful ! Thank you.
Yea im not a big fan of Jameson IPA either
Any with the wine finishes. I fine as if they just pour wine into most of the whiskey instead of it being a "finish"
I had a few... Maker's Mark was meh! Dalmore 12 and Balvenie Double wood was meh and also overpriced here in Finland. Don't get me wrong, these are fine whiskies but for me a bit dull at the price. Glendalough double barrel had a weird palate at first (like burnt clutch) but when the bottle got older it openned really nice to be that sweet single pot triple stilled irish doing nothing more what Jameson wouldn't do about 10€ less/bottle. I have to admit that many whiskies came dull to me after Lagavulin 16 but some are also bit too harsh for me like Ardbeg ten and those two octomores I've tasted. I have high hopes for Port Charlotte 10 and Ardbeg Uigeadail. Peace and love.
Agreed with the balvenie doublewood
Yeah, makers mark has a very strange taste thats hard to get past.
My biggest mistake was Lot 40. I tried every possible way to finnish that bottle...only splash of Ardbeg 10 over powered the taste of dill pickle. Just bad bad whisky for me. #whiskeyregret
In order:
1. Jim Beam Single Barrel. Holy $h!7 was this a bad whiskey. It was all the worst parts of Jim Beam turned up to 11. This became exclusively a cocktail bottle to get it off my shelf quickly.
2.Angel's Envy. Everyone talked about how great it was and it was awful. Wife and I both hated it. Weird bitter note (not barrel tannin bitter, think more like chemical bitter) that ruined the rest of what was a pretty bog-standard bourbon. It would have been completely unremarkable except for that strange bitter note. I was so, so thankful I got it at Costco and didn't pay full price for it. Ended up using it almost exclusively in coffee to help bury the off-putting flavors.
3. Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 24. Vorage 23 was pretty good, if a little unremarkable given the price, but especially in an A-B comparison with more traditional bourbons the Voyage 23 had some very clear briny notes and other flavors that set it apart. But the 24 just isn't good at any price.
4. I didn't buy it with my own money, but the Breckenridge bourbon. I get more interesting flavors out of an $18 bottle of Evan Williams BiB than anything I got out of the $60 bottle of Breckenridge. Not a BAD whiskey, but not even close to worth the price.
5. Redemption Bourbon and Rye. Just completely uninteresting MGP products. I've had good MGP whiskies. These are not in that group.
Also, as you guessed in your video, I have to take issue with the 1792 BiB being on your list. I found it to have a lot of leathery, earthy, and woody notes in it that I really enjoyed, with not a lot of the traditional sweet bourbon characteristics. Their full proof is good, the small batch is ok, and the sweet wheat is meh. But I love the unique flavor profile of the BiB. It's so unlike most other bourbons, which I really appreciate. Haven't seen it on a shelf here in months which makes me sad, but it's on my list of "Buy it when I see it."
So funny. I almost wonder if I just got a bad bottle...
@@TheWhiskeyDictionary maybe? I wondered that about the Angel’s Envy since everyone seemed to love it, but I tried it at a bar in another state and found that same bitter note. Entirely possible that the 1792 just doesn’t jibe with your palate for whatever reason.
I've had Jameson as someone recommended. The taste of it felt so metallic on my pallate, not at all gingerbread taste that everyone said it had. I had the feeling something was off with my taste buds, tried it again different occasion, same result, Jameson for me definitely a no no...
Try Jameson Black Barrell, it doesn't have that
@@Piface2099 i will, but i don't think i will buy a whole bottle...
Agreed!
First ive heard someone saw jameson tastes like gingerbread
Jameson is awful and gives me terrible headaches every time i try it no other booze does this
I don’t like the Barton profile and hate the 1792 small batch I have. (Picked up the bib and FP today at total wine hoping they are different). I regret the peerless bourbon I bought, just tastes like rubbing alcohol. Discovery series 4 was a huge disappointment and it sits almost full in the corner to this day. And finally, Sam houston 15 (I got 2 bottles at secondary pricing and the longer I have it the more I taste that Barton funk)… should have gotten a second remus V instead of that SH15.
I agree with most of your takes but I really like my bottle of Tale of Winter. Also, I've never had a bad bottle of 1792 Bottled in Bond. I love it. Could your bottle be corked? I get lots of banana from the bottles I've purchased. Nevertheless, you have a great channel! Regarding peated Irish, Teeling BlackPitts. Don't you agree that it's wonderful?
I absolutely love Teeling Blackpitts! And ye, regarding my 1792, I'm starting to wonder if I just got a bad bottle...
The only reason 1792 doesn't make my regret list is that it's no more expensive than Jack Daniels Single Barrel or SiB BP. It taste almost the same but is less viscous (I prefer the JD). As for my most regretted bottles, I would say Hudson Baby Bourbon, and believe it or not, the 2017 release of George T. Stagg for which I unfortunately paid over $400. It sits on my shelf for whiskey knowledgeable guests to try but it just wasn't any good to me. I also think Blanton's Straight From the Barrel is not that great.... What I've learned is that I get very selective on bourbons that get above $100 (pre-inflation prices). They generally aren't that special over a $40-$80 bourbon. Scotch has so much more variety for the money.
Absolutely agree with you about Tale Of Winter me and my brother picked up a wierd sour baby vomit note on the nose which burned into my brain lol
I bought a bottle of Tobasco-flavored Dickel solely for the reason that it was on sale for $6. I quickly understood why it was on sale for $6. I never thought I’d ever be so upset with a $6 purchase, but I was tempted to take it back to the store and attempt to return it out of principle. I didn’t even want to disrespect the weeds in my yard by using it to kill them, so I keep it on my shelf as a prank bottle to give shots to my friends. Tobasco Dickel makes Fireball seem like Glenlivet 18.
Wow... thats a bold statement. I've thought of buying it a few times but nope...
Everyone of your subscribers will be able to form a list of the naff whiskys they have bought/tried. Its part of the journey. Not everyone will label it 'regret' but for sure everyone experiences whisky disappointment ! (Dalmore expressions for more... Not a fan)
Does the 1792 bottled in bond taste like the old Very Old Barton bottled in bond? My theory is that they stopped producing VOB BIB so they could make more money by putting it in pricier 1792 bottles.
Unfortunately I don't have them side by side so hard to know
Tamnavulin Red Wine Cask Cabernet Sauvignon was the worst I had.
Larceny, just the normal bottle of Larceny is probably the worst standard offering I've ever bought. It just smells of straight nail polish remover, it's bitter, it doesn't have any redeeming qualities. I gave up trying to drink it and demoted it to cooking bourbon.
Writer's Tears is the only thing currently on my shelf that I "regret". Way too floral for my taste. Like drinking a Glenncairn of perfume.
Dingle Singe Malt, batch 4... what HAPPENED there?! Regret for sure.
Definitely agree, I think they used a crappy sherry or port cask on that one. I've had worse, but not worth that price tag.
I've had a few disappointments and stinkers, but none that have cost much so far. I'll start with Haig Club Single Grain Scotch Whisky, terrible stuff, even as a mixer you need to literally drown it or cover it up with bitters to make it palatable. Next up Yamazakura Blended Whisky roughly the same price as Suntory Toki but makes Haig Club seem like an upgrade. Finally for most disappointing; Weller Special Reserve. It's not really bad just bland. Tastes like a very muted or faded Eagle Rare 10. There's just not enough going on to make it a sipper but it does a solid job as a mixer. I paid it $40 CAD which is pretty cheap, but still feel I overpaid. At that price there's so many better options like Elijah Craig Small Batch, Maker's Mark, even Bulleit!
None of late comes to mind (I'm more discerning now I guess), but a number of disappoiting Signatory Vintages bottlins in the golden (chill-filtered) and silver (non-chillfiltered) tubes come to mind, like an Imperial 16YO. Actually there's a more recent one that I remember, their Edradour 2011 (10YO) that is matured in sherry casks from beginning to end. Someone on the web recommended it, so: Duh! It smells and tastes like soy sauce. The guy who owns SV also ones Edradour, which added to the disappointment.
Ouch. I had the Jefferson Ocean Voyage CS 13 and hated it. Regretted paying 100 for it too. Can’t wait to see the Glenmorangie Tale Of Woe.
Lol. Tale of woe
Mine is Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition. It smells so damn amazing. Delicate fruits like pears, apples, and banana. Maybe but tasting it there is no fruit at all. In fact, all I taste is barrel char. I made an old fashioned and the char even overpowered my old fashioned. Now I mix it 50/50 with 15 year Dickel and the sweet vitamin flavor (which I like) knocks the char down to a tolerable amount.
Interesting list. I almost thought your Sinatra Jack Daniels would make it to the list as a "not worth it".
It's not worth it, but it's not offensively so
What are some whiskies you regret buying for whatever reason?
Check out my second channel! th-cam.com/users/DungeonsAndDrams
dead guy whiskey was absolutely terrible for me.
that and the standard loch lomand were drain pours
Sensei. It was an impulse buy and I later learned it was not 100% Japanese
I usually try and do "research" on trial drams at the bar first but some are just unavailable. Paul John Bold was really good at the bar maybe I didn't have enough or something because the bottle I got was fairly harsh and meh the whole way through pretty much. Luckily I finished it so I could justify replacing it with the Amrut Fusion - SUPER GOOD! Definitely lives up to it's good reputation.Other bottles I don't regret but just wonder "what if" are great ones stuck at 40% like Hibiki Harmony and Laphroaig 10 (although I do want to try the CS at some point as I hear it's god-tier stuff). Angel's envy was good but I felt a little overpriced for the bottle.
I have a couple,
Old tub has a better use of being a target on a shooting range.
Broken barrel peated whiskey is also absolutely horrid. Luckily they are not super expensive.
The Nikka Coffey Grain Japanese Whiskey total garbage