@@rajendrabareto8065 Yes, OBC and Dalits are expoiting GC, taking way opportunities of education, job and life. And funnily, they still have guts to say we are oppressed. This is really Kaliyuga.
Even modern society is following caste system popes priests, military, businessman, labours/employees. Society cannot function without Varna. But Hindu concept of Karma and God in all living beings as all pervading consciousness is the only way we can avoid discrimination for peace, prosperity and spirituality.
You have to find how many Dalits have performed honor killing coz their child fell in love with upper caste. You need a reality check. Moreover find out casteism within Dalits. Ambedkar belonged to Mahar Dalits and his community considers Mang Dalits lower in hierarchy n untouchables.
@@r.b.8018 Yes caste system is biggest pblm in India, everyone wants to abolish reservation, if caste is the root cause for reservation, why there's no movement to abolish caste system? Everyone is Hindu, we worship same god, culture is same(with some changes depending on location) . Reservation are in only in job and education apart from that in sports, entertainment industry u get only few who are succeeded that can be counted with bare hands. Even in the entry stages in sports, entertainment industry etc they ask "which caste are u?" If he or she belongs to lower caste,they don't even let he/she go further , that's y u don't even know anyone in sports, entertainment industry etc who are from lower caste. All we need is social respect, banning caste system will provide that, later reservation can be given on the basis of Income.
@@takeshikovaich8824 I wish I could sue u for lying like a mf. Neither in sports nor in entertainment industry ppl ask abt caste. Caste is not even needed until we pass class 12 and enter college, coz from there merit dies n caste reservation starts. So shut up. I’m a Dalit. Hve been into sports all my life. Never once had anybody asked me abt my caste. Nor once i was ever barred from entering any temples. My caste came into okay when I applied for engg colleges and then jobs for govt sector. Now get lost.
He is not talking about abolishing reservation. He is talking about improving the reservation system by providing reservation on the basis of individuals. Whats the problem with that. Billionaires getting reservation on the basis is right?? Or people in need
@@chinmayhegde615 then why don't u say just demolish caste system properly, remove caste word from all entrance forms and every kind of form and then apply reservation system on the basis of occupation and wtever...? It would be a easy option..
@@archigoel The guy is privileged and didn't experienced casteism how it's feel like to be on the receiving end of the oppressing system. It's just like asking Britishers how to run india Or How to end racism to a white guy.
He exited the country when the country made laws to generalise on caste reservations. He left the country when he saw low marks earning brainless people sitting on top of talented people, as bosses, just because they have a caste certificate. He left the country when Indira Gandhi brought a law to snatch farmer lands, especially the APMC act and the genocide of Brahmins in Konkani coast done by the so called non-violence supporters who wanted to avenge Gandhi's death.. you guys crib so much about mob lynching.. lemme tell you that after the horrific partition, the very first mob-lynch of a big public figure, that happened, was when an innocent doctor Nanarao Savarkar was lynched and killed in public by these so called Gandhians, just because he was Veer Savarkar's brother. And they call Savarkar a apologist, the reality is every second or third letter which Nehru and Gandhi have written to the British, ends with "your most faithful and obedient servant of the British Empire, MK Gandhi".. and why wasn't any Congress leader ever sent to Kala Pani jail in Andaman? You say highly privileged family, but the fact is, check his family condition in India before leaving to US.. He left the country because the laws in the country compromised with talent, instead of honouring legitimate talent based on examinations.. and don't you listen when he mentioned that those who are still facing any discrimination in rural areas, must be considered in the individual based reservation system.. but then the same privilege cannot extend to a SC ST person in urban India who is the son of an IAS officer who also became IAS despite low marks in UPSC, just because of reservation.. or a urban taxi driver SC ST dad whose son is studying in a university.. different people are on different levels of privilege.. if you exclude the 3-4 major temples of the south, most of the other temples in Tamil Nadu especially in small towns, the pujaris don't get any good salary at all.. first of all the temples are under the hands of govt appointed beaurocrats, instead of setting them free.. just for example compare the income of an ISKCON pujari with the income of a small pujari of a govt controlled temple in south.. there is tremendous difference.. the TN govt submitted a report to TN High Court stating that 11000 temples in the state have only 1 person taking care each, and he does the job of a pujari, of a cleaner as well as security guard.. and the DMK and AIADMK goons just simply brush white paint on the intricate ancient carvings.. and about 12000 other temples in TN are lying down in ruins now.. no one taking care of them.. temples should not be under state control.. or else take mosques and churches also under state control if u have guts.. when all these atrocities against Brahmins and the non-SC STs are being unleased by the inconsiderate govt, that was the time Rajiv Malhotra decided to leave the country.. that was a time when due to shitty policies in India, a lot of honest talent ran away to the US.
Yes 😂 and if britisher made cast system then why these so called upper cast people r practicing it and in there temples also that's mean the whole hindu religion is made by britishers na 😂
@@krishgautam9090 pehle Varna system follow Kiya jata tha jo ki profession based tha phir dhire dhire ye change kyonki logon main superiority complex aa gaya birth based bante gaya aur class system ek time pe saari societies follow karti thi unfortunately.
Billionaire Dalits?...bruh maybe he mean OBC people who already were landlords that time so it can be but mostly Dalits are poor farmers or menial job workers that time,now days still they are farmers and labourers
@@truthtalker9375 Exactly 💯, Dalits were not even allowed to have basic human needs and he says "Dalits billionaires " , I agree with some other things he said but this one is bullshit.
@Aditi Tegwal well then discrimination is not one way upper against dalit either. Dalit vs non dalit is also reality as well as dalit against maha dalit. So this whole upper oppressing lower is a big fat media creation which is baseless as the dalit against non dalit occurs with equal frequency. So prejudice is not one sided so portraying it as one sided is ridiculous and portraying one side as innocent victims is ridiculous
@Aditi Tegwal you know what, jogendra mandal was a politician who was dalit right then. If you say how many dalits in politics, then how many upper castes do you know in business or trade? By and large less. People tend to follow what their ancestors are doing and many of it is not necessarily discrimination. Most of the kings of the biggest empires were lower caste right whether chandragupta maurya or ashoka? When the lower castes themselves were rulers thousands of years ago, how on earth can they claim discrimination? Most of the politicians today are lower caste. And where does lack of facilities have to do with caste anyway? If an upper caste stays in a very backward place, do they get any special facilities? Just like you expect me to see things holistically, we also expect the same from you instead of pushing a victimhood narrative and portraying one side as dominant bad and the other as innocent oppressed. Just like you expect upper caste to treat lower caste right, others also expect lower caste to treat upper caste right. One has to acknowledge the flaws at their end also instead of always fingerpointing the other side even when the other side is not responsible for their own self inflicted issues
Indian caste system is not the creation of British rulers...it existed in India long before the arrival.of British . The caste differences still persist.
Britishers invented caste system. That’s why I go live in their country (USA Uk same difference). Critical race theory is hogwash in India between Brahmins and Dalits (for example) but somehow is valid in the USA between blacks and whites. Person being a farmer from a rural background is less than a city cab driver from the same background. Brahmanical privilege is non existent because I benefit from it but accent privilege is real because I don’t have an American accent even though I live there.
Mr. Malhotra is my hero. He motivated me to combat the false narratives against Hindus. I'm happy to report that a letter I wrote my newspaper was included today. I already mailed the 2nd letter. It was titled:. Crucial context regarding India and was a rebuttal to another writer saying India was on Open Door Ministries list of countries persecuting Christians. My sequel is about the Kashmiri Pandits. I live in a conservative part of U.S. I'm an Indian-origin immigrant from Guyana. Karma has millions of Hindus strategically placed around the globe.
So inspirational best of luck to you difficult to do things in which u dont see direct monetary benefits but this things have a huge impoact in the long run
@@msms3260 what it means to me is: Regardless of what brought Hindus to different parts of the world, we can engage in self-interest or we can engage in confronting the false narratives that have been peddled by the two younger religions. It means Hindus have to stand up. It means it's time to stop cowering and hiding but to be proud of my Dharma enough to explain, defend and protect. That is the meaning to me.
Please talk about caste system to whom which is affected by it . There are many scholars from that background also. Plz bring them to your channel and talk to them. Thank you
Suraj Yengde is a bootlicker of the Western Black intellectuals. He is one of the snakes in Harvard, he is anything but objective. But I do agree he should interviewed and his points debunked on a live podcast.
Caste made by britisher 😂😂 Then why upper castes practices strictly, is this also given by britishers nonsense... If you want know about test of wine Then meet with who drunk it not to who made it ok... caste gives very pain who bear it but it is only word for others. Come at "science journey" or "the realist azad" for live debate.
Beacuse it has been rooted to society ,if you call someone and treat him like upper caste after some period of time they will became addicted to it and when you won't give them they will feel bad it is just reality of every human being.
They will never accept that their religion allowed a practice (caste system) which had done more harm to nation than good If asked a question they will use word play And will confuse u between caste and varna. But on ground everyone knows what the reality of this caste system . Our ancestors have to fight for water and still today the fight is on we are not even allowed to perform last rites at a public cemetery
@@archigoel Mahad satyagraha 1927 Led by Dr BR Ambedkar to allow people to acess water from public facilities And many more recorded facts are there I just don't have that much time to put it down here. Do your homework
Everyone want to abolish reservation from those lower caste peoples who r doing good in life but no body is talking about abolish caste system properly and then make reservation system as per need wise. Why???
@@archigoel upper caste people's are also equally involved in discrimination. No one from Upper ever talk about abolis all the caste, nobody will be Gen pbs SC st , all are human beings.
I'm not Brahmin while my father is....as a Bangladeshi🇧🇩 Hindu we made caste based on our occupation not family background as far as Bhagavad Gita said. NOWADAYS it's very common to us!!! And that is how 16 million Hindu still survive here...
May hindus keep surviving in all muslim majority nation more power to hindus and hope they dont discrimination and support fellow hindu, be united be safe 🙏
Angreziyat 😁.. He defined british evil ideology so precisely. .. He nailed it 😂.. Person talking in fluent english language is privileged this is also casteism was another sixer 🏏
Discrimination happens based on 'Caste', not 'Income'. If poor savarn is unable to go to school and college because of money, then tell me how the hell reservation will going to help him? All Poor people need Free education, irrespective of his caste, whereas all Lower caste people need reservation, irrespective of his economic condition. Because Untouchable always remains untouchable in the eyes of discriminators, whether untouchable is poor or rich.
@@nareshkumar3526 Naresh ji, I'm not anti reservation, but I believe if the parents got the reservation then their child must not get it. They had the shot, they missed it. Do you agree on this?
@@A_Dasgupta No, Reservation is not a 'Caste improving machine'. Untouchable will not become a brahmin after reservation. Caste is bound to birth which cannot be changed in the eyes of discriminators. But Yes I agree that Rich Lower caste people gets less discrimination as compared to poor lower caste. But it doesn't means that Upper caste community will stop doing discrimination when lower class person becomes rich. If you really want to remove reservation, then ask government to make education mandatory, gave equal lands to lower community as well, all exams and interview should be based on Roll Number i.e, no one would know name of candidate until final selection. Then yes, I would have no problem removing reservation.
i know persons whose parents are rich, well settled, educated but are not able to give up their caste, treats their girl like a shit force her to marriage, not giving her freedom etc... I think there is more internal work to do in sanathana dharma and reform the societyyy as a whole
That happens because of lack of getting on with modernity. They can make their daughters dress in beautiful chudidar best girls dress still give them freedom to pursue their dreams. Western dress culture doesn't suit parents there it ends
The problem with the English speaking Indian us that they doesn't understand the ground reality of caste in India. I just want to ask him just mention 5 dalit billionaire. I know that reservation are misused by some community and government need to fixed it, but this doesn't mean that we start giving reservation on basis on income in which about 50-60 percent of Indian will be cover and the entire concept of reservation will be destroyed. And lastly I also accept that changes need to done in system of reservation so that majority of sc/st/obc community find it beneficial.
not the majority of sc st but the really deprived ones...those whose parents have already availed the benefit of the reservation system and now living a luxurious or above-average life are not really in need of reservation.
I am a Brahmin I was always treated badly when my college friends came to know about my caste they used to call me "kharkate brahmin" also in my office they used to call me names. I never bothered coz I never knew the caste system was so deep rooted. Now I am realizing people mistreated me coz of my caste
Brahmins are being persecuted in India everywhere because of their stubborn allegiance to hindu dharm .they never were kings, political powers , but still people blame them for discrimination just because they never retailiate just ignore and do their work .
I also got discriminated many times for being brahmim in a Christian missionary school... I don't know the reason then but now I realise that they were dalits who got converted to Christianity but the hatred towards brahmins will never go from them.... It's all half baked truth that have been told everytime by their political akaas to satisfy their political fantasy.
Nice word play. The caste system has caused many fellow Indians and allies to be historically alienated from the hindus like the Jains, who left is disappointment when caste atrocities were at its peak owing to their ahimsa atheistic philosophies. This was way before the British came into the picture. In fact the caste system divided hindus into so many feuding sects that we couldn't consolidate power to stand up to larger adversaries like the Moghuls and the British and translated to india's extraordinary economic decline which was already in motion before the East India company came to our shores. These two colonisers saw the caste segregation as a weakness and exploited it, they didn't create it, it already existed and there is much historic proof of that. And they succeeded, they saw how much Brahmins enjoyed looking down on lower castes so they gave them advisory positions and high ranks to keep indians further squabbling amongst themselves so we'd be occupied in our own mess while they looted the country uninterrupted. India doesn't have diversity, it has the illusion of it. India is a deeply segregated society where each faction hardly interacts with each other. So on the outside it may seem like a lot of communities are co-existing with each other but the boundaries in-between are controlled by forces of caste, gender, superstitions and stereotypes who have been gatekeeping it making cross cultural exchange a massive challenge. That's why you have the North-South divide on everything from tax money to identity to linguistic fuedalism. Malhotra has to appeal to ignorance by saying "there must have been support for diversity for it to exist" knowing well this isn't the case and facts aren't on his side. We have come a very long way and we should celebrate that but with some degree of intellectual honesty.
@io mn The caste system was always rigid, what changes did they bring for it to appear "more" rigid in comparison to post and pre British era. If anything they alleviated it slightly by giving Dalits education in missionary schools... Although they did it primarily to proselytise, for lower castes it was a "something better than nothing" situation.
@@utkarsh_yash it's not the language that decides the depth of "viewpoint" but the points themselves. Classic excuse for not owning up to our objectionable history!
Wait !... would you talk with a 'white man' to understand racism. Then why would you ask a savarna to understand the caste system .... Your whole talk is casteist.... Your understanding of caste is wrong caste lives in cities.... Discrimination in cities comes in acts of micro-aggression. In offices in living spaces.
The white man is the one that invented the caste system. The British held a conference of churches in Madras in the 1870s where they mentioned that the jatis were the major obstacle in conversions to Christianity. Lord Herbert Risley then created a hierarchy of jatis and divided them into so called castes by birth. This did not exist before. Next the British forced all people to select one of these castes to satisfy the census beginning 1880s. Thus everyone began confirming to castes to meet census requirements. Did the Rajputs invent the Rajput regiment? No, it was the British. Did the Sikhs invent the Jat regiment? No. it was the British. 60% of all kings in India were Shudras. They were also 60 to 80% of students and teachers in the Indian education system.
This is meaningless podcast ever done by my fav. TH-camr, Dear Admin sir, I believe, Hiran ka dard samjhne keliye, hiran se baat kijiye unhe invite kijiye, Shikari kese bata sakta h, So, You need to call upon opressed(Hiran) to share his perspectives and reality over the issue. Like *Prof.Dilip Mandal, Dr. Suraj Yengde* etc....
He is itself Malhotra, so very easy to say based on income because he never faced caste discrimination so it's very to give faltu ka gyaaan , no one general person say to abolish the caste system in India but say to abolish reservation. Level of double standards.
@@Anomander5622you proved his point castist lindu .you bring out another main topic why people hide their surname because of avoiding discrimination from lindu like you .
I really love this old man, i always thought y my parents or grandparents didn't think this way about caste system which i understand this soon and also govt is so biased this way on job opportunities, he did what I always want to speak, i wanted to be like him
He is not just a old man, He is one of us and very dear to us and being an Indian he is as respectful to us as like a senior member of our family, This man is owed a lot by all of us, He has single handedly taken on the so called Left intellectuals be it Western or their sepoys in India, he has served Bhartiya specially Hindus and Bharat as a civilization and culture and Dharm also through his wisdom, knowledge and intellectualism which he has collected in his books which are going to be guiding source and force for us and generations to come, we can not do anything for him in person but we can heartily thanks him for his great service he has done to Dharm, he has also groomed new Sanatani Intellectual force under his precious guidance and supervision who will take the baton of dharm forward in future and lead the society on wards , He is real Dharmic kshatriya , GOI should also facilitate him with Padam Bhushan kind of honor for his work and this way we can contribute a little to recognize the greatness, dedication, hard pursuit of his work which we are not able to evaluate for now due to our shortsightedness, Rajiv ji ko sashtang dandvat pranam 🙏🙏🙏
English is required in many companies because you work in a team with people from all over the world. If your teammates cannot understand your ideas, your ideas are of no good. No matter how skilled you are, you cannot know everything. You always need to collaborate.
Then how is that Chinese are sucessful in engaging western English speaking businesses , we can have people learn English who have to deal with foreign business but we don't need to speak colonial language in our daily life...!
Not gonna lie but Japanese are more skillful without knowing english for their own country. Since they rely on themself than other countries. First we need priority ourselves more than others.
@@mr.d2124 FYI, China does not do highly technical job. Chinese economy is built on monotonous work on assembly line. Technological advancement in China are mostly cheap copy of Russian and Western technology. As China does not follow international laws, other cannot cannot do much when their technology is copied.
@@firetoofan5555 Japanese companies builds technology from scratch. They have patented many technology. Do you think Infosys, Wipro, TCS, HCL builds any technology? They are service based companies. Indian high skilled job market is service based. You need to know English to work on a Service sector.
Before commenting on reservation 1st need to STOP insulting so called saying low caste If this guy faces low caste harassment then he never speaks of reservations
Sir get ur facts right recently I went through a reseach there is no low caste harassment atleast in cities its now only in rural areas. Second I am a mbbs students ask me what reservation affect us. i got 94 percentile payed 50 lakhs just for 3 years now. this low caste how comes fairly upper middle class family every year waste 10000-15000 seats because they come at 70% and then can not compete this pressure.And this same seats are sold to open for double price. and more or less its every wher in engineering etc.
So Mr. Malhotra did you not know about literacy rate in India about and at what level of involvement of AI in India's Caste system . All you just heard one word AI from somewhere and cover up the atrocities due to caste system and blame reservation. What could I say for him hypocrite, he doesn't say anything against caste syste .
Dear Ranveer If you really want to know whether there is casteism in our country or not, then visit rural India and you will know everything.This person is trying to justify the castism, and instead of the upper caste people, he is blaming the western world. The fact is that this person has a problem with the reservation given to Dalits. The irony is that this person himself is from the upper caste and comes here to talk about Dalits. Please call someone from Dalit community also to hear their side.
The Temple Entry Proclamation was issued by Maharaja Chithira Thirunal Balarama Varma on November 12, 1936. The Proclamation abolished the ban on the so-called 'low caste people' or avarnas from entering Hindu temples in the Princely State of Travancore, now part of Kerala, India.
The white man is the one that invented the caste system. The British held a conference of churches in Madras in the 1870s where they mentioned that the jatis were the major obstacle in conversions to Christianity. Lord Herbert Risley then created a hierarchy of jatis and divided them into so called castes by birth. This did not exist before. Next the British forced all people to select one of these castes to satisfy the census beginning 1880s. Thus everyone began confirming to castes to meet census requirements. Did the Rajputs invent the Rajput regiment? No, it was the British. Did the Sikhs invent the Jat regiment? No. it was the British. 60% of all kings in India were Shudras. They were also 60 to 80% of students and teachers in the Indian education system.
@@dheerajnavin-pr4zx There is no "caste idea" found in the Bhagavad Gita. Caste is such as foreign idea that even the supreme court of India has not been able to define caste in a way that stays true to Indian society. The Bible is discriminates against non-Christians. The Catholic church went further and classed non-Christians as non-human beings (person non grata) whose lands and lives could be taken over via the Doctrine of Discovery. This laid the moral foundation for the Christian genocide across the world, most heavily in the Americas where upwards of 95% of the population was wiped out. The British themselves starved and killed upwards of 105 million Indians to death.
@@taitreyarr2715 Friend, I have no excuse for what the British did in India. Most of them did not act according to the teachings of the Bible their holy book. BIBLE does not discrimate against non-Christians. In Galatians 3:28 of the Bible we clearly read : There is neither Jew nor Greek ( gentile), there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are ALL ONE in Christ Jesus. The sanctitity and dignity of every humanbeing is clearly emphasized in the Bible. Jesus' message in John 3:16 of the Bible is clear and for all mankind: God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that WHOEVER believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. What so called Christians have done or do and what the Bible teaches are two different things.
@@dheerajnavin-pr4zx It is actually "So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, 27 for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise." So you are equal only if you are Christian. If you do not believe in Christ, you will burn in hell. Of that there is no dispute in Christianity. This is what leads Christians to the most genocidal of any religious people in history, Any religion can only be judged one parameter, which is the effect it has on its followers. The effect in Christianity is to turn adherents genocidal. The British were not doing anything different. They were playing by the book.
In India Our Constitution has abolished practice of Caste Discrimination.We have framed various welfare legislation for upliftment of SC/ST. Reservation policy is such a constitutional privilege. Does US have corresponding Laws in favour of Blacks, who were liberated as Slaves
Initially it was a good idea but Giving Reservation for this long years to SC/ST just on the basis of caste is not a good thing. Some with even annual income of more than 1cr enjoying this system.
How does he know that Dalits are millionaires and Brahmins are poor when he lived in the USA for more than fifty years? He knows nothing about the social structure. Caste is not only a division of labour but that of labourers also.
Caste is invention of Hinduism or sanatan dharma. When people converted to other religions from Hindu eg Sikh, Christianity and Islam their social status didn't change and society didn't forget their caste. That's why you see caste in other religions in india. It's not the case for Muslims and Christians outside india. Main difference between class which you find in almost every feudal society and caste in India is 1. Caste was determined by birth with no social mobility 2. Endogamy no intercaste marriages especially with lower caste or out caste (both are different). 3. No where in the world it was sanctioned by religion like we did. Last anybody who is blaming Muslims or British for caste discrimination is purposefully lying.
I belong to matang community according to your brahman Dharma I'm chandala ( untouchable ) matangi (green Tara) is the goddess of mahavidya there are so many Temple's of matangi in India like minakshi-amman temple Karnataka , Tarapith west Bengal and tuljabhawani Maharashtra if she born in my caste why you don't give us reservation in Temple committee
Mr Rajiv Mehrotra ur study is excellent,but i differ to say that people pf so called higher castes still try to demean & hr having grudges against so called lower caste.
Muslim society has the concept of purity and pollution of caste. The lower-class (Ajlaf) Muslims of the region have faced other forms of discrimination. Upper-class (Ashraf) Muslims dominated government jobs and parliamentary representation. There have been cases in which upper caste Muslims have opposed the burial of lower caste Muslims in the same cemetery. A study found that there exists a caste hierarchy in the Muslim community. The Sweeper Group is ranked the lowest. Other Muslim communities do not allow sweepers to touch the cooking vessels of upper ranking groups of Muslims.
@@googlesharma4477 then just say we beleive in our c@ste superiority n move on....why is this malhotra trying hard to deny it 😂🤣 he in other interviews says that c@ste is fluid....so if ur doctr you become shudr@ 🤣😂
Yes its true caste system did not exist in india ...but it was varna vyavastha based on profession...caste is not same as varna...it is a Portuguese concept....the British misused the varna vyavastha and imposed caste system into india
Reservation should be based on a weighted average score of backwardness calculated using a number of different factors such as Educational Background, Economic Background, Geographical Background & Societal/Caste Background. Each factor should carry certain weightage out of the total and each individual should be assessed based on his background and assigned a score for each individual factor. At last a weighted average score based on all the factors should be calculated and this score should be used for giving reservation. Caste based blanket reservation just doesn't serve the purpose.
@@gowrijanga6976 And who gave you the authority to decide which arbitrary group gets reservation and which group doesn't..!!?? This is exactly the sick mentality of self entitlement of being the judge, the jury and the executioner which the policy of reservation should seek to abolish. Let the entire process of reservation be democratized and given to all those who are actually in need rather than confining it to a select few arbitrary groups.
@@sdtinu yes dash.l am totally in favour of you let this caste system reservation has to death down ,those resources Equalizer equatably to every caste.caste system has become rigid ,don't make everything that it never exist ,it exists
@@sdtinuI think we need to demolish Hinduism and caste system both and make Humanity as Religion where everyone are equal so no need to give reservation and people will live in peace and with brotherhood 😄
@@truthtalker9375 Honestly anarchy is never a solution to any problem and this mindset of annihilating Hinduism and caste system is anarchy of the highest order and discriminatory to be frank. And this theme of equality is a utopian concept which is not achievable and honestly not at all desirable at the same time. This only sounds good when you are in college or while writing an essay or debating someone. But when you come out of the theoretical world and enter the practical realm you realise that equality is not at all practical. Equality of opportunity on the other hand is something we can strive for. Social stratification is a reality of society. You understand this when you start working in a job or start earning in the real world. In my view caste is not a bad thing but caste discrimination is certainly bad and evil to be exact. The best you can do is be proud of your caste/work and be appreciative of others.
It is actually Rajiv Gandhi’s time! Correction! Reservation and special consideration should be based on individual needs, disadvantage and deprivation. It should not be collective, cast or religion based which will be abused by politicians using divide and rule methods!
Bruh tell me at Ramanujacharaya's time which politician divided into caste and religion?... because he fought for discrimination in 11th century so it is not from just few years but form many decades
Castism is written in Indian scriptures like bhagwat Geeta, valmiki ramayan, rigved. Anyone who says otherwise is either a lier or a foolish I can give you exact shloks.
Caste discrimination is rooted not in religion but culture. Caste was an ancient system of occupational class delineated in Hindu texts that over the years developed into a rigid social hierarchy. The lowest castes, or untouchables, were marginalized and faced persecution. Caste-based discrimination is not intrinsic to Hinduism and should not be thought of as religiously sanctioned. the poorer workers involved in 'unclean' occupations such as sweeping or leather work were historically segregated and banished outside the city limits. Over time, personal cleanliness came to be identified with "purity", and the concept of untouchability eventually spread to the rural areas. Manusmriti text was never implemented as a law code in ancient India. The caste system as it exists today is the result of developments during the rise of the British colonial government in India. The British Raj furthered this development, making rigid caste organisation a central mechanism of administration. By 1860 the British formulated the caste system into their system of governance, granting administrative jobs and senior appointments only to Christians and people belonging to certain castes.
@@snehashispanda4808 this thesis of your have any evidence or just a fictitious creation of your mind to feel good about yourself and your caste, and hindu religion? Because I can give you specific caste based discrimination instances from valmiki ramayan, geeta, manusmriti. And don't tell these boos are written after British Empire.
@@snehashispanda4808 hinduism is caste system, actually you can't even call this religion Hinduism, because nowhere in the scriptures the word hindu appears . This religion was called brahman dharma.
Cast शब्द यूरोप में इबेरिया प्रायद्वीप में स्थित देशों पुर्तगाल और स्पेन में प्रचलित है जिसका मूल लैटिन भाषा के chasta शब्द में है जिसका अर्थ है शुद्धता purity Casta का अर्थ हुआ खून की शुद्धता जो कि इस क्षेत्र में नस्लीय शुद्धता को इंगित करता है । जब यूरोपीय उपनिवेश भारत आए । उन्होंने इस ढांचे (term) को भारत पर लागू कर दिया । लंबा इतिहास है 🙏
'Interiors of India' .. caste system. You seem to automatically assume that "upper caste brahmins" oppress "lower caste dalits". It is the OBCs who used to be Kings and ruling and warrior class - are oppressing brahmins and dalits. Also we read about dalit doing honour killing because dalit was in love with brahmin.
It's become a fashion and habit to blame brahmins every time. They have been the always targeted as the reason for oppressing the lower caste. This thought is engraved during past 200 or so in British era
Cast system comes from hindu religion and hindu texts . Brahmins positioned themselves in highest authority of religion .. sanskrit languages and hindu texts are always remained in occupation of hindu text so who spread this poison of division ..... Many hindu texts refers so much deregetory things about people belong to certain cast ... Who wrote in those texts .. it's not only confined to Sanskrit texts but was also there in many local texted written in local languages .. people who blame british only wish to white wash there crimes against indians ... British took advantage of it what already exist in hindu society ...
Well vedas rigveda gives definition of four varna, yajurveda mentions definition of chandal and nishadha which is proof of birth based varna system and discrimination, mahabharat has many stories about birth based varna system ( check what " sut" in sutputra karna means) , bhagwat Gita talks about paap yoni etc and says one must do work of varna he was born into no matter how bad he was at it, and never do work of other varna no matter how good he is at it, (bhagwatGita 18:47)....with this context all Gita is actually trying to implement birth based varna system and discrimination out of which caste system originated. So caste discrimination is a religious problem that needs to be addressed.
@@arjyachatterjee6874 Dude, you are delusional. We have statistics, written records, government data, etc. Apne aap ko itna bewakoof kyu prove kar rhe ho?
I see where he's coming from. But its probably not safe for a state to collect data en-masse and feed into an AI algorithm without fully understanding the implications of what might happen. For something like this to work you would need serious privacy preserving tech which helps you collect data as an aggregate without identifying specific individuals.
there is only one solution to end casteism ,is to do inter marriages ,if you are a 3rd generation hindu make it a point that you will not marry in your own caste
I thought he will speak about caste system, but he was deviated towards same thing " Reservation " and " British imposed Caste " . I am myself a victim of caste atrocity from 15 years, today govt using IAS officer to cover up matter. In these past 15 years no one came to help us or even tried to stop it. It is like PARAMPARA that continues. We asked for legal aid, but denied with fake excuses. Now I want to fight and to fight I want to study Law, but I have no money for Law collage.
@@SigmaAvi : There was no caste system before the british. There was only Varna system which was based on profession and qualities or gunas which was acquirable and was not decided entirely by birth. Viswamitra became brahman from kshatriya. A four member family could have 4 different varnas. Valmiki had a stint as a thief before turning into the compiler of Ramayana. Moreover there was no higher or lower varna as each profession was important in its own way. Perunthachan was a highly renowned and respected blacksmith of pre-british India in Kerala.
@@pamelapati1219 I am 33 years old, sick, it created a rukus in my brain. I have very weak memory now,hard to remember everything. At age 31 joined a class, where I read english grammar with students twice younger than me in age.
@@thereisnospoon123 Might be but current situation is not same. I am 33 years old trying to get admission after 12th to study law. Caste play vital role. I speak with experience, evidence, legal documents nothing fictional..
Sir, u r just finding ways to justify evils of jaati system.. Jaati hierarchy was sanctioned by ritualistic purity ascribed to every caste, by brahmanical system... where the supreme caste brahmin kept them on top..
"ब्राह्मणों द्वारा जितने धर्मशास्त्र, स्मृति, पुराण, महाकाव्य आदि रचे गये, सबमें उन्होंने अपने स्वार्थ की बातें लिखीं और अपने स्वार्थ के लिए ही अन्य वर्ग को पशु के समान जीने के लिए विवश किया। विद्या, धर्मशास्त्र, धर्मकृत्य, ऊंचे पद, संन्यास आदि का अधिकारी अपने को माना और अन्य को, ज्यादातर तथाकथित शूद्रों को इनसे सर्वथा दूर रखा। यह सब पुरोहितों के द्वारा की जाने वाली चोरियां ही हैं। ब्राह्मणों के भेदभाव की नीति ने हिन्दू-समाज को कमजोर बनाकर रख दिया है। जाति-पांति का जहर हिन्दू धर्मग्रन्थों में उसी प्रकार समाया है जैसे दूध में पानी। आज भी उसका प्रभाव हिन्दू समाज पर छाया है। यह भी ध्यान देने योग्य बात है कि ब्राह्मण नाम एक वर्ग है और संसार में किसी भी वर्ग के सारे लोग गलत नहीं होते हैं। ब्राह्मण वर्ग में रहे हुए पुरोहितों ने ही भेदभाव तथा छल-छद्म की नीति अपनायी है। इससे पूरा ब्राह्मण-समाज दोषी नहीं है। ब्राह्मणों में भी सदा-सर्वदा से कुछ ऐसे मानवतावादी चिन्तक होते आये हैं, जो ब्राह्मण पुरोहितों की भेदभाव-जनित व्यवस्था के घोर विरोधी तथा मानव-समानता के प्रबल पक्षधर रहे हैं। इस प्रकार ब्राह्मण-समाज में भी ब्राह्मण-व्यवस्था-विरोधी आग यत्र-तत्र सदैव सुलगती रही है, जिसके परिणाम में आचार्य बृहस्पति ने भौतिकवादी पक्ष लेकर ब्राह्मणों के कर्मकांडों की धज्जियां उड़ायी थीं। ब्राह्मण-व्यवस्था के विरोधी स्वर उपनिषद्, महाभारत, गीता आदि धर्मग्रन्थों में यत्र-तत्र देखे जा सकते हैं। ब्राह्मण समाज की संतान जैन, बौद्ध, सिद्ध-नाथ, कबीरपंथ तथा निर्गुणीधारा के नाना संप्रदायों में दीक्षित होकर ब्राह्मणवादी भेदभाव नीति का सदा घोर विरोध करती रही और भविष्य तो अधिक उज्ज्वल है। सद्गुरु कबीर ने तो उन्हीं ब्राह्मणों की यहां आलोचना की है जो विषमताजनित व्यवस्था के संस्थापक तथा परिपोषक रहे हैं। कबीर साहेब का उद्देश्य ब्राह्मण कहे जाने वाले वर्ग को न दुखाना है और न चिढ़ाना है। संत किसी को दुखाते नहीं। वे ब्राह्मणों को एक तथ्य सुझा रहे हैं। उन्हें सावधान कर रहे हैं। वे समझें और अपने आप को जाति और वर्णविहीन शुद्ध मानवतावादी स्तर पर लाने का प्रयत्न करें। इसी की आवश्यकता सब समय थी, आज तो अत्यावश्यक है ही। केवल ब्राह्मण पुरोहित ही दोषी हों, ऐसी बात नहीं है, जहां कहीं भी, किसी भी परम्परा में पुरोहित होगा वह ऊंच-नीच का भेदभाव डालना शुरू ही करेगा। किसी पुराण में ब्रह्मा की महिमा की गयी, तो किसी पुराण में कृष्णगोपाल को ब्रह्म माना गया, किसी में शिव को सर्वोपरि कहा गया, तो किसी में भूत-प्रेतों की महिमा गायी गयी। जैनियों ने अपने तीर्थंकरों की महिमा कर उनकी पूजा का विधान किया, तो मुसलमानों ने अपनी पद्धति चलाकर नमाज पढ़ना आरम्भ किया। इसी तरह और अनेक गुरुओं-पुरोहितों के मार्ग निकले और वे अपने- अपने को मोक्ष तथा ईश्वर के एकाधिकारी घोषित करते रहे।" --कबीर बीजक व्याख्याकार श्री अभिलाष दास
Being oblivious of caste system is itself a position of privilege owned by dominant caste. This knowledge is so superficial and full of biases. Ranveer if you really want to understand Indian caste system invite Dr. Suraj Yegde to the show to get the real perspective!
your Dr. suraj yegde keeps running away from debate with rajiv malhotra at harvard . look a rajeev sir channel he wants 500 million dollar to debate with rajeev sir . if he is true then why running away
@@Arya_BhattWhy do a great scholar need any approval from Rajeev Malhotra. Who's he??? Not even equally qualified as Dr. Suraj. Dr. Suraj Yegde is an intelect par excellence. He's PhD from Harvard and currently doing post doctoral fellowship from Harvard. He's writer of Bestsellers like " Caste Matters". He has been awarded as 25 Most influential young Indians by GQ magazine. He has participanted in nany international events and now in reputed Hollywood movie as Dalit activist. His profile is far more impressive than Malhotra's. The only thing where Mr. Malhotra is ahead is the age! 😅 It's a global world. Sanatanis really need to come out of their megalomania!
@@AK-ct8bb arguements facts and logic matter more than educational qualification. and rajiv malhotra is not an ordinary guy why this so called intellectual keeps running away from debate . he is asking half a million dollar for just facing malhotra which itself speaks everthing . and getting in any hollywood movie is not an acheivement and does not make you any more credible leftist lobby is supporting him thats why. and bestsellers lol every influencer book becomes bestseller it means nothing . your dp already tells me everything i need to know . ask yegde to have the courage if he is such a big intellactual .
{Long post, dont know how many will read it} Purane Bharat me sab miljulke rehte the. Ye pichhle kuchh 600, 700 saal ka result hai, sab angrez logo ne kiya dhara hai. "Caste" to shabd hi introduce karvaya tha angrezo ne. I understand, even at this time, lower castes are stereotyped in various remote areas of our country, but we need to understand the root/origin of this divisive policy. _We had "Varna" system not caste system. Varna system was dynamic. Even a son/daughter of a brahmana can become a shudra proudly based on his/her inclination. All 4 varnas were equally useful based on the purposes they served. Yess, shudra wasnt a derogatory term as many people percieve it today. It was just for convinience for everyone._ _Like a brahmana wudnt be given the work of shudra, because that wud require immense physical durability. Similarly brahmana's mental capability was honoured and given the job to lead the society._ (And mind you again, anyone could become a kshatriya or shudra etc based on his/her liking. It was dynamic. Aisa nhi ki, brahman ka beta brahman, etc) Thus as we can understand, it was a kind of job profile name. Nthin to be ashamed or too much proud of. *_Shudras indeed were the building blocks of any society, so were the vaishyas in keeping the society wealthful, kshatriyas to protect everyone and brahmanas to lead the society spiritually._* U see everyone was of immense importance, nthing less nthing more. It was our own wrongdoing, leaving spiritual texts reading, we ourselves desecrated this smooth fabric of society under influence of those haramkhor invaders; so much so that we started seeing each other enemies than those fkin invaders. _I am hopeful for Bharat though. We will be that old civilization again. We just need to read our scriptures again n again. Go back to our roots._ _We were not separated like they show on tv, movies etc. whatever they showed us the degradation of lower castes by upper castes on these screens, whatever we read about it too ; that was all in our just remote past, just around we were invaded by those haramkhors, and NOT BEFORE._ DO NOT MAKE THAT MISTAKE THAT Bharat was always like this. Noo, we were, are still united. Just got to tap that. _To remove the still ongoing practices of discriminating against lower castes, we need to go back to our roots, know our real history, nit the one told by westerners._ I am hopeful. I want to see that beautiful Bharat again. I want all people to look for their "gotra" irresp of castes, and they will see how all were united at one point. (p.s. m from a backward caste myself, if that helps anyone to assimilate the facts)
Why do we see only a amlhotra or a agrawal or a sighn talkl that caste system doesnot exist in india . if u want ssee the truth go tru any matrimony page in india . caste is a realityay and disriminatio exists . yes caste system is teh racism of india
We had caste based reservations since independence and now it is 50% reservations. Why teh system established by Congress did not work and still they are saying no representations from dalit, OBC etc? The reason is it is the same family again and again enjoying reservations, generations after generations. It is same wealthy class among OBC, Dalits who are misusing reservations. Reservations has to be given only one or 2 generations for a family and once they have financial means to educate their children then their children should be considered as general category. Also reservations has to consider financial status. Keeping the current system and increasing reservations above 50% is injustice to the general category and injustice to economically backward people of other casts. Actually casts should not be a factor in reservations and time has proved this since independence
Bloody bring some Anthropologist or a Sociologist to the conversation, these bloody hindu recreationalists will just talk rubbish. Invite Dr. kartic Godavarthy to understand actually what caste system actually is.
We all know we have the tech to identify the most deprived and give help to those who need it the most. But at the end of the day politics triumphs every rationale; and humans, especially Indians, are extremely tribalistic people. Indian Politics is ultimately a game of numbers and casteist politicians like Lalu Yadav or Mulayam Singh Yadav will keep on winning in the end.
@@ramaswamyk3380 read about how MH brahmins refused to coronate him and he had to summon gaga bhatt ji from Kashi. In spite of being the student of konddeo ji
@@princeofheaven19 you think mh brahmins are more orthodox than kashi brahmins? Kashi brahmins are supposed to be the top and most knowledgeable and most orthodox. So if as per the brahmin from kashi shivaji can have a thread ceremony, then definitely mh brahmins could not have objected because kashi is the supreme of hinduism
Caste system has been created by a specific community to get benefitted to them who created this system of hierarchy. Hierarchy is not created by British. British were against the caste system but they never opposed because they want to rule. Caste and religion based discrimination is dragging india backwards.
You cant be myopic , India's caste is the foundation of Spiritual - Life , Give equality of opportunity if you like , but never lose the truth of this life is but ONE pearl on a string of pearls - Hare Krishna
Those who benefited from caste will never blame it nor they want it to go away.
@@rajendrabareto8065 quite obvious bro... that's why there should be no benefit on the basis of caste
@@AsmitTiwari-hd4pj benefits also comes in society my friends taking away all the benefits to themselves.
@@rajendrabareto8065 Yes, OBC and Dalits are expoiting GC, taking way opportunities of education, job and life. And funnily, they still have guts to say we are oppressed. This is really Kaliyuga.
@ ohh yea. Now you still call them Dalits and obc my friend
@@archigoel ye nahi sudhrenge 🥲
Caste is not just economic, it is the mindset of people to discriminate other human beings based on the sur name.
Name a single hindu book which says Varna is by birth,not by karm.We have a saying Varna karm se hain,janm se nhi.
Varna means Colour, so it's colour based system @@soch1110
Even modern society is following caste system popes priests, military, businessman, labours/employees. Society cannot function without Varna. But Hindu concept of Karma and God in all living beings as all pervading consciousness is the only way we can avoid discrimination for peace, prosperity and spirituality.
@@Batega_toh_Katega_Hindu_108hence reservation is needed
@@wellfelix7883 who will pay for your reservation money?
Cast doesn't matter if you are a upper caste 😊
Explain
@@justrelaxxzz9279discrimination is never seem against upper caste
@@justrelaxxzz9279 go to any place and tag yourself as a Dalit. Go to a mob and shake hands with them. They will 'explain' with utmost care.
Totally agree with you
Yes .dalits are abused by brahmin and upper caste by using bad language
Wooooooow, another man talking against reservation, but not caste system.😢
You have to find how many Dalits have performed honor killing coz their child fell in love with upper caste. You need a reality check.
Moreover find out casteism within Dalits. Ambedkar belonged to Mahar Dalits and his community considers Mang Dalits lower in hierarchy n untouchables.
@@r.b.8018 Yes caste system is biggest pblm in India, everyone wants to abolish reservation, if caste is the root cause for reservation, why there's no movement to abolish caste system? Everyone is Hindu, we worship same god, culture is same(with some changes depending on location) .
Reservation are in only in job and education apart from that in sports, entertainment industry u get only few who are succeeded that can be counted with bare hands. Even in the entry stages in sports, entertainment industry etc they ask "which caste are u?" If he or she belongs to lower caste,they don't even let he/she go further , that's y u don't even know anyone in sports, entertainment industry etc who are from lower caste.
All we need is social respect, banning caste system will provide that, later reservation can be given on the basis of Income.
@@takeshikovaich8824
I wish I could sue u for lying like a mf. Neither in sports nor in entertainment industry ppl ask abt caste. Caste is not even needed until we pass class 12 and enter college, coz from there merit dies n caste reservation starts. So shut up. I’m a Dalit. Hve been into sports all my life. Never once had anybody asked me abt my caste. Nor once i was ever barred from entering any temples. My caste came into okay when I applied for engg colleges and then jobs for govt sector.
Now get lost.
He is not talking about abolishing reservation. He is talking about improving the reservation system by providing reservation on the basis of individuals. Whats the problem with that. Billionaires getting reservation on the basis is right?? Or people in need
@@chinmayhegde615 then why don't u say just demolish caste system properly, remove caste word from all entrance forms and every kind of form and then apply reservation system on the basis of occupation and wtever...?
It would be a easy option..
Ask your parents that you want to marry someone from different caste then you will find how castism is rooted in Indian society 😂
So? Even Hatred for LGBT is but we bring laws and change it. But for casteism we bring laws to ensure this divide remains even in future
@@tejasbhagat4444 your community is responsible for that dude
how marriage= to casteism? stop reading saumyak bs
@@Changinglives2000Because some parents don't accept intercaste marriage because they think their child caste gets polluted by lower blood.
@@Changinglives2000 dude, a girl was burned alive in front of the village and the boy was killed 😭 in Bihar. Stop the cap 😠
This guy comes from a highly privileged family and he lived 52 years in America.
When u can't argue the Logic, then u attack a person's upbringing. It means u have lost the argument.
@@archigoel The guy is privileged and didn't experienced casteism how it's feel like to be on the receiving end of the oppressing system. It's just like asking Britishers how to run india Or How to end racism to a white guy.
@@bond69690 play identity politics .
Education makes you privileged in modern times not nepotism. You leftists just want to demonise him
He exited the country when the country made laws to generalise on caste reservations. He left the country when he saw low marks earning brainless people sitting on top of talented people, as bosses, just because they have a caste certificate. He left the country when Indira Gandhi brought a law to snatch farmer lands, especially the APMC act and the genocide of Brahmins in Konkani coast done by the so called non-violence supporters who wanted to avenge Gandhi's death.. you guys crib so much about mob lynching.. lemme tell you that after the horrific partition, the very first mob-lynch of a big public figure, that happened, was when an innocent doctor Nanarao Savarkar was lynched and killed in public by these so called Gandhians, just because he was Veer Savarkar's brother. And they call Savarkar a apologist, the reality is every second or third letter which Nehru and Gandhi have written to the British, ends with "your most faithful and obedient servant of the British Empire, MK Gandhi".. and why wasn't any Congress leader ever sent to Kala Pani jail in Andaman? You say highly privileged family, but the fact is, check his family condition in India before leaving to US.. He left the country because the laws in the country compromised with talent, instead of honouring legitimate talent based on examinations.. and don't you listen when he mentioned that those who are still facing any discrimination in rural areas, must be considered in the individual based reservation system.. but then the same privilege cannot extend to a SC ST person in urban India who is the son of an IAS officer who also became IAS despite low marks in UPSC, just because of reservation.. or a urban taxi driver SC ST dad whose son is studying in a university.. different people are on different levels of privilege.. if you exclude the 3-4 major temples of the south, most of the other temples in Tamil Nadu especially in small towns, the pujaris don't get any good salary at all.. first of all the temples are under the hands of govt appointed beaurocrats, instead of setting them free.. just for example compare the income of an ISKCON pujari with the income of a small pujari of a govt controlled temple in south.. there is tremendous difference.. the TN govt submitted a report to TN High Court stating that 11000 temples in the state have only 1 person taking care each, and he does the job of a pujari, of a cleaner as well as security guard.. and the DMK and AIADMK goons just simply brush white paint on the intricate ancient carvings.. and about 12000 other temples in TN are lying down in ruins now.. no one taking care of them.. temples should not be under state control.. or else take mosques and churches also under state control if u have guts.. when all these atrocities against Brahmins and the non-SC STs are being unleased by the inconsiderate govt, that was the time Rajiv Malhotra decided to leave the country.. that was a time when due to shitty policies in India, a lot of honest talent ran away to the US.
Now inventors of caste are blaming the British for caste system what a hypocrite.😂😂😂😂
Yes 😂 and if britisher made cast system then why these so called upper cast people r practicing it and in there temples also that's mean the whole hindu religion is made by britishers na 😂
@@krishgautam9090 caste is a Portuguese word brother. Also
the person who wrote ramayan used to be a daku
@@PranjalJha-k4m jaat paat ye bhi Portuguese hai kya
@@krishgautam9090 pehle Varna system follow Kiya jata tha jo ki profession based tha phir dhire dhire ye change kyonki logon main superiority complex aa gaya birth based bante gaya aur class system ek time pe saari societies follow karti thi unfortunately.
It's not Rahul Gandhi....it's Rajiv Gandhi
thats not important here😇
hahah gand nhi jlaate jaada
Yes, I was wondering how he forgot his own name.
Lol@@iamelsy
"There were Dalits billionaires " during the formation of the constitution 😂😂😂
Bruh 😂
Billionaire Dalits?...bruh maybe he mean OBC people who already were landlords that time so it can be but mostly Dalits are poor farmers or menial job workers that time,now days still they are farmers and labourers
@@truthtalker9375 Exactly 💯, Dalits were not even allowed to have basic human needs and he says "Dalits billionaires " , I agree with some other things he said but this one is bullshit.
Jogendra nath mandal was dalit billionaire in 1947
@Aditi Tegwal well then discrimination is not one way upper against dalit either. Dalit vs non dalit is also reality as well as dalit against maha dalit. So this whole upper oppressing lower is a big fat media creation which is baseless as the dalit against non dalit occurs with equal frequency. So prejudice is not one sided so portraying it as one sided is ridiculous and portraying one side as innocent victims is ridiculous
@Aditi Tegwal you know what, jogendra mandal was a politician who was dalit right then.
If you say how many dalits in politics, then how many upper castes do you know in business or trade? By and large less. People tend to follow what their ancestors are doing and many of it is not necessarily discrimination.
Most of the kings of the biggest empires were lower caste right whether chandragupta maurya or ashoka? When the lower castes themselves were rulers thousands of years ago, how on earth can they claim discrimination?
Most of the politicians today are lower caste. And where does lack of facilities have to do with caste anyway? If an upper caste stays in a very backward place, do they get any special facilities? Just like you expect me to see things holistically, we also expect the same from you instead of pushing a victimhood narrative and portraying one side as dominant bad and the other as innocent oppressed. Just like you expect upper caste to treat lower caste right, others also expect lower caste to treat upper caste right. One has to acknowledge the flaws at their end also instead of always fingerpointing the other side even when the other side is not responsible for their own self inflicted issues
Indian caste system is not the creation of British rulers...it existed in India long before the arrival.of British . The caste differences still persist.
What is the Criminal Tribes Act ?
Britishers invented caste system. That’s why I go live in their country (USA Uk same difference).
Critical race theory is hogwash in India between Brahmins and Dalits (for example) but somehow is valid in the USA between blacks and whites.
Person being a farmer from a rural background is less than a city cab driver from the same background. Brahmanical privilege is non existent because I benefit from it but accent privilege is real because I don’t have an American accent even though I live there.
British corrupted and twisted it.
Caste is there in ramayan mahabharatha.
Your show always helps me to know about religion, history,global issues. Love from🇧🇩🇧🇩
All good in Bangladesh ? Hope you and your family keeping well there. 👍
Dude this is not unbiased history. Read books rather than this.
Mr. Malhotra is my hero. He motivated me to combat the false narratives against Hindus. I'm happy to report that a letter I wrote my newspaper was included today. I already mailed the 2nd letter. It was titled:. Crucial context regarding India and was a rebuttal to another writer saying India was on Open Door Ministries list of countries persecuting Christians. My sequel is about the Kashmiri Pandits. I live in a conservative part of U.S. I'm an Indian-origin immigrant from Guyana. Karma has millions of Hindus strategically placed around the globe.
Good luck with your work 🙏 Thank you for your service as a soldier of Dharma in your own way🙏
So inspirational best of luck to you difficult to do things in which u dont see direct monetary benefits but this things have a huge impoact in the long run
“Karma has placed Hindus… globe”. What does this mean?
@@msms3260 what it means to me is: Regardless of what brought Hindus to different parts of the world, we can engage in self-interest or we can engage in confronting the false narratives that have been peddled by the two younger religions. It means Hindus have to stand up. It means it's time to stop cowering and hiding but to be proud of my Dharma enough to explain, defend and protect. That is the meaning to me.
@@kausalyabahadur7667 May i follow you on Instagram or any other social media?
Please talk about caste system to whom which is affected by it . There are many scholars from that background also. Plz bring them to your channel and talk to them. Thank you
Please bring Dr Suraj Yengade for this topic and multilateral views of the caste system throughout the world...
His theory is just copy paste American narrative on racism.
He is a urban naxal , Rajeev Malhotra has unravelled his connections with Harvard humanities board and equality labs , which he co - founded
Suraj Yengde is a bootlicker of the Western Black intellectuals. He is one of the snakes in Harvard, he is anything but objective. But I do agree he should interviewed and his points debunked on a live podcast.
Nope. He should bring in learned people. Yengade is more of hearsay. He is whatsapp University with Harvard packaging.
Bhagwat Gita chapter no 9 Shlokas no 32 says shudra and women are born in papyoni
"Caste base discrimination dosen't exists in modern India" - upper caste
Caste made by britisher 😂😂
Then why upper castes practices strictly, is this also given by britishers nonsense...
If you want know about test of wine Then meet with who drunk it not to who made it ok... caste gives very pain who bear it but it is only word for others.
Come at "science journey" or "the realist azad" for live debate.
Come to Sanatana Samsiskha if you have balls, kiddo and he will expose your Buddhist caste system.
@arjyachatterjee6874 Abe pehle TANATAN KINDU DHARMA KA CASTISM DEKH....😅😅😅
Beacuse it has been rooted to society ,if you call someone and treat him like upper caste after some period of time they will became addicted to it and when you won't give them they will feel bad it is just reality of every human being.
@@ShalabhKumar-n6rare bhau buddisam to sanatan darm se hi nikala he Agar history badate Hoge to Pata hoga
Name the Dalit billionaires?
Rajiv M is biased against Dalits and Adivasis.
He expressed his prejudices.
There is no such thing as Adivasis. Just Vanvasis. Tribes which are isolated.
Check networth of Babasaheb Ambedkar some day
Catholic school boi name one billionaire from rajput community of up?
As usual anti-hindu Missionary propaganda using dalit victimhood
@@mrshadowcool174is not both r same
Reservation based on Caste is must til there is Discrimination based on Caste. Forget rest of shit.
Whatever we may discuss on caste system, but ultimately we know this system is causing deep problems in india
They will never accept that their religion allowed a practice (caste system) which had done more harm to nation than good
If asked a question they will use word play
And will confuse u between caste and varna. But on ground everyone knows what the reality of this caste system .
Our ancestors have to fight for water and still today the fight is on we are not even allowed to perform
last rites at a public cemetery
How do u know about the past? Who told you? RajivJi information is from the primary sources.
@@archigoel
Mahad satyagraha 1927
Led by Dr BR Ambedkar to allow people to acess water from public facilities
And many more recorded facts are there
I just don't have that much time to put it down here. Do your homework
@freidrick-neitzsche British Missionary started their propaganda work in 1800s.
Portuguese missionary started much earlier.
Can you show where it is written in shastras that Caste System exists and some people should be discriminated against ?
@@devolishash3946
Manusmriti
Everyone want to abolish reservation from those lower caste peoples who r doing good in life but no body is talking about abolish caste system properly and then make reservation system as per need wise.
Why???
What is caste system? The govt maintains the caste system, when it says this person will be discriminated "against" from birth.
@@archigoel upper caste people's are also equally involved in discrimination.
No one from Upper ever talk about abolis all the caste, nobody will be Gen pbs SC st , all are human beings.
I'm not Brahmin while my father is....as a Bangladeshi🇧🇩 Hindu we made caste based on our occupation not family background as far as Bhagavad Gita said. NOWADAYS it's very common to us!!! And that is how 16 million Hindu still survive here...
Power to you guys!!
May hindus keep surviving in all muslim majority nation more power to hindus and hope they dont discrimination and support fellow hindu, be united be safe 🙏
The state politics didn’t just kill soemthing called as your gothra ,but also your belief on how your ancestor used to look at it.
Angreziyat 😁.. He defined british evil ideology so precisely. .. He nailed it 😂.. Person talking in fluent english language is privileged this is also casteism was another sixer 🏏
@@achieved81u Says a telugu/malayalam guy
@@Horizon429 Wow language destroying other language logic. It only justifies India's education system sucks.
@@rayyanabdulwajid7681 ya they hate hindi. 🙊
@@reenapalav8000they don't hate Hindi but people who force them to do certain things which they are not comfortable of doing 🥲
Bhagwat Gita chapter no 9 Shlokas no 32 says shudra and women are born in papyoni
I absolutely agree that reservation should be on income basis not caste bases
Discrimination happens based on 'Caste', not 'Income'. If poor savarn is unable to go to school and college because of money, then tell me how the hell reservation will going to help him?
All Poor people need Free education, irrespective of his caste, whereas all Lower caste people need reservation, irrespective of his economic condition. Because Untouchable always remains untouchable in the eyes of discriminators, whether untouchable is poor or rich.
Right
@@nareshkumar3526 discrimination happened based on religion also. What should be done for it?
@@nareshkumar3526 Naresh ji, I'm not anti reservation, but I believe if the parents got the reservation then their child must not get it. They had the shot, they missed it. Do you agree on this?
@@A_Dasgupta No, Reservation is not a 'Caste improving machine'.
Untouchable will not become a brahmin after reservation.
Caste is bound to birth which cannot be changed in the eyes of discriminators.
But Yes I agree that Rich Lower caste people gets less discrimination as compared to poor lower caste. But it doesn't means that Upper caste community will stop doing discrimination when lower class person becomes rich.
If you really want to remove reservation, then ask government to make education mandatory, gave equal lands to lower community as well, all exams and interview should be based on Roll Number i.e, no one would know name of candidate until final selection. Then yes, I would have no problem removing reservation.
i know persons whose parents are rich, well settled, educated but are not able to give up their caste, treats their girl like a shit force her to marriage, not giving her freedom etc... I think there is more internal work to do in sanathana dharma and reform the societyyy as a whole
That happens because of lack of getting on with modernity.
They can make their daughters dress in beautiful chudidar best girls dress still give them freedom to pursue their dreams.
Western dress culture doesn't suit parents there it ends
The problem with the English speaking
Indian us that they doesn't understand the ground reality of caste in India. I just want to ask him just mention 5 dalit billionaire. I know that reservation are misused by some community and government need to fixed it, but this doesn't mean that we start giving reservation on basis on income in which about 50-60 percent of Indian will be cover and the entire concept of reservation will be destroyed. And lastly I also accept that changes need to done in system of reservation so that majority of sc/st/obc community find it beneficial.
not the majority of sc st but the really deprived ones...those whose parents have already availed the benefit of the reservation system and now living a luxurious or above-average life are not really in need of reservation.
It will be good when financial help will be given on basis caste + economic background ( if they need it)
Kuchaa ataaa jtaaa haiii nhii upper caste kaaaa title rakhh keeee bakiatii Kerr diyaaa .murkh auratt pehlee kulll aurrr kull Devi kaaaa concept smjho
Exactly .look at these 2 Gupta and baniya they are proud of their lcaste
I am a Brahmin I was always treated badly when my college friends came to know about my caste they used to call me "kharkate brahmin" also in my office they used to call me names. I never bothered coz I never knew the caste system was so deep rooted. Now I am realizing people mistreated me coz of my caste
Brahmins are being persecuted in India everywhere because of their stubborn allegiance to hindu dharm .they never were kings, political powers , but still people blame them for discrimination just because they never retailiate just ignore and do their work .
Are u from Maharashtra
@@sahilsagwekar no
@@sahilsagwekar yes
I also got discriminated many times for being brahmim in a Christian missionary school... I don't know the reason then but now I realise that they were dalits who got converted to Christianity but the hatred towards brahmins will never go from them.... It's all half baked truth that have been told everytime by their political akaas to satisfy their political fantasy.
Nice word play. The caste system has caused many fellow Indians and allies to be historically alienated from the hindus like the Jains, who left is disappointment when caste atrocities were at its peak owing to their ahimsa atheistic philosophies. This was way before the British came into the picture. In fact the caste system divided hindus into so many feuding sects that we couldn't consolidate power to stand up to larger adversaries like the Moghuls and the British and translated to india's extraordinary economic decline which was already in motion before the East India company came to our shores. These two colonisers saw the caste segregation as a weakness and exploited it, they didn't create it, it already existed and there is much historic proof of that. And they succeeded, they saw how much Brahmins enjoyed looking down on lower castes so they gave them advisory positions and high ranks to keep indians further squabbling amongst themselves so we'd be occupied in our own mess while they looted the country uninterrupted.
India doesn't have diversity, it has the illusion of it. India is a deeply segregated society where each faction hardly interacts with each other. So on the outside it may seem like a lot of communities are co-existing with each other but the boundaries in-between are controlled by forces of caste, gender, superstitions and stereotypes who have been gatekeeping it making cross cultural exchange a massive challenge. That's why you have the North-South divide on everything from tax money to identity to linguistic fuedalism. Malhotra has to appeal to ignorance by saying "there must have been support for diversity for it to exist" knowing well this isn't the case and facts aren't on his side. We have come a very long way and we should celebrate that but with some degree of intellectual honesty.
Agreed. It's just that this has become borderline dangerous now, and for what? Some views.
Classical English view point.
@io mn The caste system was always rigid, what changes did they bring for it to appear "more" rigid in comparison to post and pre British era. If anything they alleviated it slightly by giving Dalits education in missionary schools... Although they did it primarily to proselytise, for lower castes it was a "something better than nothing" situation.
@@utkarsh_yash it's not the language that decides the depth of "viewpoint" but the points themselves. Classic excuse for not owning up to our objectionable history!
Nice word play in this comment for sure
This is the same person who asked Bill Gates money so hell give him back to him in his next life. Interlufe deposits😂😂😂
Two "upper castes" discussing Casteism. Hilarious it is!!😂😂 I hope they end up calling it all "Dalit's" fault.
So to think also you need a certificate?
😂😂
Wait !... would you talk with a 'white man' to understand racism.
Then why would you ask a savarna to understand the caste system ....
Your whole talk is casteist....
Your understanding of caste is wrong caste lives in cities....
Discrimination in cities comes in acts of micro-aggression. In offices in living spaces.
The white man is the one that invented the caste system. The British held a conference of churches in Madras in the 1870s where they mentioned that the jatis were the major obstacle in conversions to Christianity. Lord Herbert Risley then created a hierarchy of jatis and divided them into so called castes by birth. This did not exist before. Next the British forced all people to select one of these castes to satisfy the census beginning 1880s. Thus everyone began confirming to castes to meet census requirements. Did the Rajputs invent the Rajput regiment? No, it was the British. Did the Sikhs invent the Jat regiment? No. it was the British. 60% of all kings in India were Shudras. They were also 60 to 80% of students and teachers in the Indian education system.
You are asking a murder to get the solution for a murdered.
Looks like Ranveer's editing team never leave the room, they really did just put Rahul Gandhi beside Indira Gandhi 😂
Ranveer do something to eradicate harassing low caste people pls
God bless you
Malhotra seems to be a bodyguard of 'Brahmins'
He is bodyguard of baman-vaad
He's body guard for logic..you label it as Brahmin waad is nice. Coz you actually are appreciating Brahmins.
@@tejasbhagat4444 ambedkarite buddhist community has never entertained Brahmins, go learn something frnd
Rigthfully so. Dalits are oppressing todays innocent Brahmins.
@@Batega_toh_Katega_Hindu_108 recently a brahmin called me untouchable and he said my blood is impure 😢
This is meaningless podcast ever done by my fav. TH-camr,
Dear Admin sir,
I believe, Hiran ka dard samjhne keliye, hiran se baat kijiye unhe invite kijiye, Shikari kese bata sakta h,
So, You need to call upon opressed(Hiran) to share his perspectives and reality over the issue. Like *Prof.Dilip Mandal, Dr. Suraj Yengde* etc....
Your podcast is of totally Different level Sir Love from Assam
Joi Aai Axom ❤
He is itself Malhotra, so very easy to say based on income because he never faced caste discrimination so it's very to give faltu ka gyaaan , no one general person say to abolish the caste system in India but say to abolish reservation. Level of double standards.
why you use singh. use a lower caste surname. are you ashamed of using mahar, pasi etc?
@@Anomander5622you proved his point castist lindu .you bring out another main topic why people hide their surname because of avoiding discrimination from lindu like you .
This interview is like a Bangladeshi talking problem of Russian society 😂😂😂
I really love this old man, i always thought y my parents or grandparents didn't think this way about caste system which i understand this soon and also govt is so biased this way on job opportunities, he did what I always want to speak, i wanted to be like him
Who is stopping you? उत्तिस्था भारती
I also love this old man he has lot of so much knowledge
Old man ? Or a gentleman who has lived longer than you on earth ?
@@sudhirsehgal1143 , Haha, Old man, Uncle, Grand Pa, this is not even Angreziat Mr. Malhotra mentioning, this phenomena is Indianized Angreziat.
He is not just a old man, He is one of us and very dear to us and being an Indian he is as respectful to us as like a senior member of our family, This man is owed a lot by all of us, He has single handedly taken on the so called Left intellectuals be it Western or their sepoys in India, he has served Bhartiya specially Hindus and Bharat as a civilization and culture and Dharm also through his wisdom, knowledge and intellectualism which he has collected in his books which are going to be guiding source and force for us and generations to come, we can not do anything for him in person but we can heartily thanks him for his great service he has done to Dharm, he has also groomed new Sanatani Intellectual force under his precious guidance and supervision who will take the baton of dharm forward in future and lead the society on wards , He is real Dharmic kshatriya , GOI should also facilitate him with Padam Bhushan kind of honor for his work and this way we can contribute a little to recognize the greatness, dedication, hard pursuit of his work which we are not able to evaluate for now due to our shortsightedness, Rajiv ji ko sashtang dandvat pranam 🙏🙏🙏
English is required in many companies because you work in a team with people from all over the world. If your teammates cannot understand your ideas, your ideas are of no good. No matter how skilled you are, you cannot know everything. You always need to collaborate.
Then how is that Chinese are sucessful in engaging western English speaking businesses , we can have people learn English who have to deal with foreign business but we don't need to speak colonial language in our daily life...!
Not gonna lie but Japanese are more skillful without knowing english for their own country. Since they rely on themself than other countries. First we need priority ourselves more than others.
@@mr.d2124 FYI, China does not do highly technical job. Chinese economy is built on monotonous work on assembly line. Technological advancement in China are mostly cheap copy of Russian and Western technology. As China does not follow international laws, other cannot cannot do much when their technology is copied.
@@firetoofan5555 Japanese companies builds technology from scratch. They have patented many technology. Do you think Infosys, Wipro, TCS, HCL builds any technology? They are service based companies. Indian high skilled job market is service based. You need to know English to work on a Service sector.
@@shameekd9192 Not denying ur word instead of doing that whole crap. Priorities our language first for privacy. Then English.
There is NO RELIGION CALLED Hinduism! It's Bramhanism, Caste is integral part of Bramhanism 😍
True 😂
Before commenting on reservation
1st need to STOP insulting so called saying low caste
If this guy faces low caste harassment then he never speaks of reservations
Sir get ur facts right recently I went through a reseach there is no low caste harassment atleast in cities its now only in rural areas. Second I am a mbbs students ask me what reservation affect us. i got 94 percentile payed 50 lakhs just for 3 years now. this low caste how comes fairly upper middle class family every year waste 10000-15000 seats because they come at 70% and then can not compete this pressure.And this same seats are sold to open for double price. and more or less its every wher in engineering etc.
@@vishwasparab am neet aspirant but let's visit my village in u.p then gets your fact correct
So Mr. Malhotra did you not know about literacy rate in India about and at what level of involvement of AI in India's Caste system . All you just heard one word AI from somewhere and cover up the atrocities due to caste system and blame reservation. What could I say for him hypocrite, he doesn't say anything against caste syste .
Dear Ranveer If you really want to know whether there is casteism in our country or not, then visit rural India and you will know everything.This person is trying to justify the castism, and instead of the upper caste people, he is blaming the western world. The fact is that this person has a problem with the reservation given to Dalits. The irony is that this person himself is from the upper caste and comes here to talk about Dalits. Please call someone from Dalit community also to hear their side.
Very well said
The Temple Entry Proclamation was issued by Maharaja Chithira Thirunal Balarama Varma on November 12, 1936. The Proclamation abolished the ban on the so-called 'low caste people' or avarnas from entering Hindu temples in the Princely State of Travancore, now part of Kerala, India.
Rajiv ji is a gem. He has done fabulous work for Sanatan. ❤❤
Caste moulds an individual as a psychopath
The white man is the one that invented the caste system. The British held a conference of churches in Madras in the 1870s where they mentioned that the jatis were the major obstacle in conversions to Christianity. Lord Herbert Risley then created a hierarchy of jatis and divided them into so called castes by birth. This did not exist before. Next the British forced all people to select one of these castes to satisfy the census beginning 1880s. Thus everyone began confirming to castes to meet census requirements. Did the Rajputs invent the Rajput regiment? No, it was the British. Did the Sikhs invent the Jat regiment? No. it was the British. 60% of all kings in India were Shudras. They were also 60 to 80% of students and teachers in the Indian education system.
@@dheerajnavin-pr4zx There is no "caste idea" found in the Bhagavad Gita. Caste is such as foreign idea that even the supreme court of India has not been able to define caste in a way that stays true to Indian society. The Bible is discriminates against non-Christians. The Catholic church went further and classed non-Christians as non-human beings (person non grata) whose lands and lives could be taken over via the Doctrine of Discovery. This laid the moral foundation for the Christian genocide across the world, most heavily in the Americas where upwards of 95% of the population was wiped out. The British themselves starved and killed upwards of 105 million Indians to death.
@@taitreyarr2715 Friend, I have no excuse for what the British did in India. Most of them did not act according to the teachings of the Bible their holy book. BIBLE does not discrimate against non-Christians. In Galatians 3:28 of the Bible we clearly read : There is neither Jew nor Greek ( gentile), there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are ALL ONE in Christ Jesus. The sanctitity and dignity of every humanbeing is clearly emphasized in the Bible. Jesus' message in John 3:16 of the Bible is clear and for all mankind: God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that WHOEVER believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life.
What so called Christians have done or do and what the Bible teaches are two different things.
@@dheerajnavin-pr4zx It is actually "So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, 27 for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. 28 There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29 If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise." So you are equal only if you are Christian. If you do not believe in Christ, you will burn in hell. Of that there is no dispute in Christianity. This is what leads Christians to the most genocidal of any religious people in history, Any religion can only be judged one parameter, which is the effect it has on its followers. The effect in Christianity is to turn adherents genocidal. The British were not doing anything different. They were playing by the book.
In India Our Constitution has abolished practice of Caste Discrimination.We have framed various welfare legislation for upliftment of SC/ST. Reservation policy is such a constitutional privilege. Does US have corresponding Laws in favour of Blacks, who were liberated as Slaves
Initially it was a good idea but Giving Reservation for this long years to SC/ST just on the basis of caste is not a good thing. Some with even annual income of more than 1cr enjoying this system.
Reservation is caste discrimination. How can caste discrimination be abolished when it is promoted in the form of reservation?
Reservation is caste discrimination
Promotion of diversity does not require the caste system.
How does he know that Dalits are millionaires and Brahmins are poor when he lived in the USA for more than fifty years? He knows nothing about the social structure. Caste is not only a division of labour but that of labourers also.
Obviously this guy Malhotra hasn't suffered from caste discrmination! Reservation system has helped low caste people to come up in life.
What about reservations of Kashmiri Pandits ?
Caste is invention of Hinduism or sanatan dharma. When people converted to other religions from Hindu eg Sikh, Christianity and Islam their social status didn't change and society didn't forget their caste. That's why you see caste in other religions in india. It's not the case for Muslims and Christians outside india.
Main difference between class which you find in almost every feudal society and caste in India is
1. Caste was determined by birth with no social mobility
2. Endogamy no intercaste marriages especially with lower caste or out caste (both are different).
3. No where in the world it was sanctioned by religion like we did.
Last anybody who is blaming Muslims or British for caste discrimination is purposefully lying.
What was estates of realm in France, kiddo ?
I belong to matang community according to your brahman Dharma I'm chandala ( untouchable ) matangi (green Tara) is the goddess of mahavidya there are so many Temple's of matangi in India like minakshi-amman temple Karnataka , Tarapith west Bengal and tuljabhawani Maharashtra if she born in my caste why you don't give us reservation in Temple committee
Their hypocrisy 💹💹
Mr Rajiv Mehrotra ur study is excellent,but i differ to say that people pf so called higher castes still try to demean & hr having grudges against so called lower caste.
When Caste is determined by birth .. then why the reservations should be income based and not be caste based ?
This guy totally fails at steelmanning the argument. Doesn't at all look at every aspect.
Upper caste will aalwaays. Spin the argument to keep power to thmselves
Muslim society has the concept of purity and pollution of caste. The lower-class (Ajlaf) Muslims of the region have faced other forms of discrimination. Upper-class (Ashraf) Muslims dominated government jobs and parliamentary representation. There have been cases in which upper caste Muslims have opposed the burial of lower caste Muslims in the same cemetery. A study found that there exists a caste hierarchy in the Muslim community. The Sweeper Group is ranked the lowest. Other Muslim communities do not allow sweepers to touch the cooking vessels of upper ranking groups of Muslims.
Ae Hussain tu bhangi ko apna damad bnaega kya
@@googlesharma4477 then just say we beleive in our c@ste superiority n move on....why is this malhotra trying hard to deny it 😂🤣
he in other interviews says that c@ste is fluid....so if ur doctr you become shudr@ 🤣😂
@@googlesharma4477Ye btao koi trika h jisse insan ki na caste rhe na religion. Agar hota ho to batana.
@@rohitpratap5946 toh kya kar loge tum aisa karke
3:15 it takes courage & knowledge for even Rajiv Malhotra....
Bhagwat Gita chapter no 9 Shlokas no 32 says shudra and women are born in papyoni
This complete video is like present distorted facts and information in good well mannered english.😂😂😂
Yes its true caste system did not exist in india ...but it was varna vyavastha based on profession...caste is not same as varna...it is a Portuguese concept....the British misused the varna vyavastha and imposed caste system into india
Bhramins made this caste and Varna and discriminated certain class of people for almost 2 millenium. Read properly
Awesome!!! real use of technology i.e. AI should be implemented
Reservation should be based on a weighted average score of backwardness calculated using a number of different factors such as Educational Background, Economic Background, Geographical Background & Societal/Caste Background. Each factor should carry certain weightage out of the total and each individual should be assessed based on his background and assigned a score for each individual factor.
At last a weighted average score based on all the factors should be calculated and this score should be used for giving reservation.
Caste based blanket reservation just doesn't serve the purpose.
No apart from SC st no one deserves reservation
@@gowrijanga6976 And who gave you the authority to decide which arbitrary group gets reservation and which group doesn't..!!??
This is exactly the sick mentality of self entitlement of being the judge, the jury and the executioner which the policy of reservation should seek to abolish.
Let the entire process of reservation be democratized and given to all those who are actually in need rather than confining it to a select few arbitrary groups.
@@sdtinu yes dash.l am totally in favour of you let this caste system reservation has to death down ,those resources Equalizer equatably to every caste.caste system has become rigid ,don't make everything that it never exist ,it exists
@@sdtinuI think we need to demolish Hinduism and caste system both and make Humanity as Religion where everyone are equal so no need to give reservation and people will live in peace and with brotherhood 😄
@@truthtalker9375 Honestly anarchy is never a solution to any problem and this mindset of annihilating Hinduism and caste system is anarchy of the highest order and discriminatory to be frank. And this theme of equality is a utopian concept which is not achievable and honestly not at all desirable at the same time. This only sounds good when you are in college or while writing an essay or debating someone. But when you come out of the theoretical world and enter the practical realm you realise that equality is not at all practical. Equality of opportunity on the other hand is something we can strive for. Social stratification is a reality of society. You understand this when you start working in a job or start earning in the real world. In my view caste is not a bad thing but caste discrimination is certainly bad and evil to be exact. The best you can do is be proud of your caste/work and be appreciative of others.
They have only one excuse - Britishers for caste system and Aryan dravid conflict,😂😂😂
It is actually Rajiv Gandhi’s time! Correction!
Reservation and special consideration should be based on individual needs, disadvantage and deprivation. It should not be collective, cast or religion based which will be abused by politicians using divide and rule methods!
Bruh tell me at Ramanujacharaya's time which politician divided into caste and religion?... because he fought for discrimination in 11th century so it is not from just few years but form many decades
Excellent interview.
Castism is written in Indian scriptures like bhagwat Geeta, valmiki ramayan, rigved.
Anyone who says otherwise is either a lier or a foolish I can give you exact shloks.
Caste discrimination is rooted not in religion but culture. Caste was an ancient system of occupational class delineated in Hindu texts that over the years developed into a rigid social hierarchy. The lowest castes, or untouchables, were marginalized and faced persecution. Caste-based discrimination is not intrinsic to Hinduism and should not be thought of as religiously sanctioned. the poorer workers involved in 'unclean' occupations such as sweeping or leather work were historically segregated and banished outside the city limits. Over time, personal cleanliness came to be identified with "purity", and the concept of untouchability eventually spread to the rural areas. Manusmriti text was never implemented as a law code in ancient India. The caste system as it exists today is the result of developments during the rise of the British colonial government in India. The British Raj furthered this development, making rigid caste organisation a central mechanism of administration. By 1860 the British formulated the caste system into their system of governance, granting administrative jobs and senior appointments only to Christians and people belonging to certain castes.
@@snehashispanda4808 this thesis of your have any evidence or just a fictitious creation of your mind to feel good about yourself and your caste, and hindu religion?
Because I can give you specific caste based discrimination instances from valmiki ramayan, geeta, manusmriti.
And don't tell these boos are written after British Empire.
@@snehashispanda4808 hinduism is caste system, actually you can't even call this religion Hinduism, because nowhere in the scriptures the word hindu appears .
This religion was called brahman dharma.
@@RohitRaj-rd7tl yup absolutely that's why am ex-hindu/atheist here
Cast शब्द यूरोप में इबेरिया प्रायद्वीप में स्थित देशों पुर्तगाल और स्पेन में प्रचलित है जिसका मूल लैटिन भाषा के chasta शब्द में है जिसका अर्थ है शुद्धता purity Casta का अर्थ हुआ खून की शुद्धता जो कि इस क्षेत्र में नस्लीय शुद्धता को इंगित करता है । जब यूरोपीय उपनिवेश भारत आए । उन्होंने इस ढांचे (term) को भारत पर लागू कर दिया । लंबा इतिहास है 🙏
LMAO... Isnt he the same guy who proposed first inter life trust managemenet startup idea with Nithyananda??
Yes.
'Interiors of India' .. caste system. You seem to automatically assume that "upper caste brahmins" oppress "lower caste dalits". It is the OBCs who used to be Kings and ruling and warrior class - are oppressing brahmins and dalits. Also we read about dalit doing honour killing because dalit was in love with brahmin.
It's become a fashion and habit to blame brahmins every time.
They have been the always targeted as the reason for oppressing the lower caste. This thought is engraved during past 200 or so in British era
Cast system comes from hindu religion and hindu texts . Brahmins positioned themselves in highest authority of religion .. sanskrit languages and hindu texts are always remained in occupation of hindu text so who spread this poison of division ..... Many hindu texts refers so much deregetory things about people belong to certain cast ... Who wrote in those texts .. it's not only confined to Sanskrit texts but was also there in many local texted written in local languages .. people who blame british only wish to white wash there crimes against indians ... British took advantage of it what already exist in hindu society ...
Well vedas rigveda gives definition of four varna, yajurveda mentions definition of chandal and nishadha which is proof of birth based varna system and discrimination, mahabharat has many stories about birth based varna system ( check what " sut" in sutputra karna means) , bhagwat Gita talks about paap yoni etc and says one must do work of varna he was born into no matter how bad he was at it, and never do work of other varna no matter how good he is at it, (bhagwatGita 18:47)....with this context all Gita is actually trying to implement birth based varna system and discrimination out of which caste system originated. So caste discrimination is a religious problem that needs to be addressed.
Oh chacha😔
What happened for centuries, can't be calibrated in decades.😒😡
What's your proof that caste system existed in India for centuries ?
@@arjyachatterjee6874 Dude, you are delusional. We have statistics, written records, government data, etc. Apne aap ko itna bewakoof kyu prove kar rhe ho?
@@arjyachatterjee6874I guess you belong from upper cast that's why you have never seen caste system 😂
Rajiv sir is a legend. We should get inspired and be like him.
I see where he's coming from. But its probably not safe for a state to collect data en-masse and feed into an AI algorithm without fully understanding the implications of what might happen. For something like this to work you would need serious privacy preserving tech which helps you collect data as an aggregate without identifying specific individuals.
OMG!! This guy is really the king of manipulators and liars. But sad for him, the caste system he is dreaming to bring back is not coming back. Sorry
there is only one solution to end casteism ,is to do inter marriages ,if you are a 3rd generation hindu make it a point that you will not marry in your own caste
really cool idea this can change the country for the better
SANATAN DHARMA promotes unity through diversity 🙏 Jai Bharata!
I thought he will speak about caste system, but he was deviated towards same thing " Reservation " and " British imposed Caste " .
I am myself a victim of caste atrocity from 15 years, today govt using IAS officer to cover up matter. In these past 15 years no one came to help us or even tried to stop it. It is like PARAMPARA that continues. We asked for legal aid, but denied with fake excuses. Now I want to fight and to fight I want to study Law, but I have no money for Law collage.
There are cases, which fails to get headline. When I hear "British bought Caste " I wonder who were the people doing atrocity before British ?
spelled College.
@@SigmaAvi : There was no caste system before the british. There was only Varna system which was based on profession and qualities or gunas which was acquirable and was not decided entirely by birth. Viswamitra became brahman from kshatriya. A four member family could have 4 different varnas. Valmiki had a stint as a thief before turning into the compiler of Ramayana. Moreover there was no higher or lower varna as each profession was important in its own way. Perunthachan was a highly renowned and respected blacksmith of pre-british India in Kerala.
@@pamelapati1219 I am 33 years old, sick, it created a rukus in my brain. I have very weak memory now,hard to remember everything. At age 31 joined a class, where I read english grammar with students twice younger than me in age.
@@thereisnospoon123 Might be but current situation is not same. I am 33 years old trying to get admission after 12th to study law. Caste play vital role. I speak with experience, evidence, legal documents nothing fictional..
You become Indian when you leave India..... You are divided in castes when you are in India😢😢😢
True
@@ayushimishra1912 and the credit goes to... 😂😂
Amazing... After ABHIJIT sir I like this MAN ...
Untouchables ke liye koi economic criteria nahi , ye social and psychological he . Caste based reservation for untouchables to ensure representation.
Errata.....at 0.58 should be "Rajiv Gandhi" instead of "Rahul Gandhi" 🙏🙏
Sir, u r just finding ways to justify evils of jaati system..
Jaati hierarchy was sanctioned by ritualistic purity ascribed to every caste, by brahmanical system... where the supreme caste brahmin kept them on top..
"ब्राह्मणों द्वारा जितने धर्मशास्त्र, स्मृति, पुराण, महाकाव्य आदि रचे गये, सबमें उन्होंने अपने स्वार्थ की बातें लिखीं और अपने स्वार्थ के लिए ही अन्य वर्ग को पशु के समान जीने के लिए विवश किया। विद्या, धर्मशास्त्र, धर्मकृत्य, ऊंचे पद, संन्यास आदि का अधिकारी अपने को माना और अन्य को, ज्यादातर तथाकथित शूद्रों को इनसे सर्वथा दूर रखा। यह सब पुरोहितों के द्वारा की जाने वाली चोरियां ही हैं। ब्राह्मणों के भेदभाव की नीति ने हिन्दू-समाज को कमजोर बनाकर रख दिया है। जाति-पांति का जहर हिन्दू धर्मग्रन्थों में उसी प्रकार समाया है जैसे दूध में पानी। आज भी उसका प्रभाव हिन्दू समाज पर छाया है।
यह भी ध्यान देने योग्य बात है कि ब्राह्मण नाम एक वर्ग है और संसार में किसी भी वर्ग के सारे लोग गलत नहीं होते हैं। ब्राह्मण वर्ग में रहे हुए पुरोहितों ने ही भेदभाव तथा छल-छद्म की नीति अपनायी है। इससे पूरा ब्राह्मण-समाज दोषी नहीं है। ब्राह्मणों में भी सदा-सर्वदा से कुछ ऐसे मानवतावादी चिन्तक होते आये हैं, जो ब्राह्मण पुरोहितों की भेदभाव-जनित व्यवस्था के घोर विरोधी तथा मानव-समानता के प्रबल पक्षधर रहे हैं। इस प्रकार ब्राह्मण-समाज में भी ब्राह्मण-व्यवस्था-विरोधी आग यत्र-तत्र सदैव सुलगती रही है, जिसके परिणाम में आचार्य बृहस्पति ने भौतिकवादी पक्ष लेकर ब्राह्मणों के कर्मकांडों की धज्जियां उड़ायी थीं। ब्राह्मण-व्यवस्था के विरोधी स्वर उपनिषद्, महाभारत, गीता आदि धर्मग्रन्थों में यत्र-तत्र देखे जा सकते हैं। ब्राह्मण समाज की संतान जैन, बौद्ध, सिद्ध-नाथ, कबीरपंथ तथा निर्गुणीधारा के नाना संप्रदायों में दीक्षित होकर ब्राह्मणवादी भेदभाव नीति का सदा घोर विरोध करती रही और भविष्य तो अधिक उज्ज्वल है। सद्गुरु कबीर ने तो उन्हीं ब्राह्मणों की यहां आलोचना की है जो विषमताजनित व्यवस्था के संस्थापक तथा परिपोषक रहे हैं। कबीर साहेब का उद्देश्य ब्राह्मण कहे जाने वाले वर्ग को न दुखाना है और न चिढ़ाना है। संत किसी को दुखाते नहीं। वे ब्राह्मणों को एक तथ्य सुझा रहे हैं। उन्हें सावधान कर रहे हैं। वे समझें और अपने आप को जाति और वर्णविहीन शुद्ध मानवतावादी स्तर पर लाने का प्रयत्न करें। इसी की आवश्यकता सब समय थी, आज तो अत्यावश्यक है ही।
केवल ब्राह्मण पुरोहित ही दोषी हों, ऐसी बात नहीं है, जहां कहीं भी, किसी भी परम्परा में पुरोहित होगा वह ऊंच-नीच का भेदभाव डालना शुरू ही करेगा। किसी पुराण में ब्रह्मा की महिमा की गयी, तो किसी पुराण में कृष्णगोपाल को ब्रह्म माना गया, किसी में शिव को सर्वोपरि कहा गया, तो किसी में भूत-प्रेतों की महिमा गायी गयी। जैनियों ने अपने तीर्थंकरों की महिमा कर उनकी पूजा का विधान किया, तो मुसलमानों ने अपनी पद्धति चलाकर नमाज पढ़ना आरम्भ किया। इसी तरह और अनेक गुरुओं-पुरोहितों के मार्ग निकले और वे अपने- अपने को मोक्ष तथा ईश्वर के एकाधिकारी घोषित करते रहे।" --कबीर बीजक व्याख्याकार श्री अभिलाष दास
@dhiren26 very true analytical knowledge
Being oblivious of caste system is itself a position of privilege owned by dominant caste. This knowledge is so superficial and full of biases. Ranveer if you really want to understand Indian caste system invite Dr. Suraj Yegde to the show to get the real perspective!
No, its not.
@@umax870 ha ha contrary to your belief system....sorry to say your words aren't the ultimate wisdom 😅
your Dr. suraj yegde keeps running away from debate with rajiv malhotra at harvard . look a rajeev sir channel he wants 500 million dollar to debate with rajeev sir . if he is true then why running away
@@Arya_BhattWhy do a great scholar need any approval from Rajeev Malhotra. Who's he??? Not even equally qualified as Dr. Suraj.
Dr. Suraj Yegde is an intelect par excellence. He's PhD from Harvard and currently doing post doctoral fellowship from Harvard. He's writer of Bestsellers like " Caste Matters". He has been awarded as 25 Most influential young Indians by GQ magazine. He has participanted in nany international events and now in reputed Hollywood movie as Dalit activist. His profile is far more impressive than Malhotra's. The only thing where Mr. Malhotra is ahead is the age! 😅 It's a global world. Sanatanis really need to come out of their megalomania!
@@AK-ct8bb arguements facts and logic matter more than educational qualification. and rajiv malhotra is not an ordinary guy why this so called intellectual keeps running away from debate . he is asking half a million dollar for just facing malhotra which itself speaks everthing . and getting in any hollywood movie is not an acheivement and does not make you any more credible leftist lobby is supporting him thats why. and bestsellers lol every influencer book becomes bestseller it means nothing . your dp already tells me everything i need to know . ask yegde to have the courage if he is such a big intellactual .
Ewual opportunity for all.
A Hindu from Guyana
Just because Rahul Gandhi was dismissed as Lok Sabha MP, you people reciprocated by putting his photo in the former PM frame🤣🤣
I’m upper caste in my school days I’m bullied by majority lower caste students and teachers in everywhere
Can u mention what are the things bullies said to u?
But have u ever been lynched?
Ha ha which planet you live in by the way?😂
{Long post, dont know how many will read it}
Purane Bharat me sab miljulke rehte the. Ye pichhle kuchh 600, 700 saal ka result hai, sab angrez logo ne kiya dhara hai. "Caste" to shabd hi introduce karvaya tha angrezo ne.
I understand, even at this time, lower castes are stereotyped in various remote areas of our country, but we need to understand the root/origin of this divisive policy.
_We had "Varna" system not caste system. Varna system was dynamic. Even a son/daughter of a brahmana can become a shudra proudly based on his/her inclination. All 4 varnas were equally useful based on the purposes they served. Yess, shudra wasnt a derogatory term as many people percieve it today. It was just for convinience for everyone._
_Like a brahmana wudnt be given the work of shudra, because that wud require immense physical durability. Similarly brahmana's mental capability was honoured and given the job to lead the society._
(And mind you again, anyone could become a kshatriya or shudra etc based on his/her liking. It was dynamic. Aisa nhi ki, brahman ka beta brahman, etc)
Thus as we can understand, it was a kind of job profile name. Nthin to be ashamed or too much proud of.
*_Shudras indeed were the building blocks of any society, so were the vaishyas in keeping the society wealthful, kshatriyas to protect everyone and brahmanas to lead the society spiritually._*
U see everyone was of immense importance, nthing less nthing more.
It was our own wrongdoing, leaving spiritual texts reading, we ourselves desecrated this smooth fabric of society under influence of those haramkhor invaders; so much so that we started seeing each other enemies than those fkin invaders.
_I am hopeful for Bharat though. We will be that old civilization again. We just need to read our scriptures again n again. Go back to our roots._
_We were not separated like they show on tv, movies etc. whatever they showed us the degradation of lower castes by upper castes on these screens, whatever we read about it too ; that was all in our just remote past, just around we were invaded by those haramkhors, and NOT BEFORE._
DO NOT MAKE THAT MISTAKE THAT Bharat was always like this. Noo, we were, are still united. Just got to tap that.
_To remove the still ongoing practices of discriminating against lower castes, we need to go back to our roots, know our real history, nit the one told by westerners._
I am hopeful.
I want to see that beautiful Bharat again.
I want all people to look for their "gotra" irresp of castes, and they will see how all were united at one point.
(p.s. m from a backward caste myself, if that helps anyone to assimilate the facts)
Why do we see only a amlhotra or a agrawal or a sighn talkl that caste system doesnot exist in india . if u want ssee the truth go tru any matrimony page in india . caste is a realityay and disriminatio exists . yes caste system is teh racism of india
We had caste based reservations since independence and now it is 50% reservations. Why teh system established by Congress did not work and still they are saying no representations from dalit, OBC etc? The reason is it is the same family again and again enjoying reservations, generations after generations. It is same wealthy class among OBC, Dalits who are misusing reservations. Reservations has to be given only one or 2 generations for a family and once they have financial means to educate their children then their children should be considered as general category. Also reservations has to consider financial status. Keeping the current system and increasing reservations above 50% is injustice to the general category and injustice to economically backward people of other casts. Actually casts should not be a factor in reservations and time has proved this since independence
डिवाइड एंड रूल का औपनिवेशिक एजेंडा आज भी चल रहा है । जरूरत है औपनिवेशिक काल से जड जमायी हुए शासन व्यवस्था से निजात पाने की ।
Bloody bring some Anthropologist or a Sociologist to the conversation, these bloody hindu recreationalists will just talk rubbish. Invite Dr. kartic Godavarthy to understand actually what caste system actually is.
Another man talking just about reservation ,,,just ignoring brutal caste system 😂😂
We all know we have the tech to identify the most deprived and give help to those who need it the most. But at the end of the day politics triumphs every rationale; and humans, especially Indians, are extremely tribalistic people. Indian Politics is ultimately a game of numbers and casteist politicians like Lalu Yadav or Mulayam Singh Yadav will keep on winning in the end.
lol...which Dalits are billionaire in India?
If caste came after the British why did the brahmins refuse to coronate shivaji as the maharaja
Did they? Then how come dadaji konddev who was the high ranking brahmin official took Shivaji as his student in the same kingdom?
@@ramaswamyk3380 read about how MH brahmins refused to coronate him and he had to summon gaga bhatt ji from Kashi. In spite of being the student of konddeo ji
@@princeofheaven19 you think mh brahmins are more orthodox than kashi brahmins? Kashi brahmins are supposed to be the top and most knowledgeable and most orthodox. So if as per the brahmin from kashi shivaji can have a thread ceremony, then definitely mh brahmins could not have objected because kashi is the supreme of hinduism
Who was Chokhamela?
जाति न पूछो साधु की, पूछ लीजिये ज्ञान,
मोल करो तलवार का, पड़ा रहन दो म्यान।
Sant kabir.
Caste system has done more damage to India than any other system. We cannot talk bullshit skirting the main issue
Caste system has been created by a specific community to get benefitted to them who created this system of hierarchy.
Hierarchy is not created by British.
British were against the caste system but they never opposed because they want to rule.
Caste and religion based discrimination is dragging india backwards.
You cant be myopic , India's caste is the foundation of Spiritual - Life , Give equality of opportunity if you like , but never lose the truth of this life is but ONE pearl on a string of pearls - Hare Krishna
Everything in India is diverse beyond understanding.