Hacking State 24 - Nathan Cofnas: Jewish Group Evolutionary Strategy | Cofnas-MacDonald Debate pt. 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Nathan Cofnas is Faculty of Philosophy at the University of Cambridge. His work is primarily in the philosophy of biology and ethics. We discuss his paper “Still No Evidence for a Jewish Group Evolutionary Strategy” in the context of his ongoing debate with Kevin MacDonald and his “Culture of Critique.” We cover explanations for outstanding and disproportionate Jewish success, differences in Jewish intelligence, whether Jews are particularly ethnocentric, Jewish involvement in Multiculturalism, Liberalism, mass immigration, and other political & intellectual movements, Margherita Sarfatti and Jews’ role in Italian Fascism, and the relationship of these unanswered questions to antisemitism.
Relevant Links:
nathancofnas.c...
x.com/nathanco...
nathancofnas.com/
------------------------------------------
If you enjoyed this interview, please leave a review on Spotify/iTunes.
Support Hacking State: hackingstate.s...
Listen on:
TH-cam: / @alexmurshak
Apple: podcasts.apple...
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
RSS: feed.podbean.c...
Fantastic conversation. Although Cofnas and MacDonald fundamentally disagree, they continually argue in good faith.
I am so grateful for his work. Thank you, Nathan Cofnas!👍
I was not convinced by Cofnas. I appreciate the good faith!!!
When MacDonald’s book was published over 20 years ago, the ‘Tribe’ kept largely quiet about it because they couldn’t refute the damning evidence contained within its pages, and also because they didn’t want to draw attention to it.
Cofnas has tried desperately to refute MacDonald’s thesis, but has failed miserably. He has corrected only very minor points in CoC, but has not even come close to refuting the main points nor the book in its entirety.
If one understands the issues at heart, including the specific details that both Cofnas and MacDonald make, they will discover that Cofnas falls far short of his goal in discrediting MacDonald.
More than that, MacDonald has pulled together overwhelming evidence that the ‘Tribe’ has worked endlessly to racially and culturally subvert both Europe and America.
The problems that the ‘Tribe’ brings to their host countries has been pointed by a countless number of persons throughout history which is something that many Jews have conceded.
All you've stated are vague generalities without actually explaining anything so I have a hard time believing Cofnas fails as hard as you say. From reading the initial back and forth it appears MacDonald derived conclusions on jewish group behavior citing evidence that Cofnas showed was false or misrepresented such as claims regarding Franz Boas's jewish identity as well as misrepresenting a list from the 90s of prominent jewish academics that MacDonald falsely claimed acted in jewish group interests. I'd be interested in hearing just three pieces from the pool of "overwhelming evidence" of concerted jewish activism in racially subverting the US and Europe that can logically be attributed to with direct evidence a highly ethnocentric anti-White jewish interest.
The reason why nobody can debunk MacDonald's book or the JQ is because almost nobody smart pays any mind to it and when someone does address the JQ, they only go for the surface-level stuff. MacDonald and JQers will gish-gallop their way through arguments while citing a bunch stuff without saying how what they're citing proves what they're saying meaning that you have to spend days if not weeks going through all of their arguments and sources.
You misunderstand. It's not "the tribe". It's a fanatical offshoot sect, that split from mainstream Judaism in the 19th century and rebranded Marxism and Communism as Judaism. These Tikkun Olam lunatics fled to the West instead of to Israel, where most of the right wing nationalist Jews are.
Yes, the Tokkun Olam guys are indeed working on racially destroying the West. But so are white leftists.
The only valid rebuttal to McDonald is that he doesn't go far enough, particularly that he believes in their IQ myth and couldn't see how their takeover of physics was quite similar to the group strategy they applied to other academic fields, with damaging results to civilization (fundamental physics being stalled for 50 years, essentially over an inability to let go of Einstein's ideas about gravity).
Really? I thought the counterargument was pretty good. You can't seriously look at the history of liberalism and say that if Jews weren't there, mass migration after World War 2 wouldn't have occurred. Just look at Sweden.
Dude looks like Mort from the Family Guy. Lol what's hilarious is that MacDonald's thesis in CoC is kind of a trap. If a Jew tries to refute the claims being made, it makes them look like they're being defensive as a survival mechanism, and that is the entire point of the thesis. The idea that MacDonald "cherry-picked" is to basically say that no group patterns exist.
What would say to the pro-CoC people in the comments?
Kevin MacDonald has published 3 books on this topic. A People That Shall Dwell Alone & Separation And It's Discontents an evolutionary theory towards anti-Semitismm. Wonderful works and I very much felt Separation and it's Discontents show cases a lot on that topic! Self Deception is very much a real thing! I see this behavior in my children everyday
David Irving isn't a denier. He's a critique and historican.
Macdonald nailed it, sorry buddy.
Nope. The Catholics opened the borders
Catholics opened the borders
MacDonald's argument is sound. There's evidence to his argument.
Really? I thought the counterargument was pretty good. You can't seriously look at the history of liberalism and say that if Jews weren't there, mass migration after World War 2 wouldn't have occurred. Just look at Sweden.
Antisemitism bros... we got too cocky
All 'protected classes' are the problem. It allows those with nefarious purpose , as all groups have within them ,to gain outsized power , influence and voice.
Children should be the only ones given special status/protections.
Well I appreciate you changing your mind when you are confronted with new evidence -at the very least that's how I am reading it lol- Being a hardcore right-wing jewish guy myself I often bemoan how many prominent jews are insufferable shit-libs but it's just a consequence of being highly educated and affluent. Same dynamic affects most gentiles who meet the same criteria.
@rrrrrrktjtj we need more Jews like you who aren't anti-white and right wing.
@@rrrrrrktjtj As a non-white gentile I agree with this 100%
Catholic opened the borders of the west
No.
Nathan has nothing
Rodriguez Mary Jackson Helen Lee Edward
Cofnas on point.