imo kamden deserves all stars when u consider that he wrote that rap. he was outshadowed by jay cos jay gave the best performance of the entire star level test
@@cheyscorner1056 i know that but lee hoe taek had like ten day to make the arrengement, choregraphy and practice and his vocal were the best. And honestly, even if rush hour is harder than the choregraphy hui make, it's still not that heavy(i've tried it before) and they were two to perform a song of two when hui was alone to perform a song of four.
@@laviestzeygetting into Lay’s company is already a great feat knowing how Lay is so strict as a mentor/PD. Yes, im an EXOL, i knew him when the company tweeted about it last december 2022 but i just became Zihao’s fan last January 28, 2023 after i watched all his previous videos from all the roadshows he participated prior he became a trainee of Lay’s company. He’s been dancing for 10 years and already got alot of fans due to all the roadshows he had been and even gaining more after becoming a Chromosome trainee. Well, i couldn’t question Lay, the boy really is talented.
@@pcyeol2327 the way i can assure ppl that no fan of Lay would've voted for Zihao just bc he is in his company if he wasn't talented. As Lay said when he launched his company that the low standarts of his trainees is he himself and they shall beat him in the first place, ofc we had high expectations for his trainees. For a matter of fact we were waiting for Zihaos stage more in excitement but also with even much more expectations(especially when some of us were introduced to Zihao not long ago when he already had his fans before even joining CEG bc of his roadshows and dancing). I still remember Lay's words when he was a mentor on Idol producer.
1:04 Originally, Shine was to perform with six members (Yutaka, Hyou, Towie, Ouju, Itsuki, and Ichika) instead of three. However, one of the members contracted the coronavirus, and on the day of the filming, Mnet told them to change to a three-member group, and they only had one hour to practice, which was not enough time to perform. Among the members who couldn't perform on stage, there were some great vocals. If it had been a six-person stage, they would have all received 2 or 3 stars.
yeah the member count for all the stages were super important. The weaker vocals get less parts. No hate to Yujjin or Gyuvin as they are zb1 members and I love them, but they sang for like a second each on their performance and got all stars. If they had to cover the other high parts, they likely would have gotten less
Seowon and woongki was in idol groups. Now you can see them the song 'supercharger' with very powerful dance. They only practiced it for 3days but you will know how they are so talented. They are not my favorite but they deserve more than 1 star.
@@lauraisenburg9390 I'm not getting what you mean, I'm stating that the person who made the video got it wrong cause Seowon got 3 stars originally and then got all stars during the re-evaluation
Did none of the comments actually watch PD 101- the talent was INSANE and great trainees got C or D in first eval,,, this grading is really generous and quite high honestly by PD101 standards
I think it's just the first two season? Well especially season 2 where only 7 people got A during the level test and nobody went down from that level after the re-evaluation. Like in PDX, I remember they gave an A for a trainee with definitely not A level skill because "he's got potential". Ofc that trainee went down bcs his potential wouldn't just show itself in 3 days lol
@@anxious_cucumber oh yeah I was talking about Produce 101 specifically bc that’s what it said in the title, produce 48 grading was kinda weird bc of the AKB girls and I didn’t watch produce X so,,,
G Kick IT: I will give Brian C instead kokobop: Winnie C Damdadi: Seyun D Criminal: Donggun F Tiger Inside: Renyou B Glitch Mode: Haruto B Rush Hour: Kamden A Mirotic: Ichan B Attention: Seowon is C and Jiho D The rest same opinion
@@mybaelam Op gave Brian B, but his dancing is a little bit stiff, so I gave him C instead. For Donggun, he cracks too much and skips a lot of lines, and I hate that type of singers /;
stage presence and dance (heavy on yujin for the latter. the masters took a liking to him because he was already THAT good at his considerably young age.) their version of the song in general suited dance breaks over actual vocal & rap parts, unlike g-group where the members had more lines (not to put down any of the teams because their performances were pretty different and good in their own ways) so if you had less lines you kinda had to give off a good show and captivate the audience at least once so that you could get all stars and it seems like gyuvin and yujin did just that
@@whenthequalityisbadbutiamI know this was a year ago but I’m just surprised that they got such high grades considering that, if we’re being completely honest, vocals are the number one most important thing, especially in a survival show where the missions depend on stable singing, because at the end of the day they’re all wanting to be become singers who make music. Not disagreeing with you at all btw, I’m just saying that Jiwoong, Yujin and Gyuvin got way too much praise considering they all barely sang (and still don’t now). People loved the fact that Jiwoong was a BL actor and was gorgeous so his fans mass voted a lot and people were just surprised by Yujins age.
i'm late but im convinced the reason he got no stars is bc of his huge tumble after his backflip in the beginning, which mnet edited out from the broadcast
yes its a shame mnet didnt put his performece on the show. they are really trying to gatekeep the most skilled conttestants so they dont overshadow their favorites
I still think Kim tae rae and Sung hanbin deserve an A. Tae rae sings great and his dance were ok not bad at all, Shanbin perform alone and he incorporate his signature tutting, his vocal were stable, his expression is great it should be an A. Meanwhile Han yujin and kim gyuvin should be B, they dance great but vocal or rap were so so.
You can see clearly the difference!! A lot of G contestants could’ve gotten more stars if they were ranked as K people 🥺 it’s so frustrating!! Winnie it’s a good example of that!! He deserve 3 stars 😩
Simply put, this group did well and put in a lot more effort. I also liked their dancing and singing skills. Krystian, Chen Jianyu, Chen Yugeng, Web Yechan China rocked. I'm Brazilian 🇧🇷 I follow all of you trainees.
why they didn't show all the good trainee and then shows 143 trainees that absolutely lack everything many trainees got all stars we dk any thing about them (: wow mnet you didn't change anything from produce 101 s1
seriously, it's becoming pd101 all over again. they removed sm girls planet things that made it girls planet. i mean ya cell system was bad, but it doesn't have the planet feel anymore.
honestly the amount of g group trainees getting very low scores was one of the things that posed me off the most. a lot of the F or D trainees def deserved C or B
My opinion: Ichika - C Winnie - B Choi Jiho - D Krystian - B Chen Yugeng - C Cong - B Sung Hanbin - A Han Yujin - B Gyuvin - B Ji Yunseo - B Haruto - B Na Kamden - A Jeon Wooseok - B Daeul - D Lim Junseo - D Woongki - C Hwanhee - A Dongyeol - B Taerae - A Minseok - A Seobin - B Park Jihoo - B Haru - B Seowon - C Jang Jiho - F
baek doha has a very nice tone tho, I bet its just the same cube bs play as making han chowon seem "meh" before showing everyone how good she actually was
I can’t believe they (Mnet) cut Kamden’s rap from broadcast bcos of that I only started noticing him towards the middle of the show. Jay has always been my fav since ep 1
nah I completely disagree with kamden, you're telling me you watched their performance, saw kamden's rap and thought that's only B material? nah we need to regrade my man deserves an A 👏
my opinion zhanghao A ricky B ollie B brian C ichika D ouju F itsuki F winnie C nice F jung mingyu D choi jiho C osuke D yuki D bak doha F krystian B chen jianyu D chen yugeng D wen yechen C chen liang C feng junlan C xuan hao D lin shiyuan D han yuseop B jang yeojun C park gunwook A park hyunbeen C seok matthew A jung seyun D jang minseo F lee donggun D chen kuanjui A chen reonyou C qiu shengyang C dong dong D wang yanhong F yanh jun F dang honghai C cong C sung hanbin A han yujin A ji yunseo A kim gyuvin A yoo seungeon A haruto A anthonny B min B jay A na kamden A jeon wooseok D lee daeul C lim junseo C lee yedam A wang zihao B keita A kei C hiroto B yuto C ma jingxiang X zhuang shuaibo D cai jinxin D tao yuan F oh sungmin C cha woongki C kim minseoung A kum junhyun A hong keonhee B choi woojin B wumuti C lee hwanhee B lee dongyeol B park hanbin A kim taerae B lee jeonghyeon B park minseok B mun junghyuj B han seobin A park jihoo A takuto D jeon hoyoung D choi seunghun D kim jiwoong A yoom jongwoo B lee seungwan C jung hwanrok C jeong ichan B lee hoetaek A haru C riku C park gwanyoung C kim minhyuk C jung hojin D jo eun woo D jang jiho C seowon C
welp i just saw a comment like this one but, have none of the comment section watched pd101? if the comment section did, then u would get it. the ranking are considered really generous right here. but also after seeing the word “Moonbin”…. may he rest in peace…
Yes! My ranking was basically a conversion of the bp ranking and yes they were a lot stricter back then. and yes i rewatched hwanhee and dongyeols performance and saw moonbins name and i rlly like that song too so yes may he rest in peace
I think Osuke and Yuki should've gotten more attention for their dancing even though their vocals were a mess. TXT's choreos are hard to adapt to less than 5 people and I think they did pretty well with most of the dance moves, even though they definitely sacrificed vocals for dance.
I think Krystian deserves a B, Haru as well because his dancing is an A and he's voice is a C, co the in-between score should be B, and Winnie definitely should be at least a C. He was REALLY stable at that performance considering the choreo. Also Takuto deserves a D at least, he was better than almost all F trainees.
The basis on their levels/grades are kpop idol group standards. Anyone would perform as good as Takuto did even better if they had the same routine. What he performed was something elementary students would perform for school activities which is very far from kpop idol standards. That’s why the final grade given to him was No star/F.
*here my opinion no one asked for.* yuehua g group: zhang hao: A ricky: he kinda between B and A i cant decide ollie: B brian:B they deserved All star in my heart. one of the best demo performance .i prefered this one instead of Kgroup ot was more lively and unique.zhang hao did justice to taeil"s part and just for that he deserved all stars. ricky ? ricky did amazing he didnt lie when he say he was the charisma boss he really deserved a all star. ollie nailed marks rap which is hard , and brian vocals was great. i hope they will cross path on show mission bc they make a cohesive team tokyo team: ichika: C ouju: D itsuki: D the performance was not bad as mnet make it sems they have room for improvement thailand team: nice : F winnie: C winnie was great idc what ppl say my house: jung mingyu: F bak doah: F i have nothing to say. choi jiho:B its was great for a solo trainee aichi team: osuke: D yuki: F the song was to high infortunetely but mnet love to edit the japanese trainees as they are the worst beijing team: krystian: B chen jianyu: B chen jugeng:C wen yechen: C its was a ok performance not bad not great but i loved krystian and yechen vocal color cant wait to hear them sing more ,jianyu was also great . guandong team: feng junlan:C chan liang:D xuan hao:D liu shiyuan:D pretty forgettable infortunately, i just find that impressive that they did the raps well for non korean speakers jellyfish team: han yuseop:B jang yeojun:B park gunwook:B park hyunbeen:B its was great i have to say it the team was oneof the most complematary, it show that they trainned toghther. gun wook took all the spotlight infortunetly (for the other boys) but for someone who call himself a all rounder his vocals were not that great han yuseop vocals were great why nobody talk about that seok matthew:B he dance, he sing great but i think the song choice was not the greatest , not even bc it jay park (i mean too) but i really want to see him on more "idolesque" perfromance than a chill song by krappers woollim team: jung seyun:F jang minseo:F its a pretty forgattable one sorry lee donggun:C the dance was great but the vocals were questionable. taipei team: chen kuan jui: A chen ren you; B qui shangyang:C dong dong: C its was a great one saldy we didnt see the other. also same as matthew i really want to see what chen kuan jui can do in a more idolesque setting but in this one he got to show his traditional dance skill but will see in regular kpop performance szechuan team: wang yanhong: F yang jun:F same as my house perf no word vietnam team: dong hong hai: C cong: B one of the best performance, they were great and full of energy and also very skilled . cong did not deserved a D sung hanbin:B he a great dancer one of the best on the show but the vocals were questonable. he shine more as a dancer than a kpop idol if you ask me. yuehua k group: han yujin:B ji yunseo:B kim gyuvin:B yoo seungeon:B lets be honest they are skilled but not deserved all star. they choose to focus on dancing while the g group on singing and rapping and it show. the performance was great but like i seen 100 covers of kick it and this one is just one of them while g group they embodies the nct 127 spirit. fun and unique, unforgattble and colorful. i think mnet is searching for korean contestant to push and yujin is their star: young,visual and descenty talented the whole package for them. w1 g group: haruto:A anthonny:A min:A they all deserved all stars. also one of the best demos they really did nct dream justice with this flashy interpreation min was amazing with his rap why nobody talk about. haruto didnt make shame to the reputation that he have and anthonny was great he wasnt flashy as the other two but wow he his really expressive. also i hope min and haruto will crosspath on show mission bc they make a great main dancers duo usa team: jay:A na kamden:A they were great two its a shame that only jay got all stars cant wait to see them perform jeon wooseok:C the dancing was not perferction the singing also but this man really have interpretation quality and its something that lack in kpop. idk if he did drama or he is a actor but man really played the song. 143ent: lee daeul:F lim junseo:F i was between F and D also its was a bad performance its was really the moment where mnet show its bias toward the korean conttestant, two stars for this?. the fact that lee daeul is on the top 9 rn make me crazy lee yedam: A++++++++++++++++++++++++ yedam the man you are ! im glad that i watched the performance that wasnt show bc i would miss him. i someone who just discorvered him now ( i did watch loud or anything)im just wooooow he will the stage by himself a lot of debuted idols could never do what he did. he the most talented on the k group and even on the whole show. the only all rounder with keita. wang zihao : B great dancer questionable vocal but great stability he had a bit of chance since he sang in chinese so cant wait to him perform on mission. osaka team: keita:A kei:C hiroto:C yuto:C great, keita steal the show unfornately for them but it was great i liked yuto part too also treasure fan didnt lie about keita ,he is the moment shanghai team: ma jiangxaing:C zhang shuaibo:C cai jinxin:D vocally it was a mess cai jinxin off key ruined the perfomance beside it was ok. tao yuan was great kinda a shame he have to left. bloom bloom team: oh sungmin:C cha wonggki:C its was a ok performance no bad not perfect, its was cute concept but well executed its a shame that wonggki made a mistake he will do better on mission redstart team: kim minseoung:B kim junhyun:B hong heonhee:C choi woojin:C they are ok but the performance was boring sorry wumiti:B he could been A /All stars if he danced a bit. i love the performance but sadly vocalist get overlooked so sad top media: lee hwanhee:B lee dongyeol:C hwanhee could have the potential to be a A / All stars but saldy its was boring. ,since their debuted idols i wish them the best. W1 k group: park hanbin:B kim tae rae:B lee jeonghyeon:B mim junghyeon:B park minseok:B another bias from mnet hanbin did not deserve all stars his vocals are questionable and his dance boring but he do have sp. kim taerae have the most potential out of the 5. they shouldnt perform a ateez song in the first places you need a lot of energy to do so and that why the performance felt flat. overall W1 g group is way way better. H1HGR music han seobin: A park jihoo:A its was superb why they did show this performance on live. one of the best takuto:F its was bad sorry. but takuto really have star power in 4 or 5 years he will be star i told you oui ent: jeon hoyoung:D/C choi seunghun:F not the best but hoyoung was really stable. he have potential. mirotic team: kim jiwoong:B yoon jongyoo:C lee seungwhan:B jeong ichan:C jung hwarok:C they clearly give everything on the sexy concept to make ppl forget about their skill but it did not work with me. jiwoong really in his hot bl actor persona but he have questionable vocal and his dance is boring. seungwhan vocals are the focus of this perfromance not the little thing they did for the gays. i really want see what the boys of this unit will do in misson bc jiwwong clearly steal the show lee hoe taek: between B and A ppl dont come at me. his vocals and arrangement were on tops of the world but the dancing and just the performance where a bit underwhelming. so sad hyogo team: haru:C riku:C they were not bad to be honest.maniac is kinda tricky to perform bc its bc a fever dream created and thinked by skz members its kinda look weird to me when other do it but its was ok lullaby team: park gwanyoung::C kim minhyuk:C jung hojin:D the syncronisation was great othet than its pretty forgotatble attention team: jung jiho:C seo won:between C and B this performance was great why giving seowon a D ? i love his dance and i loved jiho vocals. i didnt like the concept they created for this performance i would prefered if they performed as it was but it was great.the NINEi boys are very talented. finally its the end
Poor my dear Seowon 😭 How can you bring Seowon down that far, from 3 stars to 1 star. Okay.. You have indeed explained that you made a mistake, but I hope that in the future you will be even more careful in making videos so that mistakes like this don't happen again 🙏
Yes ofc! My source was incorrect so that is my mistake fir not double checking! I will be more careful next time! I will pay reparations by voting for him
If you give yujin and gyuvin A, than you should give shanbin A too. He is not just dance but also singing with stability and moreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee much line than them. shanbin did both, dance and vocal
Ichika Uehara es un actor y modelo chileno de desnudo moderno. Nació el 30 de julio de 1983 en Santiago de Chile, Chile. Es un mexicano japonés. Es de ascendencia mexicana y japonesa. A los 13 años se mudó a Madrid, España. A los 17 años comenzó su carrera como modelo. E hizo su debut en la industria del desnudo moderno en 2009, a la 26 años la edad.
For those who are confused about where they are, here: 1. Chai Jinxin, Tao Yuan 09:05 2. Choi Jiho 02:05 3. Park Minseok 10:45 4. Choi Seunghun 11:45 5. Riku 12:45 6. Hoetaek 13:48 7. Seowon 13:26
Another very beautiful group the presentation was this da China também cover straykids. Perfeito! Chen Liang, Feng Julan, Xuan Hão, Lin Shiyan. I'm from Brazil 🇧🇷 I follow all the trainnes. Congratulations boys from China
what you did to seo won in this is a crimeeeeee!! mans was stable and great at dancing! he got 3 star in the actual ranking and definitely didn’t deserve a D! i would honestly have given him a B because i think he was as good as Matthew. (all love + lighthearted dw)
@@KPOPTrashLyrics OH MY GOSH!! it says exactly what i said!! i’m beaming now. thank you for directing me to the pinned comment!! so sorry i initially missed it
imo kamden deserves all stars when u consider that he wrote that rap. he was outshadowed by jay cos jay gave the best performance of the entire star level test
I know it's a comment from a year ago but imo lee hoetaek gave the best performance so far😊
@@K-LimuI think it was Jay considering he was so stable while dancing. Hui was really good vocally but his demo stage wasn't really that dance heavy
@@cheyscorner1056 i know that but lee hoe taek had like ten day to make the arrengement, choregraphy and practice and his vocal were the best. And honestly, even if rush hour is harder than the choregraphy hui make, it's still not that heavy(i've tried it before) and they were two to perform a song of two when hui was alone to perform a song of four.
Even without considering that he wrote the rap, he was still very very stable and has a great capacity and flow too. He is also a good dancer
Wang zihao really talented!! It’s sad that Mnet doesn’t give him a screentime he deserves to be in top 9
u guys love him just because he's in the company of lay
@@laviestzey Some do, some may not, as you can see he is very talented, if you have ever watched his performances....
@@ExolCarat1485 i absolutely agree with u he's talented but his supporters (who don't watch the show and just vote for lay) are weird
@@laviestzeygetting into Lay’s company is already a great feat knowing how Lay is so strict as a mentor/PD. Yes, im an EXOL, i knew him when the company tweeted about it last december 2022 but i just became Zihao’s fan last January 28, 2023 after i watched all his previous videos from all the roadshows he participated prior he became a trainee of Lay’s company. He’s been dancing for 10 years and already got alot of fans due to all the roadshows he had been and even gaining more after becoming a Chromosome trainee. Well, i couldn’t question Lay, the boy really is talented.
@@pcyeol2327 the way i can assure ppl that no fan of Lay would've voted for Zihao just bc he is in his company if he wasn't talented. As Lay said when he launched his company that the low standarts of his trainees is he himself and they shall beat him in the first place, ofc we had high expectations for his trainees. For a matter of fact we were waiting for Zihaos stage more in excitement but also with even much more expectations(especially when some of us were introduced to Zihao not long ago when he already had his fans before even joining CEG bc of his roadshows and dancing). I still remember Lay's words when he was a mentor on Idol producer.
1:04 Originally, Shine was to perform with six members (Yutaka, Hyou, Towie, Ouju, Itsuki, and Ichika) instead of three.
However, one of the members contracted the coronavirus, and on the day of the filming, Mnet told them to change to a three-member group, and they only had one hour to practice, which was not enough time to perform.
Among the members who couldn't perform on stage, there were some great vocals.
If it had been a six-person stage, they would have all received 2 or 3 stars.
yeah the member count for all the stages were super important. The weaker vocals get less parts. No hate to Yujjin or Gyuvin as they are zb1 members and I love them, but they sang for like a second each on their performance and got all stars. If they had to cover the other high parts, they likely would have gotten less
Yedam was so underrated during the whole show. He was one of the BEST singers and dancers!! I am so sad :(
Bruh Winnie is atleast a C cmon he was so stable and his dancing was pretty good
Yeaaaaah He was sooo God ❤
i know i'm late... but yeah... even B honestly (only based on what i saw in here)
I know right! He carried the performance..
🤝
KEITA definitely deserves that A that boy can do everything
Exactly
KEITA IS SLAYTA 👑
EXACTLY bp fumbled so hard with keita and Jay
Seowon and woongki was in idol groups. Now you can see them the song 'supercharger' with very powerful dance. They only practiced it for 3days but you will know how they are so talented. They are not my favorite but they deserve more than 1 star.
I think these were based off of the star level test woonggi cried in the middle of the star level test so he was unstable
actually, Seowon got 3 stars in the star level
Agreed definitely three are two star
@@ellix_that was evaluating
@@lauraisenburg9390 I'm not getting what you mean, I'm stating that the person who made the video got it wrong cause Seowon got 3 stars originally and then got all stars during the re-evaluation
kamden's rap was so good
13:44 really seo won got one star?? he was really stable at the stage, I can't believe this
Noooo, he have 3 stars. The person of the video have a mistake
@@afrogflying3885 ohh I didn't know, thank you
He actually got 3 stars on the demo stage and then promoted to allstar
5:46 cong and honghai's performance is great!! at least they're stable
I will give Cong a C, I believe that he deserves a C with that performance
Did none of the comments actually watch PD 101- the talent was INSANE and great trainees got C or D in first eval,,, this grading is really generous and quite high honestly by PD101 standards
I think it's just the first two season? Well especially season 2 where only 7 people got A during the level test and nobody went down from that level after the re-evaluation.
Like in PDX, I remember they gave an A for a trainee with definitely not A level skill because "he's got potential". Ofc that trainee went down bcs his potential wouldn't just show itself in 3 days lol
@@anxious_cucumber oh yeah I was talking about Produce 101 specifically bc that’s what it said in the title, produce 48 grading was kinda weird bc of the AKB girls and I didn’t watch produce X so,,,
@Tiffany Wong omg watch produce x 101 its literally the best produce season also you probably mean yohan well he made it to x1
@@arianayusufzai8756 nah i believe it was tony (? Correct me if im wrong tho
@@sardine7766 ??? Tony
G Kick IT: I will give Brian C instead
kokobop: Winnie C
Damdadi: Seyun D
Criminal: Donggun F
Tiger Inside: Renyou B
Glitch Mode: Haruto B
Rush Hour: Kamden A
Mirotic: Ichan B
Attention: Seowon is C and Jiho D
The rest same opinion
Bye no way you put brian c but donggun f make it make sense
Omg renyou as B i so agree! Maybe he lacks a bit in dancing but he still did decent!
@@mybaelam Op gave Brian B, but his dancing is a little bit stiff, so I gave him C instead. For Donggun, he cracks too much and skips a lot of lines, and I hate that type of singers /;
Dong Gun F? I don't see any sense in this. I agree that his vocals were not strong. But his dance was good.
This is a crime yuto deserved a b this whole team deserved a b are a
i don't understand how gyuvin and yujin got all the stars when they sang for about 3 seconds each.
same
stage presence and dance (heavy on yujin for the latter. the masters took a liking to him because he was already THAT good at his considerably young age.) their version of the song in general suited dance breaks over actual vocal & rap parts, unlike g-group where the members had more lines (not to put down any of the teams because their performances were pretty different and good in their own ways) so if you had less lines you kinda had to give off a good show and captivate the audience at least once so that you could get all stars and it seems like gyuvin and yujin did just that
@@KPOPTrashLyrics wait so if u agree why would u rate them as an A?
@@whenthequalityisbadbutiamI know this was a year ago but I’m just surprised that they got such high grades considering that, if we’re being completely honest, vocals are the number one most important thing, especially in a survival show where the missions depend on stable singing, because at the end of the day they’re all wanting to be become singers who make music. Not disagreeing with you at all btw, I’m just saying that Jiwoong, Yujin and Gyuvin got way too much praise considering they all barely sang (and still don’t now). People loved the fact that Jiwoong was a BL actor and was gorgeous so his fans mass voted a lot and people were just surprised by Yujins age.
I thought Jongwoo's dance in Mirotic was perfect, he really seems to be enjoying what he does! He deserves A for sure
Hot take but Takuto deserved at least 1 star
Yeahh he literally deserve 1 star
Agreed!!!
Spoiler warning for episode 2:
he leveled up and got 1 star, so proud of my boyyy
agree! his performance is much better than daeul junseo
exactly
i'm late but im convinced the reason he got no stars is bc of his huge tumble after his backflip in the beginning, which mnet edited out from the broadcast
Lee Yedam & Wang Zihao ...absolutely talented one, sad that they didn't get much screen time.
Thanks for recognizing Lee Yedam’s talent. Guys go look at his performances his really great. Let’s Vote for him !!!!
yes its a shame mnet didnt put his performece on the show. they are really trying to gatekeep the most skilled conttestants so they dont overshadow their favorites
@@lovegalore-3732 he butchered the song completely... Stop justifying their performances being ass cuz their other performances are "better".
matthew deserves all stars
bro my guy seok matthew deserves all stars.
I love how you always return once a year to make one of these videos lmao
LMFAOOO 🥺🥺🥺 IM HAPPY U NOTICE
this must have taken so much time editing and downloading the audition videos, good job and thank u for making it!
ahh!! thank u, i rlly tried my best and yes it does take a bit of work. i made quite a bit of mistakes lolz but ty for recognizing my work!
Wang Zihao is so talented please give him all star
He is in the show.
I think he is very talented too but his latter perfomances were way better!! He has really showed us what he can do in Law, I fell in love :D
SHanbin and Taerae deserved an A
Cong D? naur his voice is solid
5:16 Chen Kuan jui is just wonderful🎉
Ichan is so stable though, and did most of the ad-libs along with seunghwan (I think seunghwan)
Winnie deserves a higher grade !! He literally carried
Jeong I Chan deserved a B imo. His vocals carried. Imagine the vocals being gone from the Mirotic group. 🤔
I still think Kim tae rae and Sung hanbin deserve an A. Tae rae sings great and his dance were ok not bad at all, Shanbin perform alone and he incorporate his signature tutting, his vocal were stable, his expression is great it should be an A.
Meanwhile Han yujin and kim gyuvin should be B, they dance great but vocal or rap were so so.
You can see clearly the difference!! A lot of G contestants could’ve gotten more stars if they were ranked as K people 🥺 it’s so frustrating!! Winnie it’s a good example of that!! He deserve 3 stars 😩
taerae & kamden deserve A 😔
Simply put, this group did well and put in a lot more effort. I also liked their dancing and singing skills. Krystian, Chen Jianyu, Chen Yugeng, Web Yechan China rocked. I'm Brazilian 🇧🇷 I follow all of you trainees.
I agree with practically everything except for Ichan, he deserves atleast a B
Seowon... a D?? He sounded good, at least a B
13:27 seowon deserved B or C tbh he carried
why they didn't show all the good trainee and then shows 143 trainees that absolutely lack everything many trainees got all stars we dk any thing about them (: wow mnet you didn't change anything from produce 101 s1
seriously, it's becoming pd101 all over again. they removed sm girls planet things that made it girls planet. i mean ya cell system was bad, but it doesn't have the planet feel anymore.
i feel like krystian deserves a B he carried that performance so hard and hes so talented
ik! im upset the judges gave him such a low score
Unfortunately I don't think it's fair considering contestants like Sung Hanbin and Matthew had a better impression but only got B
Agreed. He's not my pick but he was stable and has a good understanding of where to put emphasis and energy
@@KPOPTrashLyricsbut u gave C lol
@@emiliexol He did based on the stars.
honestly the amount of g group trainees getting very low scores was one of the things that posed me off the most. a lot of the F or D trainees def deserved C or B
SEOWON DESERVES AT LEAST 3 👺🗣️🗣️🗣️
matthew ate that solo performance
10:51 Taerae not getting A or full star is a crime
My opinion:
Ichika - C
Winnie - B
Choi Jiho - D
Krystian - B
Chen Yugeng - C
Cong - B
Sung Hanbin - A
Han Yujin - B
Gyuvin - B
Ji Yunseo - B
Haruto - B
Na Kamden - A
Jeon Wooseok - B
Daeul - D
Lim Junseo - D
Woongki - C
Hwanhee - A
Dongyeol - B
Taerae - A
Minseok - A
Seobin - B
Park Jihoo - B
Haru - B
Seowon - C
Jang Jiho - F
Where's Lee hoe taek?
baek doha has a very nice tone tho, I bet its just the same cube bs play as making han chowon seem "meh" before showing everyone how good she actually was
Woonggis improvement is still crazy to me
I can’t believe they (Mnet) cut Kamden’s rap from broadcast bcos of that I only started noticing him towards the middle of the show. Jay has always been my fav since ep 1
Sung Hanbin deserves a A
I'm sorry but that criminal cover is a crime
Ichan deserved the 3 stars 😭😭
12:49I think haru deserve a B😭
It's so interesting to see that usually the duos don't do very well, I don't follow BP but it's just wild lol
seowon got 3 stars in demo stage not 1 so he should be B
7:38. How did that get 0 stars? That was literally so good!!!
Yuseop is in makemate1 now VOTE FOR HIMMMMM
Gun wook deserves all star
nah I completely disagree with kamden, you're telling me you watched their performance, saw kamden's rap and thought that's only B material? nah we need to regrade my man deserves an A 👏
some of these are very generous 😭😭
my opinion
zhanghao A
ricky B
ollie B
brian C
ichika D
ouju F
itsuki F
winnie C
nice F
jung mingyu D
choi jiho C
osuke D
yuki D
bak doha F
krystian B
chen jianyu D
chen yugeng D
wen yechen C
chen liang C
feng junlan C
xuan hao D
lin shiyuan D
han yuseop B
jang yeojun C
park gunwook A
park hyunbeen C
seok matthew A
jung seyun D
jang minseo F
lee donggun D
chen kuanjui A
chen reonyou C
qiu shengyang C
dong dong D
wang yanhong F
yanh jun F
dang honghai C
cong C
sung hanbin A
han yujin A
ji yunseo A
kim gyuvin A
yoo seungeon A
haruto A
anthonny B
min B
jay A
na kamden A
jeon wooseok D
lee daeul C
lim junseo C
lee yedam A
wang zihao B
keita A
kei C
hiroto B
yuto C
ma jingxiang X
zhuang shuaibo D
cai jinxin D
tao yuan F
oh sungmin C
cha woongki C
kim minseoung A
kum junhyun A
hong keonhee B
choi woojin B
wumuti C
lee hwanhee B
lee dongyeol B
park hanbin A
kim taerae B
lee jeonghyeon B
park minseok B
mun junghyuj B
han seobin A
park jihoo A
takuto D
jeon hoyoung D
choi seunghun D
kim jiwoong A
yoom jongwoo B
lee seungwan C
jung hwanrok C
jeong ichan B
lee hoetaek A
haru C
riku C
park gwanyoung C
kim minhyuk C
jung hojin D
jo eun woo D
jang jiho C
seowon C
welp i just saw a comment like this one but, have none of the comment section watched pd101? if the comment section did, then u would get it. the ranking are considered really generous right here.
but also after seeing the word “Moonbin”….
may he rest in peace…
Yes! My ranking was basically a conversion of the bp ranking and yes they were a lot stricter back then. and yes i rewatched hwanhee and dongyeols performance and saw moonbins name and i rlly like that song too so yes may he rest in peace
9:46 Minsung’s picture is not him 😢 The picture is Park min suk ( wakeone )
I think Osuke and Yuki should've gotten more attention for their dancing even though their vocals were a mess. TXT's choreos are hard to adapt to less than 5 people and I think they did pretty well with most of the dance moves, even though they definitely sacrificed vocals for dance.
I think Krystian deserves a B, Haru as well because his dancing is an A and he's voice is a C, co the in-between score should be B, and Winnie definitely should be at least a C. He was REALLY stable at that performance considering the choreo. Also Takuto deserves a D at least, he was better than almost all F trainees.
oh, also Matthew should be an A!
The basis on their levels/grades are kpop idol group standards. Anyone would perform as good as Takuto did even better if they had the same routine. What he performed was something elementary students would perform for school activities which is very far from kpop idol standards. That’s why the final grade given to him was No star/F.
@@yunaring407 but beside his song choice, he was pretty stable for a jumpy choreo, that why I would grade him higher. Those are my standards tho :)
*here my opinion no one asked for.*
yuehua g group:
zhang hao: A
ricky: he kinda between B and A i cant decide
ollie: B
brian:B
they deserved All star in my heart. one of the best demo performance .i prefered this one instead of Kgroup ot was more lively and unique.zhang hao did justice to taeil"s part and just for that he deserved all stars. ricky ? ricky did amazing he didnt lie when he say he was the charisma boss he really deserved a all star. ollie nailed marks rap which is hard , and brian vocals was great. i hope they will cross path on show mission bc they make a cohesive team
tokyo team:
ichika: C
ouju: D
itsuki: D
the performance was not bad as mnet make it sems they have room for improvement
thailand team:
nice : F
winnie: C
winnie was great idc what ppl say
my house:
jung mingyu: F
bak doah: F
i have nothing to say.
choi jiho:B
its was great for a solo trainee
aichi team:
osuke: D
yuki: F
the song was to high infortunetely but mnet love to edit the japanese trainees as they are the worst
beijing team:
krystian: B
chen jianyu: B
chen jugeng:C
wen yechen: C
its was a ok performance not bad not great but i loved krystian and yechen vocal color cant wait to hear them sing more ,jianyu was also great .
guandong team:
feng junlan:C
chan liang:D
xuan hao:D
liu shiyuan:D
pretty forgettable infortunately, i just find that impressive that they did the raps well for non korean speakers
jellyfish team:
han yuseop:B
jang yeojun:B
park gunwook:B
park hyunbeen:B
its was great i have to say it the team was oneof the most complematary, it show that they trainned toghther. gun wook took all the spotlight infortunetly (for the other boys) but for someone who call himself a all rounder his vocals were not that great
han yuseop vocals were great why nobody talk about that
seok matthew:B
he dance, he sing great but i think the song choice was not the greatest , not even bc it jay park (i mean too) but i really want to see him on more "idolesque" perfromance than a chill song by krappers
woollim team:
jung seyun:F
jang minseo:F
its a pretty forgattable one sorry
lee donggun:C
the dance was great but the vocals were questionable.
taipei team:
chen kuan jui: A
chen ren you; B
qui shangyang:C
dong dong: C
its was a great one saldy we didnt see the other. also same as matthew i really want to see what chen kuan jui can do in a more idolesque setting but in this one he got to show his traditional dance skill but will see in regular kpop performance
szechuan team:
wang yanhong: F
yang jun:F
same as my house perf no word
vietnam team:
dong hong hai: C
cong: B
one of the best performance, they were great and full of energy and also very skilled . cong did not deserved a D
sung hanbin:B
he a great dancer one of the best on the show but the vocals were questonable. he shine more as a dancer than a kpop idol if you ask me.
yuehua k group:
han yujin:B
ji yunseo:B
kim gyuvin:B
yoo seungeon:B
lets be honest they are skilled but not deserved all star. they choose to focus on dancing while the g group on singing and rapping and it show. the performance was great but like i seen 100 covers of kick it and this one is just one of them while g group they embodies the nct 127 spirit. fun and unique, unforgattble and colorful.
i think mnet is searching for korean contestant to push and yujin is their star: young,visual and descenty talented the whole package for them.
w1 g group:
haruto:A
anthonny:A
min:A
they all deserved all stars. also one of the best demos they really did nct dream justice with this flashy interpreation
min was amazing with his rap why nobody talk about. haruto didnt make shame to the reputation that he have and anthonny was great he wasnt flashy as the other two but wow he his really expressive.
also i hope min and haruto will crosspath on show mission bc they make a great main dancers duo
usa team:
jay:A
na kamden:A
they were great two its a shame that only jay got all stars cant wait to see them perform
jeon wooseok:C
the dancing was not perferction the singing also but this man really have interpretation quality and its something that lack in kpop. idk if he did drama or he is a actor but man really played the song.
143ent:
lee daeul:F
lim junseo:F
i was between F and D also its was a bad performance its was really the moment where mnet show its bias toward the korean conttestant, two stars for this?. the fact that lee daeul is on the top 9 rn make me crazy
lee yedam: A++++++++++++++++++++++++
yedam the man you are ! im glad that i watched the performance that wasnt show bc i would miss him. i someone who just discorvered him now ( i did watch loud or anything)im just wooooow he will the stage by himself a lot of debuted idols could never do what he did.
he the most talented on the k group and even on the whole show.
the only all rounder with keita.
wang zihao : B
great dancer questionable vocal but great stability he had a bit of chance since he sang in chinese so cant wait to him perform on mission.
osaka team:
keita:A
kei:C
hiroto:C
yuto:C
great, keita steal the show unfornately for them but it was great i liked yuto part too
also treasure fan didnt lie about keita ,he is the moment
shanghai team:
ma jiangxaing:C
zhang shuaibo:C
cai jinxin:D
vocally it was a mess cai jinxin off key ruined the perfomance beside it was ok. tao yuan was great kinda a shame he have to left.
bloom bloom team:
oh sungmin:C
cha wonggki:C
its was a ok performance no bad not perfect, its was cute concept but well executed its a shame that wonggki made a mistake he will do better on mission
redstart team:
kim minseoung:B
kim junhyun:B
hong heonhee:C
choi woojin:C
they are ok but the performance was boring sorry
wumiti:B
he could been A /All stars if he danced a bit. i love the performance but sadly vocalist get overlooked so sad
top media:
lee hwanhee:B
lee dongyeol:C
hwanhee could have the potential to be a A / All stars but saldy its was boring. ,since their debuted idols i wish them the best.
W1 k group:
park hanbin:B
kim tae rae:B
lee jeonghyeon:B
mim junghyeon:B
park minseok:B
another bias from mnet hanbin did not deserve all stars his vocals are questionable and his dance boring but he do have sp. kim taerae have the most potential out of the 5. they shouldnt perform a ateez song in the first places you need a lot of energy to do so and that why the performance felt flat.
overall W1 g group is way way better.
H1HGR music
han seobin: A
park jihoo:A
its was superb why they did show this performance on live. one of the best
takuto:F
its was bad sorry. but takuto really have star power in 4 or 5 years he will be star i told you
oui ent:
jeon hoyoung:D/C
choi seunghun:F
not the best but hoyoung was really stable. he have potential.
mirotic team:
kim jiwoong:B
yoon jongyoo:C
lee seungwhan:B
jeong ichan:C
jung hwarok:C
they clearly give everything on the sexy concept to make ppl forget about their skill but it did not work with me.
jiwoong really in his hot bl actor persona but he have questionable vocal and his dance is boring. seungwhan vocals are the focus of this perfromance not the little thing they did for the gays. i really want see what the boys of this unit will do in misson bc jiwwong clearly steal the show
lee hoe taek: between B and A
ppl dont come at me. his vocals and arrangement were on tops of the world but the dancing and just the performance where a bit underwhelming. so sad
hyogo team:
haru:C
riku:C
they were not bad to be honest.maniac is kinda tricky to perform bc its bc a fever dream created and thinked by skz members its kinda look weird to me when other do it but its was ok
lullaby team:
park gwanyoung::C
kim minhyuk:C
jung hojin:D
the syncronisation was great othet than its pretty forgotatble
attention team:
jung jiho:C
seo won:between C and B
this performance was great why giving seowon a D ? i love his dance and i loved jiho vocals. i didnt like the concept they created for this performance i would prefered if they performed as it was but it was great.the NINEi boys are very talented.
finally its the end
Thank you for appreciating yedam
VOTE FOR CHEN KUAN JUI!
ichika should get an C at least he was pretty stable while dancing like that
I think taerae should've gotten A, but i agree with most grades!
Poor my dear Seowon 😭 How can you bring Seowon down that far, from 3 stars to 1 star. Okay.. You have indeed explained that you made a mistake, but I hope that in the future you will be even more careful in making videos so that mistakes like this don't happen again 🙏
Yes ofc! My source was incorrect so that is my mistake fir not double checking! I will be more careful next time! I will pay reparations by voting for him
If you give yujin and gyuvin A, than you should give shanbin A too. He is not just dance but also singing with stability and moreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee much line than them. shanbin did both, dance and vocal
its based on the stars gyuvin and yujin 4= A shanbin 3 = B
@@KPOPTrashLyrics ah it's still based on the stars and you just changed it to abcdef, i think it's 100% your opinion. Sorry
@@yllwgurl3099 no bc if u look its literally based on stars to abcdf like i need to u to look and think.
@@KPOPTrashLyrics lmao well then why mention at the beginning "All grades are my opinions" if all you did was transfer their star grade to abcdf.
@@kodzw girl bye let me live 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
but why is wang zihao's back it up back it up at 8:30 so addictive!!!!!!!!please vote for him.
Lmao 😂You're so right
9:46 Kim Minseoung's photo is not the right one
i mean it’s easy to make this video, the number of tiers is the same so yeah
A - All star
B - 3 stars
C - 2 stars
D - 1 star
F - No star
junhyeon deserves better pls vote for him he is very talented!!
キムミンソンがパクミンソクになってる
D for woonggi??? TWISTED
Wang Zihao and Na Kamden deserve A.
Bak Doha my poor man
seowon, 3star.........
Ichika Uehara es un actor y modelo chileno de desnudo moderno. Nació el 30 de julio de 1983 en Santiago de Chile, Chile. Es un mexicano japonés. Es de ascendencia mexicana y japonesa. A los 13 años se mudó a Madrid, España. A los 17 años comenzó su carrera como modelo. E hizo su debut en la industria del desnudo moderno en 2009, a la 26 años la edad.
Seyun and Minseo, imo, deserve one star
winnie deserves more 😭
ERRORS: Thank you to those who have commented! It really helps and I apologize for the mistakes, I will do better next time
For those who are confused about where they are, here:
1. Chai Jinxin, Tao Yuan 09:05
2. Choi Jiho 02:05
3. Park Minseok 10:45
4. Choi Seunghun 11:45
5. Riku 12:45
6. Hoetaek 13:48
7. Seowon 13:26
@@anneliesegregory8222 ty :)
also u got the wrong pic for kim minseoung hes the one with red hair :)
@@parmiz oops! i had a template and it had whoever there first so
i mustve missed him!
You should pin this :)
i cant believe matthew didn't get an all star for his performance TT
my boy jingxiang deserves a B I mean bro is a rapper but was still really stable and good
Tao yuan should have got three stars he was stable I'm sad he had to leave the show
9:22
9:44 Kim Minseoung’s face is a different person omg😅😂
honestly i think seowon deserves at least 2 or 3 stars cause he slayedd. but this comment doesnt mean to hate or bash the creator of this vid.
Another very beautiful group the presentation was this da China também cover straykids. Perfeito! Chen Liang, Feng Julan, Xuan Hão, Lin Shiyan. I'm from Brazil 🇧🇷 I follow all the trainnes. Congratulations boys from China
btw!! jay and kamden performed rush hour by CRUSH feating J-Hope (not DEAN)
ichan deserved a B.
chen kuan jui is so underrated bro istg
hes my top pick 🫶
9:44 the trainee in the first picture is not kim minseoung but park minseok from wakeone
Kamdem deserved better
I WAS WAITING 4 THIS
🥺🥺🥺🙏
what you did to seo won in this is a crimeeeeee!! mans was stable and great at dancing! he got 3 star in the actual ranking and definitely didn’t deserve a D! i would honestly have given him a B because i think he was as good as Matthew. (all love + lighthearted dw)
check pinned for seowon anf all good ❤️!!!
@@KPOPTrashLyrics OH MY GOSH!! it says exactly what i said!! i’m beaming now. thank you for directing me to the pinned comment!! so sorry i initially missed it
@@mickymorelli ahahah all good! all good and love and justice for our seowon
Chen Kuanjui❤❤❤
Takuto and lee daeul is so cute
nahh seowon deserved his 3 stars like come on?
check pinned comment
15 contestants from japan!😳
Red house alway be perfect for me okay guys dont judge me
07:21 isn't Rush Hour Crush's song ft Jhope?
ur right i thought it was jhopes song