Jay is so underrated honestly, he has a great vocal and the best part is his musicality! He nails the R&B vibe every time! He should just write more songs for himself! While no doubt that Winka and Joyce can sing, I winced when they sang “how many times”, the vibe was just not right. Anyway, totally enjoyed seeing Jay performing and singing! Thanks music panda!
Can’t agree more ! He’s talented in both singing and composing! Love the way how he’s obsessed with music purely and work very hard to improve himself !💕He’s literally way too underrated 😟he should deserve more and more!
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
Enjoyed filming this episode so much with Winka and Jay~ these BEAUTIFUL BEAUTIFUL voices! Thanks for having me!
Thank you for the nice songs Joyce ❤️❤️❤️
Thankyou for coming !!!! Joyce 😍😍😍😍
Joyce 你首opening好正~ >_
Thank you 香港最佳女歌手-鄭欣宜！Your performance always blow our mind and so cool 🤩🥰
入大峙。你水
Loved singing with you guys Joyce and Winka!!! Both incredibly beautiful voices and personalities 🙏🏻❤️🤗🙆🏻♂️
Jay, no matter what genres you sing beautifully. Good job
I really love all your harmonies and ad-libs 🙆🏻♂️ AND CANT WAIT FOR YOUR CONCERT
Keep up the good work yayyyy 🎉🎉🎉
the harmonizing is remarkably amazing, you guys! Insane!
I really like your song howmanytimes~
Jay Fung Ga Yau❤
我本來入嚟係睇Jay 及Joyce 的，2位唱歌好聽已經唔使懷疑。但聽完Winka唱記憶眠之後，真心勁好聽。我係第一次坐定定睇到Winka唱歌的，我喜歡呢位小妹妹，成個Collar 女團，唱歌最好係Winka.雖然外界集中力不太在你身上，但我睇到你的好，Winka, 比心機，用心做好每一件事，一定有人欣賞的。
Winka唱得太好聽喇，香港好耐無呢種女歌手 ，希望樂壇行內人士可以比多啲機會比佢
希望阿Wing同魯生比機會佢
普通，音準okay但冇咩特色。
@@cassidylenochan4847 同感，音準有驚喜，但唔夠氣，低音一般，高音太薄，無乜點處理細節，尾音幾求其。而家有人氣，出咩歌都有人buy。長遠黎講要揀岩路，不過唔熟佢，唔知佢音樂品味如何
唔知係唔夠氣定唔識換氣
喉嚨發音係未開聲定點。。。？
同joyce合唱好明顯。。。
winka唱的是感情過於技巧 好聽!
三位都是難得的好歌手。Winka有實力、年紀小小但心態正面，造星4到現在一路留意，期待佢未來發光發亮; 欣宜憑實力和堅韌撐到今日，終於得到佢值得擁有嘅成績; Jay係極之被低估，佢啲創作品質高，特別係上年吸血鬼三部曲，由音樂到mv都極高質，佢應該得到更多的認同和成就，希望佢最終可以大大成功
Agree! Jay Fung 廁創作既歌曲及其歌聲真係世界級！ 佢既MV 配合歌曲一連串故事， 好有心思！
@@workshopgreenangel2590 啱啱睇咗佢首
Can’t agree more ! 好欣賞佢對唱歌及音樂創作果份熱愛同純粹，嚟緊佢七月concert 一定吾可以錯過，佢唱live 簡直係神級，上次同Janice 係concert 合唱嗰首whenever You Call 直頭達國際水準👍👍
Winka唱得好好，相信Winka應該係女團中率先出單曲的其中一位，佢嘅聲音已經ready了。
欣宜望住winka唱記憶棉個樣好好笑，聽完第一段仲不停點頭😆
好有前輩氣場呀！！
佢話想知道WINKA唱歌果陣個嘴係點運用
Yes, very supportive. She was probably hoping Winka would look at her back haha but Winka was too focused on singing this hard song.
Joyce was like daimmmmm go girlll u slayyyyyy!!!
Winka記憶綿是我聽過最動容的女版。
@@dickieccm1 中學生版都好正
好開心可以聽Winka 唱返《無名》🥰🍈🤎🙍🏻♀️，成件事感到好意外😍，仲要以COLLAR 成員身份去演唱👍👍，希望COLLAR 同Winka 喺之後嘅日子可以前程似錦，遇戰遇強💪🏻💗💗🤎🍈
請問本來邊個唱？
@@yvonneyvr Winka 本人！
@@yvonneyvr Winka 就係原唱，未參加造星同入團之前Winka 已經係個人身份歌手佢已經自己出歌，
@@yvonneyvr th-cam.com/video/o4JRTD4dR7M/w-d-xo.html
希望其他成員再加油
winka唱歌真係好觸動人，一唱起歌就一啲都睇唔出佢得23歲
Jay唱雪不完的浪漫呢類都好正喎，可以唱多啲，rap埋
Joyce真係唱得好放，已經到咗好應付自如
想Panda請呢兩個組合上嚟
1. Tyson Yoshi、姜濤、Gareth.T
2.張敬軒、林家謙、Tyson Yoshi、Serrini
Pls🥹真係好想睇佢哋同台表演
張敬軒、林家謙、Tyson Yoshi、Serrini!!!!
組合2 相信錄片時 會笑多過唱😂😂
@@JokerSoul21 林家謙直接串到Tyson重傷，跟住樹rrini幫Tyson又俾林家謙串，最後軒公好無奈咁睇住三隻小學雞😂
組合二可以分兩次上🤣林家謙鐵膽
2隊都貴show錢
我鍾意泳伽個人，好好人，個人好得意，唱歌又好聽。
Jayyyyy so amazing 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻 see u in Hung Hom stadium 💓💓💓💓
因為 Winka 我比 like👍
Winka唱得好好喎, 唔係話技巧好高但已經有點個人風格, 好有潛質👍🏼
有馮允謙我就like!!!
So lovely this one!!!!love them !!
WINKA good job😍
Keep going!
Love Jay🥰Joyce
我第一次聽Winka完整solo唱一隻歌，我話晒聽咗幾十年歌
我反應係「嘩！好好聽喎！」
WINKA 下一站天后
只欠個機會
Joyce 同 Jay好比機會Winka唱歌。好有愛嘅姐姐同哥哥，好照顧Winka妹妹。
Winka is an incredible new talent. I can't wait for her solo songs. Jay and Joyce are so groovy. All 3 are so jenggg.
She has a solo song named “CUPID-19 十九邱比特” before becoming a member of COLLAR though.
damnnn jay fung's so cute...
Winka咬字清晰👍🏻
Jay做和聲真係正到爆，rap又得，好驚喜～
欣宜唔使講。感情滿分💯
How many times❤️
Winka cover記憶綿好好聽啊！
自己首《無名》都好高質！
欣宜好專心望住winka唱歌 好正
欣賞您，Winka！繼續努力！Joyce Jay love you as always！😘
第一次聽winka唱歌，感覺佢可以單飛了（真係好好聽⋯⋯
想睇 MC & 林家謙 & Gareth T！！！
Winka 好有feel🧡🤎💜🤍💙😩🖤💛❤️
jay fung!!!! 努力有回報的～期待你的concert love and support 多謝music panda 邀請 :p
ａｇｒｅｅｅ！！！！
Agreed x2
欣宜live 真係超級穩又好聽😭
我想同winka示愛啊🥹好鐘意佢把聲 好鐘意聽佢唱cover🤍
欣宜 jay Fung 無得輸💕
唔好話唱功, 淨係WINKA份心地同經歷已經足以令我替佢依家開心, 好心有好報, 希望佢將來會有更加多成就
2023 仲聽緊 Winka 🤎
Winka唱記憶棉唱得太好了吧😍😍 恭喜Joyce 再得最受歡迎女歌手!🎉🎉 Support. Love u both.
抖氣聲好大好大
同鄭欣宜比較就有距離
聽完記憶海綿體。之後就返唔到轉頭了
Winka果然係女版jer👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
winka世一
老實我冇睇全民造星亦好少睇ViuTV，雖然有聽過Collar呢個組合嘅跳唱快歌，但印象唔深刻…今次第一次聽Winka solo完全改觀晒！原來Collar都有咁有實力嘅女仔！！從今日起，我會記得你個名，亦會留意你唱嘅歌！加油❤❤
Winka 把聲會唔會太正？！😳💗 Joyce 同 Jay 都好正🔥！BLACKPINK in your area 🤘🏻🖤💗
Winka同Jay嘅雪不完的浪漫真係好好聽😭🤎 好有畫面感🥰🤎🫶🏻
唱雪不完的浪漫的時候，我想講Winka個一刻真係好靚😍，入哂首歌，同Jay Fung真係有交流今唱，真係開始有星味！加油！
Winka演繹記憶棉太2完美吧！好聽到crazy!!低音中音高音假音靚到耳朵懷孕了，聽得投入非常！
Winka真係好CUTE, 好ENJOY音樂既空間. 🤗🤗
因為一首 我也難過的 今晚我成為咗泳瓜
小編嘅民意調查又嚟喇～
今集嘅Music Panda唔知大家又有邊首想我地Pick出嚟做，等大家放入playlist 狂loop呢？😍
Winka cover嘅記憶棉，值得俾多啲人認識一把咁好聽嘅靚聲👍
報復式浪漫🙏🙏
我也難過的
我也難過的
How many times!!!! 夾得超好聽！！🤩🤩😍
宜家翻睇，雖然只係過左一年，但覺得jay個陣好似小朋友咁 好cute cute.😂
Winka♥️
Winka首無名真係好聽到癲咗
呢三個人嘅組合係我心目中嘅：
女金 男金 新金 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
Winka is amazingly good - one thing she can get even better is to be confident to open her mouth when sings
平日睇collar未必留意列WINKA
今集後愛上WINKA了
给最爱的Jay Fung加油助威！
Winka嘅歌聲好值得被聽到 多謝Music Panda 邀請！！！可以同Joyce and Jay Fung合作一定好開心🥳
點解Jay fung 把聲聽極吾厭，佢把聲同邊個Jam都夾到🤩🤩
Winka 23歲就有這麼好的唱功👍🏻, 前途無可限量🎉, 繼續努力💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
多謝你地俾機會WINKA同JOYCE同JAY咁好嘅歌手交流合作~
今晚真係耳朵懷孕~ 好正呀!!!!!!
WINKA 好好聽，呢個組合正！ 首雪不完的浪漫好過原唱好多！！！
winka值得單飛
WINKA 唱記憶棉好出色, 顏值清麗帶優雅, 睇好妳將來單飛彈出!
winka add oil!!
Jay要做regular班抵plz!!!!!!!!! I love Jay!!!!!!!
Winks和jay fung可以推出合唱歌曲，好正
我每一天都播一次，除了J fung joyce， 重有一位我很欣賞的新星Winka， 不要被世人平庸眼光抹去你的才華，要加油！你把聲好靚
Winka sifu 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻!
Winka響Joyce 面前發揮記憶綿都咁好，抵讚
Winka年紀輕輕但經歷不少，態度正面，聲線充滿攝人心魄的情感，為她感到驕傲。
Joyce可以有韻味，good job！Winka好可愛
surprised by Winka. She is insane.
Winka真係唱得好好呀👍好鍾意您把聲👏繼續努力加油Winka💪
太喜歡Winka 和 Jay 合唱！！！！
開心Winka有機會獨立出嚟唱，幾好聽，係小清新，雖然實力同Joyce和Jay有距離，但睇得出兩位前輩好謙虛同照顧後輩，好有大將之風，論實力兩位絕對應該再上一層樓，尤其是Jay。
Dayummmm didn't know Winka is this good. I am a fan now
欣怡，馮允謙好搞笑，睇定定望著winker
被Winka驚艷到了! 好好聽~😻
今集聽得好開心好舒服, 三位都唱得勁好聽~💛
有jay fung 就有好歌聽！呢集太幸福啦 joyce 同jay 本身已經好好聽，估唔到winka 係佢兩個隔離 一d 輸蝕既感覺都冇！今集太幸福啦
Yup !! Jay live 就係保證👍👍👍😍
Winka!!!!!!
最好睇嘅一集💗💗💗💗
三個都唱得好正
WINKA 記憶棉真係唱得好好聽🤎❕
幾好睇、有KB又有jay , 欣宜都越來越有星味
呢集Winka有驚喜，同馮允謙合唱好聽
jayfung真係好可愛❤️
呢個組合好正 三位都唱歌都好聽❤️❤️
希望更多人認識winka💪🏻
Winka 😍😍 靚人靚聲 😚
Winka 😍😍😍 加油~
Winka 唱記憶棉好好聽
winka勁
多謝Music Panda 🐼 再次請Joyce/Jay, Winka 面對兩位都冇怯場，唱得好好👍💪🏻💪🏻
Jay 依舊咁可愛😍😍🤪
成晚聽得好舒服🥰🥰
Winka 唱歌勁好聽! 支持師父!
好鍾意欣宜既態度，每次聽人唱都好專心咁望住，樂壇大家姐feel
Love this three singers! add oil all of them !
第一次認識winka, 她的聲音很甜很入咪,好好聽, 轉音也很圓滑, 會令人繼續想聽下去。
每次都很想多謝Music Panda給一個平台新人, 2021,2022的新聲音,我全都是從Music Panda中聽到的, 也謝謝專業的剪接和音效, 每次重新編曲都比原曲更好聽.
最後三個的清唱真係好聽到痴咗線,我連續reloop咗5次
Collor@Winka 🤎🤎🤎🤎
Winka 唱歌比比賽時更好, btw, 達達都好cute
WinkaJoyce 好正好聽👏👏
Jay is so underrated honestly, he has a great vocal and the best part is his musicality! He nails the R&B vibe every time! He should just write more songs for himself! While no doubt that Winka and Joyce can sing, I winced when they sang “how many times”, the vibe was just not right. Anyway, totally enjoyed seeing Jay performing and singing! Thanks music panda!
Can’t agree more ! He’s talented in both singing and composing! Love the way how he’s obsessed with music purely and work very hard to improve himself !💕He’s literally way too underrated 😟he should deserve more and more!
Winks👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻✅👍🏻👍🏻✅
越嚟越鍾意Winka❤
不得了
Winka 好有感染力，好想聽佢唱 "不求月老"
jay winka 合唱夾得幾好， 仲見到winka好投入，新人來講都好淡定、不枉以前儲備經驗豐富
Winka嘅記憶綿 Good good
今集好正！！！ Joyce and Jay Fung把聲真係無得頂！！
Winka好靚聲
想music panda 搵陳蕾啊🤩🤩🤩🤩
愛死jayfung同Prince Joyce
Winka都要加油 好有天份