Anand Ranganathan's Fiery Response To Critics Questioning Bonanza To Andhra Pradesh In Budget 2024
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Anand Ranganathan's Fiery Response To Critics Questioning Bonanza To Andhra Pradesh In Budget 2024?
#anandranganathan #budget #budget2024 #unionbudget #nirmalasitharaman #bjp #congress #pmmodi #modi
Those who think Andhra is getting more benefited than other states. Just rewind 10 years, we were bifurcated without allocating proper funds, lost revenue from Hyderabad, all assets went to Telangana and liabilities are divided based on population, no capital city. This was the first in history that who demanded separate state got everything and who didn’t want the bifurcation needed to adjust with empty bowl. You guys never understand what congress and BJP did to AP until when you were thrown out of your state without the capital and revenue and with liabilities, and suffer 10 years of ignorance. Then you will understand.
Stop crying atleast now. This is not even 5% justice for what had happened to us.
Exactly. well said. These jokers who cry about AP getting funds dont understand that these benefits are officially promised to AP as pre-condition before bifurcating AP and making it Orphan. In fact both BJP & Congress back stabbed Andhra by not giving special status which was promised on floor parliament which was not fulfilled.
AP was cheated by center two times. Once by giving away chennai to Tamilnadu when AP was carved out from Madras state where as Telugu people had a big part of Chennai. Then again second time the same happened with Telangana bifurcation. You can not cheat same state twice by promising & not giving the same.,,.
Welcome.. this is what congress does..
If AP develops under Chandrababu Naidu then what’s the problem?! As long as the funds aren’t misused, AP being a part of our nation should advance. Unlike in WB where even if any funds are given, it’s bound to be used only for appeasement.
All the so called members are blind to the injustice done to andhra in 2009 with intended destruction done by jagan in 2019 to 2024...Now they r opening mouth and crying
100% agree
When Mr. Chidambaram was Finance Minister how many industries and funds transferred to Tamilnadu by bypassing the other states
@Harshaganeshj63290 finance minister alone can't transfer any industry and funds to any state without PM approval, till date there is no single tamil PM. So there are no special packages given to Tamilnadu bypassing other state!!!! There is tamil president called APJ Abdul kalam who worked for whole country without seeing any partiality.
Enough for TN ...let's develop other states@@josejoseph8725
Has PC ever done any such good to TN? If he comes to know that unintentionally he has done some good to TN, he will do his best to nullify it.
@@josejoseph8725tn recieves 29 rupees for every 100 rupee direct tax, nothing more to say
That guy is the most selfish and behind AP bifurcation
Since 2014 to 2024 when when Andhra Pradesh suffered a lot no one supported it.
Anand is telling real facts..Funds to Andra was due.Our state lost everything after bifurcation.May it prigress now under Chandrababu
No one speaks about how DMK was pampered with critical portfolios of their choice in NDA and UPA
@@Vin-cv6qn Agreed.But others did not get portfolios of their choices
Kyun be Anand Napunsak anginat baap ki aulad. Ab Kyun chup hai jab TDP Andhra mein muslims ko 4 percent reservation de rahi hai, Urdu University, Urdu as second Official language, Haj House,Financial Assistance to Haj Pilgrimage, Muslim students ko 15 lakh rupaye for abroad higher studies, Shadi par dulhan ko 1 lakh Aur pata nahin Kya kya. Sab kuch to de diya. Ab kyun BJP chup hai aur tu to muh mein lekar baith gaya hoga apne baap logon ka nahin to Bahut uchakta hai. Sala Napunsak Anand Rangnathan.
we were completely victimised by Congress divided Andhrapradesh and we did not have any capital due to jobs sake we are currently Working around all the major cities in India..now KA brought up a new Act that only locals would work in KA the same thing would happen in Telangana also. We won't trust Pappu Italian..Congress Hatav Desh Bajav.
Congress is more dangerous than Ter'ism....
Yes you should trust BJP who sold everything to ADANI/AMBANI😅
@@humanbeing6838 Just correcting you it's only Adani not Ambani... 😂
Congress could divide AP only with the help of the BJP.
Congress is responsible for Andra problems. Why divide Andra? Bihar is backward state so give importance. Ok in case indi get support?
Bihar is awarded for its corruption. 12 bridges collapsing in 30 days, world record. Award well deserved😅
Do you think Congress and BJP are corruption less parties ? If so if so then you are corrupted@@humanbeing6838
Bihar is ever backward
Not only CONG main part is CHIDAMBARAM played main role in bifarcation. and DMK also votted .
That's why Andhra people's will not trust Pappu Congress...Even Congress offered special status if TDP supports I.N.D.I.A Alliance....We don't have hope ..So thats TDP JSP goes with BJP Alliance.....Sambars always a sambar..
No TDP always interested in Congress infact Chandra babu naidu Co is cm of telangana but the idiot pawan Kalyan doesn't want it
@AM-pg1zo when andhra people protested to divide tamilnadu state for seperate andhra state, congress divided tamilnadu state. When Telangana people protested to divide andhra state for seperate Telangana state then congress divided andhra. Congress divided states because many died in state division protests. Now andhra hypocrites was ok with madras division and not ok with Telangana division of congress. Sambar! That sambar funds only you are licking🤡
@@josejoseph8725madras was developed with Andhra funds in erstwhile madras state. Prakasam was dislodged from CM post in madras state through defections even before India won it's freedom. Rajagopalachary was given preference over freedom fighters from Andhra. Even now for many South India means only Tamilnadu.
@prabhakarvalivelu1955 lmao next what delhi developed with andhra funds? Madras was a bustling trade centre with many ancient temples like thiruvallikeni, thiruninravur, thiruvotriyur built by tamil people dating long even before your language is born. Many mad made lakes in chennai like chembarabakkam and cholavaram even today serve madras people is built by our tamil cholas. After british annexed arcot nawabs during 1751 chennai came under british rule, then your andhra zamins helped british so much to build their forts and resulted in british colonization. Even tirupati doesn't has any telugu records before 11th century but you snatched tirupati from tamilnadu. Read history before blabbering anything you are talking as if all are beggars and are build with andhra funds lmao.
@@josejoseph8725when Andhra people protested for separate state they didn't get the capital or revenues of Chennai. And Tamilnadu got it. And Andhra merged with Telugu speaking state and shifted capital from Andhra to Hyderabad because Telangana people demanded it to be in Hyderabad now Telangana people wanted seperate state and got capital where is capital for Andhra Pradesh.? And Andhra Pradesh in 1972 under Indira govt only wanted t o be seperated against mulki rules in Hyderabad that time Indira Gandhi forced Andhra people. It's the Tamil people who are hypocrites who get everything without voting center govt. And it's them who loot kongu Nadu where majority Telugu people contribute it's economy.
Who is this sambhar crying 😅 AP was ignored for the past 10 years, this is a loan we got from centre not a grant . Bihar got a grant of 58000 crores , cry on them
Don’t worry dear spokesman under Chandra babu Naidu Amaravati will develop and generate lot of revenue for AP & India also
🙏
All is well under NDA government for Andhrapradesh
Amaravathi still a caste capital..
@@Ramabhupalreddy1 Sakshi effect😄
@@Ramabhupalreddy1 in future your kids will come here and work.
Karnataka Capital- Bangalore..Andra Pradesh capital?? AP doesn't have a Capital from 10yrs.. Congress n RaGa doesn't know this.. Bihar is the Poorest state in India- Bihar should Improve or Not??
That this opp won't talk because they were the one who created this problem.
Bihar is the sinkhole of india , complete liability jitna bhi paisa dedo gayab ho jata h
First the governance of Bihar should improve..
@@dhah5947 exactly!
@@sureshchithaly any doubt, bihar politician fool the uneducated public and take everyone for granted
Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra may be contributing more, But Kerala is only taking everything and not giving anything...
Receipts ? Or just talking crap ?
Kerala is the most financially stressed state in india 😂😂😂 poor lads
Ask joker Pappu to answer this question. Inside the house he talks all bullshit things and jump from one issue to another.
Why are people so against andhra getting funds this is not something new it was all clearly mentioned in Andhra Pradesh reorganisation act we are getting what was promised to us and we deserve it after losing Hyderabad
Firstly Andhra Pradesh was killed in 2014 by all the political parties behind the close door. They even closed their eyes when Jagan Reddy killed our state. Now, suddenly some of the Jokers are crying when Andhra Pradesh reorganisation act is being implemented only because of the situations created in the central Government.
This man who is criticizing the Bihar and Andhra allocation - is really out of his brain. He should look back last 10 years
bihar is getting money for 60 years continously without improvements. keep politics away, this is strange. problem isnot money for bihar may be bihar politicians. mr.nithiseh is rulling for 20 years mostly alias with bjp and 2 years with rjd. some fundamental issue to be addressed. we people of tamilnadu keep throw money to bihar and up. i am not sure about AP as part of bifurcation they can get some capital assistance but this shouldnot become forever like bihar this would affect coordial relationships within states.
@@Vin-cv6qn i don't deny AP need assistance and it was committed by union. it was a mistake last 10 year they didn't received. i stand with words, i will still say giving the money to bihar. bihar is getting 284 percent tax share but all the south Indian states including AP less than 50 percent tax share (TN - 40.8, karnadaka even worst less than 40 percent of union share). Bihar is receiving the fund last 60 years but still they didn't developed the infrastructure, education and medical. where these money gone, some politicians pocket. bihar is already getting 284 percent tax share over and top if they ask special assistance absolutely we criticize.
@@Vin-cv6qn is Every AP citizen part of indian Army, don't act smart by fake fake nationalism. if you really concerned for jawans you should criticize union government and they have reduced the army fund to 12.5 percent of budget. this was lowest in the history. we are better and honest indian nationals. i am not sure you from AP or bihar but i support AP special assistance for next 3 years never for bihar until they find the root cause of the problem.
Kyun be Anand Napunsak anginat baap ki aulad. Ab Kyun chup hai jab TDP Andhra mein muslims ko 4 percent reservation de rahi hai, Urdu University, Urdu as second Official language, Haj House,Financial Assistance to Haj Pilgrimage, Muslim students ko 15 lakh rupaye for abroad higher studies, Shadi par dulhan ko 1 lakh Aur pata nahin Kya kya. Sab kuch to de diya. Ab kyun BJP chup hai aur tu to muh mein lekar baith gaya hoga apne baap logon ka nahin to Bahut uchakta hai. Sala Napunsak Anand Rangnathan.
Center now implementing the AP REORGANIZATION ACT made by UPA GOVERNMENT. WHAT IS WRONG. CONGRESS HAS NO MORAL RIGHT TO QUESTION 😅😅😅😅😅😅
Congress Divided Andhrapradesh
Which Bjp also supported
@@Kkc3126 congress was the one ruling ap during bifurcation not BJP, AP used to be Congress stronghold but congress backstabbed us
@@saisrinivasv.d136 if bjp said no to the bifurcation of Ap in parliament state would not have been divided both the parties are culprits before division they should have granted special category status to AP first and bifurcated Bjp was from first willing for bifurcation of Ap for there political benefit also they had little 2% vote share in Telangana region and they promised and accepted for 10 years special category status for Ap in parliament but they betrayed Bihar is shit they always eat but produce no result even now many bridges built in Bihar collapsed highest corrupted state Bihar AP was highest tax payer to India till 2014 from South and 2 after Maharashtra in whole india they divided unethically giving assets and capital to Telangana and all debts to Ap Before bifurcation Ap use to pay more taxes to center compared to Karnataka Tn to be frank atleast 25-30% more than tn kar it was richest state go check statistics in net.
Shut up
If a state want to divide from AP
No one will stop it
Have you seen Telangana movement
How students came on to streets
All educational institutions were closed
All bus and train services are closed
So all pvt sector was closed
This happened again and again for 4 years
Telangana becoming a state is in evitable
Congress had not choice
So enjoy your state and don't cry when Andhra gets money
P. Chidambaram says on most budget proposals: our idea. Yes, that is true: INC never acted on its ideas, which were mere false promises not meant for execution.
Why no one questioned when Andhra was backstabbed during Telangana state division.? When whole country kept numb at that time, pls shut ur mouth now as well.
Just talking like fool, since bifurcation 10 years andhra did not get funds without capital.
Tamilnadu such a state got everything from centre.
Bad propaganda.
@sbksrinivas5703 till now tamilnadu don't has any AIIMS. TN has NIT trichy, Ap has NIT tadepalligudem. TN has IIT madras, AP has IIT tirupati. AP also got eastern naval command, ISRO and so on while most of the chennai things are from british era Don't talk as if andhra got nothing and tamilnadu got everything.
@josejoseph8725 bifurcation done by shinde,chidambaram, jairamramesh played a key role to down grade the telugu people. 42 mps become 25 +17
No voice in parliament.
Without having revenue for andhrapradesh how the state runs for development. Jagan reddy hijacked congress vote bank and with freebies came to power and spoiled state further 100 years. But tamilnadu is having very strong and wise leadership is there since independence. Tamilnadu is for better than andhrapradesh sir.
@sbksrinivas5703 wow seems like sir forgot about andhra division from tamilnadu by congress on the demand of andhra people with the help of andhra leaders . Also the same telugu people of Telangana protested for seperate state from andhra, many people died in Seperate Telangana movements that forced central government to divide andhra and Telangana. If there is no protest by Telangana telugus why would state division happens!
Yes Mr Hypocrite Joseph, Unlike you Tamilians we Andhra people not snatched away the Hyderabad like u guys did it for Chennai.
Shut up and sit down.
If you are talking about Telangana movement and then go back to past and remember 1970's Jai Andhra movement. Having half knowledge about history and coming here and barking doesn't make sense
Very unfortunate that the discussion is completely political while the truth is that the bill is introduced in the Parliament by UPA. Now is giving what is in the bill to AP a political gimmik? What nonsense is this?
Exactly
Since Andhra bifurcation nothing is allotted now Andhra is creating a State Capitol anew naturally deserve special financial package. Congress simply divided the One Telegu speaking into two States without any packages.
We are Telangana not Telugu
@venkatreddykangati actually telangana deserves that special financial package! Andhra looted telangana money and build their cities like vizag and bezawada. Today also andhra people dominates hyderabad and andhra people are richer than telangana people. Then why special financial package for andhra? Actually telangana need to get it.
@@josejoseph8725 In fact, Vijayawada developed relatively less in the United AP. Guntur used to be an educational hub until everything moved to Hyderabad in the '90s. Does Telangana fill with gold/diamond mines to become richer than Andhra? AP needs the capital since it lost Hyderabad, so I am not sure why any sane person would suggest Telangana and not AP need assistance in building the capital. I always supported Tamilians' fight in the language and considered all of us as South Indians (Dravidians) but your utterances suggest me I may be wrong in considering myself a Dravidian. I understand your thoughtless utterances on AP if AP had asked for state bifurcation and crying now for help.
Indian opposition is always crying.
They are crying seeing the pitiable situation of states
@@shalumagic exactly. As if the congress era was such a golden period in the history of this nation 🙄
Barking and shouting is the only business for them. Their leader with immature thoughs is not good.
@@gurupadappakabbur6648 ‘barking’ 😂
Opposition crying is over! Now NDA 's turn😅😅😅
The spokesperson for TN state should understand that Andhra does not have at least 10% of industries of TN. We were divided unethically and not even fulfilled the promises which were made during the bifurcation.. we are in a dire state. 😢
@Satya2408 andhra people protested to divide madras presidency, Congress divided madras presidency. Telangana people protested to divide andhra, congress divided. What congress did is what people asked and protested for years, if people never protested why would they divide?
If as "As per Taxes paid" is the formula as a Indian Tamil Hindhu then my questions is why are minorities geeting more then their share than the ppl who paid more taxes.
Even if Tamilnadu is given funds it will go for freebies
Perfect question bro. As soon as you say minority they will p!ss in their pants. 😂
Do you know in the constitution their has 10 years of special provisions for Buddhists but they are still carried even after 60 years. And even if the central government tried to end it, the opposition won't let it happen. That's why still the minorities our overwhelmed in this country
If feku leaders read your remarks loose motion will start.
Kyun be Anand Napunsak anginat baap ki aulad. Ab Kyun chup hai jab TDP Andhra mein muslims ko 4 percent reservation de rahi hai, Urdu University, Urdu as second Official language, Haj House,Financial Assistance to Haj Pilgrimage, Muslim students ko 15 lakh rupaye for abroad higher studies, Shadi par dulhan ko 1 lakh Aur pata nahin Kya kya. Sab kuch to de diya. Ab kyun BJP chup hai aur tu to muh mein lekar baith gaya hoga apne baap logon ka nahin to Bahut uchakta hai. Sala Napunsak Anand Rangnathan.
Simply give special status to Andhra Pradesh, as promised by parliament.
Straight way Modi ji conveyed the message that we will care those who are with us. Now, NO VOTE NO WORK.
Andhra Pradesh deserves these allocations of funds , these are pending for last ten years. Khangrace divided AP in unacceptable terms and made Andhra an ailing state. Now bjp rectifying this mistake.
How many central government industries and institutions does Tamilnadu and Karnataka has and how many Andhra does have? How many international flights land per week in Tamilnadu and Karnataka and how many come to Andhrapradesh?
Andhra is only state without capital....they have to start with zero....
All want to blame 10 years where were they 70 years of Congress
Bro 60 years
Congress leaders looted the exchequer money by rampant corruption involved in various scams
Indi alliance is really feel that people are dumb 'jitni abadi utna hak ' is the slogan of indi alliance now states that more abadi is getting more hak then they have problems such a hypocrite congress 😅
Bhai unka kaam sirf nara dena hai.. Garibi hatao 45 saal pehle diya tha, aur sacchai kya hua, toilet bhi Modi ko aa kar dena pada..😂😂😂
Well. Well. Well. Even without the rebuttal, message to voters: VOTE FOR MODI next time
😅😅😂😂
@@anupamkumar6858they never have ANY solutions. If they come to power we will lose all progress. I’m happy to pay my taxes if i see my nation developing.
Both Pappu and sister are laughing and enjoying how nicely they can cheat the innocent voter's by making unbelievable free schemes with bogus promise.kata cut is one example for their survival.
@@StraitsAsiakata cut spealist joker Pappu don't have in-depth knowledge of giving effective suggestions applicable to various problems of this great mother land. He must change his mind set.
Fantastic debate and big introspection for congress, they cannot exist in this country by dividing it!!!
INDIA bloc boycotting means running away from the truth
Impact of kata cut free gifts bogus promise is the root cause for present crisis in the opposition. No one has a concrete plan or vision about the progress and prosperity of this great mother land.they are creating unnecessary problems on each and every thing. Ultimately innocent common people will be the worst sufferers.
How long you will give funds? Is that guy stupid? Andhra has been bifurcated by centre in a very unconstitutional way despite massive protests. Andhra lost everything. The provisions in reorganization act have not been implemented since and now people are complaining that Andhra has been given funds? Wtf
Past years when ap got nothing no body even talked about that and now every on one are crying on us
Sharam honi chahiye
what about the time when tamil nadu got huge investment when bihar got nothing…in the past…….
With their lobbying and black mailing tactics, T. N. got most of the central sponsored industries all these days. But now they are crying if some relief is announced to A. P.
It is right time for TN people to mingle with the fellow citizens of other states also and refrain from thinking that they and their language is supreme.
@narasimhamanumula6235 can you mention so called centre sponsoring industries? Andhra got many central sponsoring industries like eastern naval command, SAIL etc in vizag by which whole vizag developed. Got ISRO etc. Telugu people should also refrain from thinking they and their language is supreme, they always say telugu is sweetest language as if other indian languages are ugly.
@@josejoseph8725 can you plz. enlist me how many industries A.P got previously inspite of their staunch support to khangress. Regarding TN, you got railway coach factory in avadi, you got most of the railway projects completed by getting sufficient funds alloted, whereas projects in A. P. was allowed to be dragged on
Now the Union Government have opened their eyes and alloted some funds which was a part of A. P.R. act. . Still you people are weeping. What a bad situation?
@@josejoseph8725 Well we didn't say your language is ugly, we said our language is sweet as the Tamil poet Bharatiyar recognized it to be. we don't have the superiority complex of the oldest language in the world nonsesne.
@josejoseph8725 well our tamil poets are broadminded to praise other languages. they didn't praised only your telugu they said kavinmalayalam- "dainty malayalam" & irupadupol kannadam "endless kannada" . But telugu people never praise other language, they only praise telugu because they have so much superiority complex. Also we don't have superiority complex of the sweetest language or desabasalodu telugu lesa in the world crap as if other languages are not sweet and great.
One Tamilnadu minister allegedly had made some offensive remarks against workers of Bihar and other economically backward states of India few days ago.
If with the additional budgetary allocation, the economy of few poorer States are revived, then it will benefit India as a whole including Tamilnadu and Maharashtra. Please be broad minded and leave narrow thinking.
As far as 15K cr is mentioned in the budget for AP, which is only the assistance by the central govt. in getting the loan by AP govt. Further, how long did the central govt. support AP? In fact, if AP had not been divided forcefully by Congress with the help of the BJP, there would be no need for new capital for AP.
P Chidambaram from TN was the first to comment that Telangana should be given. That gave impetus and led to a vociferous demand from TG people. So TN should not complain.
Opposition wants to complain only, what they did 70 years
People like Shashi Tharoor were in Congress now whatever BJP does is talking rubbish...yes his English very good 😮😂
Problem is think tamil nadu and kerala people needed to be reminded they didn’t rise on their own
Tax benefits are given by central government for development of industries
They reaped all the benefits and now they wanna talk about trust
If you are that accountable pay the 2g spectrum money lost due to dmk party members a raja and Kanimozhi Karunanidhi
I guess talking like this , kannadiga reservation is the actual moto of bharat jodo yatra by upa parties
15000 crores is just a 0.020% from total budget of 48.50 lakh crores
But debates are only on 0.020% not remaining budget y
15kcr to amaravati is center to facilitate funds from world bank it is not grant.. It has to be repaid by ap
Andhra people are only sect who lost their capital 2 times - erstwhile Madras and Hyderabad. Both the cities are highly developed, despite their contributions they got raw deals on both ends. So this 15K cr should be seen as investment and not as a liability. We have the skills and work ethic to make Amarvathi as another world class city.
@naveendeevi7992 Madras and hyderabad never belonged to andhra people BTW. Madras was a well established trading centre during tamil chola rajas time, the most of the lakes which provides water in chennai are built by tamil chola rajas. Later british annexed madras from arcot nawabs with the help of andhra zamins who helped british so much in colonization by donating lands. Hyderabad belongs to Telangana after dividing madras presidency andhra itself went and joined hyderabad state under visalandhra. So stop claiming everything as if they belong to andhra.
@@josejoseph8725 , can you point to the sentence where I claimed Madras & Hyderabad belongs to Andhras ? Can you prove me that Andhra people contributed 0% to the development of Madras & Hyderabad ? And please understand, at this point Andhra has no capital, fact is that Madras - TN & Hyd - TG, no dispute on that at all. All I am saying is Andhra people are on loosing end all the time, so granting 15k cr, should not be seen as a lost cause instead as investment. We are currently migrating to your Chennai, Hyd or Bengaluru, to make living where we are treated as 2nd class citizens. Just don’t want that anymore.
@@josejoseph8725your chennai was developed by Telugu people.
@naveendeevi7992 you only said andhra lost capital two times as if those are andhra cities. Even before British annexed madras with the siege of arcot in 1751 it was developed trading centre during tamil chola rajas. The reason why it is called cholamandalam earlier, even when dutch done trade with establishments in 1610 they called it is dutch coromandel(cholamandalam). Don't claim other properties. Even tirupati doesn't have any telugu record beyond 11th century but andhra snatched away from tamilnadu. Are we crying for tirupati now? But my god you andhra people claiming everything as if others doesn't have any capability. If you keep on telling fake stories like we developed chennai, hyd, bengaluru then definitely you will be treated like that! Just ask your funds we are also asking our funds.
@prabhakarvalivelu1955 then your nellore, tirupati are developed by tamil people.
Everyone was silent when Gujarat got funds to build a GIFT city,which is already developed and has capital.Silent when expressways weee build ,silent when bullet train where 80% line passes through state.But why everyone is bragging when a capital less state got funds?? Is Tamilnadu doesn’t have capital?
It is not even a grant but a loan.
Where were these Tamil slang English speakers when Andhra was bifurcated and became capitaless?? It was chidambaram who played major role in bifurcation as commune Andhra had 42 MP seats,thought Andhra will surpass Tamilnadu in terms of bargaining for funds with central due to its more MP seats. Some Tamil people were jealous then,and jealous now.
Tamils need to Shut their mouths and understand that without Andhra there is no South India. They are the majority and they deserve majority of funds for development after the UPA criminals divided AP without compensation.
Simple logic to immature people, people are crying for funds just give us Hyderabad and take all the funds allocated to AP. Hyderabad was developed by AP people.
These self-centered people don't understand managing a whole nation.
OMG OMG,, what did Andhra really got..? This is a topic neither TDP nor BJP defend as they know they did not do anything for Andhra in this budget. 15000 crores is a loan guys,, that too the DPR has to be presented to financial entities and through the case.. So TDP has to say now is this not an addition to existing debt, wouldnt Andhra turn Srilanka now.. Funny..
Polavaram suppose to complete by centre by now, dont say centre is doing any benefit there.. Again remember 15000 is a loan vs 21000 Bihar has got is aid.. What a discrimination.. TDP cannot demand more than this..?? Wht hppnd to spl category status CBN has demanded for, no one gets a better chance than now to fulfill such demands.. Looking at all this,, guys i feel there was some conspiracy in Andhra election..
Actually andhra not got enough funds..why centre divided andhra with out capital..have some sense..
Waiting for 10 years andhra will deliver more than you said states
Sonia,Rahul Gandhi and chidamaram really have guts to ask andhra funds they weee the reason for andhra ruined state
This is the first time justice has been served to Andhra Pradesh, where Congress divided the state without adequate provisions. Those criticizing Andhra Pradesh's funding should consider the past, where industries, ministries, and funds were diverted to Tamil Nadu for many years.
@ravikumar-zq9jf till now tamilnadu don't has any AIIMS. TN has NIT trichy, Ap has NIT tadepalligudem. TN has IIT madras, AP has IIT tirupati. AP also got eastern naval command, ISRO and so on while most of the chennai things are from british era Don't talk as if andhra got nothing and tamilnadu got everything.
@@josejoseph8725the treatment meted out to people of other languages by Tamil politicians and congress high command led to formation of linguist states. It is again when Chidambaram was home minister that Andhrapradesh was devided because Andhrapradesh had 42 mps. This was to weaken Telugu people's place in Centre.
@prabhakarvalivelu1955 the second class treatment done by andhra politicians to Telangana people forced Telangana people to protest for new state, the protests were very violent that many people died. Telangana statehood demand started with 1969 Telangana agitation (i.e even before chidambaram came) where 369 Telangana students were died. So stop over assuming yourself.
@@josejoseph8725 Don't include isro. They constructed it there just die to geography. And alot of Isro centers are present in Kerala and tn as well
@@josejoseph8725 Congress only included Telangana into Andhra Pradesh
The Bafoons who are crying that Andhra is getting funds cry it doesn't affect us at all. We were the one's who built Hyderabad but during separation what did we got nothing. Congress destroyed Andhra. From then onwards we waited for our time now we got our time. If you still cry then cry we dont care.
Why to give u states who are anti bjp , anti hindu , anti india and muslim supporting parties
Then why do u want to collect taxesvfrom these states
Well deserved special treatment needed for a state like Andhra which has been made a poor state artificially by the unilateral and unfair bifurcation done by Sonia gandhi. Congress has promised special status for Andhra. You need to thank BJP as it just stopped at allocating funds for capital city building. It was the turn of Tamilnadu during UPA rule of 10 years when the DMK was coalition partner. Today is the turn of Bihar and Andhra. Every state will ger turn in course. Be patient!
@@maheshkonidala9777 agree dear
@@Ravikumar-pd2dosecurity ehi is giving
@@Ravikumar-pd2do taxes are collected in these states hindus are divided by caste, sanatan dharma is insulted while muslims are given sweet treatment
India is blessed to Have states like Andhra/telangana/Karnataka...They simple keep hard woring, paying tax , Does not make fuss for govt facilities, No big protests or anything ..
This is how debate should be. Raise your hand and then get a chance to speak instead of talking over each other.
Those who are speaking about grants to Andhra.. you should know the state is divided by Congress in 2014 and the state lost its revenue generating capital city Hyderabad. It is the responsibility of the central government to implement AP Reorganization act for the development of the divided Andhra. Talking about other states, they have well established capital cities like chennai, Bangalore, Mumbai etc and getting revenue.
State governments who are not qualified to even be a nanny instead of a stepmother cannot provide more financial assistance than this!
Many ministers from Tamil Nadu and other states tried hard to bifurcate AP by giving nothing apart from debt to AP. So atleast now AP needs funds and justice from Center
The gentleman started to talk on a very important point… We don’t have any issues giving money to Bihar as Bihar is the poorest state in India… But till what time??? There should be some results coming out of it… on the contrary we are seeing 13 bridges collapsed in 2 weeks.. is this for we are spending our hard earned money??? This is a very important question we need to ask…
CONGRESS WILL NEVER EVER IN THEIR LIFETIME OR ETERNITY WILL WIN IN AP DUE TO THEIR INJUSTICE DONE TO AP.
Where are all these intellectuals when Andhra was bifurcated and left without a capital, and for 10 years neglected all projects.
Even Karnataka is not Recognised
Kerala is the Bihar of south India //it recently went bankrupt
Kerala 😂😂😂
Andra pradesh doesn't has a capital//it needs the money
I cannot think of politics without a capital😮😮😮
No state should compare and cry on state which don't even have a capital. Andhra deserve to get what it's getting as per the act of parliament which is due from last 10 years.
During Congress rule 3G scam was because of coalition compulsion. During NDA rule no compulsion to promote Corruption.
It's responsiblity of entire nation to fund and build Andhra Pradesh capital , as all the Members of Parliament trunketed the state against the will of Andhra Pradesh taking away the golden goose Hyderabad to telangana. We deserve even more.
Those who say kerala,TN , WB were neglected should check the 2021 -22 budget . When they announce special packages for Bihar and Andhra , it doesn't mean other states are not allocated anything. The present financial situation of Kerala is because of the poor governance of the state govt.
How did Dr. Ranganathan agree with the non factual statements by Mr. Gandhi?
Well said, sir. Even the BJP can't tell how difficult for it to give resources and why because both BRS and khangress exploit it though it really did a lot of regig to alott Rs 15000 crores due to Sonia dividing erstwhile AP to the disadvantage of AP by giving away Hyderabad totally and how difficult for it to make good the revenue loss, give amount to construction of the capital with its position itself is precarious. Criminals are khangress and BRS for AP.
Sri RN 👏👏👏👏👏👏
People: How many father you have
Chaudhary: East Pakistanis has rights in Bangladesh
People: How many father you have
Chaudhary: East Pakistanis are relatives
I challenge all politicians to bring a resolution to have only one pension per MLA/ MP. Then see the amount available for development. Hamam mein sab nange hai
Either keep income tax or indirect tax
You cannot have both. This is extortion.
Guilty DMK feels being jilted. Ask yourself what proposal you have put up. So far no DMK have mentioned what proposal you have been missed. It's all sour grapes
I used to admire mr anand as reasonable person, but his silence over personal tax and gagging the middle class shows his slavish mindset.
Dont you think products made is TN and rich state is used by entire country. Shall we start putting tax like import tax in other states .andhra people have contributed to chennai in madras presidency. hyderabad and bangalore ( where 25 percent people leave).
And they go on to say caste reservation doesn’t create distrust amongst Indians? Where are all those deshbhakts ? Inequality in taxation doesn’t divide Indians? Only Inequality in budget allocation divides the states and Indians??
😂😂😂tamilnadu congress chidambaram divided ap.. 2014 ... Now 2024 got 26000 to POLAVARAM project. ... Loan15000 to new capital of andra😂😂😂
NDA should help AP any how..other wise Modi Chair is in danger.
Karnatak govt has been giving less than 5% revenue to development of North Karnatak region, while we in north Karnatak has been paying 100% taxes; karnatak govt gave most of it to one city known as Bangalore.
Why ???
I am from karnataka and i am glad about this. Let people suffer for more freebies😂
Bihar is really sad case of investment 😮
In the last 5 years there has been no development in the Adhra due to the CM having 32 CBI/ED cases. Jai Janasena
No body is taking about Odisha which mostly facing cyclones at least twice every year
Andhra Pradesh devided by Sonia ji's congress and promised spl status to AP. Now says against
India needs a TAX PAYERS UNION which will sanction these budgets
This one sided govt budgets are not working.
AP is not still a full fledged State. Revenue comparison between TN & AP is not justified.
Ranganathan's whole career is built on clowning 'i'm smarter than you' grins on media platform. When infact, his grin is about 'i'm paid to pass this grin and suggest every opposition argument is a conspiracy'
Tamilnadu is most benefited state from south since the independence. Still they complain
Stupid dmk 65 years they sing the song even when khancross was ruling
Against the wish of AP people, the state was divided with no capital. That was done by the central govt. Now the fund allotted is for building the capital.
I do agree with one of panel as how long we need to give funds to state like Bihar where there is no improvements from decades.
Andra we can understand as it is new state and chandra babu Naidu will show results fir each penny given to his state.
Then why TM govt is giving freebies from our tax money?? We pay so much tax but what we are getting as tax payers...
Nobody talks about the injustice done to Andhra, the vulgar way in which the state was divided without a capital and the empty promise of special status, which was reneged subsequently both by congress and bjp. The people are docile and never protested the way they were shortchanged. Telangana created a false narrative of backwardness and being exploited by Andhra and was rewarded with all the benefits including the capital Hyderabad.
Chennai sambar taste nice
Politics has touched the lowest point with the formation of the INDI bloc.
False narratives are the norm of the day .
These chokers who cry about AP getting funds do'nt understand that these benefits are officially promised to AP as pre-condition before bifurcating AP and making it Orphan. In fact both BJP & Congress back stabbed Andhra by not giving special status which was promised on floor parliament which was not fulfilled.
AP was cheated by center two times. Once by giving away chennai to Tamilnadu when AP was carved out from Madras state where as Telugu people had a big part of Chennai. Then again second time the same happened with Telangana bifurcation. You can not cheat same state twice by promising & not giving the same.--😬
@Vidyasagarbb chennai never belonged to you andhras BTW, chennai was a good trading centre with so many lakes and ancient temples from thiruvallikeni to thiruvotriyur established by chola rajas. After that british annexed chennai from arcot nawabs using doctrine of lapse with the help of andhra zamins who support british extensively. Don't cry on chennai everytime as if it belong to yours, you andhra people got tirupati at that time driving away tamils.
@@josejoseph8725 You neither seem to have facts nor have manners. When you split a state, when the capital is capitalized by both the people who are now getting split, they deserve another city being developed or get common capital. That never happened. If you have elders at home, go ask them telugu speaking population % in chennai. show your ignorance somewhere else. Did you even read the discussions that happened in Center & state assembly during separation of Andhra? Do you even know that Tirupati was not even a big town & you claim that to be equivalent of chennai? have some bone of truth. I am not surprised at your ignorance in your words because I know where is it coming from. Stop crying here for me stating facts. All I said was to remind that Andhra state did not get their due twice in history. if you have problem with facts, deal with it.,.
@Vidyasagarbb first you need to be ashamed to claim someone historical lands. For you chennai is just capital and tirupati is a town but we have thousands of years relation with those lands. Just because andhra people helped british to build fort and resulted in whole colonization of India and got benefits from chennai doesn't mean we have to give our thousands of years land to you! However you heartless people snatched away our tirumalai and kalahasthi, which are important places in our tamil bhakti movements. Also for you hyderabad is golden egg laying goose you don't have emotions regarding hyderabad like telangana people. The centre- state assembly are all formed after 1947 but our cholas developed chennai more than 1000 years ago. No wonder you don't like historical facts and clinging towards history after 18th century as your andhra zamins joined british and did enough looting our chennai! Also at that time andhra happpily accepted the looted tirupati and never complained. Atlast you money minded people only wanted revenue from that cities like chennai and hyderabad nothing more than that. Just because you don't want to hear facts, facts never change.
@@josejoseph8725 When you have some fabricated historical reasons to claim Chennai (aka Madras), then why you are uttering Hyderbad belongs only to Telangana. Wasn't Seema Andhra part of Hyderabad princely state when it was sold by Nizam Nawab's predecessors to the British. If I were Tamil, I would keep quiet rather than regurgitate some fabricated history.
@@josejoseph8725 what you said is the most foolish statement I heard in a long time. Not me but you should be ashamed of both your ignorance and stupidity of highest order. Just because you use some abuses, historical facts won’t change. Have some shame in spreading lies. Don’t you know that, those days when language based states are not made, the extensive land of the south are divided differently and most Andhra people were both part of and investing in their capital which is chennai? When new state is divided, it’s obvious that there has to be a consensus on the lands as well as capital. Have you read the bill separating the state of Andhra from Tamil Nadu? Or you think your arrogance and abuses will cover up for ignorance and idiocy?? It’s a highly discussed topic and documented fact that Andhra people are rightful owners of the common land from ancestry. It’s also agreed that, Tirupati is a temple town with very less income for state to sustain than Chennai. Still Andhra people accepted because of the bias and bullying by tamils. And that bullying is still can be seen from you arrogant and abusive intolerance. Tirupati and Kalahasthi belong to entire Hindus and not just a bully population. ThankGod these sacred places did not fall in your land of athiests who are hellbent to destroy Hinduism and you have audacity to ask for Such sacred places. By the way the very name of kalahasthi is a Sanskrit name and a Sanskrit hating cult claiming for it laughable.
Next, abusing entire andhra people because they stated historical facts exposes you and your mindset. Have guts to open and read the extensive studies and discussions that happened in parliament and assembly while separating Telugu state from the bullying tamils. I have respect for Tamils but can’t hide facts to an ignorant hater online who abuses entire Andhra people for his ignorance.
Next, If f Andhra people were money minded, they would have converted name to Joseph for cheap rice bags from church and elected Dravidian politicians again and again. But they didn’t do it. They got a state after 56 days of fasting on to death by Shri Potti Sree Ramulu. Real money minded people are happy not to split state and fighting for it because they can continue to loot. And now despite all these being well documented facts, an idiot comes and uses some abuses to paint a different picture is beyond idiocy.
By the way, why are you crying for Tirupati when your name is Joseph? Is it to try and destroy the temple which is core pillar for f Hinduism? With the Christian’s in the name of athiests ruling your state for several decades, why do you even deserve the temple?
Andhra people unlike their looters do trust and invest their hard earned money and hardwork in any state that they belong. So they invested in Hyderabad which is now again snatched away from them. If hatefilled eyes can’t see it, I pity such people. Andhra people were not selfish nor money minded but wanted to separate from a selfish, bullying money minded, Christian stooges and hence they led movement and even lost lives. One can abuse but can never change those facts. Shame on anyone who never read a single discussion but keeps exposing verbal diarrhoea.-
Every one wants to save ones Kursi. AND they criticise others. 3:46