For me modern horizons 3 is an s teir along with bloom burrow just because of bias. Ngl i love mh3 i got the eldrazi deck and with some help understanding it from a friend and upgrading it with a few cards it destroys even more that it dose straight out of the box. other than that i think your teir list was pretty accurate and encompassed most peoples feelings about releases this year :)
Actually, MH3 is the only S tier of 2024.... I put Bloomburrow at a C. COMPLETE miss in every aspect... Flavor - barf, Good Cards - meh, power level - meh. Really nothing good about that set IMO. I also have Duskmourne and Foundations as A-Tier.
for me s- A- foundation B- MH3 ( after 2 box i don't need more vs mh2 i open 6 box and i love opening mh2 box), Bloomburrow i love the flavor and nice limited format but for the rest i pass C- Duskmourn (good card but i don't like the lore and the flavor) Outlaw (good mechanic spree and plot but the the story is pretty bad and i didn't really like bonus sheet in particular in this set with breaking new and big score), Ravnica remaster ( good for shock but ravnica miss something ) D- Fallout ( i don't care), assassin creed ( i'm not a fan of the franchise and beyond booster) murder at karlov (bad story and a shit load of trash card) Clue edition (useless)
Go to rankings, Matt. Couldn't have been better. Go to choices. Excellent work
Cool video man. I’m pretty much right there with you. I agree with all of your choices. 😎👍. Not a bad year for magic.
Appreciate that, glad you're enjoying the video!
In terms of raw card power for commander, what’s the best?
For me modern horizons 3 is an s teir along with bloom burrow just because of bias. Ngl i love mh3 i got the eldrazi deck and with some help understanding it from a friend and upgrading it with a few cards it destroys even more that it dose straight out of the box. other than that i think your teir list was pretty accurate and encompassed most peoples feelings about releases this year :)
You forgot to mention nadu fun times with consideration for modern horizons 3 to be S tier
You’re right, good call!
Actually, MH3 is the only S tier of 2024.... I put Bloomburrow at a C. COMPLETE miss in every aspect... Flavor - barf, Good Cards - meh, power level - meh. Really nothing good about that set IMO. I also have Duskmourne and Foundations as A-Tier.
for me
s-
A- foundation
B- MH3 ( after 2 box i don't need more vs mh2 i open 6 box and i love opening mh2 box), Bloomburrow i love the flavor and nice limited format but for the rest i pass
C- Duskmourn (good card but i don't like the lore and the flavor) Outlaw (good mechanic spree and plot but the the story is pretty bad and i didn't really like bonus sheet in particular in this set with breaking new and big score), Ravnica remaster ( good for shock but ravnica miss something )
D- Fallout ( i don't care), assassin creed ( i'm not a fan of the franchise and beyond booster) murder at karlov (bad story and a shit load of trash card) Clue edition (useless)