Iron Farm Changes, new Farm Design App, and a new 9000/hr Farm for Minecraft 1.16.2 [Fun Farms 34]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2024
- Today we have 34th Episode of Fun Farms, where I discuss changes to Iron Farms in 1.16.2, update our previous designs to 1.16.2 and provide a new 20X design capable of producing 9000 items/hr with minimal compute requirements
I also introduced a new AI Tracker app that can be used to design and debug your own farms. AI tracker app is bundled with carpet 1.4.9 for Minecraft 1.16.2
To load the app, type
`/script load ai_tracker`
then use it with the `/ai_tracker` command.
Downloads for updated 1.16.2 designs (single cell, updated quad setups, updated 10x setup, and a new 20x, 9000/hr design):
bit.ly/ff34_ir...
Previous talk on iron farms in 1.14.4:
• Simple, Cheap, Efficie...
--------------
Recorded with Minecraft 1.16.2 Carpet Mod 1.4.9
Carpet Mod with Scarpet API:
github.com/gne...
github.com/gne...
github.com/gne...
github.com/gne...
Carpet Mod for 1.12:
github.com/gne...
Minecraft IGN: gnembon
Find me on Twitter: / gnembon_mc
Intros/Outros by Reye and TDL
Music:
Edvard Grieg - Holberg Suite. musopen.org/mu...
![Piglin Bartering at 800000 items/h like a BOSS. [Fun Farms 33]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/re3OKwY2UKs/mqdefault.jpg)
I have tested this on 1.20.4 and yes - it still works a charm. Thank you Gnembon!
Also remember that in newer versions you should install lightning rods to keep your villagers safe
Logs on to Minecraft: Huh my iron farm broke. Wonder if there is a fix?
Gnembon: HERE'S A FIX PLUS A NEW DESIGN PLUS A TOOL TO HELP YOU MAKE YOUR OWN!!
Gnembon, I know this comment will seem really cliché but, I really enjoy what you do and how you do/explain it! I really hope you also enjoy making it as much as we enjoy watching it! Keep doing what you do
LIKE THIS COMMENT SO GBEMBON SEES IT. PLEASE.
I like the accent
Same!
Haha I was literally just about to make your old design
I just finishes his old design
@@sjorsbarten8900 same, few days ago. now i wish i would have waited xD ahh well, 10 villager cell design is already producing way more iron than id ever need. maybe i should just consider that i dont really need double that xD
yep i too was just about to make it
BUT HAS IT STOPPED WORKING ??
Jhazzrun yes its more than i need but i feel like i Should have waited
Me too 😂😂😂
Tested in 1.18 and it works
Could u plz tell me where to afk for this farm :))
@@safinmasteryoutube1461 Either build it in your spawn chunks in which case it would function 24/7 or if u build it somewhere else then just make sure you're not super far away from it (more than 128 blocks). around 30 blocks away from the nearest module's center should be ok.
@@Person-hb3dv Really appreciate your reply. Thank you. Is it a good idea to make the farm 128 blocks above the ground? (Spawn proofing or smthing I am quiet new). And being afk at the centre of the farm for maximum irons? :))
@@safinmasteryoutube1461 I don't think you'd need that. ig around 30 blocks above the surface would be ok
@@Person-hb3dv ok bro thank you. And I should afk in the centre of all the chunks that the farm is built on right? (And yes it is Abt 1000 blocks away from spawn so need to afk) Hope u can clear my confusion :))
We all know the guys in hermitcraft are building this farm next season xD
next? they'll dismantled they farm right when they update!
@@ErreGamer Lol probably xD
Not tango
Hermitcraft is based on gnembon
@@hoops1133 at this point it they should rename the server to GNEMBONCRAFT! I can imagine Xsuma saying, welcome back to GnembonCraft! xDDDDDDD
Can confirm, works on 1.18.1
Material list for the 20x farm (based on litematica):
1598 glass
600 slab
260 fence
205 packed ice
131 rail
120 string
120 carpet
60 bed
60 villagers
40 chain
30 sign
28 pressure plate
20 blocks
16 powered rail
15 redstone dust
10 lava bucket
10 redstone comparator
8 torch
5 button
5 detector rail
5 redstone torch
2 hopper (or more)
1 pillager
where did you get the litematica farm ??
@@guillaumebaert693 just download the world save and make yourself schematic
Hey please can u share the file of litematic pls
@@topg6500 download the world and do it yourself, not that difficult
Tested it in 1.18.1 and it works perfectly.
Block List for the 9000/hr farm according to Litematica(so it should be completely accurate):
-1598 glass blocks
-600 slabs
-260 fences
-205 packed ice
-131 rails
-120 string
-120 carpets
-60 beds
-50 water buckets
-40 chains
-30 signs
-28 pressure plates
-20 solid blocks
-16 powered rails
-15 redstone dust
-10 lava buckets
-10 redstone comparators
-8 torches
-5 wood buttons
-5 detector rails
-5 redstone torches
-2 hoppers (obviously not counting the ones you need for your own storage system)
The dimensions are 80x23x45
thanks king
Can I have the litematica file pls
Your mod is too over the top my friend, you must be breaking the law somewhere :-] Jokes apart congrats on your 100K plaque, your contributions to the communuity are very appreciated!
Am I the only one who knows this dude invented the categorizer showcased in impulseSV's HC7 base?
@@ashishagrawal1406 no you aren't
It also looks like that you could use Nit-Wits in Iron Farms, as they no longer require Workstations to function again.
Yeah, I can’t see why they wouldn’t work.
Do they sleep and wake up later than normal villagers?
@@theseangle I didn't consider that and don't know if it's a factor or not. But considering how rare Nit-Wits are, you could just have them Breed as they don't need a Profession to do that, or have one handy if you have a Channeling Trident and a Thunderstorm pops up. (May want to set up a Potion Farm before you convert the Nit-Wit to a Witch, as they are nowhere near as aggressive.)
Sacrifice them
Rough estimate of amounts (not all items were included)
- 390 blocks (turn into 780 slabs)
-1284 glass
-185 packed ice
-134 rails
-60 beds
-120 string
-40 iron chains
-120 carpet
16 powered rail
-5 detector rail
Feel free to comment corrections (or additions) to make this list more accurate for others. Personally, for how I play survival, I really would've liked to see a list of items and amounts somewhere.
glass: 1598 = 24 stacks + 62
slab: 601 = 9 stacks + 25
fence: 260 = 4 stacks + 4
packed ice: 205 = 3 stacks + 13
rail: 131 = 2 stacks + 3
carpet: 120 = 1 stack + 56
string: 120 = 1 stack + 56
bed: 60
water bucket (water source): 50
chain: 40
sign: 30 = 1 stack + 14
pressure plate: 28
solid block: 20
powered rail: 16
redstone dust: 15
lava bucket: 10
redstone comparator: 10
torch: 8
detector rail: 5
redstone torch: 5
button: 5
hopper: 2
Time to edit my iron farm for the 20th time it seems lol
@10:24 correction, mobs can spawn on iron trapdoors since 1.16. You can now make a vanilla shifting floor without relying on glitches
edit: I was wrong mobs can spawn on trapdoors up to 1.16.1, it was removed in 1.16.2
Δημήτρης Παπανικολάου my fortress farm was broken when they change that, this is the best news I heard all month
Actually mobs spawning on trap doors was patched in 1.16.2, and the current method of shifting floor isn't using a glitch.
And now I'm sad again
@@jurassic1067 depends on what you consider to be a glitch. Current shifting floor designs use the elevation change between soul sand and regular blocks to function. I don't think that this is intended behaviour and it could get patched.
@@dimitrispapanikolaou6699 Mojang confirmed it won't get patched
It's a glitch which turned into a feature
gnembon dude, this is some crazy sh*t you make, you're the man. aitracker is pure awesomeness.
*shit
@Rafiul Alam does he have a tool? hmmmm?
@Rafiul Alam Just scaled up lmfao and just a rip off of an already existing design. Shulkercraft has no technical skill. They hold no candle to Gnembon or any other technical minecrafter.
excellent, as always. I was just struggling with my villager breeding setup because of the bed changes and this solves the mystery of why the heck they won't get out of bed on the stupid fence post anymore! Always look forward to your vids, gnembon. Informative and fun. You're a credit to the community.
when i heard visitor design pattern i was like "aaaah yes, he's a good programmer..."
Gnembon, your're simply a genious
Gnembon THE GOAT!!!!!!!!!!
@@Tactcat GGOAT
SIMP????!!!?!??
@@ThoVCor999 lol
Gnembon: Creates better iron farm.
Tango: STONKS!!!!
what is he gonna do next to kill golems tho? do guardians target them?
@@samschellhase8831 no, not unless golemns attack them first
tango designs his own farms :)
(I bet he'll use the new tool tho)
Ceazar Carr yeah, I was just trying to think of a different obscure mob to kill the golems
Ooh, thanks a lot, that'll come in handy!
As for the tracker functions: it would be really useful if there were functions for other villager-related data, such as their designated beds and inventories (for breeding) or workstations (for trading halls).
I believe he addressed how to do that in his 1.14 villager breeder vid
@@jonaspaladin1398 True, I even used that, but the new tool seems way more flexible. As far as I recall, there was no way to see which bed the villager chose (only if it was taken/available or not) and which items are in its inventory (only the number of portions). The latter would be especially handy to keep track of inventory fillers and food types, and could also be used to debug crop farms
@@Sithoid There's actually a datapack by Zefryo which allows you to see the closest villager's bed and workstation, discord.gg/grz5UCW
is his discord, it's in #creations
Love that you just share your world downloads with google drive without a confusing advertising site.
Great video as always. I love how gnembon explains his entire though process in designing a farm. Keep doing what you are doing!
Gnembon, I don't know what I'd do without you. You're a hero bro
gnembon cat scare radius would be perfect for this data pack
its not a datapack, its a mod.
I'm so happy for you Gnembon for reaching 100k subs and getting your plaque! It's well deserved! You put together incredible designs/ideas for those of us who love the technical aspects of minecraft. I will continue to be a big fan of your channel, keep up the amazing work!🥳
Important: do not build all cells at once or the poi gets skuffed. build one cell at a time and put 3 villagers in it and repeat. i cant remember if he said it in the video, but i have to rebuild it now^^
Just yesterday I noticed that the old design wasn't working anymore perfect timing
Thank you! I could not figure out what was wrong with my iron farm, now I have the answer.
wow these rose farms are getting their own branch of science!
Materials list for the 20x setup: (these are not exact, so bear with me)
260 (4 stacks and 4 blocks) Birch Fence
20 solid blocks (in the video they used iron blocks)
2 chests (just extra storage, you're gonna need it)
5 detector rails
1596 (24 stacks and 60 blocks) glass
2 hoppers
1 lava bucket
205 (3 stacks and 13 blocks) packed ice
16 powered rails
600 (9 stacks and 24 blocks) slabs
131 (stacks and 3 blocks) rails
10 Redstone comparators
15 redstone dust
5 redstone torches
120 (1 stack and 56 blocks) string
6 torches
1 water bucket
76 (1 stack and 12 blocks) carpet
thank
I struggled for like 2 weeks on my own with villagers falling off their beds before I found the solution with placing carpet above them. I should have just watched this video- arg!! Thank you!
It would be great to see the ai tracker with a raid farm
The AiTracker is an invaluable tool, Gnembon! That vertical design is similar to what I did in 1.15, but I wasn't sure how far the golem detect range was, so the bottom 2 quads weren't spawning like 80% of the time. I will use this app and attempt to make a dense vertical design that prevents the golems from being detected as they fall. I'm sure it can be done.
> Visitor Design Pattern
Oh god, no please anything but OOP
OOP is good, it's all the patterns >< I have nightmares of factories, visitors, singletons that aren't really singletons and whatever else :'(
@@Blazagg oop ?
@Primus xyz Im a java developer at work (i graduated a year ago with a CS degree but used python a lot right before graduating). ive forgotten all the terms and stuff of OOP so whenever anyone says anything im just like ...????
setting it up so that all 4 villager pods trigger a summon at the same time is genius. Completely trivializes making an efficient iron farm. I can't help but note that if a pillager is used for such a set up, with a little bit of careful placement, you could theoretically triple the rates of this farm.
So I missed why you made it a 5 station (20x) design? Was that just for timing purposes, and it works better than if you had made it a 4 station (16x) design, like the older ones? Could you do 6 as well to keep it a nice rectangle design?
I have build 12 villager and pillager one works good on 1.21.1, a major issue I ran into was that the villagers were not able to sleep so no iron golems were spawning, after looking into it again I figured that I had placed the beds in opposite direction (the head cushion part was on the opposite) due to this the villagers weren't able to sleep and wont produce any golems, just place the cushion part of the bed towards the villagers like in the video and it works :D
Thanks! I was looking for someone to say if it still worked on version 1.21.1, I will take your advice on the beds into consideration. :)
Can you make a step by step tutorial for the final farm that you have displayed? It would be much appreciated
A little late but there is a tutorial on YT now
Wher is it
Just use litematica
Thank you so much for the fix for the old design! I've been looking for these answers since the iron farm on our server broke last week with 1.16.2.
[=20x design exact resource list=]
1598 Glass
600 Slabs
260 Fences
205 Packed Ice
131 rails
120 string
120 white carpet
60 beds
60 villagers
50 water sources
40 chain
30 signs
28 pressure plates
22 solid blocks
16 powered rails
15 redstone dust
10 lava sources
10 comparators
8 torches
5 buttons
5 detector rails
5 redstone torches
2 hoppers
1 Pillager
you are a great person.
@@joper3338 thanks! =)
I though it was 1592 glass... I must have missed something
@@ryanlarson6835 I could've messed up somewhere. I used litematica, so it's possible!
@@nivdy It's probably because I removed all of the unnecessary glass
These new visualizations are soooo much better than the old ones! Absolutely incredible work, as always. Love it! Thanks for your time. :)
7:57 is the fix for the old iron farm. Your welcome.
This is amazing! You have so much talent!
That into is a time capsule to 2012.
IDK if it would fit under the AI tracker or not, but I've been having trouble with Raid farms recently. Specifically I think the nature of the village centre location which scans for the illagers/raid. I've not been able to find a mod/app that will tell me where it is so that I can investigate what's going on better.
Can Carpet do that? I admit I'm pretty noob at all this atm it's enitrely possible I've missed the functionality I need somewhere :S
This is rly useful for being able to adjust Iron Farms before updating to 1.16.2 as well as the huge farm at the end being something worth working towards.
Love your videos!
Also of note you mentioned the Cauldron Iron Farm as preferable earlier but I'd argue against that. I once spent 5 hours trying to get a zombie to fit into a cauldron and they would always stand on the edges. The trapdoor version would be preferable to me as an actually easy early iron farm. Anything without the Cauldron honestly. I'm sure there are tricks but if it's just a starter farm why make it require tricks?
Anyway that's not really the point of your video so NVM :P
You don't have the amount of followers you deserve, it's amazing.
Awesome! I made the Pillager quad farm. Nothing like a farm that fits inside one chunk and pumps out 4 iron golems at a time. I even used a captain so I can see his banner bouncing up and down -forever.
I think an AI tracker app with bee would be really helpful !
I love how in depth your farm videos are
Bro I get 13 stacks of iron blocks per hour on a realm. This farm is insane
Hey gnembon, these videos have really helped me with learning more and I've been getting more and more into making my own farm designs. I made a 2-cell iron farm with the help from these and I'm really pleased with how it turned out, plenty enough iron for me on my realm.
Hah! What a nice explanation of all the concepts related to iron farm. You always make the best farms. Also, hermitcraft people coming to take this idea in 3...2...1...
Hermit and almost every sub from his chanel and anyone how knows about this farm, cause it's simply the best.
I don't think so, they will just fix it probably. They will make a new farm if the old is completely broken, or if they start another season.
They don't take... Why do you think gnembon posts these videos ? To help the redstone community. Also whenever hermits build gnembons farms they always mention that it was gnembons design and usually give links to the tutorials
No hermit plans on building iron farms at the moment. Tango has his own design so he does not care... And Mumbo will probably just make the changes that were shown in this video. Xisuma's farm also does not need these changes and neither does Keralis's farm. I don't see this as an impact to Hermitcraft at all. It does affect people like us who have his designs in our own survival worlds. Impulse might build this, but that is it. Etho will kill himself before thinking about going online for farm designs.
I recently noticed that villagers have a new type POI entry in their "Brain" data, besides home, workstation and meeting point, they now also list golems they have seen and where. I'm not entirely sure why this were added but I suspect it might be due to some of the bugs pertaining to golems spawning out of control in villages (which they still seem to do)
And their pathfinding also seem to be changed a bit in 1.16.3, they have difficulties pathfinding up stairs correctly and often try to jump up on the side of stair blocks that are 2 blocks up which they can't and they will continue to do so until either being pushed by someone or getting a new pathfinding task.
It would be nice if you could make a video about some of the bugs/issues there are with villagers. Highligting the problem they cause and how to mitigate some of them when playing around with villagers.
Hey, I've just built the farm you showed at 18:27 and, even by using litematica to make sure things were correct, this farm keeps breaking. I did a long afk session in the area (spawn chunks) and I got nothing. One thing I noticed is that only one or 2 villagers per cell sleep when the farm is off, and even when I make them pathfind and sleep properly, they generate some iron golems but still stop pathfinding to the bed soon after and it breaks. Is there a solution for this?
Same, I did it exactly like the world and only two of them sleep, but they dont spawn any iron golems
@@tesiiin dude same!
Same problem
@@santiagomejia6540 make sure the beds are facing the correct way
Guys I fixed this a long time ago but didn't post my solution, sorry. I changed the layout of the beds, keeping the single glass block that they stand on at the same place. It's a layout that Gnembon uses during the video. Here it is: imgur.com/a/1nlvY4t
Nice designs I love your vids :)
I would love to see a tutorial for the last design, as I'm thinking of building it in my world
There's a world download in the description.
@@SuperNikio2 how do I download it? Is it not working or am I crazy?
Coming back to this video to check some things.. It's a classic! Thanks for everything, Gnembon. You're a wizard :)
I need help. I build this on a server but the problem is it take a bit longer for the villager to be scare and the cooldown is running slow. The only fix I can think of is making the comparator timer a bit longer but that fix is not always gonna work every time the Pillager come around. So any fix or solution?
I've got the same problem on a server. sometimes the villagers won't get scared at all
make sure that there are glass blocks above rails as shown in the world download. it will stop the pillager from scaring the villagers to early. and scare them all at the same time with would result in a consistent 4 iron golems per module.
Hey i just got the same Problem aswell did you find a fix by any chance? Also what server are you running? ours is paper with constant 20tps i guess paper breaks the farm but i am not to sure. golems only spawn every second time the pillager comes around
@@jermainaugustin8750 you ever fix this?
@@hithere9530 Not really. It seems like paper changes the spawning of iron golems or interactions between villagers or something. Vanilla and Fabric works fine
I so needed this video. All my villagers keep falling out of bed. Didn't want to cart another 30 villagers just to have it happen again.
gnembon is absolutely incredible. Your content is such high quality, man. I really do appreciate all the effort you put in!
pure genius!!!!
I just built an iron farm and im on 1.16.1, will it still work on 1.16.2?
Yeah you're good
yeah, it will. it will only be a bit slower at night. Just change the bed design as he showed in this video and you're good to go
Should be. Just make sure the killing lava blade still works: most old designs had golems touching both water and lava. This was patched in 1.16.2
You just have to add string and carpet over all the bed blocks
@@zay_dog1267 no, this only happens in 1.16.1 pre relase, this was reverted back in 1.16.1 full release.
Good vid, so cool you mentioned spigot, I switched over to fabric, for more vanilla behavior, but I know spigot/paper is pushed hard by hosting sites. Pretty cool.
Please update the villager trading system vid! P L E A S E
Nice touch with the Iskall gold plate spawn protection. :)
Imagine just minding your own business and some random person shoves you into a weird thing and puts a criminal near you,
So you call the police but they just burn up.
Lol nice drugs but ok
Thank you for the clarification and the idea for a small cell 9 villager farm!
Does this farm still work in 1.16.4?
Have you tried? I was thinking about it
Absolutely fantastic work! Would be nice to have the velocity include a magnitude value as well :)
Does it work on 1.20?
Yes
I love you. Ever since I saw my first video from you, it was love at first sight. Now this video has shown me much more I should love you. Thank you Gnembon. Congrats on getting your award. You deserve it and so much more!
After Shulkercraft
You've gained a new subscriber! This tool looks amazing and is extremely useful.
Video posted 4 seconds ago lol
Tested the 20x iron farm on 1.20.1 and it works like a charm so you dont have to worry to make it and i doesnt work and it is hard to make but not too hard that its not worth it if you make it in the spawn chunks you will have an ungodly amount of iron and red roses
Congratulations on reaching this mark. You trully deserved it. All the work and effort you put on your videos is not something we see every day. Thank you for that
Can I suggest tracking for farmer villager behavior in the AI tracking app? I think there's probably some room for improvement with regard to villager-based crop farms that could be more easily explored with tracking.
gnembon you are the man! This is a beautiful piece of work. Good job!
I just built this and it’s amazing. Definitely time consuming to get the villagers in but it’s definitely worth it.
As always, you are a fount of knowledge on the technical aspect of Minecraft. Thank you for all the hard work. I really appreciate it.
Wonderful stuff as usual!
Tested in 1.21.1 and works! At least the 4x iron farm
Pls make an in depth tutorial block to block, great video!
Just download the world and copy it?
Thx
I love your farm ,
I appreciate the work for this community , thanks dude
i love your video presentation style. keep up the great work!
That new horrorcoaster design at the end is very nice. Though the previous one made so much iron I can't imagine needing the better version. It is good to see there isn't much needed to fix the previous one.
12:30 “Youʼre not gaining much. Youʼre gaining a few seconds at best”
Based on the mechanics in your previous video, and my own testing, that means you arenʼt gaining *anything*. Golems can only spawn every 100 ticks, and the way the counter works (based on `/tick freeze` testing), that means even if theyʼre removed instantly they canʼt respawn as soon as the 30-second countdown reaches zero. This means that the fastest possible design is a 35-second spawning cycle, so as long as you remove golems within 5 seconds itʼs essentially free.
I suppose portals might remove golems at a different point in the tick meaning that they *did* let you work on a 30-second clock instead of a 35-second one, for almost a 17% improvement, but I donʼt think so, and if that doesnʼt work in 1.16.2 any more then itʼs not worth it to me to test that either.
Oh, I think misunderstood; I thought that was still part of the reload farm fix. And reload farms *were* 7 times faster, not 17%, which you said would make it worth it for you.
I do not know if that can be done but if not this can be a nicr feature. Add the hability to show valid spawn points with in the 8 block sphere. Did I explain it well? my english is not 100% good :)
Gnembon is that one professor that actually teaches the subject in a way that you can understand.
Your videos have two uses, at least: your videos are good to get the best information on the specific farms, and to sleep because your voice and the background music are so relaxing.
It seems absolutely crazy to me that you only have 123k subscribers. Should easily be more in the 1.23 million range
thank you for your videos and mod
Thank you for this. I've been super discouraged from making one given how much they have changed in the past year. Seems like whenever a new design comes out, it only survives 3-6 months. Hoping this will be the last design I have to adapt to.
I love this iron farm design and I made it for myself. I did however find one small problem with it that has a simple fix. The distance between the spawning platform and the bottom of the redstone timer in only 2 blocks. Since iron golems are taller than 2 blocks, I kept having them get stuck causing that whole module to stop producing golems as one already existed. The solution I found was move the comparitor timer up one block being powered by the side of the detector rail instead of the underside. That made the gap 3 instead of 2 and I no longer have golems getting stuck. Line of site does not change so spawn rates appear to be unaffected by the change.
I found an easier solution. 1) Use solid blocks instead of glass for the circuit platform. 2) There should be no block under the block with the redstone torch.
Honest Question: I am trying to understand the village spacing mechanics. How are we able to place these villages 12 blocks away from each other with out combining, when village mechanics states a distance of 32 (64×64 village center)? Thanks in advance. Love the amount of information you provide!
Excellent video, thanks a lot!
- What are you need for big iron farm?
- Some iron for some rails...
For anybody wondering, I tested the farm shown at 19:30 on fabric 1.21 and it does still work.
I'll go insane doing this tomorrow, thanks :)
This was very helpful. Thanks gnembon.
You're the best Gnembon! Of course you knew that already because you are a super genius, but I felt I should tell you anyway. Thanks!