I put the recipe details in the description if you are curious. This not a tested recipe, just one I came up with so I'm not sure how it will turn out... I'll. Update of course once. It's done! Enjoy👍🍻
Hi, I have a question. Before bottling the beer do we use any method to kill the yeast post fermentation or does the yeast remain in the bottle and till the consumer drinks the beer? Does it make it a safe beer to drink?
I have their early 110v system, which was an upgrade from my basic “turkey fryer in the garage” set up. It takes a bit longer to get to temp but otherwise, it has been great. Easy to use, easy to clean and we’ve made some great beer with it.
How long does the 110v system take to come up to mash temp and then to boil temp? They tend to gloss over the timelines in their videos, which makes it hard to judge the system fully.
Brian, thanks for all the great videos. I’ve been using the 120V version of this system for a while now. There’s no need for a double crush. The micron mesh level of the grain basket is small enough that I use a .025 setting on my mill and I hit my pre-boil and original gravities very consistently. One crush at that setting and you’re good to go.
Yep.. I leave mine a bit wider since I am not just brewing on one system.. The double crush was the solution for me not to adjust the mill. Should have done it this time..live and learn!! 👍🍻
Love their 120v system, for the money. I added a whirlpool arm and an edge pickup tube. Made all the difference. Great to see they are working out the kinks with the big boy model. I hope to see more brew days on this system.
I run a DIY basket type system and I get between 85-90% efficiency regularly. My experience is that you do a normal strike water volume as if you were doing a 3 vessel brew. Use a smaller crush (I’m set to around .037”), slow down recirculation and stir about every 10 minutes. Then sparge to preboil volume as you would with a 3 vessel system. Of course this requires another vessel for sparge water, I use the grainfather hot liquor tank personally..
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Hi Brian. Was curious. I noticed the basket is mesh on all sides even up to the top. Seems like most of the ebiab systems like foundry/robo have a mash basket that is not mesh/perforated on the sides, but rather, only near the bottom. Does having a basket with mesh up to the top allow the flow to go out the basket near the top instead of filtering down through the grain? Does having the mesh all the way up the sides affect effeciency if it can "leak out" the sides near the top? Thanks!
Yeah that seems to be the consensus. In hindsight I think my mash was lower than 148 to be honest. I am almost 100% sure. The beer finished at 1.008 so it was definitely low.
First of all. Your channel is awesome. I've learned so much about equipment and the process. I'm looking to upgrade from my 3 tier 10 gallon batch cooler system to an EBIAB. I've narrowed it down to the clawhammer 240 or the Anvil 18 gallon. In your opinion, which is the better system all the way around. I know the clawhammer is modular (which is why I'm kind of leaning that way) but also just recently saw that anvil now makes an 18 that does 10 gallon batches. Now I'm torn between the 2. Thank you for your response and for the information on all things brewing. Cheers
Thanks for the feedback! They are both good systems so you really can't go wrong with either one. The Anvil has a little less power requirements than the clawhammer so that is a difference to note. The Anvil will run on a 20 amp inline GFCI (Did it last weekend as a matter of fact) so if you don't have a 240 volt outlet handy you can run it off a dryer outlet. Clawhammer as you said is modular and that is a plus since you can replace a component should it fail or you burn an element. Let me know which way you go. Use my links and help support the channel if you don't mind. 😁👍🍻
That thing looks so tiny compared to the larger systems you’ve been using. It’s so cute. Seems to be a decent system. Don’t forget to let us know how the Marzen turns out too.
Yeah making the recipe.. "Oh how cute, only 12lbs of grain" Lol will definitely let you know on the beer.. It is super active in the fermenter right now.. 👍🍻
Tip for when you add dme or sugars to boil use an empty hop spider then put any sugars etc in there as it allows it to peculate slowly into the boil-cheers
I have the 20 gallon 230 volt system. I also have lower efficiency issue. I tightened my grain mill to its smallest and I gained 5%. I have also had issues with mash temp as well.
I was going to contact you before I made this video but did not have time. Have you auto tuned the controller? What kind of efficiency are you getting?
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Hi Brian! I have auto tuned the controller. I may do it again. I was thinking of putting a "T" connector in line with the pump with a thermo well so I could see the actual temp of the wort as it circulates. (Not sure how accurate Clawhammer thermowell is where it is positioned). When I take a temp reading of the mash it is sometimes off by 5 F. (mash temp is lower than the wort at the bottom of the brewing kettle). I think its a flow issue.I never have stirred the mash half way through the mash but will try that as well. I wish that the basket sides were solid like Spike. The first 2 brews I did I got 60- 65% efficiency. Not happy with that as I would get 80% efficiency on my old system using a cooler and fly sparging. I set my mill to its tightest position (bottom of the line grain mill) and my efficiency went up to 70% I can live with that. I usually add an extra pound of grain. Over all I do like the system. Reach out any time Brian! Love your channel. You inspired me to go electric. Need more electric brewers YouTubing! Cheers. Shawn.
Hey Brian thanks for doing this review I watched you review on the Robobrew when I was thinking of buying a system and your review helped me in my decision, and I want this system to so my question is was it just an individual controller you had a problem with or was it that model for the controller and they gave you a newer one?
Great video! I watch claw hammer videos all the time. Wife asked me why I don’t buy one of those systems and I showed her the price and she said never mind keep using your old equipment! Lol 😂 one day I’ll justify in buying a all in one system. Keep up the great videos
I got lucky, the wife gave me the go ahead to get some fancy kit, but I'm consistently at 75% efficiency and 3.5-4 hour start to pitch days that I have no desire to change up any time. I might invest in some diy type SS fermenters if I can get a line on some cheap SS bins.
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers seems like the hops would work fine in the basket if you weren't using the pump though, correct? Hop spiders set too high most times so that you can't do more than a couple of ounces, so for IPA's, I'd think the basket for that would be a great selling point.
The bazooka tube clogging up is annoying. It happens to me a lot. I’m gonna just brew without it and just use a fine mesh strainer when transferring to my fermenter.
I use their system. I think they did a great job and are constantly improving. I wish they had a more user-friendly heat control that connected to the phone and the temperature system on mine is hit or miss and has caused me to kill off enzymes a couple times. Otherwise, pretty simple. Good people. Thank you for making these videos!
Very nice review Brian. We cannot buy these in Europe but looking at the price I am kind of wondering how that is justified? Especially when much of this can be sourced easily enough and put together quite cheaply.
Seems like it performed better this time Brian. Its unfortunate you had some failures on the live demo. Off the self parts unfortunately do fail. Seems like a one off. Very nicely done
On the fence with this system. Not sure I like the idea of a no sparge system. No rinsing of the grains??? all that yummy sugar left in the grains after the initial mash and draining. : (
I have a few questions for anybody reading this: 1 Have you used the 120v? If yes what are your impressions 2 I have no experience with this type of system and I noticed sparge is not required, what’s the water to grain ratio for this? 3 Is it possible to brew 5 and 10 gallon batches on this kettle?
1 I have not 2 I use a calculator software, but you can Google biab calculator for an idea in how much grain you can use. 3 it will not do 10 gallon batches. Kettles not big enough. 👍🍻
Hello great video, I have never brewed before but I have watch a lot of videos and want to try a kettle gose brew. I would like the all in one set up would you recommend this? Do you have. A better suggestion?
It is definitely a worthy system for what you want to do. There are lots of options out there... Check out the rest of my channel. I have lots of systems on here. 👍🍻
I love the content of your videos! Super helpful. I'm currently debating on which all in one system to go with. Would you recommend the Grainfather 30L or the Anvil 10.5G. I'm not super worried about the price differences, just would like to know some pros and cons in comparison to one another.
I have used both, personally the grainfather does not add enough value to justify the extra cost. Now that the anvil controller is up top it makes it even harder to justify the grainfather. Get the anvil with the recirculating kit and spend the extra on a Jaded Scylla chiller and a fermenter.. Thanks for the feedback too!! 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thank you very much. I was leaning towards purchasing the Anvil system but just needed that push and that extra money being saved can definitely go to corny kegs or extra fermenters. Thanks!
Not having brewed on the larger clawhammer system I can't say definitively, the capacities are about the same from what I can tell. I'd provably say the spike system due to the controller having replaceable parts. Having brew with electric for as long as I have... Things go bad eventually and can you easily replace them.. 👍🍻
Still trying to weigh my buying options ;-). Can you elaborate a bit about the temp probe and how it is "held" into the kettle port? I saw it quickly in one of CHS's vids. It looks a lot like an Inkbird style probe. I'm concerned with its accuracy at high temps and of course its longevity. I would think the RTD/XLR connector types would be more resilient.
It is exactly what you are saying. A ink bird probe in a thermo well. It is not really held in at all just slides in. I typically use weldless RTD probes in my kettle. They are using a RTD probe in this case you'd just have to adapt it to a 3.5 mm plug. Which you can do because I've done it. 😉
Another great review Brian ! Thank you very much. Now that you have brewed on both the Clawhammer and Brewtools. Which one was more challenging and which one did you have the most fun with? 🍻
They are vastly different in the operation. I do enjoy both systems. The Clawhammer I enjoy the simplicity, and the Brewtools customization is insane. Kinda depends on what you are in the mood for.
Another good video. Thank you. I’ve been looking at this system and the anvil foundry. Like I have spoken to you before. I’m new to this and haven’t started yet. Could I get your opinion on what system would be best for somebody just getting into brewing.. thanks again
This system will brew great beer for sure. And quickly too lol! I think starting out it is not a bad idea to look at lower cost all in one systems . The initial investment is a. Little lower and if you should upgrade to a larger more expensive system the all in one vessels. Make a great water heater for sparging etc. 👍🍻
Thanks again for your information. Would I be okay with the anvil foundry 6.5. ?.. and is there website to help you adjust from 5 gallon batches to 2.5-3 gallon batches ? And how can I purchase one of your t-shirts.. thanks.
@@danielsweet937 I too would recommend a less expensive (and simpler) system for starting out. I went with a Mash & Boil for $300 (as I added the fermenting lid to it), and have done 30+ brews on it with great success. Fermenting in it is a HUGE bonus as well, as my cleanup is minimal, and it helps keep my brew days under 3.5hrs. It also eliminates a transfer, which is a risk point for contamination. The clawhammer is what I was looking to move up to next, but I don't think I would unless I needed to brew 20gallon or high gravity batches. If you want to do 2.5-3 gallon batches on the anvil/mash&boil type systems, there are PLENTY of online resources to adjust your recipie, and these systems will give you great versatility and ease of use for that size for sure.
I'm looking for a BIAB system (120v for me unfortunately) and this seems like a nice system. You seem to be the only channel that has tried so many different brands of these systems. How does this compare to other systems? I currently run a gigawort and bags. Wile I like it fine, it kind of limits me on batch sizes. Thanks again.
On 120 volts, the brewzilla and anvil are also contender in the batch size range. The advantage the clawhammer is that you can replace some of the parts. Other all in one's lack repairablity. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thanks. More to think about. Which one's controller holds temps the best? If the other 2 more inexpensive systems produce the same results, it might not be worth paying double the price.
I am considering switching from Robobrew to something different. Do you think the mesh basket prevents a “column” from flowing from top of grain bed through the grain bed as opposed to brau supply’s (and I guess even robobrew and grainfather for that matter) solid wall with porous bottom design, in turn reducing efficiency? With the clawhammer, have you noticed any improvement in mash efficiency with increased lautering rate/volume?
The system is designed as a full volume no sparge mash. You can sparge with it, but I wouldn't say the at the basket inherently is more efficient. What can be more efficient with the system is the ability to grind fiber and have a possibility if better conversion. I also think even if you're recirculating it's not a bad idea to stir the mash every 15 minutes or so. Long before we had the column type systems people were doing brewing a bag with just a bag which is very similar to this basket. I wouldn't expect much higher than 75% efficiency on average. 👍🍻
Short Circuited Brewers I agree with my Robobrew I find my efficiency best when I stir. With it, as long as I let it settle down for at least 10 minutes before I sparge and use the spigot to obtain a couple or 3 large aliquots to get the trash back on top of my grain bed before sparge my efficiency soars and wort is clear. I just like the idea of continual column motion and I think a solid wall probably helps if you do not plan to stir.
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Sorry, no, I generally run at 148 for 75 minutes, then set to 160 and hold it for 5-10 minutes. I usually see another .03 to .05 in that time period.
Ok I did not say it in the video. I guess I assume that is common practice.. I always do it. If you can see the controller it is at 168 or something like that in the video.. I thought you were laying some knowledge on me!! Lol thanks for the clarification. 👍🍻
The capacity is about the same, the basket on this system. Allows for a finer crush than the anvil. The clawhammer system has quite a bit more power than the foundry so heating times will be less. The clawhammer system is a bit more "modular" so you can replace an element or sensor if it goes bad. There are advantages on both sides of the argument. Price is a factor to consider too. Both systems will make great beer for sure. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers it's not (yet). three options #1 build one yourself (boils down to flash a Sonoff TH16), $25, 20min time #2 buy one at Crafthardware (they have shipping to US, but that will come with an EU plug) #3 reach out to bierbots via email and ask kindly for a creative solution 😎
Short Circuited Brewers good call. I wouldn’t want to mess with that throughout the brew day. I know this is off topic, but which system do you recommend for my setup? Do you like the Auber Brew Buddy (240v)?
From the results I could not tell you for sure.. Lol I will say the way that the basket is designed, it won't hurt anything because you're not really filtering through the grain bed like other systems that have solid walls on the basket. A friend of mine that has been doing brew in a bag for a long time used to stir his mash at least twice during the mashed period. 👍🍻
Hey there. I just bought this - the 120v however. Quick question. Would you consider (if you haven’t yet) publishing construction plans and budget for your brew room? That would be cool!
Also a rough guess on budget, somewhere between $10 and $15k but I did EVERYTHING myself. No help from anyone else. Well my wife helped me carry the concrete countertops down..lol 👍🍻
The system is designed as a no sparge. You can sparge if you want. It might gain you a little bit. I did use the BIAB Full volume mash profile so it does give you a no sparge full volume of water. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thanks for replying! Does this system also use the 1.5 Triclamp fitting for element or is a larger one? Website isn't too clear, and the photo is of the smaller 120v element
Is that sparging throughout the mash? What sort of sparging would you call that? I'm a brew-in-a-bag brewer so I don't really know much about sparging.
It not actually sparging more of just a recirculation. Sparging would be with just water rinsing the grains after you pull them from the kettle. The clawhamner is a no sparge system.👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers OK thanks, that's what confused me as you seemed to be spraying over the wort as well as the grains. What's the benefit of the recirculation? I'd love one of those clawhammer systems. They look the real deal, but unfortunately they don't do systems for the UK market.
Hi! should this system work in south america where we have 220v/50hz outlet? maybe not out of the box but with some minor modifications? would appreciate your thoughts on this. cheers!
I have the same issue... I watch Phillip Defranco and sometimes it notifies me, and sometimes I have to go to the actual page to find the video... SHEESH
Thank you for the video, I've been waiting to see how this came out. I'm making the change from 3 vessel propane to electric, and scaling up to 10 gal batches. I know this was a 5 gallon batch, but in your opinion, how does the Clawhammer System compare to the Spike SVBS? I've narrowed it down to those two, and clawhammer seems a few hundred cheaper and they throw in a chiller. Open to ideas if I should be seriously considering another brand. Thank you for your time and all the videos, very helpful.
The controllers are about the same. From a functionality standpoint. I would say, outside of a warranty period, the Spike controller is probably a little more repairable. If a PID goes bad, you can just swap it out with a new one. I don't think that's possible with the clawhammer supply system. The baskets are different. I am used to doing a sparge on single vessel systems. Neither of these are really meant for that. However, I think you probably could get away with doing a sparge easier on the spike system because of the way the basket is designed. The Spike system kettle definitely is higher quality construction, not that there's anything wrong with this one, just something to note. I think you can make great beer in either system, it comes down to your personal preference. Both of the companies have excellent customer service and are reputable in the home brewing market.
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Good call. I just want to Clawhammer's website and the 10gal 240v system is $1499 so it's almost 3x the cost of the Anvil...going with the Anvil!
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Great videos by the way! Very, very well done and extremely informative. You saved me a lot of money since I was set on the Clawhammer and hadn't considered the Anvil till I watched your reviews.
Not really even the same type of system. They both make beer the Anvil is cheaper, but not modular like this system. Quite a few differences between them. 👍🍻
I can appreciate the product and its design elements, and I always love to watch videos on new/other platforms. However, for now I think I'll stick to the Brewzilla 65L. Such an impressive package for the price. Keeps these type of videos coming please. Are you going to build another custom home brewing rig one day? Maybe with one of these controllers?
I can't really speak too much with brau supply they promised to send me a unit multiple times but never came through on it. From what I've seen online and photos the brau supply is fairly well built. I can tell you firsthand though that the customer service from clawhammer is very good. 👍🍻
I put the recipe details in the description if you are curious. This not a tested recipe, just one I came up with so I'm not sure how it will turn out... I'll. Update of course once. It's done! Enjoy👍🍻
Hope you enjoy
Hi, I have a question.
Before bottling the beer do we use any method to kill the yeast post fermentation or does the yeast remain in the bottle and till the consumer drinks the beer? Does it make it a safe beer to drink?
@@soumyabiswas3689 sure it's safe. That's called a bottle conditioned beer. 👍
InstaBlaster...
I have their early 110v system, which was an upgrade from my basic “turkey fryer in the garage” set up. It takes a bit longer to get to temp but otherwise, it has been great. Easy to use, easy to clean and we’ve made some great beer with it.
Nice!! 👍🍻
How long does the 110v system take to come up to mash temp and then to boil temp? They tend to gloss over the timelines in their videos, which makes it hard to judge the system fully.
Brian, thanks for all the great videos. I’ve been using the 120V version of this system for a while now. There’s no need for a double crush. The micron mesh level of the grain basket is small enough that I use a .025 setting on my mill and I hit my pre-boil and original gravities very consistently. One crush at that setting and you’re good to go.
Yep.. I leave mine a bit wider since I am not just brewing on one system.. The double crush was the solution for me not to adjust the mill. Should have done it this time..live and learn!! 👍🍻
Love their 120v system, for the money. I added a whirlpool arm and an edge pickup tube. Made all the difference. Great to see they are working out the kinks with the big boy model. I hope to see more brew days on this system.
Yes I will be brewing again on it.. Your mods are definitely worthwhile. 👍🍻
Where'd you get the parts? Looking to do this to mine!
I run a DIY basket type system and I get between 85-90% efficiency regularly. My experience is that you do a normal strike water volume as if you were doing a 3 vessel brew. Use a smaller crush (I’m set to around .037”), slow down recirculation and stir about every 10 minutes. Then sparge to preboil volume as you would with a 3 vessel system. Of course this requires another vessel for sparge water, I use the grainfather hot liquor tank personally..
Sounds like you got the process dialed in very well. Good tips! 👍🍻
Just had to watch this again since I ordered my Clawhammer system wanna be prepared for my first brew and not screw it up LOL
Got the 120v system in the mail and should be here by Saturday brew day. I’m stoked, can’t wait to give it a go!
Awesome! Let me know how it goes.. Be sure to Auto tune the controller and adjust the temp offset.
Thank you Brian. I’ve been wondering about cleaning that basket myself for ages. You cleared that up for me, cheers.
I was curious about that too!! Having used fine mesh bags that were real pain!! This was really easy. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Hi Brian. Was curious. I noticed the basket is mesh on all sides even up to the top. Seems like most of the ebiab systems like foundry/robo have a mash basket that is not mesh/perforated on the sides, but rather, only near the bottom. Does having a basket with mesh up to the top allow the flow to go out the basket near the top instead of filtering down through the grain? Does having the mesh all the way up the sides affect effeciency if it can "leak out" the sides near the top? Thanks!
Everyone I know with a basket type system seems to run in the 70 to 80% range efficiency. Good video Brian.
Yeah that seems to be the consensus. In hindsight I think my mash was lower than 148 to be honest. I am almost 100% sure. The beer finished at 1.008 so it was definitely low.
First of all. Your channel is awesome. I've learned so much about equipment and the process. I'm looking to upgrade from my 3 tier 10 gallon batch cooler system to an EBIAB. I've narrowed it down to the clawhammer 240 or the Anvil 18 gallon. In your opinion, which is the better system all the way around. I know the clawhammer is modular (which is why I'm kind of leaning that way) but also just recently saw that anvil now makes an 18 that does 10 gallon batches. Now I'm torn between the 2. Thank you for your response and for the information on all things brewing. Cheers
Thanks for the feedback!
They are both good systems so you really can't go wrong with either one. The Anvil has a little less power requirements than the clawhammer so that is a difference to note. The Anvil will run on a 20 amp inline GFCI (Did it last weekend as a matter of fact) so if you don't have a 240 volt outlet handy you can run it off a dryer outlet. Clawhammer as you said is modular and that is a plus since you can replace a component should it fail or you burn an element. Let me know which way you go. Use my links and help support the channel if you don't mind. 😁👍🍻
Cracking video. You’ve created a beautiful space to brew. Top marks for pulling up that grain basket solo - I always always use the pulley 💪🤟
Thanks Martin!! Big fan of your videos! We need to figure out a collaboration of some kind!! 👍🍻
Short Circuited Brewers That would be awesome, would love to work on a collab video.
What's the best way to get in touch with you?
That thing looks so tiny compared to the larger systems you’ve been using. It’s so cute. Seems to be a decent system. Don’t forget to let us know how the Marzen turns out too.
Yeah making the recipe.. "Oh how cute, only 12lbs of grain" Lol will definitely let you know on the beer.. It is super active in the fermenter right now.. 👍🍻
Very happy to see you didn't experience the same pains as the live brew day, especially after using an actual hop spider :)
True!
Tip for when you add dme or sugars to boil use an empty hop spider then put any sugars etc in there as it allows it to peculate slowly into the boil-cheers
I just turn off the element and stir it in... Always works for me.. Good too. Though if you have an extra spider. 👍🍻
I have the 20 gallon 230 volt system. I also have lower efficiency issue. I tightened my grain mill to its smallest and I gained 5%. I have also had issues with mash temp as well.
I was going to contact you before I made this video but did not have time. Have you auto tuned the controller? What kind of efficiency are you getting?
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Hi Brian! I have auto tuned the controller. I may do it again. I was thinking of putting a "T" connector in line with the pump with a thermo well so I could see the actual temp of the wort as it circulates. (Not sure how accurate Clawhammer thermowell is where it is positioned). When I take a temp reading of the mash it is sometimes off by 5 F. (mash temp is lower than the wort at the bottom of the brewing kettle). I think its a flow issue.I never have stirred the mash half way through the mash but will try that as well. I wish that the basket sides were solid like Spike. The first 2 brews I did I got 60- 65% efficiency. Not happy with that as I would get 80% efficiency on my old system using a cooler and fly sparging. I set my mill to its tightest position (bottom of the line grain mill) and my efficiency went up to 70% I can live with that. I usually add an extra pound of grain. Over all I do like the system. Reach out any time Brian! Love your channel. You inspired me to go electric. Need more electric brewers YouTubing! Cheers. Shawn.
Another great video Brian, thank you! My brother in law first told me about the Clawhammer system, and it seems pretty impressive.
Yeah it works pretty well. I do like the basket! 🍻👍
Hey Brian thanks for doing this review I watched you review on the Robobrew when I was thinking of buying a system and your review helped me in my decision, and I want this system to so my question is was it just an individual controller you had a problem with or was it that model for the controller and they gave you a newer one?
Just that controller..they replaced it..it happens sometimes with electronics..👍🍻
Neat bit of kit! I like the convenience of my current Kettle and Cooler Tun, but this would definitely be in the consideration if I ever upgrade.
Totally agree!
Great video! I watch claw hammer videos all the time. Wife asked me why I don’t buy one of those systems and I showed her the price and she said never mind keep using your old equipment! Lol 😂 one day I’ll justify in buying a all in one system. Keep up the great videos
Haha.. Thanks man!! Keep the wife happy!! 👍🍻
I got lucky, the wife gave me the go ahead to get some fancy kit, but I'm consistently at 75% efficiency and 3.5-4 hour start to pitch days that I have no desire to change up any time. I might invest in some diy type SS fermenters if I can get a line on some cheap SS bins.
I thought they were nuts also when they used the grain basket for the hops lol. Thanks for the video Brian. Great video like always.
Yeah I made the mistake of trying it and learned really quick!! Lol👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers seems like the hops would work fine in the basket if you weren't using the pump though, correct? Hop spiders set too high most times so that you can't do more than a couple of ounces, so for IPA's, I'd think the basket for that would be a great selling point.
The bazooka tube clogging up is annoying. It happens to me a lot. I’m gonna just brew without it and just use a fine mesh strainer when transferring to my fermenter.
Yeah I thought about it. I wanted to brew with it as is though.
Great review! I’ve been meaning to test one of these systems out.
It is a nice system!! 👍Q
I use their system. I think they did a great job and are constantly improving. I wish they had a more user-friendly heat control that connected to the phone and the temperature system on mine is hit or miss and has caused me to kill off enzymes a couple times. Otherwise, pretty simple. Good people. Thank you for making these videos!
Thanks for the comments!! 👍🍻
This could very well be a good upgrade for me but concerned that 3 gallon batches would be too little ... awesome video Brian. Cheers!
The Homebrew Challenge TH-cam channel has been doing 2.5 gallon batches without any issues from what ive seen. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thank you Sir ... must investigate!
Very nice review Brian. We cannot buy these in Europe but looking at the price I am kind of wondering how that is justified? Especially when much of this can be sourced easily enough and put together quite cheaply.
Good points, you can definitely diy a solution for cheaper.
Seems like it performed better this time Brian. Its unfortunate you had some failures on the live demo. Off the self parts unfortunately do fail. Seems like a one off. Very nicely done
Thanks Gary!! It happens sometimes! Cheers! 👍🍻
This is the video I've been waiting for, thanks Brian.
Awesome!! Thanks for the feedback! 👍🍻
Thanks for the review! I enjoy your videos.
Thanks man!! 👍🍻
Thank you for sharing. Keep up the good job 👍🏻
Thanks! 👍🍻
Great review Brian. I always watch til the end. Cheers!
Haha! Thanks Matt! 👍🍻
Thanks for the update!
You bet!
I love the studio!
Thanks man!! Lots of work went into it.. If you haven't watched the build series you should check it out. 👍🍻
Thanks for the video👍 if your gravity is lower than you want can you boil the mash until you reach your target gravity Thanks man
👍🍻
Great video!! very thorough and informative! cheers :)
Thanks!! 👍🍻
I’ve just started out my brewing adventures :)
On the fence with this system. Not sure I like the idea of a no sparge system. No rinsing of the grains??? all that yummy sugar left in the grains after the initial mash and draining. : (
Nothing says you CAN'T rinse the grain. It was just designed to not need to do it. If you have the extra equipment, rinse away. 👍🍻
I have a few questions for anybody reading this:
1 Have you used the 120v? If yes what are your impressions
2 I have no experience with this type of system and I noticed sparge is not required, what’s the water to grain ratio for this?
3 Is it possible to brew 5 and 10 gallon batches on this kettle?
1 I have not 2 I use a calculator software, but you can Google biab calculator for an idea in how much grain you can use. 3 it will not do 10 gallon batches. Kettles not big enough. 👍🍻
Hello great video, I have never brewed before but I have watch a lot of videos and want to try a kettle gose brew. I would like the all in one set up would you recommend this? Do you have. A better suggestion?
It is definitely a worthy system for what you want to do. There are lots of options out there... Check out the rest of my channel. I have lots of systems on here. 👍🍻
I love the content of your videos! Super helpful. I'm currently debating on which all in one system to go with. Would you recommend the Grainfather 30L or the Anvil 10.5G. I'm not super worried about the price differences, just would like to know some pros and cons in comparison to one another.
I have used both, personally the grainfather does not add enough value to justify the extra cost. Now that the anvil controller is up top it makes it even harder to justify the grainfather. Get the anvil with the recirculating kit and spend the extra on a Jaded Scylla chiller and a fermenter.. Thanks for the feedback too!! 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thank you very much. I was leaning towards purchasing the Anvil system but just needed that push and that extra money being saved can definitely go to corny kegs or extra fermenters. Thanks!
Because you used both the Spike solo and Clawhammer, which do you think is better. I’m in the market.
Between those 2 the clawhammer is a better option .👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thank you Brian, I respect your opinion. Happy New year
All things considered, would you choose the Spike single vessel system or the Clawhammer single vessel system and why?
Not having brewed on the larger clawhammer system I can't say definitively, the capacities are about the same from what I can tell. I'd provably say the spike system due to the controller having replaceable parts. Having brew with electric for as long as I have... Things go bad eventually and can you easily replace them.. 👍🍻
Still trying to weigh my buying options ;-). Can you elaborate a bit about the temp probe and how it is "held" into the kettle port? I saw it quickly in one of CHS's vids. It looks a lot like an Inkbird style probe. I'm concerned with its accuracy at high temps and of course its longevity. I would think the RTD/XLR connector types would be more resilient.
It is exactly what you are saying. A ink bird probe in a thermo well. It is not really held in at all just slides in. I typically use weldless RTD probes in my kettle. They are using a RTD probe in this case you'd just have to adapt it to a 3.5 mm plug. Which you can do because I've done it. 😉
Another great review Brian ! Thank you very much. Now that you have brewed on both the Clawhammer and Brewtools. Which one was more challenging and which one did you have the most fun with? 🍻
They are vastly different in the operation. I do enjoy both systems. The Clawhammer I enjoy the simplicity, and the Brewtools customization is insane. Kinda depends on what you are in the mood for.
Short Circuited Brewers thanks ! 🍻
No problem!!
Another good video. Thank you. I’ve been looking at this system and the anvil foundry. Like I have spoken to you before. I’m new to this and haven’t started yet. Could I get your opinion on what system would be best for somebody just getting into brewing.. thanks again
This system will brew great beer for sure. And quickly too lol! I think starting out it is not a bad idea to look at lower cost all in one systems . The initial investment is a. Little lower and if you should upgrade to a larger more expensive system the all in one vessels. Make a great water heater for sparging etc. 👍🍻
Thanks again for your information. Would I be okay with the anvil foundry 6.5. ?.. and is there website to help you adjust from 5 gallon batches to 2.5-3 gallon batches ? And how can I purchase one of your t-shirts.. thanks.
@@danielsweet937 I too would recommend a less expensive (and simpler) system for starting out. I went with a Mash & Boil for $300 (as I added the fermenting lid to it), and have done 30+ brews on it with great success. Fermenting in it is a HUGE bonus as well, as my cleanup is minimal, and it helps keep my brew days under 3.5hrs. It also eliminates a transfer, which is a risk point for contamination.
The clawhammer is what I was looking to move up to next, but I don't think I would unless I needed to brew 20gallon or high gravity batches. If you want to do 2.5-3 gallon batches on the anvil/mash&boil type systems, there are PLENTY of online resources to adjust your recipie, and these systems will give you great versatility and ease of use for that size for sure.
I'm looking for a BIAB system (120v for me unfortunately) and this seems like a nice system. You seem to be the only channel that has tried so many different brands of these systems. How does this compare to other systems? I currently run a gigawort and bags. Wile I like it fine, it kind of limits me on batch sizes. Thanks again.
On 120 volts, the brewzilla and anvil are also contender in the batch size range. The advantage the clawhammer is that you can replace some of the parts. Other all in one's lack repairablity. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thanks. More to think about. Which one's controller holds temps the best? If the other 2 more inexpensive systems produce the same results, it might not be worth paying double the price.
Just bought the 20 gal claw
27BREWING
Nice!
I am considering switching from Robobrew to something different. Do you think the mesh basket prevents a “column” from flowing from top of grain bed through the grain bed as opposed to brau supply’s (and I guess even robobrew and grainfather for that matter) solid wall with porous bottom design, in turn reducing efficiency? With the clawhammer, have you noticed any improvement in mash efficiency with increased lautering rate/volume?
The system is designed as a full volume no sparge mash. You can sparge with it, but I wouldn't say the at the basket inherently is more efficient. What can be more efficient with the system is the ability to grind fiber and have a possibility if better conversion. I also think even if you're recirculating it's not a bad idea to stir the mash every 15 minutes or so. Long before we had the column type systems people were doing brewing a bag with just a bag which is very similar to this basket. I wouldn't expect much higher than 75% efficiency on average. 👍🍻
Short Circuited Brewers I agree with my Robobrew I find my efficiency best when I stir. With it, as long as I let it settle down for at least 10 minutes before I sparge and use the spigot to obtain a couple or 3 large aliquots to get the trash back on top of my grain bed before sparge my efficiency soars and wort is clear. I just like the idea of continual column motion and I think a solid wall probably helps if you do not plan to stir.
I agree. 👍🍻
At 148F you will see an efficiency bump by raising the temp to 160 for 10 minutes
Ok when during the mash are you talking about? In the beginning?
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Sorry, no, I generally run at 148 for 75 minutes, then set to 160 and hold it for 5-10 minutes. I usually see another .03 to .05 in that time period.
Ok I did not say it in the video. I guess I assume that is common practice.. I always do it. If you can see the controller it is at 168 or something like that in the video.. I thought you were laying some knowledge on me!! Lol thanks for the clarification. 👍🍻
Many thanks for your nice videos and the useful information. How would you compare / rate this system against the Anvil Foundry?
The capacity is about the same, the basket on this system. Allows for a finer crush than the anvil. The clawhammer system has quite a bit more power than the foundry so heating times will be less. The clawhammer system is a bit more "modular" so you can replace an element or sensor if it goes bad. There are advantages on both sides of the argument. Price is a factor to consider too. Both systems will make great beer for sure. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Hello Brian, many thanks for your quick and helpful reply. Your videos are very informative and enjoyable. Best, -Wolfgang
👍🍻
great reveiw. thanks.
Thanks for watching!👍🍻
Thanks man! Really helpful.
Glad you found it helpful!! 👍🍻
Sounds like a great system with some simple fixes any diy homebrewery can do. If they see it as an issue. Well done, cheers!
Thanks Wally!! 👍🍻
Rather than use the hop basket could you just stick the grain basket back in during the boil and put the hops in there?
Just watched your comments at the end, don’t understand why it didn’t work though? Is the mesh not as fine?
It is too fine and gets clogged and the wort boils up around the basket. I did it on a live stream. Not a good idea.. Lol 👍🍻
Can you review a BierBot Bricks system?
Where is that available in the US?
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers it's not (yet). three options #1 build one yourself (boils down to flash a Sonoff TH16), $25, 20min time #2 buy one at Crafthardware (they have shipping to US, but that will come with an EU plug) #3 reach out to bierbots via email and ask kindly for a creative solution 😎
@@BernhardSchlegel thanks
Would this system work well with a 3 vessel HERMS? I’m looking for a good controller for my electric upgrade at some point.
It's meant for a single vessel system so it is not ideal. You would have to switch the controller between the vessels for the brew day.
Short Circuited Brewers good call. I wouldn’t want to mess with that throughout the brew day. I know this is off topic, but which system do you recommend for my setup? Do you like the Auber Brew Buddy (240v)?
Is it ok to constantly stir the mash?
I'm also wondering if it's a good idea just to get a better efficiency or higher gravity ?🤔? What do u think
From the results I could not tell you for sure.. Lol
I will say the way that the basket is designed, it won't hurt anything because you're not really filtering through the grain bed like other systems that have solid walls on the basket. A friend of mine that has been doing brew in a bag for a long time used to stir his mash at least twice during the mashed period. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers i got solid walls on my :)
@@leroygross9144 🍻👍
Hey there. I just bought this - the 120v however. Quick question. Would you consider (if you haven’t yet) publishing construction plans and budget for your brew room? That would be cool!
Didn't have any real "plans" and the budget I have no idea.. lol have you seen my basement brewery build series?
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers No but I’ll have a look. How far back are your vids?
@@attyjim1 there is the first video in the planning stage. th-cam.com/video/WYcWiHKMH6A/w-d-xo.html
Also a rough guess on budget, somewhere between $10 and $15k but I did EVERYTHING myself. No help from anyone else. Well my wife helped me carry the concrete countertops down..lol 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers gonna tuck in now and watch! Pax! And ty for this.
Is it recommended to sparge at all? Os is this already accounted for in the mash and grain profile. Would that potentially increase efficiency?
The system is designed as a no sparge. You can sparge if you want. It might gain you a little bit. I did use the BIAB Full volume mash profile so it does give you a no sparge full volume of water. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thanks for replying! Does this system also use the 1.5 Triclamp fitting for element or is a larger one? Website isn't too clear, and the photo is of the smaller 120v element
Is that sparging throughout the mash? What sort of sparging would you call that? I'm a brew-in-a-bag brewer so I don't really know much about sparging.
It not actually sparging more of just a recirculation. Sparging would be with just water rinsing the grains after you pull them from the kettle. The clawhamner is a no sparge system.👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers OK thanks, that's what confused me as you seemed to be spraying over the wort as well as the grains. What's the benefit of the recirculation? I'd love one of those clawhammer systems. They look the real deal, but unfortunately they don't do systems for the UK market.
Recirculation just helps make sure the grains are completely saturated to ensure as much conversion as possible. 👍🍻
Are you still using the Clawhammer system?
It's in the rotation of systems I use. 👍🍻
No sparge?
Hi! should this system work in south america where we have 220v/50hz outlet? maybe not out of the box but with some minor modifications? would appreciate your thoughts on this.
cheers!
I am pretty sure more of the components in the controller are compatible with 50hz Power. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers thanks for the reply!
@@tomasnavarro 👍🍻
how do u deal with the hot break with the clawhammer system? thanks
Either turn the element off or use a spray bottle with water to spray the hot break. 👍🍻
Hey, this 240v has a built in CFGI is it necessary to add a CFGI breaker?
It actually does not. It is a breaker only. It does need a GFCI.
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers ok, thanks for clarifying, I actually ordered a GFCI for my breaker just in case. I will install that for sure. Thanks!
@@jonathanhillman9364 👍🍻
Wow, Alex Jones has a homebrew channel? COOL!
Haha.. we brew for the lizard people...
Great video Brian, thx! Sláinte!
Thanks!! 👍🍻
I swear I hate TH-cam. I, subscribe, have the bell set, and still don't get notifications constantly!
I have the same issue... I watch Phillip Defranco and sometimes it notifies me, and sometimes I have to go to the actual page to find the video... SHEESH
Thank you for the video, I've been waiting to see how this came out. I'm making the change from 3 vessel propane to electric, and scaling up to 10 gal batches. I know this was a 5 gallon batch, but in your opinion, how does the Clawhammer System compare to the Spike SVBS? I've narrowed it down to those two, and clawhammer seems a few hundred cheaper and they throw in a chiller.
Open to ideas if I should be seriously considering another brand. Thank you for your time and all the videos, very helpful.
Paddy M same boat here
The controllers are about the same. From a functionality standpoint. I would say, outside of a warranty period, the Spike controller is probably a little more repairable. If a PID goes bad, you can just swap it out with a new one. I don't think that's possible with the clawhammer supply system. The baskets are different. I am used to doing a sparge on single vessel systems. Neither of these are really meant for that. However, I think you probably could get away with doing a sparge easier on the spike system because of the way the basket is designed. The Spike system kettle definitely is higher quality construction, not that there's anything wrong with this one, just something to note. I think you can make great beer in either system, it comes down to your personal preference. Both of the companies have excellent customer service and are reputable in the home brewing market.
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Thank you for the feedback, that's helpful. And thank you again for the review on this system.
Thank you and love the channel
@@arty4673 thank you for the feedback! 👍🍻
What do you think of this system compared to the Anvil 10.5?
For the price the Anvil is a better way to go IMO. The 240 version of the clawhammer is faster heating but twice the price. 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Good call. I just want to Clawhammer's website and the 10gal 240v system is $1499 so it's almost 3x the cost of the Anvil...going with the Anvil!
Hey I'm just here giving you all the info.. the choice is yours! 👍🍻
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers Great videos by the way! Very, very well done and extremely informative. You saved me a lot of money since I was set on the Clawhammer and hadn't considered the Anvil till I watched your reviews.
@@j.leavenworth7006 👍🍻
I still cant believe people have luck using hop spiders. I've tried afew it killed the hops for me.
Not my preference either... But big time clogging if you don't on this system. 🍻👍
@@ShortCircuitedBrewers ahh fair enough.
How would you say this compares to the Anvil?
Not really even the same type of system. They both make beer the Anvil is cheaper, but not modular like this system. Quite a few differences between them. 👍🍻
I will use Maine spring water. Send me one...
I'll let them know... lol
I can appreciate the product and its design elements, and I always love to watch videos on new/other platforms. However, for now I think I'll stick to the Brewzilla 65L. Such an impressive package for the price.
Keeps these type of videos coming please. Are you going to build another custom home brewing rig one day? Maybe with one of these controllers?
I have a "clone" Of this system. I just need to finish the video on it. 👍🍻
Is this brew system nema 14-50 plug compatible?
14-30 and you need a gfci breaker
Brau supply vs claw hammer?
I can't really speak too much with brau supply they promised to send me a unit multiple times but never came through on it. From what I've seen online and photos the brau supply is fairly well built. I can tell you firsthand though that the customer service from clawhammer is very good. 👍🍻
pressurized fermentation?
Never heard of it? Pretty awesome technique.. I use it all the time. 👍🍻
You should do a Vid on that😁
@@24JesterKings I will soon! 👍🍻