@Josiah Dean hmm, 2 accounts with generic names, no profile picture, joined 1 week ago, replying to each other comments instantaneously, promoting some random app? seems legit
@@randominternetguy3537 Well, that is only the American way of doing things. British English usually have punctuation outside of a quotation mark (or an asterisk acting like a quotation mark, in this case).
thank you as a 3d animator from the 90s, this channel is like trauma counselling for the days and weeks of rendering that broke my brain. praise the papers
5:15 I love how some of the "dog" hairs fall out from the force of the water tugging on them lol. I think the water there is a little too sticky or their hair isn't quite slippery/absorbant enough. This simulation is great at a lot of things. Not the best for hair simulations though depending on what you're looking for.
Recently I was starting to read about soft body sims and was amazed at how complex this problem is. Then I read about how limited those techniques were, like being slooooow, or only one soft body at a time. And then, today you post a video like this. My jaw dropped so hard. I can't wait to see how this is going to be 2 more papers down the line.
After watching some of your videos i started to pay more attention to details in movies and video games. After watching some animated movies i had a moment of realization that the water in the movie wasn’t real, and that it was instead a simulation that was made by what you show us. It was pretty cool realizing that fact.
"None of these techniques use any machine learning; these are all good old-fashioned hand-crafted algorithms." - I love how we've gotten to a point where this sentence makes perfect sense!
Perhaps they can add in some osmosis that varies depending on viscosity, cloth density, liquid particle size etc to maybe simulate filtration of dirty water.
good to see that there are still some areas which need lots of work. many of the simulations on this channel look nearly perfect, but that paper looked like rubber. can't wait to see two more paper papers down the line.
hyper elastic elasto-plastic also. it seems like common trends i've seen in computer graphics are turning rabbits into water droplets, and turning armadillos into shrapnel. cool.
Dude sounds like Igor, if Igor was the servant to a 3d modeled Dracula. Honestly pretty cool, love your stuff! Subed after the gta photo realism Ai vid! Keep up the good work!
I was going to suggest that they should just allow interaction between properties and objects such that they combine, but it looks line that was the solution
That is some nice two way coupling! Water still seems to split into unnaturally small droplets though. I've tried to simulate water, it's extremely difficult to do the cohesion convincingly
3:24 You can tell that the shadows aren't affected by the liquids light absorption/ color change or that the shadow is pre baked of the cup/not affected by the fluids and only the balls are rendered. Not bashing just pointing out.
I clicked this because it was the weirdest sounding random thing that showed up on my feed. But I was not disappointed. It's interesting watching this evolve.
A year or 2 ago there was a paper that simulated sand and water mixing. It was good but not quite real looking persay. In another year or 2 after this one all this stuff is going to look great!
Another cool thing that confirms our hardware thesis. Look at the comp time between wet paper and biscuit. Wet paper is faster and x10 more complex. They are using an i9. Higher single core speed than xeon in the biscuit sim. It seems these simulations are not multi core yet.
I hate when I accidentally make a mess in the kitchen, yet these examples of making a virtual mess push the boundaries of what mankind is capable with the aid of science and creativity. It's like when we switched from analog audio to digital. When it was analog, it was all about getting the best quality, but now with digital we want to lo-fi the sound up a bit so that it sounds more natural/realistic.
so, what have we been seeing in 3d movies this whole time? did they use that old method? i mean, all the animation in movie are pretty realistic in simulating such as explosion, fracture, etc...
I love all of these new simulations, but when they will probably be available to the public? I'm just asking out of curiosity, are we talking like a year from now or more like few years untill they get used in some software?
Just FYI as a grammar suggestion, "paper" is one of those words where the singular form sounds better unless you're explicitly referring to multiple pieces of paper. The title would sound more natural as "Is Simulating Wet Paper Possible?". Keep up the excellent content :)
I have always wanted to saturate thin slices of the corpses of trees for my entertainment through the medium of computer generated simulations, thank you good sir you have provided my ultimate wish to me without me even searching for it.
physics simulations are amazing, one day they will be more realistic than real life, it's like saying -1nm CPUs could exist, it wouldn't make sense but it sounds cool
On a computer programmers need to invent different algorithms for all possible material interactions while irl we have "atoms" that do all of that by physical laws
Great now I can finally show a simulation to my professor of what happened when somebody spilled their drink on my homework.
Innovating for the better of humanity? Nah.
Coming up with better proof for excuses? Take my money!
Wait, but what if your homework is digital?
@@steampunknord "Is simulating an explosion of your pc possible?"
@@Thepewdiepiebro5 Who knows? Not me I just use computers, not run simulations.
@@steampunknord 🤣
Now we can simulate my sweaty palms while I am holding onto my papers
Is simulating two minute papers possible?
@@dingdong2103 might be with the next GPT-3 version (GPT-4?)
@@dingdong2103 huh
Hyperhidrosis?
toilet paper commercials will never be the same
Lol
🐵🐵🐵🐵🐒
@Josiah Dean lmao i see you two bots everywhere
@Josiah Dean hmm, 2 accounts with generic names, no profile picture, joined 1 week ago, replying to each other comments instantaneously, promoting some random app?
seems legit
toilet paper commercials will never be the same
2 more papers down the line and we can simulate how the paper gets all distorted and crunchy after you spill some coffee on it and let it dry out 😭
Amen!
Time traveler spotted!
we can simulate how we squeeeze that paper
i wonder if it would work with papers with paintings or text on them
20 papers down the line doing a simulation like that will be a standard workflow for making crunchy, coffee stained paper 3d models.
Finally now i can find the correct way to hold on my papers *underwater*.
Put the period before the asterisk
@@randominternetguy3537 then i will lose the heart, so IT IZ WHOT IT IZ. Thank you for your help tho.
@@theencore398 ye lol.
@@randominternetguy3537 Well, that is only the American way of doing things. British English usually have punctuation outside of a quotation mark (or an asterisk acting like a quotation mark, in this case).
@@leesiheon8013 *underwater.* vs *underwater*.
I've been doing my own research on dunking biscuits in coffee for years.
Not written a paper on it yet but the research has been delicious.
finally the channel with an item named on their channel talks about the item being simulated
Your videos are awesome
One paper to simulate them all. One algorithm to find them all, one paper to bring all the solutions and in videos bind them.
This comment needs to be stickied.
@@allensilver8178 Stickiness provided by the one algorithm!
thank you
as a 3d animator from the 90s, this channel is like trauma counselling for the days and weeks of rendering that broke my brain.
praise the papers
@Two Minutes Paper Report this account, it's obviously fake
@@rzesiette594 why is it fake?
@@Hassan-zw9tb Check the channel, it has no subs
@@cedrick25 which one, starkman does have subs?
@@Hassan-zw9tb The one @Grzesiek Krupa replied to
The moment you realize there will be always two more papers down the line 🤯
Even phyics newton -> einstein general relativity
until the world ends
@@saxo689 that's only 1
@@ammyvl1 the quantum physics is 2, maybe?
@@ammyvl1 well obviously there was several papers and ideas between newton(18th century) and Einstein(20th century)
"The arguments contained in this paper really hold water". The pun game was strong in this one
5:15 I love how some of the "dog" hairs fall out from the force of the water tugging on them lol. I think the water there is a little too sticky or their hair isn't quite slippery/absorbant enough. This simulation is great at a lot of things. Not the best for hair simulations though depending on what you're looking for.
none of the sims are particularly good
Recently I was starting to read about soft body sims and was amazed at how complex this problem is. Then I read about how limited those techniques were, like being slooooow, or only one soft body at a time. And then, today you post a video like this. My jaw dropped so hard. I can't wait to see how this is going to be 2 more papers down the line.
At this point, whenever I see a 2MP video title that says "is X possible?" I mentally add "yes, it is" to the end.
the only place on youtube that question titles have a yes answer.
Is this contradicting Betteridge's Law of Headlines? Yes.
@@TheZenytram you are not wrong
One of the more interesting video's you have uploaded (not that there are any bad ones), what a time to be alive!
After watching some of your videos i started to pay more attention to details in movies and video games. After watching some animated movies i had a moment of realization that the water in the movie wasn’t real, and that it was instead a simulation that was made by what you show us. It was pretty cool realizing that fact.
What movie?
@@official-obama i made this comment five months i don’t remember what movie
@@boyjoeyboy ah ok
they might’ve used real footage or animated it by hand
So close to 1 million subscribers! Great work!!
Your voice is soothing and the footage is relaxing.
Ez az végre egy magyar tulajdonossal lévő angol csatorna. Jó lett a videó.
0:56
Imagine you're playing your character in a physics simulator and feel everything he feels, and suddenly your muscles clip into one another
It must be uncomfortable, what about all the nerves that get clipped along.
Yes
"The Matrix" but over the web
Dream Mask music video: look what they need to mimic a fraction of our power
I don't understand how any of this works other than the simple explanations you always provide, and yet I find myself watching every new video.
"None of these techniques use any machine learning; these are all good old-fashioned hand-crafted algorithms." - I love how we've gotten to a point where this sentence makes perfect sense!
Well, it means they just use bioware for their machine learning, just like human robots were used to clean up after Chernobyl.
3:30 **dips the biscuit into the water**
The viewer does not like that.
Perhaps they can add in some osmosis that varies depending on viscosity, cloth density, liquid particle size etc to maybe simulate filtration of dirty water.
What a time to be alive!
That first paper demonstration gave me a serious sense of déjà vu for some reason. That's not a joke, it actually did.
Maybe in your past live you were one of developers!
This channel inspires me to read more papers. Thank you a lot!
good to see that there are still some areas which need lots of work. many of the simulations on this channel look nearly perfect, but that paper looked like rubber. can't wait to see two more paper papers down the line.
Soccadillo physics simulations get me everytime lol. Such an obscure character that I recognize immediately.
I never knew that guy has a name lol
hyper elastic elasto-plastic
also. it seems like common trends i've seen in computer graphics are turning rabbits into water droplets, and turning armadillos into shrapnel. cool.
I've been watching this channel for so long and I still have no idea which papers I'm supposed to be holding onto
You have such a calming voice
Dreams report card be like.
undergrad students be like : yes if you approximate the wet paper as a perfectly dry and immobile plane.
0:24
I love how the cookie dough doesn't look too realistic, but the longer the cookies are baked, the more real they look!
Imagine when these will be implemented into video games.
Hello az algoritmus feldobta ezt a videót nekem!!! Meglepő volt hallani hogy Magyar az alkotója!!!! Így tovább Gratula az 1 millióhoz!
Dude sounds like Igor, if Igor was the servant to a 3d modeled Dracula.
Honestly pretty cool, love your stuff! Subed after the gta photo realism Ai vid! Keep up the good work!
Absolutely , Mind Blowing
Truly marvellous results.
Everyone who is building there Channel good luck you will get there I promise never give in
I was going to suggest that they should just allow interaction between properties and objects such that they combine, but it looks line that was the solution
Please combine all of this, and make on simulation with all 6 factors
Thx, very interesting area.. a brief introduction into the algorithm would be awesome :)
Keep up the good work
That is some nice two way coupling! Water still seems to split into unnaturally small droplets though. I've tried to simulate water, it's extremely difficult to do the cohesion convincingly
3:24 You can tell that the shadows aren't affected by the liquids light absorption/ color change or that the shadow is pre baked of the cup/not affected by the fluids and only the balls are rendered. Not bashing just pointing out.
I clicked this because it was the weirdest sounding random thing that showed up on my feed. But I was not disappointed. It's interesting watching this evolve.
A year or 2 ago there was a paper that simulated sand and water mixing. It was good but not quite real looking persay. In another year or 2 after this one all this stuff is going to look great!
Nagyon halad a technológia, jó videó lett!
can't wait to use this simulations in the future, especially for academic purposes.
The capillary forces on the biscuit were next level.
Another cool thing that confirms our hardware thesis.
Look at the comp time between wet paper and biscuit.
Wet paper is faster and x10 more complex.
They are using an i9. Higher single core speed than xeon in the biscuit sim.
It seems these simulations are not multi core yet.
That honey simulator is sweet!
Almost forgot about this guy, thank you TH-cam recommendations
1:25
*"It starts melting the armadillos beautifully"*
this is so satisfying to look at
I'm happy that sometime in my lifetime, we'll be simulating life on another level
love these videos, so interesting!
Great paper, I also noticed that so many talented Chinese researchers work on Computer Graphics. Good news.
I hate when I accidentally make a mess in the kitchen, yet these examples of making a virtual mess push the boundaries of what mankind is capable with the aid of science and creativity. It's like when we switched from analog audio to digital. When it was analog, it was all about getting the best quality, but now with digital we want to lo-fi the sound up a bit so that it sounds more natural/realistic.
3:00 "Destroying armadillos in the most spectacular fashion."
Interesting paper...
so, what have we been seeing in 3d movies this whole time? did they use that old method? i mean, all the animation in movie are pretty realistic in simulating such as explosion, fracture, etc...
This is amazing
The explanation is also very good
What a time to be alive!!!!
We need a solid paper holder now, it's getting difficult to hold on to my papers these days.
I love all of these new simulations, but when they will probably be available to the public? I'm just asking out of curiosity, are we talking like a year from now or more like few years untill they get used in some software?
I have no idea what you're talking about, but it looks cool.
3:28 Dipping Oreo in milk simulation when
Ice formation and water evaporation is the next step!!!
This seriously means one day we will be able to render perfectly accurate versions of ourselves into electronics WOW
First I come here for "What a time to be alive!" and "Now hold onto your papers"
Second I come here for the awesome simulation
So many puns! I love it! Oh, and the paper, too! :D
Just FYI as a grammar suggestion, "paper" is one of those words where the singular form sounds better unless you're explicitly referring to multiple pieces of paper. The title would sound more natural as "Is Simulating Wet Paper Possible?".
Keep up the excellent content :)
But in the title it was used in the meaning of "articles", for which the plural form is fine?
1:13. The third armadillo looks absolutely devastated when his armadillo bros get liquefied.
When biscuit falls in the bowl
I: oh, no :(
Dr. Karoly: oh, yes!
koolaid man: *oh yeah*
I've been playing Noita for the past couple days, so the 2D demos make me smile more than the 3D.
Once a solution is saturated with a certain substance it shouldn’t dissolve any more. Does this happen with this algorithm?
Have you seen the Dream animation for his song lmao?
lmao I knew someone would comment about the dream video
now i can send this video to my friends and tell them the whole channel is about simulating paper :D
You should start looking for papers on subtitle timing.
Nice now I can use this for t-shirts 👀
I have always wanted to saturate thin slices of the corpses of trees for my entertainment through the medium of computer generated simulations, thank you good sir you have provided my ultimate wish to me without me even searching for it.
5:00 Pseudo-dog is my new favorite band name
the muscle simulation is very cool
damn , the dissolution one is insane
now this is an actual try not get satisfied video
physics simulations are amazing, one day they will be more realistic than real life, it's like saying -1nm CPUs could exist, it wouldn't make sense but it sounds cool
"what kind of dog is this?" A cylindrical dog
can make realistic movement in the water but can't make a realistic drop interacting with any dry surface
1:44 “makes my head spin” I see what you did there ;)
Now we can have 2 minute wet papers :)
Please tell me all of these simulations are being catalogued for future use when our hardware can run them easily.
I really want to see the day we can simulate burning papers underwater, just like that spongebob scene
At 2:10, why does orange material also stick to the edge of the outside of the invisible container? is that a real thing that happens?
This is just amazing and lovely paper
Damn! My papers got wet again
the only part i don't like is how elastic the paper is just for a few frames after it tears.
this guy sounds wholesome, really, any old-ish nordic person sounds wholesome
On a computer programmers need to invent different algorithms for all possible material interactions while irl we have "atoms" that do all of that by physical laws
Plot twist: “real life” is a simulation.
2:00
One paper to rule them all!